Text



Faith Beyond Fundamentalism
      & Anti-Fundamentalism:
         where do we go from here?
Faith Beyond a Failed Narrative:
 Reframing Jesus in a new narrative space




                Text
From the place where   But doubts and loves
we are right
                           Dig up the world
Flowers will never
grow                   Like a mole, a plow.
In the spring.
                       And a whisper will be
The place where we        heard in the place
are right                  Where the ruined
Is hard and trampled     House once stood.
Like a yard.                    Israeli poet Yehuda Amichai
Something is on the way out and something
                   else is painfully being born.
       It is as if something were crumbling,
              decaying, and exhausting itself,
  while something else, still indistinct, were
                     arising from the rubble....
        We are in a phase when one age is
   succeeding another, when everything is
                                        possible.
               Vaclav Havel, “The New Measure of Man”
Fr. Vincent Donovan:
,,, do
     not try to call them back to where
they were, and do not try to call them to
where you are, as beautiful as that place
might seem to you. You must have the
courage to go with them to a place that
neither you nor they have ever been
before.
Never accept and be content with unanalyzed
assumptions, assumptions about the work, about the
people, about the church or Christianity. Never be
afraid to ask questions about the work we have
inherited or the work we are doing. There is no
question that should not be asked or that is
outlawed. The day we are completely satisfied with
what we have been doing; the day we have found
the perfect, unchangeable system of work, the
perfect answer, never in need of being corrected
again, on that day we will know that we are wrong,
that we have made the greatest mistake of all.
(Christianity Rediscovered, 146)
a new kind of
christianity:
ten questions that
are transforming the
faith
!                        ?
  Statements evoke debate that
 creates a new state, sometimes
   producing division and hate.
            Questions can create
conversations that launch us on
                    new quests.
The Jesus

 Question
Just over 1500 years ago ...
Medieval Christianity was conceived
        through Augustine of Hippo.




            Almost 500 years ago ...
  Modern Christianity was launched
           through Martin Luther.
Both of whom experienced
conversion through Paul and
               his message.
If a new kind of Christian faith
      is going to be born in and
            through us today ...



   it will come through a fresh
understanding of Jesus and his
                      message.
Varied Jesuses “on the market” today
The tribal/nationalist/ ethnic/
religious US VERSUS THEM Jesus …
backing colonizers and empire
builders since the 4th century!
     The PERSONAL ENHANCEMENT
    Jesus … helping ME have a better
time in this life and the next. Bringing
  you the exclusive Personal Savior …
      and the ever-popular Prosperity
                                 Gospel!
The STAINED GLASS Jesus … the nicest
man who set up nice places where nice
people could honor him. Amen.
        The TICKET-TO-HEAVEN Jesus …
     solving the problems of original sin,
 total depravity, and eternal damnation,
    so you can be one of the chosen few!
The INSTITUTIONAL Jesus … he may
have proclaimed a radical kingdom, but
we created a big, bureaucratic religion
out of it!
The SECOND COMING WARRIOR Jesus
… He may have been peaceful the first
time, but next time ... watch out!
-Whatever a new kind of
Christian faith is and will be, it
involves a fresh vision



                    of Jesus
A revolution in Jesus
study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native
historical setting (various “quests”)
A revolution in Jesus
study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native
historical setting (various “quests”)
-New insights into “second-temple
Judean Judaism”
A revolution in Jesus
study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native
historical setting (various “quests”)
-New insights into “second-temple
Judean Judaism”
-Seeing Jesus primarily through the
sight-line of his ancestors rather than
his descendants
A revolution in Jesus study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native
historical setting (various “quests”)
-New insights into “second-temple
Judean Judaism”
-Seeing Jesus primarily through the
sight-line of his ancestors rather than
his descendants
-Fresh perspective on Paul,
Apocalypse
A revolution in Jesus study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native historical
setting (various “quests”)
-New insights into “second-temple Judean
Judaism”
-Seeing Jesus through the sight-line of his
ancestors rather than his descendants
-Fresh perspective on Paul, Apocalypse
-New understandings of the formation of
the gospels … starting with Mark (Q).
A revolution in Jesus study:
-Putting Jesus back in his native historical setting
(various “quests”)
-New insights into “second-temple Judean Judaism”
-Seeing Jesus through the sight-line of his ancestors
rather than his descendants
-Fresh perspective on Paul, Apocalypse
-New understandings of the formation of the gospels
… starting with Mark (Q).

-New emphasis on the themes of
empire/captivity and liberation
In what narrative do we
place Jesus?

              (A pre-critical question)
Eden                       Heaven



       Fall                Salvation


              Fallen history/
              The fallen
              world                    Hell
Platonic Ideal                  Platonic Ideal



        Fall                    Atonement,
                                purification
        Into
Aristotelian     Aristotelian
       Real
                 Real
                                              Hades
Pax Romana                 Pax Romana

                                  Civilization,
 Rebellion                       development,
       into                        colonialism
 barbarism    Barbarian/          assimilation
              pagan
              world
                               Destruction,
                               defeat
Is there an
alternative
understanding?
sdrawkcab gnidaer
Rick Warren, Billy Graham, Charles Finney, John Wesley (or Calvin), Luther,
Aquinas, Augustine, Paul, Jesus




reading forwards
Adam, Abraham, Moses, David, Isaiah, John the Baptist, Jesus
Exodus: Liberation & Formation
Exodus: Liberation & Formation


Genesis: Creation and Reconciliation
Isaiah: Peaceable Kingdom - Justice and
                 Mercy



        Exodus: Liberation & Formation


Genesis: Creation and Reconciliation
G
e
      Isaiah: Peaceable Kingdom - Justice and
n
      Mercy
e
s
i
s


    Exodus: Liberation & Formation
HUMAN DESTRUCTION
  G
  e
         Isaiah: Peaceable Kingdom - Justice and
  n
         Mercy
  e
      HUMAN VIOLENCE
  s
  i
  s   HUMAN EXPLOITATION

       Exodus: Liberation & Formation
HUMAN DESTRUCTION
  G
  e
         Isaiah: Peaceable Kingdom - Justice and
  n
         Mercy
  e
      HUMAN VIOLENCE
  s
  i
  s   HUMAN EXPLOITATION

       Exodus: Liberation & Formation
A New Exodus: Jesus leads us into a new freedom.



A New Genesis: Jesus leads us into a new creation - a new
humanity. New Adam, New Abraham, New Joseph.


A New Isaiah: Jesus leads us into a new future - a new kingdom.
Jesus as a servant-leader of social
change ...
   Not an evacuation plan, but an
        incarnation/new creation/
   transformation/reconciliation/
                  liberation plan -
        into which we are invited.
The Gospel Question:

SEEING WHAT HAS
 BEEN THERE ALL
 ALONG ... BUT WE
   WERE WELL-
TRAINED TO MISS IT:
JESUS AND THE
KINGDOM OF GOD
After John was put in
prison, Jesus went into
Galilee, proclaiming the
      good news of God.



The time has come, he
 said. The kingdom of
  God has come near.
Repent and believe the
           good news!
                 Mark 1:15
What does “Kingdom
  of God” mean?
Remember:
   Kingdoms (or
  Empires) were
   contemporary
realities in Jesus’
              day!
There was Herod ruling
over the Jewish people
… and the Emperor
Caesar ruling over the
whole region.
Jesus could have
proclaimed a new
religion.

But he didn’t.

 He proclaimed
         a new
      kingdom.
It was a dangerous time to
proclaim a new kingdom.
That kind of thing could
get you killed!
Too few people realize the
radical nature of the message of
the Kingdom of God.


   There are several reasons for
         this misunderstanding.
• Many think “kingdom of
      God” means heaven
         (after you die)…
       especially because
  Matthew frequently uses
    “kingdom of heaven.”
But it’s clear that
 “kingdom of heaven”
 does NOT mean
 “heaven after you die.”
 Consider the Lord’s
 prayer:
It does NOT teach us to pray
         May we come to your
        kingdom when we die.
      May we all go to heaven
      where, unlike earth, your
                  will is done.
  Instead, it teaches us to pray-
Your kingdom come.
Your will be done on earth as it is in
                            heaven.
Why do Mark and Luke
     say “Kingdom of
   God,” but Matthew,
  John, and Paul don’t
              (much)?
As the most Jewish gospel …
 Matthew follows the Jewish
 reticence about using the name of
 God directly. “Heaven” substitutes
 for God.
Why does John hardly ever say
 “kingdom” at all?
John uses “kingdom” only in chapter 3
  and 18. Elsewhere, he uses the phrase
  “life” - life to the full, or eternal life.
     But it is also clear that “eternal life”
     doesn’t simply mean “life in heaven
       after you die,” contrary to popular
                                    opinion.
Zoein Aeonian means “Life of the
 ages” - not life limited by this present
 age.

 “Now this is life of the ages: that
    they may know you, the only
      true God, and Jesus Christ,
           whom you have sent.”
Paul actually does speak constantly
  about the kingdom of God - but he
  uses a variety of kingdom-related
  terms:
Lord (supreme king), Christ
 (liberating king), church (ecclesia,
 assembly of citizens).
       Consider the Book of Acts …
Paul (as Fr. Richard Rohr has helped
    us see) comes to see a universal,
  cosmic, and mystical dimension to
         the life of Jesus ... which he
 embodies in the phrase “in Christ.”
 The term might be rendered “in the
          messianic” or “in the new
   humanity” or “in the kingdom of
                              God”
After John was put in
prison, Jesus went into
Galilee, proclaiming the
      good news of God.


   The time has
  come, he said. The
   kingdom of God has
come near. Repent and
believe the good news!
                 Mark 1:15
“The Spirit of the Lord is on me,
  because he has anointed me to
  preach good news to the poor …
  freedom for prisoners … recovery
  … release … the year of the Lord’s
  favor.” … Today this scripture is
  fulfilled in your hearing.
                          Luke 4:18 ff
This may be the most radical challenge
  of Jesus’ message: Someday, everyone
  agrees …
  The poor should helped
  The rich should be generous
  Racism should end
  The environment should be cared for
  Wars should cease.
Jesus says the time has come - today!
  The poor should helped
  The rich should be generous
  Racism should end
  The environment should be cared for
  Wars should cease.
                No wonder Jesus says ...
Repent!


... which means, “Rethink
             everything!”
This vision of the
kingdom of God
gives us a new
sense of mission
and a new sense of
identity.
261

versus

  3
Christian: 3

vs.

Disciple: 261
Disciples of Jesus

Learners of his way

Disciples/Apostles of
the good news of the
kingdom of God
All of our traditions are
contributing to this fresh
vision of Jesus.




Eastern Orthodox   Roman Catholic   Protestant
All of our traditions have contributed to this fresh vision
of Jesus.
Catholic liberation theologians, missionaries, and biblical
scholars …
Mainline Protestant Jesus scholars …
Evangelical missionaries and Bible scholars …
Eastern Orthodox scholars and leaders who maintained
a non-Western approach…
                 And sincere Christians of all traditions …
 who listened to the Holy Spirit speaking of Jesus in their
                                                     hearts.



 Eastern Orthodox        Roman Catholic             Protestant
“‘…do not [leave them where they are],
and do not try to call them to where you
are, as beautiful as that place might seem
to you. You must have the courage to go
with them to a place that neither you nor
       they have ever been before.’
     - Fr. Vincent Donovan (Spiritan priest to Masai)




Eastern Orthodox       Roman Catholic               Protestant
Eastern Orthodox   Roman Catholic   Protestant
Eastern Orthodox   Roman Catholic   Protestant
“Follow
                                     me!”




Eastern Orthodox   Roman Catholic   Protestant
“Follow
                                         me!”




Eastern Orthodox   Roman Catholic   Protestant
“‘…do not [leave them where they are],
and do not try to call them to where you
are, as beautiful as that place might seem
to you. You must have the courage to go
with them to a place that neither you nor
       they have ever been before.’
     - Fr. Vincent Donovan (Spiritan priest to Masai)




Eastern Orthodox    Roman Catholic           Protestant
Text



        Reframing Jesus:
beyond fundamentalism & anti-
             fundamentalism
The Lord’s Prayer


1. Our Father above us
 and all around us …

2. May Your unspeakable
 Name be revered.
3. Now, here on earth
 may Your
 commonwealth come.

4. On earth as in
 heaven may Your will
 be done.
5. Give us today our
 bread for today.

4. Forgive us our
 wrongs as we forgive.
3. Lead us away from
 the perilous trial.

2. Liberate us from the
 evil.
1.For the kingdom is
 yours and yours alone.
2. The power is yours and
 yours alone.
3.The glory is yours and
 yours alone.
4.Now and forever, amen.
5. Now, here on earth may your
  commonwealth come.
4. Here on earth may your
  dreams come true.
3. Hallelujah
2. Hallelujah
1. Amen.
Text



Faith Beyond Fundamentalism
      & Anti-Fundamentalism:
         where do we go from here?
Circle Conversation:
What idea from this session was most
hopeful to you? Most troubling? Most
confusing? Most important to take away?
And why?
What emotion do you feel now?
   What does “the good news of the
   kingdom of God” mean to you?