Effective Questioning Strategies for Educators
Effective Questioning Strategies for Educators
Facilitator instructions
Part A – Strategy overview, approach and impact – opportunity to collect data that could be used in Part
C. The presenter will need to facilitate this. Part A includes an activity relating to technique guides that
can be found on the using effective questioning webpage.
Part B – Implementing the strategies through techniques – the group activity requires pre-planning.
Part C – Evaluating a whole-school approach – opportunity to link to the School Excellence Plan.
Leaders should engage with Part C before implementing the professional learning with staff.
Slides are repeated across strategy modules so they can be implemented with the same structure. Note:
1
NSW Department of Educati
on
Effective
questioning
Strategy learning module
Acknowledgement of
Country
3
NSW Department of Education
Introduction
Enabling factors
Know students and how they
High expectations
learn
Teachers know how the knowledge builds Explicit teaching both relies on, and brings
and connects to create learning that is about, a safe and inclusive learning
strategic, sequenced and cumulative. environment.
5
Learning modules and technique guides
6
The importance of all moving together (1)
7
Effective feedback professional
learning
Measure baseline student data and set a
goal
8
Initial reflection point (1)
Teacher observation 0 1 2 3 4
Students demonstrate their Not yet Minimal Some students Most students All students
thinking by actively observable students demonstrate demonstrate demonstrate
responding with an answer actively their thinking their thinking their thinking
during effective questioning respond to by actively by actively by actively
throughout each lesson. effective responding to responding responding to
questioning effective to effective effective
questioning questioning questioning
9
Planning and rehearsing (1) (1)
Rehears Feedbac
Plan
e k
Evidence for Learning (2022) Effective Professional Development, Sydney: Evidence for Learning. 10
Rehearsal (1) (1)
11
NSW Department of Education
Part A
Understanding the strategy
Purpose and outcome (1)
Purpose
Outcome
We can articulate how and why we deliberately plan questioning to build complexity for all
students.
14
What it is (1)
Effective questioning:
• activates prior knowledge
• prompts practice and retrieval
• helps correct misconceptions
• scaffolds thinking to build
complexity
• engages students in thinking.
15
Prompt retrieval
16
Correct misconceptions
Identify
Redirect or reteach
misconceptions
17
Develop complexity
Questioning can be used to develop increasing complexity in student thinking and understanding.
• Recall information
• Deepen thinking
• Make connections
18
Engage students in thinking
19
Why effective questioning is important
‘Questions allow a teacher to determine how well the material has been learned and
whether there is a need for additional instruction.’ (Rosenshine 2012:14)
‘Effective questioning strategies cause all students to think. This creates high engagement
classroom environments which improve student achievement.’ (Black and Wiliam 2018)
20
Questioning in safe and inclusive learning
environments
21
What it isn’t
• Too general
22
The mechanisms of effective questioning
(2)
Planned
at the Increase
right level in
of complexit
Develop
challenge y
increasingl
All y complex
Retrieve students schema
prior are
learning thinking
of an
answer
23
Activity 1 – technique guide discussion
Identify the key points in Planning for Describe the connections between the
effective questioning technique guide technique guide and the learning in Part
or the Using questioning to build A.
complexity
technique
guide.
24
NSW Department of Education
Part B
Implementing the
strategies through
techniques
Part B instructions
Facilitator instructions
27
Purpose and outcome (2)
Purpose
Outcome
We can articulate how and why we deliberately plan and facilitate questioning.
We have whole-school teaching principles for effective questioning that are ready to use in our
classrooms.
28
The mechanisms of effective questioning
(1)
Planned
at the Increase
right level in
of complexit
Develop
challenge y
increasingl
All y complex
Retrieve students schema
prior are
learning thinking
of an
answer
29
NSW Department of Education
Technique A
Using questioning to build
complexity
What it is (2)
31
Key considerations
32
Wait time – student benefits
33
Wait time – teacher benefits
When teachers practice wait time, positive changes occur in their own
behaviour: Their questioning strategies tend to be more varied and flexible.
They decrease the quantity and increase the quality and variety of their
questions. They ask additional questions that require more complex
information processing and higher-level thinking on the part of students.
(Stahl 1994:2)
34
Inviting answers – creating the right climate
35
Scaffold thinking to build complexity
Connect
Deepen
Recall
36
Recall
37
Deepen
38
Connect
39
Justify and reflect
1. NCTM (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics) (2014) Principles to actions: ensuring mathematical success for all, NCTM. 40
Turn and talk
Record one key takeaway you could apply in your next lesson and why.
41
Examples
42
Primary example – mathematics
Students have marked the location of one-quarter on a 0–1 number line and a 0–2 number line.
The teacher:
• asks students to recall 'How did you locate one-quarter on the 0–2 number line?' (wait time).
• deepens thinking by asking 'How did you know to do this?' (wait time).
• supports students to make connections by asking 'Using what you know about locating one-quarter, how
would you locate one and one-quarter?' Students turn and talk to share their strategies.
• encourages students to justify and reflect by asking 'If zero, one-half and 2 were marked on a number line,
would you still need to locate one-whole to accurately mark one-quarter?' (wait time). Students think-pair-
share.
44
Secondary example – visual arts
The teacher shows a sample artwork. Students are then given time to examine the artwork and apply prior
learning
The teacher:
• asks students to recall prior learning by asking ‘What types of lines has the artist’s used in this work?’ and
then “How can line create mood?”
• prompts students to deepen thinking by asking ‘‘Why do you think has the artist used 3 different types of
lines?’ (wait time)
The teacher then shows another artwork by a different artist. This artwork is significantly different to the first
artwork.
The teacher:
• encourages students to make connections between two artists by asking ‘How does the artist’s use of line
compare to the use of line in the previous artwork?’ (wait time) Students turn and talk
Visual Arts 7-10 Syllabus (2025) – VA4-CHV-01 45
• asks students to reflect by asking ‘What mood does the use of lines create in this work?’
Visual arts example unpacked
46
Secondary example 2 – mathematics
• draws an image of a triangle and asks ‘Which side is the hypotenuse of the triangle?’ (wait time)
Students are encouraged to make connections between commutative property* and Pythagoras’ Theorem by
asking ‘I notice that Ben has labelled the vertical side as ‘a’ whereas Frida has labelled the horizontal side as
‘a’. Does this matter?’ Students deepen thinking by sharing their reasoning with a partner.
After students share their responses, the teacher displays a completed example, and
• deepens thinking by asking ‘How can you prove that a triangle contains a right angle?’ (wait time)
• then ask ‘If I know the length of the hypotenuse and one of the sides, could I use Pythagoras’ Theorem to
work out the length of the other side?’ the after providing wait time, asking students to justify their
*Thereasoning
commutativeby asking
property ‘How?’
states that the order of adding or multiplying two numbers does not change the result. For example, in
addition, 3+5=5+33+5=5+3.
Mathematics K-10 Syllabus (2022) - MAO-WM-01, MA4-PYT-C- 47
01
Mathematics example unpacked
48
Responsive questioning
49
NSW Department of Education
Technique B
Planning for effective questioning
What it is
51
Key considerations when planning
• response systems
‘More effort has to be spent in framing questions that are worth asking’ (Black et al. 2003:41).
52
Response systems
Choral response
53
Planning questions to activate prior
learning
Plan questions to:
54
Planning questions for recall
• Retrieval practice builds and strengthens connections in long term memory (AERO
2023).
55
Planning questions to identify
misconceptions
• Identify possible misconceptions in the planning phase.
• Prepare responses for each misconception if they are identified, including a check for
understanding to ensure accurate understanding following the intervention.
56
Planning questions to scaffold thinking to
build complexity
Recall Deepen Connect
What is a force? Explain why magnetic attraction is a How is magnetic attraction similar to
57
Planning questions and response systems
when developing complexity
Recall Deepen Connect
What is a force? Explain why magnetic attraction is How is magnetic attraction similar
58
Planning to build
complexity
Recall Deepen Connect Justify and reflect
• What, who, when • How, why, explain • Cause and effect, how • Do you agree or
questions questions is x similar (or disagree with this
• Expect success • Give prompts if needed different) to y statement? Why do
for success • Give prompts if needed you say that? How
• Shorter wait time
for success do you know?
(3 seconds) • Longer wait time
(5 or more seconds) • Longer time needed for • Longer time needed
thinking and working to prepare responses
Response systems Response systems can
include: Response systems can Response systems
can include:
include: can include:
• Choral response • Cold calling
• Class discussions • Class discussions
• ABCD cards • Mini whiteboards
• Concept maps • Debate
• Cold calling • Think-Pair-Share
• Extended written • Extended written
• Extended written
response response
response
59
Activity
Plan a series of questions that build in complexity for a lesson using the diagram on the
previous slide. Consider the wait time and response systems you will use.
60
NSW Department of Education
62
Planning and rehearsing (2) (1)
Rehears Feedbac
Plan
e k
Evidence for Learning (2022) Effective Professional Development, Sydney: Evidence for Learning. 63
Rehearsal steps and feedback prompts
64
NSW Department of Education
Part C
Evaluating a whole-school approach
Purpose and outcome (3)
Purpose
Outcome
Refine the whole-school practices of effective questioning and plan for future success and
activities.
67
NSW Department of Education
Teacher observation 0 1 2 3 4
Students demonstrate their Not yet Minimal Some students Most students All students
thinking by actively respond observable students demonstrate their thinking demonstrate
with an answer during actively their thinking by actively their thinking
‘effective questioning’ respond to by actively responding by actively
throughout each lesson. ‘effective responding to to ’effective responding to
questioning’ ‘effective questioning’ ‘effective
questioning’ questioning’
69
The mechanisms of effective questioning
(2)(2)
Planned
at the Increase
right level in
of complexit
Develop
challenge y
increasingl
All y complex
Retrieve students schema
prior are
learning thinking
of an
answer
70
The importance of all moving together (2)
71
Planning and rehearsing (3) (1)
Rehears Feedbac
Plan
e k
Evidence for Learning (2022) Effective Professional Development, Sydney: Evidence for Learning. 72
Rehearsal (2) (1)
73
NSW Department of Education
75
Measures of impact
Longer term
Short term
• Increased understanding
• Increased ability to
articulate connections • Increased learning
between pieces of
• Student data indicates
knowledge.
learning gains
76
Data sources to measure impact
Teacher observation 0 1 2 3 4
Students demonstrate their Not yet Minimal Some students Most students All students
thinking by actively respond observable students demonstrate their thinking demonstrate
with an answer during actively their thinking by actively their thinking
‘effective questioning’ respond to by actively responding by actively
throughout each lesson. ‘effective responding to to ’effective responding to
questioning’ ‘effective questioning’ ‘effective
questioning’ questioning’
77
Maintaining a whole school approach
through data
Video observation Peer observation and
and reflection feedback
78
Connecting to the School Excellence
Framework
‘School-wide explicit teaching approaches
incorporate modelled, guided and
independent practice.
Contact us
ContactCurriculumImplementation@[Link]
[Link]
80
Explicit teaching strategies and resources
• explicit teaching
[Link]
ching
81
Reference list (1)
Archer AL and Hughes CA (2011) Explicit instruction: effective and efficient teaching, Guilford Press.
AREO (Australian Education Research Organisation) (2021) Focused classrooms: managing the classroom to maximise learning, AERO, accessed 11
February 2025.
AERO (Australian Education Research Organisation) (2023a) Teaching routines, AERO, accessed 20 February 2025.
AERO (Australian Education Research Organisation) (2023c) Gaining all students’ attention, AERO, accessed 27 February 2025.
AERO (Australian Education Research Organisation) (2023d) Explicit instruction optimises learning, AERO, accessed 15 February 2025.
Australian Education Research Organisation (AERO) (2024) Monitor progress, AERO, accessed 25 February 2025.
AITSL (Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership) (2023) Teacher standards, AITSL, accessed 12 February 2025.
Black P, Harrison C, Lee C, Marshall B and Wiliam D (2003) Assessment for learning: putting it into practice, Open university Press.
Black P and Wiliam D (2018) 'Classroom assessment and pedagogy', Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 25(6):551–575.
Bogdanovich P (28 October 2014) Higher-order questions, Dataworks Educational Research, accessed 25 February 2025.
CESE (Centre for Education Statistics and Evaluation) (2017) Cognitive load theory: research that teachers really need to understand, NSW Department
of Education, accessed 21 February 2025.
CESE (Centre for Education Statistics and Evaluation) (2018) Cognitive load theory in practice: examples for the classroom, NSW Department of
Education, accessed 21 February 2025. 82
Reference list (2)
Martin AJ and Evans P (2018) 'Load reduction instruction: exploring a framework that assesses explicit instruction through to independent learning',
Teaching and Teacher Education, 73:203–214, doi:10.1016/[Link].2018.03.018.
Martin AJ (2002) ‘Motivation and academic resilience: developing a model of student enhancement’, Australian Journal of Education, 46:34-49. doi:
10.1177/000494410204600104.
McCrea P (2020) Motivated teaching: harnessing the science of motivation to boost attention and effort in the classroom, CreateSpace
Independent Publishing Platform.
Madgwick H (14 July 2021) ‘Exploring the evidence: prior knowledge and pupil misconceptions', Education Endowment Foundation, accessed 4
October 2024.
NCTM (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics) (2014) Principles to actions: ensuring mathematical success for all, NCTM.
Nuthall G (2007) The hidden lives of learners, New Zealand Council for Educational Research.
Stahl RJ (1994) 'Using think time and wait time skilfully in the classroom', ERIC Digest, accessed 19 February 2025. RJ (1994)
83
'Using think time and wait time skilfully in the classroom', ERIC Digest, accessed 19 February 2025.
Reference list (3)
Rosenshine B (2012) ‘Principles of instruction: research-based strategies that all teachers should know’, American Educator, 36(1):12–39.
Sims S, Fletcher-Wood H, O’Mara-Eves A, Cottingham S, Stansfield C, Van Herwegen J and Anders J (2021)
What are the characteristics of teacher professional development that increase pupil achievement? A systematic review and meta-analysis ,
Education Endowment Foundation.
Wiliam D (2011) Embedded formative assessment, Solution tree press, accessed 3 February 2025.
Wiliam D (2014) ‘The right questions, the right way’, Educational Leadership, 71(6):16–19.
Wiliam D and Leahy S (2015) Embedding formative assessment: practical techniques for F-12 classrooms, Hawker Brownlow Education.
Visual Arts 7–10 Syllabus © NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) for and on behalf of the Crown in right of the State of New South Wales,
2025.
Mathematics K–10 Syllabus © NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) for and on behalf of the Crown in right of the State of New South Wales,
2022
Science 7–10 Syllabus © NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) for and on behalf of the Crown in right of the State of New South Wales, 2023.
84
Copyright
© State of New South Wales (Department of Education), 2024
The copyright material published in this resource is subject to the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) and is owned by the NSW Department of Education or,
where indicated, by a party other than the NSW Department of Education (third-party material).
Copyright material available in this resource and owned by the NSW Department of Education is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license.
This license allows you to share and adapt the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Attribution should be given to © State of New South Wales (Department of Education), 2024.
• Please note that the provided (reading/viewing material/list/links/texts) are a suggestion only and implies no endorsement, by the New South Wales
Department of Education, of any author, publisher, or book title. School principals and teachers are best placed to assess the suitability of
resources that would complement the curriculum and reflect the needs and interests of their students.
• If you use the links provided in this document to access a third-party’s website, you acknowledge that the terms of use, including licence terms set
out on the third-party’s website apply to the use which may be made of the materials on that third-party website or where permitted by the
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). The department accepts no responsibility for content on third-party websites. 85