Introduction:
Risk-Return Trade-offs
Chapter 1
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Risk vs Return
There is a trade off between risk and
expected return
The higher the risk, the higher the
expected return
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Example (Table 1.1, page 3)
Suppose Treasuries yield 5% and the
returns for an equity investment are:
Probability Return
0.05 +50%
0.25 +30%
0.40 +10%
0.25 –10%
0.05 –30%
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Example continued
We can characterize investments by their
expected return and standard deviation of
return
For the equity investment:
Expected return =10%
Standard deviation of return =18.97%
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Combining Two Risky Investments (page 5)
P w11 w2 2 P w12 12 w22 22 2w1w2 1 2
16
Expected
14 Return (%)
1 10% 12
2 15% 10
1 16% 8
6
2 24%
4
0.2 2 Standard Deviation
of Return (%)
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Assumptions
Investors care only about expected return and SD of
return
The e’s of different investments are independent
Investors focus on returns over one period which has the
same length for all investors
All investors can borrow or lend at the same risk-free
rate
Tax does not influence investment decisions
All investors make the same estimates of m’s, s’s and
r’s.
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Arbitrage Pricing Theory
Returns depend on several factors
We can form portfolios to eliminate the
dependence on the factors
This leads to result that expected return is
linearly dependent on the realization of the
factors
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Risk vs Return for Companies
If shareholders care only about systematic risk, should
the same be true of company managers?
In practice companies are concerned about total risk
Earnings stability and company survival are important
managerial objectives
The regulators of financial institutions are primarily
interested in total risk
“Bankruptcy costs” arguments show that that managers
may be acting in the best interests of shareholders when
they consider total risk
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
What Are Bankruptcy Costs?
(Business Snapshot 1.1)
Lost sales (There is a reluctance to buy
from a bankrupt company.)
Key employees leave
Legal and accounting cost
Etc.
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Approaches to Bank Risk
Management
Risk aggregation: aims to get rid of non-
systematic risks with diversification
Risk decomposition: tackles risks one by
one
In practice banks use both approaches
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023
Credit Ratings
Moody’s S&P and Fitch
Aaa AAA
Aa AA Investment
A A grade bonds
Baa BBB
Ba BB
B B
Non-investment
Caa CCC grade bonds
Ca CC
C C
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 6e, Chapter 1, Copyright © John C. Hull 2023