Digital Signatures in IT Law
Digital Signatures in IT Law
TECHNOLOGY UNIT 2
LAWS
DIGITAL Section 3 and 3A
SIGNATURES of IT Act
AND
ELECTRONIC
SIGNATURES
The traditional signatures are
handwritten and are uniquely
representative of one’s identity. The
use of signature is mandatory in law
in certain cases and holds an
important legal position in the
document as it signify two things,
the identity of the person and its
intent to it. The Signature is one’s
identity on a document and is used
in day to day transaction and in case
Digital
of illiterate persons its fingerprint is
considered as his signature.
Under Law of Evidence, the ‘original’
document constitutes primary
Signatures
evidence, while a copy of the
‘original’ document constitutes
secondary evidence. The originality
of paper-based documents is usually
established with the presence of
original handwritten signatures.
As the handwritten signature is
prone to forgery and tampering
hence insufficient for online
transaction and contracts. The
online transaction requires unique
and strong protection which is
served by electronic signature.
Equivalent criteria for the legality
and validity of transactions in an
electronic form were laid down by
the Model Law. Such criteria were
Digital
based on the principles of non-
discrimination, technological
neutrality and functional
equivalence. So the validity of
information cannot be challenged
Digital
the person. This meant that
an equally unique, specific
and inimitable form of
authentication was required
Digital
traditional authentication procedures has
suggested the need for a specific legal
framework to reduce uncertainty as to
the legal effect that may result from the
Signatures and
signature. In cyber world electronic
signature ensures that the electronic
records are authentic and legitimate as
Electronic
electronic signature are safer and cannot
be forged and is convenient as the
sender himself does not have to be
Definitions
verification, to affix a digital signature. A
digital signature would be valid only if it is
used by a subscriber, i.e. the person
under Digital
holding a valid digital signature certificate.
The use of digital signature is not
mandatory under the Act but is a legal
Digital
using the corresponding private
key and vice versa. The unique
feature in public key
infrastructure is that the public
Signatures
and private keys are related to
each other and only the public
key can be used for encrypting
messages that can be decrypted
using the corresponding private
key.
The public key is shared,
whereas the private key is
known only to its possessor.
The digital signature is
based on Cryptography.
Cryptography is the science
to secure communications
by converting the message
(encrypting ) into an
unreadable format and only
Digital
key that is known only
the recipient of
messages. In India
Signatures
signature uses an
asymmetric system that
has a public key and
private key.
Digital Signature
Certificates
Digital Signature
Certificates are digital
format certificate to prove
identity in the digital
world. The digital signature
certificates are issued by
Certifying Authorities
Digital
under the authority of
Controller of Certifying
Authorities. A Digital
Signatures
Signature Certificate is an
electronic document that
can be used to verify that
the public key belongs to
the particular individual.
Digital Signature
Certificates contains Public
key of the certificate
owner, Name of the owner,
Validity “from” and “to”
dates, Name of the issuing
authority, Serial number of
the certificate, Digital
signature of the issuing
Digital
authority name of the
person, etc. There are
three different classes of
digital certificate. They
Digital
use of an asymmetric crypto
system and hash function for
authentication of electronic
records. Authentication of an
Signatures
electronic document is important
as it ensures that the message
has not been tampered and
confirms the creator’s identity,
making it non-repudiable i.e., the
sender cannot deny its creation.
The object of authentication is
achieved by the use of
asymmetric system and hash
function which convert the
electronic message into an
unreadable format to prevent
tampering of electronic record.
Signatures
digest. It plays an important
role in ensuring that the
message has not been
tampered and information is
safe and secure.
Authentication of electronic records
(1) Subject to the provisions of this section
any subscriber may authenticate an
electronic record by affixing his digital
signature.
(2) The authentication of the electronic
record shall be effected by the use of
asymmetric crypto system and hash
function which envelop and transform the
initial electronic record into another
Digital
electronic record.
Explanation-For the purposes of this sub-
section, “hash function” means an algorithm
Signatures-
mapping or translation of one sequence of bits
into another, generally smaller, set known as
“hash result” such that an electronic record
yields the same hash result every time the
Authentication of
algorithm is executed with the same electronic
record as its input making it computationally
infeasible
electronic
(a) to derive or reconstruct the original
electronic record from the hash result
produced by the algorithm;
(b) that two electronic records can produce
Signatures-
smaller length using a
mathematical algorithm.
Authentication of
For a given hash function, the
smaller length to which the
information is to be converted is
electronic fixed. Means it will always produce
a hash result of same length
regardless of the length of the
records-Section 3 information to which it is applied.
Hash function consists of a many:1
translation in comparison to 1:1 in
case of encryption.
A given electronic record will
always produce the same hash
result on the application of the
same hash function and no two
electronic records will produce
the same hash result on
application of same hash
Digital function. Even a slight change
in the document will produce
Signatures- the different hash result. It
means application of the hash
Authentication of
time the hash function is applied.
It is impossible (computationally
infeasible) to calculate or derive
electronic the original information from its
hash result.
Signatures
message
3) It was as reliable as
was required under
the circumstances
Section 2(1)(ta) defines
Electronic Signature as
“Authentication of any electronic
record by a subscriber by means
of the electronic technique
specified in the second schedule
and includes digital signature.”
Signatures
of ‘electronic signature’ has made
the Act technological neutral as it
recognizes both the digital signature
method based on cryptography
technique and electronic signature
using other technologies.
Functions of Electronic
Signature
The concept of electronic signature
was introduced under section 3A of
the Information Technology
(Amendment) Act 2008.
An electronic signature means
authentication of an electronic
record by a subscriber by any means
of electronic authentication
techniques. An electronic signature
technique can be used as an
Electronic
authorized electronic signature if
such technique is notified by the
central government in the official
gazette or in the second schedule of
Signatures
the Act. There are different types of
electronic signature, however, all of
them are not secure; hence only the
techniques notified in the official
gazette or in the second schedule
can be used as a legitimate
electronic signature.
For example typed name, a
digitized image of a
signature is also a form of
electronic signature, but is
prone to tampering and are
insecure. The electronic
signature technique has to
be reliable to be
recognized as an electronic
Electronic
signature. Section 3A of
the Information Technology
Act 2000 is based on
Article 6 “Compliance with
Signatures 2001.
[3A. Electronic signature.—(1)
Notwithstanding anything
contained in section 3, but
subject to the provisions of
sub-section (2), a subscriber
may authenticate any
electronic record by such
electronic signature or
electronic authentication
technique which—
(a) is considered reliable;
Electronic
and
(b) may be specified in the
Second Schedule.
(2) For the purposes of this
Signatures section
signature
any
authentication
or
electronic
electronic
technique
shall be considered reliable if
—
(a) the signature creation data or
the authentication data are,
within the context in which
they are used, linked to the
signatory or, as the case may
be, the authenticator and to no
other person;
(b) the signature creation data or
the authentication data were,
at the time of signing, under
the control of the signatory or,
as the case may be, the
authenticator and of no other
Electronic
person;
(c) any alteration to the electronic
signature made after affixing
such signature is detectable;
Signatures
(d) any alteration to the
information made after its
authentication by electronic
signature is detectable; and
(e) it fulfils such other conditions
which may be prescribed.
(3) The Central Government may
prescribe the procedure for the
purpose of ascertaining whether
electronic signature is that of the
person by whom it is purported to
have been affixed or
authenticated.
(4) The Central Government may,
by notification in the Official
Gazette, add to or omit any
electronic signature or electronic
authentication technique and the
procedure for affixing such
Electronic
signature from the Second
Schedule: Provided that no
electronic signature or
authentication technique shall be
Signatures
specified in the Second Schedule
unless such signature or
technique is reliable.
(5) Every notification issued
under sub-section (4) shall be laid
before each House of Parliament.]
Instead of specifying the technology to be used
for electronic signatures, the Legislature
specified certain criteria based on which a
technology may be prescribed by the
Government as a valid electronic signature. An
electronic record can be authenticated using any
form of electronic signature or other
authentication techniques.
Signatures
be detectable.
d) Any change or alteration of data after
affixing electronic signature must be
detectable.
The Central Government is the
authority to declare the technique
as reliable electronic signature
and can add or remove any
technique from the electronic
authentication technique. As on
date the central government has
not issued any notification on the
concept of electronic signature
electronic
the
signature
central
government to frame policy on
for
Electronic authentication of electronic
records. The only method of
Signatures and
punishes for identity theft. This
Act punishes fraudulent use of
electronic signature of any other
Electronic person and such person shall be
punished with imprisonment of
up to three years and will also
Signatures liable to pay fines which may
extend up to one lakh.
Misrepresentation or suppression of
material fact in order to obtain any license
or electronic signature is an offense under
section 71 of the Act. This section is
applicable in following cases
Digital
fact from, the Controller or Certifying
authority.
Such misrepresentation or suppression of
Digital
b) Publication of Electronic signature
certificate which subscriber of the
certificate has not accepted.
Signatures and
c) Publication of Electronic signature
certificate which is revoked or
suspended.
Signatures
electronic signature certificate for
fraudulent or unlawful purpose with
imprisonment for a term which may
extend up to two years or a fine which
may extend up to one lakh.
• Examples of Electronic
Signatures
• Click –Wrap Agreement-”I
Accept” button on websites
• Pin Numbers –ATM cards
• Digitized Image of Handwritten
Signature
Electronic
• Biometric signatures-
Electronic devices which scan
fingerprints, hand geometry,
retina scans, voice recognition
Examples
signature pads, etc which
capture handwritten
signatures
• Identity Verification Services-
Email validation, ID verification
Difference Between Electronic and
Digital Signatures
Criteria Electronic Signatures Digital Signatures
Definition It is a generic, technology neutral term that refers to It is simply a term for one technology-specific type of
the universe of all the various methods by which one e-signatures.
can “sign” an electronic record.
Technology They can take many forms and can be created by many It involves only the use of public key cryptography
different technologies. (asymmetric cryptography) to sign a message.
Examples A name typed at the end of an e-mail message by the It is a block of data at the end of an electronic message
sender; a digitized image of handwritten signature; a that attests to the authenticity of the said message.
secret code or PIN; a unique biometrics based Digital signatures are an actual transformation of an e-
identifier, etc. message using PKI. It requires a key pair and a hash
function. It provides greater assurance of a document’s
authenticity and integrity than other forms of e-
signatures.