Forging Techniques: Open vs Closed Die
Uploaded by
Rajeev RanaForging Techniques: Open vs Closed Die
Uploaded by
Rajeev RanaCommon questions
Powered by AIPiping defects are significant because they affect the integrity and strength of the extruded product. These defects arise from improper metal flow and the presence of impurities or oxides. Conditions such as high temperature, improper die design, inadequate material cleaning, and unoptimized extrusion ratios contribute to these defects, making control of these parameters essential for quality extrusion outcomes .
Slab analysis assumes the entire forging is plastic, the material is perfectly plastic, the friction coefficient is constant, plane strain conditions apply, and stresses within any thin slab of the material are uniform. These assumptions simplify the mathematical modeling of complex deformation processes, enabling easier calculation of force and stress distribution within the material during forging .
Grain flow in forging aligns in the direction of the metal flow during the operation, which enhances the mechanical properties of the parts, such as tensile strength and fatigue resistance. In contrast, casting results in a random grain structure, and machining cuts across grains, often leading to weaker areas at the interfaces .
Cogging is a specific type of open-die forging operation where the thickness of a bar is reduced through successive forging steps at specified intervals. Unlike other open-die operations, cogging involves a smaller contact area between the die and the workpiece, allowing large sections of a bar to be deformed using lower forces, which makes it particularly advantageous for reducing the thickness over a long length .
Barreling in upset forging occurs due to friction between the die surfaces and the workpiece, and thermal effects where the material near the die surfaces cools rapidly, increasing resistance to deformation at the extremities. It can be minimized by using effective lubricants to reduce friction and heating the dies to eliminate temperature gradients .
In hot steel extrusion, lubricants reduce friction between the die and the billet, facilitating smoother metal flow and reducing wear on the dies. Common lubricants include glass, which acts as a viscous barrier layer, and solids like MoS2 (molybdenum disulfide) and graphite, which help minimize friction at high operation temperatures .
Wire drawing involves plain stress and plain strain criteria, using smaller die angles with the material subjected to tensile forces, leading to a reduction in diameter or thickness. In contrast, tube drawing, especially without a mandrel, focuses on the plain strain condition without support, which means there’s limited control over thickness or surface finish. Tube drawing with a mandrel allows for more precise dimensions and finishes .
In direct extrusion, the billet is pushed through a stationary die, resulting in direct metal flow direction from the container through the die, usually involving high friction since the entire billet moves relative to the container walls. In contrast, indirect extrusion involves the die moving towards the stationary billet, minimizing container wall friction since the billet does not move relative to the container, leading to lower friction forces and potentially lower energy requirements .
In impression-die forging, the flash plays a critical role by allowing control of the material flow. As the workpiece deforms to fill the die cavity, the excess material forms the flash, which serves to ensure that the cavity is completely filled and also helps build pressure within the die to aid metal flow and fill detailed parts of the cavity. Post-forging, the flash is trimmed off .
Center cracking, or center burst, in extrusion is due to differences in velocity and tensile stresses within the material center. To prevent it, appropriate adjustments such as optimizing the die angle, controlling friction, and selecting the correct extrusion ratio can mitigate stress concentrations and ensure uniform flow, thus reducing the likelihood of such defects .