RMIT Classification: Trusted
MKTG 1421 -
Consumer Psychology
& Behaviour
Topic 3 - Problem recognition
1
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Learning Objectives
1. Problem recognition
2. Habitual, limited and extended decisions
3. Factors that affect problem recognition
4. Types of consumer problems
5. Marketing strategy and implications
2 2
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Consumer decision making process
Figure 1.6 / Consumer decision process
If consumers do not recognize a
problem to be solved, there is no
consumer decision process.
Note: Dotted lines represent
the potential for a step back
3 3
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Step 1: Problem or need recognition
1. Here the consumer is in equilibrium . Does
not recognise a problem.
Actual Ideal
2. Problem recognition occurs when
consumers perceive a gap between their
actual state or desired ideal state.
3. Cause may be actual state declining, or the
ideal state moving upward.
Actual Ideal
4. The magnitude of the gap must be enough
to motivate the consumer to proceed to
Stage 2
Actual Ideal
4 4
RMIT Classification: Trusted
What causes problem or need recognition?
Actual State: Where Ideal State: Where We
We Are Now Want To Be
Often determined by Based on our
simple physical expectations, future
factors goals or aspirations
External stimuli can
change how we
Changes in our life
perceive our actual situations
state
5 5
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Market polarization across categories
(Kotler et al
2021, p. 41)
6 6
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Does the consumer perceive a difference
between their actual or ideal state ?
No Yes
Terminate the Is the discrepancy strong enough to
decision process motivate the consumer ?
Yes.
No. Terminate the
Proceed to
decision process.
Stage 2
7 7
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Process of problem recognition
Desired Consumer
Current Situation
Lifestyle
Temporary factors
The way the consumer
affecting the consumer
would like to feel
Actual State
Desired State
The condition the
The condition the
consumer perceives him
consumer would like to be
or herself to be in at this
in at this point in time
point of time
Nature of Discrepancy
Difference between the consumer’s desired and perceived conitions
Desired state Actual state exceeds
No difference exceeds actual desired state
state
8 8
RMIT Classification: Trusted
How Viettel Pay leveraged on problem
recognition?
(Viettel
2019)
9 9
RMIT Classification: Trusted
The success of ViettelPay campaign
(Dentsu Redder
2020)
1010
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Products are positioned as providing a
potential solution
Damaged
Shine
Stronger
Vibrant
Straight
Hydrated
Source
1111
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Types of consumer decisions
What is purchase involvement ? Level of involvement impacts type of
decision making
1. Consumer’s level of concern,
interest and effort in the decision
Habitual decision making or
making process
2. Influenced by the interaction of
individual, product and situational Limited decision making or
characteristics
Extended decision making
1212
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Purchase involvement and types of
decisions
Low purchase High purchase
involvement involvement
Habitual Limited Extended
decision decision decision
making making making
Source 1313 Source
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Purchase involvement and types of decision
making
1414
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Difference between generic and selective
problem recognition
Generic Problem Selective Problem
Recognition Recognition
Need recognition occurs Need recognition occurs at
at product category level brand level as brands are
as all brands are similar differentiated.
The solution is the The solution is the brand
product category that is perceived as best
1515
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Example - Generic problem recognition
• Selling the product category to
increase demand for the category
• Sometimes the leading brand will do
this
• All brands will benefit
• The lead brands will benefit most due
to high market share
Source
1616
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Example – Selective problem recognition
Source
This ad attempts to activate selective problem
recognition by hoping to increase demand for
the brand
1717
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Types of consumer problems
1. Routine problems
o Expected, require immediate solution
2. Emergency problems
o Not expected, require immediate solution
3. Planning problems
o Expected, don’t require immediate solution
4. Evolving problems
o Not expected, don’t require immediate solution
1818
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Non-marketing factors affecting problem
recognition
Figure 3.3. / Non-marketing factors affecting problem recognition
1919
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Factors influencing the actual state
Source Source
Source Source
2020
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Activity: Problem recognition and
influencing factors
1. Identify the problems that a car can potentially solve for different
segments of customers? List as many as you can.
2. How different factors affect the problem recognition?
2121
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Marketing strategy and
problem recognition
1. Measuring problem recognition
2. Responding to consumer problems
3. Activating problem recognition
2222
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Activating problem recognition (1)
• Generic problem recognition (product category), e.g. dairy foods
• Selective problem recognition (a brand) e.g. Colgate Vitamin C for good
breath, Vinamilk for strong bones
2323
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Activating problem recognition (2)
1. Disrupt perceptions of the existing
state
Actual Ideal
2. Influence the desired state
3. Timing problem recognition
Actual Ideal
4. Suppressing problem recognition
Actual Ideal
2424
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Disrupt the perception of
the current state and desired state
(Samsung
2020)
2525
RMIT Classification: Trusted
WWF alerts people on plastic pandemic
(WWF n.d.)
2626
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Activity: How could you activate problem
recognition and timing for the following?
How could you activate problem recognition for:
• (a) bathroom scales
• (b) life insurance
• (c) laptop computers
• (d) vitamins
• (e) electric bicycles
2727
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Summary
1. What is the nature of problem recognition?
2. How does purchase involvement impact consumer decision making
3. What is the difference between habitual, limited and extended
decision making?
4. What factors affect problem recognition?
5. What are the types of consumer problem?
6. What marketing strategies can be used to activate problem
recognition?
2828
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Step 1: Problem recognition in the
consumer decision making process
Figure 1.6 / The consumer decision process Changes in actual
or desired state
1st step
Creates a felt
discrepancy
Consumer may be
motivated to
Note: Dotted lines
proceed to step two
represent the
potential for a step information search
back
2929
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Reference list (1)
Drews, G and Simms, M 2020, WWF: Your Plastic Diet, WARC An
Ascencial Company, viewed 14 April 2021, link to external site.
Dentsu Redder 2020, ViettelPay: Make Tet easy again – challenge
accepted!, WARC An Ascential Company, viewed 14 April 2021,
link to external site.
Haber, J 2010, Sofitel Official TVC, YouTube, viewed 14 April 2021,
link to external site.
3030
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Reference list (2)
JustaTee Music 2021, Lam Gi Phai Hot, Official Music Video, Vimeo,
viewed 14 April 2021, link to external site.
Phan, T & Tirunagari, A 2020, How brands in Vietnam inspire and connect
with audiences during Tet, Think With Google, Vietnam, viewed 14 April
2021, link to external site.
3131
RMIT Classification: Trusted
Reference list (3)
Samsung 2020, Galaxy Z Flip 5G: Official Film | Samsung, Samsung
YouTube, viewed 14 April 2021, link to external site.
WWF 2020, Your Plastic Diet, WWF, WARC, viewed 14 April 2021,
link to external site.
Quester, P, Neal, C, Pettigrew, S, Grimmer, M R, Davis, T, & Hawkins, D
2014, Consumer behaviour: Implications for marketing strategy. McGraw-
Hill.
3232