History of Child Rights & UN CRC
for Child parliamentarians
19TH SEPTEMBER 2016
Iqbal Ahmed Detho
Presentation Plan
History of Child Rights Evolution
UN CRC
Gaps in practice
Challenges
Conclusion
Question-Answer session
Phases of Evolution
1901-1947
1948-1977
1978-1989
1989-2000
2001-onwards
1901-1947
Ended the invisibility of children
Attention on the issues of child labor, hazardous
work, trafficking and sexual exploitation
ILO conventions on minimum age, night work
Geneva Declaration on the rights of child-1924
(care/protection model)
Mankind owes to the child the best it has to give
1948-1977
Universal Declaration of Human rights-art:25(2)
Geneva Conventions on the laws of war-Child as specific category of
protected person
UN declaration on the rights of child-1959(Social /Welfare model)
Child by reason of his physical and mental immaturity, needs special
safeguards, including legal protection, before as well as after birth
Two International Human rights Covenants
ICCPR-23&24, ICESCR-10
Non-discrimination as general principle of Human rights
Discrimination in education (UNESCO-60), employment and
occupation (ILO-58)
CERD and CEDAW-female and girl child
1978-1989
1978 Polish proposal in Commission on Human
Rights (CHR) now renamed as Human rights
council (HRC)
1979-1989 Drafting in the commission on human
rights
1989 (20th November) General Assembly
adoption.
1990 (2nd September) entry into force.
192 States Parties latest ratification - Timor Leste
1989-2000
World Declaration on the survival , Protection and
Development of Children-1990
Vienna declaration and program of Action -1993,Art-21
ILO convention on WFCL-1999
Landmines convention
Optional Protocol on sale of children, child prostitution,
child pornography entry into force 18 January 2002.
Optional protocol on involvement of children in Armed
conflicts entry into force 13 February 2002, Amendment of
article 42 (2) came into force in 2002.
2001-onwards
World summit for Child rights
A world fit for children-Out come
document (GA Resolution 10th May 2002)
The Yokohama Global commitment 2001
WHY DO CHILDREN HAVE A SET OF
HUMAN RIGHTS SPECIFIC TO THEM
Children as Humans-Recognition that they are entitled to
Human rights (not as property of their guardians)
Children require additional protection
MORAL AND LEGAL RECOGNITION OF
THEIR EMOTIONAL, PHYSICAL AND
PSYCHOLOGICAL VULNERABILITY
THEIR NEED FOR SPECIAL CARE.
RECOGNITION OF THE OBLIGATION TO RESPECT
AND ENSURE RESPECT FOR THEIR RIGHTS.
UN CONVENTION ON THE
RIGHTS OF THE CHILD
ORIGINS :-
Invisibility of the child in general human rights
law and its enforcement.
Fragmentation of child – specific provisions.
Significant gaps in the law.
Lack of an advocacy and programming focus for
children
DISTINTIVE CHARACTERISTICS OF
THE UNCRC.
UNIQUELY addressing a phase of human development.
Uniting civil, political, economic, social and culture rights and
identifying child-specific rights.
Organized around four core principles :
Non-discrimination-article 2
The child’s rights to be heard-article 12
The best interests of the child-article 3
The child’s rights to survival and development (Evolving
capacity of the child)-article 6
• Bridging human rights and humanitarian law.
• Recognizing roles for civil society, UN agencies and others
EXCEPTIONAL ASPECTS
OF THE IMPLEMENTATION
PRACTICE OF THE UNCRC
Near universal ratification from the outset
Promoting innovative implementation tools
Eg Governmental inter-departmental bodies
Government/civil society coordination bodies
Rights-audits/policy impact assessments
From national to local: Child Friendly Cities
Independent national child rights institutions
Promoting innovative treaty body and reporting
methodologies
Compliance
E.g Report preparation by states
The role of civil society
Procedures for consideration of reports
The role of Concluding Observations
CRC informing other human rights
instruments and mechanism
Regional level recognition of
children's rights
African Charter on the Rights and the Welfare of the Child
(1999)
Inter-American Court of Human Rights
Villagran Morales et al. V. Guatemala (1999)
Advisory Opinion, “Legal Status and Human Rights of the Child”
(2002)
Council of Europe
European Convention on the Exercise of Children’s Rights (1996)
Calls by Parliamentary Assembly for a European Omnibus Convention
on Child Rights
Challenges for CRC in Human
rights framework
CRC creating space for human rights in
hostile environments and complex
emergencies
Promoting of human rights compliance
(formal and practical) by non-state armed
groups (e.g South Sudan and Sierra Leone)
Initiating efforts toward a culture of human
rights
CHALLENGES FACED BY
THE UNCRC
IMPLEMENTATION
Notwithstanding near universal ratification
of CRC the levels of human rights abuse of
children remain at crisis levels across the
globe
At least five elements underlie the gap
between obligation and implementation of
the rights of the child:
Gaps in implementation
Gaps in law
Lack of will
Ignorance
Lack of resources
Weak enforcement
• Gaps in law e.g
• A need to address specific groups including the
girl child, indigenous, the disabled and IDP’s
New duty bearers
The responsibility of non-State actors
The responsibility of international
organizations
The responsibility of TNC and MNCs