From Reliable Sources: An Introduction to Historical Methods
RELIC OR
ARTIFACT?
Frescos from Cycladen island of Santorini Frescos from Crete
[Link]
[Link]
RELIC OR
ARTIFACT?
Hoi An’s Champa Ruins, Vietnam
[Link]
WHAT IS A SOURCE?
SOURCE- artifacts that have been left by
the past that exists as:
RELICS or REMAINS
TESTIMONIES
RELICS or REMAINS offer a clue about the
past simply by virtue of their existence.
TESTIMONIES are oral or written reports
that describe an event.
What
How
Why
Relics are typically used in the daily life
before.
Testimonies were composed to provide
proof of an act or a right that informs the
people about the fact.
Testimonies and Artifacts were created
to serve as records, however, there are
sources that are created intentionally
or unintentionally.
INTENTIONAL SOURCES
contain features not under the
control of their authors and have lives
beyond their original intentions
UNINTENTIONAL SOURCES
Are unintentional only in the sense
that they were not produced with the
historian’s question in mind.
“A source provides us evidence about the
existence of an event; a historical
interpretation is an argument about the
event.”
PRIMARY SOURCE
are immediate, first-hand accounts of a
topic, from people who had a direct
connection with it.
SECONDARY SOURCE
are one step removed from primary
sources, though they often quote or
otherwise use primary sources.
PRIMARY SOURCE
DIRECT- might be the letters or chronicles, a
law, or a poem.
INDIRECT- might be an inventory list of the
letters and books from which an
interpretation can be deduced.
SOURCE TYPOLOGY
TYPOLOGY OF SOURCES
WRITTEN
-Literary or Narrative
-Diplomatic
-Social Documents
UNWRITTEN
-Archaeological
-Oral
WRITTEN
LITERARY or NARRATIVE
Traditional classification that
includes chronicles or tracts that are
presented in order to impart a
particular message.
WRITTEN
DIPLOMATIC
Documents relating to legal
situation, treated as the best
“PUREST” source.
WRITTEN
DIPLOMATIC
Documents relating to legal
situation, treated as the best
“PUREST” source.
DIPLOMATIC sources composed of
three parts:
1. Protocol
2. Content
3. Closing
WRITTEN
SOCIAL DOCUMENTS
Products of record-keeping by
bureaucracies. Contains information
of economic, social, political or judicial
import.
UNWRITTEN
ARCHAEOLOGICAL EVIDENCE
Tells historians a great deal about
culture of the area, ways of life,
artistic ambitions of the people.
UNWRITTEN
ORAL EVIDENCE
comes in the forms of tales and
the sagas of ancient peoples, or folks
songs and rituals.
“OTHER SOURCES”
Added as technology emerges
RADIO
TELEVISIONS
SOUND RECORDINGS
Even with the categories of sources,
historians still aid their interpretation
with a mixture of different types of
sources to come up with an accurate
historical argument.