Management of Medium-Size /
Revamping Projects
Oil & Gas Downstream Projects
1. Introduction to Oil & Gas downstream projects
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013
Course Scope and Purpose
Scope:
• Project Management, from conceptual to operation readiness
• Applied to Medium-Size and Revamp projects (no grassroots)
• Refining and Chemicals projects
Course Objectives:
• Explain to the participants how to:
− Manage a Medium-Size / Revamping project at each stage
− Effectively manage Q.H.S.E, Cost and Schedule Risks
− Plan and control the project execution from beginning till completion
− Manage critical interfaces with authorities, operations, stakeholders
• Make sure that the participants:
© 2011 - IFP Training
− Understand the concepts that are explained during the course
− Are able to apply them on actual practical cases
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 2
Management of Medium-Size /
Revamping Projects: course content
I. Introduction
II. Preliminary Studies
III. Basic Engineering (or FEED)
IV. EPC Contracting
V. Organization and Engineering
VI. Procurement
VII. HSE, Quality and Risk Management
VIII. Project Control (cost/schedule)
© 2011 - IFP Training
IX. Construction and Fabrication Management
X. Completion / Commissioning / Start-up / Closure
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013
3
MS/R Project types
Project size “definition”:
• Projects can be very small ... (criticality and risk are not proportional to amount)
• Total cost is typically between 20 and 200 million $ (above, large project)
Project characteristics:
• Executed within existing facilities
− Either being operated in standard conditions (plant in operation)
− Or shutdown for a short period (a few weeks)
Various types of technical scope:
• Safety, regulatory or environmental compliance improvement
• Debottlenecking, moderate capacity or reliability increase
• Rejuvenation, upgrading of key process equipment
• Improvement of technical performance (energy, yields)
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 4
Project activities
Project Management of
Estimates
structure resources
Typical steps
to handle (as
per PMIbok) Delivery
Project time
definition reduction
Introduction Measurement
Management Audit and
Organization of progress
of risks closure
Cost control
© 2011 - IFP Training
Project Manage
Leadership Partnership
strategy team
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 5
Project stages
EPC contract
Project approval
Approval
Project Development Project Execution Start-Up
Operation
Business
Plan
Detailed Engineering Reception
Screening Planning Basic Commissioning
Engineering Procurement
Construction
Gate 1 Gate 2 Gate 3 Final
agreement
© 2011 - IFP Training
This process is applicable to oil & gas projects but also to any kind of industrial projects
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 6
Facility operational organization
Owner organization may be involved in projects development:
Operations (Production, Maintenance)
• Personnel training, operating manuals
• Subcontracted work and field supervision
• Commissioning and Startup
Technology / HSE
• Scope validation and optimization
• Process Risk Analysis, Change management
• Management of controlled documentation
Regional Headquarters
© 2011 - IFP Training
• Financial and technical support
• Project auditing
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 7
Typical production site organization
Owner site Resident engineers
organization
Project Manager Engineering
contractor
Lead
Safety Quality Support Construction Reception
engineering
manager manager manager manager manager Engineering
engineer
leader
Contract Supervision Reception
Project Process engineer engineer engineer
engineer engineer Project Process
engineer engineer
Cost Site
Expert Expert engineer supervisor
engineer engineer Expert Cost
engineer supervisor
Accounting
engineer
Safety Construction
engineer engineer
© 2011 - IFP Training
Computer
engineer
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 8
Why & when a project?
Economical justification of Projects
New products Increase capacity
Increase feedstock
New qualities enhancement Sulphur level
CO2 emission
Energy conservation Waste heat recovery
Energy yield improvement
H.S.E improvement Reduce atmosphere emissions, SO2, Nox, BETEX, CO2
Reduce effluents to sea, to river, waste treatment
Improve safety equipment, safety systems, emergency systems
Operability Control systems upgrade
Electrical systems upgrade
Increase utilities production
Increase capacity storage
© 2011 - IFP Training
Increase communications systems
Maintenance Increase equipment reliability
Upgrade working conditions
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 9
Project execution process: stages
Before Project final approval After Project final approval
Idea Contracting
Conceptual design Detailed Engineering
•Technical Concept studies
•(Prelim.) Project Planning
Procurement
(Simple Projects) (Equipment, bulks)
(Fabrication), Construction, (T& I)
Basic (or FEED) Commissioning, Start-Up, [Link]
Engineering
© 2011 - IFP Training
•Technical Package(s)
•Project Planning
Guarantee Period
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 10
Project execution process: gates
Before Project final approval After Project final approval
Idea Contracting
Proceed to Concept Contract Award
Detailed Engineering
Conceptual design Project approval
Procurement
(Simple Projects)
Proceed to Basic
(Fabrication), Construction,
Commissioning, Start-Up, [Link]
Basic (or FEED) Mechanical Completion
Provisional Acceptance
© 2011 - IFP Training
Engineering
Guarantee
Period
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013
Final Acceptance 11
Maintenance activities
All activities required to keep the Plant equipment in working condition
Planned (preventive/predictive program, running or during shut-downs)
• Inspections (piping, vessels, lining…)
• Replacement of parts (pipes, seals, bearings, tubing…)
• Equipment cleaning (heat exchangers, turbine blades…)
• Instruments/Analyzers (verification, calibration, replacement…)
• Catalysts and chemicals loads replacement
Unplanned (equipment repairs due to failures)
• Leaks (valves, gaskets, piping, seals, furnace and exchanger tubes…)
• Vibrations (rotating equipment, structures, piping, supports…)
• Breaks (instruments, rotating equipment, vessels…)
© 2011 - IFP Training
May even include very minor improvements
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 12
HSE risks of projects in existing facilities
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 13
Reliability risks of projects in existing facilities
© 2011 - IFP Training
Key data will often be missing, misleading, contradictory or confusing
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 14
Risk mitigation
Participation of Plant personnel to design/construction
• Knowledge of existing facilities, of operating procedures
• Availability of up-to-date and correct documentation
• Scope and schedule extensive communication
Field surveys before starting engineering studies
• Soils, topography, underground equipment
• Civil works, structures, foundations, buildings
• Piping configuration, E&I cable networks, tag numbers
Site procedures applicable for Project field works
• SHE: access, work permit, emergency, confined spaces, height…
• Operations: change management, communication…
© 2011 - IFP Training
• Project: standards, key steps, documentation, exceptions…
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 15
Project schedule and Plant shut-downs
Existing facilities are subject to Maintenance S/D, to be considered when
planning a project which requires stoppage of units or other facilities
Planned Shut-Downs
• Plant turnaround (regulatory inspection, major repairs): 3 to 6 years
• Unit or equipment turnaround (spared or by-passable): 1 to 3 years
• Overhaul of large unique equipment: sometimes up to every year
• Planned shut-downs of downstream facilities providing utilities
• Short duration shutdowns for connecting or installing a project
Unplanned Shut-Downs: sometimes a tie-ins opportunity (if ready)
Minimizing shutdown duration is always a key project objective:
• Works during shutdown are always more costly
© 2011 - IFP Training
• Production losses may kill the project benefits
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 16
Managing several projects simultaneously
Each Project has its own budget, cost and schedule
Several activities can be shared between projects
• Project Management and Coordination
• Quality Assurance and Control
• HSE and specialized field supervision
• Part-time technical support
• Procurement/Expediting activities
• Secretarial services
Managing priorities implies
• Flexibility
• A good understanding of project justifications
© 2011 - IFP Training
• Close cooperation with the Owner
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 17
Introduction to project management
Key points to keep in mind
Project risks are not proportional to project cost
HSE and Reliability risk has to be closely managed
Interfaces with Owner organization are critical to success
The Stage-Gate process should be strictly applied
Understanding Maintenance organization can help a lot
Simultaneous success in all areas is a Must
• Safety, Health and Environmental
• Quality / Owner full satisfaction
• Schedule compliance
• Cost optimization
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 18
Management of Medium-Size / Revamping Projects
Downstream examples
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 19
Downstream: typical petrochemical complex
© 2011 - IFP Training
Exxon by courtesy
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 20
Refinery: general process functional diagram
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 21
Two stage hydrocraker: typical process flow diagram
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 22
Downstream: typical refining process vessel and compressor
Screw high pressure compressor
© 2011 - IFP Training
Hydrocracker process vessel
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 23
Downstream: typical revamping work
Tank relocation Shell and Conoco by courtesy
Tower modifications
Pipe rack reinforcement
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 24
Downstream: typical revamping work
Shell and Exxon by courtesy
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 25
Downstream: typical revamping work
Shell, Conoco and Exxon by courtesy
© 2011 - IFP Training
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 26
Refinery: jet fuel storage ... Engineering and construction
3D view as per engineering
Construction at site
© 2011 - IFP Training
Shell by courtesy
RC - PR GES - 08168_A_A - Rev.1 - 18/07/2013 27