INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
ERP Selection
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Overview
Basic question: How does a firm justify implementing an ERP system?
Why are we doing this? How do we know that the benefits outweigh the costs? What is the business case for ERP?
What are the categories of benefits? What are the costs? What are the hidden costs?
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
IS/IT Projects
Typically
Late Over budget Fail to satisfy design specifications
Are among the largest IT projects there are for most organizations Cost range $5 million to over $100 million (+)
ERP projects
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Expected Installation Time
Mabert et al. (2000); Olhager & Selldin (2003)
Time to Install ERP
12 months
US
34%
Sweden
38%
13 to 24 months
25 to 36 months
45%
11%
49%
8%
37 to 48 months
> 48 months
INFO245
6%
2%
4%
1%
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Estimated Installation Cost
Mabert et al. (2000); Olhager & Selldin (2003)
Installation Cost
< $5 million
US
42%
Sweden
40%
$5 million to $25 million
$26 million to $50 million
33%
10%
35%
18%
$51 million to $100 million
> $100 million
INFO245
7%
7%
7%
In prior
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
ERP Life Cycle
The ERP Life Cycle is composed of 5 major Phases
Grouping of related activities Analysis: understanding business needs how do we want configure the software (choose from software options) Design: prototyping, pilots, etc. Implementation: final configuration, testing (lots), and rollout Project planning Support
Three major activities
Two additional phases
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Cost / Benefit Analysis
Assess if project is worth doing, from a financial perspective Quantify costs Quantify benefits Perform financial calculations to assess economic feasibility are financial benefits significantly greater than financial costs? Types of analysis: Net present value, Payback period, ROI over specified time period
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Cost Proportions
Mabert et al. (2000); Olhager & Selldin (2003)
Where money spent
Software Consulting Hardware Implementation team Training Other
INFO245
US
30% 24% 18% 14% 11% 3%
Sweden
24% 30% 19% 12% 14% 1%
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Intangibles in Cost / Benefit
Intangible costs and benefits cannot always be measured, but must be considered. Sometimes, intangibles determine if project proceeds or not. Intangible Benefits
Increased levels of service Customer satisfaction Survival Need to develop in-house expertise Reduced employee moral Lost productivity Lost customers or sales
Intangible Costs
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Defining Business Rationale: tangible and intangible benefits
Need to define business rationale/anticipated benefits for imple ERP:
Helps set clear, unambiguous objectives
> Why?
Makes the firm commit necessary resources Provides direction for ERP design focus
> For example, business process improvement
Determine how success will be measured
> This is sometimes critical to whether or not the project is approved > Metrics: examples?
Ensure senior management on board
> Why?
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Business Rationales
Categories
Technology: Replace outdated hardware and software with more scalable, flexible and maintainable technology Business Process: Replace inefficient legacy processes with new processes that are grounded in best practices Strategic: Implement a technology platform that gives the organization abilities it did not have before Competitive: Provide the organization a better ability to compete in their industry
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Technology Rationales Year 2000
The Y2K bug Quoted Y2K costs: $1 + per line of code (typical large organization: 10s of millions of lines) Multiple vendors and platforms Inability to access and share critical information Expensive to maintain (muliple DBs, OS, programming environments) Staff acquisition and training a big issue
Multiple distinct, disparate systems
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Technology Rationales
Poor quality of existing systems
Often the result of a band aid approach the 10 room shack difficult to fix, impossible to improve Different coding schemes, disparate platforms cross company integration very difficult Common integration platform
Need to integrate corporate acquisitions
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Technology Rationales Measurement
Often made on yes-no basis
Solve Y2K? Facilitate integration of processes? Acquired companies? Scalable? More easily maintained and supported? Cost avoidance is often sited as rationale Technology an enabler of direct monetary impacts
Strong non-monetary motivation (although)
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Business Process Rationales
Improve business processes with an eye to efficiency, new capabilites. Personnel and IT cost reduction
especially accounting, clerical and IT personnel affecting any number of process areas Less paper, handoffs
Productivity improvements
Financial Cycle Close
timely official financial information for decision-making Real time availability of data
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Business Process Rationales Measurement There may be specific, quantifiable monetary goals
Some goals e.g., quality are difficult to quantify in monetary terms
Predictability / accuracy of measurement depends on reengineering method Common monetary goals:
productivity gains do more with less people and associated reduction in costs Increased reliability due to better maintenance: no unscheduled downtime, Reduction in raw material purchases/less inventory fewer warehouses lower freight costs Reduced costs associated with accounting function
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Strategic Rationales
Facilitate new strategies for the organization Reasons beyond process / transaction efficiency
better customer satisfaction, quality corporate image allow base for emerging technology : e-commerce Allow the organization to do things it could not do before Allow company to enter new markets Employee retention and attraction Project a professional, modern image New revenue generating opportunities
Measured in non-monetary terms
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Competitive Rationale Our competitor has it, so we need it to stay in business
Why does our competitor have it? Do we need it too? What happens if we dont? cost and impact on business is not certain E.g. - Availability to promise 110% Guarantee Superior customer response
Measured in non-monetary terms
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
Levi Case
What rationale(s) did Levi used to justify ERP decision? Categories
Technology Business Process Strategic Competitive
INFO245
INFORMATION SYSTEMS @ X
The REALLY important criteria
How does a firm finally decide whether or not to go ERP?
By addressing the question..What keeps executives awake at night? Is there some crisis (technical, competitive, or other) that necessitates a change? Organizations often need to be galvanized into action
INFO245