Needs
Criteria Excellent (5) Good (4) Satisfactory (3)
Improvement (2)
Mostly
Many steps are out
Steps are fully correct order
Structure & Some steps are of order or
logical and in with one
Order out of order sequence is
correct sequence minor
unclear
mistake
Mostly clear Some Instructions are
All steps are clear,
Clarity of with minor instructions are very unclear or
specific, and easy
Instructions unclear unclear or difficult to
to follow
wording confusing understand
All necessary steps One minor Two important
Several important
Completeness are included; step is steps are
steps are missing
nothing is missing missing missing
Steps show
Steps show clear
Logical logical Limited logical Steps show little
logical thinking
Thinking & thinking but thinking; steps logical thinking or
and include
Detail lack some are too general are too vague
appropriate detail
detail