Is eating meat by humans considered predation?
the introduction:
From an ecological perspective (According to Ecology), human consumption of meat falls
under the concept of predation, but with fundamental transformations that distinguish it from
other predatory animals:
Position in the food chain:
Humans are currently secondary and tertiary consumers, but their nutritional level (Trophic
Level) according to the Food and Agriculture Organization.
The reason: Man's great dependence on plants and animal products from herbivores (i.e.,
energy reaches him after an additional intermediary).
Energy efficiency:
Environmental laws state: Energy transfer between food chains should not exceed 10%.
Humans often prey on herbivores (cows, poultry), which is more environmentally efficient
than preying on other predators.
Important note: When comparing human meat consumption with the behavior of wild
predators, we must differentiate between the traditional behavior of humans in the past and
the behavior of humans prevalent in modern life.
Therefore, the concept of predation in humans can be divided into two concepts:
1- Predation in traditional (ancient) systems:
Humans were apex predators (Apex Predator) in its local environments.
• When hunting deer or fish, he regulated the number of prey like any wolf or tiger.
· It did not cause a major environmental disruption due to the limited number and weak
technology.
2-Predation in industrial systems (today):
Predation has become detached from the environment: Natural predation occurs within a
closed ecosystem. Humans import feed, confine animals, and control reproduction.
Displacement of natural predators: Humans have taken over hunting grounds, reduced the
number of wolves and lions, and then replaced them with farms.
Breaking the nutrient cycle: In nature, predators return elements to the soil through waste
and carcasses. Humans prevent this return and require artificial fertilizers.
Impact on the food web:
Natural predation preserves biodiversity.
Overhunting or large-scale livestock farming leads to a simplification of the food web, i.e.
replacing the diversity of species with only two or three species (cow, chicken, pig).
Environmental summary:
Environmentally speaking, the act of eating meat is predation, but the modern system of
meat production is not predation in the classical environmental sense.
The latter is the industrial production of herbivores within a semi-closed system, which has
implications for energy, nutrients, and biodiversity, making it more akin to agriculture than to
wild predation.
References:
[1]Bonhommeau, S., Dubroca, L., Le Pape, O., Barde, J., Kaplan, D. M., Chassot, E., &
Nieblas, A.‐E. (2013). Eating up the world's food web and the human trophic level.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 110(51), 20617–20620.
[Link]
[2]Lennox, RJ, Darimont, CT, Childs, DZ, Piczak, ML, & Cooke, SJ (2022). The roles of
humans and apex predators in sustaining ecosystem structure and function: Contrast,
complementarity and substitution. People and Nature, 4(5), 1085–1098.
[Link]
[3]Adams, M. S., Service, C. N., Bateman, A. W., Bourbonnais, M., & Artelle, K. A. (2024).
Human disturbance in riparian areas disrupts predator–prey interactions between grizzly
bears and salmon. Ecology and Evolution, 14(1), e10842. [Link]
[4]Machovina, B., Feeley, K. J., & Ripple, W. J. (2020). Human carnivory as a major driver
of vertebrate extinction. Perspectives in Ecology and Conservation, 18(4), 221–229.
[Link]
[5]Fleming, P. J. S., & Ballard, G. (2017). Homo sapiens is the apex animal: A review of
predator control and its implications for conservation. Australian Zoologist, 39(1), 62–75.
[Link]
[6]Darimont, CT, Fox, CH, Bryan, HM, & Reimchen, TE (2015). The unique ecology of
human predators. Science, 349(6250), 858–860. [Link]
[7]Ripple, W.J., Wolf, C., Newsome, T.M., Betts, M.G., Ceballos, G., Courchamp, F., ... &
Van Valkenburgh, B. (2019). Are we eating the world's megafauna to extinction?
Conservation Letters, 12(3), e12627. [Link]
[8]Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2023). Livestock Primary: Production and
Trophic Level Estimates. FAOSTAT Statistical Database.
[Link]
[9]Österblom, H., Crona, B., Folke, C., Nyström, M., & Troell, M. (2017). Marine science
ecosystem on an intertwined planet. Ecosystems, 20(1), 54–61.
[Link]