0% found this document useful (0 votes)
22 views3 pages

Problem Set 5

The document outlines a problem set for a course on Grand Canonical Ensembles, focusing on Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein statistics. It includes various problems related to partition functions, probability calculations for distinguishable and indistinguishable particles, and the differences between classical and quantum statistics. Additionally, it addresses concepts such as Bose-Einstein condensation, entropy, and fluctuations in particle systems.

Uploaded by

khush.vns37
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
22 views3 pages

Problem Set 5

The document outlines a problem set for a course on Grand Canonical Ensembles, focusing on Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein statistics. It includes various problems related to partition functions, probability calculations for distinguishable and indistinguishable particles, and the differences between classical and quantum statistics. Additionally, it addresses concepts such as Bose-Einstein condensation, entropy, and fluctuations in particle systems.

Uploaded by

khush.vns37
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Problem-Set-V: Grand Canonical Ensembles: FD

and BE statistics
CHM322: Dr. Arnab Ghosh

March 27, 2025

1. Consider a system of two atoms, each having only 3 quantum states of


energies 0, ε and 2ε. The system is in contact with a heat bath at temper-
ature T . Write down the partition function for the system if the particles
obey (i) Classical statistics and are distinguishable. (b) Classical statistics
and are indistinguishable. (c) Fermi statistics and (d) Bose statistics.
2. Consider a system of two identical particles wich may occupy any of the
three energy levels εn = nε, where n = 0, 1, 2.... Assume that the lowest
energy state ε0 is doubly degenerate. The system is in thermal equilib-
rium at temperature T . Calculate the partition for the following cases:
Particles obey (i) Fermi statistics (ii) Bose statistics. Carefully enumerate
the configurations in each cases.
3. Imagine that a particle can exist in one of the two states, labelled by
|0i and |1i. Now, consider two such particles. What is the probability
that both particles are in the state |0i when they are (a) distinguishable
(b) indistinguishable, but classical (c) indistinguishable bosons and (d)
indistinguishable fermions. Finally, comment on are identical particles
always indistinguishable?
4. ∗ BE and FD statistics using microcanonical ensemble: (a) Show
that the number of ways distributing nj bosons among gj states with any
number of particles in each is
(gj + nj − 1)!
Ωj =
nj !(gj − 1)!
For fermions distributing nj fermions among gj states with not more than
one particle in each is
gj !
Ωj =
nj !(gj − nj )!
Here show that
X
S = −kB gj [nj ln nj ∓ (1 ± nj ) ln(1 ± nj )]
j

1
where nj = nj /gj are the mean occupation numbers of the quantum parti-
cles. Maximize this expression subject to the constraint that total energy
E and number of particles N are constant, show that
1
nj =
eα+βEj ∓ 1

1
5. By rewriting the FD function f (E) = eβ(E−µ)−1
, as
 
1 1
f (E) = 1 − tanh β(E − µ)
2 2

Show that f (E) is symmetric about E = µ and sketch the function. Find
simplified expressions for f (E) when (i) E  µ (ii) E  µ and (iii) E ≈ µ.
6. For a system of non-interacting electrons, show that the probability of
finding an electron in a state with energy ∆ above the chemical potential
µ is the same as the probability of finding an electron absent from a state
with energy ∆ below the µ at any given temperature T .
7. State the basic differences in the fundamental assumptions underlying
Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB), Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) statis-
tics. (a) Why the distinction between the above three types of statistics
becomes unimportant in the limit of high temperature? Comment on
“how high is high”?
8. Argue which statistics (MB, FD, BE) would be appropriate for (a) density
of He4 gas at room temperature and pressure. (b) density of electrons in
Cu at room temperature. (c) density of electrons and holes in semicon-
ducting Ge at room temperature (Ge band-gap ≈ 1 volt).

9. Show that for Z = eβµ  1, FD and BE statistics tend to MB statistics.


Using the DOS of an ideal gas, show that gas density n = Zλ3th (or Z =
nλ3th ), where λ3th = (h2 /2πmkB T )3/2 is the quantum volume.
10. Calculate the temperature at which nλ3th = 1, when n = 1Å−3 .

11. Consider a gas of non-interacting, non-relativistic, identical bosons. Ex-


plain why BEC does not occur in one and two dimensions.
12. ∗ Give the Boltzmann’s statistical definition of entropy. Consider a two-
level system (TLS) of N = n↓ + n↑ particles is distributed among two
eigenstates 1 and 2 with eiegenenergies E1 and E2 respectively. The sys-
tem is in contact with a heat bath at temperature T . If a single quantum
emission into the reservoir occurs, populations changes n2 → n2 − 1 and
n1 → n1 + 1 take place in the system. For n1  1 and n2  1, obtain the
expression for the entropy change of the TLS and reservoir, and derive the
Boltzmann relation for the ratio n2 /n1 .

2
13. Estimate the spacing in between the ground and the first excited state
of the para-hydrogen in kelvin unit. Show that the ratio of ortho-and
para-hydrogen is given by
2
e−J(J+1)~ /2IkB T
P
J=1,3,5,...
f = 3P −J(J+1)~2 /2IkB T
J=0,2,4,... e

Find the value of f at 50 K.


14. ∗∗ A 7 N14 nucleus has nuclear spin I = 1. Assume that the diatomic
molecule N2 can rotate but not vibrate at ordinary temperature and ignore
electronic motion. Find the relative abundances of the ortho and para
molecules in a sample of N2 gas. What happens to the relative abundance
as the temperature is lowered towards absolute zero?
15. Use the canonical ensemble to prove that
1
Cv = h(E − hEi)2 i
kB T 2

16. (a) Show that the average energy E of a system in contact with heat bath
(canonical ensemble) is
∂ ln z
E=−
∂β
P
where z = n exp(−βEn ), sum over all states of the system. (b) Obtain
an expression for E 2 in terms of the derivativeqof ln z. (c) Calculate the
2 √
dispersion (∆E)2 = E 2 − E . (d) Show that (∆E)2 = kB Cv T . (e)
q
Use the above results and derive an expression for (∆E)2 /E for an ideal
monoatomic gas.
17. What is root-mean-square fluctuations in the number p of photons with
mode frequency ω of a black body cavity? Show that h(∆n)2 i is always
greater than hni for photon gas in blackbody cavity.
18. ∗ Consider an ideal Fermi gas at a temperature T . (a) Write the probabil-
ity p(n) that there are n fermions in a single particle state as a function of
mean occupation number hni. (b) Find the r.m.s fluctuation h(n−hni)2 i1/2
of a single particle state as a function of hni. Sketch the result.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Deriving the heat capacity expression using the canonical ensemble is crucial as it relates energy fluctuations to observable thermodynamic quantities through Cv = (1/k_BT^2)⟨(E−⟨E⟩)^2⟩. This shows that heat capacity fundamentally measures energy fluctuations within a system, indicating how a system's energy spreads around its average value. It highlights the connection between microscopic fluctuations and macroscopic properties, allowing deeper insight into system stability and phase transitions. The expression also provides a practical tool for calculating Cv, validating theoretical models with experimental measurements .

Quantum mechanical degeneracy pressure is vital in understanding white dwarf stability because, as Fermi-Dirac systems, the electrons in a white dwarf are subject to the Pauli exclusion principle, resulting in degeneracy pressure that counteracts gravitational collapse. This pressure arises as electrons fill available quantum states up to the Fermi energy, leading to a high momentum that does not depend on temperature. Unlike thermal pressure, which relies on temperature, degeneracy pressure provides a fundamental stability mechanism, allowing white dwarfs to remain stable despite lacking nuclear fusion for pressure support .

The partition function for such a system depends on the statistics of the particles involved. For distinguishable particles following classical statistics, the partition function Z is given by Z = (1 + e^{-βε} + e^{-2βε})^2, as each particle can independently occupy any of the three states. For indistinguishable particles under classical statistics, the expression changes due to the indistinguishability factor: Z = (1 + e^{-βε} + e^{-2βε})(1 + e^{-βε} + e^{-2βε})/2. For Fermi-Dirac statistics, only states with no more than one particle per quantum state are permissible, resulting in Z = 1 + e^{-βε} + e^{-2βε} + e^{-2βε}, with combinations of states (0,0), (1,ε), and (2,2ε). Under Bose-Einstein statistics, multiple particles can occupy the same state, resulting in additional terms in the partition function to account for such combinations .

Entropy changes in a two-level system illustrate the statistical link between microstates and macroscopic observables via the Boltzmann relationship, S = k_B ln Ω, where Ω is the number of microstates. When a system is in contact with a heat bath, the change in populations n2 and n1 due to energy transitions alters entropy, effectively bridging changes in microstate probabilities with macroscopic entropy. Such changes emphasize the link between microscopic dynamics and macroscopic thermodynamic laws, underlying predictions of equilibrium and energy distribution across states .

Boltzmann's statistical definition of entropy, S = k_B ln Ω, applies to a system in thermal equilibrium with a heat bath by quantifying entropy as a function of accessible microstates. This definition serves as a bridge to thermodynamics because changes in Ω reflect variations in state probabilities as a system exchanges energy with its surroundings. This provides the basis for deriving relations such as dS = δQ/T, where δQ is heat exchanged and T is temperature, further illustrating how statistical mechanics underpins the macroscopic phenomena described in classical thermodynamics. It highlights the emergence of equilibrium states and spontaneous processes from microscopic disorder .

Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB) statistics assume particles are distinguishable and do not obey the quantum constraints applicable in Fermi-Dirac (FD) or Bose-Einstein (BE) statistics. FD statistics apply to particles that are indistinguishable and obey the Pauli exclusion principle, allowing only one particle per quantum state (e.g., electrons). BE statistics apply to indistinguishable particles that can multiple-occupy the same quantum state (e.g., photons). At high temperatures and low densities, the differences between these statistics fade because the quantum effects become negligible, reducing the contribution of quantum states configuration, and particles behave more classically, following MB statistics .

The Fermi-Dirac distribution function f(E) = 1/(e^{β(E−μ)} + 1) can be rewritten using hyperbolic functions as f(E) = 1/2 (1 - tanh(1/2β(E−μ))), showing that it is symmetric about E=μ because the tanh term is an odd function centered around zero. This symmetry implies that for energies equal to the chemical potential, the probability of occupancy is exactly 1/2, which is critical for understanding electron distributions around the Fermi energy. It also indicates that energy states above and below the chemical potential have complementary occupation probabilities at any given temperature .

For two particles in the same state, the probability depends on their statistics. For distinguishable particles, assuming two possible states |0⟩ and |1⟩, the probabilities are straightforward calculations of occupancy, resulting in 1/4. Classical indistinguishable particles introduce a symmetry factor, resulting in a probability of 1/3. For bosons, which can occupy the same state without restriction, the probability increases to 1/2. Fermions cannot occupy the same quantum state due to the Pauli exclusion principle, resulting in a probability of 0 for both particles being in the same state .

Bose-Einstein Condensation does not occur in one and two-dimensional systems because the required phase space density necessary for BEC cannot be achieved in these lower dimensions. The condensation requires a macroscopic occupation of the ground state, which necessitates a divergence in the density of states which is not present in one or two dimensions due to reduced phase space volume and the geometry of confinement. Thus, in lower dimensions, the critical temperature for BEC effectively reaches zero, preventing condensation from occurring .

For small fugacity (Z = e^{βμ} ≪ 1), both Fermi-Dirac and Bose-Einstein statistics converge to Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics. This is due to the exponential growth of e^{βE} dominating the Boltzmann factor in this limit. As a result, the quantum volume, λ_{th}^3 = (h^2/2πmk_BT)^{3/2}, becomes significant compared to the density, making quantum effects negligible. Consequently, gas properties tend toward classical behavior, simplifying calculations of properties such as pressure and volume. This highlights how, under conditions of high temperature or low particle density, quantum statistics recede to classical statistics .

You might also like