Article
Article
nacera86@[Link]
Abstract:
The main purpose of this article is to identify the link between service quality and
customer satisfaction/loyalty in the field of mobile telephony. To Carry out our survey, we
conducted an exploratory study with a sample of customers who use 4G services launched
by the Algerian operator Ooredoo. The data collected is processed using SPSS-22
software.
The results obtained underline that the satisfaction of the people questioned depends
as much on the quality of the offer proposed as on the welcome and attentive listening that
the staff in contact reserve for customers. Just as the loyalty of the latter, measured by
their intention to change operator, is impacted by the quality of service offered to them.
Keywords:service quality; satisfaction; loyalty; 4G, Ooredo
Jel Classification Codes : L21 ; M31.
:ملخص
. والء العمالء في مجال الهاتف املحمول/ الهدف من هذه املقالة هو تحديد الرابط بين جودة الخدمة ورضا
Ooredoo التي أطلقتها شركةG4 أجرينا دراسة استكشافية على عينة من العمالء الذين يستخدمون خدمات،للقيامبذلك
.SPSS-22 تتم معالجة البيانات التي تم جمعها باستخدام برنامج.الجزائرية
تظهر النتائج التي تم الحصول عليها أن الرضا يعتمد إلى حد كبير على جودة العرض املقدم كما يعتمد على
الذي يقاس بنيتهم فيتغيير، مثلما يتأثر والء هؤالء.االستماع الترحيبي واليقظ الذي يحتفظ به املوظفون املتصلون بالعمالء
. بجودة الخدمة املقدمة لهم،املشغل
.Ooredoo ،G 4 ، الوالء، الرضا، جودة الخدمة: الكلمات املفتاحية
.M31 ؛L21 : JEL تصنيف
- 42 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
I. Introduction:
The transition to a market economy leaves no chance to those who do not adapt to it. It
encourages companies to adopt new forms of management allowing them to optimally combine
their various resources (human and financial). This aims to continuously improve the quality of
their offers in a market where competition is intense, and where customer requirements are
growing.
The increased development of new information and communication technologies, particularly
the Internet, is leading to changes in consumer behavior. The use of mobile Internet and
applications on users' mobile phones is constantly increasing.
Service marketing research shows that service quality remains the antecedent of customer
satisfaction. To this end, quality has become a fundamental principle, an imperative and a real
strategic tool. In the field of mobile telephony, customer satisfaction depends on the access to the
network, the ease of access to the service, the reliability of the service, the durability of the
service (Sutherland, 2007) but also on the pricing applied by the operator and the behavior of the
staff in contact and the reception it reserves for users...
4G is the fourth generation of mobile telephony technologies. The 4G network is the advanced
generation of 3G (third generation). It is a technology that brings together a set of performance
criteria such as: technology compliance, data transfer rate, capacity, architecture IP (Internet
Protocol) and speed…etc. In this context, the quality of services has become a variable of
differentiation and an essential component of the offer aimed at customer satisfaction and
loyalty.
Ooredoo is the first telephone operator to have launched 4G services in 2016 in Algeria, and
Tizi-Ouzou is one of the three wilayas chosen by the operator for this launch. That is why we
have chosen to conduct this exploratory study with Ooredoo customers in this wilaya. The
objective is to show to what extent the quality of service influences customer satisfaction and
loyalty in the field of mobile telephony,by looking for the link between these variables.
To do this, we have articulated our article in four points. First, we recall the concepts of service
quality and the models that have proposed its measurement, we present an overview of the
literature dealing with the relationship that links the concepts of service quality and customer
satisfaction, then the one that links consumer satisfaction and loyalty. Secondly, we present the
methodology used. The results of our research are presented in the third part. Finally, the interest
of the results of this work and its limits are highlighted in the conclusion of this article.
- 43 -
Baruche (1992, p. 86) states that quality of the service is: “the provision, the
accompaniment, the advice, the after-sales service associated with the main service, in a
way the human dimension which is at every moment of serviceˮ.
To measure the concept of service quality, some authors have proposed models
based on different dimensions.
The Gronroos model
Presented mainly by Gronroos (1984), he analyzed the factors determining the quality of
service, and identified two service quality dimensions, the technical and the functional aspect.
The technical aspect: this is the core of the service offered to customers and the expected
result of the service delivery process (“what” service is provided).
The functional aspect: it relates to the service delivery process, to the way the service
experience takes place (“how” the service is provided).
The SERVPERF model
The word originates from two concepts: service and performance. It was formulated by
Cronin.J and Taylor.S (1992), who propose a measurement scale based on performance, and
demonstrate that service quality is an antecedent of customer satisfaction.
The SERVPERF model assesses the quality of services based on the perceived
performance of the services provided without taking into account consumer expectations.
The SERVQUAL model
Researchers Parasuraman, Zeithman and Berry (1988) developed a service quality
measurement scale composed of several criteria called determinants of perceived quality,
namely:
– Tangibility: physical facilities, equipment and appearance of personnel.
– Reliability: or the ability to perform the services promised in a safe and precise manner.
- 44 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
prior expectations and a consumption experienceˮ. Kotler and Armstrong (2018), on their part
view that customer satisfaction indicates how the services provided meet or surpass customer
expectations.
The research of Czepiel, Rosenberg and Akerele (1974), proposed that satisfaction with
an organization is cumulative, that is an attitude that is composed of a feeling of satisfaction
withregards to several components, such as the staff or the products/services offered by the
company. Thus, from the perspective of services, it is interesting to assess satisfaction with the
different dimensions of the service, in order to know precisely what is working or what is not
(Tremblay, 2006).
IV. Quality of service and customer satisfaction:
The quality of services is the factor that comes to mind immediately when we talk about
customer satisfaction.
A customer can only be satisfied if the services are of high quality. Quality and
satisfaction are thus fairly close concepts, quality is a characteristic of the product or service, it is
cognitive; Satisfaction is part of the state of the person, in this case the customer, it is affective
and emotional. Moreover, quality has no effect on the customer and can only lead to his
satisfaction through two mechanisms, the perception of this quality and the comparison with his
own expectations.
Perceived service quality and overall satisfaction are two concepts that have been the
subject of numerous studies in service marketing. From a global or relational perspective,
satisfaction corresponds to a global judgment resulting from an accumulation of experiences
over time (Anderson, Fornell and Lehmann, 1994; Ngobo, 1997; Garbarino and Johnson, 1999;
Jamal and Naser, 2002; Vanhamme, 2002; Montoya-Weiss et al., 2003, cited by Seck, 2009).
Besides, to measure it, different methods can be used by the company. The complaint is
one of the indirect methods that allows the customer to express his dissatisfaction with the
service provided by the company. We integrate this variable in the framework of our study, in
order to measure the dissatisfaction of the people questioned.
Sureshchandar et al. (2002) point out that customer satisfaction and service quality are
two different but strongly correlated concepts. Cronin and Taylor (1992) find that service quality
is an antecedent of satisfaction.
In addition, many studies have shown the existence of a causal relationship between these
two constructs. Indeed, according to Carman (1990), Fornell (1992), perceived quality precedes
consumer satisfaction.
The quality of customer service determines the degree of customer satisfaction
(Ramachandran and Chidambaram, 2012). The results of the study carried out by Sivadas and
Baker-Prewitt (2000) confirm that service quality and customer satisfaction are two related
constructs. As well as Keaveney and Parthasarathy, 2001; Lim et al., 2006; Shin and Kim, 2008)
pointed out that service quality is closely linked to consumer satisfaction.
Various studies on mobile services have confirmed the relationship between service
quality and customer satisfaction (Wang and Lo, 2002; Kim et al., 2004; Turel and Serenko,
2006; Wang and Liao, 2007; Shin and Kim, 2008; Kuo et al., 2009; Lai et al., 2009). The
company must take customer complaints into account, as it is a valuable source of free
information that allows the malfunction to be identified.
A complaint is a: "request for information, rectification and/or compensation, from the
client and intended for the organization, following a dissatisfaction involving the responsibility
of the organization" Prim Allaz and Sabadie (2003, cited by Boyer and Nefzi, 2008).
In this sense, the complaint is an attempt by the customer to leave the company. In this
way, he tries to express his dissatisfaction but he gives the company a chance to retain him.
- 45 -
V. Customer satisfaction and loyalty:
- 46 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
VI. Methodology:
Our study aims, in particular, to analyze the levels of consumer satisfaction as well as
their loyalty to their operator and the services they offer.
The choice of the sample fell on the non-probabilistic method. This is a technique which
consists in administering a questionnaire without taking into account a list drawn up in advance
comprising individuals belonging to the population to be studied 2003, cited by Rachidi, 2009).
Given the objectives of our research and the type of information to be collected, we have
chosen to carry out a survey by means of a self-administered questionnaire.
The choice of our approach is exploratory, taking into account the few studies carried out
in the field and the inaccessibility of databases relating to the characteristics of the customers of
this Algerian telephone operator, to better explore the phenomenon to be studied.
Our sample is made up of 100 respondents, Ooredoo company customers, who are
located in the Tizi-Ouzou region. The users of 4G services are aged between 18 and 62 and they
belong to different socio-economic categories. We have therefore chosen people who are able to
provide us with relevant advice.
VII. Results and discussion:
The sample questioned is mainly composed of individuals aged 18 to 27 (69%). Thus,
71% of respondents are women and 29% of them are men.
Regarding the profession of the respondents, the results of our survey indicate that the
majority of 4G consumers of "Ooredoo" are students with a frequency of 47%.
More than half of respondents use 4G outside their homes (57% in transport, 39% at
university). And 78% take the one-month package.
Assessment of the quality level of 4G:
We mainly taken three dimensions of quality which seem relevant to us in our field of
application and in the Algerian context, namely; the quality of the connection during watching
videos and downloads, the quality of the network during telephone calls but also customer
contact employee behavior. These dimensions seem to us to be those to which the people
questioned would be most sensitive.
For this, the respondents were asked to rate the “overall service quality” and their
satisfaction using a 5-point semantic differential scale. Scores could range from “very poor” to
“excellent”. For internet shutdown, it was measured using 4-point. Scores could range from
“never” to “always”.
Figure 1: Evaluation of Ooredoo's 4G connection quality when watching
movies and videos
- 48 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
Figure 4 shows that only 41% of customers are satisfied with the quality of telephone calls
madeby using 4G services, 20% of them are dissatisfied and 7% are even very dissatisfied.
Figure 5 above shows that 58% of customers are satisfied with the quality of the connection
while browsing social networks, 25% are neutral, 13% are dissatisfied and 2% very dissatisfied.
These results show the failures of Ooredoo's 4G services in terms of the reliability of the Internet
network.
The results of figures 4 and 5 make it possible to release the following observation: the
dimension of performance (Cronin and Taylor, 1992) and reliability (Parasuraman, Zeithman and
Berry, 1988) which are determinants of the quality of service are still lacking in the operator
Ooredoo.
- 49 -
Use of the claims department:
When the customer is not satisfied, it may mean that the service provided by the operator is
not efficient and does not meet his expectations. This dissatisfaction may result in the formulation
of a complaint.
Figure No. 6. Use of the Ooredoo claims department
According to this graphic representation, we notice that 60% of 4G service consumers use the
claims department to provide answers to their questions and try to solve the problems they
encounter.
45% of the customers formulate their complaints by calling the company, while 20% of them
prefer to go to the branch level and 3% use the operator's website.
These results show that despite the technological development of information and communication,
the operator's website is far from being a tool which makes it possible to give more dynamics and
interactivity in the relationship between a customer and one company (Dabholkar et al., 2000).
The results in the figure below make it possible to assess the degree of loyalty of the respondents.
Figure 7. Results inherent in the intention of users to change operator
- 50 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
It would therefore be interesting for the operator Ooredoo to devote more efforts to listening to
its customers using 4G services and taking their arguments into consideration, in order to reduce
the attrition rate.
To measure the level of loyalty of respondents, we asked them to express their intention to
change operator. To do this, we used the chi-square test. It allows us to verify the hypothesis of
independence of the variables. We will use it in the context of our study to check whether there
is a significant link between two nominal qualitative variables.
Table 1: changing operator and Poor Mobile Network Coverage
Chi-Square tests
Asymp. Sg (2-
Value df sided)
a
Pearson Chi-square 49,846 1 ,000
b
Continuity correction 46,062 1 ,000
Likelihood Ratio 54,015 1 ,000
Linear-by-linear association 49,347 1 ,000
N of valide cases 100
Source: Survey results after treatment with SPSS.
The table above shows that there is a significant relationship between the two variables, namely
the intention to change operator and poor coverage (internet network). Indeed, the chi-square test
shows a degree of significance of 0.000. Thus, the value of cramer which is 0.706 indicates that
the relationship between poor coverage (internet) and the intention of respondents to change
operator is strong.
Chi-Square tests
Asymp. Sg (2-
Value df sided)
Pearson Chi-square 42,428a 1 ,000
b
Continuity correction 38,943 1 ,000
Likelihood Ratio 42,960 1 ,000
Linear-by-linear association 42,004 1 ,000
N of valide cases 100
Source: Survey results after treatment with SPSS.
Table 2 shows that the intention to change operator is significantly correlate⁹d with the pricing
applied by Ooredoo. Indeed, there is a significant association between these two variables
because the value p=0.000 is less than 0.005. As for the value of cramer which amounts to 0.651,
it indicates that the association between these two variables is more than average.
We find that the dissatisfaction of respondents with poor coverage or unsuitable pricing
encourages them to switch to other operators. It is therefore important to review the pricing in
order to retain the customer.
These results corroborate those of Décaudin and Lacoste (2000, cited by Ben Arous, 2015).
These authors observe that dissatisfaction due to a bad shopping experience or inadequate
service that does not meet customer expectations could affect the loyalty rate expected by the
company.
- 51 -
Thus, it seems important to us that the operator offers special offers, especially for students, with
good speed and reduced rates. There is no relationship between raising complaints and customer
retention. Indeed, the chi-square test displays a value of 0.327. These results are interesting
insofar as the formulation of complaints does not necessarily lead to the loss of customers, on the
contrary, it is a judicious way for the company to listen to the customer and to treat him with
benevolence, courtesy and respect.
The latter being one of the dimensions of trust which is an antecedent of the long-term
consumer-business relationship. At the managerial level, the company could transmit strong
signals to consumers concerning benevolence, in particular by offering truly innovative
commercial offers (Gurviez and Korchia, 2020).
VII. Conclusion
This exploratory study shows that it is imperative for the telephone company to
understand and identify the factors likely to impact the level of satisfaction of its customers with
regard to the use of 4G services.
The results of our survey highlight the fact that perceptions relating to the quality of 4G
service offered by the operator Ooredoo, measured in particular by the quality of the connection
and communication during telephone calls as well as the reception that the staff in contact gives
to the customer. These dimensions are fundamental factors in the creation of a lasting
relationship between the operator and its customers.
Our contribution can be interesting by helping Ooredoo’s managers to offer a better offer
to customers to satisfy them and build loyalty, especially in a context where differentiation is
essential to face competition.
As a result, Ooredoo should improve the determinants of the quality of its services in
order to achieve a higher level of customer satisfaction, while taking into account their
suggestions and complaints. Indeed, a higher level of service quality will generally lead to higher
satisfaction, which results in customer loyalty, considered as a source of profit for the company.
Thus, our study raises certain problems, particularly those relating to poor coverage and
sometimes to poor quality of telephone calls, which should be seriously resolved in order to meet
user expectations. This would allow the operator to retain its customers and not expose them to
the temptation of competitors' offers.
However, our study has a major limitation, namely the small sample size. It is desirable
to extend this type of study to a larger sample in order to achieve more convincing results on the
link between service quality and customer satisfaction or even customer loyalty.
- 52 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
References
1. Baruche, J.P. (1992). la qualité de service dans les entreprises. Paris : édition
d’organisation.
2. Ben Arous, O (2015). La gestion de la qualité du service client. Mémoire. Trois-Rivières,
Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières.
3. Carman J. M. (1990), Consumer perceptions of service quality: an assessment of
SERVQUAL dimensions, Journal of Retailing,33 - 55.
4. Chatelet, J-M. (1996). méthodes productiques et qualité. Paris : Ellipses.
5. Cronin Jr, J. J., & Taylor, S. A. (1992). Measuring service quality: a reexamination and
extension. Journal of marketing, 56(3), 55-68.
6. Cronin, J.J., et Taylor, S.A. (1992). Measuring service quality: a reexamination and
extension. Journal of Marketing. 56:3.55-68.
7. Czepiel, 1. A, L. Rosenberg. et A Akerele. (1975). Perspectives on Consumer
Satisfaction: Proceedings of the 1974 National Conference, American Marketing
Association Chicago: American Marketing Association, 1975: pp. 119-123. Reprinted in
Japan in YTV Report, no. 98 (May 1975): p. 64-69.
8. Dabholkar, P. A., Shepherd, C. D., & Thorpe, D. I. (2000). A Comprehensive Framework
for Service Quality: An Investigation of Critical Conceptual and Measurement Issues
through a Longitudinal Study. Journal of Retailing, 76, 139-173.
9. Eiglier, P., et Langeard, E. (1987). Servuction - le marketing des services. Ediscience.
10. Fornell C. (1992), A National Customer Satisfaction Barometer: the Swedish experience,
Journal of Marketing, vol. 56, 6-21.
11. Gemme, M. (2004). Etude sur la satisfaction de la clientèle : le cas d'une pme de service
Québécoise. Mémoire présenté à l'université du Québec à Trois-Rivières.
12. Grönroos., C. (1984), "A Service Quality Model and Its Marketing Implications,"
European Journal of Marketing, 18 (4), 36-44.
13. Gurviez., P, Korchia M. (2002). Proposition d’une échelle de mesure
multidimensionnelle de la confiance dans la marque. Recherches et Application en
Marketing, Vol. 17, n° 3, pp. 41-61
14. Hoq, M.Z. and Amin, M. (2009), “The role of customer satisfaction to enhance customer
loyalty”. African Journal of Business Management, 2(4), 139-154.
15. Horovitz, J. (1987). la qualité de service à la conquête du client. Pais : interédition.
16. Kaura, V. (2013), “Antecedents of customer satisfaction: a study of Indian public and
private sector banks”. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 31(3), 167-186.
17. Keaveney, S. &Parthasarathy, M. (2001). Predicting customer switching behavior in
online services: an exploratory study of selected characteristics of continuersvs switchers.
Journal of the Academiy of 29(4), 374-390.
18. Kim, M. K., Park, M. C., &Jeong, D. H. (2004). The effects of customer satisfaction and
switching barrier on customer loyalty in Korean mobile telecommunication
[Link] policy, 28(2), 145-159.
19. Kotler, P. and Armstrong, G. (2018), Principles of Marketing, 17th edn., Pearson
Education Limited.
20. Kotler P., et Dubois, B. (2000). « marketing management », Paris : édition, Publi-Union.
21. Kuo, Y.F., Wu,C.M., & Deng, W.J. (2009). The relationships among service quality,
perceived value, customer satisfaction, and post-purchase intention in mobile value-
added services. Computers in human behavior, 25(4), 887-896.
- 53 -
22. Lai, F., Griffin, M., & Babin, B.J. (2009). How quality, value, image, and satisfaction
create loyalty at a Chinese telecom. Journal of Business Research, 62(10), 980-986.
23. Lam, S.Y., Shankar, V., Erramilli, K. &Murthy, B. (2004), “Customer value, satisfaction,
loyalty, and switching costs: an illustration from a business-to-business service context”.
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 32(3), 293-311.
24. Lam, S.Y., Shankar, V., Erramilli, K. &Turel, O., &Serenko, A. (2006). Satisfaction with
mobile services in Canada: an empirical investigation. Telecommunications Policy, 30(5-
6), 314-331.
25. Laurent Hermel et Gérard Louyat, « la qualité de service », édition Saint-Denis, 2005,
p.82.
26. Lendrevie, J., Levy, J., et Lindon, D. (2009) « Mercator, théorie et nouvelles pratiques
du marketing » 9 édition, Edition dalloz, Paris 2009, p859
27. Lendrevie,J., Lévy, J., et Lindon, D. (2005).Mercator, théorie et pratique de marketing.
Paris : édition Dalloz.
28. Lim, H., Widdows, R., & Park, J. (2006). M-loyalty: winning strategies for mobile
[Link] of consumer Marketing, [Link] of consumer Marketing, 23(4),
208-218.
29. Loudoyer., G. (2000). la satisfaction ISO 9000, un moteur pour la qualité. Paris: édition
d’organisation.
- 54 -
The impact of service quality on customer satisfaction and loyalty: the results of an exploratory study with
41. Shin, D.H., & Kim, W.Y. (2008). Forecasting customer switching intention in mobile
service: An exploratory study of predictive factors in mobile number
[Link] Forecasting and Social Technological Forecasting and Social
Change,75(6), 854-874.
42. Sivadas, E., Baker-Prewitt, J.L. (2000). An Examination of the Relationshipbetween
Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction, and Store Loyalty. Journalof Retail &
Distribution Management, 28(2), 73-82.
43. Sureshchandar, G.S., Rajendran, C. and Anantharaman, R.N. (2002), "The relationship
between service quality and customer satisfaction – a factor specific approach", Journal
of Services Marketing, Vol. 16 No. 4, pp. 363-
379. [Link]
44. Sutherland, E. (2007). The regulation of the quality of service in mobile networks. Info,
9(6), 17-34.
45. Tremblay P. (2006), «Mesurer la satisfaction et les attentes des clients: Des modèles
classiques aux modèles asymétriques». Centre d'expertise des grandsorganismes,
septembre 2006.
46. Wang, Y., & Lo, H.P. (2002). Service quality, customer satisfaction and behavior
intentions: Evidence from China's telecommunication [Link], 4(6), 50-60.
47. Wang,Y. S., & Liao, Y. W. (2007). The conceptualization and measurement of m-
commerce user satisfaction. Computers in human behavior, 23(1), 381-398.
- 55 -