Comprehensive Spectroscopic and
Electrodynamic Analysis of the Planck
Constant via Semiconductor
Electroluminescence
The quantification of energy represents the foundational pillar of modern physics, marking the
transition from the deterministic framework of classical mechanics to the probabilistic and
discrete reality of quantum theory. At the center of this transition is the Planck constant, h, a
universal scaling factor that determines the relationship between the frequency of
electromagnetic radiation and its constituent energy. The experimental determination of this
constant is a cornerstone of physics education and research, with the light-emitting diode (LED)
method offering a particularly elegant synthesis of solid-state physics and quantum
electrodynamics. By analyzing the electrical and optical characteristics of various semiconductor
junctions, it is possible to derive h with significant precision, while simultaneously exploring the
complex interplay between electron-hole recombination and photon emission.
The Quantum Revolution and the Blackbody Conflict
The historical genesis of the Planck constant is inextricably linked to the crisis in classical
physics known as the ultraviolet catastrophe. Throughout the late 19th century, physicists
attempted to describe the spectral distribution of energy emitted by a blackbody—an idealized
physical body that absorbs all incident electromagnetic radiation. Classical models, such as
those proposed by Lord Rayleigh and James Jeans, were based on the principle of equipartition
of energy, which predicted that the intensity of radiation would increase without limit as the
wavelength decreased toward the ultraviolet spectrum. This divergence not only contradicted
experimental observations, which showed an energy peak followed by a rapid decay at high
frequencies, but also implied an infinite energy output from any object in thermal equilibrium.
In October 1900, the German physicist Max Planck proposed a revolutionary mathematical
solution to this problem. By synthesizing the Wien displacement law, which held true for high
frequencies, and the Rayleigh-Jeans law, which was accurate for low frequencies, Planck
derived a new radiation law that matched experimental data across the entire spectrum. To
justify his formula, Planck was forced to abandon the classical assumption that energy is a
continuous variable. Instead, he hypothesized that the electromagnetic oscillators within the
blackbody cavity could only exchange energy in discrete "packets" or quanta. He formulated the
energy of these quanta as being proportional to the frequency of the radiation, introducing h as
the proportionality constant:
This postulate, which Planck initially regarded as a "purely formal assumption" or an "act of
desperation," fundamentally altered the course of science. It established that the universe is
granular at its most fundamental level. The significance of this discovery was recognized with
the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1918, as it laid the groundwork for the development of quantum
mechanics, influencing the subsequent work of Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr, and Werner
Heisenberg.
The Physical Nature and Significance of Light
Understanding the experiment for determining h requires a comprehensive grasp of the dual
nature of light. Throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, the wave theory of light, supported by
Thomas Young’s interference experiments and Augustin-Jean Fresnel’s studies on diffraction,
was the dominant paradigm. These phenomena demonstrated that light behaves as a
transverse electromagnetic wave, characterized by frequency (\nu), wavelength (\lambda), and
the speed of light in a vacuum (c), related by the expression:
However, the wave theory failed to account for the absorption and emission of light at the atomic
scale. The photoelectric effect, observed by Heinrich Hertz and later explained by Albert
Einstein in 1905, provided the necessary evidence for the particle aspect of light. Einstein
proposed that light consists of discrete particles, or photons, each carrying a specific amount of
energy defined by Planck’s relation. This wave-particle duality is essential to the operation of an
LED, where the movement of charge carriers (particles) results in the emission of
electromagnetic radiation (waves).
The intensity of light in these experiments often follows the inverse square law, which states that
the intensity of illumination is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the
source. This relationship is critical when using a phototube or a vacuum photo-sensitive device
to verify the quantum nature of light, as the number of emitted photoelectrons is strictly
proportional to the intensity of radiation, while their kinetic energy depends solely on frequency.
Property Description Mathematical Expression
Photon Energy Energy carried by a single E = h\nu
quantum of light
Wave Relation Connection between speed, c = \nu\lambda
frequency, and wavelength
Momentum Linear momentum of a photon p = h/\lambda
Inverse Square Law Relationship between intensity I \propto 1/r^2
(I) and distance (r)
Theoretical Dimensions of the Planck Constant
The Planck constant is not merely a number but the "quantum of action," representing the
smallest possible change in the physical state of a system. Its dimensions are the product of
energy and time (Joule-seconds), which is the same as the dimensions of angular momentum.
In the International System of Units (SI), h is defined as exactly 6.62607015 \times 10^{-34}
\text{ J}\cdot\text{s}.
A modified version, the reduced Planck constant (\hbar = h/2\pi), appears in equations
governing the quantization of angular momentum in atomic orbits and the Heisenberg
Uncertainty Principle. The constant h defines the scale of the universe; if its value were
significantly different, the stability of atoms, the behavior of stellar evolution, and the chemistry
of life would be fundamentally altered. In modern metrology, h has taken on even greater
importance, as it is now used to define the unit of mass (the kilogram) through the Kibble
balance, replacing the physical artifact previously held in France.
Semiconductor Physics and the P-N Junction
To utilize an LED for measuring h, one must understand the electronic structure of
semiconductors. In a solid-state crystal, the allowed energy states for electrons form bands. The
valence band is the highest range of electron energies in which electrons are normally present
at absolute zero temperature, while the conduction band is the range of electron energies high
enough to allow electrons to move freely through the material.
Between these two bands is the bandgap energy (E_g), a region where no electron states can
exist. In insulators, the bandgap is large, making conduction impossible under normal
conditions. In conductors, the bands overlap. Semiconductors, however, have a narrow
bandgap that can be bridged by thermal excitation or applied electrical potential.
The P-N Junction Dynamics
An LED is a specialized form of a p-n junction diode. By doping a semiconductor with impurities,
researchers create p-type regions (excess holes) and n-type regions (excess electrons). When
these regions are brought into contact, a depletion region forms at the interface, creating a
potential barrier that prevents further movement of charge.
When a forward bias voltage (V) is applied, the potential barrier is reduced. Once the voltage
reaches the "threshold" or "turn-on" voltage (V_0), electrons gain sufficient energy to cross the
junction and recombine with holes. This process of recombination results in the emission of
energy. In silicon or germanium, which are indirect bandgap materials, this energy is dissipated
as heat (phonons). However, in direct bandgap semiconductors like Gallium Arsenide (GaAs) or
Gallium Nitride (GaN), the energy is released as photons.
Electroluminescence Mechanism
The energy of the emitted photon (E_{ph}) in a direct bandgap semiconductor is approximately
equal to the bandgap energy (E_g) of the material. Since the electrical energy provided to an
electron to cross the junction is given by the product of the electronic charge (e) and the
threshold voltage (V_0), we can establish a fundamental equality:
This equation is the primary tool used in the laboratory to determine h. By measuring the
threshold voltage for various LEDs of known wavelengths, we can correlate electrical energy
with optical energy.
Materials Science of Light Emitting Diodes
The color of an LED is determined entirely by the chemical composition of the semiconductor
crystal, which dictates the width of the bandgap. Modern LEDs use III-V compound
semiconductors, combining elements from group III (Al, Ga, In) and group V (N, P, As) of the
periodic table.
Composition and Spectral Range
By adjusting the ratios of these elements, engineers can tune the bandgap to produce specific
wavelengths. For instance, Aluminum Gallium Arsenide (AlGaAs) is commonly used for red and
infrared LEDs, while Indium Gallium Nitride (InGaN) is the standard for high-brightness blue and
green LEDs.
Color Wavelength Range Semiconductor Typical V_0 (V)
(nm) Composition
Infrared > 760 GaAs, AlGaAs 1.2 - 1.6
Red 610 - 760 AlGaAs, GaAsP, 1.6 - 2.0
AlGaInP
Orange 590 - 610 GaAsP, AlGaInP, GaP 2.0 - 2.1
Yellow 570 - 590 GaAsP, AlGaInP, GaP 2.1 - 2.2
Green 500 - 570 InGaN, GaP, AlGaP 2.2 - 3.0
Blue 450 - 500 InGaN, ZnSe, SiC 3.0 - 3.5
Violet 400 - 450 InGaN 3.5 - 4.0
Ultraviolet < 400 AlGaN, AlGaInN > 3.1
The "White" LED presents a unique case in this context. Most white LEDs are not a
single-junction device but are composed of a blue InGaN chip coated with a yellow phosphor
(usually Yttrium Aluminum Garnet or YAG). The blue light from the chip excites the phosphor,
which re-emits yellow light; the combination of blue and yellow appears white to the human eye.
Because this involves a process of "down-conversion" rather than direct band-to-band
recombination for the entire spectrum, white LEDs are generally avoided in high-precision
Planck constant measurements.
Experimental Architecture and Setup
The objective of the experiment is to measure the threshold voltage for a series of LEDs and
relate them to their emission wavelengths. This requires a precise electrical circuit and optical
measurement tools.
Necessary Apparatus
The standard apparatus for this experiment includes a regulated variable DC power supply
(0-10V), a series of LEDs of different colors (typically red, yellow, green, and blue), a
current-limiting resistor (usually 1 \text{ k}\Omega), a digital voltmeter, and a digital ammeter or
nanoammeter. For more advanced setups, an optical bench, a diffraction grating, and a viewing
tube are included to measure the wavelength directly.
Circuit Configuration
The LED is connected in forward bias. The ammeter is placed in series with the LED to monitor
the current (I), and the voltmeter is placed in parallel specifically across the LED to measure the
potential drop (V) only across the semiconductor junction, excluding the voltage drop across the
current-limiting resistor. High-precision experiments use a nanoammeter to detect the very first
onset of current, as the visual detection of light is subjective and often occurs at a slightly higher
voltage than the actual electrical threshold.
Methodological Procedures for Measurement
There are two primary methods for determining the threshold voltage V_0: the visual detection
method and the I-V characteristic analysis.
Visual Detection Method
In this approach, the voltage is slowly increased until the LED just begins to emit light. A viewing
tube or dark box is often used to increase the sensitivity of the observer. This voltage is
recorded as V_0. While simple, this method is prone to random error due to variations in human
vision and ambient light. To improve reliability, multiple observers may take readings and
calculate an average, or the experiment can be performed in a completely darkened room.
I-V Characteristic Analysis
A more rigorous method involves plotting the current-voltage (I-V) curve for each LED. As the
voltage is increased, the current remains near zero until the potential reaches the neighborhood
of the bandgap energy. Beyond this point, the current increases exponentially, and then linearly.
By drawing a tangent to the linear region of the I-V curve and extrapolating it back to the x-axis
(I=0), the "knee voltage" or "activation voltage" (V_a) is determined. This value is used as V_0
in the Planck relation. This method is preferred in professional research as it relies on objective
data points rather than subjective visual cues.
Measuring the Peak Wavelength
While many student labs use the wavelength provided by the manufacturer, an expert-level
report requires empirical verification. A diffraction grating is placed at a known distance (y) from
the LED. The observer looks through the grating and locates the first-order diffraction image at a
distance (x) from the central axis. The angle \theta is calculated as \arctan(x/y). Using the
grating spacing d (where d = 1/N, and N is the number of lines per mm), the wavelength is
calculated as \lambda = d \sin \theta. This accounts for the fact that LEDs are not perfectly
monochromatic and have a spectral width of 20-40 nm.
Mathematical Modeling and Data Analysis
The data analysis phase transforms the raw electrical and optical measurements into a value for
the Planck constant. The relationship eV_0 = hc/\lambda can be rearranged into the form of a
linear equation, y = mx + c:
Linear Regression and the Slope Method
By plotting the threshold voltage (V_0) on the vertical axis and the reciprocal of the wavelength
(1/\lambda) on the horizontal axis, a straight line should emerge. The slope (m) of this line
represents the physical quantity hc/e.
This graphical method is superior to calculating h for individual LEDs because it allows for the
identification and isolation of systematic errors. For example, if there is a constant voltage offset
due to contact potential at the probes, it will appear as a non-zero y-intercept rather than
affecting the slope of the line.
LED Color \lambda (nm) 1/\lambda (10^6 \text{ V_0 (V)
m}^{-1})
Blue 465 2.15 2.70
Green 525 1.90 2.45
Yellow 590 1.69 2.18
Red 635 1.57 2.02
A successful linear fit of this data typically yields a value for h that is within 1% to 5% of the
accepted standard.
Error Analysis and Precision Discussion
A critical aspect of professional reporting is the evaluation of experimental uncertainty. The LED
method, while effective, contains several inherent sources of error that must be mitigated or
discussed.
Systematic Electrical Errors
One significant source of error is the internal resistance of the LED and the presence of contact
resistance in the circuit. If the current is significant when V_0 is measured, an additional voltage
drop (V = IR) will be included in the reading, leading to an overestimation of the bandgap energy
and, consequently, an overestimation of the Planck constant. High-quality experiments use
four-point probe techniques or very low-current detection to minimize this effect.
Thermal Effects on Bandgap
The bandgap of a semiconductor is not a fixed value; it is dependent on temperature. As
temperature increases, the atomic vibrations in the crystal lattice increase, leading to a
decrease in the bandgap energy. If the LED is left on for extended periods, it may heat up,
causing the threshold voltage to drift lower. In rigorous settings, LEDs may be pulsed or cooled
to maintain a constant temperature, or the temperature dependence may be measured and
corrected for in the final calculation.
Spectral Width and Monochromaticity
As noted, LEDs do not emit a single wavelength but a distribution. The energy E = hc/\lambda is
most accurately applied to the peak wavelength, but the threshold voltage might correspond to
the lowest energy (longest wavelength) at which recombination can occur. This mismatch can
result in systematic shifts in the calculated value of h.
Subjectivity in Visual Thresholds
In the visual method, the "turn-on" point is determined by the observer’s eye. Human eyes have
varying sensitivities to different colors; for instance, the eye is much more sensitive to green
light than to red or blue. This can lead to a situation where the green LED appears to turn on at
a lower relative energy than the blue or red ones, purely due to biological perception. This is
why the I-V characteristic method is the standard for professional-grade reports.
Comparative Experimental Context
While the LED method is a powerful pedagogical tool, it is one of several ways to measure h.
Understanding its place among other experiments provides a nuanced perspective on quantum
metrology.
LED Method vs. Photoelectric Effect
In the photoelectric effect experiment, light of a known frequency is shone on a metal surface,
and a retarding potential is used to find the maximum kinetic energy of the ejected electrons
(eV_s = h\nu - \phi). The LED experiment is essentially the inverse: an electrical potential is
used to generate photons of a known frequency. The LED method is often easier to set up and
provides data much more quickly, but the photoelectric effect remains the more direct proof of
the quantization of the electromagnetic field itself.
Blackbody Radiation and Wien’s Law
The original method used by Planck involved measuring the spectral radiance of a blackbody at
various temperatures. This requires much more complex equipment, such as a
high-temperature furnace and a spectrophotometer. While historical, this method is rarely used
in student laboratories due to the difficulty of maintaining an ideal blackbody and the complexity
of the Stefan-Boltzmann and Planck radiation laws.
Modern Technological Implications
The precision of the Planck constant has enabled the development of technologies that define
the modern era. The ability to manipulate energy levels in semiconductors has led to the
creation of lasers, fiber-optic communications, and solar panels.
The Redefinition of the Kilogram
In 2019, the General Conference on Weights and Measures (CGPM) officially redefined the
kilogram. Historically, the kilogram was defined by a platinum-iridium cylinder stored in a vault in
Sèvres, France. However, this artifact was found to be losing mass over time. To ensure a
stable definition, the kilogram is now defined using the Planck constant through the Kibble
balance, which relates mechanical power to electrical power measured in terms of the
Josephson and quantum Hall effects—both of which depend on h.
Integrated Circuits and Smartphones
The operation of every transistor in a modern smartphone or computer processor is governed
by the quantum mechanics of semiconductors. The design of these devices requires an exact
knowledge of h to calculate the switching speeds, power consumption, and thermal limits of the
silicon chips. Without the discovery made by Planck in 1900, the digital revolution would never
have occurred.
Synthesis and Conclusion
The experiment to determine the Planck constant using LEDs serves as a profound
demonstration of the unity of physics. It connects the macroscopic world of batteries, resistors,
and voltmeters to the microscopic world of electron-hole pairs and photons. Through the
systematic measurement of threshold voltages across various semiconductor compositions, the
experiment confirms the fundamental relation E = h\nu, which defines the very graininess of our
universe.
The accuracy of the results depends heavily on the methodology employed. While visual
detection provides a quick approximation, the analysis of I-V characteristics and the empirical
measurement of wavelengths through diffraction gratings represent the professional standard.
By acknowledging and analyzing the systematic errors inherent in semiconductor
junctions—such as internal resistance, thermal shifts, and spectral width—one gains a deeper
appreciation for the precision of the modern quantum framework.
Ultimately, h is more than just a constant in a textbook; it is the fundamental "quantum of action"
that makes the existence of stable matter and the development of advanced technology
possible. The LED experiment provides a direct path for researchers to interact with this
absolute limit of nature, proving that even a simple light bulb is a gateway to the most complex
laws of physics. The transition from Planck's "act of desperation" in 1900 to the highly efficient
LEDs of today represents one of the most successful chapters in human intellectual history,
demonstrating our ability to decode the fundamental constants that govern the cosmos.
Works cited
1. Planck's constant | Definition, Units, Symbol, & Facts - Britannica,
[Link] 2. Planck's law - Wikipedia,
[Link] 3. Energy in packets – What did Planck discover?,
[Link] 4. It's October 1900. Max Planck
thinks he's found the function that will solve the blackbody radiation problem that's been vexing
physicists in recent years. How on earth does he plot it to know that it looks right? :
r/AskHistorians - Reddit,
[Link]
_hes_found_the/ 5. Max Planck – Facts - [Link],
[Link] 6. Planck constant - Wikipedia,
[Link] 7. Planck's Constant: What is it and Why Does it
Matter? - Edulab, [Link] 8.
Experiment No. 14 Planck's constant (Photo Electric Effect),
[Link]
Photo_Electric_Effect.pdf 9. Light-emitting diode physics - Wikipedia,
[Link] 10. Light Emitting Diodes -
Engineering LibreTexts,
[Link]
ience)/Semiconductors/Light_Emitting_Diodes 11. The Planck Constant | NIST - National
Institute of Standards and Technology, [Link]
12. Effect of Various Factors on the Accuracy of Determining the Planck Constant in a Student
Physics Laboratory - MDPI, [Link] 13. 64.56 -- Light-emitting
diode (LED) - UCSB Physics,
[Link] 14. 5:
Measurement of Planck's Constant (Experiment) - Chemistry LibreTexts,
[Link]
_Chemistry_for_Majors_I/Chem_4A%3A_Laboratory_Manual/08_5%3A_Measurement_of_Plan
ck's_Constant_(Experiment) 15. Light Emitting Diode <img src='[Link]'> - TU Graz,
[Link] 16. The determination of the Planck's constant
using an experimental approach with arduino, [Link] 17.
Determination of Planck's Constant (Theory) : Modern Physics Virtual Lab,
[Link] 18. PLANCK'S CONSTANT
EXPERIMENT, [Link]
19. DETERMINATION OF PLANCK'S CONSTANT USING LEDS,
[Link]
Files/Plancks%20Constant%[Link] 20. Determine Planck's Constant with LEDs | PDF |
Light Emitting Diode | Photon - Scribd,
[Link] 21. What are the names of the
materials used to make different colour LEDs (i.e. red, green, yellow, infra, etc.)? - Quora,
[Link]
s-i-e-red-green-yellow-infra-etc 22. What factors does LED chip colour depend on - Ledestar
SMD LED, [Link] 23.
light-emitting diode (led) - Physics Club,
[Link] 24. Defining the Color Characteristics
of White LEDs | DigiKey,
[Link] 25. Plank
Constant with leds. A good experiment to get the plank… | by Carlos Alvarez Rosales | Medium,
[Link] 26. Lab Report
Planck's Constant | PDF | Photon | Electromagnetic Radiation - Scribd,
[Link] 27. PLANKS
CONSTANT Experiment | PDF | Light Emitting Diode - Scribd,
[Link] 28. Experiment
| Mrs Physics,
[Link]
df 29. 88.10 -- Planck's constant demonstration - UCSB Physics,
[Link] 30.
Classroom fundamentals: measuring the Planck constant - Science in School,
[Link] 31. Classroom
fundamentals: measuring the Planck constant – [Link],
[Link] 32. Lab Manual - Plancks Constant | PDF | Light
Emitting Diode - Scribd,
[Link] 33. Measuring
Planck's Constant Using Light Emitting Diodes - TSI Journals,
[Link]
[Link] 34. Determine Fundamental Constants With LEDs And A Multimeter - Hackaday,
[Link]