Influence of A Nonuniform Coupling Coefficient On The Static and Large Signal Dynamic Behavior of Bragg-Detuned DFB Lasers
Influence of A Nonuniform Coupling Coefficient On The Static and Large Signal Dynamic Behavior of Bragg-Detuned DFB Lasers
Abstract—A time domain model is used to study the large signal structures with multiple discrete phase shifts located along
dynamics of general Bragg-detuned cavities. Such structures, the cavity [8], [9] or phase-adjusted DFB lasers with a step-
in which the grating pitch is spatially nonuniform so that a like nonuniform stripe width structure [10], [11]. Alternatively,
distributed phase shift is produced along the cavity, are often
called corrugation-pitch-modulated distributed feedback lasers DFB lasers with modulation of their grating pitch (CPM–DFB
(CPM–DFB). Furthermore, by introducing a longitudinally de- for corrugation-pitch-modulated) provide a longitudinal Bragg
pendent coupling coefficient , a corrugation-pitch-modulated detuning so that a distributed and more gradual phase shift
distributed-coupling-coefficient DFB laser (CPM-DCC-DFB) with is produced [12]–[14]. The discontinuity in the corrugation of
quite different spectral properties can be realized. We present in QWS–DFB cavities is then smoothed and, consequently, the
this paper a comparison between these two kinds of components.
It is shown that an adequate profile of the coupling coefficient photon density exhibits a less pronounced maximum. Although
(stronger coupling at the center of the cavity) in a CPM-DCC- good results are obtained at threshold, static above-threshold
DFB structure can help to achieve better steady-state singlemode studies revealed that these structures could be subject to modal
operation with respect to conventional CPM-DFB lasers (uniform instabilities.
coupling coefficient). However, in CPM-DCC-DFB lasers, side We propose in this paper a multisection DFB laser with
modes are liable to be excited during the turn-on transient
interval, thus imposing a limitation to the modulation depth longitudinal variation in both its grating pitch and coupling
requirement. coefficient profile (CPM-DCC-DFB for corrugation-pitch-
modulated distributed-coupling-coefficient DFB). Threshold
Index Terms— Coupled mode analysis, distributed feedback
lasers, optical modulation, semiconductor laser, time domain studies performed on a three-section CPM-DCC-DFB cavity
analysis. [14] have shown that this particular grating configuration
help to improve simultaneously the gain margin and the
intracavity field flatness. To date, results about large signal
I. INTRODUCTION dynamics of CPM-DCC-DFB cavities have not been presented
(1)
(2)
In (3) and (4), is the optical confinement factor and is the effective index at transparency and is the
is the differential gain. stands for the carrier phase-amplitude coupling factor.
density defined further while is the carrier density at The longitudinally dependent coupling coefficient en-
transparency. is the photon density and the nonlinear ables distributed-coupling-coefficient structures to be taken
gain coefficient. is an approximate emission wavelength into account. describes the spontaneous emission and
and the effective index. is the longitudinally- is generated from a Gaussian distributed random number
dependent (structural) grating pitch, allowing Bragg-detuned generator that satisfies the correlation
DFB structures to be considered. In the model, a flat mate-
rial gain (with no frequency-dependence) is assumed.
However, the frequency dependence can be taken into account (8)
by using a digital filter [19], [20].
The carrier density is described by its rate equation is the spontaneous coupling factor, the Petermann factor
and the total length of the laser.
All equations involved in the calculation are solved nu-
merically. LSHB is described by discretizing the intrinsic
parameters all along the cavity. All parameters are constant
(5) in a subsection but can vary from subsection to subsection.
The time-domain model is principally developed for studying
is the uniform biasing current density, the electric charge large signal dynamics of various structures but, by allowing
and the thickness of the active layer. is the linear the transient response to settle for a given injection current,
recombination lifetime, the radiative spontaneous emission steady-state characteristics can also be obtained.
coefficient and the Auger recombination coefficient.
The total photon density is the sum of the photon III. NUMERICAL RESULTS
densities of the two traveling wave
The proposed CPM-DCC-DFB structure (Fig. 1) is a sym-
(6) metric three-section laser of total length m, with
no facet reflection. The length, grating pitch and normalized
where the star represents the complex conjugate. coupling coefficient of center section are denoted by ,
The effective index is given by and , respectively while those of side sections are called
and . The CPM-DFB structure is characterized by
a -dependent grating pitch and a uniform coupling coefficient
(7)
. In the CPM-DCC-DFB cavity, both and
FESSANT: DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR OF BRAGG-DETUNED DFB LASERS 421
(9)
(10)
The 120 subsections are used for numerical calculations. The (b)
lasers are biased at transparency and switched to a high current
Fig. 2. Transient response to a heavy-side step, from transparency to twice
density according to a Heaviside step, i.e., the threshold, of the output photon density. (a) Conventional CPM-DFB laser
(uniform coupling) and (b) CPM-DCC-DFB laser (z -dependent ).
with if and if
(a) (a)
(b) (b)
2
Fig. 3. Transient response to a heaviside step, from transparency to 4 2
Fig. 4. Transient response to a heaviside step, from transparency to 8
threshold, of the output photon density. (a) Conventional CPM-DFB laser threshold, of the output photon density. (a) Conventional CPM-DFB laser
(uniform coupling) and (b) CPM-DCC-DFB laser (z -dependent ). (uniform coupling) and (b) CPM-DCC-DFB laser (z -dependent ).
becomes rapidly multimode with increasing modulation depth properties. That is, a higher value of leads to
[Fig. 6(b) and (c)]. So, the spectral stability with respect to the same results as far as the spectral stability is concerned: the
the excitation of a second mode is very poor and would cause Fourier spectra are almost unchanged (excepted that the noise
detrimental pulse-spreading in communication systems. The floor is higher) while the dynamic and steady-state SMSR keep
onset of multiple side modes is believed to be the result of the same values.
modeling a flat material gain (so that the gain is uniformly The same calculations have been repeated for a range of
distributed upon all the modes) but a frequency-dependent biasing currents going from up to in order to
gain with a gain peak located around the main mode would estimate both steady-state and dynamic SMSR (during the
probably reduce the side modes influence [19]. turn-on-transient) versus normalized biasing current. Follow-
The case of the CPM-DCC-DFB cavity is entirely different ing [22], we assume that singlemode operation is ensured if
(Fig. 7). Indeed, the turn-on-transient appears to be multimode the drop between the starting and final values of the SMSR
and all the involved modes broadened, despite the gain margin do not exceed a fixed value (say 40 dB). It is shown in
is large at threshold . However, for the range of Fig. 9 that the steady-state SMSR of the conventional CPM-
operating biasing currents, the main mode remains preponder- DFB structure falls down rapidly with while that of the
ant even at high injection current (SMSR drops from a value of CPM-DCC-DFB cavity is clamped to a high value.
65 dB at to a value of 30 dB at ). On the other side, Better static spectral stability in CPM-DCC-DFB lasers
in the steady-state regime, the laser remains singlemode with with respect to conventional CPM-DFB structures comes from
a good SMSR, whatever the modulation depth (Fig. 8). This several physical phenomena.
time, a transition from a multimode regime to a singlemode 1) First, higher threshold gain margins are achieved in such
one is obtained. structures when , so that the possible onset of
It must be pointed out that a relatively low value of the side modes induced by LSHB is delayed (with respect
spontaneous emission factor has been used in the simulations to increasing bias current).
and higher values can be found in the literature. 2) Second, modulating spatially the coupling coefficient
On the other side, it has been shown that the actual value of induces a nonlasing side mode competition. The modes
(as well as that of the nonlinear gain coefficient) was a source closer to the stop-band do not necessarily have the
of damping in the relaxation oscillations [21]. In this work, lowest net gains and this phenomenon may help to
we have not really focused on the relaxation frequency and enhance the lasing mode contribution in the above-
damping phenomena but rather on the spectral and dynamic threshold regime.
FESSANT: DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR OF BRAGG-DETUNED DFB LASERS 423
(a) (a)
(b)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 5. Fourier transform spectra of time-domain signals for the conventional (c)
CPM-DFB laser. The Hanning window covers the turn-on-transient interval
and the modulation depth is increased from twice the threshold to 8 2 Fig. 6. Steady-state Fourier spectra of time-domain signals for the conven-
threshold. tional CPM-DFB laser. The modulation depth is increased from twice the
2
threshold to 8 threshold.
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 7. Fourier transform spectra of time-domain signals for the
CPM-DCC-DFB laser. The Hanning window covers the turn-on-transient (c)
interval and the modulation depth is increased from twice the threshold
2
to 8 threshold.
Fig. 8. Steady-state Fourier spectra of time-domain signals for the
CPM-DCC-DFB laser. The modulation depth is increased from twice the
2
threshold to 8 threshold.
slightly for the CPM-DCC-DFB laser with biasing current
(Fig. 10). We believe that the onset of side modes at high modulation depth requirement but this limit is high so that
bias currents during the turn-on transient interval in the CPM- a -dependent is a good mean to achieve very good static
DCC-DFB laser may result from the interaction between and dynamic singlemode stability in Bragg-detuned cavities
the gain distribution along the cavity and the spatial profile for the range of usual bias currents.
of the side modes, i.e., these side modes may be favored Another kind of mode instability has been reported in index-
temporarily before the gain is clamped to its steady-state coupled or complex-coupled DFB lasers [23], [24]. Indeed,
value. That is, the CPM-DCC-DFB cavity tolerates rather high depending on the bias current and for particular sets of
bias currents and will become problematic only for very high physical parameters, DFB structures may be subject to mode
ones. The maximum bias current for single mode operation hoppings as the result of spatial hole burning. The lasing mode,
is found to be around . Our criterion of dynamic stable and dominant at a given injection current, may become
singlemode operation is nevertheless kept in the range of unstable at a different bias current and then hops to another
operating currents. laser mode. More spectacular with this modal instability is the
So, in CPM-DCC-DFB structures, the turn-on-transient can possible induced asymmetry in the carrier density and effective
be worrying because side modes are liable to be excited index longitudinal profile of this new mode as well as that of
during this interval. This behavior imposes a limitation to the the output power. Such instabilities have not been predicted in
FESSANT: DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR OF BRAGG-DETUNED DFB LASERS 425
Fig. 9. Steady-state side mode suppression ratio versus biasing current for Fig. 11. Evolution of the carrier density longitudinal profile in the
the conventional CPM-DFB and CPM-DCC-DFB structures. steady-state regime for the CPM-DFB cavity with increasing biasing current.
The typical “break” of QWS-DFB lasers located at the cavity center is
removed thanks to the distributed phase shift.
(a)
IV. CONCLUSION
Large signal dynamics of general Bragg-detuned cavities
have been analyzed. Conventional CPM-DFB structures (uni-
form coupling coefficient ) are found to exhibit poor steady-
state singlemode operation because of spatial hole burning
effects which allows side modes to be excited. A solution to
this limitation is to modulate spatially the coupling coefficient
so that a CPM-DCC-DFB cavity is produced. A stronger
at the cavity center tends to enhance the static singlemode
properties because these particular structures are less sensi-
tive to LSHB. Unfortunately, in CPM-DCC-DFB lasers, side
modes are liable to be excited during the turn-on transient
interval, thus imposing a limitation to the modulation depth
(b) requirement. However, in the case of the optimized CPM-
Fig. 13. Variations induced on the steady-state carrier density profile, due to DCC-DFB cavity studied in this paper, this limit is high
the mode beating in the cavity. (a) In the conventional CPM-DFB, the carrier (around ) so that a -dependent is a good means to
profile before and during the beating departs from each other, due to the onset
of a side mode. (b) The CPM-DCC-DFB cavity remains singlemode and the achieve very good static and dynamic singlemode stability in
carrier profile is clamped, whatever the instants chosen in the steady-state the range of operating bias currents.
regime. The simultaneous longitudinal and time dependence of this
multimode model can be used to visualize LSHB as well as the
occurrence of a side mode in the cavity. A characterization of
if the biasing current is clamped after the switch-on (the multimode operation in complicated DFB structures is carried
biasing current is kept constant). The carrier profile out through transient responses (mode beating), Fourier spectra
is thus modified because of the occurrence of a second mode and longitudinal carrier density profiles (gradual departure of
in the cavity: before the beating, only the main mode depletes the carrier density at two instants of the steady-state regime).
FESSANT: DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR OF BRAGG-DETUNED DFB LASERS 427