Economic Growth and Business Cycles
Problem Set 5: Consumption
Johannes Van Vlodrop
1. Two-period consumption–savings
A representative household lives for two periods and maximizes
U (C1 , C2 ) = u(C1 ) + β u(C2 ), u′ > 0, u′′ < 0, β ∈ (0, 1].
Income (Y1 , Y2 ) is exogenous. The gross interest rate is R ≡ 1 + r, r > 0.
(a) Derive the intertemporal budget constraint.
(b) State the Euler equation and interpret it.
C 1−σ −1
Consider the case of CRRA (constant relative risk aversion) utility u(C) = 1−σ
, σ > 0.
(c) Derive u′ (C) and express C2 in terms of C1 . (Hint: Use the Euler equation.)
(d) Solve for C1∗ and C2∗ in closed form.
(e) How does r affect C1∗ when σ > 1 versus σ < 1?
2. IES and marginal propensity to consume
Y2
Keep CRRA utility and denote PV = W1 + Y1 + R
, with initial wealth W1 .
(a) Define the intertemporal elasticity of substitution (IES).
(b) Express C1∗ as a function of PV, β, σ, R.
(c) Compute the marginal propensity to consume (MPC) out of W1 (net wealth). What
does the MPC represent?
(d) How does MPCW1 vary with R when σ > 1?
1
3. Ricardian equivalence and credit constraints
Consider two types of consumers: a fraction µ ∈ [0, 1] is credit constrained (hand-to-
mouth), the remaining 1 − µ are unconstrained. Preferences are
U (C1 , C2 ) = u(C1 ) + βu(C2 ), u′ > 0, u′′ < 0, β ∈ (0, 1].
Endowments (Y1 , Y2 ), lump-sum taxes (T1 , T2 ), and initial wealth V1 are given. Gross
interest rate R = 1 + r, r > 0.
For the constrained type, the desired (unconstrained) choice would entail borrowing in
period 1 (S ⋆ < 0), but borrowing is not allowed. Therefore the borrowing constraint
S ≥ 0 binds: S = 0.
(a) Write the period budget constraints for both types and the intertemporal budget.
(b) State the optimality conditions (FOCs/KKT) and show what binding implies for
marginal utilities.
(c) Assume β(1 + r) = 1. Derive optimal consumption for both consumer types.
(d) Derive aggregate consumption (period 1 and period 2).
(e) Show that the aggregate MPC out of current disposable income is
∂C1agg 1+r
= µ + (1 − µ) .
∂ [V1 + Y1 − T1 ] 2+r
Compare to the MPC in an economy without credit-constrained consumers and
explain the difference.
(f) Derive the effect of switching from tax to debt finance on aggregate private consump-
tion in period 1. That is, consider a one-unit tax cut in period 1 that is temporarily
financed by issuing government debt, with government spending unchanged and all
debt repaid by the end of period 2. What is the effect on optimal period-1 con-
sumption when there are no credit-constrained consumers? Explain whether there
is a difference compared to the case with constrained consumers.
(g) Consider a temporary one-unit tax cut in period 1 that is financed by cutting gov-
ernment consumption in period 1 so that the intertemporal government budget con-
straint holds (no change in T2 ). Derive the effect on aggregate private consumption
in period 1 and compare it to the case with no credit-constrained consumers.