TQM Unit - 1
TQM Unit - 1
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION
• According to ISO, Total Quality Management is the management
approach of an organization, centered on quality, based on the
participation of all its members and aiming at long-term success through
customer satisfaction, and benefits to all members of the organization
and to society.
• The Simple Objective of TQM - “Do the right things, right the first time,
every time.”
• TQM is the art of managing the whole to achieve excellence.
• It consists of 3 Paradigms:
o Total – Made up of the whole (or) Complete.
o Quality – Degree of Excellence a product or service provides to the
customer in present and future.
o Management – Act, art, or manner of handling, controlling,
directing, etc.
QUALITY
Quality is the most important thing. The quality of your work defines you.
Whoever you are, whatever you do, I can find the same products and services
cheaper somewhere else. But your quality is your signature.
CHARACTERISTICS OF QUALITY
• Customer dependent
• Market attributed
• Fitness for use
• Degree of preference
• Dynamic and different
BENEFITS OF QUALITY
• Higher customer satisfaction
• Reliable products/services
• Better efficiency of operations
• More productivity & profit
• Better morale of work force
• Less wastage costs
• Less Inspection costs
• Improved process
1
• More market share
• Spread of happiness & prosperity
• Better quality of life for all.
EVOLUTION OF QUALITY
• The history of total quality management (TQM) began initially as a term
coined by the Naval Air Systems Command to describe its Japanese-style
management approach to quality improvement.
• An umbrella methodology for continually improving the quality of all
processes, it draws on a knowledge of the principles and practices of:
– The behavioral sciences
– The analysis of quantitative and nonquantitative data
– Economics theories
– Process analysis
2
o Another by-product was the idea of improving not only
quality of the products, but also every aspect of
organizational issues.
o This probably was the start of the idea, total quality.
4. Total Quality:
o The term ‘total quality’ was used for the first time in a
paper by Feigenbaum at the first international
conference on quality control in Tokyo in 1969. The term
referred to wider issues within an organization.
o Ishikawa also discussed ‘total quality control’ in Japan,
which is different from the western idea of total quality.
o According to his explanation, it means ‘company-wide
quality control’ that involves all employees, from top
management to the workers, in quality control.
5. Total Quality Management:
o In the 1980s to the 1990s, a new phase of quality
control and management began. This became known as
Total Quality Management (TQM).
o Having observed Japan’s success of employing quality
issues, western companies started to introduce their
own quality initiatives.
o A typical definition of TQM includes phrases such as:
customer focus, the involvement of all employees,
continuous improvement and the integration of quality
management into the total organization.
6. Quality Awards and Excellence Models:
o In 1988 a major step forward in quality management
was made with the development of the Malcolm Baldrige
Award in the United States.
o The model, on which the award was based, represented
the first clearly defined and internationally recognized
TQM model.
o It was developed by the United States government to
encourage companies to adopt the model and improve
their competitiveness.
o In response to this, a similar model was developed by
the European Foundation of Quality Management in
1992.
o This EFQM Excellence Model is the framework for the
European Quality Award.
7. Business Excellence:
o TQM models are often called Business Excellence
Models.
o Also, TQM itself is now often called Business Excellence.
o This is to distinguish the “new TQM” from the past work
on TQM.
o Business Excellence is really the same as TQM, but with
a more clearly defined approach.
DEFINITIONS OF QUALITY
• Quality is the degree to which an object or entity (e.g., process,
product, or service) satisfies a specified set of attributes or
requirements.
• Quality means when a product or service meets or exceeds
expectation considering the intended use and the selling price.
– If the quality of a product is high then that means that it is
fit for its purpose.
– If the quality of an item is low that means that the product
may break easily or not work properly.
• Quality means "degree of excellence“.
3
– Quality = performance / expectation
• Quality is defined as the predictable degree of uniformity and
dependability, at low cost suited to the market. (Deming).
• Quality is defined as fitness for use (Juran).
• Quality is defined as conformance to requirements (Crosby).
• Quality is totality of the characteristics of entity that bear on its
ability to satisfy stated and implied needs.(ISO).
DIMENSIONS OF QUALITY
• Products and Services that meet or exceed customer expectations
result in customer satisfaction.
• Quality is the expected product/service being realized.
• Various dimensions of quality that the customers do look for in a
product, in order to satisfy their needs, only decide the characteristics
of a product.
• Two categories:
a. Dimensions of product(or manufacturing)quality
b. Dimensions of service quality
4
o This is how well your organization is able to handle service-
related issues such as customer complaints or product
repairs. This can also include the ease of repair of the
product, which can be a determinant in whether the
customer will buy the product.
o Example: Service expenses in mobile phone.
7. Aesthetics
o This involves the characteristics of the product that are
related to its appearance, feel, smell, or taste (if applicable).
o Example: Sleekness, weight, Colour combination in mobile
phone
8. Reputation
o This describes the name the supplier has made over time.
o Example: Maruthi Suzuki service, Nokia Mobile Phone
9. Response
o Human to human interface, such as the courtesy of the
dealer. It refers to the degree they react and act quickly to
resolve the problems.
o Example: Replacement of defective parts – TATA Indica,
Honda
6
Principle 1: Customer Focus
– "Organisations depend on their customers and therefore should
understand current and future needs of the customer, meet customer
requirements and strive to exceed customer expectations“.
– Steps in application of this principle are:
1. Understand customer needs and expectations for products,
delivery, price, dependability, etc.
2. Ensure a balanced approach among customers and other stake
holders (owners, people, suppliers, local communities and society
at large) needs and expectations.
3. Communicate these needs and expectations throughout the
organization.
4. Measure customer satisfaction & act on results and
5. Manage customer relationships.
Principle 2: Leadership
– "Leaders establish unity of purpose and direction of the organisation.
They should create and maintain the internal environment in which
people can become fully involved in achieving the organisation's
objectives.“
– Steps in application of this principle are:
1. Be proactive and lead by example.
2. Understand and respond to changes in the external environment.
3. Consider the needs of all stake holders including customers,
owners, people, suppliers, local communities and society at large.
4. Establish a clear vision of the organisation's future.
5. Establish shared values and ethical role models at all levels of the
organisation.
6. Build trust and eliminate fear.
7. Provide people with the required resources and freedom to act with
responsibility and accountability.
8. Inspire, encourage and recognise people's contributions.
9. Promote open and honest communication.
10. Educate, train and coach people.
11. Set challenging goals and targets, and
12. Implement a strategy to achieve these goals and targets.
8
3. Analyse the data and information using valid methods.
4. Understand the value of appropriate statistical techniques, and
5. Make decisions and take action based on the results of logical
analysis balanced with experience and intuition.
TQM FRAMEWORK
TQM is an umbrella under which the management includes everything
that it considers important for its success. Most of the elements are common to all.
TQM programmes and the list of elements can be divided into 2 groups – TQM
Principles and practices and TQM tools and techniques.
A. Quality Gurus:
1. Walter Shewhart: Known for the Shewhart Cycle (PDCA) and statistical
process control.
2. W. Edwards Deming: Developed the Deming Cycle (PDCA) and 14 Points for
Management.
3. Joseph Juran: Introduced the Juran Trilogy (Quality Planning, Quality
Control, Quality Improvement).
4. Arm and Feigenbaum: Developed the concept of Total Quality Control.
5. Kaoru Ishikawa: Introduced the Fishbone Diagram (Ishikawa Diagram) for
root cause analysis.
6. Philip Crosby: Developed the Crosby Quality Management Maturity Grid.
7. Genichi Taguchi: Introduced the Taguchi Methods for quality engineering.
This detailed breakdown covers the key components of the TQM Framework,
including the contributions of renowned quality gurus, various tools and
techniques, and essential principles and practices for achieving quality excellence.
10
[Link] Cycle
11
o Encourage staff to learn from one another, and
provide a culture and environment for effective
teamwork.
7. Implement leadership.
o Expect your supervisors and managers to
understand their workers and the processes they
use.
o Don't simply supervise – provide support and
resources so that each staff member can do his or
her best.
o Figure out what each person actually needs to do his
or her best.
o Emphasize the importance of participative
management and transformational leadership.
o Find ways to reach full potential, and don't just focus
on meeting targets and quotas.
8. Eliminate fear.
o Allow people to perform at their best by ensuring that
they're not afraid to express ideas or concerns.
o Let everyone know that the goal is to achieve high
quality by doing more things right – and that you're
not interested in blaming people when mistakes
happen.
o Make workers feel valued, and encourage them to
look for better ways to do things.
o Use open and honest communication to remove fear
from the organization.
9. Break down barriers between departments.
o Build the "internal customer" concept – recognize
that each department or function serves other
departments that use their output.
o Build a shared vision.
o Use cross-functional teamwork to build
understanding and reduce adversarial relationships.
o Focus on collaboration and consensus instead of
compromise.
10. Get rid of unclear slogans.
o Let people know exactly what you want – don't make
them guess.
o Don't let words and nice-sounding phrases replace
effective leadership. Outline your expectations, and
then praise people face-to-face for doing good work.
11. Eliminate management by objectives.
o Look at how the process is carried out, not just
numerical targets. Deming said that production
targets encourage high output and low quality.
o Provide support and resources so that production
levels and quality are high and achievable.
o Measure the process rather than the people behind
the process.
12. Remove barriers to pride of workmanship.
o Allow everyone to take pride in their work without
being rated or compared.
o Treat workers the same, and don't make them
compete with other workers for monetary or other
rewards. Over time, the quality system will naturally
raise the level of everyone's work to an equally high
level.
13. Implement education and self-improvement.
o Improve the current skills of workers.
12
o Encourage people to learn new skills to prepare for
future changes and challenges.
o Build skills to make your workforce more adaptable
to change, and better able to find and achieve
improvements.
14. Make "transformation" everyone's job.
o Improve your overall organization by having each
person take a step toward quality.
o Analyze each small step, an understand how it fits
into the larger picture.
o Use effective change management principles to
introduce the new philosophy and ideas in Deming's
14 points.
13
d. Juran's 10 steps for quality improvement; and
e. The breakthrough concept.
f. Pareto Principle
g. Quality by design
h. Employee Empowerment
i. Continuous Improvement
a. Internal Customer
– Juran realised that the customer was not just the end customer
and that each person along the chain has an internal customer.
– Each person along the chain, from product designer to final user,
is a supplier and a customer.
– In addition, the person will be a process, carrying out some
transformation or activity.
– Therefore Juran maintained that at each stage was a "three role
model". supplier, process, and customer, as shown in Figure.
b. Cost of Quality
– Juran classified the cost of quality into three classes as:
(i) Failure costs: Scrap, rework, corrective actions, warranty
claims, customer complaints, and loss of customer.
(ii) Appraisal costs: Inspection, compliance auditing and
investigations.
(iii) Prevention costs: Training, preventive auditing, and process
improvement implementation.
– Juran demonstrated the potential for increased profits that would
result if the costs of poor quality could be reduced.
14
The entire concepts of Juran's quality trilogy can be summarized below.
1. Quality Planning
Identify the customers
Determine the customer's needs
• Develop product features
Establish quality goods
• Develop a process
Prove process capability
2. Quality Control
• Choose control subjects (what to control?)
Choose units of measurement
Establish measurement
Establish standards of performance
• Measure actual performance
Interpret the difference (actual vs, standard)
Take action on the difference
3. Quality Improvement
• Prove need for improvement
Identify specific projects for improvement
Organise to guide the projects
Organise for diagnosis- for discovery of causes
Diagnose to find the causes
• Provide remedies
Prove that remedies are effective under the
operating conditions
Provide for control to hold gains
f. Pareto Principle
– Juran popularized the Pareto Principle (80/20 rule), which states
that approximately 80% of problems are caused by 20% of the
variables.
g. Quality by Design
– Juran emphasized the importance of designing quality into
products and processes, rather than relying on inspection and
testing.
h. Employee Empowerment
15
– Juran advocated for employee involvement and empowerment,
encouraging organizations to tap into the knowledge and skills of
their workforce.
i. Continuous Improvement
– Juran stressed the importance of continuous improvement,
encouraging organizations to strive for ongoing quality
improvement.
17
Crosby's contributions have had a lasting impact on quality management,
emphasizing the importance of prevention, measurement, and continuous
improvement. His ideas continue to influence industries worldwide.
18
o To improve various processes of the organization, various key
characteristics of the processes are to be measured. Also
access to data and quick retrieval is necessary for effective
processes.
o Finding the root cause, correcting the problem and eliminating
the root cause are the key to prevent recurrence of the
problem.
7. Paying inadequate attention to internal and external customers.
o For effective TQM implementation, the organization requires to
understand the changing needs and expectations of its
customers.
o Effective feedback mechanisms should be devised to convert
the needs/feedback of both internal and external customers
into tangible product features and actions.
o The right people (who are directly working on the product)
should be given direct access to the customers. This will
provide the person accountability along with the responsibility.
8. Inadequate use of empowerment and team work.
o Team members should be trained enough in problem solving,
monitoring, and resolving conflicts. Norms need to be
established around the issues of leadership, membership, and
processes.
o Individuals should be empowered to make decisions that affect
the efficiency of their process or the satisfaction of their
customer.
9. Failure to continuously improve.
o A lack of continuous improvement of the process, product and
service will even throw the best-in-the-industry out of the
market.
o There is need to explore problems; constantly improve the
system of production and service. There should be continual
rise in productivity and a decrease in costs.
QUALITY STATEMENTS
– Quality statements are established by the quality council to provide overall
direction for achieving the total quality culture.
– Three elements of quality statements are:
a. Vision statements
b. Mission statement
c. Quality policy statement
a. Vision Statement:
o The vision statement is a short declaration of what an organization
aspires to be tomorrow.
19
o The vision should be coined in such a way that the leaders and the
employees working in the organization should work towards the
achievements of the vision statement.
o A well-written vision statement, regardless of the type of organization,
has the following characteristics:
Is easily understood by all stakeholders
Is briefly stated, yet clear and comprehensive in meaning
Is challenging, yet attainable etc..
o Example:”to be the leading customer battery company in the world”-
Duracell International
b. Mission statement:
o The Mission statement is usually one paragraph, describes the
function of the organization.
o It provides a clear statement of purpose for employees, customers and
suppliers.
o Key elements of a mission statement:
a. Obligation to stakeholders: The most important stakeholder and
the relative emphasis placed on meeting the needs of various
stakeholders.
b. Scope of the business: The areas in which the company will
compete defined by the customers served, the functions provided,
and the technology employed.
c. Sources of competitive advantage: The skills that the company will
develop/leverage to achieve its vision and a description of how the
company intends to exceed in creating customer value and
competitive advantage
d. View of the future: The anticipated regulatory, competitive and
economic environment in which the company must compete.
o Example:”We exist to create. make, and market useful products and
services to satisfy the needs of the customer throughout the world”-
Texas Instruments.
20
provide them an open and participative environment." - Parle Products
Limited
3. Xerox is a quality company. Quality is the basic business principle
for Xerox. Quality means providing our external and internal
customers with innovative products and services that fully satisfy
their requirements. Quality is the job of every employee. - Xerox
Corporation
– The quality statements consist of the core values and concepts given in a
previous section, the vision statement, the mission statement, and the
quality policy statement. The core values and concepts should be condensed
considerably for simplicity and publication.
CUSTOMER FOCUS
– Customer focus is a business approach that prioritizes understanding and
meeting the needs of customers. It involves:
• Emphasis on customer-defined quality
• Emphasis on customer service
• Integration of customer information for new product development
• Partnering with customer for the product development , R&D,
technology forecasting
CUSTOMER ORIENTATION
– Customer orientation is a business philosophy that prioritizes
understanding and meeting the needs of customers. It involves:
• Understanding customer needs, preferences, and behaviors
• Aligning products, services, and processes to meet customer needs
• Delivering value to customers through quality, convenience, and
support
• Continuously gathering customer feedback to improve offerings
– Customer orientation leads to:
• Increased customer satisfaction
• Loyalty and retention
• Positive word-of-mouth and referrals
• Competitive advantage
• Revenue growth
– Key aspects of customer orientation include:
• Customer insights: gathering and analyzing customer data
• Customer-centric culture: aligning company culture with customer
needs
• Customer touchpoints: managing all interactions with customers
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
– The most important asset of any organization is its customers. An
organization’s success depends on how many customers it has, how much
they buy, and how often they buy. Customers that are satisfied will increase
in number, buy more, and buy more frequently. Satisfied customers also pay
their bills promptly, which greatly improves cash flow—the lifeblood of any
organization.
– Customer satisfaction refers to the degree to which a product, service, or
experience meets or exceeds customer expectations. It's a key performance
indicator (KPI) for businesses, as satisfied customers are more likely to:
• Return for repeat business
21
• Recommend to others
• Provide positive reviews
• Be loyal to the brand
– As emphasised so far, in today's buyers market 'the customer is the king'.
Even the definition of quality, 'quality is what customer wants', emphasises
on the customer requirements. In other words, quality is a measure of
customer satisfaction.
– It is obvious that business cannot survive without satisfied customers.
Therefore TQM's purpose is meeting or exceeding customer expectations, so
that the customers are delighted.
22
Customer Satisfaction Model
The above figure shows the Teboul's model of customer satisfaction. In the
figure, the customers' needs are represented by the circle, and the square
represents the product or service offered by the company. The intersection portion,
shown with dots, is perceived as the customer satisfaction. So it is understood that
the company should strive for increasing the intersection portion ie., customer
satisfaction.
Types of Customers
– Customers are two types. They are:
1. Internal customers, and
2. External customers.
1. Internal Customers
o The customers inside the company are called internal customers.
o As there is a flow of work, product and service in the organisation,
each department is dependent on the other.
o In this, each department or each quality management unit is
considered as a customer by the previous department and as a
supplier for the next department.
o Similarly every person in a process is considered as a customer of the
preceding operation, This explains the concept of internal customer.
2. External Customers
o The customers outside the company are called external customers.
o In other words, on external customer is the one:
who uses the product or service;
who purchases the product or service; or
who influences the sale of the product or service.
o Types of external customers
a) Purchaser: Someone who buys the product for himself or
herself or for someone else; e.g., anyone who purchases food
for his or her family.
b) End user/Ultimate customer: Someone who finally benefits
from the product: e.g., the patient who goes to health care
facility for diagnostic testing.
23
c) Merchants: People who purchase products for resaler,
wholesalers, distributors, travel agents, and brokers.
d) Processors: Organisations and people who use the product
or output as an input for producing their own product; e.g.,
a refinery that receives crude oil and processes it into
different products for a variety of customers.
e) Suppliers: Those who provide input to the process.
f) Potential customers: Those are not currently using the
product but capable of becoming customers.
g) Hidden customers: Those who can exert great influence over
the product design: regulators, critics, opinion leaders,
payers, the media, corporate policy makers, labour unions,
professional associations.
Customer-Supplier Chain
– In order to achieve the total customer orientation, TQM requires the
better customer-supplier relationship. Figure shows the model of
customer-supplier chain.
24
CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS
What is a Customer Complaint?
– A customer complaint in any communication a customer has with a
company in which 'displeasure' is expressed.
– A customer complaint may be defined as an expression of
dissatisfaction with a product/service, either orally or in writing, from
an internal or external customer.
– A customer may have a genuine cause for complaint, although some
complaints may be made as a result of a misunderstanding or an
unreasonable expectation of a product or service.
– How a customer complaint is handled will affect the overall level of
customer satisfaction and may affect long-term customer loyalty.
Thus it is important for enterprises to have clear procedures for
dealing rapidly with any customer complaints.
– From many statistical analysis of customer satisfaction, the following
conclusions were made:
o A totally satisfied customer contributes 2.6 times as much
revenue to a company as a somewhat satisfied customer.
o A totally satisfied customer contributes 17 times as much
revenue as a somewhat dissatisfied customer.
o A totally dissatisfied customer decreases revenue at a rate
equal to 1.8 times of what a totally satisfied customer
contributes to business.
– Thus the number of dissatisfied customers should be reduced as
much as possible. In order to do so, customer feedback must be
continuously solicited and monitored.
a. Comment cards
Comment cards are normally attached, to the warranty card,
issued with the product at the time of sales. It is completed
later and mailed back.
b. Customer questionnaire
A customer questionnaire, also known as a survey, is a more
effective and also a popular tool for obtaining opinions and
perceptions about organization ads its product and services.
25
c. Post-transaction surveys
Post-transaction surveys are conducted immediately after a
customer service interaction and usually provide feedback
directly on that interaction.
Survey include:
o Survey through mail
o Survey through E-mail
o Survey through telephone
Particularly online, phone and mail survey are most frequently
used methods to collect customer feedback.
Types of online surveys:
o E-mail: Survey is emailed to customer, either as a
link to a web based survey, or questions are included
in the body of the email.
o Pop-up:”pop ups” are request for feedback after a
visitor has landed on company website.
o Website: a link on company website to a survey often
used to gather feedback on website or web-based
interaction.
d. Report (feedback) cards:
Report cards, like comment cards are physical, paper cards or
forms with one or more survey questions designed to collect
customer feedback.
e. Focus groups
Focus groups are moderated, small group discussions where a
pre-selected group of individual (often customers) provides
insight into their preferences, attitudes and opinions about
products or services.
f. Social media
Social media such social networks, online communities, blogs,
forums or discussions boards, can be used to collect customer
feedback.
g. Toll free telephone numbers
Toll free telephone numbers are an effective tool for receiving
customer feedback/compliant.
h. Customer visits
Visits to customer place of business is an another technique for
gathering information and feedback of the product.
i. Employee feedback
Employee feedback is also potential source of information.
CUSTOMER RETENTION
– Customer retention is more powerful and effective than customer
satisfaction.
– Customer retention represents the activities that produce the necessary
customer satisfaction that creates customer loyalty, which actually
improves the bottom line.
– Customer retention moves customer satisfaction to the next level by
determining what is truly important to the customers and making sure
that the customer satisfaction system focuses valuable resources on
things that really matter to the customer.
– Customer retention is the connection between customer satisfaction and
the bottom line.
26
3. Offer Loyalty Programs: Reward repeat customers with exclusive benefits,
discounts, or premium services.
4. Gather and Act on Feedback: Collect customer insights and implement
changes to improve products and services.
5. Stay Top of Mind: Engage customers through regular newsletters,
updates, and relevant content.
6. Foster a Sense of Community: Create online forums or social media
groups for customers to connect and share experiences.
7. Provide Value-Added Services: Offer complementary products, training,
or support to enhance customer experience.
8. Set Clear Expectations: Communicate transparently about products,
services, and processes to avoid misunderstandings.
9. Measure and Monitor Retention: Track key metrics like churn rate,
retention rate, and customer lifetime value.
10. Empower Customer-Facing Teams: Give employees the autonomy and
resources to make customer-centric decisions.
27
COST OF QUALITY
– Cost of Quality can be termed as the process that measures and determines
where and how organizations’ resources are utilized to maintain quality and
prevent poor outputs. It can be regarded as a method of process
improvement and quality assurance and prevents internal and external
audit failures.
– Cost of Quality (CoQ) refers to the costs associated with quality control,
quality assurance, and quality improvement within an organization. It
includes costs incurred to prevent, detect, and correct defects or errors in
products or services.
– This two-pronged approach to quality can be categorized as “control” (good
quality) vs. “failure of control” (bad quality).
– Cost of quality has four main components between the two buckets of “good”
and “bad” quality.
– Taken together, the four main costs of quality add up to make up the total
cost of quality.
CoQ = Appraisal + Prevention + Internal Failure + External Failure
28
How to Measure the Cost of Quality (COQ)
– Cost of Quality calculation differs from organization to organization.
Many times, organizations determine the Cost of Quality by
calculating total warranty dollars as a percentage of sales.
– But this method looks externally at the Cost of Quality and not
internally. For better understanding, a more comprehensive overview
of all quality costs is essential.
– The cost of Quality is categorized by:
o Prevention Cost (PC)
o Appraisal cost (AC)
o Internal Failure Cost (IFC)
o External Failure Cost (EFC)
– By applying these four categories to the original Cost of Quality
equation, which states that Cost of Quality is the sum of Cost of Good
Quality and Cost of Poor Quality, the basic equation can be expanded
as shown below:
o The Cost of Good Quality is the total of Prevention Cost and
Appraisal Cost (COGQ = PC + AC)
o The Cost of Poor Quality is the addition of Internal and
External Failure Costs (COPQ = IFC + EFC)
– By combining the above equations, the Cost of Quality can be more
defined, as shown below:
COQ = COGQ+ COPQ = (PC + AC) + (IFC + EFC)
**********************************
29