Chapter - 06
Chapter - 06
1
• Professional judgment is the application of
relevant training, knowledge and experience
in making informed decisions about the
courses of action that are appropriate in the
circumstances of the audit engagement.
• Professional skepticism is an attitude that
includes a questioning mind, being alert to
conditions which may indicate possible
misstatement due to error or fraud, and a
critical assessment of audit evidence.
3. Audit risk is:
(a) = (inherent risk + control risk) * detection
risk
(b) = inherent risk * (control risk + detection
risk)
(c) = (inherent risk - control risk) * detection risk
(d) = inherent risk * control risk * detection risk
(correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Audit risk is the risk that the auditor expresses an
inappropriate audit opinion when the financial
statements are materially misstated. It is a function
of the risk of material misstatement (inherent risk
and control risk) and the risk that the auditor will
not detect such misstatement (detection risk).
4. In the context of audit risk point out detection risk?
(a) That the auditor's substantive procedures
will not detect and correct material errors
which exist in the financial statements
(correct)
2
(b) That the company's control system will fail
to detect and correct material errors in the
processing of transactions
(c) That the susceptibility of financial statement
transactions and balances to material errors
which may or may not be detected
Answer (a)
Explanation:
As per ISA 200 Overall Objectives of the
Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit
in Accordance with International Standards of
Auditing - Detection risk is auditor related and
controlled.
5. Control risk would be increased by which
circumstance?
(a) There is a high turnover of staff in the
finance department (correct)
(b) The client operates in a highly regulated
industry
(c) The auditor is relying on tests of controls
and reducing substantive procedures
accordingly
Answer (a)
Explanation:
There is a risk that control procedures are not
followed due to the unfamiliarity of staff with the
requirements of those procedures. (b) increases
inherent risk. (c) increases detection risk.
6. What are the two elements of the risk of material
misstatement at the assertion level?
3
(a) Detection risk and control risk
(b) Inherent risk and detection risk
(c) Audit risk and detection risk
(d) Inherent risk and control risk (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
The risk of material misstatement at the assertion
level is made up of inherent risk and control risk.
Detection risk is the risk that the auditor's
procedures will not detect a misstatement that
exists in an assertion that could be material. Audit
risk is the risk that the auditor gives an
inappropriate audit opinion when the financial
statements are materially misstated. Audit risk is
made up of inherent risk, control risk and detection
risk (AR = IR x CR x DR)
7. Audit procedures designed to evaluate the
operating effectiveness of controls in preventing,
or detecting and correcting, material misstatement
at the assertion level. It is known as:
(a) Substantive tests
(b) Tests of controls (correct)
(c) Analytical procedures
(d) Tests of detail
Answer (b)
Explanation:
Tests of controls are audit procedures designed to
evaluate the operating effectiveness of controls in
preventing, or detecting and correcting, material
misstatement at the assertion level.
4
8. During the course of the audit, a team member
traced the annual lunch payment, of the client,
from the credit card bill and found the figure to be
different from the lunch invoice. The team member
informed the senior personal of the team. Which of
the following best describes the team member's
attitude?
(a) Professional judgment
(b) Professional estimate
(c) Professional skepticism (correct)
(d) Professional behavior
Answer (c)
Explanation:
Professional skepticism is an attitude that includes
a questioning mind, being alert to conditions which
may indicate possible misstatement due to error or
fraud, and a critical assessment of audit evidence.
9. Point out which statement is not true?
(a) Materiality may depend on either the nature
of an item or its monetary amount
(b) Materiality is a matter of professional
judgment
(c) Materiality depends on the monetary
amount of an item (correct)
Answer (c)
Explanation:
5
Materiality can be both quantitative and qualitative.
10. Point out material misstatements?
I. An error of PKR 5,000 in relation to assets
of PKR 2m.
II. A payroll fraud of PKR 100 in a company
where profit before tax is PKR 10,000.
III. Non-disclosure of a material uncertainty.
IV. Financial statements have been prepared
on a going concern basis when the
company is in the process of being
liquidated.
(a) I and II
(b) II and III
(c) III and IV (correct)
(d) I and IV
Answer (c)
Explanation:
I is not material being only 0.25% of assets. II is
not material being only 1% of PBT. III is material
by nature as disclosures are required to aid the
understandability of the Financial Statements. IV is
material and pervasive as the basis of preparation
is incorrect which will affect whole of the financial
statements.
11. Is this statement true or false?
“Performance materiality levels are higher than the
materiality for the financial statements as a whole.
“
(a) True
(b) False (correct)
6
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The statement is false. Performance materiality
levels are set lower than materiality for the
financial statements as a whole.
7
I. Analytical procedures
II. Inquiry
III. Confirmation
IV. Reperformance
8
uncover non-compliance with laws and
regulations.
15. Identify the primary purpose of planning an audit?
(a) To ensure that the client obtains added
value from the audit to increase the chances
of retaining the audit for next year
(b) To ensure that appropriate team members
are selected to enable the development of
their competencies and capabilities
(c) To organize and manage the audit so that it
is performed in an effective and efficient
manner
(d) To reduce the risk of giving an inappropriate
audit opinion to an acceptable level (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
(d) is the primary purpose of planning an audit,
whereas (b) and (c) may be reasons to plan the
audit.
9
(d) Detection risk will increase to 100%
Answer (a)
Explanation:
Detection risk is the risk that the procedures
performed by the auditor to reduce audit risk to an
acceptably low level will not detect a misstatement
that exists and that could be material, individually
or when aggregated with other misstatements.
17. Point out the categories of risk that can be
controlled by the auditor?
Category of risk:
I. Control risk
II. Detection risk
III. Sampling risk
(a) I and II
(b) II and III (correct)
(c) II only
(d) I and III
Answer (b)
Explanation:
Control risks (together with inherent risk) are
components of the risk of material misstatement,
which is governed by the circumstances of the
audit client and therefore is outside the control of
the auditor. Sampling risk is a component of
detection risk, which is controlled by the auditor.
The correct answer is therefore option (b).
10
18. Risk that inventory has a lower net realizable
value than cost and is therefore overstated. Some
possible responses to this risk are as follows:
I. Focus on testing internal controls over those
assets.
II. Examine the instructions to identify slow
moving inventory lines when attending the
inventory count.
III. Increase the emphasis on reviewing the
year end aged inventory analysis for
evidence of slow moving inventory.
IV. Ascertain sales values for items sold post
year end that were in inventory at the year
end to ensure their NPV was higher than the
cost recorded as part of the inventory value
in the financial statements.
11
"The materiality level calculated at the planning
stage should not be revised during later stages of
the audit."
(a) True
(b) False (correct)
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The materiality level calculated when planning the
audit may need to be revised as the audit
progresses. For example, where it appears that
the actual financial results for the period are
significantly different from those that were used in
calculating the materiality level at the planning
stage.
13
be revisited throughout the audit and revised if
necessary.
Explanation:
16
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The external auditor is responsible for obtaining
reasonable assurance that the financial
statements are free from material misstatement
whether caused by fraud or error. The internal
audit function may assist management and those
charged with governance in its monitoring and
reviewing role but are not ultimately responsible.
29. Auditors have a duty to detect fraud:
(a) True
(b) False (correct)
Answer (b)
30. The audit team is required to discuss the
susceptibility of the financial statements to
material misstatements:
(a) True (correct)
(b) False
Answer (a)
17
(c) Auditors have to rely on the data provided
by the client, only.
(d) The nature of audit procedures. (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Inherent risk is affected by the nature of the entity
and also the nature of the strategies it adopts.
32. Identify which items of information that comes to
an auditor's attention would be most likely to
suggest non-compliance with laws and
regulations?
(a) The presence of several difficult-to-audit
transactions affecting expense accounts
(b) An exchange of property for similar property
(c) The discovery of unexplained payments
made to government employees (correct)
(d) The client's failure to develop adequate
internal controls that prevent or detect
unauthorized purchases
Answer (c)
Explanation:
The discovery of unexplained payments to
government employees is a possible indicator of
non-compliance with laws and regulations. (d) is
an internal control weakness. (a) and (b) are not
indicators of non-compliance.
33. In relation to laws and regulations which best
describes the auditor's responsibilities?
18
(a) The auditor has no responsibility in respect
of laws and regulations
(b) The auditor must consider whether the
financial statements are materially misstated
as a result of non-compliance with laws and
regulations (correct)
(c) The auditor must detect all instances of non-
compliance and report them to the police
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The auditor has to consider the risk of material
misstatement in the financial statements. Non-
compliance may lead to unrecorded liabilities
which may have a material effect on the financial
statements.
34. You are performing the audit, for the year ended
31 March 2011, of Company G. During the course
of the audit, you received the working papers of
the period ended 30 September 2010. According
to the working papers, the controls of the entity
were effective. Since then, no change has been
made in the controls of the company. Which of the
following is true?
(a) You will not perform test of controls as you
have audit evidence of the operating
effectiveness of the controls and no change
has been made in the controls. (correct)
(b) You will perform test of controls only on the
six months ending 31 March 2001 as
19
remaining six months were tested by other
auditors of your firm.
(c) You will not perform test of controls as
substantive procedures are enough if
controls are operating effectively.
(d) You will perform test of controls as the audit
evidence covers only 6 months of the period
for which you intend to rely on those
controls.
Answer (a)
Explanation:
You will not perform test of controls as you have
audit evidence of the operating effectiveness of
the controls and no change has been made in the
controls.
20
(b), (c) and (d) are overall responses.
21
The matters mentioned in option (a) relate
specifically to business operations. The matters
mentioned in the other options relate specifically to
financial reporting (option (b)), investments (option
(c)) and financing (option (d)).
38. Best way of describing a material item is?
(a) It is large in relation to the same figure in
previous years
(b) It amounts to more than 10% of the total of
which it forms a part
(c) Its omission or disclosure would reasonably
influence the decisions of a user of the
financial statements (correct)
(d) It is one which would reduce a company's
profits
Answer (c)
Explanation
ISA 320 Materiality in Planning and Performing an
Audit.
22
account balance, disclosure and assertion
and not on the design and effectiveness of
controls.
(c) You will not perform test of controls as you
cannot rely on operating effectiveness' of
controls, hence, your control risk will
increase
(d) You will not perform test of controls as you
cannot rely on controls to determine the
extent of substantive procedures (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
As you find several weaknesses in control design
of Sana Company you will not perform test of
controls as you cannot rely on controls to
determine the extent of substantive procedures.
40. You are planning the audit of Delta Co. and this is
your first year. As a result there is a lack of
cumulative audit knowledge and experience which
increases detection risk. Point out an appropriate
auditor's response to the risk described?
(a) Reduce reliance on tests of controls
(b) Extended controls testing should be
performed
(c) More time and resource will need to be
devoted to obtaining an understanding of
Delta Co. at the start of the audit (correct)
(d) Consideration should be given to relying on
an independent expert
Answer (c)
23
Explanation:
The risk arises due to the lack of knowledge of the
client - in order to address this, the auditor must
spend time obtaining that knowledge. This will
include, but is not restricted to, documenting their
understanding of the internal controls in place.
25
44. Which of the following shall an auditor consider
while determining the significant risk?
(a) The controls in place to identify that risk
(b) Whether the risk is a financial risk
(c) The assertions effected by that risk
(d) The degree of subjectivity in the
measurement of financial information related
to that risk (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Significant risks are complex or unusual
transactions that may indicate fraud, or other
special risks. Significant risks are those that
require special audit consideration. The following
factors indicate that a risk might be significant:
Risk of fraud
Its relationship with recent economic, accounting
or other developments
The degree of subjectivity in the financial
information
It is an unusual transaction
It is a significant transaction with a related party
The complexity of the transaction
45. Which procedures might an auditor use in gaining
an understanding of the entity?
I.
26
___________________________________
____
II.
___________________________________
____
III.
___________________________________
____
Answer:
I. Inquiry
II. Analytical procedures
III. Observation and inspection
27
(b) He is likely to be found liable if he found
indications of a possible fraud but dismissed
them as immaterial having failed to
adequately investigate them (correct)
(c) He is likely to be held liable if he has not
designed specific tests to look for fraud in all
areas of the accounting records
(d) He is unlikely to be held liable because the
engagement letter specifically stated that
management were responsible for the
prevention and detection of fraud
Answer (b)
Explanation:
(b) is the most accurate statement as the auditor
clearly suspected possible fraud but failed to
sufficiently investigate. (a) is incorrect as the
engagement letter refers to "reasonable
expectation". (d) is incorrect as the auditor has
specific duties in relation to fraud and error and
cannot pass them onto management. (c) is not
appropriate as the auditor should design his tests
to have "reasonable expectation" for those areas
he considers being at risk from fraud (not all
areas).
28
(d) None of the above
Answer (c)
Explanation:
Both (a) and (b), since risk of material
misstatement comprises of control risk and
inherent risk. Audit risk is the risk that the auditor
expresses an inappropriate audit opinion when the
financial statements are materially misstated. It is
a function of the risk of material misstatement
(inherent risk and control risk) and the risk that the
auditor will not detect such misstatement
(detection risk).
48. Point out example of an audit risk?
(a) A customer has gone out of business
(b) The business is experiencing cash flow
problems
(c) A supplier has increased prices
(d) Inventory may be overstated due to
damaged items being valued at cost instead
of net realizable value (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
(a), (b) and (c) are all business risks. (a) would be
an audit risk if the customer owed money to the
client which had not been written off. However,
there is no indication of that from the information
given.
29
49. While performing the audit of Company W, you
came to know that the company has entered into
the lease for the first time. There has been no
change in the internal controls of the Company
from previous year. Which of the following is true?
(a) You will test the controls on the recognition
and calculation of lease liability and expense
because of the significant risk of error
inherent in the transaction (correct)
(b) You will not test the controls on the
recognition and calculation of lease liability
and expense because no change has been
made in internal controls from last year audit
(c) You will test the controls on the recognition
and calculation of lease liability and expense
because in previous audit controls on these
account balances were not tested
(d) You will not test the controls on the
recognition and calculation of lease liability
and expense, because, as per ISA 330, the
controls are tested once in three audits if no
change in control takes place
Answer (a)
Explanation:
The Company W has entered into the lease for the
first time and there has been no change in the
internal controls of the company from previous
year. Therefore, you will test the controls on the
recognition and calculation of lease liability and
30
expense because of the significant risk of error
inherent in the transaction.
50. Which of the following statements is/are true with
respect to analytical procedures?
I. Analytical procedures can be used
throughout the audit.
II. Analytical procedures must be used as risk
assessment procedures.
(a) I only
(b) II only
(c) Neither I nor II
(d) I and II (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Analytical procedures can be used throughout the
audit but must be used as risk assessment
procedures and at the review stage of the audit.
31
(d) Check the financial impact of the breaches
and if immaterial continue with the test of
controls and if material then move t
substantive procedures, increasing their
extent
Answer (b)
Explanation:
In order to overcome the weaknesses in the
operating effectiveness of the controls you have to
increase the sample for test of controls.
52. If control risk and inherent risk are assessed as
sufficient low, substantive procedures can be
abandoned completely:
(a) True
(b) False (correct)
Answer (b)
32
Explanation:
Auditor is concerned with the fraud that causes a
material misstatement in the financial statements.
54. Which of the following would be the best sources
of information about a company's financial
systems that the auditors may use as sources of
information?
I. The company's systems procedure manuals
II. The internal audit function's system notes
III. The prior year audit file
IV. Inquiries made of company staff
V. The company's website
Answer:
I. Audit, auditors, inappropriate
II. Inherent, susceptibility, misstatement,
internal controls
Explanation:
I. Audit risk is the risk that auditors may give
an inappropriate opinion on the financial
statements.
II. Inherent risk is the susceptibility of an
assertion to a misstatement that could be
36
material, assuming there were no related
internal controls.
61. An entity has few employees in its accounting
department; point out which audit risk should be
considered?
(a) Inherent
(b) Detection
(c) Control (correct)
Answer (c)
Explanation:
Control - few employees indicates limited
segregation of duties, which is a control
weakness.
37
other special risks. Significant risks are those that
require special audit consideration.
63. Identify which is not an example of audit risk?
(a) Intangibles may be overstated due to
development costs not meeting the relevant
criteria of IAS 38 Intangibles
(b) There is a tight reporting deadline which
may mean there is material misstatements
due to a higher number of estimates
included in the financial statements
(c) Disclosures of going concern issues may
not be adequate
(d) The company may not be compliant with
relevant laws and regulations (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Compliance with laws and regulations is a
business risk. The audit risk would be potential
unrecorded liabilities as a result of non-
compliance.
64. Identify which actions could the auditor take to
reduce audit risk?
I. Increase sample sizes
II. Reduce control risk
III. Assign more experienced staff to the
engagement team
(a) I only
(b) I and III (correct)
(c) II only
(d) II and III
38
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The auditor cannot affect control risk or inherent
risk. The auditor can reduce audit risk by
manipulating detection risk. Increasing sample
sizes and assigning more experienced staff to the
audit will both reduce detection risk and therefore
audit risk.
Explanation:
39
materiality level or levels for particular classes of
transactions, account balances or disclosures.
66. The external auditor of Karachi Co. has set a
planning materiality threshold of PKR 40,000 and
a performance materiality of PKR 30,000. The
audit testing approach to the following financial
statement items is being considered:
I. Ali, a director of Karachi Co., owes PKR
1,000 to the company (borrowed during the
year).
II. Sundry income of PKR 35,000
41
(a) Materiality at Financial statement level is Rs.
8,000,000 while Performance materiality is
Rs. 4,000,000 (correct)
(b) Materiality at Financial statement level is Rs.
8,000,000 while Rs. 4,000,000 is not the
performance materiality
(c) There is no need to compute a materiality
which is below Rs. 8,000,000
(d) ISA does not require computing
performance materiality in listed companies
Answer (a)
Explanation:
Option (a) is correct because performance
materiality refers to the amount or amounts set by
the auditor at less than the materiality level or
levels for particular classes of transactions,
account balances or disclosures i.e. performance
materiality Rs. 4,000,000 is less than the
materiality level of Rs. 8,000,000.
70. Is the following statement true or false?
“ACCA recommends that working papers should
be retained for a minimum period of five years“
(a) True
(b) False (correct)
Answer (b)
Explanation:
ACCA recommends a minimum retention period of
seven years.
42
71. Which of the following includes risk assessment
procedures?
(a) Test of details
(b) Analytical procedures (correct)
(c) Test of controls
(d) All of the above
Answer (b)
Explanation:
Analytical procedures can be used at all stages of
the audit. ISA 315 requires their use during the
risk assessment stage of the audit.
72. Point out which one is not a test of control?
(a) Inspection of a title deed for the name of the
client to confirm rights and obligations
(correct)
(b) Inspection of capital expenditure forms for
evidence that three quotations have been
obtained to ensure the best price is paid
(c) Inspection of the reconciliation of the non-
current asset register with the physical
assets to confirm the reconciliation has been
performed on a regular basis
(d) Inspection of non-current assets for
evidence of asset tags/barcodes that can be
used to trace assets
Answer (a)
Explanation:
43
(a) is a substantive procedure as it is testing one
of the financial statement assertions. Test of
control is performed to verify that a control is in
place and working effectively. Evidence of
reconciliations being performed, quotations being
received and asset tagging are all tests of
controls.
Explanation:
45
(c) 35 (correct)
(d) 44
Answer (c)
Explanation:
Receivables days are calculated as
(receivables/revenue) x 365.
(121,000/1,267,000) x 365 = 35 days
46
(a) The auditor is responsible for obtaining
reasonable assurance that the financial
statements are free from material
misstatement whether caused by fraud or
error. (correct)
(b) The auditor is responsible for the prevention
and detection of fraud and error.
(c) The auditor is not responsible for the
prevention of fraud and error but is
responsible for detection.
(d) The auditor is responsible for detecting all
errors and should attempt to detect fraud
where information comes to light as a result
of standard audit procedures.
Answer (a)
Explanation:
The directors are ultimately responsible for the
prevention and detection of fraud and error. The
auditor needs to obtain reasonable assurance that
the financial statements are not materially
misstated.
78. The auditor of Woodland Co. is facing a legal
claim for negligence that the manager alleged a
fraud at one of the smallest of the company's 80
branches. According to rotational testing approach
the auditor not visited that branch for three years;
as a result the fraud had gone undetected for two
years. What is the auditor's best defense against
the claim?
(a) An up-to-date letter of engagement which
points out to the directors that the audit
47
should not be relied upon to detect all frauds
which may exist
(b) Audit documentation shows that the audit
was carried out in accordance with
International Standards on Auditing (correct)
(c) Written representations from management
or other documentary evidence from the
directors in which they acknowledge primary
responsibility for the prevention and
detection of fraud
(d) Case law judgments which indicate that an
auditor should not be held responsible for
ingeniously laid frauds
Answer (b)
Explanation:
(b) is the best answer because it is a "positive"
rather than "negative" defense.
(b) is a better defense than just (a) or (c) since
both (a) and (c) (together) would be encompassed
by (b). (a) denial of responsibility (d) is not as good
as having evidence to show that the audit was
properly conducted.
48
(d) Profit before tax (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
Profit before tax is the most suitable bench mark
for determining the materiality for a listed
company.
80. Audit risk is best describes by?
(a) The risk profits will decrease as a result of
intense competition in the market
(b) The risk a customer cannot pay their debts
(c) The risk the company's reputation may be
damaged by a product recall
(d) The risk a provision has not been
recognized resulting in understatement of
liabilities (correct)
Answer (d)
Explanation:
(a), (b) and (c) are all business risks. An audit risk
must be either a detection risk or a risk of material
misstatement in the Financial Statement.
81. Identify which option is not included in the
agreement obtained by the auditor?
(a) Management's responsibility to provide the
auditor with all information relevant to the
preparation of the financial statements
(b) Management's responsibility to prevent and
detect fraud (correct)
(c) Management's responsibility for preparing
the financial statements
49
(d) Management's responsibility for internal
control to enable the preparation of financial
statements which are free from material
misstatement
Answer (b)
Explanation:
Although the directors are responsible for the
prevention and detection of fraud this is not one of
the matters included in the agreement obtained by
the auditors to establish that the preconditions of
an audit exist in accordance with ISA 210
Agreeing the terms of audit engagements.
50
83. An auditor has discovered a PKR 100,000 wages
fraud by a director of a listed company. The
amount is not material and that fraud does not
constitute money laundering. To whom does the
auditor have a primary duty to report this matter
to?
(a) The company's shareholders
(b) Those charged with governance (correct)
(c) The tax authorities
Answer (b)
Explanation:
The auditor has a primary duty to report the fraud
to those charged with governance. As the
company is a listed company, this would initially
be to the audit committee as the fraud was carried
out by a director. It would only be reported in the
audit report if it affected the true and fair view.
84. In respect of audit risk which explanation is valid?
(a) Higher receivables days indicate a risk of
understatement of receivables
(b) Higher gross profit margin indicates either
overstatement or revenue or
understatement of cost of sales (correct)
(c) Higher payables days indicate a risk of
understatement of payables
(d) Higher inventory days indicate that cost of
sales may be overstated
Answer (b)
Explanation:
51
Higher receivables days indicate overstatement or
receivables. Higher payables days would indicate
overstatement of payables or would be used to
assess the need for going concern disclosure due
to cash flow issues. Higher inventory days would
indicate overvaluation of closing inventory which
would decrease cost of sales and therefore lead to
understatement of cost of sales.
54