Soil Pollution Management in Poland
Soil Pollution Management in Poland
Introduction
Within the last decade Polish agriculture has undergone deep changes in terms of
economical, social and environmental aspects. Over forty years of socialism resulted in an
created that exhibited various types of degradation resulting from industrial activity and
mismanagement of soil and water resources. It is important to emphasize that soil pollution
with heavy metals and residues of organic compounds is localized. On the other hand the
characterize the status of soil degradation and pollution. This paper will address general
Present and Outlook for Agricultural Production in Poland Relative to the EU Situation
The transition from a centrally planned economy to a market economy striving to join the
European Union brought a number of challenges for rural communities and the agricultural
but the impact of agriculture on the country’s economy is much stronger than reflected by
statistical data (Wos et al., 1998; GUS, 1998b) This is associated with the fact that the
agriculture and other activities in rural areas provide income and subsistence for nearly 30%
of the Polish population. The area of agricultural land in Poland is 18.5 million hectares
which is 14% of all agricultural land in the European Union. The number of operating farms
in Poland is equal to 26% of all farms in the EU (Krzyżanowska 1998). The share of arable
land and orchards compared to the overall total agricultural land in Poland is much higher
than in EU countries, while grasslands are half the EU average. Employment in Polish
agriculture is equal to 50% of total employment in the EU’s agriculture sector. This indicates
that labor efficiency in Polish agriculture is quite poor. There are two million farms operating
in Poland which means that employment in the agricultural sector per hundred hectares is 3 to
4 times higher than in the EU (Wos et al., 1998). At the same time land productivity is twice
as small due to the sandy texture of sixty percent of soils, the poor water retention, and high
acidity. Poor quality of agricultural land, along with a smaller area of agricultural land per
capita than the EU, means that the productive area, adjusted for soil quality, is much less than
the EU average. Land productivity is twice as large in the EU than in Poland. Average
yields commonly produced in the EU are only possible on experimental farms or large
agriculture eliminated subsidies for mineral fertilizers causing a dramatic decrease in their use
(Table 1). In the years 1975-1988 the average rate of NPK per hectare of agricultural land
came to 180 kg while currently this rate does not exceed 90kg (GUS 1998a). The use of
pesticides dropped almost three fold in spite of the fact that before the transition it was several
times smaller than in the EU (Table 1). The current use of fertilizers and pesticides does not
pose any great environmental threat, however there is some environmental risk associated
with improper use of chemicals in agriculture as farmers sometimes over apply chemicals and
demonstrates significant potential. This potential is not used for several reasons. The first
reason is that employees are working on small farms because other job opportunities are
limited. This slows down the rate of innovation and technological development as production
is still very labor intensive. Another reason of low land productivity is lack of capital and
cash flow needed for proper farm operation (Krasowicz et al., 1996). Credits and loans are
available but most farmers are reluctant to taking loans due to fear of going in debt. The
dropped from 70% to 40%. These factors combined caused limited competitiveness and
production. Seventy percent of cattle production is grown on farms with less than ten animals,
while in the EU such herds represent only 5.4% of cattle production (Krasowicz et al. 1996).
The average number of pigs on a farm is eight animals while in EU countries it is seven times
higher. The intensity and structure of agriculture production varies depending on the region.
In northern and western Poland, production is more intensive due to better management
practices and larger farms, the average being 16 hectares as compared to 4 hectares in
southern Poland.
Another trend is the elimination of smaller producers from the market and transition of
their land to stronger farms with growth potential. It is estimated that only 30% of currently
operating farms will be able to compete and adapt to the European market conditions after
Poland’s accession to the European Union (Wos et al., 1998). Poland does not use any
instruments of agriculture policy used in the EU. The extent of state protection of agricultural
production is much smaller in Poland than in the EU. Average farms in Poland are
multifunctional and unspecialized in any particular production type. Even though the soil
quality, climate and infrastructure are not optimal, there is significant potential for yield
adequately promoted abroad. The slow development of exporting food products to the
European Union is the reason for the trade deficit in the food sector. In the years 1992-1997,
Polish exports of food products was only 55% of the value of imported food products (Wos et
al., 1998). The conditions of Polish agriculture described determine the status of agriculture
Expert analysis predicting future trends for agriculture production in Poland indicate the
prospects of development are poor. In the short term, before accession to the EU, there will
be temporary barriers limiting access to European markets. The local demand for food
products will grow slowly, not exceeding 1% per annum, while the quality expectations of the
consumers will grow steadily. In the next 10-15 years it is doubtful the demand will increase
production until the year 2010 will depend on the following factors: the area of agricultural
land will be 17 million hectares, population will be from 40-41 million people, food
consumption will be similar to other Western European countries, consumption will be more
quality oriented, while agricultural policy will be environmentally oriented, Poland will be
self sufficient in food production, employment in agriculture will decrease, significant areas
of cropland will be converted to other functions such as parks, wildlife reserves and timber
(Krasowicz et al., 1996). Predicted changes in animal production for the year 2010 can be
seen in Table 2. Table 3 summarizes current and predicted crop production for the year 2010
based on the assumption that the technology will improve and significant areas of
agricultural land will be set aside. This estimate is provisional and cannot account for the
impact of economic factors and policy changes in the EU. It is assumed that yields produced
There is hard data identifying problem areas with soils polluted with heavy metals,
hydrocarbons, sulfur and other toxic compounds. A typical example of such a polluted area is
the Silesia region of Poland. Some soils in this region are contaminated with metals as a
consequence of long term emissions of metal dust from smelters, either directly from stack
emissions or indirectly as a fugitive dust blowing from smelter waste piles. Economical
transition to a market economy and new environmental laws forced the smelting industry to
close the majority of old installations which were environmental hazards. This greatly
reduced the direct emissions from smelting processes, however the indirect threat from the
remaining waste piles remain. These sites require extensive rehabilitation and remediation
The total concentrations of heavy metals (Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb, Zn) and sulfate sulfur were
analyzed in over 45 000 soil and plant samples collected from the arable land of Poland in the
years 1991-1997 (Terelak et al., 1996). The degree of soil polluted with metals and sulfur
was classified according to a system that consisted of 6 classes. These classes depended on
total metal content, soil pH, organic matter content, and soil texture. These properties are
known to control metal mobilization/immobilization and transfer to the food chain, (Kabata-
Pendias, 1993). Digital maps with scale of 1:500 000 demonstrating the degree of soil
range from 0.2 to 1.05 mg kg-1 of soil, depending on the geological origin of the parent
material, texture, intensity of weathering processes, organic matter and other factors. Studies
by different authors indicated, however, that background cadmium is usually not higher than
0,5 mg kg-1 of soil (Adriano 1992; Kabata-Pendias & Kabata, 1993; Dudka et al.,1994).
Our recent study, based on analyses of 45 000 samples, has indicated that cadmium in soils
of Poland ranges from 0.01 to 49.73 mg kg-1 of soil. The expected range, however, derived by
provides a more realistic characterization of soil metals in a given area. It is evident that
average cadmium concentration and its variability in agricultural soils of Poland is not
substantially different than that of soils from other countries (Kabata-Pendias & Pendias,
1993). The highest concentrations of cadmium were found in southern Poland, particularly in
however, it can also be explained by composition and geological origin of parent rock
material, often containing metal ore outcrops. Importance of parent rock material properties
as a factor controlling cadmium level in soils is reflected in data from other studies conducted
in Czestochowa and Bielsko Biala Provinces, where high cadmium concentrations were found
in many soils that were not exposed to emissions from industry or to land disposal of high
cadmium waste (Terelak et al., 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997). As indicated before, there is
and mining region, is significantly higher than values typically found in other areas of
Poland.
Spatial and geostatistical analyses of our data provide strong evidence that as much as
88.2% of agricultural land in Poland is not contaminated with cadmium and contains only
background amounts of this element (0o). It should be emphasized that even in Silesia, 41.3%
of soils are not contaminated with cadmium, according to our rather conservative evaluation
criteria (Kabata-Pendias et al., 1993) (Table 4). It is important for Silesia that the majority of
soils (70.4%) are either not polluted (0o) or contain only slightly elevated (Io) levels of
cadmium. We recommend that such soils be used for production of most crops, however
growing vegetables should be limited. Slightly polluted soils (IIo) represent 1.2% of
agricultural land in Poland, Silesia contributes 12.6% (Table 4). Significant food chain
cadmium risk is related to higher degrees of soil contamination (IIIo-Vo). This element is
limited to small areas in Poland (0.6%), however in regions such as Silesia, these soils can
In general, cadmium in soils of Poland does not pose a particular environmental risk as far
as food quality is concerned, except the heavily industrialized regions such as Silesia.
The average concentration of copper in soils of Poland is 6.6 mg kg-1 of soil, which is
similar to background levels reported for other countries (Kabata-Pendias & Pendias, 1993).
According to our studies copper in soils ranges from 0.2 to 293.3 mg kg-1 of soil (Table 4).
Soil contamination with copper poses certain risk only in areas with copper mining and
concentration in soils is 11.2 mg kg-1 of soil, which is much below the upper limit of the
expected range for the whole country (Table 4). Over 97% of agricultural land in Poland is
characterized by natural (0o) concentrations of copper, and even in the Silesia region, 96% of
(Table 4), elevated levels of copper were found in 2.2% of Polish soils (Io), mainly located in
the copper mining area within Legnica Province. On a national basis, the percentage of soils
conclude, that copper is not a factor of concern, which could limit agricultural production,
except small areas affected by copper industry and soils formed on a parent rock material
0.1-328 mg kg-1 of soil. It is accepted that a value of 100 mg kg-1 of soil is the maximum
permissible level (Kabata-Pendias & Pendias, 1993). It is important that the upper level of
expected range for nickel (15.4 mg kg-1) throughout the country do not exceed the threshold
value. In the Silesia region the average concentration of soil nickel (13.3 mg kg-1 of soil) is
also well below the threshold values. We have established that 94.7% of agricultural land in
Poland is characterized by a natural content of nickel (0o) (Table 4). In Silesia, only 87% of
soils belong to this category. Larger areas of soils with elevated nickel levels in Silesia is
very likely associated with the use of nickel in smelting and galvanizing processes. Slight
pollution with nickel is present sporadically in Silesia and other regions, however, it does not
exceed 0.4% of the total agricultural land in Poland (Table 4). The latest data shows that soils
with a higher contamination of nickel (IIIo-Vo) are few. From our findings it can be
concluded that nickel distribution in soils of Poland do not significantly affect agricultural
The average concentration of lead in agricultural soils of Poland is 13.8 mg kg-1 of soil with
a range of 0.1-1722 mg kg-1 of soil (Table 4). Extreme values reported were found in a
number of locations in Silesia associated with lead and zinc mining. In average soil lead in
this region (50.9 mg kg-1 of soil) is three times higher than what is found throughout the
country. The expected range for lead in all soils studied (7.6-25 mg kg-1 of soil) is remarkably
more narrow than the observed range (0.1-1722 mg kg-1 of soil) which indicates that
extremely high concentrations of lead are not very common. Over 97% of agricultural soils in
Poland exhibits natural content (0o) of lead (Table 4). In the Silesia region, soils not
contaminated with lead total 61.6% of agricultural land. Areas of soils containing elevated
levels of lead (Io) are 2.3% of the total farm land, while, in the Silesia region, such soils
occupy 21.6% of the agricultural land. Only a small proportion of the agricultural land in
Poland (0.3%) is classified as slightly polluted (IIo) with lead. In Silesia, however, 8.4% of
soils is slightly polluted. Soils representing medium pollution with lead (IIIo) appear locally in
southern Poland, particularly in Silesia, where 8.2% of land is polluted to this degree (Table
4). Higher degrees of pollution with lead are of little importance, except some locations in
Silesia.
The average concentration of zinc in agricultural soils of Poland is 32.7 mg kg-1 with an
observed range of 0.5-2837 mg kg-1 of soil (Table 4). The expected range (16.6-64.6 mg kg
-1
of soils), however, is significantly different than the observed one which indicates that
extreme values are not common throughout the country. Nevertheless, the upper limit of the
expected range is significantly higher than the value considered as the natural background (40
mg kg-1 of soil) (Kabata-Pendias & Kabata, 1993). The average concentrations above the
natural background are usually found in southern Poland. This can be explained by zinc
emission by the smelter industry located in Silesia. The origin of parent rock material plays
also an important role, particularly in areas which are not directly exposed to industrial
pollution. The total area of farm land characterized by natural content of zinc (0o) is 88%. The
elevated concentrations of zinc (Io) are found in 10.6% of soils. Environmental and food chain
risk caused by elevated levels of zinc in soils becomes an open question since zinc deficiency
in diet may be a problem in certain areas. Moreover zinc seem to play an important role in
controlling the cadmium uptake in cadmium contaminated soils, whenever the ratio Zn:Cd is
The Silesia region (wojewodztwo katowickie) has the largest areas of zinc contaminated
soils, however even within this polluted region, soils not contaminated (0o) with zinc occupy
41.3%. The area of soils with natural and elevated levels of zinc in Silesia is as high as 74%,
however. Therefore in the Silesia region, zinc is a factor seriously potentially affecting the
have the most comprehensive data: Poland as the representative of Central Europe and the
UK as representative for Western Europe. PAHs emission data from both countries were
compared. Poland’s agricultural soils were evaluated on the basis of the results of the Polish
Arable Soils Monitoring Program carried out in the Institute of Soil Science and Plant
Cultivation in Pulawy. English soils, mainly grazing areas, were evaluated using work by
Cousin et al. (1997) from Lancaster University, UK. Evaluation of the data indicates rather
uniform levels of PAHs in agricultural soils from both Central and West Europe (0.3 - 0.5
mg/kg) and point out the need for further international studies in this field. About 1/3 of the
arable lands in Poland contain PAHs at the level <200 µg/kg and nearly 90 % of these
territories - including the areas exposed to anthropogenic activity, at the level <1000 µg/kg.
Less than 2 % of the samples represent areas with PAH content above the German
precautionary value of 3000 µg/kg (Soil background and reference values in Germany, 1995).
Elevated content of PAHs occurs mainly in soils from the areas with strong anthropogenic
stress (e.g. near petrochemical refineries in Plock and in Gdansk, steelworks in Nowa Huta, or
former Russian military basis near Zielona Góra). Soils with the higher PAHs content were
concentrated also in the highly industrialized Silesia region and within the influence of
Soil and water polluted with pesticides is localized in storage and disposal areas and
does not occur on regular agricultural land since the application rates used are very small
(Table 1). There may be some cases of pesticid excessive use in horticulture and vegetable
production, however the high cost of chemicals effectively controls this risk. Studies by
Dwornikiewcz (1997) conducted on farms growing chops which require more extensive use
of pesticides, did not show any significant evidence of pesticide accumulation in soil or
pesticides. It is estimated that there is 35 000 tones of stored pesticides kept. There are over
343 registered storage facilities for non-used chemicals of which 93 are soil pits. Many
facilities are not well protected and sealed, and there are evidences of chemicals movement to
the surrounding environment (Giza et al. 1999). Identification of such sites is needed to
Soil contamination with petrochemicals occurs around oil refineries, gas stations, pumping
stations, and pipelines. According to GIOS data (from Sliwka et al. 1999), 40% of 191
petrochemicals. It is estimated that 0.1-0.25% of oil products used enters the environment.
There are extensive areas of former soviet military bases with underground storage tanks
containing large amounts of fuels. The overall former use of such sites lead to contamination
of soil and ground water with fuel residues. It should be emphasized that the total area of land
contaminated by military bases comes to no more than few thousands hectares (Kamienski et
al., 1994). Moreover, the majority of this land is not used for agricultural production.
It is well established that soils react to pollution factors depending on the chemical
character of polluting agent, soil physical, chemical and biological properties as well as soil
system. Two sources of metal pollution can be identified: a) geogenic associated with
Large amounts of metals present in some parent rock materials in Silesia which are associated
with carbonate zinc and lead ore outcrops are relatively strongly bound by soil matrix, while
metals from industrial emissions are more mobile and accumulate in crops or move to the
ground water (Piotrowska and Dudka 1997). Soil pH, organic matter, soil mineralogy (clay
processes. Lowering soil pH will increase solubility and activity of metals in soil, promoting
Organic matter can effectively absorb metals through the formation of metal chelates
(Kabata-Pendias & Kabata, 1993). Metals can also be immobilized by reaction with minerals
such as phosphates, carbonates and others. Preliminary data demonstrate that soil
amendment with sewage sludge promotes metal sorption in soil which is associated with
sludge organic matter binding capacity (Kukla et al., 1999). A proposal was recently
biosolids. We do not know if this is going to be funded, however the concept addresses
important aspects of soil vulnerability to pollution with metals and nutrients originating from
sewage sludge and metal waste. This project expects to achieve safer management of sewage
sludge used to reclaim industrial sites and in agriculture. This is addressed by applying
models to determine and monitor environmental impacts associated with the use of sewage
sludges in agriculture and reclamation. A key objective is to determine which sludge and soil
novel sludge use, for remediation and revegetation of contaminated soils and industrial sites,
as a technique to prevent and/or reduce the risk of pollution from contaminated sites.
metal content in soils, texture, pH, CEC, total organic carbon and nitrogen, hydraulic
properties of soil profiles and land cover. These soil properties are considered to control the
movement of metals and other pollutants within soil-groundwater environment. Climatic data
will be collected from archives. All data will be standardized to a similar format to assure
valid comparisons between regions. These soil data will be used in models to demonstrate the
spatial variability of nitrogen, phosphorus and heavy metals behavior and movement in sludge
amended systems. Identification of industrial sites (metal and mine waste dumps) will be
conducted, with the help of aerial photographs, to find potential sites for reclamation with
sewage sludge. Case studies will be conducted by taking measurements of various toxic
wastes deposited in Silesia, Poland. A special emphasis will be put on reducing the risk of
environmental pollution through erosion and leaching of soluble metals from waste piles.
activity plays the most important role regulating soil response to such pollutants. Other
properties such as pH, soil moisture, redox conditions, availability of nutrients, organic matter
content and quality, and C:N ratio may also have direct or indirect impact on behavior and
role of soil physical and chemical properties in controlling the bio-degradation of PAHs.
Content of organic matter and properties of clay surfaces directly contribute to
sorption of organic compounds limiting their toxicity and risk for the ground water pollution
(Sadowski, 1996).
There is very little data available on degradation of pesticides as affected by different soil
properties and environmental conditions in Poland, however, before soil pollution with
pesticides is not a problem for regular agricultural land and is limited to areas of their storage
and disposal. Studies by Sadowski (1996) showed that application of herbicides causes their
accumulation in 0-20 soil upper horizon. There was no residue of atrazine, simazine, linuron
detected in deeper layers, however these compounds were present in water leaching through
the soil profile. The intensity of leaching and accumulation was mainly controlled by soil
persistence depends on the properties of these compounds and to a smaller degree on the
properties of the soil. Regression equations enabling the assessment of the range and rate of
PAHs disappearance from soils were developed based on data from incubation studies. The
influence of soil properties on PAHs sorption and decomposition was quite evident in the
initial period, shortly after soil was contaminated with PAHs. There was a significant
correlation observed between the rate of PAHs disappearance from soil, soil acidity, clay and
Regarding soil vulnerability related to pollution from excessive use of fertilizers, it should
be noted that the current average application rate of NPK does not exceed 90 kg ha-1 (Table
1). This data shows the potential environmental impacts are minimal. Since the beginning of
the nineties, large areas of agricultural soils demonstrate negative nutrient balance leading to
degradation of soil fertility (Fotyma, 1998). Moreover, 60% of Polish soils exhibit different
degrees of acidity which inhibits nitrification process. This results in relatively high share of
ammonium nitrogen in the mineral pool (20-50%) (Fotyma & Fotyma, 1999) slowing down
Factors influencing soil response to pollutants have been characterized in the previous
paragraph. However it is worth mentioning that existing soil databases provide georeferenced
information on soil properties such as soil pH, soil texture, organic matter content and can be
used for modeling purposes and to demonstrate pollutants behavior under changing
soil samples collected from agricultural land (Terelak et al., 1997). Pedotransfer functions
can be used to predict the behavior of different pollutants in changing soil environments.
changes in soil properties, can be used for modeling. It seems that changes in soil pH, which
are associated with leaching of base actions form soils, have a strong impact on pollutant fate
in soil environment. In metal contaminated areas, increased acid rainfall resulted in observed
changes in soil pH and will lead to mobilization of metals (Marchwinska et al., 1998).
factors will have an impact on activity of soil enzymes involved in biodegradation of different
Mineralization of soil organic matter can adversely affect the ability of soils to absorb and
immobilize organic contaminants. Possible changes in organic matter content will affect
biological activity which can result in decreasing soil potential for bio-degradation of organic
transformations and behavior of different pollutants as affected by soil physical, chemical and
biological properties.
Impact of soil pollution on crop production, environment, and socio-economic
conditions in Poland
In some reports the soils of Poland are characterized as strongly polluted [Glinski & Turski,
1990; Komitet Nauk. PAN 1993). Such opinions were often developed by using data typical
for heavily polluted industrial regions for general characterization of all arable land in Poland.
For example, according to the UNEP/ISRIC map, published in 1990 to demonstrate the status
of human induced degradation of soils of the world, the area of Poland was shown as strongly
degraded. This caused serious economic and social consequences associated with the
reduction of agricultural products export from Poland to foreign markets. This phenomenon
of exaggerating existing problems was quite widespread throughout Central and Eastern
Europe.
cultivated areas and the amount of food produced, however there may be a dietary risk
through consuming food grown in this area. This is particularly true with vegetables grown in
private gardens. There are also soils in this region that have a naturally high background
content of heavy metals associated with parent rock material which must be taken into
consideration.
Relatively low metal contents of soils in most of Poland reflect in a low average
concentrations in crop plants of the whole country (Table 5). The Cd contents of carrots,
diets. Recently Cd concentration in carrots was surveyed in several other European countries,
and data reveal a much higher Cd contents than in carrots grown in Poland (Kabata-Pendias &
whereas it is negligible for other metals (Table 6). There is about three times more Cd in
wheat and rye grains from the industrial regions than agricultural areas, and almost five times
more Cd in carrots. Crop plants grown in industrial areas have more Cu and Zn by a factor of
about 1.2. Contents of Ni and Pb do not differ significantly. This data indicates Cd is the main
pollutant and seriously affects crop quality in the industrial Silesia region.
Studies on the transfer of Cd, Zn, and Pb from soils to plants show that not only the form in
which metals entered the soil environment but also the physiological properties of crop species
Piotrowska, 1998). The results of this investigation confirmed an easy uptake of Cd by plants.
The variation in metal forms affect their availability to plants (Table). The addition of Cd and
Zn sulfates greatly increase the exchangeable forms of these metals, but not Pb. The response
of plants to increased exchangeable forms of Cd and Zn was manifested mainly by corn plants,
with a very small effect on the Pb concentration. Regardless of the source, Cd was the most
intensively absorbed metal. Trace metal concentrations in plants grown on the most polluted
soil with Zn-Pb smelter dust showed potato tubers most likely to accumulate both Cd and Pb,
especially in intact tubers (well washed). This observation is supported by the results of other
As yet, there is no systematic approach to predict the future trend of soil pollution using
quantitative terms. Most studies focus on evaluation of the current status of soil degradation.
Most commonly, evaluation and prediction of soil pollution and soil vulnerability is based on
the descriptive approach, using relationship between pollution loads and changes of soil
properties as they affect the environment. Pedotransfer functions hold certain promises to
predict soil pollution and degradation development. This approach allows using data from
studies assessing responses of representative soil types to pollution. Spatial variability of soil
responses to pollution is identified using pedotransfer functions and georeferenced soil
databases. This integrated informational system combining soil databases with pollution
parameters is being developed at IUNG (Zaliwski 1999). More work is needed to develop or
adopt valid models predicting interactions of various pollutants with soil under different
environmental conditions.
various pollutants decreases as the industrial activity declines. Increased pollution prevention
regulations will play an important role in development of future pollution and soil
vulnerability trends. However, it is difficult to include the legal framework as an input into
models.
Predicting the future pollution trends should recognize the fact that the measures
water systems and technologies designed to minimize waste production have contributed to a
general reduction of air, water and soil contamination. However, these measures have not
completely eliminated the impact of toxic waste piles on the environment. Water and wind
erosion, which are present in varying degrees of intensity depending on local conditions in
Silesia, lead to movement of toxic elements from dump sites to the biosphere. The most
troubling risks which come from stockpiling smelter waste ooccur when dump sites are
located in or near urban areas. These sites have a significant effect on nearby populations, and
unfortunately this is frequently the case in Upper Silesia. According to data supplied by the
Katowice Regional Statistics Department, the total area of smelter sites which require
reclamation comes to approximately 300 hectares (WUS, 1998). Recently we have tested the
potential of using aerial photographs and digital terrain models to monitor and predict the
movement of pollutants from smelter waste in Silesia Poland. These sites are known to
It is important to emphasize that there is a certain risk for mobilization of heavy metals in
soils associated with their acidification. The emissions of SO2 and the severity of acid rains
have been decreasing in Poland (GUS, 1998c), however soil acidification is a natural process
occurring in humid zones at the rate depending on soil texture, soil saturation with bases,
weather conditions and management practices such as using mineral fertilizers and lime for
pH control. Existing databases were used to predict the extent of metal mobilization and
transfer to the food chain as affected by changes in soil pH and to identify areas of particular
risk. Identification of such areas is crucial since the use of lime has dramatically decreased in
In 1997 (SOVEUR), a project for the assessment of soil vulnerability for thirteen Central
and Eastern European Countries (CEEC) was established by ISRIC Wageningen, with the
support of FAO (Batjes & Bridges, 1997). The objective of this project is to model and
predict future development and environmental impacts of soil pollution with metals organic
contaminants nitrogen and phosphorus. The concept is based on the chemical time bomb
approach. Various models are used to reflect cycles and movement of pollutants, and predict
spatial dimension of environmental hazards. The input data, including soil and terrain
information and pollutants loads represent a standardized format allowing for valid regional
The potential of neural computing for predicting the movement of metals within the
soil-plant system has been studied by Stuczynski et al. (1997). This study shows that neural
Poland’s methods for analysis of soil pollution are similar to those used in other European
countries. During the last decade ISO methods were adopted and implemented for soil
analysis, particularly in soil monitoring programs (Terelak et al., 1998). Sampling and
analytical protocols were developed to ensure the accuracy of the monitoring. For the state
soil monitoring program, soil profiles of 150 cm depth were dug to evaluate vertical
Recently, clay dispersion of soil aggregates collected from different soil types, land
uses, and management systems was measured to evaluate stability of aggregates (Dexter &
Czyz, 1998). This data will be used to evaluate spatial variability of soil stability as affected
by management practices, land use etc. Pedotransfer will be used for modeling purposes.
The assessment of soil quality, based on the content of heavy metals, has been a broad
national program for industrialized areas. One of the most urgent problems is sewage sludge
disposal. Thus current research is focused on determining the suitability of sludges for the
Soil protection and remediation is of vital importance for both the environment and
agriculture. This is especially pronounced in densely populated and/or industrial areas where
special strategies are undertaken for the reclamation of degraded soils. One treatment
technique is related to the application of sludges to arable soils as well as for the remediation
of contaminated soils. This last field has recently received more attention in Poland. An
example of a case study of using sewage sludge for reclamation of contaminated land is
research involving the Institute of Ecology of Industrial Areas (IETU), Florida State
University (FSU), and Phytotech Inc., USA (Kucharski et al., 1998). The main objective of
this project was to implement phytoremediation at a full scale and to document the cost, and
efficiency of this technology. The tested technology was originally used for lead removal
from polluted soils. As the soils in Katowice region are highly contaminated with various
elements, it was important to make other elements extractable and available for
phytoextraction process. A one acre plot was used in this study which was located in
industrial part of the Katowice District, close to a derelict lead and zinc smelter. The
phytoextraction plan included the following phases: site identification, site characterization,
treatability study, selection of soil amendments to enhance metal mobility, toxicity test, seed
bed preparation, application of amendments , planting, crop protection, harvest and disposal.
(Swinarski et al., 1998). Undisturbed samples of sandy soil polluted with coal tar were
bioremediated by forced aeration with periodical water flushing in nutrient amended system.
The length of the treatment period was 700 days. The rate of pollutant degradation process
was evaluated by online CO2 and O2 monitoring and effluent analyses. The effects of
temperature, nutrients availability and ozonation on degradation rates were studied. After the
first 50 days, the biological activity decreased and was strongly related to the temperature.
Degradation rates increased by a factor between 2.2 and 2.5 per each 10° C of temperature
increase up to the maximum at 38- 40° C. Use of pure oxygen instead of air and amendment
with nutrients did not enhance the rate of the degradation process. Lipophilic organics were
their initial concentration, was observed. Low molecular weight PAHs with 2-3 rings shifted
to low solubility compounds of 4-6 rings. PAHs concentrations in soil eluates ranged from 6
to 44 mg L-1 after 700 days of bioremediation as compared to a minimum of approximately
500 mg L-1 in eluates of untreated soil samples. Relative toxicity of soil eluates measured as
Poland. Environment Protection and Management Law is the most important act regulating all
aspects of using and protecting natural resources (Dz. U. 1994 r Nr 49, poz. 196). There is a
specific act regulating protection of agricultural and forest soils (Dz. U. 1995 Nr 16, poz. 78
and changes in: Dz. U. 1997, Nr 60 poz. 370 and Nr 80, poz. 505). The soil protection act
regulates all aspects of responsibility for protection and rehabilitation of soils. Three groups
of issues are regulated: rules creating a formal background for soil protection, reclamation
and rehabilitation of degraded soils, and improving quality of agricultural and forest soils.
These regulations established the layout for the National Land Conservation Fund. Resources
for this fund are generated through payments for converting agricultural land into industrial or
urban uses. The resources are used to support land conservation programs which are
Entities responsible for soil pollution and degradation must compensate farmers for
their production loss caused by industrial activity. In cases of extreme degradation, industry
Guidelines were developed for the classification of soils contaminated with trace metals to
facilitate appropriate land protection and land use (Kabata-Pendias et al., 1993). In spite of
elaborate monitoring programs, the net impact on the soil environment by a large amount of
trace metals is not yet fully predictable. Therefore, surveys of background levels and soil
contamination with metals have been carried out. Varying standards have been proposed for
classifying soils contaminated with metals and for the corresponding land use. These values
are usually established based on ecological risk assessment and safety for metal exposure to
farmers using scientific information and guidelines about how to change the crop structure
into industrial crops or other uses such as biomass production for fuel. Such strategies are
planned for polluted regions to protect the food chain against heavy metals transfer.
Unfortunately, there is minimal financial resources to initiate and support the implementation
stage.
There is increasing interest in developing strategies for the appropriate use of soil
resources. This has prompted policy makers and researchers, as well as legislators to initiate
projects evaluating the quality of soils and crops, particularly, those associated with heavy
metals, sulfur and organic contaminants such as PAHs. With this in mind, the Ministry of
(OSCHR) to conduct measurements of heavy metals and sulfur in soils and crops. The
obtained data was compiled and interpreted by the Institute of Soils Science and Plant
In 1995, in addition to this extensive survey, IUNG was contracted by the Ministry of the
arable soils (Terelak et al., 1998). This program has become an integral part of the State
Environment Monitoring System. This soil monitoring project evaluates the time course of
arable soils properties changes as measured at 216 monitoring sites. The results are used to
evaluate the extent of changes of the environmental quality of soils farming practices,
A mineral nitrogen monitoring program was established in 1997 (Fotyma and Fotyma
1999) to collect soil samples from 5000 soil profiles located throughout Poland. The program
evaluates the distribution of nitrogen forms in the spring and fall. Three years of data are now
available showing mineral nitrogen content in soils of different origin and management.
Mining and smelting in Upper Silesia have a long tradition going back to medieval times.
In the 13th century, silver and lead smelters were established near Bytom and Tarnowskie
Gory, and the mining and processing of zinc and lead ores has continued to date.
Unfortunately, the non-ferrous industry has many adverse ecological effects associated with
emissions of metallic dust. The reclamation of smelter waste sites, currently being carried out
within the framework of the Silesia Project, is a joint effort of local government, industry, and
Agency (EPA), the Center for Research and Control of the Environment (OBIKS), Virginia
Polytechnic Institute and IUNG. The main objective of the Silesia Project is to develop
guidelines on all aspects of sludge use for the reclamation of degraded lands and waste sites.
shutdown site of a Huta Warynski smelting plant. The revegetation of such wastes is a
challenging task for reasons of phytotoxicity. Since there was a lack of data concerning this
subject, a number of field and pot experiments were conducted. The field experiments were
designed to evaluate the impact of sludge and lime application rates on vegetation. In pot
experiments a number grass species have been tested for their adaptation to harsh
environmental conditions. The objective was to select the best performing species on the
The two hectare pilot area covered with two different metal waste was treated with sewage
sludge and lime. Prior to treatment this site was barren of vegetation. Sludge application at
the rate of 300 dry tons per hectare combined with the incorporation of lime, in an oxide and
carbonate form at the rate of up to 1 1/2 tons and 30 tons per hectare, ensured successful
revegetation.
The large spatial variability of properties responsible for phytotoxicity controls the spatial
the reclamation work must be preplanned with a detailed grid-based spatial analysis of basic
waste chemical properties. This allows a site-specific treatment of the most problematic areas
with specially-designed rates of biosolids and lime as well as appropriate grass mixes.
Though the toxicity of the waste land was very high, the treatment used allowed the
establishment of ground cover over more than 80 percent of the area tested. This shows that
the adaptation capabilities of selected species were considerable. At the same time, when
tested on Doerschel waste the same approach failed miserably because of high concentrations
The interpolation of waste properties overlaid with graphs of biomass performance enabled
the study to identify and quantify factors responsible for phytotoxicity. It was assumed that
areas with at least 80 percent of ground cover did not exhibit toxicity to plants even though
the total metals, the water extractable metals and the salinity were quite high (Figure 1).
The Welz plots were covered by vegetation which consisted predominantly of grasses. A
number of the twenty grass cultivars which were tested in pot experiments seemed to be
useful for revegetation purposes and demonstrated different degrees of adaptation to chemical
stress (Stuczynski et al., in press). The results allow us to propose a mixture of the most
acid/salt-tolerant species. Such a selection of cultivars may be needed for different types of
waste. This demonstration project was followed by the industry and implemented into a large
Extensive reclamation work was conducted in Jeziorko, Grzybow and Lubaczow which is
an area affected by Europe’s largest sulfur strip mining operation (Lekan, 1980). Emission of
elemental sulfur dust is the main degradation factor leading to strong soil acidification as
reflected in pH ranging from 1.5 to 2.5. Extensive monitoring of soil pH was conducted on
over 6000 hectares of surrounding agricultural land. Lime application rates were calculated
based on the exchangeable acidity and the content of elemental sulfur in soils. Amounts of
lime required for neutralization of degraded soils came up to 100 tones per hectare in most
affected areas, the average rate however was 60 tones per hectare. Incorporation of lime into
the upper soil layers is an important part of the reclamation technology. Lime treatment
Bioremediation of soil contaminated with fuel residues was conducted at the former soviet
military base in Kluczewo (Lebkowska et al., 1997). Contaminated soil was piled and
days of the process 95% reduction of total hydrocarbons was achieved. The amount of
References
Stuczynski T., Daniels W., Pistelok F., Chaney R., Siebielec G. (in press): Application of Sludges for
Remediation of Contaminated Soil Environment. In: W: J. Wilson, B .Maliszewska-
Kordybach (Eds). "Soil quality in relation to sustainable development of agriculture and
environmental security in Central and Eastern Europe". NATO Scientific Series. Kluwer
Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London. Special NATO Series, Kluwer, Amsterdam.
Swinarski J. (1998) Boremediation of coal tar-contaminated large soil samples in long term
experiments Fourth International Symposium and Exhibition on Environmental
Contamination in Central and Eastern [Link] September 1998. Symposium
Proceedings.
Sztompka E.(1995): Biodegradacja paliwa Diesla w glebie. III Sympozjum Naukowo-Techniczne nt.
„Biotechnologia Środowiskowa”. Ustroń-Jaszowiec, 6-8 grudnia 1995 r. Politechnika Śląska
w Gliwicach.
Terelak H., Piotrowska M., Motowicka-Terelak T., Stuczyński T., Budzyńska K., Pietruch Cz.,
Sroczyński W. (1994) Właściwości chemiczne gleb oraz zawartość metali ciężkich i siarki w
glebach i roślinach. Ekspertyza wykonana dla MRiGŻ. Maszynopis powielony IUNG
Puławy.
Terelak H., Piotrowska M., Motowicka-Terelak T., Stuczyński T., Maliszewska-Kordybach B.(1995)
Budzyńska K., Pietruch Cz.: Ocena stanu ekologicznego rolniczej przestrzeni produkcyjnej
województwa częstochowskiego. Ekspertyza wykonana na zlecenie ODR w Częstochowie z/s
w Potoku. Maszynopis powielony.
Terelak H., Piotrowska M., Motowicka-Terelak T., Stuczyński T., Maliszewska-Kordybach B.,
Budzyńska K., Pietruch (1996) Chemical properties and heavy metals and sulfur in soils and
plants. IUNG, Pulawy, (Report in Polish).
Terelak H., Stuczynski T., Piotrowska M. (1997) Heavy Metals in Agricultural Soils in Poland. Pol. J.
Soil Sci., XXX/2, 35-42.
Terelak H., Stuczyński T., Motowicka-Terelak T (1998). Monitoring of arable soil properties in
Poland. Protection and recultivation of the Odra-Basin areas. The situation after overlow 1997.
The I International Conference, Zielona Góra, 15-16.09.1998.
Wos A. (1998) Rolnictwo polskie w okresie transformacji systemowej (1989-1997). IERiGŻ
Warszawa.
World Map on Status of Human - Induced Soil Degradation. (1990) UNEP/ISRiC, Wageningen.
WUS (1998). Environmental Protection Katowice Voivodship.
Zaliwski A. (1999) Raport ze stanu realizacji grantu zamawianego nt: Zintegrowany System
Informacji o Rolniczej Przestrzeni Produkcyjnej.
.
Table 1. Use of mineral fertilizers and pesticides in Poland
Active ingredient (kg ha-1) 1,23 1,09 0,68 0,53 0,52 0,47 0,50 0,50
GUS data (1998a)
Table 4. Soil pollution with heavy metals in Poland
Metal Area Geom. Range Percentage of agricultural land exhibiting different degrees of metal
mean mg/kg pollution
mg/kg observed expected 0o Io IIo IIIo IVo Vo 0o-Io IIo-Vo
Cd Silesia 1.06 0.10-49.73 0.37-3.06 41.3 29.1 12.6 8.6 5.5 2.9 70.4 29.6
Poland 0.22 0.01-49.73 0.1-0.48 88.2 10.0 1.2 0.3 0.2 0.1 98.2 1.8
Cu Silesia 11.2 1.0-66.5 6.6-19.0 96.0 3.8 0.2 0 0 0 99.8 0.2
Poland 6.6 0.2-293.3 3.2-13.5 97.5 2.2 0.2 0 0.1 0 99.7 0.3
Ni Silesia 13.3 0.5-80.5 6.8-26.1 87.0 12.6 0.4 0 0 0 99.6 0.4
Poland 6.4 0.1-328.3 2.6-15.4 94.7 4.9 0.4 0 0 0 99.6 0.4
Pb Silesia 50.9 10.0-1722.7 23.1-112.2 61.6 21.6 8.4 8.2 0.2 0 83.2 16.8
Poland 13.8 0.1-1722.7 7.6-25.0 97.2 2.3 0.3 0.2 0 0 99.5 0.5
Zn Silesia 116.2 5.0-2837.5 45.9-294.3 41.3 32.7 18.5 6.8 0.7 0 74.0 26.0
Poland 32.7 0.5-2837.5 16.6-64.6 88.0 10.6 1.2 0.2 0 0 98.6 1.4
Table 5. Trace metals in some crop plants, geometric mean (mg kg-1 air dried matter)
Plant Cd Zn Pb Cu Ni
a
Cereal grain (6 500) 0.06 33.3 0.23 0.44 3.74
b
Potato tubers (5 680) 0.11 19.9 0.33 0.61 4.46
Grass (3,760) 0.12 31.6 0.89 0.84 5.51
a
In parentheses number of samples collected in the period 1992/96 (Terelak et al. 1996).
b
Unpeeled tubers
Crop Regiona Cd Cu Ni Pb Zn
Carrots- roots NE 0.13 3.71 0.97 1.05 27.85
SW 0.62 4.65 0.66 0.79 29.93
Potato – tubersb NE 0.10 3.09 0.57 0.64 18.77
SW 0.22 5.03 0.42 0.28 21.49
Rye – grain NE 0.06 3.52 0.43 0.25 31.81
SW 0.17 4.28 0.41 0.22 40.42
Wheat - grain NE 0.06 3.52 0.43 0.25 31.81
SW 0.17 4.28 0.41 0.22 40.42
a
NE - north-eastern agricultural region, SW - south-western industrial region
b
Unpeeled tubers
Table 7. Chemical properties of waste material sampled before (1994) and after (1995)
amendment with sewage sludge and lime
Waste Sampling Soluble Soluble Soluble pH EC
material time zinc cadmium lead
mg kg-1 mg kg-1 mg kg-1
Welz Before 343 17.6 1.8 7.0 7.3
After 279 17.7 1.1 7.2 3.5
Doerschel Before 1670 108 5.4 5.8 16
After 983 57.4 2.9 6.0 9.0
values reported reflect averages of 80 samples of each material
EC
Biomass mS/cm
t/ha
no vegetation 0.4 - 1.4
0.0 - 0.5 1.4 - 2.4
0.5 - 1.1 2.4 - 3.4
1.1 - 1.7 3.4 - 4.4
1.7 - 2.3 4.4 - 5.4
2.3 - 2.9 5.4 - 6.4
6.4 - 7.4
vegetation boundaries
0 10 20
meters
Table 2. Predicted animal production (in thousands of tons)
Figure captions