Social Psychology: Conformity Insights
Social Psychology: Conformity Insights
Paper 1
Specification point Notes Homework Extra Qs
Definition of conformity:
Types of Conformity
1.)_______________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
_
2.)_______________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
_
3.)_______________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
_
Questions
Identify which type of conformity is being shown for each statement:
1.) Matt has been revising for his History exam. Just before he goes in, three of his friends tell him he has
learnt the wrong date for something. In the exam he writes the date they told him instead of the one he
had learnt from his notes.
Answer: ____________________
2.) Claudia wants to be a cheerleader. She starts to wear her hair in a pony-tail like they all do and she trains
every morning, she also starts to speak like the other cheerleaders and to hang out where they do. When
she starts her exams, she decides that cheerleading isn’t actually that important and she stops it all.
Answer: ____________________
3.) Jack doesn’t like the taste of alcohol. When he is hanging out with a new group of
friends they pass a bottle of vodka round and he takes a swig even though he still
thinks it is disgusting.
Answer: ____________________
Identification Anticonformity
The desire to be right. We conform
by looking at others whom we
believe to be correct, to give us
information about how to behave,
Compliance Conformity particularly in novel or ambiguous
situations.
Evaluation
Use page 17 of your illuminate book to complete the evaluation table
Normative Social Influence
Research Support…..
✓
Individual differences……
🗴
Individual differences…….
🗴
Select the two phrases that describe internalisation. Tick two boxes only.
C
The beliefs of the group become part of the
individual’s own belief system.
D
The individual goes along with the group but
does not agree with them.
E
The individual changes his / her beliefs, but it
is a temporary change.
(Total 2 marks)
b.) Andrea has recently started a new job and on her first day at work she noticed
that all her colleagues were much more smartly dressed than she was.
3.) Jan and Norah have just finished their first year at university where they lived in a house with six other
students. All the other students were very health conscious and ate only organic food. Jan had listened to their
point of view and now she also eats only organic food. Norah was happy to eat organic food while in the house,
but when she went home for the holidays she ate whatever her mother cooked. Both girls conformed, but for
different reasons.
Table
Results
Fill in the gaps activity:
Evaluation
Lesson 3 – Asch variations
Variations on Asch Experiment:
Unanimity –
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Supports:
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Task difficulty–
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Supports:
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Size of majority
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Supports:
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
PEEL 4 (Extension)
1.) (a) Outline one method that psychologists have used to study conformity.
(2)
(b) Explain one limitation of this method.
(2)
(c) Suggest an appropriate way of overcoming this limitation.
(2)
(Total 6 marks)
2.) (a) One type of conformity is compliance. What do psychologists mean by the term
compliance?
(1)
(b) A group of students has to decide what to do with the money left over in their
school fund. Most of them want to give the money to a local charity. However, two
students, Lisa and Sean, want to buy a pool table for the common room.
Briefly explain how two factors might affect whether or not Lisa and Sean will
conform to the rest of the group.
(4)
(Total 5 marks)
______________explanation of behaviour:
Presumes people will act in a way that they think is required by their social
role – what is normal/expected in different situations (i.e. they will conform to the role they have been
assigned)
Evaluation Continued
Stron
g
evide Evidence B: In the
nce BBC study,
prisoners were
for
given the possibility
of ‘promotion’ after
Evidence D: The 3 days from the
male participants prisoners group to
in the SPE were the guards group.
Evidence E:
psychologically As a result, the
Over the first
and physically prisoners offered no
few days of the
screened and the challenge to the
SPE, the
24 most ‘normal’ guards in the first
guards grew
and ‘stable’ were few days.
Evidence G:
Haslam (2012)
suggests that
Zimbardo gave his
guards a general
sense of how he
expected them to
behave. This
suggests that the
‘behavioural scripts
Evidence A: Even associated with the
when the roles’ were not the
participants in the sole source of
SPE were unaware guidance.
that they were being Evidence C: In
watched, their Abu Ghraib, a
behaviour still military prison in
conformed to their Evidence F: Banu
Iraq, the Iraqi
‘guard’ or ‘prisoner’ and Movahedi (19
prisoners were
role. One prisoner presented some o
abused and
even asked for details of the SPE
tortured by
‘parole’ rather than experimental
American soldiers.
asking to withdraw procedure to a lar
Situational factors
from the study. sample of student
such as lack of
who had never he
training, boredom,
Stron of the study. The v
and a lack of
g majority of the
accountability
evide students guessed
were present in
the purpose of the
nce both Abu Ghraib
Extra practice – Exam
again
questions and the SPE.
study was to show
ordinary people
st
assigned the role
1.) Outline the procedures and findings of Zimbardo's research into conformity to prisoner or guard
would act like a
social roles.
prisoner or guard.
(Total 4 marks)
2.) Which two of the following statements about Zimbardo's prison study are
correct?
(Total 2 marks)
Identify and briefly discuss two reasons why people have criticised Zimbardo’s
prison study.
(Total 6 marks)
Conformity or Obedience?
Anne agrees to try snails to avoid upsetting her French exchange partner.
_______________________
Wilf runs round the pitch as his coach told him to.
_______________________
The recruit remade his bed following a ‘request’ from the sergeant.
_______________________
The car driver pulled over to allow an ambulance through after three others did the
same.
_______________________
Flora arrived at the new yoga class and took off her shoes having noted that everyone
else was barefoot. _______________________
Evaluation:
Homework– Exam questions
1.) Some psychologists criticise Milgram’s research into obedience to authority, in
terms of both methodological issues and ethical issues.
(Total 6 marks)
3.) Describe two ethical issues that can be illustrated by Milgram’s research into obedience to authority.
(Total 4 marks)
Lesson 6 – Milgram (Obedience) Variations
Variations of Milgram
Original experiment
Experimenter in lab coat ‘called away’ and a ‘ordinary member of the public’ in
everyday clothes takes his place
Variation 1:
Variation 2:
Variation 3:
Extra practice – Exam questions
4.) Identify two factors that have been shown to affect obedience to authority.
Briefly discuss how each of these factors affects obedience to authority.
(Total 6 marks)
2.) The following results are percentages of participants who gave the maximum shock,
in variations of Milgram’s experiment into obedience to authority.
Condition % Participants
obeying
Agentic state
When we blame the person giving the order for any negative consequences of our
actions, becoming an ‘________’ of theirs.
The opposite of this is being in an ___________________ (we feel a sense of responsibility
for our own actions). The shift from autonomy to agency is known as the
‘__________________’.
The person remains in the agentic state because of ‘____________________’ which are
aspects of the situation which allow the person to ignore or minimise the damaging
effect of their behaviour and thus reduce the ‘moral strain’ they are feeling e.g. blame
the victim
Legitimacy of authority
We are more likely to obey people whom we see to have accepted __________ over us.
Society is __________________ and we are taught to and accept that some people have
power over us and we should hand control of our behaviour over to them.
The authority someone has is justified by the individual’s position of power within the
social hierarchy.
Activity:
Evaluation of Agentic state:
Evaluation of legitimacy of authority
(b) Briefly evaluate one of the explanations that you have outlined in your
answer.
(3)
(Total 9 marks)
2.) Some research into obedience has been carried out in laboratories. Other
studies into obedience have been carried out in the real world, including field
experiments and observations.
3.) When you are a passenger on a train, you are much more likely to move to
another seat if the ticket collector tells you to move than if another passenger tells
you to do so.
4.) Discuss at least two explanations for defiance of authority. Refer to evidence in
your answer.
(Total 16 marks)
2.)
3.)
4.)
5.)
6.)
Complete the brain storm of aspects of parenting that Adorno believed led to the
authoritarian personality:
Strict discipline
Activity:
Circle the characteristics from the authoritarian personality:
Forgiveness
Respect Conventional Superstition
attitudes
Empathy Inflexible
Love
Submissiveness
Apply it:
Evaluation:
Cut and stick evaluation points to form full PEEL paragraphs:
Read and mark the following example answer:
Milgram’s research required people to give electric shocks to
another person. He told his participants that this was a test of
learning on memory and that they were the teacher and the
other person was the learner, although he was actually a
confederate of Milgram’s. Every time the learner got a
question wrong they were told to give them an electric shock
by the experimenter. These shocks increased by 15 volts each
time, going up to 450 volts. This research found that 65% of
participants went to 450 volts and all went to at least 300
volts.
Milgram believed that it was the situation that people find
themselves in which determines whether they obey or not.
When Milgram moved his experiment from Yale university to a
run-down office block, the obedience rate dropped from 65%
to 45%.
Whether the experimenter wore a uniform had a much larger
impact on the level of obedience shown. Bushman’s research
had a female researcher dressed either as a beggar, a
business executive or in a police style uniform asking people to
give a confederate some money for a parking meter. When she
was in uniform 72% of people obeyed compared to 48% when
dressed as a business executive.
The main criticism of Milgram’s research is that it has many
ethical issues, including deception and no real right to
withdraw. Participants were deceived about the true nature of
the study, believing it to be an experiment about learning.
Also, while the participants were given the right to withdraw
the prods from the experimenter telling them to continue
made it more difficult for them to exercise this right.
Extra practice – Exam questions
1.) Milgram’s work into obedience provided us with valuable insights into why people obey, even though it was
carried out in a laboratory.
2.) Briefly outline and evaluate the authoritarian personality as an explanation of obedience to authority.
(Total 4 marks)
3.) (a) Briefly discuss the Authoritarian Personality as an explanation for obedience to authority.
(4)
(b) Apart from personality type, outline one psychological explanation for defiance of authority.
(2)
(Total 6 marks)
4.) Outline and evaluate one or more explanations of why people obey.
(Total 12 marks)
Lesson 10 – Resisting Social Influence – Locus of control
1.) ___________________________________________
2.) ___________________________________________
Why bother?
I can sometimes determine my
future, it might depend on the
I am in control
I make things happen situation
Holland (1967)
Study overview: How does this support locus of control Picture to help
as a way of resisting social influence? you remember!
Twenge et al (2004)
Study overview: How does this challenge locus of control Picture to help
as a way of resisting social influence? you remember!
Extra Evaluation:
(iii) George did not put his name forward as the class representative. Use your
knowledge of social influence research to explain this.
(4)
(b) Which one of the three students is most likely to resist pressures to conform?
Use your knowledge of psychology to explain your choice.
(4)
(Total 8 marks)
Social Support:
How can social support help people to resist conformity? (Hint: use Asch variations)
How can social support help people to resist obedience? (Hint: use Milgram variations)
2. What about social support – is asking people if they have social support the best
way of measuring it? What might be a weakness of this method?
3. Do you think that this study demonstrates the power of social support to resist
social influences to smoke? Explain your answer.
4. What other factors might be more important in giving up smoking than social
support?
2.)
3.)
Sticking to an argument.
Synchronic consistency – agreement between people in the minority
group ‘they’re all saying the same thing’ Commitment
Diachronic consistency – agreement over time ‘they’ve been saying the same
thing for some time now’
Being extremely consistent can be seen as being rigid. If minority members can
adapt their point of view and accept reasonable and valid counter-arguments they Flexibility
are more successful
When minorities engage in extreme activities which are at some risk to them,
majority group members pay more attention – the augmentation principle Consistency
Consistancy
Commitment
Flexibility
Artificial tasks 🗴
2.) Read the item and then answer the question that follows.
Use your knowledge of conformity and minority influence to explain the factors
that will determine how successful the small group of students will be.
(Total 7 marks)
3.) Mike and his grandfather were having a conversation about recycling. Mike explained
that he always puts empty cans and plastic bottles in one box and newspapers and
cardboard in another box and that his mum takes these to be recycled once a week.
His grandfather said that when he was Mike’s age, people did not recycle. Mike said that
everyone in his street recycles and that they have a big box at school especially for
recycling.
Using what you know about minority influence, explain how this change might have
occurred.
(Total 6 marks)
Lesson 14 – The role of social influence in social change
I am the desire to be
Match up the key terms!
right
Milgram
Asch I found young people are
Moscovici more external, but people
Normative social are also less obedient
influence I am how
Zimbardo personality can
Internalisation affect obedience
Dispositional (authoritarian
explanation personality) I am one of the
Agentic state situational factors in
Proximity obedience where the
Location position of the
Twenge et al authority figure and
Compliance I am the desire to be liked
‘victim’ is important
Informational social
influence
Rotter
Nemeth I conducted the
Identification Stanford prison I conducted a study where
Augmentation principle study participants had to guess
Holland the colour of slides
Anticonformity
I am when a person
conforms publicly and I am when people
privately because they conform publicly but
I am when people pay value membership of the maintain their own
attention to those who group. Depends on view privately
have put themselves at presence of group
risk for their cause
__________________________________________________________________________________________
5.) Snowball effect
__________________________________________________________________________________________
6.) Social cryptomnesia
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Practice question:
Read the item and then answer the question that follows.
With reference to the article above, explain how social influence leads to social change.
(Total 6 marks
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Evaluation
Write a paragraph outlining how effective minority influence is in bringing about social change. Make sure you include
the key ideas from the box!
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
2.) Social influence research helps us to understand how it is possible to change people’s behaviour: for
example, understanding how to persuade people to eat more healthily.
With reference to this example of social change, explain how psychology might affect the economy.
(Total 4 marks)
3.) A small environmental group wants to encourage people to use public transport or bicycles instead of using
their cars.
Using your knowledge of the role of minority influence in social change, what advice would you give the
environmental group?
(Total 6 marks)
4.) Explain how social influence research helps us to understand social change.
(Total 6 marks)