Contract of guarantee

Unit 2
 Content

Unit-II Contract of Distinction between Indemnity and Guarantee, Kinds

Guarantee of Guarantee, Rights of Surety, Liability of
6 hours Surety, and Discharge of Surety.
 Introduction
• The term "guarantee" is defined by the Black Laws Dictionary as "the certainty that a
legal contract will be duly enforced.“
• A guarantee contract is regulated by Indian Contract Act, 1872, and comprises of 3
parties, including one who serves as the guarantor if the defendant fails to meet his
obligations.
• Eg: Whenever a party seeks a loan, products, or employment, a guarantee contract is
usually required.
• In such arrangements, the guarantor promises the creditor that the person in
need can be trusted and that in the event of a default, he will accept
responsibility for payment.
 Parties to contract
• Surety: A surety could be a person giving a guarantee during a contract of guarantee.
Someone who takes responsibility for paying cash performs any duty for one more
person just in case that person fails to perform such work.

• Principal Debtor: A principal mortal could be a person for whom the guarantee is
given during a contract of guarantee.

• Creditor: The person to whom the guarantee is given is referred to as a creditor.

He is the lender of cash or service.
 Requirements of Contract of Guarantee-
• It must be agreed upon by all three parties - All the three parties to the
transaction that are the principal debtor, creditor, and surety, must consent with
each other's approval.
• Accountability - A surety's liability is secondary under a guarantee arrangement.
This tells that the primary contract was between the creditor and the principal
debtor. The surety is solely responsible for repayment if the principal debtor
defaults.
• Assume the presence of a debt - The fundamental purpose of a guarantee
contract is to ensure the payment of the major debtor's obligation. if there is no
such debt. As a result, in circumstances where the debt is time-barred or void,
the surety has no duty.

• It must include all of the fundamental elements of a legitimate contract as the

guarantee contract is an agreement, it must meet all of the standards as a legal
contract.

• No False Information - Any circumstances that may affect the surety's

obligation must be disclosed by the creditor to the surety. The confidence
gained through the concealment of such knowledge is invalid.
• There will be no misrepresentation - This is to be noted that the guarantee
shouldn't be acquired by misrepresenting the facts to the surety. It does not
require the primary debtor even while it is not a contract of ultimate good
faith.
 Types of Guarantee-
• Specific Guarantee
A specific guarantee (also called a particular guarantee) is given for a single transaction or
specific debt. Once that particular transaction is completed or the debt is repaid, the guarantee
automatically comes to an end.
Example:
Mr. A guarantees to the bank that he will repay a ₹50,000 loan taken by Mr. B. Once Mr. B
repays the ₹50,000, Mr. A’s guarantee ends. It does not apply to any future loans taken by Mr. B.
Continuing Guarantee
• According to the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a continuing guarantee is a
guarantee that extends to a series of transactions. It remains valid until it is
revoked by the guarantor. This means that the surety’s responsibility covers all
ongoing and future dealings between the creditor and the debtor, not just the first
one.
• Example:
Mr. A guarantees repayment to a bank for any loans that Mr. B may take from time
to time, up to ₹5,00,000. This means Mr. A’s guarantee applies to all loans Mr. B
takes within that limit until Mr. A revokes the guarantee.
 Contract of Indemnity

• A Contract of Indemnity means a promise to compensate someone for any loss or damage suffered due
to the conduct of the promisor (the person giving the indemnity) or someone else.
• A contract of indemnity is like a safety shield—one person promises to protect another from financial loss
due to certain acts.
Parties in a Contract of Indemnity
• Indemnifier – The person who promises to compensate for the loss.
• Indemnified (or Indemnity Holder) – The person whose loss is to be compensated.

Eg:An insurance contract is the most common example of indemnity.

If you insure your car against accidents, the insurance company (indemnifier) promises to compensate
you (indemnified) if the car gets damaged in an accident.
 Guarantee Vs Indemnity
Number of Parties
• Contract of Guarantee: Involves three parties—the creditor, the principal
debtor, and the guarantor. The guarantor promises to pay the creditor if the
principal debtor defaults.
• Example: A person (guarantor) guarantees a bank loan taken by a friend (debtor). If
the friend fails to repay, the guarantor must pay.
• Contract of Indemnity: Involves two parties—the indemnifier and the
indemnified. The indemnifier promises to compensate the indemnified for a loss
caused by the indemnifier or a third party.
• Example: An insurance company (indemnifier) compensates the insured
(indemnified) for losses due to theft or fire.
Nature of Liability
• Contract of Guarantee: The guarantor's liability is secondary and
arises only when the principal debtor fails to fulfill their obligations.
• Example: If a student (debtor) defaults on a study loan, the parent (guarantor) is
held liable.
• Contract of Indemnity: The indemnifier's liability is primary and arises
as soon as the indemnified suffers a loss.
• Example: If a ship carrying goods sinks, the insurance company
compensates the exporter immediately under the marine insurance policy.
Purpose
• Contract of Guarantee: Designed to provide security to the creditor for
recovering their dues.
• Example: A landlord asks a guarantor to secure rent payments if the tenant
defaults.
• Contract of Indemnity: Designed to compensate for losses or
damages suffered by the indemnified.
• Example: A construction company purchases an indemnity bond from an
insurer to cover damages caused during construction.
Rights Against Other Parties
• Contract of Guarantee: The guarantor, after paying the creditor, can recover the
amount from the principal debtor.
• Example: If the guarantor settles a friend’s loan, the guarantor can demand repayment
from the friend.
• Contract of Indemnity: The indemnifier has no rights against third parties but
may seek subrogation if explicitly stated in the agreement.
• Example: If an insurance company pays for stolen goods, they may claim the recovered
goods if found later.
 Rights of the Surety
1. Rights Against the Principal Debtor.
a. Right of Subrogation
After the surety pays the debtor’s loan or obligation, the surety gets all the
rights that the creditor had.
This means the surety can now recover the money directly from the
principal debtor, just like the creditor could.

b. Right to Indemnity
The surety can ask the principal debtor to repay all the money the surety
has paid on their behalf.
• Reimburse the Surety
2. Rights Against the Creditor
a. Right to Securities
• If the creditor holds any security from the principal debtor, the surety
is entitled to claim the benefit of that security once the debt is paid
off.
• This right exists even if the surety was unaware of the existence of
such security.
c. Right to Discharge

• Variation in the Contract: If the terms of the original contract

between the creditor and the principal debtor are altered without
the surety's consent.
• Release of Principal Debtor: If the creditor releases the principal
debtor from their liability, the surety is also discharged.
• Loss of Security: If the creditor loses or negligently deals with the
securities held, the surety’s liability is reduced to the extent of the
loss.
3. Rights Against Co-sureties

a. Right to Contribution
• If a surety has paid more than their share of the debt, they are
entitled to recover the excess from the co-sureties in proportion to
their respective liabilities.
• This is based on the principle of equitable contribution.
b. Sharing of Securities
• If one surety has the benefit of security provided by the principal
debtor, they must share it with the co-sureties. (If one surety has a
security, must be shared with everyone)
 Discharge of a Surety (Sec.130 – 141)

• A surety is discharged from his liability on:

1. The death of a surety as regards future transactions in case of a continuing
guarantee in the absence of a contract to the contrary.
2. Notice of revocation as regards future transactions in case of a continuing
guarantee.
3. Any variation in the contract terms between the principal debtor and the
creditor without surety’s consent.
4. If the creditor releases the principal debtor, the surety also automatically
discharges.
5. Any act or omission to do an act by the creditor that harms the surety’s rights,
impairs the eventual remedy of the surety himself against the principal debtor,
discharges the surety.
6. Where the creditor loses or parts with any security which he receives from the
principal debtor without the consent of the surety, this discharges the surety to
the extent of the value of such security.
Done with Unit 2 ☺

• Lets read !

[Link]
/document/474659590/
contract-of-indemnity-an
d-guarantee-case-laws
 Banking and Loans
Insurance
Construction and Real
Instructions to Students Estate
• Each group must select one business sector from the list:- Logistics and
Transportation
• Identify minimum two real-world examples from your chosen Retail and E-commerce
sector where: Automobile Dealerships
• A Contract of Guarantee is used (e.g., bank loan guarantees, performance
guarantees).
• A Contract of Indemnity is used (e.g., insurance policies, indemnity bonds).
• Explain:
• Parties involved (Creditor, Principal Debtor, Surety OR
Indemnifier/Indemnified)
• Purpose of the contract
• Key terms/risks
• Why Guarantee or Indemnity is preferred in this scenario