Understanding Ethics and Morality Differences
Understanding Ethics and Morality Differences
behaviour, choices and actions. The word ‘ethics’ comes from the original
Greek term ethikos, meaning ‘arising from habit’. ‘Ethics’ presupposes that
there is a certain set of mannerisms and behaviours that are ‘right’ and must
be followed.
Further, as a subject, Ethics is the philosophical treatise that studies human
behaviour and tries to determine what is right or wrong behaviour. It is a
discipline based on logical justification of human action.
It is closely related to ‘Morality’ and is also called Moral Philosophy.
Morality
Morality comes from the Latin word ‘mores’ which means, ‘ways of behaviour’
or ‘human character’. Morality refers to the set of beliefs that guides an
individual to distinguish right from wrong.
Morality assumes that there is a spontaneous awareness of a distinction
between ‘right’ and ‘wrong’, i.e. there is something intuitively telling us what is
right and wrong. It is generally based on our conscience. If someone says that
“I feel from my heart, this is right”, this person is guided by a personal sense of
morality.
Ethics Morality
Origin of Greek term Ethikos, which The Latin word ‘mores’ means, ‘ways
term means ‘arising from habit’. of behaviour’ or ‘human character’.
“…we know that as knowledge comes, a person grows, morality is evolved, and the idea
of non-separateness begins. Whether men understand it or not, they are impelled by that
power behind them to become unselfish. That is the foundation of morality.”
Essence of Ethics
Essence is the intrinsic quality of something that determines its character.
The Essence of ethics can be charaterised as follows:
1. It is both relative as well as Universal
Ethics is relative are determined in a social setting at a given point in time.
A society’s history, culture, values etc. determine ethical standards, which
may vary from society to society. For example in medieval India practice of
Sati was perceived to be ethical as society legitimised it where it was unethical
practice.
However it applies to the all members of the society, and everyone generally
agrees upon what is right and what is wrong. It is therefore universal. For
example, everyone agrees that we must not steal.
2. It is Subjective as well as objective
Ethics is not an objective universal concept. Its understanding varies from
time to time, from person to person, society to society. Ethics
are subjective in nature are they are affected by an individual’s emotions and
perceptions.
But it is also objective: Ethics preach a certain kind of behaviour to us. It
tells us how people should behave. In fact, laws and rules are formed when
ethics is codified. Even as social norms, ethics is objective.
3. Originates from the idea of Justice
Ethics originate from the sense of justice prevailing in a particular society.
Ethical conduct implies treating a person equally with dignity.
Ethical values are interrelated to each other. For example – honesty,
truthfulness, integrity; values of equality and justice cannot exist without
tolerance etc. All these stem from the same idea of justice.
4. It is abstract as well as real
Ethics are abstract as it is a system of thoughts and judgments and all
thoughts are abstract in the sense that they are “of ” or “about” an object; they
are not the object itself.
But it applies to the real world, and is therefore real.
5. Applies at Various Levels:
Ethics operates at different levels individual, organization, socio-cultural,
political and international. Ethics at each level affect each other. For example,
a leader who is ethical in their personal life is more likely to act ethically in
their political life. Like Lal Bahadur Shastri was ethical in the individual and
political life.
Ethical standards may transcend the narrow stipulations of law and code
of regulations.
6. It is benefitial
Ethical behaviour leads to various benefits for an individual as well as the
society at large. Ethics leads to peace, harmony, respect, justice etc. For
example, Gandhi’s strong ethical and moral principles benefitted society as
well.
Determinant of Ethics
Determinants of ethics are the factors that affect and shape an individual’s
beliefs, values, and behaviours. These determinants are varied and complex,
often interlinked with each other to form the ethical framework that guides a
person’s decisions and actions. Understanding these determinants is crucial
for comprehending why people behave the way they do in moral and ethical
situations.
Some of the determinants of ethics are as follows:
Person: Ethical decision depends on the mental makeup of an individual. It
depends upon how the person has internalized personal attitudes and values
regarding ethical behaviour.
Place: It refers to the external environment, which includes family, school,
etc. For example, as kids, we were told by our parents and teachers not to
steal things. As we grow up we tend to carry such knowledge and apply it to
the real world. Similarly, work workplace teaches us the ethics of teamwork,
punctuality, responsibility, etc.
Time: Different individuals, societies and cultures have different sets of moral
codes at different times. It was once considered ethical to own a slave. But
today such a practice is unethical.
Object: It is unethical to lie despite any circumstances, purpose or
intention. Telling a truth to harm a person intentionally is also unethical as
the intention of telling a truth is not pure.
Circumstances: Circumstances also affect the person’s decision and it
determines whether it is ethical or not. Thus, the situation often makes
morality subjective. For example, Stealing is unethical in the first place but
when a poor person steals to feed her children, it reduces the unethicality
of the act.
Culture: Culture has a profound effect on shaping individual values. For
example, western culture surrounds individualism and Indian culture is based
on universalism.
Role Models/Celebrities/Famous Personalities: The leadership or role
models and celebrities of a society organization or nation also help to
determine whether the conduct of their followers or admirers is ethical.
God & Religion: Every religion and god advocate universal peace and ethical
practices. Religious textbooks teach how one should behave in a society and
how the society should be.
Conscience & Intuition: A person who follows his conscience & Intuition
feels that what is good is good because it is good and what is bad is bad
because it is bad. Intuition doesn’t need any justification while following its
actions. But conscience is justified based on his actions because of its moral
nature and it has reasoning and justification.
Family: Family is the first interaction where a child’s personality develops
since his birth. Today’s Children are tomorrow’s citizens. Therefore, its utmost
importance that the Family environment teaches what is ethically correct.
Classification of Ethics
Ethical theories can be classified as either teleological or deontological.
Teleological ethics/Consequential ethics:
Consequentialism is a theory that says whether something is good or bad
depends on its outcomes.
For example, most people would agree that lying is wrong. But if telling a lie
would help save a person’s life, consequentialism says it’s the right thing to
do.
Deontological ethics:
It judges the ethical behaviours of the person based on the principle. It
evaluates the morality of an action based on its inherent rightness or
wrongness, regardless of its consequences. For example, Gandhi ji
denounced the Violence in the Chauri-Chaura incident based on the principle
of non-violence.
We shall study about these in detail in the next chapter.
Levels Consequences
Meant to control and regulate behaviour Meant to guide and inspire behaviour
Public Life
Public life refers to the collection of a person’s relationships, interactions
and dealings with the society at large. Different values and ethical standards
are followed in public life.
Nolan Committee
One of the most comprehensive statements of what constitutes ethical
standards for holders of public office came from the Committee on
Standards in Public Life in the United Kingdom in 1994 to promote ethical
conduct in public office. It is popularly known as the Nolan
Committee worldwide.
It introduced the Seven Principles of Public Life—Selflessness, Integrity,
Objectivity, Accountability, Openness, Honesty, and Leadership—to ensure
transparency and accountability in governance:
Selflessness: Holders of public office should make decisions solely in terms
of public interest. They should not do so in order to gain financial or other
material benefits for themselves, their family or their friends.
Integrity: Holders of public office should not place themselves under any
financial or other obligation to outside individuals or organizations that might
influence them in the performance of their official duties.
Objectivity: In carrying out public business, including making public
appointments, awarding contracts or recommending individuals for rewards
and benefits, holders of public office should make choices on merit.
Accountability: Holders of public office are accountable for their decisions
and actions to the public and must submit themselves to whatever scrutiny is
appropriate to their office.
Openness: Holders of public office should be as open as possible about all
the decisions and actions they take. They should give reasons for their
decisions and restrict information only when the wider public interest clearly
demands.
Honesty: Holders of public office have a duty to declare any private interests
relating to their public duties and to take steps to resolve any conflicts arising
in a way that protects the public interest.
Leadership: Holders of public office should promote and support these
principles by leadership.
Private Life
Private life is integrated with family members, life partners, friends,
colleagues etc. These kinds of relationships are based on emotional
attachments, and personal bonding with them rather than simply a formal
mechanism.
Ethics in Private Life
Ethics in private life is shaped and affected by the following factors:
Family: Family is the first foundation where ethical values are seeded into
one’s own mind. If a family encourages and supports you in times of crisis
then you can take any hard decision, which is ethically correct.
In addition, the parent is the first friend and guide to a child. They teach
him not to be greedy, kind towards others, be empathetic. It will be helpful in
shaping a child’s intellectual ability and cognitive skills.
Friends: One famous quote says “Our friend circle tells our
character”. The role of friends plays in moulding one’s personality.
For Example – In Mahabharata, though Karna is individually moral and has
greater war skills than Arjuna his decision to fight along with Kauravas’s side
makes him unpopular which leads to his death in Kurukshetra. It’s just
because he promised his friend Duryodhana to help in the war.
Crisis of Conscience
When there is a difference between ethics in public and private life there is
a crisis of conscience or dissonance. For example, one civil servant may
have an opinion based on personal experience that women should not be
allowed in Sabarimala Temple. However, he has to follow the Supreme Court
verdict in allowing women. This may lead to a crisis of conscience.
A person might portray himself to be secular in public life but actually has a
negative attitude towards others’ religion. This creates a crisis of conscience.
Once an old lady brought his son to Gandhiji to preach to him stop eating sugar.
But didn’t say anything at that moment and asked that lady to come back after one
month.
During this gap, Gandhiji stopped eating sugar. After one month he was in a moral
position to ask that young boy to not eat sugar.
Temporary in nature in
the form of transfers,
Relations here permanent in nature
Nature of moving to a different
Relationship company
Ethics in Public
relationships is
generally based on
Ethics in private relations is based on
societal and personal
personal values, morality and family
norms. These are
values. These are generally not codified and
generally Codified in
are regulated by emotional bonding.
the form of a code of
ethics, norms, rules
and laws.
Openness, Honesty
and integrity, Respect,
Important Love and care, Confidentiality, Truthfulness,
Rule of law, Equality
Values Responsibility, Perseverance
and uniformity, and
Accountability.
Human values
Human values are values which are very core to the human/ for being
human or the inherent qualities which are desired to be called human
are human values.
Human values deals with values associated with human emotions and
feelings like given below:
63. Integrity
It means having strong moral principles/ value systems in one’s
conduct. It represents honesty, the character of uncorrupted virtues,
uprightness, something ‘whole’, not divisible or breakable &
consistency between what you say and what you do (thought and
action).
People with absolute integrity include Ajit Doval, JM Lyngdoh, TN
Seshan, Porijes Mishra.
Compassion
An emotional urge in a civil servant to serve the downtrodden sections
of society. Showing an act of positive discrimination. In general, it is
about showing respect, care, empathy & emotional support.
Compassion involves a sense of empathy. It does not end with pity. It
involves sensibilities to understand and even feel the pain of others
and motivates one to be truly helpful in overcoming this pain.
Empathy
It is like putting ourselves into other issues and thinking and feeling
the way they think. Thinking and feeling the way others think demands
a wider perspective or 360° thinking. Empathy demands compassion,
tolerance, emotional intelligence & objectivity or impartiality. A
prejudiced mind, stereotyping, patriarchal attitude, being feudal and
egotist are manifestations of lack of empathy.
Sympathy
Empathy
It is an urge which continues.
It is momentary in nature.
Example: Example:
Objectivity
Any decision based on facts, merit or observable phenomenon is said
to be objective. Any decision which has objectivity will have
connotations of impartiality, rationality, merit and facts. It is a
manifestation of scientific temper or rationality in decision making.
Rationality
Rationality is about the act of reasoning and logic based on objectivity
which has consistency in human behavior. Rationality can be on the
basis of statements based on facts or knowledge and is expressed in
an objective fashion which has justification. It’s a process which brings
us close to truth and therefore includes objectivity.
Conscience
Conscience is a human intellect/ faculty of sense which gives
understanding about right & wrong. It’s a moral sense in humans.
Humans are not born with the ability to logic, reason & understanding
good or bad things rather there is moral development through the
process of socialization. Therefore, conscience is also developed
through socialization as explained by Kant and Lawrence Kohlberg.
Collective conscience of society
It refers to the shared set of values, beliefs, norms, and moral
standards that are widely accepted and internalized by members of a
community or society. It represents the collective understanding of
what is considered right and wrong, acceptable and unacceptable
within a particular cultural or social context.
Tolerance
It is having a permissive or receptive attitude towards others’ beliefs,
feelings, views, values, caste, religion etc. Tolerance is respect,
acceptance, and appreciation of the rich diversity of our world’s
cultures, our forms of expression and ways of being human. It is
fostered by knowledge, openness, communication and freedom of
thought, conscience and belief. Tolerance is harmony in difference.
Attitude
Attitude is a learned/acquired predisposition to behave in a favorable
or unfavorable manner against the given object or It is about how
people react to different situations/objects hence attitude is reflected
through reaction or behavior. It is learnt through the process of
socialization. Its quality depends on the nature of socialization.