Pediatric Pain Management Knowledge in Nurses
Pediatric Pain Management Knowledge in Nurses
KARONGI , RWANDA
ID :23964
2023-2024
APPROVAL
I MUSANABERA YVETTE hereby approve and commend the diligent efforts of
UWIBAMBE NIWEBASA EMMANUELLA in conducting this research. The dedication and
meticulous approach demonstrated throughout reflect a commendable commitment to scholarly
inquiry.
MUSANABERA YVETTE
…………………………….
DECLARATION
knowledge and attitudes towards pediatric pain management among nurses at kibagabaga district
Hospital is my original work and that all the sources that I have used or quoted have been
acknowledge using complete references and also this work has not been submitted before for any
………………………….. …………………………….
I extend my sincere thanks to God for His guidance, and to my family for their unwavering
support. This work was achieved through the many people whom I would like to express my
appreciation. Special gratitude to my supervisor, MUSANABERA YVETTE, for invaluable
guidance, and to all contributors who played a crucial role in shaping this research. Grateful for
the collaborative spirit that enriched this journey
DEDICATION
Dedicated to my family, whose unwavering support fuels my aspirations, and to the countless
individuals whose contributions and encouragement have illuminated the path of this research
endeavor. Your belief and inspiration have made this journey possible. Grateful for the collective
spirit that has made this dedication meaningful. In honor of those whose guidance and kindness
have left an indelible mark on this pursuit
Table of Contents
In this section, we delve into key aspects such as the context in which the research is situated, the
issues being addressed (problem statement), the historical context and rationale behind the study
(background), the overarching goal, as well as the specific aims of the research (main objective
and specific objectives), the inquiries that guide our investigation (research questions), the
importance and relevance of the study (significance of the study), precise definitions of crucial
terms central to the study (operational definitions), and a brief overview of the structure of this
WHO defines pediatric pain as the discomfort experienced by children, incorporating physical,
emotional, and social dimensions? Nurses play a vital role in assessing and managing pediatric
pain, and their knowledge and attitude towards pediatric pain management are essential for
providing high-quality care. The World Health Organization (WHO) also has continued to
prioritize pain management, it released the Global Action Plan on Pain (WHO, the Global Action
Plan, 2019) especially in Developing countries they face considerable challenges related to
pain management due to limited knowledge, poorly developed healthcare systems due to lack of
education and access to information, cultural attitudes, and lack of analgesic medication
constraints, and the prioritization of infectious diseases, including both knowledge and attitude
noticeable for around two decades. Persistent gaps in knowledge continue to be an issue. The
findings from numerous surveys conducted over the past two decades unequivocally demonstrate
that a significant number of nurses responsible for patients experiencing pain lack sufficient
information about pediatric pain management. (Friedrichsdorf, 2020), Under or untreated pain in
children has multiple consequences including both physiological and psychological effects.
chronic pain, anxiety, and depression (Olmstead, 2018)Nurses play an integral part in pain
management in children. As advocates for the child and family, nurses are responsible for
Previous research indicates that nurses’ knowledge and attitudes affect their response to children
in pain and thus pain management (Vincent, 2017) Nursing factors related to under management
of children's pain include lack of standardized assessment and evaluation methods, limited
knowledge of pediatric pain, education level, lack of knowledge of analgesics, and lack of time
(Olmstead, 2018)In Rwanda, based on the researcher's observations, the inadequate management
of pain in hospitals can be attributed to various factors, stemming from healthcare provider’s
knowledge and attitudes. One significant factor is deeply rooted in Rwandan culture, which
encourages individuals to suppress their pain expressions in order to project strength within
society. Additionally, the scarcity of certain pain-relief medications within healthcare facilities
exacerbates the problem, particularly in pediatric care. Another formidable challenge lies in the
limited understanding of pain assessment, especially when dealing with pediatric patients who
may struggle to communicate effectively with their healthcare team due to their underdeveloped
cognitive abilities.
The problem at hand is the inadequate management of pediatric pain at Kibagabaga District
Hospital in Rwanda. Despite the recognition of pain relief as a fundamental human right, nurse’s
level about managing pain is still low that cause children continue to suffer needlessly from pain.
This issue is substantiated by recent research findings, such as a 2022 study in the journal Pain
highlighting disparities in pain relief access between different income countries (Vlaeyen, 2022)
and a 2023 study in The Lancet revealing the under treatment of pain in children with cancer.
(Dr. David Eccleston, 2023) The study involved 1,367 children with cancer from 86 hospitals in
26 worldwide. The study found that 63% of the children were experiencing moderate to severe
pain, but only 37% were receiving adequate pain relief. In Africa also showed that 53 % of
Nurses had poor knowledge toward pain management in children as it is shown in a study
research of kholowa (Kholowa, 2017; Kholowa, 2017) The major problem in hospitalized
children is the nurses’ knowledge and perceived barriers towards pain management among
hospitalized children and poor pain relieve leads to the negative outcomes
While Rwanda's Ministry of Health has taken steps to enhance pediatric pain management by
establishing guidelines and distributing pain medications to the district level, there remains a
critical gap in knowledge and attitude among nurses regarding this vital aspect of care. A 2020
study in African Health Sciences showed that Rwandan nurses possessed inadequate knowledge
of pediatric pain assessment and management (Benimana, 2020), also in a 2022 study in BMC
Pediatrics stands for "BioMed Central Pediatrics, indicated poor and negative attitudes on 40%
among these nurses toward the use of opioids in children (the journal BMC, 2022).This
knowledge deficit among nurses constitutes a significant barrier to effective pain management in
pediatric patients. Nurses often serve as the frontline of defense in pediatric Ohealthcare,
assuming a pivotal role in identifying and addressing pain. However, when nurses lack the
requisite knowledge and skills to manage pain adequately, children are left vulnerable to
unnecessary suffering.
The existing knowledge gap in the specific context of Kibagabaga District Hospital is a critical
concern. Despite a growing body of research on pediatric pain management globally, there is a
conspicuous absence of research addressing the knowledge and attitudes of nurses in Rwandan
hospitals, particularly at the district level. This research gap is of utmost importance, as it
represents a fundamental step in identifying the precise areas where nurses require additional
training and support to improve pediatric pain management practices at the hospital. Thus, this
study aims to bridge this knowledge gap, enhance pediatric pain management practices, and
1.3. Objectives
To assess the knowledge and attitudes towards pediatric pain management among nurses at
District Hospital
2. To identity the attitudes of nurses towards pediatric pain management at Kibagabaga District
Hospital
1. What is the level of knowledge of nurses about pediatric pain management at Kibagabaga
District Hospital?
2. What are the attitudes of nurses towards pediatric pain management at Kibagabaga District
Hospital?
enhancing nurses' knowledge and attitudes in pediatric pain management, the study directly
benefits mothers seeking quality healthcare for their children and pediatric patients, resulting in
nurses at Kibagabaga District Hospital. Elevating the expertise and competence of the nursing
staff not only ensures a higher standard of healthcare within the hospital but also strengthens the
management practices driven by this study plays a vital role in enhancing the hospital's
reputation. This, in turn, fosters greater trust and confidence from the community, solidifying
Kibagabaga District Hospital's position as a healthcare leader in the region. The study's impact,
therefore, resonates not only within the hospital walls but also radiates outward, positively
influencing the broader community's perception and reliance on the hospital's healthcare
services.
This study is justified by its fundamental aim to improve the well-being of pediatric patients. By
addressing gaps in nurses' knowledge and attitudes towards pediatric pain management. Recent
studies have shed light on the persistent challenges in pediatric pain management. While older
studies from the 2000s indicated that many pediatric patients continued to experience pain, more
recent investigations have reaffirmed these concerns. For instance, a study by Bernie in 2014
found that a significant proportion of pediatric inpatients, ranging from 21% to 64%, reported
experiencing moderate pain. It seeks to enhance the quality of care provided to children at the
hospital (CarterBernie, 2014). This research holds global significance as it contributes to the
limited body of knowledge on this subject in low- and middle-income countries like Rwanda.
The findings can guide the development of targeted interventions to improve pediatric pain
management not only in Rwanda but also in similar resource-constrained healthcare settings
worldwide. Ultimately, this study aligns with evidence-based care principles and has the
potential to positively impact patient satisfaction, nursing practice, and the overall healthcare
The goal of conducting this study at Kibagabaga District Hospital in Rwanda, a low- and middle-
income country with limited prior research on pediatric pain management, is the aim of
benefiting the hospital and serving as a reference for similar healthcare institutions. The study's
findings will inform targeted interventions and policies to enhance pediatric pain management,
improve healthcare practices, and ultimately enhance the well-being of pediatric patients.
Additionally, the research seeks to contribute to the global understanding of pediatric pain
management in low- and middle-income countries, raising awareness of challenges and guiding
This study will be conducted at Kibagabaga District Hospital in Kimironko sector, Gasabo
district, Kigali city, Rwanda. It employs a cross-sectional research design, focusing on self-
reported responses from nurses within this specific healthcare institution. Delimited to nurses,
the findings may have limited generalizability beyond the unique context of this hospital and
Rwanda. The study excludes perspectives from other healthcare professionals such as physicians,
pharmacists, and psychologists. Acknowledging its cross-sectional nature, the research provides
a snapshot view, lacking an analysis of changes in nurses' knowledge and attitudes over time.
Additionally, to address feedback, a specified time frame will be included, enhancing the
presentation of the study's scope. The study transparently acknowledges resource constraints and
Pain: According to the International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) taxonomy, pain is
defined as "an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience from actual or potential tissue
damage or described in terms of such damage (Association for the Study of Pain , 2017)
Pain management: is the use of a variety of approaches to reduce or eliminate pain, improve
life function, and enhance quality of life (World Health Organization, ([WHO], 2023)
Attitude: according to Cambridge Dictionary, (2016) attitude is defined as the way of thinking
(Merriam-Webster, 2023)
Pediatrics: is the branch of medicine that deals with the health and well-being of infants,
children, and adolescents from 1 month of birth through (American Academy of Pediatrics,
2023)
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW
This chapter will present the overview of nurses’ knowledge and attitude regarding pediatric pain
management based on existing theory and literature that talk about the topic which is of interest
in this research
The empirical review of the study highlights the vital role of pediatric pain management in
which revealed significant knowledge and attitude gaps among nurses. The collective findings
emphasize a global need for targeted training programs in pediatric pain management. The study
serves as a compelling call to action, stressing the importance of enhancing nurses' knowledge
and attitudes to improve the quality of care for pediatric patients in Rwanda and beyond.
The assessment of nurses' knowledge regarding pediatric pain management reveals consistent
challenges across various regions. In Rwanda, Kholowa's study (2017) uncovered a significant
gap, with 53% of nurses demonstrating insufficient knowledge in pain assessment. This finding
aligns with Uwera & Kamanzi's (2022) similar observations in Rwanda, emphasizing
deficiencies in understanding pain scales and non-verbal cues. Similarly, Bhattacharya et al.
(2019) in India reported that 48% of nurses exhibited poor scores in pain knowledge
assessments, while Liu et al. (2018) found that 62% of Chinese nurses had inadequate knowledge
Exploring nurses' attitudes towards pediatric pain management reveals diverse perspectives and
potential barriers to effective care. In Rwanda, Kholowa (2017) identified that 35% of nurses
held unfavorable attitudes, including the underestimation of pain and concerns about medication
overuse. This aligns with Altin et al.'s (2020) study in Turkey, reporting that 28% of nurses
believed children do not experience pain like adults. Additionally, Walker et al. (2015) in the
USA found that 23% of nurses expressed concerns about opioid addiction in children, while
Akinsulure et al. (2017) in Nigeria identified cultural beliefs hindering pain management in 39%
of nurses.
the Health Belief Model provides a comprehensive framework to understand the factors
influencing nurses' engagement in effective care. Beginning with perceived severity, nurses
evaluate the gravity of inadequate pain management on pediatric patients' well-being. This
assessment sets the stage for their perceived susceptibility, where recognition of potential
knowledge gaps becomes crucial in shaping attitudes toward patient outcomes. Perceived
benefits then play a pivotal role, highlighting positive outcomes and professional growth as
motivational factors for nurses to actively seek and apply comprehensive knowledge in pain
management. However, perceived barriers, such as time constraints, must be identified and
form of timely interventions like targeted educational programs, serve as stimuli prompting
nurses to improve their knowledge and attitudes. Finally, self-efficacy emerges as a critical
variable, emphasizing the necessity of building nurses' confidence in applying their knowledge
for the successful implementation of effective pediatric pain management strategies. In this
SOCIAL DEMOGRAPHIC
DATA
The study will use quantitative with a cross-sectional , and to assess nurses' knowledge and
attitudes regarding pediatric pain management at Kibagabaga District Hospital. This approach,
involving a one-time data collection, aligns with research objectives, providing insights into the
current status and areas for improvement. A structured questionnaire will be administered across
based on experience and specialization. Data analysis will employ descriptive statistics for
quantitative data and thematic analysis for qualitative insights from open-ended questions. This
approach aims to comprehensively capture nurses' perspectives and contribute valuable insights
This research study will be conducted at Kibagabaga District Hospital, situated in the Gasabo
district of Kigali city, Rwanda, East Africa. Located within Kimironko sector, the hospital serves
as a critical healthcare facility for a diverse patient population, including pediatric patients. The
study will unfold within the hospital's premises, encompassing nurses from various departments
and units. This choice of setting offers a unique opportunity to examine the knowledge and
attitudes of nurses regarding pediatric pain management within the specific context of
Kibagabaga District Hospital. As a district hospital in the Gasabo district, it plays a pivotal role
in providing essential medical services to the community, making it a fitting location for this
study
The study will target a specific population of interest, namely, registered nurses employed at
Kibagabaga District Hospital in Rwanda. The research will focus on nurses who are involves in
the care and management of pediatric patients within various hospital departments and units.
In the future, the study will aim to recruit a representative sample of these nurses to participate in
the research. This sample will be selected based on predefined criteria to ensure diversity and
relevance to the study objectives. The nurses who meet the inclusion criteria will be invited to
voluntarily take part in the study by completing the structured questionnaire designed to assess
inclusion and exclusion criteria will guide the selection of eligible participants.
The study will encompass registered nurses who are presently employed at Kibagabaga District
Hospital. To be eligible, participants must actively partake in the care and oversight of pediatric
[Link] Criteria
Nurses that are not willing to participate and those which are not meeting inclusion criteria will be
The total nurse of kibagabaga hospital are 114 , in determining sample size the simplified
formula proposed by Taro Yamane (1967) will be used
Where :
N: represent targeted population which is equal to 114 nurses
n: represents sample size
e: stands for level of precision which is equal to 0.05
n = N/(1+N(e)2.
n = 114/(1+114(0.05)2.=88.7
3.6. Sampling Techniques
This study will employ a simple random sampling technique to select participants from
Nurses responsible for the care of sick children were selected from various departments,
including pediatrics, surgery (caring for children with surgical conditions), emergency units
The research utilizes the Pediatric Nurses' Knowledge and Attitudes Survey (PNKAS),
comprising two sections meticulously designed to assess nurses' knowledge and attitudes
regarding pediatric pain management. In accordance with best practices for data collection
instruments, the knowledge section features questions evaluating nurses' factual understanding of
crucial pain-related concepts. These encompass the subjective nature of pain, accuracy in
strategies. The attitudes section explores nurses' beliefs and feelings, addressing their confidence
in assessing and treating pain in children, comfort levels in administering pain medication, and
core belief in the necessity of providing adequate pain management to all children. This
effective pain management for pediatric patients, aiding in the identification of areas for further
The Pediatric Nurses' Knowledge and Attitudes Survey (PNKAS) is a well-established tool for
evaluating nurses' understanding and perspectives on pediatric pain management. The survey
exhibits both reliability and validity, ensuring its credibility in diverse global studies.
3.8.1 VALIDITY
Content Validity: Experts in pediatric pain management review PNKAS items to ensure comprehensive
between nurses with varying levels of pediatric pain management knowledge and experience.
Criterion-related Validity: PNKAS scores correlate with other measures of pediatric pain management
3.8.2 REABILITY
Reliability, on the other hand, pertains to the consistency of the instrument's scores. The PNKAS
demonstrates reliability, with a Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.71, indicating consistent results
The data gathering procedure for this study involves using a structured questionnaire adapted
from the Pediatric Nurses' Knowledge and Attitudes Survey Regarding Pain tool. Nurses from
various departments at Kibagabaga District Hospital will be selected through simple random
sampling to participate in the study. The questionnaire will assess their knowledge and attitudes
regarding pediatric pain management. Before the main data collection, a pilot study will be
conducted to refine the questionnaire. The collected data will be rigorously analyzed to gain
insights into nurses' knowledge and attitudes, contributing to a deeper understanding of pediatric
The data analysis for the study involves cleaning and organizing collected questionnaire data,
and attitude scores. Inferential statistics SPSS, may reveal differences among nurse groups based
on experience or department. Regression analysis will explore factors influencing knowledge and
attitudes. The analysis aims to provide insights into pediatric pain management at Kibagabaga
District Hospital, aiding in identifying areas for improvement and guiding interventions to
District Hospital, ethical considerations are fundamental. The study, emanating from the
honesty and respect. Data collection, focused on selected nurses in kibagabaga, ensures
participant confidentiality and emphasizes that responses are solely for academic purposes. The
study maintains objectivity in data processing and analysis, pledging transparency and providing
the research findings to involved organizations. Upholding AUCA's ethical standards, the study
diligently follows guidelines, reinforcing its commitment to ethical integrity throughout the
research process.
APPENDIX
References:
BIBLIOGRAPHY
University of Rwanda).
nurses at Ethiopian tertiary hospital. a multi-center study. BMC nursing, 22(1), 1-8.
the journal BMC, P. (2022). the journal BMC Pediatrics. the journal BMC Pediatrics.
Uwera, A.M., & Kamanzi, S. (2022). Challenges and opportunities. Pain Management.
WHO. (2019). the Global Action Plan. the Global Action Plan.
assessment and management at Butaro Hospital, Rwanda. African Health Sciences, 20(2),
603-611.
Bernie, J. E., Stevens, B. J., Palermo, T. M., Cox, A. D., McGrath, P. J., & Weisman, S. J.
(2014). Pain prevalence and management in hospitalized children: a multi-center study. Pain
Dr. David Eccleston, P. W. (2023, February 4). Lancet study reveals under treatment of pain
Olmstead, S. E., Traub, R. J., Buerhaus, P. I., Bergstrom, I., Johnson, B. D., & Auerbach, D.
Ujeneza, J. D., Ndayisaba, L., Makuza, J. M., & Nsabimana, E. (2022). Attitudes of
Rwandan nurses towards the use of opioids in children. BMC Pediatrics, 22(1), 1-8.
Vlaeyen, J. (2022). Global disparities in pain relief access. Pain, 163(7), 1217-1218.
association-websites
Kitson, A., Rycroft-Malcolm, J., McCormack, B., Harvey, G., Seers, K., & Titchen, A.
(2022). Knowledge transfer and implementation: Theory and practice. London: SAGE
Publishing.
Routledge.
Uwera, A. M., & Kamanzi, S. (2022). Pediatric pain management in Rwanda: A review of
[Link]
Informed Consent Form
Attitudes Towards Pediatric Pain Management Among Nurses at Kibagabaga District Hospital."
The objective of this research is to evaluate the knowledge and attitudes of nurses regarding
To collect data, I invite participants to share their perspectives through a structured questionnaire
designed to gather insights into pediatric pain management. The data collection process involves
distributing the questionnaire and allowing participants ample time to complete it at their
convenience.
I request participants to voluntarily contribute to the research by providing honest and accurate
anonymized form, and individual participant information will be treated with utmost
confidentiality.
While the research entails minimal risks, such as slight discomfort or inconvenience during
provided and retain the right to withdraw from the study at any point without consequences.
QUESTIONNNAIRE.
(PNKAS).
Age (years):
A2 A1 A0 MSN Other(specify)
Emergence ……….
Surgicalward……..
DENTAL ……………
Pediatricward…….
OPD………………
OPTHAMOLOGY …….
Does your unit has a pediatric pain management protocol? Yes / No /don’t know
which of the following pain scale have you used? (Write a pain scale used if it
3. Faces
4. Numeric
5. Other…
of age have decreased pain sensitivity and limited memory of painful experiences.
T/ F 3. If the infant/ child/ adolescent can be distracted from his pain this usually
T/ F 7. Non-drug interventions (e.g. heat, music, imagery, etc.) are very effective
for mild-moderate pain control but are not helpful for more severe pain.
T/ F 8. Children who will require repeated painful procedures (i.e. daily wound
care or blood draws), should receive maximum treatment for the pain and anxiety
subsequent procedures.
codeine 32 mg PO.
T /F 11. The World Health Organization (WHO) pain ladder suggests using single
analgesic agents rather than combining classes of drugs (e.g. combining an opioid
opioid analgesics.
T /F 15. Adolescents with a history of substance abuse should not be given opioids
for pain because they are at high risk for repeated addiction.
T/ F 17. Young infants, less than 6 months of age, cannot tolerate opioids for pain
relief. T/ F 18. The child/ adolescent with pain should be encouraged to endure as
T /F 19. Children less than 8 years cannot reliably report pain intensity and
therefore, the nurse should rely on the parents’ assessment of the child’s pain
intensity.
T/ F 20. Based on one’s religious beliefs a child/ adolescent may think that pain
T/ F 22. After the initial recommended dose of opioid analgesic, subsequent doses
T F 23. The child/ adolescent should be advised to use non-drug techniques alone
_____ A. intravenous
_____ B. intramuscular
_____ C. subcutaneous
_____ D. oral
_____ E. rectal
_____ A. intravenous
_____ B. intramuscular
_____ C. subcutaneous
_____ D. oral
_____ E. rectal
27. Which of the following analgesic medications is considered the drug of choice
_____ B. codeine
_____ C. morphine
_____A. Morphine 3 mg IV
_____ B. Morphine 5 mg IV
_____ C. Morphine 10 mg IV
_____ D. Morphine 15 mg IV
_____ B. only when the child/ adolescent asks for the medication
_____ C. only when the nurse determines that the child/ adolescent has moderate
or greater discomfort
30. A child with background (continuous, persistent) pain has been receiving daily
opioid analgesics for 2 months. The doses increased during this time period.
_____ B. 1-10%
_____ C. 11-20%
_____ D. 21-40%
_____ C. only when the nurse determines that the child has moderate or greater
discomfort
32. The most likely explanation for why a child/ adolescent with pain would
_____ B. Morphine
34. The most accurate judge of the intensity of the child’s/ adolescent’s pain is
35. What do you think is the percentage of patients who over-report the amount of
effect, not for medical reasons. It may occur with or without the physiological
treating pain with opioid analgesics? Circle the number closest to what you