Understanding Differentiation in Calculus
Understanding Differentiation in Calculus
Calculus, that is, differentiation and integration, lies at the heart of seemingly
and minimum values of a function and finding the area under a curve are just
The MAT specification (but not the TMUA specification), requires you to know
about differentiation from first principles, namely that for a function f(x) as shown
in the diagram, the gradient of the tangent to y = f(x) at the point A(x, f(x)) is
Thus .
In this way, f ′(x) is a function that computes the gradient of the tangent to a curve
given the x coordinate of the point on the curve. The gradient of the normal can
then also be found by using the result that if m1 and m2 are the gradients of two
f ′(x) is a function that computes the gradient of the tangent to a curve given the x
coordinate of the point on the curve. The function f ′ is called the derivative of f
because it is derived from the function f. This notation was introduced by Joseph-
Louis Lagrange with second and third derivatives denoted by f ′′ (x) and f ′′′ (x).
For even higher derivatives, the primes (dashes) are often replaced by numerals in
(4)
brackets, e.g. f (x) for the fourth derivative.
Leibnitz used the notation in place of f ′ (x) when y = f(x). Using this notation
it is not always clear that is a function; it looks more like a fraction. When
evaluating the derivative at, for example, x = 2, Lagrange’s notation gives f ′ (2)
we write
There are some advantages to Leibnitz’s notation. If, in the above diagram, you
denote h by ∆x, and let ∆y = f(x + ∆x) - f(x), so that ∆y is the small change in y
fraction. This explains why appears to behave like a fraction in, for example,
the chain rule, where if z = f(y) and y = g(x), then, provided all of the derivatives
You are expected to know and use the results that for any
rational n (MAT and TMUA) and that for any real k (MAT only).
Try it out
You should already know how to differentiate some functions from the work you
have covered in school. Make sure you know how you would deal with each of
x.
5 The normal to the curve is drawn at the point on the curve, P, where x
= 1. This line cuts the x axis at A and the y axis at B. Simplify the ratio AP :
PB.
2
6 The line y = mx - 15, where m < 0, is tangent to the curve y = 2x - 5 at the
3 3
7 The curves with equations y = x + c and y = x touch (that is, meet
x 3
1 (e )
3
Stationary points
The derivative of a function is used to calculate the gradient of the tangent at any
point on the graph of the function. Of particular interest is when the tangent is
horizontal, and therefore the derivative is zero, since this is true at any local
maximum or local minimum on the graph. (The word ‘local’, sometimes omitted,
neighbourhood around the point and not necessarily on the whole domain of the
function.) The points on the graph of a function where the derivative is zero are
called stationary points. Assuming the curve is not a horizontal line, stationary
There are various methods for finding the number of solutions of a given
In the case of a polynomial, thinking of its graph and the location of its stationary
Example 1
Question
Solution
(i)
Want to show
i.e.
which is > 0.
Hence
5 4 3 2
For part (ii) let f(x) = 4x + 35x + 60x + 130x − 600x + 300. Since the
5
coefficient of x is positive, you know that as x → -∞ then f(x) → -∞ and as
equation).
(ii) Let .
Since adding the coefficients of the left-hand side gives zero, you can
Now the reason for the first part of the question starts to become clear:
3 2 2 3
(-6) + 8 × (-6) + 17 × -6 + 30 = 8 × 6 + 30 - (6 + 17 × 6)
x - 1 and x = -6 are the only real roots of the equation f ′(x) = 0 and x = -6.
The second derivative can be used to find the nature of these stationary
points.
x = 1,
This is equivalent to the second result that you proved in the first part
of the question.
Even though you haven’t found the actual y value when x = -6, you
know enough to roughly sketch the curve and find the number of roots.
Although the sketch gives a not-to-scale simplification of the actual shape
of the graph, all that matters is where the gradient is positive, negative and
zero.
Just from the sketch of the curve you have established that the equation f(x)
Example 2
Question
Solution
9 3 3 6 3 3 3
It is easier to consider f(x) = 9x - 9x = 9x (x - 1) = 9x (x - 1)(x + 1)
first.
It is clear that f(x) = 0 has three real roots, x = 0, x = 1 and x = -1 but you
actually have f(x)+ 2 = 0 here so you need to know about the stationary
The graph of y = f(x) has three stationary points and these can be used to
inflection and a local minimum, as this is the only way to draw a continuous
units parallel to the y axis to give y = f(x) + 2 will not raise the point
above the x axis so the graph of y = f(x) + 2 will cross the x axis in
Try it out
By using first derivatives and considering long run behaviour, sketch the graphs
of the following functions and hence determine the number of roots in each case.
Hint
For number 3 be very careful when you are finding the stationary points.
The second derivative
function in its own right and so the process of differentiation can be applied again:
derivative .
The second derivative can possibly be used to determine the nature of stationary
must be a local maximum. If then all you can conclude is that you
have a stationary point and not what type of stationary point it is. For example,
3 3 4 4
the curves y = x , y = -x , y = x and y = -x all have zero first and second
applications such as approximating functions, but this is not something you will
1 How many real roots does each of the following equations have?
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
3 2 2
3 Find the value(s) of k for which the function y = (k - 8) x - 8 (3k + 6k + 8) x
(b) .
(c)
(d) .
(e) .
(b) k = 1 or 7
(c) k > 7
(d) k = -4 or 7
(e) k < 1
(f) k = -4 or 1
(g) k < -4
(h) k = -4, 1 or 7
4 3
7 How many possible stationary points could the graph of y = 3x + 4(k − 2)x +
2
12(2 − k)x - 96x + 11 have?
Give the value or values of k that result in each number of stationary points.
Integration
In your school course, you will have been introduced to both indefinite integration
process, and definite integration, that is evaluating the integral at given limits and
constant of integration’.
computes the signed area between the curve y = f(x), the x axis and the lines x = a
and x = b. The area is signed in the sense that it is positive when the curve is
Consider the definite integral . This is shown by the shaded area in the
diagram.
The definite integral equates to 0.
(the area is below the x axis) so adding these gives zero. If you are interested in
the actual total area between a function and the x axis, you need to split the
integral into different sections according to when the graph is above or below the
x axis.
Note that this can also be written as . Swapping the limits for the
Try it out
Find the area enclosed by the curve , the x axis and the lines x
= -2 and x = 2.
Hint
You need to know where the curve is above or below the x axis. Sketch the curve
In addition to using definite integration to calculate the area between a curve and
some straight lines, you may also need to find the area between two or more
curves. For two curves this involves using the integral of the difference between
The order of subtraction in the integrand does affect whether the answer is
positive, so if the graph of y = f(x) is above the graph of y = g(x) then the area
would be .
A good question to ask would be whether this formula for the area between two
curves is also valid if the graphs of one or both of the functions lie all or partly
below the x axis. The answer is yes, as the following diagram shows for one
particular case.
Just as care is needed when finding the area between the x axis and a curve that
intersects the x axis, care is needed when finding the area between two curves that
intersect.
Try it out
3 2
Find the area between the curve y = x - x and the line y = 2x from x = -1 to x =
2.
Hint
This is clearly not the area. A sketch of both graphs will show you what you
need to calculate.
Example 3
Question
for any real numbers and and any f(x) which is defined on the
interval .
Find the area enclosed by the curve , the line and the x
axis.
Solution
parallel to the x axis. If the limits, x = a and x = b are also translated, the two
The straight line y = x - 31 has positive gradient and passes through the
points (0, -31) and (31, 0). It intersects the curve at a single point. The first
often introduces new solutions that are not valid in the original equation.
2 2 2 2
In general, A = B implies that A = B but A = B does not imply that A = B. It
. x = 26 is a solution of .
Example 4
Question
Solution
If the graphs intersect, the x coordinates of any points of intersection must
2 2
satisfy x + 6ax + a = a − 2x
For a > 0
For a < 0
positive for one quadratic and negative for the other, you know that, for the
2 2 2
enclosed area, the graph of y = a - 2x is above that of y = x + 6ax + a.
This can be thought of in simple terms as ‘the area from x = a to x = c is the same
If you recall that then you realise that this result holds
whether or not b lies in the interval [a, c]. This result lends itself to a specific type
Example 5
Question
The function f(x), defined on the real numbers, satisfies the condition that f(-x) =
f(x).
It is given that
Solution
Why have you been told that f(-x) = f(x)? It must be for a reason. What
does it mean?
For every point on the curve, (x, f(x)), there is a corresponding point, (-x, f(x)),
that is a reflection in the y axis. Since this is true for each point on the curve, it
follows that the graph of the function is a reflection in the y axis. In terms of
functions, each defined on different intervals of the real number line. For example,
consider
For this example, the function is continuous in the sense that there are no ‘jumps’
when sketching the graph, but this need not always be the case.
Piecewise functions are integrated by piecing together integrals just as you piece
together functions.
Try it out
Use the sketch of y = f(x) above to find the value of the following definite
integrals.
5
Hints
2
For 4 and 5, think about what type of function x is. What will that tell you
2 2
about the features of the graph of y = f(x )? At what values will x be equal to 0,
2 or 3?
The trapezium rule
The trapezium rule provides an approximate value for a definite integral for which
there is no analytical solution. It is part of the A level course but is often taught in
school after the date of the TMUA or MAT examinations. You may wish to do
Trapezia of equal width are formed by drawing vertical segments from the axis to
where
You need to be able to apply this formula but also to appreciate two key points.
Increasing the number of trapezia usually gives a more accurate estimate of the
actual area.
One trapezium
Ten trapezia
The gradient of the graph of the function can indicate whether the trapezium rule
Increasingly accurate overestimates will decrease in value towards the actual area
and increasingly accurate underestimates will increase in value towards the actual
area.
All areas in the diagrams have been drawn above the x axis. If any of the graph is
below the x axis then the trapezia below the x axis will have negative area. The
Example 6
Question
Solution
Writing 3 + 2 instead of 5, allows the 2 to be associated with the
first term 2, common ratio and N terms. The sum of this progression is
and N - 1 terms.
Exercise 2
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
2 For a particular function, f(x), the trapezium rule with three ordinates (i.e. two
What would the trapezium rule approximation with two ordinates (one
trapezium) of be?
3 Using the trapezium rule with five trapezia of equal width provides an
rule with five trapezia of equal width also provides an overestimate for
What can you say, if anything, about the trapezium rule estimate, using five
equal width trapezia again, for each of the following definite integrals?
(a)
(b)
(c)
When is a calculus question not a calculus
question?
In both the MAT and TMUA examinations there are questions presented using the
language of calculus, which obviously require you to understand how the language
relates to areas and gradients, but which are, in fact, best answered by not
Example 7
Question
what degree?
Solution
2 3 5 2 3 5 11
The highest power of x in (x - 1) (2x - 1) is (x ) × (2x) = 32x .
10 9
Differentiating this once gives a term in x and a second time gives a term in x .
2 5 5 10
The highest power of x in (2x - 1) is (2x) which gives a term in x .
9
Differentiating this gives a term in x .
9
As both are x terms, it is worth checking that they don’t cancel each other out.
11 10 9
For 32x , differentiating gives 352x and differentiating again gives 3520x .
10 9
For 32x , differentiating once gives 320x .
9
The x terms will not cancel so the expression is a polynomial of degree nine.
Example 8
Question
Find the area bounded by the graphs of the functions
Solution
The main clue to the fact that this question does not require you to integrate is
The straight line crosses the x axis at (6, 0), passes through a
point on the circumference of the semicircle and then meets the y axis at
gradient of the line is so the line makes an angle of 60° with the x axis.
This means that there is an equilateral triangle with vertices that are the centre
of the circle, the point (6, 0) and the point where the line intersects the
semicircle.
square units
Example 9
Question
This example requires radians and so would not appear on a MAT paper.
Solution
You are not expected to calculate any of these integrals, so your options for
dealing with a question like this are limited. You should think about the graphs
of the functions and decide which has the greatest area above the x axis
between x = 0 and .
sketch graph.
n
Reflecting the graph of gives sin x and vice versa (since
For
This answer has been reached without integrating at all. Very little working was
being integrated.
Example 10
Question
This example requires radians and so would not appear on a MAT paper.
Which of the following is true?
A T = 0
B T < 0
C T > 0
Solution
In a similar fashion, a quick sketch of the graph of y = sin x shows that the
You only need to know whether or not the value of T is positive, negative or
zero. You are therefore only interested in whether the graphs are above or
T is the product of one positive and two negative numbers, therefore T must be
positive.
Example 11
Question
This example requires radians and so would not appear on a MAT paper.
How many real solutions does each of the following equations have in the
(a)
(b)
Solution
(a) As x varies between 0 and 2π, cos x varies between -1 and 1. For y = cos(cos
Since π is just a little bit larger than 3, 1 radian is just a little smaller than
= 0, π, 2π, etc.
To appreciate the meaning of this, change the x axis to a t axis and consider
the area between the t axis and the graph of y = cos(cos t) between t = 0
Once this is clear, the solution to part a comes with relative ease.
(b)
For part b consider the area of the rectangular region below the graph from
t = 0 to t = 2π. A height of 0.5 can be used as this is just below the graph.
Since this rectangle has an area of , it follows that the area
is greater than π.
You can answer this question without actually saying what the solution is.
Differential equations
the end of your school studies, but you do need to be able to handle basic
questions on the TMUA and the MAT. The TMUA explicitly states that you need
graph.
Example 12
Question
8 and
Solution
Even if you have not studied differential equations before, you might realise that
in order to solve this problem you need to reverse the differentiation process; in
or integrating on TMUA and MAT questions is the need to rewrite the function
Example 13
Question
kx kx
The MAT syllabus requires you to know that the derivative of e is ke .
kx
For precisely which values of k does the function y = e satisfy the differential
equation
Solution
Even if you have studied differential equations before, you are unlikely to have
seen one presented like this. Do not be put off by questions of this sort, instead
think about what you do know and what you are expected to know.
kx kx kx
The derivative of e is ke . Starting with y = e and differentiating it
to find and again to find is really the only thing you can do. Once
you have these values, they can be substituted into the equation.
2kx 2
e is never 0 so this means that you are looking for values that satisfy 2k − k −
6 = 0
Example 14
Question
For all real numbers x, the function f(x) satisfies the equation
Solution
Since you do not even know what the function f(x) is, this may initially seem to
4
f(x) = 3f(-x) + Kx which is already looking more friendly.
real value of x, they have the same graphs and, in particular, they give the
same answer when integrated between the same two limits. Why integrate?
4
You want to find so integrating both sides of 8 - f(x) = 3f(-x) + Kx
between -1 and 1 with respect to x will result in at least one term that is
3 For what values of k does the function satisfy the differential equation
the curve .
A 0
B 1
C 2
D 3
F 12
Find the value(s) of a for which the maximum point on the first curve is
A 0
D ±0.8
E ±1
The value of is
A 2
B 3
C 5
D 8
E 11
F 12
F 30
3 2
5 Find the complete set of values of k for which the cubic equation 2x − 3x −
A x < 44
B x < 81
E x > 44
F x > 81
MAT style questions
4
6 The equation x − 4000x = 40 000 has
2
7 If f(x) = 4x − 12x + 18, what are the coordinates of the minimum point of
(a)
(b)
(c) (4, 3)
(d) (6, 3)
(e)
2 2
8 The diagram shows the ellipse 4x + y − 24x = 32.
The point P moves on the ellipse. What is the greatest possible distance of P
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(i) a = 4
(ii) a = 2.5
Show that .
(b) Find .
Show that
Full worked solutions can be found to all of the questions from Exercise 4 at
[Link]/step-mat-tmua-answers