Control Systems: Open vs Closed Loop
Control Systems: Open vs Closed Loop
INTRODUCTION TO cONTROL
SYSTEM, MATHEMATICAL
MODELLING AND C.S5.
COMPONENTS
Q.1. What is control system?
Ans. The control system is a means by which any quantity of
interest in a machine, mechanism or other equipment is maintained or
altered in accordance with desired manner.
Q.2. What do you mean by open-loop and closed-loop
control system. Give one example of closed-loop control system.
[E. W.99,CT S.031
OR Explain the significance of "feedback" in the functioning
of control system.
Ans. The control system is means that by which
any quantity of
is maintained or
interest in a machine, mechanism or otlher equipment
altered in accordance with desired manner.
system is that
Open L0op Control Systems :- An open loop
System in which the control action is independent
of the system
a controller or
Output. Therefore, an open loop system utilizes
Automatic Coffec/milk
Server :- Ready coffee is prepard Eyes Controtter Plant
3.
is simply releaseared
fixed proportions of ingredients and when 4ctual
by cups are placed currently but does
does not
not ensure Brain Direction
asked. It assumes coffee Legs
filled in the cup. Hence, the system which
whether the fixed volume is upon request
aims to sending a fixed volume of liquid/beverage is Desired
Direction
open loop.
4. AnElectric Lift:- Without an operator, the doors are opened
output, namely whether tho Refer figure it is a closed loop system. When we move away
for some time. But the status of
passengers have reached and let the Iift, etc. IS not monitored. So also from the desired road, our eyes give feedback to brain which controls
whether more than permitted persons have loaded, etc. are nat the motion of our legs such that error is reduced.
checked (with an operator included this becomes closed loop).
Closed Loop:
[Link]:
Refer figure. When body temperature goes up, we perspire.
1. Automatic Electric Irons- An automatic electric iron,
Body heat is uséd to evaporate the sweat and our temperature. Hence,
regulates the temperature of iron such that for a given cloth selection
he temperature remains in a specified range. When the temperature our body maintains constant skin temnperature and is closed loop
falls below the range, heating is started and when it exceeds the range system. Nervous Controller Plant
of heating is stopped. Thus it is closed loop with respect to Normalystem Actual
temperature as the control action (which intiates heating or not Sweat Dir ection
heating the coil) depends on the output temperature. This is the
Desired X} Gtands
S kin
Skin Temp.
principle of closed loop temperature control. Refer figure
Controller
Thermostat
Desired Switech
Q.4. What are the advantages and disadvantages of open
IronActua
Temp.
or OHeater
Temp
loop and closed loop control system ?
Ans. Advantages and Disadvantages of Open
Loop System:
ReterensE Advantages:
Inputt Thyristor Voltage to Motor (1) They are simple in construction and design
Controller
Bridge (2) They are economic
Tacho
generator (3) Easy for maintenance
Motor (4) Not much problems of stability.
is difficult to measure.
(5) Convenient to use when output
Disadvantages:
because accuracy is dependent on
) Inaccurate and unreliable
Gain accuracy of calibration.
adjust with parameter variations,
2) Inaccurate results are obtained
Feedback
Voltage
internal disturbances.
10 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CCS(ETICT
11
SYSTEM/CS- (ETICT)
To maintain quality and accuracy Re-calibration,
3) VBD CONTROL
of the follow the principle
controller is necessary from time to time. (ii) Non-lincar C.S: When output does not
Advantages and Disadvantages of closed loop system; of superposition.
Advantages: 2] According to the nature of control signal:
In this system, the signal is the
1) Accuracy is very high as any error arising is corrected. (i) Continuous Time Systems:-
2) It senses changes in output due to environmental continuous function of time variable.
In this system, the
(ii) Digital or Discrete [Sampled] Data C.S:
parametric changes, internal disturbances, etc. and corrects the same
time is either in the form of a pulse
3) Reduced effect of non-linearities. signal at one or more points of
4) High Bandwidth. train or a digital code.
31 According to the nature of
parameter variation:
5) Facilitates Automation.
i) Time variant C.S: In this
system, the parameters of the
Disadvantages:
1) Complicated in design and system vary with timne.
maintenance costlier In this system, the parameters of the
ii) Time in-varíant C.S:
2) System may become unstable.
Q.5. Differentiate open-loop control system and closed loop system do not vary with time.
4] According to input and output:
control system. [SISOJ System : In this system,
CT S.03 (i) Single Input Single Output
Ans. Comparison between open loop and closed loop
control input.
systems: only one variable is controlled by one
[MIMOJ System: When more
(i) Multi Input Multi Output
pen Open Loop System Closed L0op System
than one variable of the system are
to be controlled with a number of
1) An open loop system has
the | 1) A closed loop system has got
ability to perfom accurately if | the ability inputs, system is called as MIMO system.
to perform accurately of feed back signal
its calibration is good, if the because 5] According to the nature
| of the feedback. i) Positive Feedback [Re-generative feedback] C.S: When
calibration deteriorates so does
feedback system.
its performance. feedback signal is additive [+]; it is positive
[Degenerative feedback] C.S: When
|2) It is easier to build. i) Negative Feedback
| 2) It is difficult to build feedback system
3) In general, it is more feedback signal is substractive [-1;: it is negative
stable.3) It is comparatively less stable. | 6] According to the purpose of the
system:
4) If non-linearities are present, | 4) Even some
system operation degenerates.
under presence of non-
i) Regulator Ifthe object of the CS is to maintain
linearities system operates better in the presence of some
physical variable at some constant value
than an open loop system. Regulator; e.g. a voltage
disturbances, the system is called as
constant.
Q.6. Explain the types of feedback stabilizer has desired output which remain
control system. ii) Servo-Mecharnism: f the object of the CS is that the
Ans. Types of Feed Back Control desired time function,
Systems:- physical variable should follow or track some
They are classified in following
ways: It is a system which controls
1] According to the the system is called as Servo mechanism.
nature of variation derivative; e.g. Servo-voltage
of output: the mechanical position or its time
i)Linear C.S: When output follows is controlled using
the principle of stabilizer in which position'of secondary tap
superposition.
Servo-motor.
12 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM I CS-(E 13
ETICT
(ETICT)
is CONTROL SYSTEM/ CS-I
Q.7. What transfer function. Give it's limitations VBD
s. TRANSFER FUNCTIONS:
Ans. Transfer function:- It is defned as, the ratio ofLaplace SOLVED EXAMPLES ON
Lan
TF of figure (a). ICTS.031
Prob.1. Find out the
transform of output to Laplace transform of input, unde.
assumption that all the initial conditions are zero. [i.e, neglected M-
For the open loop system shown below: Eo
Ei
The transfer function is given by,
CIS
XIS)
GiS a
transform of the circuit. See figure
(b)
Soln. Taking Laplace
By KVL,
T.F=C =Gís)
X() E 6)=RI(S)+sL(S)+ sC )
Expression for closed loop transfer function
RIS E S)
Gts Cls
E)-R +sL+6)
sC
BIS Ep)6 R sL
HIS . TF=-E s)
E; )
For negative feedbacks
1/sC
Els
Ts)-C) Gs) R+sSL+
R($) 1+G(s)H(s)
If the feedback is positive, then,
Limitations
i) It is valid only for linear
time-
invariant systems. o
ii) It does not take into account
the initial conditions.
ii) It does not give any idea about how the present output
progressing. is (a)
14 VBD CONTROL SYSIEM/ Cs./e
A(ETICT 15
CONTROL SYSTEM / CS-I (ETICT)
Soln. Step 1: Draw the Laplace transtorm of the circuit VBD
R R
w- w- R
(6) R
Step 2 : Apply KVL to first loop,
R3 eo
E,6)=RI) +1SC )-2 )]
Step 3: Apply KVL to second loop,
E,)=-Rl() SC
)-12(6)] reduce to;
star. Hence circuit will
Soln. Convert figure into
Also E,(-2)
I26)=sCE,
SC
R R
12s)1+2RsC
(S)
.ii) 1+2RsC (s
Put into (i)
R SC
E,)=R4)-E,6) 1+ 2R SC
I(s)=iS)+E, ()
.(iv)
R+SC
Put (i) and (iv) into (ii),
+ 1) + (R + RL + 2R RL sC)
(2RsC + 1) sC
E,(6) [RCs +2Rs + 1)]+ (2RsC
2Rc+3RsC+1 e
Now; =11(6). Z(s)
T.F= (s) 1/R2c2 R
E;6)224S4+- and eo=RL.l2)---|Z(s)=Zp 1+2RSC
RC Rc2
16 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM /CS-
CS-(ETICT
(ET 17
(ETICT)
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-I
Rc's+2RsC+ 1 1
1() (2RsC+1)sC S+
VoS) RC S+a
Also;
Also 1(S)= S+b
RCs2-2RsC+1+(R +2RRSC+R,)SC V, (S)
S+
(2RsC+1)sC RC R2C
1 a< b
a 1
and
E () R (R-C'S +2RsC+ 1} (2RsC+ 1}+RLSC{R +RL + 2RR LSC) where
RC bR.C
R2C
function of Lag compensator
of
E() (Rc+2RsC+1+2RRLs C +RLsC} {R+RL+2RRL,s Prob.5. Find the transfer
R
fig.(a).
Prob.4. Find the transfer function of the Lcad compensator
of fig(a).
R o
Vi
Vo
V6-R
Vo)TVi(s)
Vos
RR+R2
+R2 4
Cs) R2* Cs
Rearranging
From KCL at (a) node,
[V)-Vo)] [M)-Vo()] Vo() Vo()
R2t Cs
2Cs a (s+b)=Transfer funetion
1/Cs V ($) b(s+a)
Ri R2 R +R2 * Cs
Vo(s) Cs+1/R
le-arrangngv.(
V,) Cs+1/R+ 1/R2 where a =
(R +R2)C R,C
10 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-
ETICT
(ETi 19
CONTROL SYSTEM /CS-I (ETICT)
Prob.6. Find () VBD
shown in figure 2(b),
find
i() Prob.8. For the electrical network
of the
the transfer function E,
(s)/E, (s) by writing the equations
www-
R
network. L
V
eglt
e(t)
di
Soln. V =L+Ri
dt
Taking Laplace transform, we get, Fig.2(6)
IS-991
V,S)=RI (S) + Ls Is)
Soln.
V(s)= (R + Ls) I$)
eu L
I (s)
1
eolt
Vi R+Ls ej(t
Pro.7. For the network shown in fgure. Find the transfer
function (s)
V,6) Apply KVL
Soln. Apply KVL to circuit, we have
1)
Vidt+ iR didt +Ri=e;()
..(5)
RIS E S)
G(S
CIS) Using(3); ES) = R(s) - H(s). C(s)
..(6)
E(S)
Using (2); C(s)= G(s) .
BIS)
C(S){1+G(s). H(S)} =G$). R(S)
T(s)=C) =- G(s) ..(7)
H(S) T6)R(S) 1+G(s).H(s)
For positive feedback system
It is a convenient graphical representation of the transfer Ts)=Cs) G(s) ...(8)
function which gives the clearcut idea about the components and T6)R(G) 1-G(s).H(s)
signals of the system. It can be used for linear as well as non-linear C(s)
systems. The blocks are connected by lines with arrows representing
Now if we substitute (2) in (5) for
the unidirectional flow of information from the output of one block to E(s)= R(s)- H(s).G(s). E(s)
the input of the other.
. E(s)[1+G($). H(s)]=R(s)
(9)
Block Diagram of Closed loop C.S. and its Transfer
Function
R(s)= Input signal R(s)
C(s)- Output signal ES)1+G(s). H(S)
B(s) = Feedback signal
system. For a positive
E(s)= Error signal This expression is for a negative feedback
E(s)= R(s) t B(s) feedback system it will become,
In above expression
the + sign corresponds to positive RS)
feedback
Now,
and- sign corresponds to negative feedback. E(s)-G(S). H(S)
following block
The closed loop C.S. can also be represented by
G$)= Forward path T.F.= )
E(s) diagram (BD).
H(s) = T.F. of feedback B(s) G(s) Cls)
element RS)
C(s) 3)
1+G (s), HS)
G6).H(s)= Loop T.F,=5S)
Es) (4) G(s)
C6)-T(S)
Note: R(S)
T(s)= Closed Loop T.F. = C(s)
G(s).HS)
R(S)
(ETICT)
the B.D. of a closed loop
loon system YBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-I
Hence we can conclude that, disadvantages of
: Prob.10. What are the advantages and
can be reduced to that of
open loop system, but 1.F. of the bloct IET W-00
technique?
becomes complicated. hence is
s block diagram reduction
different. For practical systems B.D. it is
get the T.F. Soln. Advantages:
necessary to reduce the B.D. in order to graphical method.
(i) Simple step-by-step
Block Diagram Reduction Technique: represented by the interconnection of
Table Rules of Block Diagram Algebra (ii) A complex system is
X,GG2
Disadvantages:
turn out to be
some ofthe control systems
1. Combining blocks XGG (i) Block diagrams of
requires
csscade evaluation of their performance
very complex, such that the
in
right, we have
X,G
6. Eliminating a
feedback loop
L
24
EMICS
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM / CS-(E
(ETICT
25
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM /CS-
(ETICT)
6s/03
the multi loop system
Prob.12. Reducç the block diagram of (E.S.98
Ris) 62 G3 Cts shown in fgure.
1+G263 H1
- CIs
RIS
HS4g9
Atter Simptification
G3 G4+Gs
G3
H115)
L
figure is
the pick off point D in
Rls G1 G2 6L Cfs)
Soln. From transformation,
shifted beyond theblock G4 (s).
G4I51
CiS
A
H2
GalS)GLSj cIS
RIS A
G G2 G3GL+ G5)
45)G5)HS)
Rs
1tG2 G3H1
Cis)
1+521G3G4+65)H2 HtS
1+ G2G3 H1
formed
negative feedback loop
Applying transformations to the
by points B and D in figure (b).
26
BD CONTROL
VBD CS-I (B
CONTROL SYSTEM/ CST (ETICT)
(ET/CT
SYSTEM/CS-I (ET/CT) 27
BD CONTROL
combine the above
RIS) 6215) 6g1S1 6S) CIS) 3) To make complete block diagram we can
figure (d).
1+Gg15) GS)HglS}+G2S)6ISIHS) figure(a) and (b) so as to give figure (c) and
No
VC
|1 6151641SIH5I6;1SI6g|5| HSj+G|ISIG,|516315I5)HH1S|
Vc
Prob.13. For the fig, draw the block diagram and reduce it. Vi
R R2 Ve
IR1
wW IR2
R1 sC1 R2
lic2
c1 iC C2
CT TC2
RLVo
the last element, we get
4) Moving a take off point ahead of
Vi
Soln.
ET S.99
1) The elements in the circuit
are represented in block diagram
notation as follows;
R
VR2
Lis
5) Combining the cascaded
elements and eliminating the
V 1+R2IC2S1/RL
2) The relations between various voltages
can be represented by
he summation points aS is shown in
figure (b).
CS1/RL
R1
Vo is shifted ahead of
the block, we
6) Now, if pick off point at
iC2 obtain,
28 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM / CS-I (ET/O
TICT)
29
1
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM / CS-1(ET/CT)
1+R21C2S+1/R
+Cs)
RIS)
| 1R2(SC2+1/R
C2S+1/RL
iR2
7) Cascading the forward loop and the feedback loop,
we get G4+6362 Cls
G2
Prob.14. Find the closed loop transfer function using block 64 6263
diagram reduction technique of following one: CT W-02,03/
CIs
G4+ 626 3
H2
Soln.
Cts)
G4+G32
RIS) 1+ GcH2+G32H2
Cis)
H G2
G4+ 62 G3
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM /ICS-ETICT 31
CS-I (ETICT)
qWBD CONTROL SYSTEM /
G,64+6,62 G3
G4+6, G3 62 HG2
1+64M2+ G263H2] |6utO2 63
H3
Soln. - G3+ 64
#63 G4H2
H3
R G3+G
+6364 H2
H1
32 VBD CONTROL SYSTEMI
EMI CSETIC
CSJ
33
CS-I (ETICT)
CONTROL SYSTEM/ following block
qBD
G3+ 64 Prob.16. Obtain the
transfer function for the
14636 LH2
T diagram: Cis)
H1
G1 G4
H1
G16
Soln.
RIs
-
/G12 1/ 93t6 \|
14G162H3/ \1+6364H2
Rls) to G2 G3 Cis)
G16263+61 62 G4
G1 G
G462 63+64
=
G G2 G3
T.F.
1+G2+G,H1 H2
GG2G3 CIs)
RIS) G162 GF63
1+G2 +GzHjH2 1+G1G2H
diaor
Prob.17. Find single block equivalent using block iagran
reduction technique. [CT S-03 (Sem.), ET 04|
G1G2 Cis)
RIs) Gut63
1+61G2H1
GG2G4 +G,G2G3H2
.T.F
+G,G1+G2GHH2 -G1G2G4+G1G2G3
C(s C(s
Prob.18. Obtain the transfer function R($) for the
following
H2
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS
36 (ETI
(ET/CT) 37
Soln. VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-I CIS)
R(S
Ha
C(S)
R 1t6,H
On simplifications,
G1
RIS 6,02 + G2 C3 CIS
1 G2H2
tl 61t G3
CIS
RIS G
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS (ET/CT) 39
38 D cONTROL SYSTEM/CS-
Soln.
Cs)
H3+H
C(s)
(G+ G5
1+164+65lH2|
Hg-H Clb
G,G6162+63} G4+G5)
Rlb
1+ (GL+65)Hat 6,5g0t63)6¢t65'
block
Prob.20. Find the single block equivalent using
following one.
| diagram reduction technique of the
[ETS.00]
3. H
RIb
e106
It
can be reduced as follows
the second error-detector
Soln. Step 1: Move Gj before
CIS
RS
RS
R
The final B.D. can be obtained by equation (1) (2) and (3)
eilt) c eolt
sI(s) 1(s
E(s) EoIS)
Soln. For such problems first write the equations for the circ 1
i from those equations draw the B.D.
For output egt)-fi0dt
Take L.T. ; Eg6)1) ...
sC
..[Link] this part will be
E p5)
44 VBD 45
aBDCONTROL SYSTEM /CS-I (ETICT)
GRAPHS (S.F.G)
SIGNAL FLOW 9) Forward path gain:- It is a product of
branch gains
representation of the relati.
Signal flow graph is
graphical Onsencountered in traversing a forward path.
algebraic equation. forward
between the variables of a set
of linear (For ex. For a forward path of xj -X2 -X3 -X4-X5
algebraic equation y = kx path gains is
kykgkgk9).
Assuming the linear
10) Loop gain:- It is a product of branch gains
encountered in
y-Independent variable,
X-Dependent variable traversing a loop.
(ex. For loop X2 -X3-X2 loop gain is kgk2)
K3 Kg C-TPA
R.
2PA
X2
where P =gain of thek" forward path
A = Determinant of the graph
gain
=1-(sum of gains of all individual loops) + (sum of
non touching loops)-
products of all possible combination of two
possible combinations of three non-
Kg
(sum of gain products of all
Definitions connected with S.F.G. touching loops) +...
touching the
1) Node:- It represents a system variable and is equalto sum A Value of A for that part of the graph not
the incoming signals.
k forward path. following
2) Branch :-A signal travels along a branch from one node
t
another in the direction indicated by branch arrow and in the proceset
Q.1. Draw the signal flow graph with the help of
and
of cause effect
relationships:
gets multiplied by gain of the branch.
3) Input node :- A node with only out going branches.
previous S.F.G. x1 is input node).
4) Outputnode: A node with only incoming branches. . X2 =t12X1 +t42X4
xs is output node).
(In previous S.F.G. X3 =tg3Xg+t13X1 +t23X2
5) Path:- It is a traversal of connected branches in
the directio X4=tg4Xo +t34Xg tls4¥s
of branch arrows, such that is traversed more than
once.
6) Forward path:- It is a path from input
node to output node.
Xs = t15X1+ t4sX4
) Loop:- t is a path which originates and
same node.
terminates on the X=to6Xo+ ti6X7 + ts6Xs
(ex. X2 -X3 -X2,
X3-X4 X3 -
previous S.F.G)
8) Non-touching
loops- Loops are said to be non-touching Xg = t787 +ggXo
they do not posses any common
node.
Ex. X2-X3 -X2 and X4 -X4 are a pair oftwo non touching) Ans. The S.F.G. is as shown in figure
VBDCONTROL SYSTE
o6 R
f04
to3
t10
to1x t2 23 *3
s xs ts67 The SFG is
we have
tL2 t76
t64 E=R-CH and C= GE
H
Application of SFG to control system Forward loops loop Gainn
1) R-E-C P =G
Feedback loop Gainn
R G
C 1) E-C-E -
GH
A = 1--GH) = 1 + GH
= 1 By Masons gain formula
A
Find C/R use S.F.G.
C A
A 1+GH
G
R(s)
Procedure. CS)with reference to figure.
1) First
choose the nodes input. Node and output Q.2. Find the transfer function R(S)
node are the
whenever there is a summer the output of summer
-
is taken as node 7
Node G8
R 1
o-
-H4 -H1
-H2
-H3
D, E, F, I and J as shown in
Ans. Marking the nodes of A, B,
Node
figure we have
[Link]. Forward path Path gain
Whenever a signal is being
tapped there is a node. (1) R-A-B-D-E-F-1-J-C P=G1 G2 G3 G4 G5 G6
2) Write the equations
at various node and (2) R-A-B-D-I-J-C P2= G1G2G6G7
set of equations. draw S.F.G. from the P3 = G,G2G3G4G8
(3) R-A-B-D-E-F-J
Loop gain aRDCONTROL SYSTEM / CS-1 (ET/CT) 49
[Link]. Feedback loops
-GGG4G5GgH3 (a) Find signal to noise Ratio, assuming 'R' as input and 'N
(1) A-B-D-E-F-1-J-A
as noise signal, use SFG technique.
(2) B-D-E-F-I-B -
G2G3G4G5H2
(b) Find C/R using block diagram reduction technique.
(3) E-F-E -G4H4 Ans. Making the node (A, B, D) in fig. we have
G5G6H A =R- H C (1)
(4) F-J-F -
B = G1A -
H2D (2)
There are non-touching loops
D= G2B -H3 C+N 3)
A =1--G,G2G,G4G5G6H3 -
G,G;G4GsH2
C G3D 4)
-
GH4-GsGgH
From (1), (2), (3) and (4), the S.F.G. is
A =1 + G1G,G;G,G;GGH3 + G2G3G4G5H2 + QN
G4H4 +G5GgH
R 1 A G1
B D
A =1
The loop shown below is not touching 2nd forward path -H2 H3
:Ap =1--G4H4) =1+ G4H4
Ag =1
- H1
GL
By Mason's gain formula Signal to noise ratio is given by
CS)P A+ P A2 +P3Ag = Output due to signal (R)_CR
H4 Signal to noise ratio
R(S) A Output due to noise (N) CN
CN
C(S) G,G,G,G4 G5G6 +G,G,G,G7((+G4H4)+G,G,G,G,Gs (i) Output due to signal (R)
R(S) 1+G,G2G3G4G5GgH3 +G2 G3G4GsH2 +G4H4 Assuming N=0 i.e. R acting alone
+G5GgH1
[Link]. Forward Path Path Gain
Q.3. For the feedback control system
shown in fig. (1) R-A-B-D-C P = GG2G3
H2 [Link]. Feedback loops Loop gain
+N () A-B-D-C-A -G1G2GH
(ii) B-D-B -
G2H2
Gii) D-C-D -G3H3
There are no non touching loops.
=l-(-GG2G3H1 -G2H2 -G3H3)
H A
=
= 1
1+ GG2G3H| + GzH2 +G3H3
VBT US(ET (ETICT) 51
50 arpcONTROL SYSTEM / CS-I
be the output due to
R. GjG2G3R
Cr Signal to noise ratio R
Let = =
CN G3N
By Masons gain formula
CRPPA CRG1
G2R
A CN N
R G G2 G3 we assume R acting alone i.e. N = 0
CR (b) For finding CIR
1+G,G2G3H1 +G2H2 +G3H3 take off point D beyond block G we have
R G) Moving the
G G2 G3R
G G G3 H +G2 H2 + G3H3
H2/a
R1+
noise
i) Output due to
Assume R =0 i.e. N acting
alone.
CN G3N
N1+G,G2G,H| + G2H2 + G3H3 ...(6) eliminating the
(iv) Combining the two blocks in cascade and
Dividing equation (5) by (6) we
get uCedback loop we have
VBDONVIR EM7CS-T(ETI
GaDCONTROL SYSTEM /Cs-I (ET/CT) 53
52 BDD
G GG3 C Non-touching loops
1+G, G, GaH3 +GzH2 + G3H3 A-B-A (G H3) and D-E-D(G,H4)
GGG3 A-E-A (G3H2) and B-D-B (G4 H4)
1+GG,G3H + G2H2 + G3H3
R . A =1 -(G1 H3 +G2H4 +G3H2 +GH1 +G,G2HiH2
flow graph of a system with +G3G4H3H,) +(G,G2H,H4 + G3G4H,H4)
Q.4. Figure givës the signal
inputs and two outputs. Find
expression for the output C & o
A = 1- G2 H4,
Also determine the condition that makes
C independent of b
Ag=l
2
and C2 independent of R1. H3 This loop is Not-touching forward path.
HL
G1 By Mason's gain formula,
_
CIL A
+P2 A2 [G, (1-G,H4)+G3G,H4]
R1 A A
]R,
.C1 =Gj (G2H4)+G3 G4 H, -..(1)
A
D 2 C12 due to R2 (i.e. R1 = 0)
C(s)-GGG2-R()
....(1)
Similarly, G2H1H2
= U(s) ==0,
C2 G3(1-G,H1)+GjHG2 ]R1 +[G2(1-GH,) Assuming W(s) acting alone i.e. R(s)
SFG becomes CIS)
+G4H3G31R2}
C2 is independent of RI
-G3 H
] G.G, GG4
-
H H2
H2
P G2 L = GG2HH2
A=1- L =1 - GjG2H1H2, Aj=l
By Mason's gain formula.
VBD CS-I (ETN
56
G2 SYSTEM Cs-I (ET/CT)
/
57
BpcÖNTROL
C
US)
-G,GH1H2 A [Link]. Forward Path Path gain
G2 -U(s)
C 1-G G2 HH2
1) U-X1-X 1a+s
(3) overall C(s) is
given by, P2 B3
From (1), (2) and 2) U-X
GG2R()+ GGpH,W(s)+G2 U(s) - B
C(s)= 3) U- X2 X1-X P3
1- G1G2HH2 s(a +S)
we have S.F.G. as
X().
U(s)
a 1+
ts
B 1+ 42
s(a +s).s(a1
1+
a2
s +s)
A =R-Cc ..(1)
at node B By Masons gain formula S-PA+PzA2
R (S) A
B A-HF ...(2)
at node D C) GG2G3+G1G4
D= GB . (3)
R() 1+G,G2G3 +G,G4 + G,G,H + GGgH2
at node E To find the effect of disturbance signal N(s) on the output
E = consider R(s) = 0.
D- H2C (4)
at node F [Link]. Forward Path Path gain
F =G2E 1. N-C -1
Path gain
at node C * (5) Feedback loop will remain the same
1
and hence A will remain the same. The loop
C= G3F+ G4D-N E
From eq. (1), (2). (3), (4)(5) ...(6) shown is not touching the forward path D
and (6) we have the SFG as shown .1 G2
henceA = 1+GjG2H G1
GL
By Mason gain formula
-H1
C)P PALl+G,G,H)
R E F
N(s) A A
1
1+G G2 G3H3 +G3G4 H2 +G5H| +G, G2 G3G4G5
[ET S-02)
- G2G,G4G6 -GiG2G3H3 -GH
0.9. For the block diagram shown in figure, draw signal
Ans. S.F.G. is as follows.
G6 graph and hence find the closed-loop transfer function using
flow
Mason's gain formula. [ET W-00, 02, CT W-03]
4
G1
/2 54 G5
H2
H3
A =1-(Sum of all single loops) + (Sum of gain products of sX2(-B, X1 ()+21 U() ....i)
twonon-touchingloops)-(.. X26)=2x,6)+LUG) ..(ii)
1--G,H-G2H2-GzH3-G^H3H2Hi) + S
=
-B2
1-s(B +5)
1+
B
B+)
loop:
a0$:
3td loop has common nodes With I" and
2 =0:
ulu A=l-(aj1 ta22 +a12a21)+ (a11a22)
GIS)
cCS)
RS)
Mj =bja12 A 1
HS)
y2 M14 ba12 G(s)
1) Sensitivity of T(s) with respect to
I-(a11 +a22 +a12a21)+ a1a22
o100
u2lu-0
;A Remains same
ST o change in T
%change in G G x100
, M1 =b2 :;
A =l-a11
G
y2
u2
b21-a1)
1-(aj1 +a22 taj2a 21)
a11222
s ST
G
G
T
CONT SYSTEM / CS-I (ET/CT)
68 VBD 69
Expression for Sc 8T
x 100
8T G T H
So5G T SH
x 100 8HT
H
G
we have,
T ST
R 1+GH
(1+GH) 1-GH
Expression for SH
Closed loop systemn
T H
G
ST
(1+GH)
shH T
G
G (1+GH T 1+GH
also
1+ 1+GH
8T0-G.G
SH (1+GH)
-G2
(1+GH)2
:. From (1) (2) and (3) -
G H
.1+GH=
(1+GH)2G/1+GH)
(1+GH)2 1+GH GH
sh11+GH
-
T G
i.e. system isvery sensitive to parameter changes in feedback.
3) Sensitivity of T w.r.t parameter K
TG sT = ochange in T
SK
also 8T % change in K
&G -1
S =1 for open loop
system
8G ST
x
T
100
8T K
Thus the sensitivity SK T
of closed loop K x 100
variation in G i.e. SG system with respect to
isreduced by K
a factor 1
+ GH as compared careful selection of the
that of open loop system. A closed loop system requires up of
2) Sensitivity component since G(s) is made
of T(s) with respect of the feedback sensor H(s)
to H(S) elements wicn
S =o change in T Power
elements and H(S) is made up of measuring
is far less cOStuy
To change
in H e at low power level. Also the selection of H(S)
than
that of G(s) to meet the exact specification.
VBDFON OL SYSTEM/CS-I( SYSTEM/ CS- (ET/ICT) 71
70 ton cONTROL
same element:
Q.14. State true or false and justify the 2) Spring
ack path
)The effect of parameter changes in feedback path of
ar
(2) Damper
-
K
(3) Spring.
1) Mass element (kg) :-
F T=K(01-02)
M Where,
K = Torsional stiffness N-m/rad.
3) Damper
element
F ma = m dx
dt2
e2
VBDCONTROL SY 73
cONTROL SYSTEM/CS-(E
VBIFO cS-ETIO
72
CS)-C(6) = K
S+O
T=F0-02) R()
where F = Viscous friction co-efficient These are two alternative forms of expressing a transfer
of c s =-0a, G(s) tends to infinity, so it is known as the pole of
Q.15. Establish mathematically the superiority the close function. At
to while t=4 is known as its time constant. The dc gain of
loop control system with reference
signal the system,
) effect of disturbance
(ii) effect of system dynamics. W-9 the system is
ET
Figure shows se =
Ans. (i) Effect of disturbance signal:- the
F G)=K
signal Tp in the for
orwar
of closed-loop system with the disturbance
With the feedback loop closed, the closed-loop transfer function is
path. K
C($) K
The ratio of output C(s) to the disturbance signal Tp (s),
whe
.....i)
R(s) TS+(1+K) s+ (+K')
R(s) = 0, is obtained by applying the signal flow gain to the graph o
figure and is given by K/1+,T¢1+K) i)
TcS+1
Cp) -G2(S)
Tp6) 1+G (s) G2 ($) H(S) From equations (1) and (i1), it is found that effect of closing the
loop, that is, introduction
of negative feedback is to shift the system's
9TpIs) pole from-a to
-
(a+K) -
or a(1+K); alternatively to reduce the
T
system time constant from t to
(1+K)
RIs) Els Cis CIs)
Q.16. Why positive feedback is generally not used in control
611s) G21s)
systems? ICT S.04]
Ans. In positive or regenerative feedback, the output is feedback
-HIs) with positive sign as shown in figure below.
If |G,G2 H6)|>>1 the working range of s, R(S) CIS
G(S
CD) -1
Tp 6) G() H(s)
Thus it is seen that if G,(s) is large, the
effect of disturbance
can be decreased by feedback.
(ii) Effect of system dynamics:- In this case, the transfer function is given by
Consider the single-loop G(s)
feedback system of figure. The open-loop CS).
transfer function of ths
system is R(s) 1-G(s) H(s)
denominator of above equation
cls) nere is a negative sign in
Std wch indicates the possibility of denominator
becoming equal to
which is the
giving an infinite output for a finite input
Cnce
condition of instability.
Fig. A simple feedback system
74 VBD EMT
) CS(ETI ncONTROL SYSTE
CONTROL SYS TEM/CS-1 (ET/CT) 75
BD
PD
loop, the closed-loop transfer function
Hence due to above some reason positive
becomess sensiti.
feedback
ck is
fo
Thus due to high loop-gain proVided by regenerative feedba
"edh
insensitive.
insensitive
to
gener G
is general
s s+s
s+s+50
used in control system. Let s=J
Q.17. What are the advantages and disadvantao. ages =_j)+ jo
.
negative feedback? jo) + jo + 50
Ans. Advantages jo-o
i) System response become fast
ii) Effect of disturbance signal is less
50-0+ jo
=1 rad/sec
ii) Sensitivity due to parameter variation reduces. At 0
j-1 j-1
Disadvantages S 50-1+j 49+j
i) Gain is reduced
ii) Due to introduction of feedback, number of componem
increases. Hence weight, cost and complexity of the system increases
Q.18. Discuss the effect of feedback on:
(i) Speed of Response
s49+ -GH
492+12
-
50
0.0288
HIS)=5
sensitivity of T.F. T(s)= with respect to the variations in
V1 S)
Soln. From figure G(s)= 10
H(s) = 5
when
= 20.
s(s+1) V;1S)
0.8SIs+3 S+4o)
S 1+GH 1+-
10
S+
s(s +1).5
0-25
76 VBD CS-I (ET/CT)
cONTROL SYSTEM / 77
Vo(s) G) vBD DELLINGG OF MECHANICAL SYSTEM:
Soln. T(s)= 1+G(s).H(s) MOD
V,(s) Mechanical systems are of two types
0.84s (S+3)xS* Translational system
A =0.8uHA
G)xs+3
Cl
s+4
(a)
(b)
system
Rotational
Translational system :- This system basically consists of
0.8 uA H(s) = 0.25 (a)
T(s) elements
1+0.2uA three
(1) Mass
Damper
Now (2)
(3) Spring.
T_(1+0.2uA) 0.8 A -0.8uA (0.2A) 0.8 A 1) Mass element (kg) :
(1+0.2uA) 1+0.24A)2
0.8AH(1+0.2uA) M
j .02uA)2
(1+0.2uA) 0.8uA
1+ 0.2pA dx
F= ma = m dt2
Given =20;
S=5%=0.05 2) Spring element:
.0.05=- A=4.75
1+4A 1 X
Prob.3. Select correct answer, out of multiple choice given
below and justify the same briefly.
) The open-loop transfer function of a unity feedback|
system is given by
8 F=K(x1-x2)
G(s)= where K = spring constant (Nw/mn).
(s+1) (s+ 2) 3) Damper element;
The closed-loop de gain of
the system is
(a) 0.8 (b) 4 (c) 8 (d) none of the above. [S-98)
Soln. The closed-loop dc gain
of the system is 0.8 because
1
2
G($)
1+G(s)H) .)
as H(s)=l (since unity feedback).
Putting in above equation
we get 0.8. (
F=f(-*2)
where F= Viscous friction co-efficient (Nw-sec/m)
78
VBD EM/ ICSAI TROL SYSTEM/cS-
(ET/CT)
77
gear radius (T &r2) of
(i) Number of teeth on the surface of
oe
gears.
1 .(1)
N2=distance
= N2I
travelled along the surface of each
gear is same
T= F¢-6,) (i) The
N_
2 N2 T2
W2
W1
..(10)
Electrical Analogue of Gear train Equating (8) and (10)
2
The electrical analogue of such mechanical systems
fig. is a Transformer. For transformer we have
sha.
hown
N
JN2
&
...(11)
These are the quantities obtained when reflecting from gear 2 too
N2
oear 1. Electrical equivalent of equation (11) is equation (7).
Significance
faN2 Te2 a Xe2 For experimental purpose the mechanical elements and variables
replaced by their electrical analogues. In the working range the
Can be
where, result can be transferred to mechanical system as experimentations is
Iel Equivalent resistance of transformer referred easy for electrical
systems.
to prima
side. CONTROL SYSTEM AND COMPONENTS:
SERVOMOTORS:
Te= Equivalent resistance of transformer referred to seconde
Servomotors are the electrical motorS which are used in servo-
side.
systems (used to control angular position, velocity, acceleration).
The general torque equation is
Servomotors can be A.C. as well as D.C. motors. The mechanical
output of AC servomotors varies from fraction of a watt to 100 watts.
T=ja+ fo =J4 de
The A.C. servomotors are used for low power applications.
d2 dt
D.C. servomotors are used in large power servomechanisms and
Ti-J +f, dej vary in size from about 1/20 H.P. to many H.P.
dt2 dt 8)
Requirement and desirablé characteristics of servomotors
de2 The rotor should have low moment of inertia. This is
1)
T2 =J2 24f dt ...9)achieved
(9) by reducing the armature diameter
From Equation (5) 2) It should give high starting torque.
3) The speed torque characteristics should have negative slope.
Rf
-0 f ewton - m
newton- m
to
motor shaft rad/sec
Teferre
Field
windn1m) displacement of motor shaft (rad)
a = angular
e =
Applying K. .L. to field circuit, we have Rsic +Le
dt
transform, we have
Taking Laplace
Es)= Brir ($) + Lf sir (5)
can
This result can be used to advantage in practice as Kh
measured more easily and with greater accuracy than KT. iE(s)Rf 1+sLf 1)
Q.1. Obtain the transfer function of a Field controlled D.c
Servomotor. CE S/94,w/99, S-97, W-9 This Ip will produce a torque
RE
TMKj K2 i ir
ia (Constant) ....(2)
Www TM KT i
where, K = Kj K2ia = Torque constant taking Laplace transform
(2) wehave
of
TM .(3)
Ip()
K
Equation of motion is
Ans. In this type of motor armature current is
kept constant ar
the field current is varied in accordance with
voltage applied to motor as shown in fig.)
the error signal. (I"| dt2 F
Consider a field controlled DC servomotor Taking L.T. we have,
in this system.
R field winding resistance (ohms)
sJe(s) + sf (0)(s) = Tm(
Lf = field winding inductance (henrys). 1
.4)
0() 1
s(sJ + F)
e = field control voltage (volts). Tm () 2J +sF .
From (1),(3) and (4)
NTROL sYSTEMI
VBIFONT
88
CSA
KT SYSTEM/
STEM/CS- (ETICT) 89
aDCONTROL
E) S(Rp+ SLf) (sJ + F) Armature contiontrolled DC servomotor is a closed loop systemn
2)
effect, while the field control DC servomotor iis an
KT/Rf to
m.f. effe
back e.m.f.
control system.
due
s(1+sLf /Rf) (1+sJ/f)
open loop field controlled DC servomotor is
Km time constant of
0(s) 3) The
compared with the time constant of comparable
E(s) s(l+sTf) (1+sTm rally large
gen
controlled motor.
where, Km = Motor gain constant = KT /Rff armature
for low power
field controlled servomotor is used
4) The.
Tr = Field time constant = Lf /Rf
applications,
afions, t
while the armature controlled DC servomotor
is used for
Controt phase
winding
increased by an amount T Rotor
Therefore in armature controll
Ra
motor, back e.m.f. contributes additional Error signat Amplifier Vo
damping over and abovetha
provided by the load friction. So this Referance
enhances the stability of phase
system in which amature controlled motor winding
is used.
On the other hand, field controlled A.C. motors
DC servomotor does Ans. For low power applications in control system,
provide any damping in the system and hence controlled are
preferred over D.C. motors because
the armature ol
DC servomotor provides more
stability than the field controlled D More rugged construction.
1)
rotations into
load
proportionate electrical Power
controller mlifien
Amplifi er
voltage. It has two coils on
it's stator namely reference
coil and the quadrature
Rotor
coil. These coils are
dt
s
e(t)=K K Tachometer conistant in V/rad/sec Kn Ra sKT+fo
f
Ra
e (t)> output voltage in volts.
& 0 any displacement in radians.
T
To obtain the transfer function (s) [Link]
Taking L.T
ref s(1+Tms) +KAKTS
DONTRO
ROL
ROLSTSEAICSA
SYSTEM SYSTEM/CS4 (ETICT)
102 .SYSTEM/CS- 103
CONTROL
-K ,T J29 FIt) K K2 8
K -(K+sF+s2 Pe M1
-K -(3 +K)(K+sF+s°]
K-K+sF+s*12|
we have
KT(s) F.B.D,for mass M
From
o (y+K)K+sF+s12)-K2
FO-ka1-
dx
a-z)
=M.d'
K
T slh+s'F+s"04K+/28)+sFK+R a{
Ft=M +kx
+
B+k -*2) )
have
For
mass M we
T) kx-2)=M2
followin
0- M2k2(1 -2) 2)
Prob.2. Find the force voltage analogy of the
ET-W-03,S-4
dt
analogy to equation(1) and (2)
Applying force voltage
system.
We have,
...3)
M L
dt
My
FItL .4)
0L22
dt
C2
M2
we havefrom (3)and(4
=i and q=|[Link]
dt
Soln. The force voltage analogy is as follows.
L1 C1
w-
R L2 At X1
+ k1x + B +B12 -X2)
C23 R M3 .)
equationof
pertormance for the.
the given syste BDAlso,
106
Writing the = Mx)+ Fx(t)
+kx(t) + kx(t)
Soln. F()= R2i2(t)
Laplace domain. Fs +2k)x (s)
in (s) = (Ms* +
or R212
(Ms2 +Fs+2k (5)
=
M
i.e. I2(5) R2
l2(s) in equation (4) we get,
L Substituting this value of
R.
Ms2+Fs+2kkRC+ ()
M- 2 (s2RLC+sL +R) k2
Coil
E;(s)
X) k2
(RM+2kCRL + FL
)-12(6)] .(1) E:(s) sMCRI +s° (FCLR+ LM) +s4
E)=RI6)+ +kik2CR+s(FR+2kL + kjkz)RL
sLla)2)-1) Prob.5. A d.c. motor
with fixed excitation has a
moment of
10N-m-
2) = 6 x 10kg-m2 and friction of 3 x
-skjX($) =-E, (s) inertia Jm of JL = 400
motor drives a load having an inertia
e)=k1 sec/rad. The
a reduction
200 N-m-sec/rad through
kg-m and a friction of is required to
Substituting the value of
100 1. If an armature current of 0.4 amp
gear of
1 N-m. Find the
response of the output speed
(2) from equation (1), we get, produce a torque of to the armature
2)-I)] in equation
input of1 amp is fed
at load and when a step steady state
generator. Find also the
sLI2)+RI6)-E;()=-sk,X(s) from a constant current
Substituting for from equation (2) in equation (1), speed in r.p.m. at the motor shaft.
I(s)
we get, Motor
E) N2
or
WL
(sL+R+sRCL) I,(s)+(sR,RC
+ sk)x (s) = E;(s). (4
108 VBD I CSAETI
STEMTCS-I(ET SYSTEM /CS- (ETICT)
ncONTROL
VoDco
Soln. We have m
m N2 100 S) 2.5
25
109
I (s) (0.1s+0.05)
moment of inertia of motor and load (s +0.5)
Jm. Equivalent relere = step of amp
1
i
to motor shaft.
) S
mm+ J 25
s(s+0.5)
6x 10-2+1
100
400 - A
s+0.5
B
kg - m 50 50
m0.1 m (s)= S s+0.5
= equivalent viscous friction c0-efficient of motor and Using partial fraction, we have
gear refer to motor shaft. A 50, B =- 50
Taking inverse Laplace transform, we have
2
Fa 50e 0.5t
N2 F n (t) = 50
Also we know,
2
=3x102+ 200 LNL=
N2 100
100
Fm0.05N-m-sec/rad.
Equation of motion is given
by,
L100 0m
dmFmea OL 50 (1 -e0.3t
100
mm=T= KTia ..1)
T KTia OL = 0.5 (1-eu.5t
when,
i =0.4 A Steady state speed of motor is given by,
T 1N-m Steady state speed = lim m)
KT == 2.5 rad/m.
a 0.4
50 (1 - eu.) = 50
Taking L.T. of equation =lim
(1) we have
s m
m) + Fm,
n($) = KTla(s) inr.p.m. (: N =
60 x
0 r.p.m.)
m) KT 2 Tt
I)s smeFma
eq Steady state speed =
50 x60 477 r.p.m.
210
V'DL EMICSAETI
SYSTEMI CONTRUL 111
110 CS-( BD
Prob.6. A simple voltage regulator
system is show
infig
own Vp=ip Rp+l diF
E
output terminals of theA dt
potentiometer is used at the he generator
tant (K Vr(s)= Ip(s) Rp + Lpslp($)= IF(s)(Rp +
givea feedback voltage KV,, where K is a constant (K. s
1).
sLp)
Now
lim
S0
Vo
VBTONTROL SYSTEM/CSA(ETICH
Kg /Rp + sLF
thene
BDCO
ONTROL SYSTEM/CSA (ETICT)
We know V.)=
50
, S
V,6)=250
20x
113
V) KAKg 280 =
20x 50
V,) RF+ SLp + KAK,K So 100 +2000s
50 1000
V, 280 [V,-25)
100
50 V = 53 volts
KAK 50 x 20x
cWhen the system is operated at open loop we want
-
S
V,(s) S
Rt sLp +KAKK 100+200s+100k
lsRg
From (1) Vglsl=Els)
KA
s 7'tls)
SX 50 x 20 x
Rp+SL
limV 250
S-0 100+ 200s+1000 K
Vo (oo)
250=20X 50 x50
= 250 when I =0
100+1000K when I
V=E. Fromblock diagram,
=0,
K= 0.1 VV,(s)RpKAK
We want Vo 250 +sLf
when I =30 A. Therefore,
we have
egV+lL Ra
E, should be more Vo )AV/s R +sLF
So Rp + sL S0 100 + 200 s
KAKg
Eg6) 20 x 50 V
Rpt sLp IV,6)- KV,($) 250=
100
V =250
114 VBD CON 115
=
e eiC
= 30 A, also
when, I terminal voltage, E(s)= Ei(s) -
E,(s)
change in
ILRa =30x 1 =30V 2)
(AV)= egKglp
Change in voltage
=-30V
voltage)
there is drop in terminal voltage).
-ve sign indicates that system shown in the fi IF() 3)
control
Prob.7. In the speed
the
constant is negligible.
generator field time e(t)= K,o
block diagram of the
system and [Link]
a) Draw the
transfer function o ($)/ ;(S),
where o is the load speed. E-K(s)
4)
system originally at rest a control voltage e.s
b) With the diagram is as shown in figure
load speed wi The block
suddenly applied. Determine how the
100 v is
change with the time.
e K,o
Given-J=6 Kg
-m E, K
(s)
KA 4Amp/ Volt
KT 1.5 N-m/amp., Kg = 50 VIAmp.. We know that
KT
V/rad/sec. K =
K = 0.2
From the block diagram,
we have
Ra
Ials) Tis
Els) Fls Eds ws
Jachometer
Ebls
en9 ebMoto
LOAD
Etls
a(s) KT/[Link] KT
e Eg(s) 1+ K K;/ Js. R sJR + KbKr
s) 4x 50x 1.5
Tor que
E;(s) sx 6 x1+ 1.5 x 1.5 + 4 x 50 x 1.5 (Nim)
3000
(s) 300
Speed ir p. m.)
E; () 6s+ 62.25 function of a.c. servomotor is given
Soln. We know that transfer
os) 50
E (6) S+10.375 by es)= km ...(1)
V (s) s(1+s Tm)
b) os) 50
k
km = motor gain constant
E;(s) s+ 10.375 where, km F - m
50 27Tx 3000-314.159 rad/sec
(s) = E() 27tNo
s+10.375 Also Wo
60 60
E(s) =100/s =1.739 x103
o(s)=30x 100 5000
K==
Ei 115
s(s+10.375) s(s+10.375) 0.2 6.36 x 10
B
m 314.159
o(s)=+
A 481.92 B
10.375
=-481.92 km
Wo
F-m
-=0-(-6.36 1.739x 10-3
x 10*))
. F 0)
481.92
-
481.92
o(s)=
S S+10.375 km 2.734
{(ETICTy CONTROL SYSTE
118 p 119
Referenece
Vodtage
mF-m
Ix10-5
1x 10 0.0157 sec
0-(-6.36 x10*)
given by ve
From (1), transfer function is
8M
2.734 Gears
Servomotor
V.(6) s1+0.0157s)
Os
Kn
Vc() s($ m +1)
where, Km =15rad/sec/volt, m =0.15 sec.
AC supply
Thegear ratiosare
=
=1 and
OM 50
Soln. The block diagram of the schematic diagram is shown in
L figure
Km 8m
) If the input shaft is driven at a constant speed of
=rad/sec, determine the value ofthe amplifier gain such that the
steady state error is less than 5°. Find this value of amplifier m50
gain determine the damping ratio and settling
time of the system.
i) If the amplifier is modified by introducing an additional
G(s)=-
s)=ApA m X 0.02
derivative term such that its output is given Tts(1+s2 m)
by
180
Vc)=K ^e()+K,"0 Kp =l volt degree=volt/radian
T
dt
x15x0.02
find the value of Kp such
that the damping ratio will improve to G(s)=80xkA
TTXs(1+0.15s)
0.5.
ICT-S-04 (Sem.))
ess()= 5 =0.08726 radian
180
120 VBIfONTROL SYSTEMIc
ICSAE
121
= YSTEM/Cs-1 (ET/CT)
pcONTROL SYS7 .
But, 0.0872
feedback
Comparing with:standard second order
Where, R
=
T rad/sec.
250, = 6.66 &=240
180xkA Xl5x0.02
lim sG(s) =
and ky =
s-0
.
T(1+0.15s)
2x15.49
6.66
=240
AS4 = 0.2148
'= 15.4919 =15.50
= 1.2 sec.
0.08726 =
54
Eo 0.2149x15.49.
kA
V (t)=kAe(t) +kp dt
o238.716 0n=15.45
2E0, =6.66+114kp Force-Current Analogy: (y> flux linkages)
=0.5
.
[20.5)x15.45]-6.66 =kp 0-CV *Vi* -Va) .(1-B)
114
kp = 0.077 sec. 0-C2V2+RÝ2*V2+2-)...1-B)
R2 L3 L2
Prob.10. Find the force-voltage and Force-current Analn.
logy Network
offollowing system: IET-W-01 3
21
Mg
Prob.11. Consider the electromechanical system given
X)
B B2 below. Obtain the transfer function ET-S-02
Soln. Following equation will be used for the mechanical
Vi,
system:
For mass-Mj: 0=Mjä +Bj*| +KX| +K2(*1 -X2) .(1)
M
0=L292+R292 +
+2 2-91) 2-A)
124 fONTROL SYSTEM IcSAETIC SYSTEM /CS-1 (ET/CT) 125
cONTROL
Soln. Assume that the back emf induced in the coil Prob.12.'Fi the rce Voltage analogy of the following
[ET S.00]
eb kdx/dt. The electrical equivalent circuit will be, system.
LLLULLLL1L
X(5)
Ck=ks
dt
R
R
wwm
Ft
V,6=Rl)+)-a6)
SC
() (1)
For second loop: Soln. The force voltage analogy is as follows
1 1)Force (F)> Voltage (V)
-e =RI2(6)+126)-1()
SC
2) 2)Displacement (x) Charge (Q
3) Mass (M) > Inductance (L)
Solving (1)& (2); I,(s)=S)e, (RsC+1) 4) Friction cofficient () Resistance (R
RsC+2R 5) Spring stiffness (k) Reciprocal of capacitance (1/C).
Now force (F) on mass M is related to coil current by;
F)ai2() ie. F()=K,i2) ie. F(o)=K^li(0)
k1x M1
x
Also, F(s) [Ms + fs +k] X($) d *
d2
B
dt
Kl2(s)=[Ms +fs +k] X(s) ...3)
Using (1), (2) & (3);
M M2
[Ms+fs+k] x(s)
=
blV 6)-KsX(s) (RsC+1)
RsC+2R
X(6) Kb
Vi(s) (Ms +fs+K)(R^sC+ 2R) + Khk.s(RsC+ 1) Ft d22
M2
dz
YSTEMICSI
BD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS CS-I (ETICT) 127
126 (ETI VTROL SYSTEMI
CONTA
dx2
0-Ma+K2(%2 -X1) 0.2, P-51 some control
dt2 examples of closed loop and open loop
0.2. Give E-W-99
equation (1) will become
By above F-V analogy, system.
1
/03, P-71
Differentiate open-loop control system and
closed loop
.3. [CT-S-03
control system.
IQ5, P-10 ICT-S-031
TF of figure (a).
Prob.1. Find out the
0-sLla)+ 9-1) 4)
Prob.1, P-13
the network show
e ()for
These equation (3) and (4) can be drawn in the form of electrica transfer function
analogous circuit as shown below.
Prob.2. Find the
IET-S-02
Steam Vatve toa
ntrol below.
boiler Stealm Furnacee
[Prob.3, P-15 block
advantages and disadvantages of
x(t Heating Prob.3. What are the IET-W-00
M,mK diagram reduction technique?
E [Prob.10, P-23] block diagram
Relay controlling Steam block equivalent using
Solenoid outlet
Themocouple Prob.4. Find the single ET-S-04)
Amplfler reduction technique of the
following one
IProb.11, P-231 system
diagram of the multi loop
Prob.5. Reduce the block E-S-981
shown in figure.
IProb.12, P-25] it.
block diagram and reduce
Prob.6. For the fig, draw the IET-S-99J
KT =
1.5 N-m/amp., Kg = 50 VIAmp. Prob.11, P-123]
Prob.24. Find the Force Voltage analogy of the following
Ki = 0.2 V/rad/sec. [ET S.00]
system.
Friction is negligible. W-9 [Prob.12, P-125]
[Prob.7, P-114
Prob.21. In the position control system shown, the sensitivityot
the synchro error detector is 1 Volt/deg. The transfer function ofth
motor is
M) Km
Vc) s(s 2m +1)
RESPONS OF
F F.C.S. D
is a constant. For
A = 1, the function r(t) is known as unit
where A
where
function. By definition of Laplace
transform,
TIME
Controi:
trol Systems: step
Feedback dt = A
Response of
Time response
response is the
Time
ion of oulpu
L[r = J r)" S
Time Artt
rt)
respect to time. ust
usually divided function This function tAt
variable with control system is intotwo i) Ramp
value of r(t) is
se ofthe
response described in figure. The
Time
is then increases linearly
parts Transient
response C (). ezero fortt<0 andequations
for defining this
The
1) response Css (t). with time.
2)
Steady state
response C()=
onse C(t C ()+Css (t). function are: 0RAMP FUNCT1ON
Mathematically, time
the response
the response, that goes r() =0 t<0
response: t is a part of to
r (t) =At t>0
Transient Lim (t) = 0.
toCr the function.
becomes large 1.e. where, A is the slope of
zero, as time response- It is ked response, when time A =1, the function is known as unit ramp
function. By definition
Steadystate For
Eor
transform,
of Laplace
reaches infnity. Order of the system is tho ighest
system
Order of the J r()e" dt f Ate" A
power of s'in the
system
characteristic: equation (i.e. 1+G($)H(S=0
function are:
follows: t<0
described
r () = 0
i) Step function:- This is Arlt)
in figure. The value of the function r(t) r () = At t>0 PARABOLIC FUNCTION
1
remains zero for 0, which increases where, A is a constant. For A =
t<
instantaneously from zero to A for t> 0.
this function is known as unit parabolic function. By definition of
STEP FUNCTION =
r() = 0 1<0
r(t)=A t>0
L[r( = r(t) estdt = Aes" dt 3
S
0
Also
E(s)= R(s)- C(s) H(s)
C(s)= G($) E(S)
Ramp function
r=At t>0
R(s) 4 Es)= R($)-G) E$) H(6)
s
E(s) [1+ G(s) H(S)] = R(s)
Parabolic function r (t)=0 t<0
r(=At t>0
R()= 4s° E(s)
R(s)
1+G(s) H(s)
iv) Impulse function:
Els) Cs)
It is definedas R$)
r)=s ()=1 t=0
0 t#0
The function has a unit value only fort = 0. In practical cases
cases Fig. Canonical diagram
apulse whose time approacheszero is taken as impulse function. is used, the expression is
Lfr(0)] =L6 (1) =1 Ifpositive feedback
R)
E)- G(S)H{S)
t St1
Combining
ES)1+
R(S
G(s) H(s)
)
H(s) =l]
Lt=0 [For a unity feedback system
Es)=R) i)
1tG(s)
feedback). In time domain
Fig. Impulse
input (Negative sign a used for + ve
Steady State Error e:
It is defined as thedifferencebetween
e(t)=LE)
time. Steady state
the desired system output, as
actual system output and
and is the expression of
error valid for all
t->o [as 't becomes largel.
It is the error is defined as
measure of system accurac i.e. system's
steady state performance.
"here are two methods for evaluating the Css t L
o e(1)
e Transtorm
Laplace
I. Error constant method From the final value theorem in
2. Error series method
138 CSJCSETICTn CONTROL SYSIEN
SYSIEM/ 9T(G7C) 139
Steady state= e (t)= s0 E(s) D Method:
Ess error Error Series IET-S.97]
nethod
[Link] the drawbacks of above method.
5E(S) This
ess
R)W6) =
sR(6) E)11+G($).H(s)J 1+G(s).H(s)
ess 0 1+G(s) H(6) series is defined as
The error
Error Constant
Method
r() + C1r()+()+ nl
n!
() +.
G(s).H(s) is given by es
In general, the loop T.F.,
K1+T s)1+T2 5)...1+Tm s)
d r(
dr(; fr(t) =.
Gs).H(s)= (A) (T) dt dt
s'1+Tís)1+T2 5)..1+Th s) coefficients
K'( + Z1) (s +22).(s +Zm) C eror
s(s +P) (s + P2)..(s + Pn) (B) Co
Li
0 We (s)
Gain; T= dWs) ..C=m dW, ()
Equation (A) is the time constant form; K = me
Co =
Lim
ds"
ds
constant Type of Input:
Equation (B) is the pole zero form;z= zeros p = poles Steady State Error and
[1] Type of C.S. : [CT-S.03 ) Step Input:
magnitude A is applied)
origin gives the type of the (A step of
Number of poles at the control
system. Above equation represent type T system. It means there are Here ()= A rr(t) = 0
t>0
t<0
T number of integrations in the system.
[2] Order of C.S. R)
Total number of poles in the loop T.E. represents the order of A/s
the system. Above equations represent nh order system. By eqn. (), ES)1+ G(s) H($)
Q.2. What are the advantages and disadvantages of statie
SE($)
cc
error constant? [ET-W.00,02,CT-W.02 ()
Ans. Advantages A A
i) Give idea about steady-state error. Lt S
s0 1+ G (s)H(s)
i) Used for three standard test inputs.
Disadvantages: A
Lt
G) The important time variation of error is
ess () $-0 1+G(s) H(S)
not known.
(ii) The exact quantum ot error is not specified A A
being extreme ess(0)
value of 0 or o. 1+ Kp
LG$)H6)
1+ s-0
VBDOÇONTROLSYSTEM/EMI CS-(ETIC SYSTEM/CS-I (ET/CT)
140
Constant Kp Of a
system is
stem defined
Cs.I
definea qBD on
CONT OL sYS
CONTROL 141
esss-+0
Lt sE(6)
ess A
ka
.(iv)
s0
Lt
14 G(s) H(S) c
LL A
S
s 1+G(s)H() s-0 S+s G(s)H(s)
A A
ky
1+sG(s)H(s)
ess A ii)
Ky
22 Type K 0 C6)C(s)s(1+Ts)
One T
3 Type
Two
K co1 Take inverse Laplace Transform
R(s) Clc)
Fig.i)
C(s)
R(s) Ts+s+ Ky s2+s+
k+ST s
k/T C(s) Kv/T (1)
+
s(s+ k/T) R6)2
A=s.C() -o =1 C(s)
ons + @ 2 2
B (s+k/T) .Cs) -k/T-1 R(s) s+2
CONTAUL E/C)
BD 137
136 VBFONTROL SYSTEM/CS (ETICT Derivation of steady state error:
respor is important
Table 1 The steady state to judge the accuracy
The difference between the steady-state of
Excitation Functions output. response and
Defining Laplace the erence gives the steady state error.
[Link] Excitation
Transform
Functions
Equations of InFigure E(s) = R(s) - B(s)
Functions B(s) = C(s) H(s)
t<0 But
Step function |r (t) = 0 R(s) = A E(s)= R(6)- C(s) H(s)
r ()=A t>0
Also
C(s)= G(s) E(s)
2 Ramp function r() 0 t<0
R(s) = E(s) = R(5)-G(s) E(s) H(s)
r () =At t>0
E(s)[1+G(s) H(s)] = R(s)
Parabolic function r()=0
=At
t<0
t>0
R($) = 2A
E(S)1+G(s) H(S)
R(s)
r ()
iv) Impulse function Es)
It is defined as Rs) C(s)
B(S)
r(t)=s(t)=1 t=0
t#0
cases
The function has a unit value only for-t 0. In practical
==
Fig. Canonical diagram
a pulse whose time approaches zero is taken as impulse
function.
If positive feedback is used, the expression is
L[r()] = L () =1 R($)
E6)1- G($)H(S)
(t St=1 R(s)
Combining E(s) = -
1)
1t G) HS)
=0 [For a unity feedback system H(s) = 1]
E(s)=R(s) (i)
1+G6)
Fig. Impulse input (Negative sign a used for +ve feedback). In time domain
Steady State Error less : e (t) =L" E(s)
It is defined as the difference between actual system output and
and is the expression of error valid for all time. Steady state
the desired system output, as t-c [as t becomes large]. It is the
error is defined as
measure of system accuracy i.e. system's steady state performance.
There are two methods for evaluating the ess ss e(t)
1. Error constant method From the final value theorem in Laplace Transform
2. Error series method
138 VBfONTROL SYSTEM/ CS cONTROL SYS
S 139
(ETICT Method:
pD
stateLte (t)= 0 S E(s) Error Serieseliminates the drawbacks of above ET-S.971
ss =Steady
error
This
nethod method.
t
sss>0 SE(s) R(s); We(s) =.
E) 11+G(s).H($)J 1+G(s).H(s)
sR(s) is defined as
Csss0 1+ error series
G(s) H(S) The
A) dt
s'(1+T s) (1+T% s).(1+Th s) errorcoefficients
C
K' (s +Z1) (s+22) .StZm , (B) Co 0 We (s)
s(s+P1) (s + P2)..(+Pn) d"W.(s)
Equation (A) is the time constant
form; K = Gain ;
T- time
Lim d We (s) CLim
Co s-0 ds ds"
constant Type of Input:
zero form; z= zeros; p = poles Steady State Error and
Equation (B) is the pole
[1] Type of C.S. ICT-S.03] () Step Input:
magnitude A is applied)
the type of the control (A step of
Number of poles at the origin gives r(t)=
.
Here
A t>0
system. It means there are
system. Above equation represent type 'J r(t)= 0 t<0
J'number of integrations in the system. A
R()
[2]Order of C.S. S
Total number of poles in the lóop T.F. represents the order of A/s
the system. Above equations represent n order system. Byeqn.(i). E(s) 1+ G(s) H($)
Q.2. What are the advantages and disadvantages of static
error constant? [ET-W.00,02,CT-W.02
es()=0 sE()
Ans. Advantages:
LL
A
s ess14k
(i) Give idea about steady-state error.
s-0 1+ G (s)H(s)
i) Used for three standard test inputs.
A
Disadvantages: ess
(i) The important time variation of error is not known.
)s-0 1+G(s) H($)
(ii) The exact quantum of error is not specified being extreme A A
ess(t)=.
value of O
or Cs I+s0G($)H(s) 1+ Kp
I40
VBIFO
ÇONTROLSYSTEM/ SYSTEM/CS-1 (ET/CT
SYST 141
ETIC CONTROL
NTROL
BD
The Position Error Constant kp
ess
.i)
Define the velocity error constant k, as
k 0G6)H)
k,08G)HG) Effect of type of system on ess:
(3) Parabolic input:
i,'1 From above derivations: -
Velocity Error G)
2. ky S.G(6)H(6) where in,
constant ky H(s) = 1
Accelerationk
Eror constant
ka os G(s) H(s)|
T(s)
C6)
R(s)
Ka = closed-loop T.F. = Gs) 1 1
No. Kp ss K, Ess Ka
ss i.e. R(S) =
R(s) in unit step input;
Type K A1+ K 0 If
Zero
C(s)
2| Type K 0 s(1+Ts)
One
0 C()
C(s)= T Take inverse Laplace Transform
3 Type 0 K 1+Ts
Two K
Table ii) c(t) = 1 -e-t/T
This is the output
response of the system. The variation of
Reduction of steady state error can be done by,
-
ET-W.98] dt
Ans. The order of a system equal to the number of poles in that
Att=0; c (0)=0
system. Hence response of a higher order system will be same as the
responsecurve, figure(b)
effect of a adding poles to that system. And dc=i=
dt T
Slope ofthe
Time Response of 1*order system
Ast oo; c(t) 1
R(s) cic)
Fig.i)
s=Eon-j o,v-E2
- Left Half Plane Right Half Plane
J
Q.6. Derive the expression for the output of a second order
underdamped system to a unit step unit. (ET-W.97,01]
Ans. Time Response of a Standard 2nd order under
Ct)i-e
I-2
-50.t
sin n i-g? tan
Damped System to Unit Step Input:
150 VBTFONTROL STEMI cONTROL SY 151
CS ETICT yBD
This is the equation for the output response standard
of standar 2nd uild up time t,: Time required for the step excited
vi) increase from zero to final value when
order unity feedback system when excited by a unit step input, outp to the increase
system stant rate and is equal to the maximum value of the actual
cons
-
knoOw
e at at a rate, is known as build up time.
or C() = 1
sin[wat+0]., s
increase shoot : The ratie
shoot: ratio of the maximum value of the step
vii) Over the final output is known as overshoot in the
system outpt
oltput to
specilications
Q.7. Give the different time response specifications ang excited The centage overshoot in the system is defined by
[ET-S.99, 02,W.91 system. Maximum output overshoot for step input
their formulae.
overshoot = Final value of output for step input x100
Ans. Time response specifcations %
ii) Settling time ts: The time required tozthe system output
to settle down and stay within + 29% of the final value, is known as
al t=t C(t,)=1
-E0,t
settling time. sin (at, +0)
1= 1--
iv) Peak time t,: The time required for the system output to 1-
reach the first maximum value, is known as peak time. -E0,tr
v Duplicating time tp: The time required for the system .. sin (at,+0)=0
output to reach the final value for the first time, is known as
duplicating time.
-E
-E0nr0
152 ONTROL SYSTER
cSAETi
VBD SYSTEL CS-I (ET/«
coNTAOL
SYSTEM/ 153
sin (oat +0) = 0
gBD
Oat +0=T atp =T
weare considering instant after zero, it is n
y- atna=2. 27 2Tt
where, 0= tan-1 min
nin 0d o, 1-2
Q.9. Derive the expression for peak time (1,) for second
Sen. OVERSHOOT
I 11 oVERSHOOT
order underdamped unity feedback control system. Cau
Ans. Expressionfor peak time (p):
Differentiating C(t) and equating it to zero we have,
dCO=00
4.0
U
TIL UNDERSHOOT
UNDERSHOOT
dt 1
we have, 21 3T
*o =n V1-E Wd
Wa Wd Wa
e 0t
sin (og t+0)-e5@".o, cos(wt+ 0)=0 peak overshoot (M,) for
Eo. o.10. Derive the expression for
cecond order underdamped
unity feedback control system.
sin (ogt +0)-1-E (ot+6)=o overshoot (M,):
cos Ans. Expression for peak
- cos0,-E3 =sin S%Mp
C(t)-C() x100
C()
cos sin (ogt +0)-sin 0 cos (@at +0)=0
= -@n 'p.
sin @at 0 e
CO=CO l=t,=1-* sin (oa tp +0)
@at =n7 (1) 1-E2
where, n = 0, 1, 2, -....
at t= tp, the first maxima or peak occurs, n =1,
sYSTEM/ CS-I (ETICT 155
cONTROL
154 VBIFONTROL SYSTEM/cS-(ETIC
Derive the expression or settling time (ts) for seco
CS >n
E/ 2.11.
[Link] feedback control system.
Cp)=1eTy- sin d +0 order. Expression for settling time: -
1- ns. e,t sin (at, +0)
c0 -E2
tolerance band at t = ts
=1- sin(-sin 0) For 2%
C(t)
-E 1-32
= 0.02
_zE small
Ct)=1+
v-2 is
-51
Ctp) =1 +e
TE/-52
-0ts 0.02
Also C(c) =1
Percentage overshoot is given by, 4 for 2% tolerance band,
100 x
Cp)-C(o)
ts
n band
M, For 5% tolerance
% = -
C(oo)
3 for 5% tolerance band,
=100 xtet $//1 -
-1
Time constant of second order system is T=
Mp
=100 eT3/Vi -2 n
y=Mp and the duration of the
transient 1.e. the settling time ts is four times
100
the time constant of
the system during which the transient error is
reduced to less than 2 percent of its initial value. During this time t,s.
= Lim
s10
=0 G(s) H(s) =lim
s +3s3+10
+3s3+10
s-0 ([Link]+1) Kp s0 s(s+5)(s+10)
r()=atat+ a2t Kp
ess =ess due to a,u(t) +ess due to ajt +ess due to a,t2
lim s G(s) HIS)
lim s+3s+10
s02(s +10)(s +5) ]
Ky s0
ess
1+Kp
Ky = o
+10]
2 =co H(s) = inS+3s3
0 s Gs)
k, limsG6)
= H S) s0 (s+10)(s+5)
The steady error equal to infinity implies that es continuously
10
increases with time. 0+0+10
Prob.2. Refer to the system slhown in figure. (0+10) (0+5)50
S
Cls) 0.2
RIs) ka
S+ 10
Steady state error due to r(t) = I+2t
+3t2 is,
essess due to 1. u(t) + ess due to 2t + ess due to 3t
St3 1 -+
s+5 1+Kp Ky Ka
6
10 1+ 2 0.2
SS+5) ess=0+0+30
Obtain steady state error for input ess30.
r(t)= 1+2t +3t2 Prob.3. G($)2 10(S+1).Find for unity feedback
Soln. The feedback loop is in parallel. From figure. s (s+2)(s+10)
H(s) 10 +S+3 () Type of system, (i) Error coefficients.
s (s+5) S+5 (ii) Steady state error for i(t) =1+4t+ t' /2.
sss +3)+10
(s+5)
+3s+10
s(s+5)
Soln. () We have,
[ET-S.03,CT-S.04]
164
VBIFONTROL SYSTEM/CS SYSTEM/CS-1 (ET/CT) 165
cONTROL
= 10 (1+s)
G) H) D 100
sx 21+0.5s)
0.5(1+s)
(10) (1+0.1s) G (s) Hs)
=
s(1+[Link])
s. G(s) H(s)
(i) Kp = lim G(s)H(s) = lim 0.5(1+s) K, 0 s.100 100
S0 s-0 s(1+0.5s) (1+ 0.1s) lim 100
S0 S(0.1s+1)
Kp
=100
0.5(1+s) Ky
K=0 SG($) HS)=
s0 s(1+0.5s)(1+0.1s) lim Ss.G(s) HS)
= lim s2.100
s(0.1s +1)
= 0
ka 0.5 2.3
Css 1+Kp K&y Ka
(iii) Steady state error due i(t) =1+4t
+is given by,
1 2
ess=ess due to u(t) + ess due to 4t+ ess due to ess1+ 100
2 o.
1+Kp
+ ss
Prob.5. Open loop transfer function of unity feedback
k
system in G(s) = Determine the factor by which gain
s(Ts +1)
0.5
Y should be multiplied, so that overshoot of unit step response
ss2 be reduced from 75% to 25%. Derive the formula used to solve
Prob.4. For a feed back control system having forward path
k the problem. (ES/95s]
G(s)= and H(s) = [Link] k=100 Soln. Characteristic equation is,
s(1+0.1s)
i) Determine the steady state error, if the input is 1+G(s) H(s) =0
r (t) = 1+ 2t+3t. [ET-S.98] 1+
k
=0
Soln. We have k = 100 s(1+Ts)
100
G (s)=
s(1+0.1s)
and H(s) = 1
0
Comparing with standard characteristic equation,
ONTROL SYSTEM/cS-1 (ET/CT)
166 VBFONTROL SYSTEM/CS 167
I CS-(ETICT Determine the value of gain k for
1)
system to
have a
s +20,s
We have,
+ o =0 mping
ratio of e
r0.5.
value
For the walue of gain k determined in part (1), find
unit step input. the
sponsetoa r
What will be the response,if () = 5u ().
3) Characteristic equation is given by,
Soln. 1)
n 1+G(6) Hs) =0
T k (0.1)= 0
250 1s(1+0.15)
0.1s+S +0.1k=0
2 2 T 2)
s+1Os +k
=0
From (1) and (2), we get Comparing with standard characteri. equation,
s +2o+ Oas +@ =0
We have,
1
= ko =/k
KT =
75
25
05
=
10
oMp, =e
1 0.0911
x= x = 0.05092.
C)=
e$t
sin (gt+0)
Prob.6. For a feedback control system having a forward
sinVI-E2
path transfer funetion G(s) = and feedback path = 10.
s(1+0.1s) 0.5,
H()=0.1
CS-I(ETICT)
M/CS-I
SYSTEM/ (ETICT) 169
CONTROL
in(2) input
standard characteristics equation s +2
We have =1.75
@nS +@
=0, of r
systemis 300
2)
V2)(s +1) (s+ 2) (s +50)
0 =1.32
2E0 =1.5
1.5
_
20 2x1.32
=0.56 SPLANE
de4d=1446 the
dt2 to unit step input,
dt system is subjected
When the
where is the actuating
and r = reference input
signal ='r-0.5 . response was observed
to be
C(0=1-2et/014-t/002
and 0 is the output
Find the value of (1) damping shaft position.
ratio, (2) natural frequencyof
oscillations and (3) damped Determinè
frequency of oscillations. transfer function. frequency of the
Soln. (1) Substituting i) The motor undamped natural
for 0 isthe given Damping ratio and
we get differential equation, i)
system. input.
for unit ramp
d44.8=1449=144
d2*4.84 ii) Velocity error KKAm, H(S)=1
we have G(s) = s(1+Tm)
dt (T-0.5 0) Soln. i) From figure,
d-4.8+
dt2 720(t) =144 r . G(S)1+Km 100
dt TmS)
...1) G(s) H(s) = 0
Characteristics equation is +
1
e(s) 144
sTm+S+100Km =0
R($s+4.85+72 00 Km=0
m=0
The characteristic equation is given
1+- s(1+Tm
by, 100 Km
1)
* 0
Tm
VBD
VBDONIROL SYSTEM
oL SYSTEM/
BD rad/sec
22.36
C()=125 0.25 500 n
sS+10 s+50 s(S+10)(s+ 50) 250, = 60
60
R( -=1.34
32x 22.36
co-efficie (Ky)=LimsG(S) H(S)
500 Velocity eror
i) s0
Cs)s(s+10) (6+50) 500 s.20x5x1/12
R($) (s+10) (s+
50) Ky lim- s(l+s/60)
s-0
S
C6) 1008.33
500
Ky =8.33
R() +605+500 12
L -=0.12.
Comparing with6 CsKy 8.333
R(S)
s +2g0,s +0 Prob.13. A feed, back
system employing output rate
We have characteristics figure.
equation
damping is shown in
s+60s+500=0 of derivative feedback (k9= 0), determine
a) In the absence
From (1) and (2), we have 2 damping factor and natural frequency ofthe
system. What is
the
resulting from unit ramp input?
60 the steady state èrror
which
m derivative feedback constant ko,
b) Determine the
What is the
Ta =0.0166 increase the damping factor of the system to 0.6.
will the
input with this setting of
100Km-500 steady-state error to unit ramp
derivative feedback constant?
Tm system with
steady-state error ofthe
c)Illustrate how the
[Link].-ST reduced to same
ramp input can be
K 100
=3 derivative feedback to unit
damping factor is
maintained at
in part (a), while the
60
value as LW94,9,98, 041
Km=0.0833 0.6?
QC
1
=500
178 VBIFONTROL SYSTEM/ CONTROOL STEM/CS-1 (ETICT) 179
O
D
n
Soln. a) In the absence of derivative feedbackie gain of the amplifier be increased from
Ko=0 Let the
s+2s+ 10=0
characteristic equation is
to
KA
KA = 10 characteristics equation is,
Comparing with s +2g o,s +0 = 0 we ha The
nave
KA
o=10 =V10 =3.162 rad/sec.
s(s+2) = 0
1+
2 2
=0.3162
n V10 1+-
Kos
1 s(s+2)
ess due toramp input is given by ess + KA = 0 ' KKa.
s (2+Ko)s= 2+Ko we want =0.6
Ky = lim s G(6) H(s) = s. 10 and 2 0 Ko .(1)
s (s+2) 2x0.6x VKA = 2+ KA
ess 0.2 lim s G(s) H(s)
==
s0 3
..(2)
also Ky= s0 ss+(2+K0
b) With derivative feedback the characteristic
10
equation, is
. Kv2+Ko we want ess 0.2 . ess =
Kv
=
1+G(s) Hs) 1+SS*2) ...(3)
1+
Kos 2+R0 = 0.2 2+ Ko = 0.2 KA
s(s+2) *K'A
s+ (2+ Ko)s + 10 =
0 From (1) and (3) we get,
1.2 KA = 0.2 KA
Comparing with standard
characteristic equation, 1.44K' = 0.04.K KA =36
2 n 2+Ko and o
=10
we have
also from (1) 2x0.6x V36 = 2+ Ko Ko 5.2
0 = v10 = 3.162 rad sec.
/ system has a dynamic
Prob.14. A simple closed loop
We want to be 0.6.
2x0.6 x V10'=2+Ko response defined by relation
= 1.7947
Ko doddo =
K,(0-0,)
Tm
also, Ky = Lim dt2 dt
50 S G(s) H(s) = 10 constant and Ky is the
velocity
where, Tm is the motor time
2 +(2+Ko)S constant. When this system is
subjected to a unit step input
Ky= 5-0
Lim 10
is given by
+(2+Ko) 01() = u(t), the response obtained
[sin(5.66t +0.927)
1.
10 e
Kv
Av 2+Ko
10
2.63
2+1.7947
0 () =1-1.25
Determine the values of
overshoot, (ii) Settling time,
ess due to ramp input is ess (i) Damping ratio, (ii) Peak
settling time,
(iv) No. of oscillations during EW/97 99]
Ky. 2.6352 0.3794
(v) Steady statetorque..
CONTROL SYSTEMI
180 VBIFONTROL SYSTEMI 181
YBD
CS (ETIC following unity fecdback system
Soln. The given system is a second order system. It Prob.15. For the
ItsTespon
to unit step input is given by, 20
RIS cls
C)=1-
e
sin at+ tan-1 Vl-3
+55+
-3
domain specilications and the expression for
Comparing this with the given response Find the time
unitystep input is applied. ET-W.03,S.04]
C()=1-1.25 e:24 sin (5.66t +0.927)1 output, when a
[Link] quation of the systemis 1+G(s) H(s) =0
we have, 20 = 0
i)
1
C(s)
iv) Number of oscillation during
settling time is given by, in standard form can be written as,
R(s)
N21- N-21-(0.6)2 C)20 X
24
N 0.8488
Tt.(0.6) R(s) 24 2+ 5s+ 24
. C() is given by,
v) Steady state torque =
output which exists in the steady state
condition = ess = =0.1696.
Ct)=20 1 sinsin (ogt+0)
182
C()
C(t)=20
is given by
e5t sin(gt
çONTROL
+0)
TEMI
CS(ETICN CONTRo
BD
0.51 =
-
sYSTEM/cS-I (ET/CT)
0.6=
- Tt
183
=5?
where, e= tan-I V-5 radians 02635(1-
0.02567
-1.1628e2.3tsin (4.2129 t + 1.03)
E = 0.1602
C()=
1= = 0.2, let = 2 and k = k2
k
Mp
02-/-
Prob.16. For the system : G(s) = For
with unity
s(1+ST)
feedback where k and T are constants. If the system overshoot
to be reduced from 0.6 to 0.2, by change in k only, show that:
is
- 1.6094= T
Tk-1=43
Tk2-1 2 0.4559
Also from
(2), we have
k and k2 corresponding k for 0.66 and 0.2 overshoot. [ET-S.04 1
=
Let for Mp 0.6, = 51 and k=kj
TK-8.7412 = 43.3
Tk2-1. 0.2028
184 VBTPONTROL SYSTEM
.
1.20397= Tt
1-E2 .1=0
1+ s(s+1)
0.38323 =
s +s+10=0
by, system is
characteristic equation for closed loop
M, =- 1+G(s) H(s)=0
. 21- 2x0.35781 (0.3578)2
10(1+ K1$)=0
M, = 1.4964 1+
s(s+1)
The resonance frequency is given
by, =
s+5+10+10 K,s 0
o On -
22
s +(1+10 K,)s+10 0
=
= 61-20.3578)2 (given)
0.5
= 5.175 rad/sec.
1+10 Kn
210
186 WAFONTROL SYSTEM/cS-I CONTROL,SYSTEM cS-1 (ET/CT)
(ETICTn 187
Hence 3.162 Kn D Figure ws the block diagram of the system.
1+ 10
Soln. a) Reference
vottage ge
K, = 0.2162 ALead
% Peak overshoot is given by.
=100 enE/y1-3 8M
%Mp Servomotor
Peak overshoot in first case
SYNCHROos
=0.158)=63.76 %
dt (S)_
Determine the value of Kp, such that the damping OR(s)=R
ratio is S 2
improved to 0.5. Does this modification affect the steady-state =skAKM_
G(s) H(s)
error as in part (a)? Also calculate the new settling time and 50 s(l+TmS)
compare it with that of párt (a). sI V/deg = 180/T V/rad, Km =15 rad/ sec/ volt
m
0.15 sec
189
188 VBIFONTROL SYSTEMIcSA sYSTEM/ CS-1 (ET/CT
cONTRO
ETIC
180/n.KA15 KmKs . = 0
G() H6)50s(1+0.15s) (KA +sKp 50s(1+ TmS)
1+
KAKmKs =0
51 [Link]/s4
2+ (50 + KpKmKs)s +
ss 180 Km K_
s0 1+ 180/[Link] .15 .(10 KpKmsss+A
50
1+ s(1+0.15s). 2+(6.66
50 Comparing it with s
+250,s+02=
s +6.66s+ 240.6=0
Comparing with s +2g0,s+ @ o = 240.639
=0, we have
O =240.639 =15.5 rad/sec.
o 240.6
2E@ =6.66+114.59 Kp
o=v240.6=15.5 we want =0.5
20 =6.6. 2x0.5x15.5 = 6.66 +114.59 Kp
6.66 6.66 15.5-6.66=114.59 Kp
=0.214
20 2x15.5
Kp
8.840.077
4
Kp114.59
4
sec.
En 0.214x15.5=1.2 4 4 = 0.516 sec.
E E
0.5x15.5
b) Here, we have
wwwTT 2)-I1()]-12s)SC
sC2
C1
)
EE() (6)]+RI1(s)
C2 R22
eo
-[)-12
sC2
ei
1,6)+ sC2
)-1,()
sC2
22i
on servomechanism show
Prob.21. Measurement conducted
the system response
to be
c(t)=1+0.2 e001.2e-10t
The describing equations for this system are to unit step input.
when subjected
closed-loop transfer function.
G-i2) dt+Rij =€ ..1) ) Obtain the expression for
frequency and damping
(i) Determine undamped natural
ET-W.00,03,CT-W.02,03]
atioof the system.
G-i)d i1 +Ria =0 Soln. We have,
c(t)=1+0.2e-o0t-1.2e-10t
R212 eo ii)
Taking Laplace transforms Taking inverse Laplace transform
of equations (i), (ii) and' (in), |
assuming zero initial conditions, we
obtain
Co)+ 0.2 1.2
Le= S+a
6-l2
sC2 ()]+RI,(s) E;() =
.(iv)
s s+60 s+10
(s+10) +0.2s(s+10)-1.2s(s +60)
S+60)
1)-h())+26)+R2
C SC
+R2 l2(6)=0 .(v)
s(s+60)(s+10)
s+70s+ 600+0.2s2 +2s-1.2s-72s
R2l2 ()=E, (s)
..(vi) s(s +60) (s+10)
193
192 VBIFONTROL SYSTEM/
ICSA(ETiR YSTEM/CS-1 (ET/CT)
SYSTEM/
coNTROL
600
s(s +60) (s+10)
DG6)s(0.5s 1
+1) (0.2s +1)
step input:
R(s)= ess tor
i) sR($)
C(s) 600 600 = lim 1+G(s)H(6)
R(s) s(s+60) (s+10) (s+60) (s +10) S-0
r(0)=u(t) R(s)
Comparing with
Comparing
witR(S)
C) (H(s) = 1)
s2 +2E0s+@n lim
essS0 1+
We have characteristics equation s(0.5s+1) (0.2s + 1)
s+70s +600 =0 s(0.5s+1) (0.2s+1)
Comparing (i) with standard characteristic equation, we have
esslim
Css
0 s(0.5s+1) (0.2s +1)+1
600 ess=0
1
24.49 rad/sec. input (Here r(t) = t, R(s) ==4
i) ess for unit ramp
2g0 =70 = 70 Css limn
s-0 sG(s) H(s)
70 =1.42
2x24.49 1
Prob.22. A unity feedback system is characterised by the
sslim
S-0 1
i) Determine the steady-state errors to unit step, unit ramp (0.5s+1) (0.2s +1)
and unit parabolic inputs = lim(0.5s+1) (0.2s +1)
s0
i) Determine rise time, peak time, peak overshoot and
settling time of the unit step response of the system. IE-W.00 'ess1
Soln. Given: m) ess for parabolic input, here r(t)=
(ET/CT) 195
SYSTEM/cs-1
SYSTE
cONTROL
L
194 VBDçONTROL SYSTEM lcs ypD
Specilications:
= lim-
S
T 1.5707 sec.
s-0 (0.5s+1) (0.2s +1)
ess =0
Prob.23. The system equation is el v1-2 4.321%
% Mp = 100.x
+4+8y=8x. = 2 sec.
dt dt
TsE
-
Find the time domain specifications for unit step input.
[CTS.03
(ogt +B)
Soln. Given :+4+8y=8x C(t)= 1- sin
dt dt
Taking Laplace for zero initial conditions
C0=-1.4le sin(2t+0.7853°)
sY(6)+4s Y(s)+8 Y(s) =8X()
(s+4s+8)Y(6)=8X(6) Prob.24. G(s) =-s(s+4) and H(s) =1
4
(iv) Ts = settling time = 2.002 sec.
rt 23S231+0265
S
55 T305T C(s) 129.72s
R(s) 159.72s+7.8s +690 Ks
C(s) 129.72s
R(s) s(159.72+7.8s +690 Ks)
129.72
[ET-S.977
Soln. Given:block diagram is as follows: 7.8s+690 Ks+159.72
rlt) Comparing with the standard equation
23S Clt
R0265
T0s i.e.
We get,
s+20,s + @n
o=129.72
=11.38 rad/sec.
198 VBFONTROL SYSTEM/ 199
ySTEM/CS-1 (ETICT)
CONTROL S
Prob.26. For a unity feedback system IBD
36
G) = 100x el v-*) 52 Ao a
s(s+0.72) Peak overshoot, % Mp
Determine the characteristic equation that,
of the 1
[Link] We know
calculate the damping ratio, peak time, =
settling time T,
overshoot and number of cycle completed peak Rise time =
before outnt
tput
settled, when unit step is applied to the system.
[CT-S.03
in radians
Soln. Given: G(s) =- 36 NowB=tan
and H(s)=1
s(s+0.72)
1.229
Characteristic equation is given as
= 3.14-1.2 - = 0.32 sec.
1+G(s) H(s) = 0 T, 5.9
system having a forward
1+
36
=0 Prob.27. For a feedback control
s(s+0.72) function
path transfer
s(s+0.72)+36 0 G(s)=K/ls(s +0.15)] and H(s)=0.1
s+0.725+36 =0 Determine the value of gain K for the system to have a
G)
= s+2E0,s+@ 0
T =
W
"
5.9
= 52.45 %
We have, aw =0.1 K
VBDONTROL SYSTEM/I
SYS
SAETIE CONTROL STEM/CS1(ET/CT) 205
ROL
204
= 16.8 a D ess for Ramp input
2(0.5) 4
a =0.23 T-B
=
time, T, ess Ky
Rise
=Lims.G(s) H(s)
where, Ky
p=tan
-=60 S-0
s10 10
= = 10
Lim-s(0.5s+1)(0.1s+1) (1) (1)
=3.464 y S0
1-E 4l-0.25
0.1
-60 16.41 sec. ess
T3.464 ess for
parabolic input
= 0.90 sec. Lims*G(s).H(S)
where Ka =
essKa S-0
10 =0
=Lims2
=100 x el v =8.08 . KaLiSs(0.5s+1)
Ka (0.1s+1)
Mp
4 4 L=2 seC. Ess conducted on a
servomechanism
T 0.5(4) 0.5 Prob.33. Measurements
be
Prob.32. A unity feedback system
is characterized1 ythe show the
error response to
function e(t)=1.66 e
sin (6t +37°)
Determine
open loop transfer sudden unit displacement.
10 is given a
where the input and damped natural
G(S)(0.5s +1)(0.1s +1) damping ratio
natural frequency,
Determine the steady-state errors to unit step mthe input, [ET-W.02,04]
inputs. IET-S.02,W.03)frequency.
ramp input and unit parabolic e sin (6t +37°)
10
and H(s) =1 Soln. Given: e(t) = 1.66 system given by
Soln. Given: G(s)= s(0.5s+1)(0.1s+1)
that, the response to a second order
We know
1 system, input is as
followed.
It is a type step
ess for step input is given by, (wdt +0)
A
et) = 1-
1- e sin
VI-E2
ess1+Kp where Kp = LimG(s) H($) response
S0 Comparing this with the given
10
e(t) = 1.66e sin (6t+37°)
KLim
S0 S(0.5s +1)([Link] +1) We have
ess0
SYSTE 1/CS-I (ETICT)
206 CONTRO
ROL
aa 1/T1/t K
or
wBFONTROL STEMICS
D
2n 2
(ETICT
i 1-E2
1.66 1-=0.36 250 2
0.25
=0.64 0.8 M,
Mp
25% or
Damping ratio = 0.8
-Ew = v-g
0.8 =
-8
Mp
100xel
8
S1
n = 10 rad/sec. Let =
og On = 10/1-(0.8)2
el V
25=100x
= 10/1-0.64 = 6 rad / sec.
Prob.34. The open-loop transfer function
of a unity
feedback system is given by
0.25 =el
- -
K both sides,
G) Taking log on
s(TS+1) -51T 0.071 =F-
(0.25)=-
() By what factor should be amplifier gain K° be
so that the damping ratio is increased from 0.25 to
multipied, In
0.75? we get
(ii) By what factor should K be multiplied, so Squaring both sides,
that the
minimum overshoot of step response is reduced from 80% to x 1-5f)=3}
8.385 10
20%? IET-W.02,04
8.385 x 10 = 1.00838 f
Soln. Given: G(s) = K
s(TS+1) andH(s) = 1
51=0.321
K Solving for Mp =75°
C). G() s(TS+1)L= K K/t K=0.0431
R(6) 1+G(6) H(s) K_
14
s(Ts+1)
sts+K2 T T
Gain must be increased by K
or
n 0.8= el -?
Taking log on both sides,
U8
A
TROL SYSTEM
CONTROL SYS
SYSTEM/ CS-I (ET/CT
cSAETICT D K
Or. In (0.8) = . =T G(S)HS) s(s+1)
: finite error for a ranp input.
system, it will ihave a
type 1
As a =LO.1 t =
0.183 R(s)=Lr()
v1-2
s.R(s) Ii0.1/sxs_0.1
Squaring and solving for
1 esss01+ G(s) H(s) K +1)
s01+s K
S1 =0.341
Similarly for Mp = 0.2 for
2 SO.005 i.e. s 0.005
ess
Solving similarly
2 =0.398 0.005
0.1K
20.
But.
12KT K2
Deah.36. In the position control
system shown, the
P error detector is 1 Volt/deg. The
acifivity of the synchro
1
sensi
function of the
motor is
0.341= transfer
2 KT M (6)
eM Km
. KT =8.349 and for 2
Vc s)
where
S.m+1)
s(s 2m +1)
Kn = 15rad/sec/volt, 2m
0.15 sec.
ICT-S.031 the steady state error is less than Find this value of
5.
Soln. We know that amplifier gain determine the damping ràtio and settling time of
K the system.
Gs)= and H(s) = 1
Tt
rad/sec.
where R
180xkA x15x0.02
lim sG(s) =.
and ky=lim; s0
Tt(1+0.15s)
BM
Gears
Servomotor
=A54
0.08726 5= 54
kA TT
synchros
36 36/0.15 240
ICT-S.04] =
Soln. The block diagram of the schematic diagram +s s+6.66s
figure.
is shown in (s+0.15s)6.66s
Transfer function with unity feedbacks
Km
G(s)H(S)= 240x1
ec sl1+SZm 1+G(s)H(s) 240
s+6.66s
L 240/s+6.66s
s2 +6.66s +240/($ +6.66s)
Gs)=pKA km X0.02
ns(1+s2m) 240
_180
= s+6.66s+240
Kp =l volt degree volt/radian
T
:
5 R(s) Cs)
2n =5;
24.89=0.5112
Calculating the values of time-domain specification
Tt-tan
- ..
K= 0.5 and a=the' response is,
0.25
Rise timne 3 =0.501 sec For unit-step input,
n1-2 (t)=Ke-(k+ o)t'and Time constant (1)= 1
K+a
100 100 K
Gs)HG)2+10s) s(S+10) s (s +6) K
K
1+ -x1 s+6s+K
r()=2+2() s (s+6)
16 16
-2(-2+4) -4
16 2
D 4 (s+4) 16
s(s+2) (s+4)-4(-4+ 2)
sec
=0.0029 m for an output displacement
Soln. From Figure; Mp
D--2 C)=2- (s+2) s
4 2
(s+4) 0.01 m. On
percentage basis it will be 29%
of
0.29= etE/y1-?
Taking inverse Laplace transform
s (s+2)(s+10)
Find for unity feedback
where, Im
t
the motor time constant and K, is the velocity
is the
G) Type of system, (i) Error coefficients, constant. When this
system is subjected toa unit step input 01() =
(ii) Steadystate responseobtabtained is given by
error for i(t) = 1+4t + t/2. (ET-S.03,CT-S.04 u,the e 4.24t sin (5.66t +0.927) 1.
[Prob.3, P-163]. 0 ()= 1 - 1.25
Prob.3. For a feed back control system having forward Determine the values of
path Damping ratio, ii) Peak overshoot, (iii) Settling time,
G(s)
and H(s) = 0.1.. Given k= 100 iv) No. of oscillations
during settling time
d+0.1s) torque.
(v) Steady state ET-W.99
i) Determine the steady state error, if the input is Prob.14, P-179]
r () = 1+2t +3t2. [ET-S.98] Prob.7. For the following unity feedback system
IProb.4, P-164] Find the time domain specifications and the expression for
Prob.4. The response of unity feedback system is given byoutput, when a unity step input is applied. ET-W.03,S.04]
Prob.15, P-181]
C() = 1-e" sin (4t + 0.5). The time constant of the closed loop
k
system (a) 2, (b) -1/2, (c) 4, (d) none of [Link]. [ET:S.98 Prob.8. For the system: G(s) = with unity feedback
s(1+ST)
Prob.8, P-170]
to be reduced
Prob.5. A feed back system employing output rate damping'is wherekand.T' are constants. If the system overshoot is
shown in figure.
from 0.6 to 0.2, by change in
k only, show that:
a) In the absence of derivative feedback (ko = 0), determine Tk 43
the damping factor and natural frequency of the system. What is the Tk2-1
steady state error resulting from unit ramp input? and k2 corresponding k for 0.6 and 0.2 overshoot. ET-S.041
b) Determine the derivative feedback constarnt ko. which
will Prob.16, P-182]
increase the damping factor of the system to 0.6. What is the steady Prob.9. Refer the figure(a). Obtain the transfer function
(ETICT)
SYSTEM/ CS-I 225
224 TROL
CONTA
VBTFONTROL SYSTEM/CS-1(T Referthe block diagram as shown in figure Q.3(b).
E, ()
c D 14.
Find the
natural frequency of the system.
value of 'K' so that the damping is critical.
E; (s) Findthe expression for e(t), assuming
Hence prove that the circuit acts as "Proportional Derivativa (ii) Fnin
[Link] r(t) as a unit step
Integral" controller.
ve-
[ET-S.97 i) [ET-S-971
function. P-1961
[Prob.20, P-190]
Prob.10. Measurement conducted on servomechanism show
b25
Prob.25,
Prob.15. or a unity feedback system
the system response to be
36
c(t)=1+0.2 e-o1.2e-l0t G(S)s(s+0.72)
when subjected to unit step input. characteristic equation of the system. Hence
Determit the
i) Obtain the expression for closed-loop transfer function. damping ratio, peak time, settling time, peak overshoot
ii) Determine undamped natural frequency and damping ratio calculate the completed before output is settled, when unit
number Of cycle
ar of
of the system. [ET-W.00,03,CT-W.02,03 andnumber
system. ICT-S-03]
Prob.21, P-191] applied to the
dep is P-1981
Prob.11. A unity feedback system is characterised by the open (Prob.26,
loop transfer function Prob.16. For a feedbacK control system having a forward path
G()- transfer
function
s(0.5s+1) (0.2s+1) H(s) = 0.1
G(s)= K/[s(s +0.15)] and
i) Determine the steady-state errors to unit step, unit ramp a
and
unit parabolic inputs Determine the value of gain K for the system to have
ii) Determine rise time, peak time, peak overshoot and settling damping ratio of 0.5.
time of the unit step response of the system. IE-W.0] For this value of K, determine the complete response for a
)
[Prob.22, P-192] ET-S-99]
unit step input.
Prob.12. The system equation is
[Prob.27, P-199]
dy+4d+8y =8x. Prob.17. A unity feedback control system has
dt2 dt
Find the time domain specifications for unit step input. 25
Gs)(s+ 6)
CTS.031
[Prob.23, P-194] Obtain the expression for dynamic error using generalised error
Prob.13. G(s)=- 6 series. Assumie unit step input. IET-W-97
and H(s) =1
s(s+4) IProb.28, P-200
Calculate the transient response parameters for the given
Prob.18. The output of a certain system, when subjected to a
system with input r(t) =2a(t). [CT-S.03] step of 3
units is given below:-
[Prob.24, P-195]
SYSTEM
SYSTEM ICS-I (ETICT) 227
CONTROL
L
226 vBDProb.23, The open-loop ansfer function of a unity feedback
cSi(ETIC
VBD cONTROL SYSTEM/CS- (ETICTn
given by K
6(s+1) systemIs
C($)2 G(s)
(2 +7s +10 s(TS+1)
Find the transfer function of the system, order and type ofth should be amplifier gain "K be multipied, so
.hat factor
what
system. ET-S-0 By is increased from 0.25 to 0.75?
g ratio is
damping
[Prob.29, P-202] the d
sotthe
what factor should K be multiplied, so that the
Prob.19. A unity feedback system is characterized by open By response is reduced from 80% to 20%?
shoot of step
overshoot
loop transfer function inimum
minin ET-W-02,04]
1
P-2061
G6s(0.5s +1)(0.2s+1) Prob.34, find K
= 0.1 t, it is desired that ess 0.005
Prob.24 For r(t)
Determine the steady-state errors for unit step and unit ram system: ICT-S-031
folloWing
input. for the P-2081
Also determine the damping ratio and natural frequency of
Prob.35,
system shown, the sensitivity
TET-W-02 Prob.25. In the position control
dominant roots. is Volt/deg. The transfer function of
1
synchro error detector
IProb.30, P-2021
f the
motor is
motoris
Prob.20. For the system shown above, find the value of 'a" he
the
such that the damping ratio is 0.5. Determine the rise time, peak OMS) K
time, maximum overshoot and settling time for the subjected unit
step input. [CT-W-021
Vc(s) s(s +1) m
rad/sec/volt, 2m = 0.15 sec.
Prob.31, P-203 where Km =15
Prob.21. A unity feedback system is characterized by the open
loop transfer function
The gear ratios are =1 and LOM 50
10 OL
G(s)=
s(0.5s+1)([Link] +1) at a constant speed of n=
) If the input shaft is driven
Determine the steady-state errors to unit
step input, unit ramp rad/sec, determine the value of the amplifier gain such that the steady
input and unit parabolic inputs. JET-S-02,W-j3
[ET-S-02, W-03]|
IProb.32, P-2041 state error is less than
5 Find this value of amplifier gain
Prob.22. Measurements condcted on a servomechanism show determine the damping ratio and-settling time of the systm.
the error response to be (i) If the amplifier is modified by introducing an additional
derivative term such that its output,is given by
1.66
e(t)= e sin(6t +37°)
where the input is given a sudden unit displacement. Determine the
-K +Kn e dt
natural frequency, damping ratio and damped natural frequency. the' damping ratio will improve to
find the value of Kp such that
[ET-W-02,04/ 05 .sit ICT-S-041
[Prob.33, P-2051 Prob.36, P-209
228
BD CONTROL SYSTEMICS[E .SYSTEM/CS-I (ETICT)
229
cONTROL
TICn
o
Prob.26. A unity feedback system has below shows mechanical vibrating system
Prob.31. Figure
is applied to the system the mass
oscillates as
K(Ts+1) NN of force
Gs) s(Tas+1)(Ths +1) When8.9
eQ
M, fand K. ET-W-011
Figure. Determine
shown
shon in
) Prove that for a unit step input, steady-state error Prob.42, P-219
be Prob.32. Consider
a unity feedback control system whose open
(ii) For a unit ramp input, find the value of 'K' to se So that fiunction is
transfer
the steady-state eror (ess) doesn't exceed 0.25. loop
IV-97 100P
0.4s+1
Prob.37, P-213] G(S)=-s(s+0.6)
Prob.27. For the following unity feedback system, find s. What is the rise timeforthis
response to a unit step input.
btain the ET-S-02
time domain specifications and the expression for output, when overshoot?
a is the maximum
system? What
unit step input is applied. ET-S-0
[Prob 43, P-220
Prob.38, P-213
Prob.28. A Control System has
2
Gs)= (4s+1)
The system time constant is required to be reduced to 1
sec.
Illustrate how it can be achieved using proper feedback, without
,
Gs)=KK
s(s+6)
Find the time response of the system when subjected
to a step
of 2 units for K = 8. Sketch this output for 2 seconds. How much
time it will take approximately to reach the steady state?
ET-W-O11
Prob.41, P-216
UNIT III CONTROL SYSTEM/ CS-I
(ET/CT) 231
stability. stability:
Q.1. Define stability in detail with suitable examples Location of poles and
all locations in left half in s-plane (L.H.P.) the impulse
[CT-W-02 1) For
response tends to zero. and hence if poles are
in LHP, the system is
Ans. A system is said to be stable, if
i) For a bounded input, the output is also bounded. Stable. Corresponding Impulse
ii) In the absence of input, the output tends towards zerm Location Root in s Plane
Response
irrespective of initial conditions. No.
6. Origin jw
it Such systems are known as marginally stable or limitedly
CIty For Repeated
roots on Jo axIs, system is unstable. In short,
Single stable.
1a
8. RHP
AJw STABLE
Real Axis L Stabte
Repeated
+6
Cit NYtor
Morginoly
stobie ZZUnstoble stable
Simple poles
INN Limted
9. RHP
Real Axis 4J S-Plane
Repeated
CI te
Q.3. State Routh's stability criteria.
: The necessary and
Ans. State Routh's Stability Criteria
stable is that there should
sufficient condition for the system to be
Ctt Routh's array.
10. RHP not be any sign change in the first column of
column of Routh's array,
Complex If there are sign changes in the first
the system is unstabl and number of
sign changes in the first
-io roots of the
column of Routh's array indicates the number of
characteristics equation in the right half of s-plane.
234 235
wBD CONTROL SYSTEM CONTROL SYSTEM/Cs-I (ETICT)
SYSTE
ICS(ETI cONTROL
Routh's array is computing
constructed from BD 39 the specific cases arising while
characteristics equation the co-cfficient
eCcn ot
of sin. Q.5. What
are
1+G ($) H (S) =0,as 0.5.
5.
(1) Arrange the co-efficient
[Link]-efici 0
as follows.
of first s in the characteti Routh's
array ?
arising while computing
Routh's array:
Specific cases Routh's array
ntwo
equation in two rows. racteri.
terisans
Case 1-The first element
in any one row of the
non-zero's. For example:
(2) First row will consist in that row are
of first, third, fifth co-efficient other elements
r hut
but other
the characteristics equation. ofs zero,
l ofsis
Second row will consist
of 2", 4", [Link] ofs
the characteristics equation. 0 2
(3) The element of remaining s
rows are computed as follows put s = 1/x in the original
overcome this difficulty,
Consider equation in
and obtain the new characteristic
F (s)= a,s" + To
as+a9s +as haracteristic equation characteristic equation.
outh's criteria to the new
apply the Rou
+as"n-+ ..n 0
,n-4
+ a4s and
and x-roots in the right half of the x-plane equals the
The number of
s a0 Qumber of s-roots in the right
half of s-plane.
a2 a4 Routh's table
All the elements in any one row of the
sh a3 a5
Case 2
are all zero.
n-2 a122-2033 a124-20a5 =b2
b a1
b3
sn-3 D a3-ab2
C1 ba5-ab3= c2 s 0 0 0 0
b b sO
an These condition indicates that there are symmetrically located
+6s +4
0 0
'. ,
'
k2 =10k
100 k1 The Routh's
array 1s as shown.
k+ 59k -832
1
100k. 0 0 0
s 10 100 52-k
.0 0
s 1000 k 100
10 For system to be
k
stable
100
For system to be at the limit of stability 52-0
1000 k-100
10
52- k>0
k< 52 .1)
1000 k1 = 100
k>0 (2)
100 -832
k 1000 -k+59k
52-k
k 0.1 k2-59k+832 >0
Prob.4. A control system has loop transfer function (k-35.6846)(k - 23.3153)>0
Gs) H(s)=. k(s+1) k> 35.6846 or k> 23.3153
s(s-1) (6*+ 4s + 16) k35.6846.
Find the frequencies at which the system can oscillate and bri:Range of k for stability 35.6846 <k< 52
explain how such oscillations can be damped out. by suitable For sustained oscillation, we should have
measures.
Ans. The characteristics equation is -k2 +59k -8320
1+G() H($)=0 52- k
k(s+1) k-59k + 832 =
0
1+ = 0
.s(s-1) (s + 4s + 16) (k-35.6846) (k-23.3153) = 0
k 35.6846 and k=23.3153
YSTEM/ CS-I TICT)
cONTROL SY 245
244 VBD should
VBD CONTROL
SYSTEM / CS-I (ETICY
system to e stable, there not be any sign changes in
Rout array.
k 35.6846
column of Routh's
first
( k= 23.3153 will make system unstable
ble) the k>0
Auxiliary Polynomial for k = 35.6846 is
21.333->0
2-k2+k = 0
128 k
(52-35.68462+35.6846 =0 or
k128 2)
-0.1666 k + 18.666 k 426.66 >0-
45-6K
as+(K+1)=0 as=-K+1
s 5
K
s2 +11
a
Substituting the value of 'a' from equation (1), we get
-K+1 =-(K+2)
For system to be stable, K> 0 and 0>0 (K+1)/K+2
45 6K>0 S=tjvK +2
But K+2 =2
45>6K
Squaring K +2=4, we get
K< 7.5
. Kmar
=2
0 <K < 7.5
a K+1 2+13 a=0.75
250
YSTEMI CS-I (ETICT) 251
VBD CONTROL SYSTEMI cONTROL
Prob.10. The
characteristic equation
Fs)=s+s +3s3 +9s +16s+10=0.
CSI (ETICT
of a feedback system
is
BD
s32 1+K
.'. s3+6s2+13s+K=0
s(1+Ts) (1 +2s)+ K (s+ 5) =0
= Routh's array is as follows.
(s+Ts )(1+2s) + Ks+ 5K 0
13
S+2s+Ts +2Tss +Ks +5K =0
= K
2Ts+ (2+ T)s+s+ Ks + 5K 0 78-K 0
2Ts+(2+ T)s+ (1+ K)s+5K =0 6
The Routh's array is as follows:
s K
252 (ETICT)
SYSTEM/ CS-I 253
yBD CONTROL SYSTEM ICS-I (ET/ cONTROL
TICT
672- and -33K>0 K>0
For system to be stable K> 0 and 78-K0 .
6 K <672
78 K>
0 K>33
-1121K-672K
K<78 0
and 14
Range ofK is 0 <K < 78.
Prob.13. The open-loop transfer function of -1121
Ká-672 K>0
a contral
system is given by ro
K >672 K
.. 1121
-112IK> 672
G() H()= K(s+0.5)(s +2) 112 K
s (s+6)(s +8) 672
Find the range of the gain constant K for stability 1.66> K.
usino
g
Routh's criterion. (ET-S-02 Prob.14. Find the
range or K for stability for a unity
ET-S-02
Also find Kmax and frequency of sustained
Soln. Given: G(s) H(s) =S+0.5)S+2) dback system.
Oscillations.
s(s+6)(s+8) K
The characteristic equation is 1
+ G(s) * H(s) = 0 CT-S-031
(s+2) GS)s(s+2)(s +4)(s +6)
i.e. 1+ (S+0.5) =0 K
s°(s+6)(s+8) Soln. Given: G(s)= and Hs)= 1
s(s+2)(s+4)(s +6)
s'(s+6)(s +8)+K(s+0.5) (s+2)=0 Characteristics equation is
:.
(s+6s)(s +8) +(Ks+0.5 K)(s +2) =0 1+
K
0
s3 +8s +6s4 +48s3 +Ks +2Ks+0.5 Ks +K=0
s(s+2)(s+4)(s+6)
s(s+2)s+4)(s+ 6)+K =0
s +14s+ 48s +Ks +(2.5K)s +K=0 . (s+2s)(s + 6s+4s+24)+K0
Routh's array is as follows
s+6s3+4s3 +24s2 +2ss +12s+8s2 +485+K=0
ss 14
48 2.5K
s +12s +44s +48s+K=0
K K
672-K 34 K The Routh's array is as follows
14 14
33K K
1
44 K
-6724 KK
-112K 0
12 48 0
14
K
s 40
1920-12K
K 0
s 0
For column I to be positive 40
672-K0 s K
14 For system to be stable
SYSTE
SYSTEM / CS-I (ETICT) 255
254 CONTROL
ONTROL
TEM / CS-I (
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM ICS-I (ETICn BD and K = 0.52 :.K> 0.52, K>2.52
K=-2.52 0.52<k<0
K>0 and 1920-12K,o
40 stained oscillations occurs in the system, when some of the
ned oscilla
1920 12 K>0 eeharacteristics equation lies on jo axis.
1920> 12 K =0
3K+6K-4
160> Kk
(K-0.52)= 0.
(K+2.52)
K<160 sustained oscillations to occur K = 0.52. Auxiliary equation
'. Range ofk is 0 <K < 160 For
160 K-0.52 is
At marginal stability Kmar for = 0
Auxiliary equation s 3Ks+4 = 0;3(0.52)s* +4
40s+K=0 i.e. 40s = -160 L.56s+4 0; s2 =4
1.56
smar=2 4
rad /sec.
S=tj2
sOscillation
tj2.56
frequency is. o = 2.56 rad/sec.
Prob.15. The characteristic equation of a system is Prob.16. Determine the range of values of k (k> 0)such that
q() = s* +3Ks* +(K+2)s +4 =0 characteristic equaton
range ot K, so that system remains'
stablo the +5) s +(4 k+7)=0
system shows sustained oscillations, find frequency of
3+3(k+1) s* +(7k
has roots more thans=-1.
oscillations. [CT-S-04 ICT-S-02]
[Link]) = s' +3Ks+ (K + 2)s + 4 0. =
Soln. For checking the stability
w.r.t. G =-1 axis;
The Routh's array is Puts-(z-1)
5)(z-1)+(4k+7)=0
s3 1
K+2 q(2)= (z-1)° +3(k+1) (z-1) +(7k+
s? 3K 4 q(2)= z-3z2+3 z-1+3 k z-6 kz+3 k+3
z2-6z+3
s 3K +6K-4
3K
+7 kz-7k+5z-5 +4k+7 0
4 q(z)= z' +z(-3 +3 k+3) + z (3 -6k-6+7k+ 5)+
=
For system to be stable, there should not be any sign changes in (-1+3 k +3-7k-5+4k+7) 0
e first column of Routh's array. 9() z+3 kz4+ (2 +k)z+ (4)=0
3K 0 and K>>0 From Routh array
3K(K+2)-40 1 (2+k)
3K
3k 4
K>0
3K +6K-4>0
3k+6 k-4
3k
: (K+2.52) (K-0.52) =0
(ETICT)
cONTROL
SYSTEM/ CS-I 257
For system to be stable, all the term in first column must be g(s)=s+qs2 +2ks+ 4 =0
positive. Routh array is
20 2
; 2-K>0 s2
1
2k
4
0
0
K<2 (1) 2qk-4
(2-K)(2+K)-2K0
4
(2-K)/2
SYSTEM/ CS-I (ETICT) 259
NTROL
258 VBD
cONTROL SYSTEM
/ cs.,
For stability q> 0 and 1-T 0
2gk-40 2qk-4>0
stability I - T>0
2qk>4 For
Atk=
4 T<I
Prob.20. Check
the stability
24
2q
The roots lie on jw-axis. +8s"+12s320s +165+16=0 ET.S-00
Forming the auxillary equation (the row above the Oneefrom
+2s Array is as shown below
Cala, The Routh
where value of k is obtained is s row)
20 16
8
A (s)=qss+4=0 1 12 16 0
2 12 16
s2
special case. Hence Auxillary eqn. is formed.
*i This is also 2
Take auxiliary,
Eqn. for s" row,
This is of the form s= tjo and 'o' is given as 4 rad/sec.
A(s)=2s*+12s +16
4 q=0.25.
dA=8s2+24s
Substitute this in equation (1) ds
4 Completing array
k= 2q
2x0.25
8.
=
q(s)=s +S+(1-sT) 0 16
i.e. s+(1-T) s+ =0 1 No sign change hence system may be stable.
From the Routh-array Solving for Aux. eqn.
2s +12s2 +16=0
CS-I (ET/CT)
ONTROL SYSTEM / 261
260 cONTROL SYSTEM /CS-I(ETICT
1VBD
[Link] the stability s +s* +2s°+2s +3s+5=0 52 +3z* +2z° +2z +z+1=0
Soln. The Routh Array shows that s row breaks, down. It is
Routh array is
1
special case of Routh Test. Replace 0 in column 1
of s row by 5 2
1
E and proceed with the array. 3 2
2 3 -4/3 -2/3
1
2 5 2 1/2
-2 0 2
2e+2 5
Two sign changes in first column indicates two roots on R.H.S.
s 4-4-5e2 Hence system is unstable.
2E+2
5
G(s)=-K As K
and mmove towards each-other.
s (s+a) s1 =-a
The characteristics equation will be 0 and
=0 2 Roots are equal; s1 and s2
qs)= 1+ G(s). H(s) = s+as + K =0 Gii) If K |
=
constantreal part;
figure(a) and gives
varying K is plotted in
The R.L. with
Construction of R.L. starts from
locating the poles and zeros o following infoT 0
openloop T.E. S-plane. They poles of the system-for K =
are as shown in figure ctartsfrom
(i) Root-locus starts
from open-loop
open-loopPo
(a).
a2
to;4 the roots move towards
(ii) As K is increased from 0
+00
l2 R.L. breaks-away
from the real-axis | from
(ii) At K=;
V 00
point - 0) and move along the line G=-
closed loop
Now let us examine the be obtained for
effect of varying Hence following information can
roots of characteristic equation; "K' on the
he location of
q(s) response of the system: K>0; the
LHS of jo -axis for
) As complete R.L. lie on the
266 positive values ot K.
VBD CONTROL
SYSTEM/CS-I (ETICT) closed-loop system will be stable for all
CONTRA6ROL 269
268 VBDçONTROL
SYSTEM CS-I (ET/C) co
BD
G) H6)24s+Z -L4s+P
j=l
R.L. lies on negative real
axis; hen. i=l
i) For 0 <K
poles will
contribute--ve angle and zero's will contribute
,
but distinct
ystem response will be over-damped as roots are real i.e. Doint s =S1 lies on root loci, then
angle. a m
2
=
both the roots are same and real; system i ve
(ii) For K KI61 +Z)
critically damped. G(s1) H(s1)=i and
TI61 +P)
Civ) For K> root are complex-conjugate with negative
j-l
real-part system will be under-damped. m
P =t (2K +1) n
(v) For any desired response; the valve of K cab
be obtained
2G61) H1) 524S1 +2i -22s+
jl
from the Root-Locus; Hence 'K' can be adjusted for getting any
Rules for
construction of root loci - The root locus statts
specific ess, [Link] etc. H(s).
from the poles of G(s)
Therefore we can conclude that R.L. is a very useful technique
for analysis and design in time-domain. ls+Z 1
...(1)
Q.2. Explain magnitude and angle criterion with respect to Fs)=imtil K
root locus technique. [ET. W.041 IIls+Pi
Ans. Magnitude and angle condition of root locus: jl
locus, the right
Closed loop poles are obtained from the equation. For K 0, that is at the starting point of the root
1+G(s) H(s) =0 side of equation (1) is intinity for which s approaches to the poles of
the loop transfer function
G(s) H(s). Hence, the locus of the
G(s) H(s) = -1 roots start from the poles of the loop transfer
characteristic equation
|G (s) H(s)=1>magnitude condition function.
4G(s) H(s) =t (2K +1) T > angle condition i) The root locus terminates at
zeros of G(s) H(s).
the root locus the
Where, K =t0, 1, 2, 3.... For K=o i.e at the terminating points of
approaches to the zeros
(s +Z2)-(s+Zm ight side of equation l is zero, for whichs
Consider, G() K(+Z) of the loop transfer function G(s) H(s). Hence
the locus of the
(s+P) + P2)-(s +Pn)
(s
zero of th loop
characteristic equation roots, terminates at the
Z. Z2, Z3Zm arethe zero's and P1, P2, P3 Pn are the
transfer function.
Pole plot of
Prob.1. Determine the points on the pole zero
KIG+Z) G() H(s)= K(s+1) (s+3) and indicate points at
which
G (s)
H(s)| =- s(s+2)(s+4)
the root
s+P) locus terminates.
is
jl doln:. The loop transfer function of the system
cONTRFo SYSTEM/cS-I (ET/CTt 271
ONTROL
270
VBTFONTROL sYSTEM/cS (ETICT D9Prob.2. Det
etermine the number of separate root locus for
transfer functions:
followingloop
G(s) H(s) =K(S+)(s+3) thes
K(s+1) (6+3)
H()= s(s+2)(s+4)
a)G()
s(s+2) (s+4)
Function G(s)H(s) contains zeros at s =-1 and s -3 as shou
=-
K
in the pole zero plot of figure. Hence, the root locus tor G(s)}Hs b) G () H(s) s(s+2)(s+4)
G()HS
function
starting from two zeros will terminate at s = -1 and s = --3,t The loop transfer
Soln: a) (s +3)
which K=o. Theseterminating points are shown in figure.
F(s)= G (s)
H(s) = A(+) (s+ 4)
s(s+2)
-
finite poles at s = 0, s = -2 and s = 4 and
Jur Function conta
1 and s = 3. Thus, for this function P = 3 and
zeros at sSE=-1
-
-
S-Plane
finite equation (2) as P Z, the number of separate root locus
2. From
N=P=3. function.
is b) The lop transfer
K
Terminating. points F6)=G($) H6)=2,
s2(s+2) (s+4)
of the root locus
order pole at s = 0 and simple
Function contains finite second
s = -2 and s =
- 4. There are no finite zeros present.
ite poles at
finite (2) as P>Z
The root locus starting from the third pole terminates at the Thus, forthis function P = 4 and Z = 0. From equation
zero of s=o, because G(s) H(s) is a rational function for which the number of separate root locus is N =P=4.
NZ For Z>P asymptotic to the straight line with angles given by,
of G(s) H(s)-2zeros of
P-Z
G($) H(s)
K 2 0 = 225°
4
where, G
Poles of G(s) H(s) = Sum of the distances ofG() K 3 4 4 315°
H(s) poles from the origin.
interception of asymptotes with the real axis i.e. the
zeros of G(s) H(s) =Sum of distances of G(s) H(s) zero The
position of
centroid fror he origin in s-plane is,
from the origin.
Prob.3. A unity feedback system has
K +2
G)- ASYMPTOTES
s(s+4)(s+2s+5) S-Plane
+1
For the loop transfer function of this system, calculate the .
35
following when K is changed from +oo to -.
i) Number of 225
-2
Soln: The loop transfer function of the system
G) H(s)= K
s(6+4) (s +2s +5)
_
2poles of G($) H($) -2 zeros of G(s) H(s)
P-Z
K
s(s+4)(S+1+2j) (s+1-2j) [0-4-1-2j-1+2]l-0-15
i) The finite poles of loop transfer function are located 4
at s = 0, which
4, s =-1-2j and s = -1 +2j. There are no finite zeros in the vii) Real axis locus: The sections of real axis in s-plane
S=- are obtained by
loop transfer function, hence P = 4 and Z = 0. lie on the root locus or on the inverse root locus
As there are no finite
zeros, four finite poles, there must be four
zeros at infinity. converting the total number of finite poles and zeros of the loop
left of the
ii) The number of root locus is N =
4 0 = 4. Hence, the
-
transfer function G(s)H(s) which are located in the right or
number of separate root locus or number section under consideration.
of asymptotes is 4.
ii) The pole zero plot of G(s)H($) is sketched in the points of the
figure The For positive values of K, (i.e. for root locus),
various angles of asymptotes are number of finite
T0ot locus on the real axis lie to the left of an odd
274 VBTEONIHOLSYSIEM/CS-I
M]esl (ETICT)
(E: CONTROL S 275
9D
poles and zeros of G(s)H(s). If no points on the real axis lie to
o the
left of an odd number of finite poles or zeros, then no portion of .
ToO
locus lies on the real axis.
J
Px +3
S-PLANE
t2
AA0
F+1
-0
--27-
ROOT LOcus
Figure Determination of the angle of departure of root locus
s bc-Kd 0 equationis
b K
Kd J3 4 4
S
To obtain the value of K at the intersection point of imagima.
ginary 2 5 K
axis with the root locus is obtained by equating the first element in 20-4K
the row for s equal to zero in the array. Hence 5
be-Kd o s K
b 9 element of th row for s in Routh's array
Solving equation 9 for K Equ ting the
K= d
D20-4-0
(10) 5
(1)
The auxiliary equation of Routh's array is K=5 of the array from the row for s2 is
sb+Kd=0 11) The auxiliary equation
Solving equation (11) for s and substituting s=j 5s+K=0 2)
Solving equation (2) for
s and substituting the value of K from
Kd
s=jo=tJ equation (1))
S=jo=tj 3
Hence the point at which= the
root locus intersects the naginary
Vb Vd 'b (12)
axes are K =5, S = -j and
K 5, S = +j.
Equation (10) and (12) define the intersection point on the x)Breakaway points [CT. S.04]: The point on the re axis of
imaginary axis with the root locus. This point on the imaginary axis S-plane at which two or more branches of root
locus depar rom or
corresponds to the point in s-plane at which the root locus changes arrive at the real axis are known as breakaway point
or saddl: point.
its position from right half to left half of s-plane. The value of K at BREAK AWAY
A
BREAK AWAY
this point is also known as the static sensitivity of the system. POINT S-PLANE OINT S-LANE
Prob.4. Calculate the values of K and w for the point in s- K 0 K-0
K-oc K 0
K P1 P2
plane at which the root locus of G($)H(s)= 2 Z1
root loci meet and then move along the real axis as K increases.S. n function. Let this equation be
loop transfer
these two cases, the breakway points A and B represent double toot 14)
of the characteristic equation. In general, a breakaway point may
1+ F(s) =a0 s" +as"...an 0
2) Differentiate the
characteristic equation with respect to s.
have more than two characteristic equation roots as shown in figure
c). The point C in figure (c) represents a breakaway point on the real Thus from eq. (14)
sn-l+bisn-2, ...n-1=0 (15)
axis at which six separate root loci meet from six different directions F)=bo
thus representing the sixth order characteristic equation root. The
where [bo =nao. bi =a1(n -1), b2 =a2 (n -2)]....etc.
root locus diagram may have more than one breakaway points which 1
+ F(s) and
3) Arrange the coefficients of s in expressions
lie on the real axis or occur at the complex conjugate poles and are
F(s) into two rows. From equation. (14) and (15), these rows
zeros, because the root locus is
symmetrical about the real axis.
Thus, breakaway points have the
following properties: a0 a a2 n-1 an
1) Breakaway
point represents the root of characteristic bo b b2..n- .(16)
equations of first or higher
order. 4) Arrange the coefficient of these rows to have
the array
11) Breakaway
points either lie on the real axis or occur in described below which is not Routh's array even though the cross
complex conjugate pairs.
special features of this tabulation are
multiplications are similar. The
11) The root loci
or inverse root loci approach or ve the
a) The term s' (where j = 0, 1, 2,....n) of each row represents
breakaway point on the
real axis at an angle
of ,where n is the a particular row in the array.
number of root loci n value-
or inverse root loci s repeats for three consecutive rows for the
the or
leaving the breakaway point. which are approaching b)The term
1V) The
roots at the breakaway =n-1...j.
pointhave infinite sensitivy
VBFONROLSYSTEM/
YSTEMICSA(ETIC
CS
280
(ETICT)
third rows of the three rows which cONTROL SYSTEM/ CS-I 281
c)The first and fom qBD
array are
identical. the ntm
group s in the Tls +Pl
ntains multiple
characteristic equation I + F(s) containe
d) If the orde
the tabulation contains all zeros thereby G(s) H()|
roots. a row of having
premature tabulation.
system, the characteristic equation j
For the third order
Draducof lengthof vectors drawnfromthe polesof G(sH(s)tos
written as S
3 +a1s* +a2s +a3 = 0 Droductof lengthof vectorsdrawnfromthezerosof G(sH(s)to
1+ F(s)= ags
17) Thus in figure the
value of K at s is
Differentiating eq. (17) with respect to s
B.D.E
F(s)=bos +bis+ b2 (18) K= A.C.
Fromeqs.(17) and (18) ju
ROOT LOCUS
ao a2 ag S1 S-PLANE
bo b2 0
Co .b1-b2o o2-b22o c2 =oa3-a C D
bo bo
bo b b2
bL-beo,b2-b2C% =
sd da b0-C
bo bo
dob-dbo.e, dob2djDo e -d0-0b, 8.3: Procedure for construction of root locus:
do .do The procedure for constructing the root locus of the loop
do oo to oo is described
transferfunction, when is varied from +
do
below:
sf doe-djeo f,-d,0-e,0
do do
1) Starting| For positive values of K, the |Locate the poles of
determine
S, Determine the breakaway equationPOnt
on of root root locus starts at the poles of | G(s)H(s) &
tne c
point by solving the
Tormed by the row of
coefficients, which is just before the row of
locus.
u G(s) H(s). For negative values the number of finite|
poles
zeros. K, the root locus starts at poles P and the
of
Xi) the zeros of G(s) H(s). at infinity.
Value of K at a point Ka
on the root locus: The value of zeros of|
a point S on the For positive values of K, the |Locate the
root locus is vectos Terminating H(s) and
determined by measuring uthe root locus terminates, at the G(s)
from the poles and |point of root zeros of G(s) H(s). For determine the
zeros of loop transfer
function to the point
.
locus. finite
theroot locus and then substituting negative values of K, the number of
the zeros Z and the zeros
values in the followmg" root locus terminates at the |
poles of G(s) H(s). at infinity.
eTEONTROL SYSTEM/CS- ONTROL SYSTEM I CS-1 (ETICT) 283
282 (Y VBD
Z>P, the number of | Determine th Departure For positive values of K, the | Determine the
3) Number of For henumbe /8) arrival departure or arrival angles at departure and arrival
separate sèparate ro
root separate root loci is N = Z. of separate
of root locus
ar
/and
at the complex poles or zeros for the| angles for positive|
|loci. For Z<P, the number of N. /angle
Doles loop transfer function of the values of K.
complex
separate root loci is N = P. the system is determmined as
plots for the Make the root
locus and described below:
4) Symmetry Root rational loop plots
lo Complex zeros
systems
of root locus transfer having ots symmetrical
to respectively. a) Select a point s, which is
functions with constant the real axis. very close to the pole or zero
diagram.
coefficients are symmetrical and lies on the root locus
with respect to the real axis, in associated with that pole or
|
S-plane. zero.
The number of asymptotes Calculate the departure and
b)
n=P-Z arrival angles for positive
5) Asymptote | For positive values of K at | Determine the values of K.
angles for the| s-»o, the asymptotes are number and sketch
|
intersection points of | Determine and locate
root locus plots straightlines at the angle the asymptotesI 9) Points of At the
o4
at intersection of |root loci with the imaginary the intersection point
at sco defined by various angles. rOot loci with axis in s-plane, the values of on the imaginary axis
0-2K+
P-Z
the imaginary K are obtained by tnewith the root locus.
criterion. For
axis in s-plane. | Routh's
where K =0, 1... upto complicated loop transfer
(P-Z) exclusive. functions, Bode plot is used.
6) Centroid or The point of intersection of| Calculate the value of and locate
10)Breakaway For all values of K, the |Determine
the intersection | asymptotes lies on the real the intercept on the saddle breakaway points on the root | the breakaway points
or
point of axis in s-plane. For positive real axis and locate by one of locus in s-
points on the |locus are obtained on the root
asymptotes. or negative values of K, the the centroid. following methods.
distance
root locus. the plane.
between the Method I: Differentiate the
centroid and the origin in s- system loop transfer
o
plane is defined by function with respect to s
=poles of G(6) H($) +
and equate equal to zero
2 Zeros of G(s) H(s) d[G(s) H(6)]_ dk=0
P-Z ie. ds ds
7) Locus of For positive values of K,this Sketch the root loci| Method II: By tabulating|
aracteristic root locus lies on afor various values of
equation roots particular section of real axis K, which lies on the
the array from the system
characteristic equation and|
on the real for which the total number real axis. Indicate
axis.
then solving the equation
of real poles and real zeros proper directions. formed from the coefficient
to the right of the section is s in this array.
odd. of
284 BIfONTROL SYSTEMICS4
CSA(ETICT coNTROL YSTEMICS1 (ETICT) 285
(EY 2D
11) Value of K | The magnitude of K at the |Determine [Link] P3 are open-loo poles. Bis break-away point.
at t jo
on the rootpoint s, on the root locus is
Jocus. obtained from
K at the of
point and comple
RLinterests Jo-axis
=
when R.L. crosses axis.
jo
K Gain This can be
Let
the root locus. Routh criterion.
hG() H6) tcrmincd from
corresponding to bfeak-away point.
Product of all vector K,= Gain
Iengths from Arrow
direction shows increase in value ofK.
> K2. We know that R.L. starts from K = 0.
Poles of G(s) HS) to s t is obvious Ki
Product of all vector lengths from
Follow ing
conclusions can be drawn.
s
zeros of G(6) H(s) of
For K< K2:R.L. branches starting from P and P2 are
0<
hing on real
axis. For the root s1 and s2 =-30n tjo,,1-2.
[Link] will you determine transient response from imaginary parts will be zero.
Roots are real and distinct.
root.
locus?
System is over damped.
Ans. Determination of Transient-Response from Root. will be equal and real (break-away
(i) At K= K2; Roots
Locus critically damped.
point). System will be
iwdn1- K2
(iii) For <K1; roots will be complex conjugate.
<K
System will be under-damped.
J (R.L. crosses joaxis).
(iv) For K = K^; root will be imaginary
System will be un-damped.
J dA
(v) For K > Kj;-R.L. will be on RHS of jwaxis. System will
wn be unstable.
. System response (Qualitatively) can be decided from above
Ps P2 P mentioned rules. Now we shall concentrate on the values
of K
K0
kO
k-
jw
k
+60
8
S-PLANE
135 +45
K-oB
K 0 K=0
-b -a B
K=0
k.
k:0
290 VBD CONTROL SYSTEMICSI{ CONTROL STEM/ CS-I (ETICT)
SYSTI 291
(ETICT BD
The root locus
TICT
of the loop transfer function (4) is sketched be conveniently carried out by rewriting the
This can
figure (b). From this figure, it is noted that the eakaway in that 'a' appears
0,Such
characteristic equation as
1
4
has shifted to the left from Bj to B2 and the root locus
point
ha.
B,
parameter.
+K s
This equation the form that
is in its root
towards the left half of s-plane. If a pair of complex bent
njugate
coniuat a gaincan be drawn for various values of 'K' by allowing 'a' to
are added to the system, loop transfer function (1) changes to poles ontours
co.
O to
yary from
=K+cs+a SOLVEDEXAMPLES
G6) HS) eah.5, Sketch the root locus and indicate all possible
s(s+ a) system with the following open-loop
5 details for a
unity eedback
The root locus of equation 5 is plotted in figure (c)
from whick transfer function:
it is noted that by adding these poles, the breakaway
point has shited K [ET-S-02/
to the left and the root locus has bent towards the
lefthalf ofs- plane GS)s(s+2)(s +4)(s+6)
Q.5. Explain the effects of pole/zero addition to K
the transfer
function ofa control system, on its root-locus. ET-W-97,CT-W-02 Soln. Given: G(5)s(s +2)(s +4) (s +6)
Ans. Effect of adding a zero and a pole: and m =0
added in the forward path for a2 order system:-
When a zero is Here n=4 =n-m4-0 4
ending at o
:. Number of loci
) Bandwidth increases, hence rise time is lessened. real axis is loci.
The
(i) Settling time increases.
Number of asymptotes= n- m=4
(ii) System becomes more stable.
When a pole is added in the forward path: Angles of asymptotes
) Bandwidth decreases, hence rise time increases. B
(2x+1)l80 x=0, 1,2,3
nm
(i) M, increases. B 450,1350,225°,315°
(ii) System becomes less stable.
Q.6. Write a short note on Root -(0+2+4+6-0)=-3 isthe centroid.
Contours. IE-W-95 4
Ans. Root Contours:
For Ob
Root-locus plot is constructed by 2)(s+4)(s+6)
over the complete range. Root contour
varying the open-looP gain
technique is adopted to the
K===-s(S+
N(S)
1
10s+K=0, 10s-KK
. Number of asymptotes=n- m =3
s2 s=-4 S=tj2
10 Angle of asymptotes,
is 40.
Thus root locus crosses at =+j2 s and value of K at cross over (2x+)180°
B
n-m
where, x =0, 1; n-m-1
B 60°, 180°, 300
Centroid:
K
Real part of poles of OLTF-
6C -3 =40
p-1
135 Real part of zeros of OLTF
n- m
S-6
S7
315 S=-2 S 0 2+6)+(0)-0
3-0
=-2.33
is given as
Breakway Points :-Characteristic equation
. 66-4 76
1+G(s) H(s) =0
1+
K
s(s+2)(s+5)
:0
s3+7s2 +10s+K=0
Asymptote
K--(s+7s +10s)
)
i.e.
dk0 /ti3
Take
ds
3s +14s+10 = 0 tj2
Apply
bvb2-4ac
2a 1
-14196-12014t 8.71
6 6 180
s=-3.78 or s - 0.88 S-0
Take s-0.88 S5 300
{-i1
As there are no complex poles or zeros, angle of arrival and Sc-233
departure are not expected.
Now, take the characteristics equation Breakaway
point=-0-88
-j2
s+7s2 +10s+K=0
Apply Routh's aray as follows Asymptote
3
s
17 10
K
3
70-K
7
-jw
K
For the system to be stable, all the elements in
Root locus of G(s) HG)
=
the 1" column of s(s+2)(s+5)
Routh's array should be positive.
i.e.K>0 and K
>0, i.e. K <70 Prob.7. For the system with
7 K H()=1
Combining 0 <k< 70 is the stable
range of k. G) (s +2s+ 2) (s +2s+5)
Take s row,
determine the closed
Thus, 7s +K=0 Sketch the complete root locus. Hence Roots
7s-Kk loop transfer function of the
system such that 'Multiple
7s-70 s =-10 exist in the system.
ICT-S-01, ET-S-971
+ j3.16
S =
6A - 1-1-1)
4
(P-Z)
-1
Step (6): Number poition ofreal axis lies
on root locus
-26
s-1,-1
t 7-0
-(s1)(2 4s 7-0
31581,- 1-J1581 are
581 and- I J1581 two actual breakzw
ay
-IJ1
-
-
Step (7): Angle of departure
point
d-180+ 190
-1+J1 Breakaway Direction-
aus
2 Angle contribution of zero
Step (9) lterection of Root locus on ja
-
Angle contribution of pole
The characteristic equation is
dp=180+[0-(90 +90-90 0)]=90° 14s (10 K)
-1+J
4s1
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/ (ETICT)
SYSTEM/ CS-I 301
300 CS-((ETICT cONTROL
wRD
y root loci for the system having
Prob.8. A unity feedback control system has G (s) = k(s +b) Prob.9. Sketch he
K and H(s)= 1.
s(S+a)
b>a
G S)2+ 2s +2) (s +2s +5)
Draw the exact root locus. Hence obtain the minim nimum the close loop transferifunction such that the system
Obtain
CT-W-011
possible damping ratio for the closed loop poles. ET-W-971 oscillatory response in the steady state.
Soln. (1) Here number of poles = n =2 xhibits an K
number of zeros= m=1 Soln.G()(2+2s+2) (s* +2s+5)
number of loci = n =2
zero Poles are located as under
number ofloci ending at oo= n - m =1 There is no
(2) Draw poles and zeros first. The Rough sketch is Figure(a).
P and P2
t4-8-1tjl
m 2
P3 and P4
-2t4-20_-1tj2
2
and they will terminate at
Branches will start from all the poles
infinity. Angle of
asymptotes : As there are four poles and no zero,
Fig.a)
(n=4 and m=0); angles
will be +45° and 135°.
(3) Real axis loci lies between 0 and -a and- b to o.
(4) There are 1 asymptotes i.e. n m along- 180°
-
Centroid (o)==-11_
4
(5) k=S)_ s(S+a)_s+as
Cross of R.L. imaginary-axis
:
input frequency. eranhical plots in different co-ordinates which give better insight for
Xi(t LINEAR Xolt analysis and design of control systems.
OUTPUT
INPUTLSYSTEM Q.1. What are the limitations of time domain analysis?
xi(t Ans. Limitations of Time Domain Analysis
) Time domain approach becomes difficult to analyse the
response as the order of the system increases.
(2) In design problems, there is a lack of an unified approach
for finding design. solutions that satisfy various time domain
v) Gain margin:
by Jarger Mp and less stabilit
This is defined as the magnitude
cross-over frequeney for which the phase of open loop transfe = s the normalized driving frequency signal
Where, u
function is -180°. Hence gain margin (G.M.) of the open loon n
frequency. From
equation (i), we get
system transfer function is equal to 20 log10 Cio at the phase
G (jo)
Tjo) =M=-u+ (2g? (ii)
cross-over frequency
vi) Phase margin: This is defined as 180° plus the phase Tjo)=¢= - tan"(2u /(1-u)]
11)
angle (o), of the transfer function at which the magnitude is unity.
The steady-state output of the system for a sinusoidal input of
This indicates the relative stability of the system.
unit magnitude and variable frequency o is given by,
vii) Gain cross over frequency: The frequency at which
G (jo)H (jo)| = 1
(0db) is called as the gain cross-over sin ot-tan-12u
+(25u)2
frequency. I-u2
viii) Phase cross over frequency: The frequency at which From equation (ii) and (ii), it is seen that when
LUr=Wr/Wn and M, co
lal
0< E <0.707, M, 1s greater than unity, », is less
For
than @n
and
E>0.707, there is no resonant peak and the M, = 1
Cor
O, 0.
-90 M, of frequency
response is indicative of g damping factor
frequency is indicative of natural
for0<E<0.707. @, the resonant
Phase
angle indicates speed of response
frequency @, (for a given ) and hence
as
180 0-4 0-8 10 12 2-0
Normatized Frequency u etting 4E@n
(b
Cut-off frequency of bandwidth
The frequency where M has a peak value is known as the has a value
Cut-off frequency @c is the point at which M
resonant frequency. At this frequency, the slope
of the magnitude 0.707. Usually control system are low pass filters, hence M = 1 for
curve is zero. Let o, be the resonant frequency
and u, =(0, {Oa)zero equal to @c. Put M = 0.707,
frequency, bandwidth becomes
.
1-u+2ueE) =2 MrMp 20
Mr
Solving u--25 JV454-42 +2
15
0-5
and BW =@c
O 0-2 04 0-5 T 0-8 10
positive sign is-taken as BW is a positive quantity. From (vi), 0:707
(1) BW is directly proportional to on only. For > Mr does not exist and Mp is also well damped.
shown by taking
3) BW and M, are directily proportional for 0<<0.707
-2 (vii)
(4) As time increases, BW decreases. 1-2
g.
Further co-ordinates between time and frequency domain It is seen both are functions of
response are discussed with reference to a step response. Relation
Again BW is indicative of g and settling time t
12r
between @d, the damped frequency of oscillation and 1.0
M,, the peak
overshoot given by relations from time domain specifications i.e. wrd o-8
0-6
0-4
0-2
M, =exp
0
00-2 0-4 0-6f 08.10
0707
376 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM ICS-IETICT
(ET
SYSTEM/CS-I (ETICT)
Q.11. What does band width imply? alD CONTROL 377
Ans. A large band width means higher frequencies are cail Q.14. Say True of False. Justify with Reasons. "As
passed through the system. This means ise time andhence damping ratio increase from 0 to 0.707, Mp increases, M,
a faster risc
system, =1
jo (jog+25@n)|
(1) Band width increases, hence rise time is lessened.
(2) Settling time increases.
i.e. -=1
(3) System becomes more stable.
When a pole is added in the forward path,
g yo+45o
(1) Band width decreases, rise time increases. a+42 .a-o =o
(2) M, increases.
If say x= o is substituted; it becomes a quadratic eqn.
(3) System becomes less stable.
Q.13. Justify with reasons. Say True or false. Solution given; o2=4S @ t/163 0+40
As damping ratio increases peak overshoot and resonating| 2
peak magnitude both reduces".
-2 oto4z+1
Ans. The resonating peak magnitude
M, =- decrease
51-2 =-22
On
+y1+45
as increases.
Now
- Tt =180° +2G(jo).Hjo) lo=@g
Mp= PM
e-
. .
dB
2) 20 dec for o>1
20log1o 2 6.02 dB
1+j
- tano
CONTROLSYSTEM /cS-I (ET/CT) 393
VBD
392 BD I CSi(ETICTn
CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-1(T Q.18. What are the limitations of Polar Plot?
Limitations of Polar Plot:
Ans.
14.42 1) The
calculation or requency response by polar plot
=1
(2.13) and not give the effect of individual poles and zero's.
g1+ogx tedious and does
2) Addition
A of poles and zero's to an existing system requires
o (1+4.54o)=207.93 recalculation of frequency response.
complete
he
@g =6.657 rad/sec Method of constructing Polar Plot:
1) Determine the transfer
function G(s) of the system.
ii) Phase-margin= pM =180° + 2G (j0)| o=og
=
2Substitute s jo in the transfer function G(s) and obtain the
PM =180°+[-90°- tan (2.13x 6.657)] function G (jo)..
frequency response
PM=4.033
3) Obtain the magnitude of G (jo) at o = 0 and o= o by
ii) M, having lim |G (jo)| and lim |G (jo)|.
251- 2x0.162 1(0.162)2 0-0
M, =3.128 4) Calculate the phase angle of G (jo) at o=0 and o=o by
180 1) Equate 2G(jo) to 180 and find the frequency. This will
0
0
bep*
2) Find
1G(jo)|by substituting o= p
3) GM=
G(jo)l a=op?
Similarly Phase margin DpM =180 + ZG(jo)|o=Dg 4) Equate will be og.
| G(ja)| to l and find the frequency. This
Where @ is the gain cross-over ency
frequency i.e. the freq
$) DPM
at which
180° +2Gjo)lo=og
|G(jo)|=1.
(ETICT)
CONTROL SYSTEM/ CS-I 419
418 VBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS1 (TICT VDD
equation (4), it is seen that the zeros of q(s) at
90 From are the roots of the characteristic equation and
1, -Z2,. Pn are same as the open-loop
poles ofq( at-P1P2
a(s)
the system. For the system to be stable, the roots of the
etem. Fo
poles of
the and hence the zeros of q(s) must lie in the left
cteristic equation
180 s-plan. It is impoftant to note that even if some of the
or the
half of
half poles lie in the right half of s-plane, all the zeros of q(s),
open- closed-loop poles may lie in the left half of
s-plane,
the
operation.
.
ie,aning thereby that an open-loop unstable system may lead to a
closed-loop stable
investigate the presence of any zero of q(s) = 1+
In order to
right half s-plane, let us choose a contour, which
Gls) H(s))in the (right) hal Or
Nyquist stability criterion itcompletely encloses this of the s-plane. Such a contour
Q. 20. State and explain Nyquist's stability criterion in
Nyquist ntour is shown in fig. (2) It is directed
called the
IE-S-98; W-99, W-00, S-02 or a infinite line segment Ci along the
most general-form. comprises
the location of roots of clockwise and
Ans. Nyquist stability criterion relates response an arc C2 of infinite radius.
frequency, io-axis and
the characteristics equation to the open-loop
not necessary. and the Along C
The computation of closed-loop poles is
stability study can be carried out graphically from the open-loop
s= jo with s varying from -jo to+ jo and along C2,
frequency response.
Re with 6 varying from + to 0 to
-
Q.21. What is Nyquist criterion? ET-S-97,
CT-W-03,S-04| =lim
R-
Ans. Nyquiststability criterion: The Nyquist contour so defined encloses all the right half
system-shown in figure
Consider the single-loop feedback s-plane zeros and poles of q(s)=1 +G(s) H(s). Let there be Z zeros
The characteristic equation of the system is
q(s)=1+G (6) H(s)=0 ..(1) andP poles of q(s) in the right half of s-plane. As s moves along the
is traversed in
transfer function yquist contour in the s-plane, a closed contour Ia
The standard pole-zero form of the open-loop
theq(s)- plane which encloses the origin N = P-Z
G () H(S) is
+ Zm) times in the counter clockwise direction.
G(s) H(s) =k 1)(S+ Z2)..(s ,mSN 2) In order, for the system to be stable, there should be no zeros of
(s+P1)(s+P2)..(s+ P)
46)-1+G (s) H ($) intheright RiS) OlS
From equation (1) and (2), we obtain
(S+22)...(s+ Zm) .. half of s-planc,
i.e., 6tS
q(s)=1+ kZ
g6) Z=0
(s+Pp) (s+ P2)... (s + Pn)
P1)(s + P2)... (s+Pn) +k(s+ z1) (s + z2)... s+Zm2
This condition is met if HIS)
(s# N=P ...(6)
(s+ P) (s+P2).. s + Pn
for à closed-loop system to be stable, the number o,
+zi)s +z5).+zn)2 . at 1s,
nter clockwise encirclements ofthe origin of the q (S) lane o
(s+P) (s +P2)...(s+ Pn)
420 STEMICS-A SYSTEM s-1 (ETICT)
BD CONTROL (ETICR CONTROL 421
g'BD poles of G(s) H(s),
of right hall s-plane
the contour iw
T should equal the number of the the closed-
S-plone
ber stable.
um
zero's of q(s) says, s=aj as shown in figure 2 while all the poles
Aiw
and remaining zero's are distributed in the s-planè outside
the
s-plane Hs) plan
contour.
S-plane
7 1gls)-plane
s2
gls2)
(sa A
Artitrarily chosen
S-plane contour
Correspon ding qls)-plane
contour
w S-PLANE iv qsPLANNE
(A 8)
once
It is found that the q(s) plane contour encircles the origin
in the clockwise direction.
contour is commonly known as principle of argument. is called as Nyquist Contour. It is directed clockwise and comprises
OPEN L0OP POLES ON THE jo Axis. of an infinite line segment C along jo axis and an are C2 of
infinite radius.
Jo
jw
L=90
w-00
w:0
0
shown below. 6
:"'.
Step 1: Part I of Figure(a)
Puts=jo in equation (1) 202 90. (3)
Hjo)=8+jo
G(s) H(gO)io(-1+j (i) For
1
iw
-1+ jo)
Now calculating the angle 2G(jo) H(j»). For doing this
let
For(-1+jo), the sketch and angle is as shown below.
us first see the angles of individual components i.e.
Angle-180-an w
(3+jo), and
jo (-1+jo)
+jw
(i) For (3+jo)
By calculation tan
20tan
CONTROL SYSTEM GS-T(ETICT)
429
(ET
CONTROL SYSTEM/ CS-I ETICT) BD othe intermediate point o=3
For any ther
428 VBD
(d)
), therefore
nerelore the Sx32 +32
However here the
component
is1+ jo Gljo)
Hjo)=<
3xV12 +32
2.236
and (4)
iw The
ws. At
this point of
intersection the angle
2Gjo)Hjo) should
From equation (2), (3)
+180 + tano
2Gjo) HGo)=tan"-90°
3
be180
180= tan -90 +180 + tano
= 0-90° + 180 +0
=90°
.At o= Ggo)Hjo)|=0
and 4G(jo) H(jo)=-90° ) tantan90-
c) For any intermediate point o =1 1-X0
Ggo)Hjo)l-
Gg)Hg)
Sx/12+32
==11.18
Ixv12+12
- 3 0 3
=1= o2 =3;: o=v3 =1.732
(1+4ReJ) = 0 e i3¢
= Lim =ce-j20 Lim
(1 + ReJ®) (1+2ReJè)
e0E ej28 R-R2
=o (180° >20°-> Z-180°)
=0 (2-270°>20°>2+270°)
This part of the map is an infinite circle shown in figure b. The complete mapped plot corresponding to the Nyquist
ii) Along the jo-axis contour of figure(a) is shown 'in figure(b). From this plot, it is
observed that (-1+j0) point is encircled twice in the clockwise
Gjo) H(jo)= +j4o) direction. Therefore, N =-2. From the given transfer function, it is
jo) (1+jo) (1+j2o)
Bseen that no pole of G(s) H(s) lies in the right half of s-plane ie. P=0.
iw iv Thus-2 0- Zor Z = 2. Hence two zeros of q(s) lie inthe
j right half of s-plane from which we conclude that the system in
unstable.
10-6 By use of Nyquist criterion, determine whether the
i W= 0 W+
Q.26.
IOSed loop. systems having the following open loop transfer
i je W=0T Wa-
functions is stable
8e 14js or not. If not, how many closed loop poles lie
wv/2 in the right half s-plane?
G(s)H6) = ET-W-98
s(1+2s)1+s)
qBD CONTROL SYSTEMI CS. CONTROL SYSTEM, T (ETICI)
AETICT
434
ies.
BD part of G(jo) HGo) to zero
435
Gjw)Hgw)= io1+jo)(1+2jo) )
I- 200
j
J
=
Putting o 1/V2 in the real part of Gjo) Hjo) we get
GG/2 ) HG 1/2)= -
=-0.666
Thus, the Nyquist plot intersect the negative real axis at- 0.666
=0, |G(jo)H(jo)= and
-i open loop transfer function
at
4Gjo)Hjo) = -90°
The Nyquist contour for the above
is shown. (3) The infinite semicircular arc of the Nyquist contour
is obtained as follows represented by
The mapping of Nyquist contour
origin
1) The semicircular indent around the pole at the ReJ° ( variesfrom 90° through 0 to -90°)
Lim
represented by R
Lim E eJo 1
S= E0 is mapped into Lim =
.0
." Ro LRed(+Re'®)(1+2Re")J
( varying from- 90° through 0 to +90 ) maps into
i.e. the origin of G(s) H(s) plane.
.
1
=.Lim
oLEea+2Eei®)0+Eej®EEeJ (4) Themappingof Im GH Plane
negative imaginary axis is the
= o e =
o(L90° >L0°> -90°) mirror imageof positive P 0
imaginary axis, The Nyquist plot -2/3 N=D
Thus the semicircular indent around the origin maps into a
s as shown in figure
semicircular arc of infinite radius in G(s$) H($) plane.
Z 0
= K
-j(sin 0.8o +ocos 0.8o)] G) H(s)
s(s+2) (s+10)
Equating imaginary part ofequation (1) to zero, we get
Determine the range of K for which closed-loop system is
sin 0.80 + o cos 0.8 o =0 stable.
sin 0.8
Soln.
cos 0.8o
+0= 0
K
tan 0.8 G(s) H(s)
.0- (2) s(s+2) (s +10)
Solving equation (2) for smallest possible value of o, we get,
. 2.4482
K/20
For point of intersection of Nyquist plot with the real
s(1+0.5 s) (1 +0.1 s)
axis
substitute o=2.4482 into the real part
of G(jo) -90
- tan
0.5 o- tan'0.1o
GG 2.4482) = k K/20
(cos 1.956 2.4482 sin 1.9586) M=-
1+(2.44822 oy1+(0.5 o) 1+(0.1
G2.4482)=-0.378 K
SYST STEMICS4
438 ETICT cONTROL sYSTEMICS-I (ETICT)
VBD 439
When, Th polar plot and magnitude versus phase plot can easily
iv) The
iv)
=0 =-900 compute from the Bode plot.
=-270 be co
be e frequency response ot a system consists of two or
more
for which the frequency response from Bode plots
Nyquist plot is shown in
Figure. cascade element
1 ained by combining the Bode plots of individual elements.
==4.47 rad/sec an be
Consider a typical ansfer function G(jo) factored in the time
0 T T20.5x0.1
Constant form
aKTT
a20 T+ 12)
mag
Gljo)=
k(1+joTa)(1+ j»T,).
Ti)(1+joT2).+28 4jo
jo(1+jo
K(0.1x0.5)
20(0.1+0.5) Wro
n
K
Rea k(1+joTa) (1+ joTp)..
240 Go)=
For stability jo'd+joT)+joTz).-+2n
W0
K <1
240 G Go in dB (i.e. log magnitude) is given by
or K<240. G jo) in dB = 20 log10 (equation 1)
BODE PLOT
.20 log G (jo)= 20 log k + 20 log(1+joT,)
The complete Bode plot of a system consists of two
Curves
ofGGo) are converted into addition terms on the plot. and the phase angle is given by
20 n
Second Order Zero 1+j2 @n
curve for 1 +2j Here magnitude plot is
Fig. Magnitudes
n (1) 0 db for <n
(2)Poles at Origin (1/jo)":
(20)-40 db n
Magnitude Plot is straight line at 20nd
dec
slope [Link]
d dec
for @>
5) First order zeros (1+jo/b): We may have to obtain it by means of experimental analysis. The
Magnitude plot is two straight 1ines at 0 db for o<bandaportance of the frequency response methods is that the transfer
unetion of the plant or any other component of a system, may be
+20 db/dec for o> b. Phase o= tano/b.
450 ETICT CONTROL SYSTEMICS-I (ETICT)
frequency-response measurem
rements. BD 451
determined by simple Choose suitable Y and X
amplitude ratio and phase
shift have been measured at f
a suffic
te Step 3 scales for magnitude
curve. Draw the Bode magnitude
within the frequency ange of interest, curve for each.
number of frequencies Step 4 Draw the Resultant,
Then the transferfunctionthe
may be plotted on the Bode diagram.. Write the phase equation corresponding
approximations. W ca Step 5 to the
be determined by asymptotic build phase of each term present.
asymptotic log-magnitude
curves consisting of several segments
.
over
time interval. But, if the input is known only
Yt) over the same
the voltage across capacitors and
the time interval t to t, then
matrix [A]. For system to be stable, all the eigen values of IAx
A] Solving for Y(s), we obtain
should lie on left hand side (L.H.S.) of s-Plane (i.e. the eigen valuo
Y(s) = C(sl-A)"X(0) +C(sl-A)"l Bu(s)
should have negative real parts). + Du(s)
The eigen values of [A] are obtained as the solution of equation Assuming zero itial conditions, we get
the system transfer
1[-[A]=0 function as,
SOLVED PROBLEMAS
Prob.1. Given the 'SISO' system
x Ax+Bu (ii) Using the results of part
(iv) Comment on,
y Cx+Du
(a) The stability of a network.
(b) The nature of response (underdamped/overdamped
Derive the expression for the transfer function Y)
U(s) Ieritically damped) to the step changes in the input.
IET-S-98
.".[ET-S-971 Soln. (i) We take mesh currents as i,i2, ig as shown in fig.
Soln. Given : x= Ax + Bu
Let
y= Cx+ Du (G1-i2)dt ..(1)
Taking the Laplace transform
X=
of equation (i) and (ii), we get
x2 =i2-i3
(2)
=
X(s)-X(0) Ax (s) +Bu(s) .3)
X3 =Ji3 dt
Writing the mesh equations, we have
VBD CONTROL SYSTEM I CS (ETICT TROL SYSTEMI CSI (ETICT
CON:
514 BD
The following equations are satisfied |A-A=0 515
dif
a) Vi =Rf i
+Li 2a+3-0
dirRLi +
dt Lf
(1) . 2(3+3) +2=0
b) =Bdo= Tm =KTi 1 +3+2=0
B
do
dt
= 0.
AT
J
.) ,
0.+1)0 +2)=0
A2=-2
dt Consider (11-A)(x)=0
dir R
dt Lr
do KT Ni
dt
1
-X1-X2 =0 and 2x1
+2x20
Choosing X1 =1, x2=-1
Prob.13. A control system is having state space
[21-A]x =0
representation.
4;y= [1 3] X
-
Soln. The canonical model from this general model is given by m2
=Ml AMZ+M-'Br
Y= CMZ+D4 M
where, M=[M1 M2-----M,]
M1 M2,------M, are the eigen vectors of A
we have, MAM=
A-2
The characteristics equation is given by
VBD CONTROL YSTEM/ Cs (ETICT SYS:
516 VBDCONTROL I CS(ETICT)
s)=Cs)_Z(s) C()
G()R(S)
MB-1-1 R(s) Z(s)
517
Consider
M-11 3 |-t2 -59
Zs) 1
R(6)s+ +6s+11s
The canonical form ofthe system is +6
53Z(s) +6s*Z(s) +l1s Z(s) + 6=R(s)
2--z- y--2-5] Z
(ii) Block diagram of the system
Taking L, we have
Z+ 6Ž +11Z+6Z=r
Let =Z, 1)
x2 X1= Z and
x^=
2 =Z=xj
2)
X=Z=x3
3)
=-112-6Z-6+r
3-11x1 -6x2 -6x3 +r ..6)
(ii) Since the eigen values (1 = -1, A2 =-2) lie to the left
From (2), (3) and (5), we have the state equation
as
half of s-plane, hence the system is stable.
Prob.14. The open loop transfer function of unity feedback
system is given by -11 -6-6]| x
5(s +3s+4)
G(s)=
G6)+1)(s+2)(s+3)
Also,
z(s)
=5 (s2+3s +4)
Obtain the state model in phase variable form, assume C(S)5s2 +15s+20
second state variable as output variable of Z(s)
the system. [ET-S-98J
G(s) =US),
Soln. G6)=R((s+
1 C(s)=5s Z(s) +15sZ (s) +20 Z(s)
(s+)6+2)(s+35(s2 +3s+4) -*
Taking L, we have
g ar32 0HVIVA-VOCE
system?
0.16. What are the drawbacks of negative feedback
system?
530 open loop no feedbact Ans. The drawbacks are
system, there is
is a so
Q.9. What Sensitivity to variations in H(s) is more.
open loop system output.
Ans. In anindependent of the ) More components for H(s) are required.
is Thus complexity
control action automatically
automaticaly car
carried for and cost increases.
OR :-h
which does not
physical system,
open loop
system. ii) Gain decreases.
Any called an iv) If G(s) H(s) =
output is loop systemn. I, than T(s) = *» and the system
-
variation in the
examples of open system are unstable.
becomes
Q.10. Give the loop control
examples of open o.17. Give the classification of control system.
Ans. The driver.
1)
Automatic hand Ans. Control system can be classified in many ways:-
toaster. 1) Linear versus non-linear system.
2) Bread
Electronic lift. 2) Continuous ume & discrete time control system.
3) etc.
drinks-milk bottling
4) Cold open loopP system? 3) Deterministic & stochastic control system.
the advantages of
Q.11. What are in
construction and design. 4) Time varying& time invariant control systen
simple
Ans. They are
1) 5) Lumped parameter & distributed parameter control system.
economic.
2) They are 6) Single- input single output & multiple input multiple
-
maintainance. - -
.
Ans. The values of 's' for which the transfer function
Mass (M) Inductance (L) Inertia (J)
magnitude G(s) becomes zero after substitution Damper (B)
in numerator of Damper (B) Resistance (R)
system is called as zero of transfer function. Spring (K) Soring (K)
e Elastance D
Q.29. Define characteristic equation.
Ans. The equation obtained by equating the denominator Displacement (x) Charge (q) Displacenment (0)
Velocity ( Velocity (w)
polynomial of transfer function to zero is called as
characteristic Currenti-
equation.
YPD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-I (ETICn CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-I (ETICn 535
WD
534
force-current analogy. Q40. What is a mathematical model?
Q.33. Give the Ans, It is the mathematical representation of physical model
Ans.
Electrical Rotational through the use of appropriate physical laws.
Transtational
Current (i) Torque (T) Q41. What is time response of a system?
Force (F)
Capacitance (C) Inertia (J) Ans. The response of a system to an applied excitation is called
Mass (M) response.
Reciprocal of Spring (K) as Time
Spring (K) Q.42. What is transient response?
inductanceT Ans. That part of the time response that goes to zero as time
becomes very large called as transient response.
1S
Damper (B) Damper (B) Q43. How can you reduce the value of steady state error?
Conductance Ans. 1) Increasing the type of the system.
R
Displacement (Q) 2) Decreasing the value of k.
Displacement (x) Flux linkage (0) (damping factor) for
Q.44. What is the value of
Velocity dQ underdamped response?
Velocitydt Voltage damping factor
Ans. For underdamped response, 0< < ,i.e.
l1
dt
Q.34. What is a block diagram? lies between 0 and 1.
Ans. It is diagramatic representation of a system, where each Q.45. What is the value of for overdamped response?
block represents an element, a plant, mechanism, device etc. without Ans. > 1, for overdamped response.
damped
internal details. Q.46. What is the value of 3 for critically
Q.35. What is signal flow graph? response?
Ans. A signal flow graph is a pictorial representation ofa Ans. =1, for critically damped response.
system & it displays graphically the transmission of signals in a
Q.47. If g<1, then poles are lie in which quadrants?
system.
Q.36. What are the components ofsignal flow graph? Ans. It lies in second & third quadrant.
system?
Q.48. What is the value of for undamped
g
Ans. The components are: Input node, output node, path,
forward path, loop, Non-touching loop, Path-gain and Loop-gain. Ans. = 0 for undamped system. undamped natural
Q.37. What is a physical system? Q49. What is the significance of
Ans. A physical system is a collection of physical objects frequency 'on 'and the damped frequeney *oa' on S-plane?
distance of the roots (poles)
connected together to serve an objective. Ans. '0,"' represents the radial
Q.38. Give the examples of physical systems. represents the imaginary
from the origin on S-plane whereas 'a"
Ans. Examples of physical systems are S-plane.
1) An electronic amplifier. component of the root on 'jo' axis of
Q.50. What values of ' are normally preferred in
2) Governing mechanism of steam turbines or communications
satellite orbiting the earths etc. practical systems?
values of lie between 0.4 and
Q.39. What is a physical model? Ans. Normally the preferred
Ans. An idealized physical system is called as a physical 0.8 for a 2"" order system.
model.
qBD CONTROL SYSTEM/CS-(T SYSTEM/CS-(ETICT)
536 CONTROL 537
response of a system? wD
Q.51. What is frequency G) By locating the rOOts of the characteristics equation in S-
Ans. The steady state response of system to sinusoidal i, s
a a
frequency response.
l inpu
planc.t
is termed as its Hurwitz stability criterion.
(i)
Q.52. What are the advantages of frequency response over (iii) Routh-Hurwitz stability criterion
time-response analysis? iv) Bode-plot technique.
Ans. The advantages are: (v) Nyquist stability criterion.
0) Ease and accuracy of meašurement.
?:
* (vi) By locating the eigen values.
more easily.'
(i) Transfer function can be obtained ku O.57. Show bounded and unbounded response?
Gii) The closed loop T.F. of a system can be known from Ans.
it.
open loop TF.
Unbounded o/P
(iv) The effects of noise disturbance and parameter variation Bounded OP
are relatively easy to visualize.
(v) The transient response of a system can be obtained from it's
AAT
frequency response through Fourier integrals."
analysis? '
M
Q.53. What are the limitations of îrequency response Bounded i/P VV.\ Bounded i/P
.
Ans. M,indicates relative stability of the
2) Polar plot in the forward
3) Magnitude verses phase Q.60. What happens when a zero is added
angle plot.
Q.55. When would you call path?
a system as a stable system?
Ans. If a bounded input is Ans. 1) Bandwidth increases.
given to a system, and the system
produce bounded and controllable 2) Setling time increases.
output, then the system is stable.
Also in the absence of inputs, 3) System become more stable.
the output shou!l tend added in the forward
increase. to zero as time Q.61. What happens when a pole is
Q.5. What are the different
methods of checking
path?
a
stability of closed loop system? the Ans. 1) Bandwidth decreases.
1
Ans. Potentiometer is a
position to an electrical voltage.
transducer which converts angular
.
Q.110. What are the limitations of potentiometer?
Ans. i) Full rotation is not available.
ii) Poor sensitivity.
et t1