Constitution vs. Constitutionalism Explained
Constitution vs. Constitutionalism Explained
1 Introduction
The concepts of constitution and constitutionalism refer to the legal framework of a country.
While the constitution is often defined as the supreme law of country constitutionalism is a
system of governance under which the power of the government is limited by the rule of law.
Constitutionalism recognizes the need for limiting the concentration of power in order to protect
the rights of groups and individuals.
In such a system, the power of the Government can be limited by the constitution and by the
provisions and regulations contained in it but by other measures and norms.
In order to understand the five concepts as well as their similarities and differences, it is
important to understand their history and evolution.
The idea of the constitution has changed significantly compare, to the first examples seen in
ancient Greece, while the concept of constitutionalism has growl around the principle that the
authority of the government is derived from and limited by a set of rules and laws.
1.4 Difference Between Constitution and Constitutionalism ............................................................... 1.3 Yet, although many countries have a written constitution, we continue to see the phenomenon of
'living constitution' in many parts of the world. As society change, so do laws and regulations.
1.5 References ......................................................................................................................................... 1.3
Furthermore, in some cases, there is no single document that defines all aspects of the state, but
rather several different documents and agreements that define the power of the government and
provide a comprehensive although not unitary legal framework. Constitution has also been
defined as:
Basic norm (or law) of the state
System of integration and organization of norms and laws; and
Organization of the government.
The Constitution provides the foundation of the government, structuring the political organization
and guaranteeing individual and collective rights and freedoms.
The Company has exclusive rights to trade in India. In the year 1765, the East India Company
obtained 'Diwani' (Rights over revenue and civil justice) of Bengal, Bihar, and Orissa.
After the Sepoy mutiny in the year 1858, the British crown assumed direct responsibility for the
governance of India. It continued up to August 15, 1947, after India is a free India. (India got
independence).
Before 1947, India was divided into two main entities.
Let us see the historical background of the Indian Constitution and its development over the
years.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
2.2 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian 2.3
Constitution Constitution
The Supreme Court was established at Fort William (Calcutta) as the Apex Court in the year 1774. 2.8 Government of India Act of 1858
It prohibited servants of the company from engaging in any private trade or accepting bribes from
The rule of the Company was replaced by the rule of the Crown in India.
the natives.
The powers. of the British Crown were to be exercised by the Secretary of State for India. He
Court of Directors (the governing body of the company) should report its revenue.
serves assisted by the Council of India having 15 members.
He was vested with complete authority and control over the Indian administration through the
2.4 Pitt's India Act of 1784 Viceroy as his agent.
The commercial and political functions of the company separated. The Governor-General was made the Viceroy of India.
The Court of Directors managed the commercial activities while the Board of Control managed Lord Canning was the first Viceroy of India.
political affairs.
it abolished the Board of Control and Court of Directors.
It has reduced the strength of the Governor General's council to three members.
It placed the Indian affairs under the direct control of the British Government. 2.9 Indian Councils Act of 1861
The company's territories in India were called 'the British possession in India'.
It introduced for the first time Indian representation in the institutions like Viceroy's executive and
Governor's councils were established in Madras and Bombay. legislative council (non-official). 3 Indians entered the Legislative Council.
Legislative Councils were established in the Center and provinces.
2.5 Charter Act of 1813 It provided that the Viceroy's Executive Council should have some Indians as the unofficial
The East India Company Act 1813, also known as the Charles Act 1813, was an Act of the members while transacting the legislative businesses.
Parliament of the United Kingdom which renewed the charter issued to the British East India It accorded statutory recognition to the portfolio system.
Company and continued the Company's rule in India.
Initiated the process of decentralization by restoring the legislative powers to the Bombay and
The Company's monopoly over Indian trade terminated. the Madras Provinces.
Elections, mainly indirect, were affirmed for all levels of society. The elected Indians were also
2.7 Charter Act of 1853 enabled to debate budgetary and complementary matters and table resolutions.
The legislative and executive functions of the Governor-General's Council were separated. It changed the name of the Central Legislative Council to the Imperial Legislative Council.
The council of legislative purposes which had 6 members now was expanded to 12 members. The member of the Central Legislative Council was increased to 60 from 16.
Four out of six members were appointed !y the provisional governments of Madras, Bombay, Introduced a system of communal representation for Muslims by accepting the concept of
Bengal, and Agra. 'separate electorate.
It introduced a system of open competition as the basis for the recruitment of civil servants of The first time, Indians were given place in Viceroys Executive Council. (Satyendra Prasad Sinha,
the Company (Indian Civil Service opened for all). as the law member)
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
2.4 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian 2.5
Constitution Constitution
2.12 Government of India Act of 1919 These six Provinces were Assam, Bengal, Bombay, Bihar, Madras and the United Province.
A Federal Court was established at Delhi for the resolution of disputes between provinces and
This Act is also known as the Montague-Chelmsford Reforms.
also between the center and the provinces. It has Chief Justice and not more than 6 judges.
The Central subjects were demarcated and separated from those. of the Provincial subjects.
The Indian Council was abolished.
The scheme of dual governance, 'Dyarchy', was introduced in the Provincial subjects (i.e., there
The Secretary of State for India would instead have a team of advisors.
were two classes of administrators Executive councilors and ministers).
This Act introduced direct elections in India for the first time. About 10% of the whole population
Under the dyarchy system, the provincial subjects were divided into two parts - transferred and
acquired voting rights.
reserved. On reserved subjects, Governor was not responsible for the Legislative council.
Sindh was carved out of Bombay Presidency.
The Governor was the executive head of the province. The Governor was in charge of the
reserved list along with his executive councilors. The subjects under this list were law and order, Burma was severed off from India.
irrigation, finance, land revenue, etc.
Aden was also separated from India and made into a Crown colony.
The Ministers were in charge of subjects under the transferred list. The subjects included were
The British Parliament retained its supremacy over the Indian legislatures both provincial and
education, local government, health, excise, industry public works, religious endowments, etc.
federal.
The Ministers were responsible for the people who elected them through the legislature.
A Federal Railway Authority was set up to control Indian railways.
These Ministers were nominated from among the elected members of the Legislative Council.
The Reserve Bank of India was established as per this Act.
The executive councilors were not responsible to the legislature, unlike the Ministers.
The Act was a milestone in the development of a responsible constitutional government in India.
The secretary of state and the Governor-General could interfere in matters under the reserved list
The Government of India Act 1935 was replaced by the Constitution of India after independence.
but this interference was restricted for the transferred list.
The Act introduced, for the first time, bicameralism at the center.
2.14 Indian Independence Act of 1947
Legislative Assembly with 140 members and Legislative council with 60 members.
Lord Mountbatten became the first Governor-General of independent India.
A system of direct elections was introduced.
Jawaharlal Nehru was sworn in as the first Prime Minister of India.
The Act also required that the three of the six members of the viceroy's Executive council (other
Muhammad Ali Jinnah became the first Governor-General of Pakistan.
than commander-in chief were to be Indians.
The Act ended the British rule and declared India as an independent and sovereign state from
Provided for the establishment of a public service commission.
August 15, 1947.
It provided for the partition of the country into India and Pakistan.
2.13 Government of India Act of 1935
The office of Viceroy was abolished and provided for the Governor-General for each dominion
The Act provided for the establishment of an All-India Federation consisting of the Provinces and
(India and Pakistan) appointed by the king.
the princely States as units, though the envisaged federation never came into being.
The Act empowered the constituent assemblies to frame and adopt any constitution.
Three Lists: The Act divided the powers between the center and the units into items of three lists,
namely the Federal List, the Provincial List, and the Concurrent List. The Indian Independence Act granted freedom to the princely states either to join India or
Pakistan or to remain independent.
The Federal List for the center consisted of 59 items, the provincial List for the provinces
consisted of 54 items and the concurrent List for both consisted of 36 items An idea for a Constituent Assembly of India was proposed in 1934 by M. N. Roy, a pioneer of the
Communist movement in India and an advocate of radical democracy.
The residuary powers were interested in the Governor-General.
It became an official demand of the Indian National Congress in 1935.
The Act abolished the Dyarchy in the provinces and introduced Provincial Autonomy.
The constituent assembly constituted in November 7946 under the scheme formulated by the
It provided for the adoption of Dyarchy at the Centre.
Cabinet Mission plan.
It introduced bicameralism in 6 out of the 11 provinces.
The Constituent Assembly met for the first time in New Delhi on 9 December 1946 in the
At the State level, the equivalent of the Lok Sabha is the Vidhan Sabha (Legislative Assembly), Constitution Hall which is now known as the Central Hall of Parliament House.
and that of the Rajya Sabha is the Vidhan Parishad (Legislative Council))
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
2.6 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-2 History of Indian 2.7
Constitution Constitution
ConstituentAssembly declares it's firm and solemn resolve to proclaim India as the Independent
Sovereign Republic and to draw up for her future governance of India.
2.15 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Contents
It was fully debated and duly enacted by the Constitution Assembly of India. 3.6 India is a Secular State
It took the Assembly 2 years, ll months and 18 days to write and enact the Constitution. Indian India gives special status to no religion.
Constitution is a very detailed constitution.
This makes it different from theocratic states like the Islamic Republic of Pakistan or other
It consists of 448 Articles divided into 25 Parts with 12 Schedules. It is a constitution of both Islamic countries.
the Centre and states of the Indian Union.
Further, Indian secularism guarantees equal freedom to all religions.
It is indeed much bigger than the US Constitution which has only 7 Articles and the French
The Constitution grants the Right to Religious Freedom to all the citizens.
Constitution with its 89 Articles.
Its first session was held on 9th December 1946. On the basis of these rights, the people freely participate in the process of politics. They elect
their government.
It passed the Objectives Resolution on 22nd January 1947.
Free fair and regular elections are held for electing governments.
Thereafter, it initiated the process of constitution-making in the right earnest and was in a
position to finally pass and adopt the constitution on 26th November 1949. For all its activities, the government of India is responsible before the people.
th
The constitution became fully operational with effect from 26 January 1950. The people can change their government through elections.
We celebrate this day as our Republic Day The constitution of India is thus a self-made and No government can remain in power which does not enjoy the confidence of the people. India
duly enacted constitution. is the world's largest working democracy.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
3.2 3.3
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3
The term 'Union of State' shows two important facts: 3.12 Fundamental Rights
That Indian Union is not the result of voluntary agreement among sovereign states; and
Under its Part III (Articles 12 to 35), the Constitution of India grants and guarantees
That states of India do not enjoy the right to secede from the Union. Indian Union has now Fundamental Rights to its citizens.
28 States and 7 Union Territories.
It is called the Indian Bill of Rights.
Initially, 7 Fundamental Rights were granted but after the deletion of the Right to Property from
3.10 A mixture of Federalism and Unitarianism the list of Fundamental Rights (44thAmendment Act 1979) their number came down to six.
While describing India as a Union of States, the Constitution provides for a federal structure The Six Fundamental Rights are:
with a unitary spirit.
Right to Equality - Articles 14-18
Scholars describe India as a 'Quasi-Federation' or as 'a federation with a unitary bias, or even
It provides for Equality before Law, End of Discrimination, Equality of Opportunity, Abolition of
as 'a Unitarian federation.
untouchability and Abolition of Titles.
Like a federation, the Constitution of India provides for :
Right to Freedom - Articles 19-22
I wrote, rigid and supreme constitution,
It incorporates six fundamental freedoms
Independent judiciary with the power to decide center-state disputes and
freedoms of speech and expression,
Dual administration i.e. central and state administrations. However, by providing a very
freedom to move freely in India,
strong center, a common constitution, single citizenship, emergency provisions, common
election commission, common all India services, etc. the Constitution clearly reflects its freedom of residence in any part, and
unitary spirit. freedom of adopting any profession or trade or occupation.
India is a federation with some Unitarian features. freedom to form associations,
This mixture of federalism-Unitarianism has been done keeping in view both the pluralistic freedom to assemble peaceably without arms,
nature of society and the presence of regional diversities, as well as due to the need for
securing unity and integrity of the nation. It ensures personal freedom and protection in respect of conviction for certain offenses.
The Constitution lays down that the freedom of life and liberty
3.11 A Mixture of Rigidity and Flexibility cannot be limited or denied except in accordance with the procedure
Some of its provisions can be amended in a difficult way while others can be amended very Now, under article 21A Right to Education for the children between the ages of 6-14 years has
easily. been granted.
In some cases, the Union Parliament can amend some parts of the Constitution by passing a Article 22 guarantees protection against arbitrary arrest and detention.
simple law. Right against Exploitation - Articles 23 & 24
Article 368, of the Constitution, provides for two special methods of amendment: This Fundamental Right prohibits the sale and purchase of human beings, forced labor
Most of the provisions of the Constitution can be amended by the Union Parliament by (beggar) and the employment of children in hazardous jobs and factories.
passing an Amendment Bill by a majority of total membership and 2/3rd majority of Right to Freedom of Religion - Articles 23-28
members present and voting in each of its two Houses.
The grant of this right involves the freedom of conscience, religion, and worship.
For the amendment of some specified parts, a very rigid method has been provided.
Under it, first, the Union Parliament passes the Amendment Bill by a majority of total Any person can follow any religion. It gives all religions the freedom to establish and maintain
membership and 2/3rd majority of members present and voting in each house. and then it their religious institutions.
goes to the State Legislatures for ratification. The Amendment gets passed only when it No person can be compelled to pay any tax for the propagation of an,v religion.
is approved by not less than one-half of the several states of the Union.
The State cannot levy a tax for any religion and the constitution prohibits the imparting of
Thus, the Constitution of India is partly rigid and partly flexible. religious instructions in schools and colleges.
Cultural and Educational Rights - Articles 29-30
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
3.4 3.5
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3
Under this category, the Constitution guarantees the rights of the minorities to maintain and 3.13 A Sources of the Constitution at a Glance
develop their languages and cultures.
It also confers upon them the right to establish, maintain and administer their educational Table 3.1 - Constitution Source
institutions.
Right to Constitutional Remedies Article 32
This fundamental right is the soul's entire BiIl rights. Fundamental rights, independence of the
judiciary, judicial review, impeachment of the
It provides for the enforcement and protection of Fundamental Rights by the Courts. US Constitution
president, removal of Supreme Court and
lt empowers the Supreme court and High courts to issue writs for the enforcement of these high court judges and post of vice-president.
rights.
Directive Principles of State Policy, the
Fundamental Duties
Irish Constitution nomination of members to Rajya Sabha and
According to Article 51 A, it shall be the duty of every citizen of India: method of election of the president.
1. to abide by the Constitution and respect its ideals and institutions, the National Flag and the
Concurrent List, freedom of trade, commerce
National Anthem;
Australian Constitution and intercourse, and a joint sitting of the two
2. to cherish and follow the noble ideals that inspired the national struggle for freedom; Houses of Parliament.
3. to uphold and protect the sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India;
Suspension of Fundamental Rights during
4. to defend the country and render national service when called upon to do so; Weimar Constitution of Germany
Emergency.
5. to promote harmony and the spirit of common brotherhood amongst all the people of India
Soviet Constitution Fundamental duties and the ideal of justice
transcending religious, linguistic and regional or sectional diversities and to renounce practices
(social, economic and political) in the
derogatory to the dignity of women; (USSR, now Russia) Preamble.
6. to value and preserve the rich heritage of the country’s composite culture;
The French Constitution Republic and the
7. to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers, and wildlife and to
French Constitution ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity in the
have compassion for living creatures;
Preamble.
8. to develop the scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform;
9. to safeguard public property and to abjure violence; Procedure for amendment of the Constitution
South African Constitution
and election of members of Rajya Sabha.
10. to strive towards excellence in all spheres of individual and collective activity so that the nation
constantly rises to higher levels of endeavor and achievement; and Japanese Constitution Procedure established
Japanese constitution
11. to provide opportunities for education to his child or ward between the age of six and fourteen by Law.
years. This duty was added by the 86th Constitutional Amendment Act, 2002.
Emergency Provision 3.14 References
Article 352 Announcement of a national emergency M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Article 356 Provisions for the occasion of the failure of the constitutional system of states Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Article 360 Provisions regarding the financial crisis Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Emergency provisions are provided under Articles 352 to 360 of Part VII of the Indian
Constitution. The provision of this crisis is considered a distinctive feature of the Indian
Constitution. Because it can protect the country. The central government has unique powers
in times of crisis.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
3.6 3.7
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-3
4.1 Fundamental Rights
The Fundamental Rights are defined as the basic human rights of all citizens.
These rights, defined in part III of the Constitution, applied irrespective of race, place of birth,
religion, caste, creed, or gender.
They are enforceable by the courts, subject to specific restrictions as necessary for the
protection of public interest.
Originally the constitution provided for seven Fundamental Rights viz.
4.1 Fundamental Rights .......................................................................................................................... 4.2 Right to constitutional remedies (Article 32)
4.2 Right to Equality ................................................................................................................................ 4.2 But, Right to property was removed from the list of the Fundamental Rights by the 44th
constitution Amendment Act, l978 and after amendment, it was made a legal right.
4.3 Right to Freedom ............................................................................................................................... 4.3
At present, there are only six Fundamental Rights. They are described below in brief.
4.4 Right against Exploitation ................................................................................................................. 4.3
4.5 Right to Freedom of Religion ............................................................................................................ 4.3
4.2 Right to Equality
4.6 Cultural and Educational Rights ....................................................................................................... 4.3
Right to Equality is the first fundamental right, which brought the end of untouchability.
4.7 Article-32 Right to Constitutional Remedies ................................................................................... 4.4
This right stands for the principle of equality before the law as well as social equality and
4.8 Features of Fundamental Rights ...................................................................................................... 4.4 supports the non-discrimination of people on any basis.
4.9 References ......................................................................................................................................... 4.5 This right also states that every Indian citizen is equal in front of the law and prohibits
discrimination on the grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex. place of birth, or any other
grounds.
Article 14 is available to any person including legal persons viz. statutory corporation, companies,
etc.
Article 14 is taken from the concept of equal protection of laws from the Constitution of the USA.
Under Article 15 (3) &. (4), the Government can make special provisions for women and children
and for a group of citizens who are economically and socially backward.
Article 16 says that there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to
employment or appointment to any office under the State.
Article 18 says that no title, not being a military or academic distinction, shall be conferred by the
State. No citizen of India shall accept any title from any Foreign State.
The awards, Bharat Ratna, Padma Vibhuhan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Shri, called as the
National Awards would not amount to the title within the meaning of Article 18.
It is command issued by the Supreme Court or High Court to any person, corporation, inferior
Article 23 deals with the prohibition of traffic in human beings and forced labor.
court, public authority or Government who has to perform statutory duty but who fails to do so.
Article 24 deals with the prohibition of employment of children in factories, etc.
Writ of Prohibition
These rights help to prevent exploitation of the weaker section of different sectors by the state,
Here prohibition command is issued by Supreme Court or High Court to an inferior court or
organizations as well as individuals.
Tribunal to refrain from doing something which it is about to do.
Forced labor, working without labor, human trafficking, child labor, and other illegal and ethically
It is based on the principle that prevention is better than cure.
unjust acts are prohibited by this Fundamental Right.
Writ of Certiorari
The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act,1976 was enacted by the Indian parliament in support
of this basic right. Certiorari means "to be certified" or "to be more fully informed of'.
It can be issued by the Supreme Court or High Court to the inferior court or any authority,
4.5 Right to Freedom of Religion whenever any authority of the court.
India is a secular country and the right to freedom of religion to all its citizens ensures that all Writ of Quo Waranto
states treat all the religions neutrally. Quo-warranto means "what is your authority"?
Every Indian citizen has religious freedom and can follow any religion of their choice. This writ prevents a person from continuing in public office who has wrongfully usurped the office.
Right to freedom of religion also promotes a right to preach, practice and propagate any religion The Supreme Court has rights to protect the fundamental rights of citizens even against private
of their choice and guarantees freedom of conscience to all Indian citizens. bodies, and can also award compensation to the affected individuals.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
4.3 4.4
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-4 Fundamental Rights Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-4 Fundamental Rights
They are 'fundamental' also in the sense that they are most essential for the all-round Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
development (material, moral, intellectual and spiritual) of the individuals.
The Fundamental Rights are enshrined in Part III of the constitution from Article 12 to 35.
The Fundamental Rights are meant for promoting the idea of political democracy.
Others are available to all including foreigners or legal persons like corporations or companies,
etc.
They are not absolute but qualified. The State can impose reasonable restrictions on them
(balance between individual liberty and social control). Courts can decide whether such
restrictions are reasonable or not.
Most of them are available against the arbitrary action of the State, with a few exceptions like
those against the State's action and against the action of private individuals.
When the rights that are available against the State's action only are violated by the private
individuals, there are no constitutional remedies but only ordinary legal remedies.
Some of Fundamental Rights are negative in character as they place limitations on the authority
of the State, while others are positive as they confer certain privileges on the persons.
They are justiciable, allowing persons to move the Courts for their enforcement on the violation.
They are not permanent and so the Parliament can curtail or repeal them but only by a
constitutional amendment act without affecting the 'basic structure' of the Constitution.
They can be suspended during the operation of a National Emergency except the rights
guaranteed by Articles 20 and 21.
The six rights guaranteed by Article 19 can be suspended only when the emergency is declared
on the grounds of war or external aggression (i.e. external emergency) and not on the ground of
armed rebellion (i.e. internal emergency).
Their scope of operation is limited by Article 31A (saving of laws providing for the acquisition of
estates, etc.), Article 318 (validation of certain acts and regulations included in the 9 th schedule)
and Article 31C (saving of laws giving effect to certain directive principles).
Their application to the members of armed forces, para-military forces, police forces, intelligence
agencies, and analogous services can be restricted or abrogated by the Parliament -Article 33.
Their application can be restricted while martial law is in force in any area - Article 34.
Most of them are directly enforceable (self-executory) while a few of them can be enforced on
the basis of a law made for giving effect to them.
Such a law can be made only by the Parliament and not by State legislatures so that uniformity
throughout the country is maintained.
4.9 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
4.5 4.6
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-4 Fundamental Rights Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-4 Fundamental Rights
5.1 Introduction
The right to equality is embodied in a series of articles from Article 14 to 18 of the Constitution of
India.
Article 14 contains the principle of rule of law and Articles 15, 16, 17 and 18 contain the
application of this principle.
The Preamble to the Constitution of India provides for equality of status and opportunity.
Contents This Article also means that individuals, whether citizens of India or otherwise shall be treated
differently if the circumstances are different.
5.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 5.2 There are two expressions used in Article 14
5.2 Article 14 - Equality Before The Law ................................................................................................ 5.2 equality before the law. and
5.3 Article 15 - Social Equality and Equal Access to Public Areas ...................................................... 5.3 equal protection of the laws.
5.4 Article 16 - Equality In Matters of Public Employment .................................................................. 5.4 Botlr these expressions sound similar but have different connotations.
5.5 Article 17 - Abolition of Untouchability ............................................................................................ 5.5 The expression 'equality before the law' has its origin in the English Common Law.
5.6 Article 18 - Abolition of Titles ........................................................................................................... 5.5 It means that amongst equals law shall be equal and shall be equally administered.
5.7 References ......................................................................................................................................... 5.5 The expression equal protection of laws has its source in the U.S. Constitution.
Equality before the law is a negative concept and equal protection of the laws is a positive
concept.
The doctrine of equality before the raw is equally operative against the legislature itself.
If the legislature dares to enact an enactment inconsistent with any provisions of Fundamental
Rights, the courts are competent enough to pronounce it unconstitutional.
Equal protection of the laws means the right to equal treatment in similar circumstances, both in
privileges conferred and liabilities imposed.
Both the rule of procedure a,d the substantive raw come under the purview of Article 14.
Equal protection requires affirmative action by the State towards unequal by providing them
facilities and opportunities.
Article 14 applies to any person including any company, association, citizen, non-citizens, natural
persons as well as legal persons.
The rule does not prevent certain classes of persons from being subject to. special rules.
It provides that the president of the Governors or the Rajpramukhs shall not be answerable to any
court for the exercise and performance of the powers and duties of the office.
In Menaka Gandhi's case, the court had opined that Article 14 was not to be equated with the Also, there a law may be passed that requires that the holder of an office of any religious
principle of classification. It was primarily a guarantee against arbitrariness in State action and institution shall also be a person professing that particular religion. According to the Citizenship
the doctrine of classification was evolved only as a subsidiary rule for testing or determining (Amendment) Bill, 2003, this right shall not be conferred to overseas citizens of India.
whether a particular State action was arbitrary or not. In the landmark case of Indra Sawhney v Union of India also known as the Mandal Commission
Case, the Supreme Court dealt with various aspects of the complex issue of reservation and gave
5.3 Article 15 - Social Equality and Equal Access to Public Areas out a very thoughtful judgment. Some of the key aspects of the judgment are
A creamy layer must be excluded from Backward Classes.
Article 15 of the constitution states that no person shall be discriminated on the basis of religion,
race, caste, sex or place of birth. Article 16(4) is not an exception to Article 16(1), but an independent clause. Article 16(a)
is exhaustive of the subject of reservation in favor of backward classes, though it may not
Every person shall have equal access to public places like public parks, museums, wells, bathing
be exhaustive of the very concept of reservation. Reservation for other classes can is
ghats, etc.
made under article 16(1).
However, the state may make any special provision for women and children.
Reservation shall not exceed the S0o/o limit. Carry forward rule is valid provided it should
As per Article 15(4), special provisions may be made for the advancements of any socially or not result in the breach of the 50 %o rule.
educationally backward crass or Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes.
Reservation in appointments under Article 16(4) confined to initial appointments only.
For the purpose of Article 15 (4), backwardness must be both social and educational and caste There shall be no reservation in promotion.
cannot be made the sole or dominant test for determining the backwardness of a class of
Backward classes referred to in Article 16(a) shall not be the same as the Socially and
citizens.
Educationally Backward Classes referred to under Article 15(5).
It was held that order under Article 15(4) need not be in the form of legislation, it can also be in
Article 16(4) permits the classification of Backward classes into backward and more
the form of an executive order.
backward classes.
Speaking generally and in a broad way, a special provision should be less than 50yo- The actual
percentage must depend upon the relevant prevailing circumstances in each case.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
5.3 5.4
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-5 Right to Equality Artical-14 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-5 Right to Equality Artical-14
In the aftermath of the Mandal commission Judgment, clause (4A) was added in Article 16 by
way of the Seventy Seventh Amendment Act, 1995 providing for reservation in the matters of
promotion.
It can be termed as one of the earliest efforts made in the direction of social reforms.
since the Article contemplates the practice of untouchability to be a punishable offense, the
legislature enacted the protection of the Civil Liberties Act, 1955 previously known as the
Untouchability (Offenses) Act, 1955 to prescribe punishment for untouchability and other
practices connected with it.
The word untouchability has not been defined either under Article 17 or the Protection of Civil
Liberties Act, 1955.
The term has not been used in the Article in a literal or grammatical sense.
it actually refers to the social disabilities historically imposed on certain classes of people by Contents
reason of their birth in certain castes and would not include instigation of a social boycott by
reason of the conduct of certain persons. 6.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 6.2
The record 'Harijan' prime facie refers to an untouchable. 6.2 Article 19- Right to Freedom ............................................................................................................. 6.2
Untouchability is an integral part of the case system and is not based on men's rea. Men's rea 6.3 Article 22 - Protection Against Arrest and Detention in Certain Cases ......................................... 6.4
means guilty, mind.
6.4 References ......................................................................................................................................... 6.4
The British government had created an aristocratic class known as Rai Bahadurs and Khan
Bahadurs in India * these titles were also abolished.
However, Military and academic distinctions can be conferred on the citizens of India.
The awards of 'Bharat Ratna' and 'Padma Vibhushan, cannot be used by the recipient as a title
and do not, accordingly, come within the constitutional prohibition.
The Supreme Court, on 15 December 1995, upheld the validity of such awards.
5.7 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
However, the government can impose restrictions on this right only in the interest of the general
The constitution of India contains the right to freedom, given in Articles 19,20,21A, and 22.
public.
Originally, Article 19 contained seven rights. But, the right to acquire, hold and dispose of the
property was deleted by the 44th Amendment Act of 1978.
Freedom to reside and settle
These six rights are protected against only state action and not private individuals. Moreover,
these rights are available only to the citizens and to shareholders of a company but not to citizens of India have the freedom to reside anywhere in the country.
foreigners or legal persons like companies or corporations, etc.
However, in the interest of the general public or for the protection of the scheduled tribes the
The State can impose ‘reasonable’ restrictions on the enjoyment of these six rights only on the State may impose certain restrictions.
grounds mentioned in Article 19 itself and not on any other grounds.
Freedom to practice any profession or to carry on any business occupation or trade
The rights to freedom are the most important fundamental rights guaranteed by the constitution
Every person can carry any business or practice any profession provided it is not dangerous or
of India. It makes democracy meaningful.
immoral.
Also, professional or technical qualifications must be acquired before practicing any profession
6.2 Article 19- Right to Freedom or carrying on any trade.
As per Article 19, the following six freedoms are guaranteed to every person of the country : Restriction on Right to Freedom
1. Right to freedom of speech and expression. It is logical that equal rights for ail must mean limited rights for any. Hence, the State may
2. Right to assemble peaceably and without arms, impose .reasonable restrictions, upon the exercise of any of these rights.
3. Right to form associations or unions, The freedom to assemble is subject to two restrictions. The assembly must be peaceable and
the members of assembly must not bear arms. However, the Sikhs are allowed to carry 'Kirpan'
4. Right to move freely throughout the territory of India,
as part of their religious creed.
5. Right to reside and settle in any part of the territory of India,
In the U.S.A. right to, bear arms is a fundamental right. In India, this right is denied in the interest
6. The right to practice any profession or to carry on any occupation trade or business. of public order.
Freedom of speech and expression The right to form associations or unions does not entitle persons to enter into criminal
Every citizen has the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. It includes the right to hold conspiracy either against individuals, groups or against the. state.
public meetings, demonstrations and take out processions. This freedom can be exercised only The right to move freely or to reside and settle in any part of India does not cover trespass into
on public land and the assembly must be peaceful and unarmed. This provision does not protect homes or restricted areas. State also may restrict this freedom to protect the aboriginal tribes.
violent, disorderly, riotous assemblies, or one that causes a breach of public peace or one that
The right to practice any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business is also
involves arms. This right does not include the right to strike. Every person has freedom of speech
subject to reasonable restrictions. Thus, professions or, trade or, the business must not be
and expression.
harmful to the interest of the community. The State may also prescribe qualifications for a
However, the State can inflict a restriction on this freedom in the interests of the sovereignty and particular profession or, technical occupation. The State may itself carry on trade or business to
integrity of the country, for the security of the state, friendly relations with foreign countries, the exclusion of citizens.
public order, in relation to the contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offense.
Power of Courts to enforce freedom of citizens of India
Freedom to assemble
Every Indian citizen has the power to move the High Court or the Supreme Court for protecting
All citizens have the right to form associations or unions or co-operative societies10b. It includes and securing his personal freedom.
the right to form political parties, companies, partnership firms, societies, clubs, organizations,
The Courts are empowered to issue writs in the nature of Habeas Corpus.
trade unions or any body of persons.
The Courts can order the presence of a detained or imprisoned person and set him free in case
It not only includes the right to start an association or union but also to continue with the
there is no legal justification for his detainment or imprisonment.
association or union as such. Further, it covers the negative right of not to form or join an
association or union. Freedom to form associations or unions or co-operative societies The State Rights to Freedom during National Emergency
can enforce restrictions on such freedom in the interest of public order, morality and the The rights to freedom under Article 19 of the Indian Constitution have suspended during the
sovereignty and integrity of the country. period of the National Emergency declared by the President of India.
Freedom to move, freely
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
6.2 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-6 Right to Certain Freedom Under Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-6 Right to Certain Freedom Under 6.3
Article 19 Article 19
Further, during the period when the National Emergency is in operation, the President is
empowered to suspend the right of citizens to move the Supreme Court for the enforcement of
their personal freedom.
Right to Information (RTI)
Article 19(1) of the Constitution has given the fundamental status to the right to information in
2005.
Under this Article, every citizen has freedom of speech and expression.
Also, he or she has the right to know how the government works, what roles does it play and what
are its functions.
6.4 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
The right to life is undoubtedly the most fundamental of all rights. 7.3 References
'Life' as mentioned under Article 21 signifies not merely living or the physical act of breathing. It M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
has a much more profound meaning that signifies the : Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Right to live with human dignity; Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Right to livelihood;
Right to health;
Right to pollution-free air; and
Right to live a quality life.
Right to go abroad;
Right to privacy;
Right against solitary confinement:
Right against delayed execution;
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
7.2 7.3
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-7 Liberty under Article 21 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-7 Liberty under Article 21
8.1 Introduction
Part IV of the Indian constitution deals with Fundamental Duties.
Originally, the Constitution of India did not contain these duties. Fundamental Duties revere
added by 42nd and 86th Constitutional Amendment Acts.
Fundamental Duties are applicable only to citizens and not to the aliens.
India has borrowed the concept of Fundamental Duties from the USSR.
Citizens are morally obligated by the Constitution to perform these duties. However, like the
Directive Principles, these are unjustifiable, without any legal sanction in case of their violation or
non-compliance.
1. to abide by the Constitution and respect its ideals and institutions, the National Flag and the
8.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 8.2 National Anthem;
8.2 Article 51A - Fundamental Duties .................................................................................................... 8.2 2. to cherish and follow the noble ideals which inspired our national struggle for freedom;
8.3 Legal Status of Fundamental Duties................................................................................................ 8.2 3. to uphold and protect the sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India;
8.4 References ......................................................................................................................................... 8.3 4. to defend the country and render national service when called upon to do so;
5. to promote harmony and the spirit of common brotherhood amongst all the people of India
transcending religious, linguistic and regional or sectional diversities; to renounce practices
derogatory to the dignity of women;
6. to value and preserve the rich heritage of our composite culture;
7. to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers, and wildlife, and to
have compassion for living creatures;
8. to develop the scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform;
10. to strive towards excellence in all spheres of individual and collective activity so that the nation
constantly rises to higher levels of endeavor and achievement.
11. to provide opportunities for education by the parent the guardian, to his child, or a ward between
the age of 6-14 years as the case may be.
It is said that by their nature, it is not practicable to enforce the Fundamental Duties and they
must be left to the will and aspiration of the citizens.
However, in the case of citizens holding public office, each and all Fundamental Duties can be
enforced by suitable legislation and departmental rules of conduct.
Appropriate sanctions can be provided for the lapse in respect of each Fundamental Duty and it
is quite practicable to enforce the sanction against every citizen holding a public office: for
instance, departmental promotions can be deferred, increments can be withheld, etc.
If an officer takes part in a strike or stalls the proceedings of his institution, he can be made to
forgo the salary for that day.
For the proper enforcement of duties, it is necessary that it should be known to all.
This should be done by a systematic and intensive education of people that is by publicity or by
making it a part of education.
In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, the Supreme Court has held that under Article 5l-A (g), it is the
duty of the Central Government to introduce compulsory teaching of lessons at least for one hour
in a week on protection and improvement of the natural environment in all the educational Contents
institution of the country.
9.1 Meaning of Directive Principles of State Policy .............................................................................. 9.2
In AIIMS Students Union vs. AIIMS, the Supreme Court said that Fundamental Duties are equally
9.2 Features of Directive Principles of State Policy .............................................................................. 9.2
important like Fundamental Rights.
9.3 implementation of the Directive Principles of State Policy ............................................................ 9.3
The legal utility of Fundamental Duties is similar to that of the Directives; while the Directives are
addressed to the state, so are the duties addressed to the citizens, without any legal sanction for 9.4 References ......................................................................................................................................... 9.4
their violation.
The citizen should keep in mind that he owes the duties specified in Article 51-A to the State and
if he does not care for the duties, he does not deserve the rights. of course, the duties as such are
not legally enforceable in the Courts of law, but if a law has been made to prohibit any act or
conduct in violation of the duties, it would be a reasonable restriction on the relevant
Fundamental Rights.
However, the Fundamental Duties are not enforceable by mandamus or any other legal remedy.
Since the Fundamental Duties are not addressed to the State, a citizen cannot claim that he must
be properly equipped by the State so that he may perform his duties under Article 51-A.
8.4 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Prevent the concentration of wealth in specific pockets through uniform distribution of the
Part IV, Articles 36-51 of the Indian Constitution constitutes the Directive Principles of State
material resources amongst all the strata of the society.
Policy.
Prevention of child abuse and exploitation of workers.
It contains the broad directives or guidelines to be followed by the State while establishing
policies and laws. Protection of children against moral and material abandonment.
The legislative and executive powers of the State are to be exercised under the purview of the Free legal advice for equal opportunities to avail of justice by the economically weaker section.
Directive Principles of the Indian Constitution.
Organization of Village Panchayats which will work as an autonomous body working towards
The Indian Constitution was written immediately after India obtained freedom, and the giving justice.
contributors to the Constitution were well aware of the ruined state of the Indian economy as well
Assistance to the needy including the unemployed, sick, disabled and old people.
as the fragile state of the nation's unity.
Ensure proper working conditions and a living wage.
Hence, they created a set of guidelines under the heading Directive Principles for the inclusive
development of society. Promotion of cottage industries in rural areas.
Inspired by the Constitution of Ireland,. the Directive Principles contain the very basic philosophy The State should endeavor towards a uniform civil code for all the citizens of India.
of the Constitution of India, and that is the overall development of the nation through guidelines Free and compulsory education for children below the age of 14years.
related to social justice, economic welfare, foreign policy, and legal and administrative matters. Economic and educational upliftment of the Scheduled Cast and Scheduled Tribe and other
However, the Directive Principles cannot be enforced in a court of law and the State cannot be weaker sections of the society.
sued for non-compliance of the same. Prohibition of alcoholic drinks, recreational drugs, and cow slaughter.
The Directive Principles are divided into the following three categories: Preservation of the environment by safeguarding the forests and wild life.
Socialistic Directives Protection of monuments, places, and objects of historic and artistic interest and national
This part contains the directives for securing the welfare of the people of India, equal distribution importance against destruction and damage.
of the material resources of the country protection of the fundamental rights of the children and Promotion and maintenance of international peace and security. just and honorable relations
youth, equal pay for equal work, education, etc. between nations, respect for international law and treaty obligations, as well as a settlement of
Gandhian Directives international disputes by arbitration.
These directives are the guidelines for organizing village Panchayat, the prohibition of
intoxicating drinks and cow-slaughter, a secure living wage, decent standard of life, and to 9.3 implementation of the Directive Principles of State Policy
promote cottage industries, to provide free and compulsory education to all children up to 14 As mentioned earlier, unlike the Fundamental Rights which are guaranteed by the constitution of
years of age, etc.
India, the Directive principles do not have a legal sanction and cannot be enforced in a court of
Liberal Intellectual Directives law.
In this section, there are guidelines for uniform civil code throughout the country and the However, the State is making every effort to implement the Directive Principles in as many
legislatures to follow in issuing orders or making laws. sectors as possible.
The noteworthy implementation is the g6th constitutional Amendment of 2002 which inserted a
9.2 Features of Directive Principles of State Policy new article, Article 21-A, making free education for children below the age of 14 compulsory.
In a nutshell, the Directive Principles consist of the following guidelines for the States : For example, the Taxation Inquiry Commission, 1953-1954 was asked to examine the tax
structure and to suggest measures to reduce the inequalities of income and wealth and some
The State should strive to promote the welfare of the people.
other related subjects.
Maintain social order through social, economic and political justice.
The Industrial Development and Regulation Act, 1954 and the establishment of the Monopolies
The State should strive towards removing economic inequality. Inquiry commission in 1965 were aimed to achieve the objective outlined by the Taxation Inquiry
Commission.
Removal of inequality in status and opportunities.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
9.2 9.3
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-9 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-9
The Monopolies commission made probing inquiries into the causes and extent of concentration
of economic power in private hands, the factors responsible for monopolies tendencies in the
national economy and their social consequences.
Similarly, in the early years of the 1950s Land Reform Legislation was enacted to abolish
intermediaries and zamindari system and now land, both rural and urban, are subject to ceilings
and the surplus land has gone to the weaker sections of the community.
In compliance with such laws, many States has enacted separate State Act to prevent the
concentration of landholdings and fixed a ceiling for an individual owner.
A large number of laws have been enacted to implement the organization of village panchayat as
a unit of self-government.
For raising the standard of living (Article 47) the Government of India adopted the first-ever large-
scale program called Community Development Project in 1952 for rural reconstruction in the field
of communication, transport, housing facilities, sanitation, agriculture, education, etc.
RRegarding the prohibition of intoxicating drinks and drugs (Article 47), most of the States have
enacted legislation and imposes some restrictions on it.
Necessary legislation has been enacted to protect places and monuments of national
importance.
As to the separation of the executive from the judiciary (Article 50), ,most of the States have
Contents
taken legislative measures. Steps have been taken to assist and give free legal aid to needy
village people. 10.1 Federal System ................................................................................................................................ 10.2
Lastly, the Government of India has enacted the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act 10.2 Features of Federal Government ................................................................................................... 10.2
(NREGA) to ensure ha undred days of work assistance to rural people which is in conformity to
10.3 Legislative Relaiions - Articles 245 - 255 ....................................................................................... 10.3
the Right to work enshrined in the Directive Principles of State Policy of the Indian Constitution.
10.4 Administrative Relations ................................................................................................................. 10.3
9.4 References 10.5 Cooperation Between the Centre and the States .......................................................................... 10.4
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication. 10.6 Gentre-State Relations during Emergency..................................................................................... 10.4
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
10.2 10.3
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-10 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-10
Article 256 states that the executive power of every State shall be so exercised as to ensure
compliance with the laws made, by the parliament and any existing laws which apply in that
State, and the executive power of the Union shall extend to the giving of such directions to a
State as may appear to the Government of India to be necessary for that purpose.
10.7 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
In a parliamentary system, an executive is a part of the legislature. Which implements the To be eligible for membership in the Lok Sabha, a person must be a citizen of India and
law and plays an active role in framing it as well. must be 25 years of age or older, mentally sound, should not be bankrupt, and should not
be criminally convicted.
In a parliamentary system, the head of the state may be a monarch or a president, but both
of these positions are ceremonial.
11.4 Rajya Sabha
The head of the Government, who is generally called as the Prime Minister, is the real head.
Thus, all the real executive powers are vested in the Prime Minister. Rajya Sabha (Council of States) or the Upper House is a permanent body not subject to
dissolution.
11.2 Parliamentary Form of Government or Parliamentary System One-third of the members retire every second year and are replaced by newly elected
members.
Tlie Parliament of India is the supreme legislative body of the Republic of India. It is a
bicameral legislature composed of the President of India and the two Houses: Each member is elected for a term of six years.
The Rajya Sabha (Council of States); and Its members are indirectly elected by members of the legislative bodies of the States.
The Lok Sabha (House of the People). The Rajya Sabha can have a maximum of 250 members.
The President in his role as head of a legislature has full powers to summon and prorogue It currently has a sanctioned strength of 245 members, of which 233 are elected from
either House of Parliament or to dissolve Lok Sabha. States and Union Territories and 12 are 'nominated by the President.
The President can exercise these powers only upon the advice of the Prime Minister and The number of members from a state depends on its population.
his Union Council of Ministers. The minimum age for a person to become a member of Rajya Sabha is 30 years.
Those elected or nominated (by the President) to either House Parliament are referred to
as Members of Parliament (MP). 11.5 Elements and Features of the Parliamentary System
The Members of Parliament, Lok Sabha have directly elected the Indian public voting in
Following are the elements and features of the Parliamentary System:
Single-member districts and the Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha are elected by the
members of all state Legislative Assembly by proportional representation. Nominal and Real Head
The Parliament has a sanctioned strength of 545 members in Lok Sabha including the 2 The head of the state holds a ceremonial position and is the nominal executive. For
nominees from the Anglo-Indian community by the President, and 245 members in Rajya example, the President.
Sabha including the 12 nominees from the expertise of different fields of science.,culter, Ln India, the head of Government is the Prime Minister who is the real executive.
art, and history.
Article 75 of the Indian constitution provides for a Prime Minister to be appointed by the
India has a parliamentary system of Government. President.
Article 74 and Article 75 deal with the parliamentary system the Centre and Articles 163 According to Article 74, the prime minister headed the council of ministers would aid and
and 164 deals with the States. advise the president in the exercise of his functions.
The Parliament meets at Sansad Bhavan in New Delhi. The executive is a Part of Legislature
The Executive forms apart of the legislature. In India, the person should be a member of
11.3 Lok Sabha parliament to become a member of the executive. However, the constitution provides that
a person can be appointed as a minister for a period of not more than six consecutive
Lok Sabha (House of the People) or the Lower House has 545 members.
months if he is not a member of the parliament, after which the person ceases to be a
543 members are directly elected by citizens of India on the basis of universal adult minister.
franchise representing parliamentary constituencies across the country and 2 members
Majority Party Rule
are appointed by the president of India from the Anglo-Indian Community.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
11.2 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-11 Parliamentary Form of Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-11 Parliamentary Form of 11.3
India India
The party which wins majority seats in the elections of the Lower House forms the He has to act on ministerial advice and therefore the prime Minister and the council of
Government. Ministers constitute the rear and effective executive.
In India, the President invites the leader of the majority party in Lok Sabha to form the The office of the president is created by article 52 of the constitution and the matters of
Government. erection are depart from Article 54 to 60 of the Constitution.
The President appoints the leader as the Prime Minister and the other ministers are The President is elected by the method of indirect erection i.e. by an electoral college
appointed by the president on the advice of the Prime Minister. consisting of elected members of both Houses of Parliament and of the State legislative
assemblies.
The President may invite a coalition of parties to form the government, in case, no party
has got a majority. .The method of indirect election was emphasized the ministerial character of the executive
that the effective power resides in the Ministry and not in the President as such.
Collective Responsibility
secondly, the method of the direct election would have been very costly and energy-
The council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Parliament.
consuming.
The Lower House of parliament has the ability to dismiss a government by getting the no-
There was also the fear that a directly elected president may in course of time assume all
confidence motion passed in the House.
the power.
In India, the government survives until the time it enjoys the support of the majority of
The President derives its power from Article 53 which vests in him all the executive
members in the Lok Sabha.
authority including the Supreme Command of the Armed Forces.
Thus, Lok sabha is empowered to introduce no-confidence motion against the
There are several other provisions in the constitution that mention specific functions of the
Government.
President.
Prime Minister as the Centre of Power
Briefly, the President has the power to appoint all important offices including those of the
In India, the Prime Minister is the real executive. Prime Minister and other central Ministers, Governors, Judges of the Supreme Court and
He is the head of the government, the council of ministers and the ruling government. the High Courts and even Election commissioners. He even has the authority to appoint
commissions with respect to the administration of scheduled areas.
Thus, he has to play a significant and important role in the working of the Government.
Most importantly, the President is vested with wide powers during Emergency under Article
352 to 360 of the Constitution including the suspension of Fundamental Rights.
11.6 President of India
Moreover, every bill comes to him for his assent and can either refuse to give his assent or
The office of the President is very august and the Constitution attaches to it many send it back for reconsideration. Powers of the President can be classified as:
privileges and immunities.
Executive functions
The President along with the council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister comprises
Legislative functions
the central executive which has been dealt from Article 52 to 78 of the Constitution.
Judicial functions
The President is the head of the State and the former executive.
Porver to issue directions to state in certain circumstances. Moreover, in certain aspects, the President's recommendation is required before the Bill is
introduced before the two houses of Parliament.
Besides the above, the executive power of the union is also vested in the union in
accordance with Article 53. This executive power may be exercised either directly or Bill relating to the alteration or states of formation of new states. (Article 3)
through officers, subordinate to him in accordance with the Constitution. A Money Bill cannot be introduced without the recommendation of the President (Article
However, a dispute exists with regards to this power due to the absence of a definition of 117(1).
the term 'executive power' in the Constitution Bill involving expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India.
The executive cannot act against a statute or exceed its statutory powers. if there exists a Any bill affecting any tax in which the states are interested.
law on that particular matter the executive is bound to act in accordance with it.
Ordinance making power
The more controversial and debatable legislative power of the President has always been
11.8 Judicial Powers of President
the Ordinance Making Power.
The central executive is empowered to appoint judges of the Supreme court and the High
Usually, the power to make the laws rests with the Parliament.
court under Article 124(2) and 217(1) respectively.
However, Article 123 confers special power on the President empowering him to
Another important judicial power vested with the President is the power to pardon under
promulgate ordinances when the Parliament is not in session and the circumstances are
Article 72 lays down the cases when the President has the power to suspend remit or
such which require immediate action.
commute sentences
An ordinance cannot be promulgated when both the houses of parliament are in session.
ln all cases where the punishment or sentence is by a Court Martial.
However, it may be passed when only one House is in session the reason being that a law
Ln all cases where the punishment or sentence is for an offense against any law relating to cannot be passed by only one House and thus it cannot meet a situation calling for
a matter to which the executive power of the Union extends. immediate legislation. This power granted to the President in the Indian Constitution is
unique and no such power has been conferred upon the executive in Britain or the USA.
In all cases where the sentence is a sentence of death.
In justification of the inception of the Ordinance Making power in the Constitution, Dr.
However, pardon should not be regarded as a matter of right' It is an act of grace. A pardon
Ambedkar said that there might be a situation of emergency when the Houses of the
not only removes the punishment but also places the offender in the same position as if he
Parliament is not in session. It is important that this situation should be dealt with and it
had never committed the offense. The effect of the pardon is ts clear the person from all
seems to me that the only solution is to confer upon the President the power to
infamy and from all consequences of the offenses for which it is granted and from all
promulgate the law which will enable the executive to deal with that particular situation
statutory or other disqualifications upon conviction.
because it cannot resort to the ordinary process of law because the legislature is not in
The scope of the power of the President under Article 72 to commute a death sentence session.
into a lesser sentence has been left open by the Court after observing that whether a case
Article 123 empowers the President to promulgate ordinance as the circumstances which
is appropriate to be sent for the consideration of Presidential Pardon depends on the facts
appear to require when: Both Houses of the Parliament are not in session.
and the circumstance of each particular case.
Therefore, this power of the president can be subjected to judicial review if the Court
discovers mala fide intention or political vengeance.
11.10 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
11.6 Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-11 Parliamentary Form of Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-11 Parliamentary Form of 11.7
India India
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication
Contents
Amendment by 2/3rd majority of the Parliament plus ratification by at least half of the several
State Legislatures (Second Method) 12.5 Additional Amendment-making the Two Houses of Parliament
There are several amendments that result in some changes in the constitution but can be passed
12.3 Amendment by 2/3rd Majority of Parliament- First Method in the houses by simple majorities. Such bills are not considered to be constitution Amendment
Bills for the purpose of Article 368. These include the following:
Most parts of the Constitution (with exception of some specific provisions) can be amended by
An admission or formation of new States and alteration of areas, boundaries or names of
this method.
existing States.
Under this method, the constitution can be amended by. the union Parliament alone.
Citizenship provision.
For this purpose' an amendment bill can be passed by each of the two Houses of Union
Provision regarding delimitation of constituencies.
parliament by a majority of its total membership (i.e. the absolute majority) and by a two_third
majority of members present and voting in each House. A quorum of the two Houses of Parliament.
It is a rigid method in so far as it prescribes a special majority for amending the constitution but it Privileges and Salaries and allowances of the Members of Parliament.
is considered to be a flexible method because under it the union parliament alone can pass any
Rules of procedure in each House of the parliament.
amendment
English as a language of the Parliament.
12.4 Amendment by 2/3rd Majority Ratification by at least half Legislatures - Appointment of Judges and jurisdiction of the Supreme Court.
Second Method Creation or abolition of Upper Houses in any State.
In respect of some specified provisions of the Constitution, a very rigid method of the Legislatures for Union Territories.
amendment has been prescribed. Elections in the country.
In respect of these the amendment-making involves two stages: The official language of India.
First, the amendment bill is to be passed by both the Houses of the Union parliament by a Second, fifth and Sixth Schedules of the Constitution.
majority of total membership and a 2/3rd majority of members present and voting in each House.
These methods of amendment reflect a mixture of rigidity and flexibility in the Indian
Constitution.
Most provisions can be amended by the Union Parliament by passing an amending act by a
majority of the total membership, and a2/3rd majority of members present and voting in each
House.
Ten provisions of the constitution can be amended, Bypassing of the amendment bill by 2/3rd
majority of the members of each of the two Houses of Parliament, It becomes finally passed
when approved by at least half of the State Legislatures.
Some provisions can be amended by the Parliament by making law by a simple majority of its
two Houses.
Signature of the President is required as the final act which transforms a duly enacted
Contents
amendment bill into an Amendment Act.
State Legislatures have been denied the power to initiate amendments. 10.1 Main Amendments in Constitution ................................................................................................ 13.2
All amendments are subject to the Judicial Review power of the courts. (The Supreme Courts and
State High Courts only) Any part of any amendment or any amendment as a whole can be
declared invalid by the Court in case it is [Link] be unconstitutional.
The Parliament has the power to amend every part of the Constitution. However, the Supreme
Court has ruled that the Parliament has no power to change the 'Basic Structure of the
Constitution.
12.7 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
So, as an advancing and subsisting document, numerous amendments have been made to it till
Introduction of Nagarpalika and Municipality (74th Amendment 1992)
2019.
During the early 90s local bodies in states had become ineffective in holding regular elections or
Amendments to the Constitution require a special majority of 'two-third, members present and
the maintenance of public infrastructure, electricity and water supply.
voting to be passed in Parliament.
Thus, an immediate need to introduce effective authorities to execute the numerous plans and
We would like to discuss a few important amendments hereinafter
programs was felt by the government.
Abolition of states according to classes and the introduction of Union Territories and
Granted constitutional status and protection to the urban local bodies. For this purpose, the
reorganization of states by language (7th Amendment Act,1956)
Amendment has added a new Part IX-A entitled as ‘the municipalities’ and a new Twelfth
Abolished the existing classification of states into four categories i.e., Part A, Part B, Part C and Schedule containing 18 functional items of the municipalities
Part D states, and reorganized them into 14 states and 6 union territories. Free and compulsory education to children between 6 to 14 years (86th Amendment 2002)
Extended the jurisdiction of high courts to union territories. one of the most important amendments, the government directed the private school to take 25%
Provided for the establishment of a common high court for two or more states. of their class strength from economically.
The mini-constitution inserted socialism and Secularism in the preamble, a provision on weaker or disadvantaged groups of society through a random selection process with the help of
fundamental (42nd Amendment 1976) the government funding'
Secularism and socialism were inserted to restore the faith of the nation that minorities would be this initiative was taken to try and provide elementary education to all.
safe and not be exploited by the rich. Moreover, the local and state governments were made to ensure its proper implementation.
Also, the rich would not be allowed to dominate, the country's economy.
The main reason to add socialism was to promote social as well as economic equality in the 13.2 References
country.
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Similarly, the main reason to add secularism was to imply that there was no official state religion
Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
of the country.
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Right to Property deleted from the list of Fundamental Rights (44nd Amendment 1978)
The Fundamental Right to properly in India was removed to permit the reorganization of land and
to facilitate land acquisition for developmental projects.
This was carried out by the Indian Government at that time since it was not affluent enough to
pay people whatever they demanded their land.
Voting age reduced from 21 to 18 (61th Amendment 1989)
Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi explained it as an expression the government's full faith in the youth
of the country
The youth are aware and informed and thus, lowering the voting age would provide an
opportunity for the unrepresented youth of the nation to vent out their feelings and motivate them
to become a part of the political process eventually.
Introduction of Panchayati raj (73th Amendment 1992)
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
13.2 13.3
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-13 History of Amendment Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-13 History of Amendment
14.1 Introduction
The emergency provisions are contained in part XVIII of the constitution, from Articles 352 to
360.
National Emergency is mentioned in Article 352 and presidents rule is mentioned in Article 356 of
the Indian Constitution.
During an Emergency, the Central Government becomes all-powerful and the states go into the
total control of the Centre.
It converts the federal structure into a unitary one without a formal amendment of the
Constitution.
14.4 Parliamentry Approval and Duration .............................................................................................. 14.3 An Emergency due to the failure of the constitutional machinery in the States (Article 356).
14.5 President Rule (Failure of Constitutional Machinery in State) - Article 356 ................................ 14.3 This is popularly known as 'President's Rule'. It is also known by two other names- 'State
Emergency' or 'Constitutional Emergency.
14.6 Parliamentry Approval and Duration .............................................................................................. 14.4
However, the Constitution does not use the word 'emergency' for this situation.
14.7 Financial Emergency - Article 360 .................................................................................................. 14.5
Financial Emergency
14.8 Parliamentary Approval and Duration ............................................................................................ 14.5
Financial Emergency due to a threat to financial stability or
14.9 References ....................................................................................................................................... 14.5
the credit of India (Article 360).
National Emergency is imposed whereby there is a grave threat to the security of India or any of
its territories due to war, external aggression or armed rebellion. Such emergency shall be
imposed by the President on the basis of a written request by the council of ministers headed by
the Prime Minister. When they are satisfied that there is an imminent danger thereof.
Every proclamation is required to be laid before each House of Parliament, it will cease to operate
after one month from the date of its issue unless in the meantime it is approved by the
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
14.3 14.4
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-14 Emergency Provisons Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-14 Emergency Provisons
However, if the dissolution of the Lok Sabha takes place during the period of six months without Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
approving the further continuation of the President’s Rule, then the proclamation survives until 30
Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
days from the first sitting of the Lok Sabha after its reconstitution, provided the Rajya Sabha has
in the meantime approved its continuance.
The Union Government may give direction to any of the States regarding financial matters.
The President may ask the states to reduce the salaries and allowances o1'all or any class of
persons in government service.
The President may ask the States to reserve all the money bills for the consideration of the
Parliament after they have been passed by the State Legislature.
The President may also give directions for the reduction of salaries an<l allowances of the
Central Government employees including the Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts.
14.9 References
M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
14.5 14.6
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-14 Emergency Provisons Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-14 Emergency Provisons
15.1 Introduction
We know there is a Government in India at the Center and State levels. But there is another
important system for local governance.
The foundation of the present local self-government in India was laid by the Panchayati Raj
System (1992).
But the history of Panchayati Raj starts from the self-sufficient and self-governing village
communities.
In the time of the Rig-veda (1700 BC), evidence suggests that self-governing village bodies called
'Sabhas' existed. with the passage of time, these bodies became panchayats (council of five
persons).
Panchayats were functional institutions of grassroots governance in almost every village. They
endured the rise and fall of empires in the past, to the current highly structured system.
15.5 Elections Held in the Local Government Bodies ........................................................................... 15.3 satisfy the demands for local autonomy.
They opened up the governance of the lowest levels to the citizens.
15.6 Qualifications Needed to be a Member of the Panchayat or Municipality ................................. 15.4
The Government of India Act, 1935 also authorizes the provinces to enact legislation.
15.7 References ....................................................................................................................................... 15.4
Later, the conceptualization of the system of local self-government in India took place through
the formation and effort of following four important committees from the year 1957 to 1986:
Balwant Rai Mehta Committee (1957)
Ashok M+ta Committee (1977*1978)
G V KRao Committee (1985)
L M Singhvi Committee (1986)
Though the 64ft Constitutional Amendment Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha in 1989 itself,
Rajya Sabha opposed it.
It was only during the Narasimha Rao government's term that the idea finally became a reality in
the form of the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts, 1992.
15.4 Panchayati Raj System under 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts,
1992
The Acts of 1992 added two new Parts IX and IX-A to the Constitution.
Both exist as three-tier ,System at the lower, intermediate and upper levels. Fresh elections should be conducted before the expiry of the five-year term.
rd
The 73 Constitutional Amendment Act provides for a Gram Sabha as the foundation of the If the PanchayavMunicipalitl. is dissolved before the expiry of its term, elections shall be
Panchal at Raj system. conducted within six months and the new Panchayat/Municipality will hold office for the
remainder of the term if the term has more than six months duration.
It is essentially a village assembly consisting of all the registered voters in the area of the
Panchayat.
The State has the power to determine uhat kind of powers it can exercise, and rvhai functions it
15.7 References
has to perform at the village level. M Laxminath “Indian Polity” 4th Edition 2013 Tata McGraw Hill Publication.
The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act provides for three types of MuniciPalities : Durga Das Basu” Introduction to Constitution of India”
Nagar Panchayat for a transitional area between a rural and urban area. Tejpal Sheth” Indian Constitution”1st Edition 2018 Mahajan Publication.
Municipal Council for a small urban area
Municipal Corporation for a large urban area
Municipalities represent urban local self-government'
Most of the provisions of the two acts are parallel, differing only in the fact that they are being
applied to either a Panchayat or a Municipality respectively.
Each Gram Sabha is the meeting of a particular constituency called ward.
Each ward has a representative chosen from among the people themselves by direct election.
The chairperson of the panchayat or Municipality at the intermediate and distinct level are
elected from among these representatives at the immediately lower level by indirect election.
The conduct of elections is vested in the hands of the State Election Commission.
The Chairpersons at the intermediate and district levels shall be elected indirectly from among
the elected representatives at the immediately lower level.
At the lowest level, the Chairperson still be elected in a mode defined by the state legislature.
Seats are reserved for Scheduled Cast and Scheduled Tribe proportional to their population.
Out of these reserved seats, not less than one-third shall be further reserved for women.
There should try a blanket reservation of one-third seats for women in all the constituencies
taken together too (which can include the already reserved seats for SC and ST).
The Acts bar the interference of courts in any issue relating to the election to local bodies.
Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering Prof. Paras [Link] Department of Mechanical Engineering
15.3 15.4
Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-15 Local SeIf Government Indian Constitution (3130007) | Unit-15 Local SeIf Government