Strong Antioxidant Nanofibers via Hydrogen Bonding
Strong Antioxidant Nanofibers via Hydrogen Bonding
Activity
Adwait Gaikwad1, Hanna Hlushko1, Parvin Karimineghlani, Victor Selin, and Svetlana A.
Sukhishvili*
Department of Materials Science & Engineering, Texas A&M University, College Station,
Texas 77843, USA
Abstract
composed of a hydrophilic polymer and a natural polyphenol that exhibit prolonged antioxidant
activity. The high performance of fibrous mats resulted from the formation of a network of
hydrogen bonds between a low-molecular-weight polyphenol (tannic acid, TA) and a water-
soluble polymer (polyvinylpyrrolidone, PVP), and could be precisely controlled by the TA-to-PVP
ratio. Dramatic enhancement (5 to 10-fold) in tensile strength, toughness and Young’s moduli of
the PVP/TA fiber mats (as compared to those of pristine PVP fibers) was achieved at the maximum
density of hydrogen bonds, which occurred at ~0.2-0.4 molar fractions of TA. The formation of
hydrogen bonds was confirmed by an increase in the glass transition temperature of the polymer
after binding with TA. When exposed to water, the fibers exhibited composition- and pH-
dependent stability, with the TA-enriched fibers fully preserving their integrity in acidic and
neutral media. Importantly, the fiber mats exhibited strong antioxidant activity with dual (burst
and prolonged) activity profiles, which could be controlled via fiber composition – a feature useful
1
INTRODUCTION
diameters using polymers, ceramics, or nanocomposite materials,1,2 and arrange them within
fibrous mats. Because of the high specific surface area and the open, porous structure, engineered
electrospun fibrous materials are finding applications in tissue engineering,3 drug delivery,4,5 water
purification,6,7 and energy storage.8,9 For many biomedical and environmental applications, several
properties of the fiber materials should be simultaneously achieved. Specifically, the fibers should
be (a) stable in water at environmental pH values, (b) demonstrate robust mechanical performance,
retaining/releasing small molecules for programmed materials functionality. While attaining one
or two of these properties with electrospun fiber mats was partially successful,10-12 none of the
previously reported materials have simultaneously addressed all three of the above challenges.
agents, or antioxidants has long been an important goal in engineering electrospun fibers. While
inclusion of functional molecules was often achieved by simple blending of small functional
molecules with polymers,13 this approach does not rely on optimized molecular interactions of
small molecules with a polymer matrix, and often results in phase separation, low payloads, and/or
poor control of small molecule functionality.14 On the other hand, in polymer-polymer systems,
polymers have been successfully electrospun into chemically stable robust nanofiber mats.10,11,15,16
Electrostatic assembly cannot be used, however, with neutral, nontoxic and environmentally
benign polymers, such as polyethylene oxide (PEO) or polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP). Yet these
2
polymers can be assembled by means of hydrogen bonding,17 which also enables facile inclusion
resulting from hydrogen bonding was demonstrated to improve both toughness and tensile strength
of polymer materials.19,20
polyphenol – tannic acid (TA) – on thermo-mechanical properties of polymer fibers and leverage
the antioxidant capability of TA. The main challenge was to simultaneously achieve robust
structural stability and high radical-scavenging performance of the fibrous mats in an aqueous
antioxidant properties. 21-23 The hydrogen-donating property of its phenolic groups enables binding
hydrogen bonding between TA and PVP persists until pH ~8.5,18 making this hydrogen-bonding
pair highly suitable for use in common environmental and biomedical conditions. In contrast, the
use of another common partner – polycarboxylic acids – for hydrogen-bonding assembly with PVP
results in materials which dissociate in neutral and basic aqueous environments.17,29-32 This
blending strategy of other natural antioxidants (such as curcumin or fenugreek) within the fibers
to achieve enhanced wound healing,34,13 rather than relying on direct hydrogen bonding. For
TA, i.e. gallic acid, within the biomedical fiber mats required formation of an inclusion complex
3
with cyclodextrin.35 Additionally, Whittaker et al.36 attempted to use hydrogen bonding to
of solution viscosity, the fiber’s morphology was largely dominated by the bead formation, and
antioxidant properties of the beaded fiber mats were not explored.36 In contrast, in our work, the
effect of TA/PVP hydrogen-bonding interactions on fiber morphology and diameters were both
well-controlled to obtain bead-free, uniform nanofibers with maximized specific surface area
desirable for leveraging the functionality of TA. In PVP/TA electrospun fibers, the polymeric
the hydrogen bonding between PVP and TA served to increase the strength and toughness of the
fibers. Importantly, composition of the fibers could be designed to achieve tensile properties
superior to those previously reported for antioxidant-containing fibers,37 and exceeding those
reported for collagen in ambient air.38 At the same time, programming the composition of the fibers
was critical for optimizing the fiber performance against two important parameters, i.e.
preservation of fiber integrity upon exposure to aqueous environment at varied acidity and
EXPERIMENTAL SECTION
Materials
dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) were purchased from Alfa Aesar. Tannic acid (TA) and N, N-
dimethylformamide (DMF) were purchased from Sigma Aldrich. 200 proof ethanol and 2,2'-azino-
VWR. Ultrapure Milli-Q water (DI) (Millipore) with a resistivity of 18.2 MΩ/cm was used in all
4
Fiber Fabrication via Electrospinning
Two separate sets of the fibers were prepared and used for studies of the effect of PVP/TA
total concentration on the fiber diameter, or for investigation of mechanical, antioxidant, and pH-
stability properties of the fiber mats. In the first case, solutions of PVP/TA were prepared in a
75/25 DMF/DMSO (v/v) solvent at an equimolar ratio of PVP and TA hydrogen-bonding units
but varied total concentration (10.5-15 wt.%). For easier dissolution, the solutions were gently
stirred at ambient temperature overnight. For preparation of the second set of fibers, PVP and TA
were dissolved in 75/25 DMF/DMSO (v/v) at 13.5 wt.% total concentration but varied mole
fractions of TA to PVP. In all cases, the solutions were used for electrospinning immediately after
preparation.
with a rotary collector covered with conductive aluminum foil was used to obtain mats of
uniaxially aligned fibers. The high voltage power supply (ES 30-0.1P, Gamma High Voltage
Research) was connected to the tip of the syringe needle (size 21G) and to the collector to complete
the circuit. The flow rate was controlled by a syringe pump (NE-1000, New Era Systems, Inc.)
and kept constant at 0.43 mL/hr. The fibers were spun for 8 hours at an applied voltage of 12 kV.
The fibers were collected on a rotatory collector which was placed at a distance of 35 cm from the
spinneret, at a rotational speed of 1000 rpm. For control fibers, electrospinning was performed
with a 12.5 wt.% solution of PVP at a flow rate of 0.5 mL/hr and 13 kV, when the collector was
placed at a distance of 25 cm from the spinneret. All electrospinning experiments were performed
in ambient conditions (24 oC and 50-60% relative humidity). After deposition, mats of aligned
5
Fiber Characterization
Scanning Electron Microscopy. The fiber mat morphology was studied by scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) using a JSM-7500F (JEOL) instrument equipped with a cold cathode UHV
field emission conical anode gun. The images were taken at an accelerating voltage of 3 kV and a
working distance of 15 mm. The surface of the samples was sputtered with 2 nm Pt/Pd coating to
avoid charging. A systematic investigation of the fiber diameter was carried out by the ImageJ®
software.39 Each average fiber diameter was obtained from more than 100 fiber diameter
Mechanical Analysis. Tensile testing of uniaxially aligned fiber mats was performed with a tensile
tester (Gatan MT10365, Deben UK Ltd.) using the procedure described elsewhere.3,40,41 The
Devcon home) as shown in Scheme 1. The specimen was then fixed by the jaws of the tensile
6
tester, and the middle of the C-shape holder was cut as shown in Scheme 1, to separate the upper
and lower sections of the scaffold. A strain rate of 0.5 mm/min and a gauge length of 15 mm were
Prior to the attachment of the fiber mat to the holder, the fiber mat thickness was
determined using a digital micrometer with a precision of 1 μm. Subsequently, the fiber mat was
placed between two glass coverslips to increase the contact area and reduce the compression of the
fiber mat, and the thickness of the sandwich construct was recorded as shown in Scheme 1. The
thickness of the fiber mat was determined after subtraction of the thickness of the glass coverslips.
While the same amounts of solutions were spun, some mass losses occurred during spinning and
sample collection, resulting in a ~30% variation in thickness of the collected samples. Specifically,
the sample thicknesses varied between 50 and 90 m, with a much smaller variation of the fiber
mat densities of 0.27±0.02 g/cm3. Values of stress, tensile strength, and elastic moduli were
determined in the tensile test experiments for the free-standing fibrous material.
(DSC) studies with the fiber mats were performed using TGA 5500 and Q2500 equipment (TA
Instruments, USA), respectively. All experiments were carried out using 10°C/min heating and
cooling rates. The samples were prepared by placing 10 to 12 mg of fiber mats into a platinum pan
for TGA analysis or into a hermetically sealed aluminum pan for DSC. The glass transition
temperature (Tg) for the fibers was determined as the middle of the transition in the DSC profile
Fiber Stability at Various pH. Stability of the fiber mats in solutions at different pH ranging from
4 to 11 was studied using a combination of visual inspection of the fiber mats, UV-Vis studies of
the supernatant solutions, and SEM studies of the fiber mats. To determine the concentration of
7
TA released in solution, the fiber mats with different PVP-to-TA ratios were cut into small
rectangular pieces with masses of 1.2 to 4 mg, weighed, and placed into vials containing 20 mL of
DI water at pH 6. Periodically, 1-mL aliquots of the supernatant solutions were collected, diluted
with 2 mL of DI water, and measured using a UV 2600 spectrophotometer (Shimadzu Inc.). The
absorbances were measured for a characteristic TA absorption band at 260 nm using DI water as
a reference and converted to the amounts of TA released to solution. The extinction coefficient of
TA solutions was determined from a calibration curve obtained in a separate experiment using TA
solutions of known concentrations. The percent of released TA was calculated using the following
equation:
3𝐴 1701
% 𝑇𝐴 𝑟𝑒𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑠𝑒𝑑 = × × 100
𝜀𝑙 𝑚(𝑓𝑖𝑏𝑒𝑟 𝑚𝑎𝑡) × 𝜔(𝑇𝐴 𝑖𝑛 𝑓𝑖𝑏𝑒𝑟 𝑚𝑎𝑡)
(1)
where A is absorbance, ε = 6.0 ∙ 104 L mol-1 cm-1 is the extinction coefficient of TA at 260 nm,
l = 1 cm, 1701 is the molecular weight of TA in g/mol, m is the mass of an immersed fiber mat in
Antioxidant Activity. Antioxidant activity of the fiber mats was assessed by their capability to
reduce the concentration of ABTS radical cation, ABTS•+. A solution of ABTS•+ was prepared by
mixing equal volumes of 7 mM solutions of ABTS precursor and 2.45 mM solutions of potassium
peroxydisulfate in DI water (all solutions were purged with nitrogen prior to use), followed by 24-
hour incubation in the dark to complete the formation of ABTS•+.42 The ABTS•+ stock solution was
prepared by diluting the original ABTS•+ solution with nitrogen-purged DI water to achieve an
absorbance value A of 1.7 or 3 at 732 nm. For comparing antiradical performance of PVP-TA0.67
bulk complexes and nanofiber mats, 20 mL of stock solutions with A of 1.17 and 18 mg samples
were used. For quantitative assessment of burst versus prolonged antiradical performance, pieces
8
of fiber mats with different PVP/TA compositions weighing 1.2 to 1.4 mg were used for immersion
aliquots were collected from the containers containing pieces of PVP/TA fibers, diluted with 2 mL
of DI water, and analyzed using UV-Vis spectrometry. To account for the contribution of TA
released from the fibers to solution, a separate set of experiments was conducted in which the fiber
mats were not continuously exposed to ABTS•+, but instead were kept in contact with DI water. In
this set of experiments, fiber mats with masses of 2 to 2.6 mg were placed in 20 mL of DI water
at pH ~ 6.5. Aliquots of these solutions were added to 3 mL of ABTS•+ stock solution and
incubated in the dark for the same amount of time as the exposure of the original fibers to water to
assure completion of the reaction. In both experiments, antioxidant activity was calculated from a
decrease in the intensity of the ABTS•+ solutions at 732 nm (ε = 25400 M-1cm-1),43 calculated as
(𝐴0 − 𝐴)⁄𝜀 , where A0 is absorbance of the control ABTS•+ solution (which was incubated for the
same time period, but without the fiber mats or supernatant solutions), and A is absorbance of
ABTS•+ solutions exposed to nanofibers or fiber supernatant solutions. The antioxidant activities
of the fiber mats and the supernatant solutions were quantified as the moles of ABTS•+ reduced by
9
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
environment, and antioxidant activity, a wide range of PVP/TA ratios was explored. Scheme 2
hydrogen bonding in organic solvents, such as DMF or DMSO, which are capable of modulating
intermolecular binding via competitive hydrogen bonding.44-46 This strategy was pursued because
disruption of ionic pairing by inorganic salts,10 hydrogen-bonded complexes are not significantly
affected by the addition of small ions.44 PVP/TA solutions in DMF/DMSO 75/25 (v/v) were easily
processable, clear viscous liquids in which intermolecular binding was suppressed. However,
hydrogen bonds between PVP and TA were formed as solvent evaporated during the spinning
process. The fiber compositions, controlled by the ratio of the components in the spinning
10
solutions, are abbreviated as PVP-TAX, where X is the molar fraction of TA hydrogen-bonding
units, calculated as the ratio of moles of hydroxyl groups of TA to the sum of moles of PVP
repeating units and hydroxyl groups of TA. In this abbreviation system, the fibers abbreviated as
PVP-TA0.5 are composed of PVP and TA with equal number hydrogen-bonding units.
Figure 1 shows that bead-free, aligned fibers with good uniformity were produced from
solutions with a broad range of PVP-to-TA ratios. Progressively thinner fibers are formed from
solutions with increased content of TA, with the average fiber diameter decreasing from 708 65
illustrates an increase in the fiber diameters obtained from solutions with an increased total
concentration but fixed PVP-to-TA ratio. Both results are consistent with previous literature and
reflect the commonly observed trend associated with the slower flow of more viscous higher-
polymer-containing solutions through the metallic needle tip during the electrospinning process.
47-49
3!m 3!m
(c) (d)
PVP-TA0.50 PVP-TA0.67
(f)
3!m 3!m
Figure 1. The dependence of the fiber diameter on the mole fraction of TA in PVP-TA solution
with the total concentration of 13.5 wt.%. SEM micrographs and insets illustrate the fiber diameter
distributions for PVP (a), PVP-TA0.33 (b), PVP-TA0.5 (c), and PVP-TA0.67 (d), change in average
diameter of a fiber with a change in mole fraction of TA (e) and a fiber mat of PVP-TA0.5 (f).
11
(a) (b)
(c)
PVP-TA0.25 PVP-TA0.50 PVP-TA0.67
PVP o o o o
o o o o o
o o o OH
o OH OH
o o o o o HO OH o HO OH HO OH
o o o OH OH OH OH
o o o OH OH
o HO OH HO OH
HO OH o
o o o o o
HO HO
HO HO
o o HO
HO
o
o o o o
OH
o HO OH o OH OH o
OH OH OH OH
OH OH OH OH
o
OH OH
OH OH
OH
o OH
o
OH
OH
o
OH
OH
HO OH o o o o o o o
o o
TA o o o o o o
o o
HO
HO
o o o
o o o o o o
o o o o o o
o
OH OH o
OH OH OH o OH o HO OH HO OH
HO OH o o o o
o OH
OH
OH OH
o HO OH o o OH OH OH
OH o o o o OH
OH HO OH o
OH o o o o OH OH
o HO
HO OH o o HO OH o HO
HO
o
HO
HO
o o HO
HO
o
o o o
HO
HO o o
o o
o o o OH OH
o
OH
o
OH
o o o o OH o OH OH
OH
OH
OH OH
o
OH OH
OH
OH o o OH OH
o o
OH
OH
OH
o o o
OH
OH
OH OH
o o o
o o o
o o
Figure 2. Tensile strength, toughness (a), as well as elongation at break and elastic moduli (b) of
the uniaxially aligned free-standing PVP-TA fiber mats as a function of molar fraction of TA,
along with schematic representation of PVP-TA binding at increased molar fractions of TA (c).
were then determined under longitudinal tension. These experiments yielded the stress-strain
curves shown in Figure S2, which were used to determine the dependencies of tensile strength,
toughness, elastic modulus, and elongation at break on the fiber composition. Note that these
results were obtained with the uniaxially oriented free-standing fiber mats, and the data shown in
Figure 2a and Figure S2 were calculated from the dimensions of the fiber mats.
12
As shown in Figure 2a, the tensile strength and toughness of pristine PVP fibers (2.6 MPa
and 0.344 MJ/m3, respectively) was greatly increased after the addition of small fractions of TA,
and achieved their maximum values of tensile strength (~16 MPa) and toughness (~1.12 MJ/m3)
at 0.25 to 0.30 TA mole fraction. The ~6-fold enhancement in tensile properties of PVP-TA
nanofibers is the result of establishment of a network of hydrogen bonds between PVP and TA.
This observation is in agreement with previous reports of the effect of hydrogen bonding on
mechanical properties of self-assembled polymer materials for other systems.19 Further increase
in TA concentration deteriorated the fiber mechanical properties, resulting in materials with only
2-fold higher tensile strength as compared to that of pristine PVP fibers. Note that single-
component TA fibers could not be prepared because of the low-molecular weight of TA and the
resulting lack of intermolecular interactions and entanglement network. The occurrence of the
maxima in tensile strength and toughness most likely results from the formation of the densest
in Figure 2c). Fewer PVP-TA hydrogen bonds are formed in a large excess of either PVP or TA
because hydrogen bonds in this system are formed exclusively between hydrogen-donating groups
Unlike tensile strength and toughness, elongation at break was the largest for pristine PVP
fibers, and decreased with increasing TA content, because small, non-polymeric TA molecules
could not support large fiber extension (Figure 2b). On the other hand, addition of TA caused an
increase in Young’s moduli of the fibers of pristine PVP fiber mats from ~35 MPa to ~293 MPa.
Comparing our results with a study on similar system, the modulus of the PVP-TA0.33 fibers was
nearly 24 times higher than that of randomly oriented electrospun fibers of hydrogen bonded
complexes with similar fiber diameters.50 Note that the fiber mats with the largest content of TA
13
studied here (PVP-TA0.67) retained their structural flexibility and could be handled without
For the solution-processed materials, including electrospun fibers, the remnant solvent
and/or the hydrating water can significantly affect materials’ mechanical and thermal properties.
51,52,53
The fiber mats in Figure 2 and Figure S2 were studied immediately after electrospinning
without any heat pre-treatment, when mats were also exposed to the ambient environment. A
question then arose of the role of the co-solvent and water on the fiber’s mechanical properties.
The data in Figure 2b and Figure S2 show the high elongation at break for the fibers of pristine
PVP (Tg of 180 oC)54 at room temperature, suggesting the occurrence of plasticization. Therefore,
it was important to quantify the fraction of solvents present in the fibers. Figure 3a shows the
TGA data of pristine PVP fibers along with PVP-TA fibers with different component ratios in the
temperature range between 50 and 250 oC. The complete TGA scans are shown in Figure S3,
(a) (b)
Figure 3. TGA analysis of individual fiber components and PVP-TA fibers: TGA data for
the fibers of different compositions during heating between 50 and 250 oC and inset image
shows the method of calculating solvent content for PVP-TA0.60 (a), as well as quantified
contents of water and DMF/DMSO as a function of mole fraction of TA in PVP-TA fibers
(b).
14
which illustrates decomposition of individual TA and PVP components above 225 oC, and 400 oC,
range, with specific decomposition profile dependent on the PVP-to-TA ratio (Figure S3). Figure
3a shows that at temperatures below 250 oC, where PVP and TA remained thermally stable, two-
step mass loss occurred, which is attributed to sequential loss of water at ~100 oC and DMF/DMSO
between 150 and 250 oC (boiling points of DMF and DMSO 153 oC and 189 oC, respectively).56
Figure 3b shows quantification of the content of water and organic solvents in the PVP-TA fibers.
Interestingly, the uptake of water versus organic solvents was highly dependent on the fiber
composition. TGA results show that pristine PVP fibers with the largest water loss of ~20% were
the most hydrated. On the other hand, as the fibers became enriched with TA, the amount of water
in the fibers decreased, while more DMF/DMSO was retained within the fibers. These trends
occurred because of the hydrophilic nature of PVP, which is soluble in water54, and hydrophobicity
The occurrence of hydrogen bonding between the fiber components was then studied in a
series of differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) experiments which aimed to explore the effect
of PVP-TA binding on the fiber glass transition temperature, Tg. During the first heating cycle,
solvent loss dominated the loss of water, as indicated by an endothermic peak between 90 oC and
125 oC observed in all samples (Figure S4a). In good agreement with the data in Figure 3,
however, the magnitude of this peak was largest for pristine PVP fibers and decreased for the fibers
with higher TA content. In the second heating cycle, shown in Figure 4a, solvent evaporation was
complete, and distinct glass transitions for fibers of all compositions were observed. The fiber Tg
increased from ~177 oC for pristine PVP (in good agreement with the previously reported of 180
o
C)54 to ~234 oC for the fibers with the equimolar ratio of PVP-to-TA units. This increase reflects
15
loss of segmental mobility of PVP due to hydrogen bonding with TA. Note that the glass transition
temperature could not be determined for the fibers with the mole fraction of TA larger than 0.5
because of the onset of degradation of excess TA, which was not bound within PVP-TA complex
(Figure S4b).
(a) (b)
Figure 4. DSC thermograms of pristine PVP and PVP-TA fibers with varied ratios of the
components collected during the second heating cycle at a heating rate of 10 oC/min (a), and the
glass transition temperature, Tg, as a function of molar fraction of TA in the electrospun fibers (b).
The total concentration of PVP and TA in the electrospinning solutions was 13.5 wt.%.
is required for leveraging the antioxidant properties of the fiber mats for potential biomedical and
function of fiber composition and solution pH. To identify specific solubility regimes (stability,
gelation, and dissolution), the fiber mats were immersed in solutions at different pH for 10 days
and studied using visual inspection. The fibers were considered stable if they fully preserved their
morphology.
16
Figure 5. Stability diagram of PVP-TA fiber mats of different compositions in aqueous solutions
at various pH after 10 days of immersion.
Figure 5 illustrates that the fiber mats of all compositions were more stable in solutions at
acidic, neutral and slightly basic pH, and dissolved in strongly basic solutions. This observation is
consistent with previous reports on PVP-TA layer-by-layer films and reflects dissociation of PVP-
stability/dissolution transitions was strongly dependent on the fiber composition. The fibers with
high percentage of PVP (such as PVP-TA0.33) were not structurally stable in the entire range of pH
because of the high hydrophilicity of PVP which was present in excess in these fibers. These fiber
mats fully lost their morphology by turning into continuous hydrogels at pH 4 to 8 and dissolving
at pH > 8. In contrast, fibers with higher content of TA were stable within a wider pH range because
all hydrophilic PVP was bound with TA within hydrophobic PVP-TA complexes. Specifically,
PVP-TA0.5 fiber mats were stable up to pH 8, swelled at pH 9, and dissolved at higher pHs. The
fiber pH stability region further expanded to more basic pH (pH =10 for PVP-TA0.67 fibers) as the
content of TA increased. More detailed studies were performed for pH 6 to correlate stability of
the fibers and retention of their morphology with release of TA to the solution. Fibers of different
17
Figure 6. SEM images of PVP-TA0.33, PVP-TA0.5, and PVP-TA0.67 fibers before (a) and after
(b) 50 days of immersion in aqueous solution at pH 6. The scale bar is 4 μm. Release profile of
TA from the fibers of various compositions a pH 6 (c), along with the analysis of the average
fiber diameters before and after the immersion (d).
18
compositions were immersed at pH 6 for 50 days, the morphology of fibers was explored with
SEM, and the release of the TA was measured with UV-Vis spectroscopy, as shown in Figure 6.
Consistent with the morphological stability (Figure 6a and 6b) was compositional stability
of the fibers, monitored as release of TA to the surrounding solution. Figure 6c illustrates the
strong effect of the fiber composition on release of TA in solution at pH 6. Consistent with our
hydrophilic PVP, PVP-rich PVP-TA0.33 fibers released almost half of assembled TA as they lost
their morphology and turned to hydrogels. At the same time, fibers with higher content of TA
retained at least 92% of TA when exposed to aqueous solutions for as long as 50 days. These
results show that controlling the composition of electrospun fibers allows one to engineer the fiber
The capability of the fiber mats to scavenge free radicals was then explored using the
morphologically stable PVP-TA samples. The advantage of using the nanofiber mats compared to
bulk complexes is illustrated in Figure 7a. While a solution-cast solid sample of PVP-TA0.67
complex was fragile and rigid, electrospun fibers were flexible and easy to handle. Because of high
specific surface area of the fibrous mats, they demonstrated orders of magnitude higher overall
We then hypothesized that assembly of TA within the fibers can restrict immediate
availability of the antioxidant as compared to solution and result in its prolonged action. Testing
this hypothesis required experiments at much longer time scales than those used in antioxidant
The antioxidant activity of the fiber mats was assessed by the standard ABTS•+ radical
scavenging assay. To quantify the capability of the fiber mats to reduce ABTS•+, small coupons of
19
Figure 7. Comparison of the antioxidant efficiency of a continuous film and a fiber mat of
PVP-TA0.67 composition to reduce ABTS•+ radicals at short time (a), and quantification of the
antioxidant activity of the fiber mats and the corresponding solution extracts as a function of
immersion time (b).
the fiber mats were exposed to ABTS•+ solutions of which absorbance was monitored during 22
and assembled TA to the overall antioxidant activity, parallel ABTS•+ antioxidant tests were
performed in which the fiber mats were exposed to water rather than ABTS•+ solutions, and
aqueous extracts were collected and analyzed for antioxidant activity after certain periods of time.
Figure 7b demonstrates that unlike TA present in solution, PVP-TA0.5 and PVP-TA0.67 fiber mats
demonstrated a long-term antioxidant performance. The fiber mats with lower content of TA
(PVP-TA0.33) were not used in these experiments because they fully lost their fibrous morphology
as a result of exposure to ABTS•+ solutions (Figure S5), similarly to their exposure to water
(Figure 7b).
During the first 2 days, the amount of ABTS•+ reduced by the immersed fiber mats closely
matched the amount of ABTS•+ radical reduced by fiber supernatant solutions (Figure 7b),
20
suggesting that at the initial stage, antiradical activity of the fibers is brought mostly by TA
released to solution. At the same time, after 2 days of immersion, the amount of reduced ABTS•+
continued increasing for the fibers and stayed relatively the same for the fiber supernatant
solutions. This suggests that at the longer times of immersion, antioxidant activity was
supplied/occurred not by TA released from fibers to solution, but by TA assembled within the
fibrous mats. The antioxidant capacity of the fiber mats continued to slowly rise between 5 and 15
To estimate the fraction of TA assembled within the fiber mats that was available for
reacting with ABTS•+, the overall maximum antioxidant capacity of the fibers was determined by
measuring the activity of free TA in solution. The maximum amount of ABTS•+ that can be reduced
by all TA in the fibers was 24.2 ± 1.3 mmol of the radical per 1 g of TA (Figure S6). From a
comparison of the amounts of ABTS•+ radical reduced by the immersed fiber mats after 22 days
with the total amount of TA in the fibers, and assuming a sharp boundary between ABTS•+-
penetrated and ABTS•+-unaffected fiber material, the penetration depth of ABTS•+ within PVP-
TA0.5 and PVP-TA0.67 fibers was estimated as ~43 nm and ~13 nm, respectively. These values
correspond to 21% and 12% of the outer circular cross-sectional area of the fibers, respectively.
Oxidation of TA within ABTS•+ penetration zone was also evident visually from the yellow color
of the fiber mats characteristic of oxidized TA (Figure S7). More efficient penetration of ABTS•+
within PVP-TA0.5 fibers (as compared to PVP-TA0.67 fibers) agrees with softened and flattened
morphology and a wider diameter distribution for the dry PVP-TA0.5 fiber mats (Figure 8), all
suggesting a significant water uptake occurring during exposure of these fibers to ABTS•+
solutions. Free volume acquired due to solvent uptake facilitated ABTS•+ diffusion within the
fibers and increased availability of TA for oxidation, ultimately boosting antioxidant performance
21
of the fibers. In contrast, the fibers with a higher content of TA (PVP-TA0.67) demonstrated no
changes in the fiber diameters or morphology (Figure 8). It is likely that the low degree of swelling
of PVP-TA0.67 fibers restricted penetration of ABTS•+ and resulted in lower antioxidant activity of
Figure 8. The average fiber diameters and SEM images of PVP-TA0.5 and PVP-TA0.67 fiber
mats before and after 22-day exposure to ABTS•+ solutions. The scale bar is 4 μm.
CONCLUSION
in their dry state, stability in aqueous environments at different pH values, and antioxidant
order of magnitude enhancement in the fiber tensile strength, toughness, and Young’s modulus as
a result of formation of a network of hydrogen bonds. At the same time, simultaneous control of
the solubility properties of the fiber mats in aqueous environments along with their functionality
(antioxidant activity) was achieved. This work demonstrates a unique capability of the fibers to
22
prolong antioxidant activity, supplied by fiber-assembled antioxidant small molecules. We believe
that this class of new antioxidant materials with high surface area, robust mechanical properties,
controlled stability in aqueous environment, and capability for long-term antioxidant protection
can find applications in environmental and biomedical engineering constructs which benefit from
the long-term antioxidant properties of these materials. One example of such application is tissue
engineering constructs which can impart controlled levels of scavenging of reactive oxidant
species across the span of weeks often required for successful tissue regeneration.
Supporting Information
The supporting information file consists of seven figures which present SEM micrographs of PVP-
TA0.5 fibers electrospun from solutions of varying concentrations; tensile stress-strain curves for
the PVP-TA fiber mats of different compositions; full TGA thermograms of pristine PVP, TA and
PVP-TA fibers; DSC thermograms for PVP, TA and PVP-TA fibers during the first heating cycle;
as well as SEM images and the visual appearance of PVP-TA fiber mats after reacting with ABTS•+
solutions.
Corresponding Author
*E-mail: svetlana@[Link].
Notes
Acknowledgment
This work was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Award DMR-1610725,
DMR-1905535, and the Texas A&M University Experiment Station. The authors acknowledge
Materials Characterization Facility at Texas A&M University for enabling optical and scanning
23
References
(1) Thenmozhi, S.; Dharmaraj, N.; Kadirvelu, K.; Kim, H. Y. Electrospun Nanofibers:
New Generation Materials for Advanced Applications. Materials Science and Engineering: B
(2) Xue, J.; Xie, J.; Liu, W.; Xia, Y. Electrospun nanofibers: New Concepts, Materials,
(4) Sill, T. J.; von Recum, H. A. Electrospinning: Applications in Drug Delivery and
(5) Jiang, T.; Carbone, E. J.; Lo, K. W. H.; Laurencin, C. T. Electrospinning of Polymer
Nanofibers for Tissue Regeneration. Progress in Polymer Science 2015, 46, 1-24.
(6) Ma, Z.; Kotaki, M.; Ramakrishna, S. Electrospun Cellulose Nanofiber as Affinity
(7) Ma, H.; Burger, C.; Hsiao, B. S.; Chu, B. Ultra-fine Cellulose Nanofibers: New
Nano-Scale Materials for Water Purification. Journal of Materials Chemistry 2011, 21, 7507-
7510.
(8) Lee, J. S.; Jun, J.; Cho, S.; Kim, W.; Jang, J. Electrospun Three-Layered Polymer
Nanofiber-Based Porous Carbon Nanotubes for High-Capacity Energy Storage. RSC Advances
2017, 7, 201-207.
(9) Chinnappan, A.; Baskar, C.; Baskar, S.; Ratheesh, G.; Ramakrishna, S. An
Overview of Electrospun Nanofibers and Their Application in Energy Storage, Sensors and
24
(10) Meng, X.; Perry, S. L.; Schiffman, J. D. Complex coacervation: Chemically Stable
Fibers Electrospun from Aqueous Polyelectrolyte Solutions. ACS Macro Letters 2017, 6, 505-511.
(11) Boas, M.; Gradys, A.; Vasilyev, G.; Burman, M.; Zussman, E. Electrospinning
(12) Celebioglu, A.; Kayaci-Senirmak, F.; İpek, S.; Durgun, E.; Uyar, T. Polymer-Free
(13) Mei, L.; Fan, R.; Li, X.; Wang, Y.; Han, B.; Gu, Y.; Zhou, L.; Zheng, Y.; Tong, A.;
Guo, G. Nanofibers for Improving the Wound Repair Process: The Combination of a Grafted
(14) Xu, F.; Weng, B.; Gilkerson, R.; Materon, L. A.; Lozano, K. Development of
(15) Ma, G.; Liu, Y.; Fang, D.; Chen, J.; Peng, C.; Fei, X.; Nie, J. Hyaluronic
(16) Penchev, H.; Paneva, D.; Manolova, N.; Rashkov, I. Novel Electrospun Nanofibers
25
(19) Song, P. a.; Xu, Z.; Guo, Q. Bioinspired Strategy to Reinforce PVA with Improved
Toughness and Thermal Properties via Hydrogen-Bond Self-Assembly. ACS Macro Letters 2013,
2, 1100-1104.
(20) Lv, Z.; Qiao, J.-N.; Song, Y.-N.; Ji, X.; Tang, J.-H.; Yan, D.-X.; Lei, J.; Li, Z.-M.
Baroplastics with Robust Mechanical Properties and Reserved Processability Through Hydrogen-
Bonded Interactions. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 2019, 11, 12008-12016.
(21) Sakagami, H.; Jiang, Y.; Kusama, K.; Atsumi, T.; Ueha, T.; Toguchi, M.; Iwakura,
I.; Satoh, K.; Ito, H.; Hatano, T. Cytotoxic Activity of Hydrolyzable Tannins Against Human Oral
(22) Chen, K.-S.; Hsiao, Y.-C.; Kuo, D.-Y.; Chou, M.-C.; Chu, S.-C.; Hsieh, Y.-S.; Lin,
T.-H. Tannic Acid-Induced Apoptosis and Enhanced Sensitivity to Arsenic Trioxide in Human
(23) Tikoo, K.; Sane, M. S.; Gupta, C. Tannic Acid Ameliorates Doxorubicin-Induced
Cardiotoxicity and Potentiates its Anti-Cancer Activity: Potential Role of Tannins in Cancer
(24) Costa, E.; Coelho, M.; Ilharco, L. M.; Aguiar-Ricardo, A.; Hammond, P. T. Tannic
(26) Kozlovskaya, V.; Xue, B.; Lei, W.; Padgett, L. E.; Tse, H. M.; Kharlampieva, E.
26
(27) Le, Z.; Chen, Y.; Han, H.; Tian, H.; Zhao, P.; Yang, C.; He, Z.; Liu, L.; Leong, K.
W.; Mao, H.-Q.; Liu, Z.; Chen, Y. Hydrogen-Bonded Tannic Acid-Based Anticancer Nanoparticle
for Enhancement of Oral Chemotherapy. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces 2018, 10, 42186-
42197.
(28) Kozlovskaya, V.; Zavgorodnya, O.; Chen, Y.; Ellis, K.; Tse, H. M.; Cui, W.;
Polyphenol for Protection of Pancreatic Islet Cells. Advanced Functional Materials 2012, 22,
3389-3398.
(29) Yang, S. Y.; Rubner, M. F. Micropatterning of Polymer Thin Films with pH-
Films. Journal of Macromolecular Science, Part C: Polymer Reviews 2006, 46, 377-395.
(32) Sukhishvili, S. A.; Granick, S. Layered, Erasable, Ultrathin Polymer Films. Journal
(33) Li, J.; Wang, Z.; Wen, L.; Nie, J.; Yang, S.; Xu, J.; Cheng, S. Z. D. Highly Elastic
Fibers Made from Hydrogen-bonded Polymer Complex. ACS Macro Letters 2016, 5, 814-818.
Potential Antioxidant Scaffold for Enhanced Wound Healing. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces
2017, 9, 5916-5926.
27
(35) Aytac, Z.; Kusku, S. I.; Durgun, E.; Uyar, T. Encapsulation of Gallic
Behavior and Antioxidant Activity of Gallic Acid. Materials Science and Engineering: C 2016,
63, 231-239.
(36) Whittaker, J. L.; Subianto, S.; Dutta, N. K.; Choudhury, N. R. Induced Insolubility
(37) Yang, W.; Sousa, A.; Thomas-Gahring, A.; Fan, X.; Jin, T.; Li, X.; Tomasula, P.;
2016, 9, 757.
(38) Naik, N.; Caves, J.; Chaikof, E. L.; Allen, M. G. Generation of Spatially Aligned
Collagen Fiber Networks Through Microtransfer Molding. Advanced Healthcare Materials 2014,
3, 367-374.
(40) Huang, Z.-M.; Zhang, Y.; Ramakrishna, S.; Lim, C. Electrospinning and
(41) Asvar, Z.; Mirzaei, E.; Azarpira, N.; Geramizadeh, B.; Fadaie, M. Evaluation of
28
(42) Huang, D.; Ou, B.; Prior, R. L. The Chemistry Behind Antioxidant Capacity
(43) Cai, H.; Liu, X.; Zou, J.; Xiao, J.; Yuan, B.; Li, F.; Cheng, Q. Multi-wavelength
(44) Selin, V.; Aliakseyeu, A.; Ankner, J. F.; Sukhishvili, S. A. Effect of a Competitive
(45) Wang, Y. H.; He, J.; Aktas, S.; Sukhishvili, S. A.; Kalyon, D. M. Rheological
(46) Ma, S.; Yuan, Q.; Zhang, X.; Yang, S.; Xu, J. Solvent Effect on Hydrogen-bonded
Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects 2015, 471, 11-18.
(47) Deitzel, J. M.; Kleinmeyer, J.; Harris, D.; Tan, N. B. The Effect of Processing
Variables on The Morphology of Electrospun Nanofibers and Textiles. Polymer 2001, 42, 261-
272.
(48) Thompson, C.; Chase, G. G.; Yarin, A.; Reneker, D. Effects of Parameters on
Nanofiber Diameter Determined From Electrospinning Model. Polymer 2007, 48, 6913-6922.
(49) Zong, X.; Kim, K.; Fang, D.; Ran, S.; Hsiao, B. S.; Chu, B. Structure and Process
29
(50) Heiny, M.; Shastri, V. P. Nanofibers of Elastin and Hydrophilic Segmented
(51) Gupta, D.; Jassal, M.; Agrawal, A. K. The Electrospinning Behavior of Poly (vinyl
(52) Hassan, A.; Rahman, N. A.; Yahya, R. Moisture Absorption Effect on Thermal,
(53) Yin, F.; Tang, C.; Li, X.; Wang, X. Effect of Moisture on Mechanical Properties
and Thermal Stability of Meta-Aramid Fiber Used in Insulating Paper. Polymers 2017, 9, 537.
(54) Turner, D.; Schwartz, A. The Glass Transition Temperature of Poly (n-vinyl
Polyvinylpyrrolidone Nanocomposites Having SiO2 Nanoparticles Modified With Citric Acid and
(56) Vinci, D.; Donaldson, M.; Hallett, J.; John, E.; Pollet, P.; Thomas, C.; Grilly, J.;
Jessop, P.; Liotta, C.; Eckert, C. Piperylene sulfone: A Labile and Recyclable DMSO Substitute.
(57) Zhang, W.; Yang, Z.-Y.; Cheng, X.-W.; Tang, R.-C.; Qiao, Y.-F. Adsorption,
Antibacterial and Antioxidant Properties of Tannic Acid on Silk Fiber. Polymers 2019, 11, 970.
30
Table of Content
31