Structured Answers on Constitution & Law
Uploaded by
Kanika SehrawatStructured Answers on Constitution & Law
Uploaded by
Kanika SehrawatCommon questions
Powered by AIIn Indian democracy, checks and balances prevent any one government organ from becoming too powerful. The judiciary checks laws via judicial review, the legislature can control executive actions, and the executive requires legislative approval for ordinances. This system ensures that power is not centralized, thereby supporting a balanced and fair democratic process .
The Constitution is the supreme law, meaning no other law can override it. Legislative actions contrary to the Constitution are void, the executive must operate within its framework, and the judiciary acts as its guardian. For example, Article 13 nullifies laws inconsistent with Fundamental Rights, underscoring the Constitution’s supreme authority .
Constitutionalism limits government power by ensuring it operates within constitutional boundaries. This includes the supremacy of the Constitution, the rule of law, separation of powers, an independent judiciary, and the protection of fundamental rights, thereby safeguarding democracy from arbitrary rule .
Comparative Law is a method rather than an independent branch, focusing on the analysis of differences and similarities between legal systems for deeper understanding and reform facilitation. This approach broadens legal understanding and informs richer legal frameworks by integrating successful practices from other jurisdictions, evidenced by India's integration of provisions from UK, USA, and Canada .
Courts, particularly the Supreme Court, safeguard federalism by interpreting Centre-State relations, conducting judicial review, resolving disputes under Article 131, and limiting the misuse of Article 356. In cases like S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, the judiciary has curtailed the misuse of the President's Rule, thereby maintaining the federal balance and protecting state autonomy .
According to John Salmond, the significance of Comparative Law lies in understanding similarities and differences across legal systems, thus enhancing legal reforms and fostering global harmony. For instance, the Indian adoption of the UK's Parliamentary system illustrates how comparative study aids legal development and enriches law understanding .
Public law governs state vs. individual relations, focusing on constitutional and criminal law, whereas private law deals with individual vs. individual matters such as contract and tort law. Public law impacts how state functions relate to citizens, while private law influences personal relationships and interests .
Dicey’s rule of law, emphasizing supremacy of law, equality before the law, and predominance of legal spirit, is crucial for modern democracies. Theoretical aspects underline absolute equality and no discretionary power, but in practice, administrative discretion and special laws exist. In India, it is embodied in Article 14 and upheld by judicial review and cases like Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, illustrating its backbone support for democracy and human rights .
The concept of 'Living Law' suggests that law is not static but evolves with society. It involves judicial interpretation and adaptability of the law in accordance with social changes and demands. Jurisprudentially, it is rooted in the Sociological School of thought, particularly Ehrlich's views, and is supported by the Realist approach. The Indian Constitution exemplifies this as it is dynamic and flexible, incorporating changes through judicial interpretation and amendments .
The Constitution is a 'living document' because it adapts to changing societal norms and conditions. This dynamism is facilitated through judicial interpretation and the amendment process, allowing governance to remain relevant and responsive to contemporary issues. In India, this is evident through the flexible constitutional amendments and progressive judicial interpretations adapting to social changes .