Understanding Sex Determination Mechanisms
Understanding Sex Determination Mechanisms
UNIT 7
SEX DETERMINATION
Structure
7.1 Introduction 7.6 Sex-Limited and Sex-
Enfluenced Traits
Objectives
Sex-Limited Traits
7.2 Genetic Basis of Sex
Determination Sex-Influenced Traits
7.1 INTRODUCTION
One of the probable deductions from your study of Mendel’s laws of
inheritance and their extensions and modifications in Units 1 and 2 may be
that contribution to inheritance is equal from both the parents. But sex linkage
is a major exception to it. Sex linkage occurs when a gene controlling a trait is
located on the sex chromosome. The sex chromosome bears several genes in 183
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
addition to those directly concerned with sex determination. The inheritance of
these genes follows a characteristic pattern which is different from that seen in
the examples of monohybrid and dihybrid inheritance, that you have studied
so far. The unique sex-linked pattern(s) of inheritance of any particular trait
can be easily recognised and studied by pedigree analysis.
Sex linkage forms the main theme of this unit. But we begin by a brief
discussion on mendelian factors that we now know are the genes and are
located on the chromosomes. Then you will study examples of genes located
on the sex chromosomes and their mode of transmission to the next
generation. These would be explained with examples of X-, and Y-linked
genes. This is followed by a subsection dealing with sex determination in
eukaryotes, which involves both environmental and genetic factors. Next, you
would study the genetic basis of sex determination, which is either of genic
type or of chromosomal type.
Objectives
After studying this unit you would be able to:
First, we shall see how the genic type of sex determination evolved into a
chromosomal type of sex determination mechanism. In the primitive forms, the
only difference between the two sexes was in their gametes. Later in
evolution, morphological or phenotypic difference developed in the two sexes
of a species.
The X and Y chromosomes differ from each other in many respects. This is
because, there is accumulation of sex determining genes on the respective
sex chromosomes. Also, there is negligible crossing-over between the X and Y
chromosomes. This helps to preserve gene combinations favouring distinct
sexual differences. The consequence is that the Y chromosome bears mostly
the genes essential for the male determination while all the other genes
become inert. These regions got reduced in size in some species and are
completely lost in others. This was how the heteromorphic sex chromosome
evolved.
186
36
Fig. 7.3: The ZZ-ZW system of sex determination in domestic fowl.
Unit 7 Sex Determination
7.3.3 The XX-XO System
In some species, the two sexes have different numbers of chromosomes. The
difference often involves the sex determination mechanism. This phenomenon
is called the XX-XO system (O indicates the absence of one sex
chromosome). The female has two sex chromosomes just as in the XX-XY
system, but the male has only one and is thus designated XIO. In the species
exhibiting this system, the diploid number of the chromosomes in male is one
less than that of the female as a result of the absence of one sex
chromosome. Consequently, the number of chromosomes is odd in males and
even in females. The grasshopper (Fig. 7.4) is a good example of this mode of
sex determination. The cricket and the beetle also exhibit a similar
chromosomal basis of sex determination.
Because males do not undergo meiosis for gamete production, all the sperms
from one individual are genetically identical to each other and to the male
parent. This has the interesting consequence of increasing the gametic
relatedness of a male’s daughters. Remember in this system, a male produces
no sons - only daughters. On an average, all daughters of one mated pair of
bees share 75% of their genes, rather than the normal 50% relatedness of 187
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
offspring of most species. The daughters are identical for all the 50% of the
genes received from their father, plus one-half of the 50% of the genes from
their mother, this makes a total of 75% genetic relatedness.
Fig. 7.6: Drosophila melanogaster, (a) male, (b) female. Two distinguishing
features are: the merging of the posterior bands in the male versus
their distinct separation in the female, and the longer more tapering
abdomen of the female. (c) shows details of a male leg with sex comb
188
36
(arrow).
Unit 7 Sex Determination
7.4 THE CHROMOSOME TNEORY OF
INHERITANCE AND SEX-LINKAGE
Soon after the discovery of Mendel's work in 1900, most geneticists accepted
the particulate nature of genes. Mendel had predicted that each gamete
contains only one allele of each gene instead of two. This prediction was
based on the fact this there is reduction in the number of chromosomes by
one-half at the time of meiosis during gamete formation.
The proposition of the Chromosome Theory was a crucial new step in genetic
thinking at that time. No longer were genes just disembodied factors, now they
were a part of the observable entities in the cell nucleus. Some geneticists,
particularly, Thomas Hunt Morgan remained skeptical of this idea. Ironically it
was Morgan himself who in 1910 provided the first definitive evidence for the
Chromosome Theory based on his studies on sex linkage.
Morgan worked with fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. When he mated red-
eyed flies R II R (dominant) with white-eyed flies r r (recessive), the IF,
progeny were red-eyed. Furthermore, when Morgan mated red-eyed males of
the F, generation with their red-eyed sisters, they produced about 1/4 white-
eyed males, but no white-eyed females. In other words, the eye colour
phenotype is X-linked. X-chromosome and eye colour are transmitted together
because the genes governing this character are located on the X-
chromosome. In a diploid individual, we know, the autosomes occur in pairs
but as regards to X-chromosomes the female fly has two copies and the male
has just one. However, Morgan was reluctant to draw this conciusion until he
observed sex-linkage with two more characters - miniature wings and yellow
body in the fruit fly. That was enough to convince him and other geneticists of
the validity of the chromosome theory of inheritance.
The X-linked traits have a unique mode of inheritance because females have
two doses of X-linked genes, while males have only one. Males are thus
hemizygous for X-linked traits.
Dominant X-linked genes are always expressed in both the sexes just as
in autosomal traits. One dose of X-linked dominant allele produces its effects
in males as well as females. The hemizygous male transmits the gene to all its
daughters but none to his sons. There is no father to son transmission. The
heterozygous females transmit the trait to half their children, irrespective of
their sex. On the other hand, females homozygous for the dominant allele
produce all affected children. For example, a form of vitamin D-resistant
rickets is inherited as an X-linked dominant trait (Fig. 7.7).
Fig. 7.7: Pedigree demonstrating X-linked dominant trait. The affected progeny
are shaded.
The opposite is true for recessive alleles. Males being hemizygous, always
express the recessive X-linked alleles. Females, however, express recessive
alleles only when they are homozygous. Thus, the frequency of X-linked
recessive traits is always lower in females than males.
Most X-linked genes are recessive alleles, and they are discovered when their
deleterious effects appear in males. Males transmit their X chromosome to
every daughter, and their Y chromosome to every son. Recessive X-linked
190
36
traits thus show a pattern of inheritance, in which the phenotype is usually
Unit 7 Sex Determination
expressed only in males of alternate generations. A male bearer transmits the
recessive allele to daughters, who does not express the allele because it
occurs in the heterozygous condition. However, each of her male offspring has
a 50% chance of receiving that allele and expressing the phenotype. The trait
should thus appear in 1/4 of her offspring (1/2 of her offspring are expected to
be male and 1/2 of her sons receive the recessive allele: 1/2 × 1/2 = 1/4). The
heterozygous female is a carrier of the allele. The X-linked allele is often said
to show a criss cross pattern of inheritance. In this pattern of inheritance, the
allele is transmitted from male to female, female to male, and the trait is
expressed only in males in alternate generations (see Fig. 7.8). Well-known
examples of X-linked recessive alleles include Red green colour blindness,
Haemophilia, Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency (G-6PD),
Congenital hyperuricemia, Duchenne muscular dystrophy, and Ichthyosis.
Fig. 7.8: Criss cross inheritance, i.e., the inheritance of a character from father
to daughter grandson. It is characteristic of a sex-linked gene. Genes
are shown on the chromosomes illustrating a cross between a woman
with normal vision and a green-colour defective man. The symbol g
represents the sex-linked recessive gene for green colour defective
vision, and G the normal condition. 191
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
SAQ 1
A husband and wife are normal although both their fathers have a trait which is
X-linked recessive. What is the probability that their first child will be:
a) A normal son?
b) a normal daughter?
Fig. 7.9: Absorption spectra of the blue, green and red proteins present in the
cone cells of the retina of the human eye. The ability of humans with
normal colour vision to distinguish colours throughout the visible
spectrum depends on the presence of all three proteins. Defective
colour vision results from the absence of, or a defect in, one or more of
these proteins. [After Nathans, K 1989. The Genes for: colour vision, Sa.
192
36
Amer, 260(2): 42-49].
Unit 7 Sex Determination
By 1986, the genes that encode the above three light-absorbing pigments of
the retina were isolated and their nucleotide sequence was determined. The
sequences have been used to find out the amino acid sequences of the three
light absorbing proteins. These light-absorbing proteins were found to have
very similar structures. The genes that encode the green-, and red-receptor
proteins are located on the X-chromosomes, thus the sex-linked patterns of
inheritance are observed for defects in green and red colour vision. And the
gene encoding the blue receptor protein was found to be located on
chromosome-7, that is, an autosome. Let us now examine some crosses (see
Fig. 7.10) and assess the pattern of inheritance of this defect. For the sake of
simplicity we are only considering here one gene, that is, gene causing defects
in the green receptor protein, as a single sex-linked recessive allele. Since the
Y chromosomes carried no colour vision locus, the single allele is expressed
causing colour blindness. Stop here for a minute and carefully study the five
crosses in the figure. The symbol G denotes normal receptor pigment, and g is
for the defective receptor pigment causing colour blindness.
In the above crosses have you noticed that sex-linked inheritance does not
conform to the Mendel’s laws of inheritance? Fig. 7.10 shows the results of
reciprocal matings of affected and unaffected parents. The normal male and
colour blind (recessive, homozygous) female produce normal but
heterozygous daughters, but all sons have the disease (cross a). The
reciprocal cross (b) demonstrates criss cross inheritance. A colour blind male
(hemizygous) with a normal (homozygous) female produces no affected
offspring, but the daughters are carriers (cross b). A colour blind male and a
carrier female result in 50% colour blinds (see cross c). Another possibility, a
normal male mated with a carrier female, produces all normal, female offspring
but 50% affected male offspring (see cross d). The mating of two colour blind
individuals result in all colour blind offspring (see cross e) if they have the
same colour blindness. 193
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
Haemophilia: Haemophilia is a disease in which one of the factors required
for the normal clotting of blood (see Fig. 7.11) is deficient. As a result, the
blood fails to clot or clots very slowly. Thus even minor injuries can cause
profuse internal and external bleeding which can lead to death.
Fig. 7.11: Blood clotting is the end result of a series of reactions requiring
various enzymes and cofactors, leading to the formation insoluble
fibrin. Many of the steps in the chain entail the conversion of a gene
Haemophilia is one of product to its active enzymatic lor111 by the enzymatic action of the
the earliest known active product a previous step. Cofactors (e.g., factor VIII and V) are
diseases, According required to work along with some of the active enzymes. Factor VIII,
to Talmud, the absent/defective in haemophilia A, is a cofactor required along with
Hebrew book of law, factor 1X to activate factor X. If factor VII is absent as a result of a sex-
when excessive linked recessive condition, the sequence is interrupted and the end
bleeding occurred result is defective clotting. In haemophilia B, factor a is deficient.
during circumcision of
two male infants of a Three forms of haemophilia controlled by three different gene loci are known.
mother, future male One of them is rare and is controlled by an autosomal recessive gene, while
offspring were
two forms, that is, haemophilia A and B result from recessive alleles at two X-
exempt. When sons
of three sisters linked loci. Haemophilia B also known as Christmas disease, comprises about
exhibited bleeding, 20% of all haemophilia and is caused by the deficiency of factor IX (see Fig.
sons of other sisters 4.7, step 3).
were also exempt.
However, sons of Haemophilia A, classical haemophilia is caused by an abnormality or
brothers were not deficiency of a protein cofactor known as factor VIII is located on X-
exempt, implying an chromosome. Factor VIII is needed for the activity of one of the enzymes -
understanding of criss factor IX, in the series of events leading to the activation of thrombin. Absence
cross pattern of
of functional factor VIII interrupts the steps leading to the activation of
inheritance.
thrombin, and consequently fibrin cannot form. Until recently, haemophilia A
was untreatable and only about 25% of the affected males reached age of
194
36
twenty five. Treatment with factor VIII now results in a longer life span.
Unit 7 Sex Determination
The frequency of haemophiliacs is about one in ten thousand males, but is
much lower in females, about one in one hundred million or less. A female
haemophiliac can result from the mating of a heterozygous female with an
affected male. Such a mating, is highly unlikely because very few male
haemophiliacs survive long enough to reproduce. Haemophiliac females are
also belived to die at the onset of menstruation.
Haemophilia A has been called the “Royal disease” because it affected males
in the royal families of Europe. Queen Victoria, a carrier of the haemoptrilia
allele had nine children (Fig. 7.12). Her eighth child, Leopold was a
haemophiliac who died at the age of thirty one. Her other three sons were
unaffected as they did not receive the allele. One daughter had no children,
her status as a carroerr cannot be assessed. Two daughters had children,
none of whom were haemophiliac, indicating that mothers probably were not
carriers. Two other daughters were carriers giving birth to haemophiliac sons.
In the recent years, a serious threat to victims of haemophilia has arisen due
to their continuing dependence upon blood transfusions. Such transfusions are
one means of transferring Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS)
and some haemophiliacs have infact acquired AIDS in this way. Extensive
surveillance of donor blood supplies is required to protect haemophiliacs and
all others requiring transfusions.
Ichthyosis: So far you have seen the examples where the recessive X-linked
are expressed in males. There are, however, instances where these are also
expressed in females in certain situations. Consanguineous matings (see
Consanguineous
means “of the same adjacent Margin Remark) can greatly increase the frequency of expression of
blood”. The term X-linked traits in females. In consanguineous pedigrees containing X-linked
means sharing genes recessive alleles, females have a high probability of carrying the X-linked
derived from a allele, as they can receive the allele from either parent. In turn, matings of
common ancestor, carrier females and affected males (Fig. 7.12) produce daughters and sons
related by descent. with an equal likelihood (i.e., 50%) of being affected.
Fig. 7.12: Cross between ichthyosis carrier female and affected male showing
196
36
50% affected progeny.
Unit 7 Sex Determination
Ichthyosis is a disorder characterised by extreme dryness, roughness and
scaliness of the skin. The prefix ‘ichthy’ means fish-like. Children produced in
situation as shown in Fig. 7.12 show ichthyosis at birth.
SAQ 2
A couple have a colour blind daughter and son with normal vision. What are
the genotypes of the parent in this cross?
SAQ 3
Draw a three generation pedigree of a family starting from a couple, where
male is a haemophiliac and the female is normal. They have 3 sons and a
carrier daughter. The daughter marries a normal male and has 3 daughters
and 2 sons. What is the probability of her children being carriers and
haemophiliacs?
SAQ 5
Is a Y-chromosome linked gene supposed to be dominant or recessive in
order to be recognised? How is a Y-linked gene transmitted to grand children?
197
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
7.6 SEX-LIMITED AND SEX-ENFLUENCED
TRAITS
Not all of the characters that differ in the two sexes are X-linked. There are
certain traits that are determined by autosomal genes, but their expression is
altered or influenced by the sex of the individual. Many a times these traits are
confused with the sex-linked traits. Actually, they are entirely different in their
mode of inheritance since their genetic determinants are not located on the
sex chromosomes. There are two kinds of such traits: sex-limited, and sex-
influenced traits.
Sex-Limited Traits are traits expressed only in one sex, although the genes
controlling them are present as well as transmitted to both the sexes.
Therefore, males and females with the same genotype, with respect to a
particular locus may have different phenotypes.
HH hen-feathered hen-feathered
Hh hen-feathered hen-feathered
hh hen-feathered cock-feathered
Thus Sebright bantams are all HH. Hamburgs and Wyandottes may be H-, or Pattern baldness
hh, and Leghorns are all hh. Cock-feathering where it occurs is limited to the refers to a definite
male sex. genetic pattern. In
this condition hair
7.6.2 Sex-Influenced Traits usually thins on top
ultimately leaving a
Sex-Influenced or Sex-Controlled Traits appear in both sexes but occur in fringe of hair low on
one sex more than the other. the head (Fig. 4.13).
Baldness may also
The genes for Sex-Influenced Traits show differing patterns of expression in arise due to various
each sex-usually the trait behaves as dominant in one sex and a recessive in causes such as
the other. Genes for sex-influenced traits occur only on autosomes. disease, radiation,
thyroid defect.
The best documented example of sex-influenced inheritance is pattern
baldness (Figs. 7.15 and 7.16). Individuals expressing pattern baldness begin
to lose their hair on the front and the top of the head, relatively early in life,
often in their twenties. Affected individuals are not totally bald: a distinct rim of
hair surrounds their head in patterns varying from person to person. It has
been proposed that a single pair of alleles is involved. The allele B1 which is
responsible for pattern baldness is dominant in males, and the heterozygous
males therefore, express pattern baldness. In females, however, the gene is
recessive. The allele for normal hair growth can be designated as B2.
Individuals with the genotype B1 B1 show pattern baldness, regardless of sex.
In such situations, in females there is marked thinning, rather than total loss of
hair on the top of the head. Persons with B1B2 genotype ale bald if they are
male but not bald if they are female. The presence of male hormones, are
strongly implicated in the expression of pattern baldness.
Fig. 7.15: Pedigree showing the incidence of pattern, baldness in a family. The
men represented by the dark squares became bald before they
reached the age of 35. Those represented by light squares are over 35
and have thick hair. No woman in this family pedigree expressed the
trait (After Gardner el ul. 1991, Principle of Genetics, John Wile-y h
Sons, Inc.) 199
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
Some human traits, such as certain types of white forelock, absence of upper
lateral incisor teeth, a particular type of enlargement of the terminal joints of
the fingers, and cleft-lip, exhibit a pattern of inheritance characteristic of sex-
influenced genes.
SAQ 6
Compare the inheritance pattern of the sex-limited traits with those of the sex-
linked traits.
The hypothesis that all but one X chromosome(s) are inactivated in each cell
was proposed by the geneticist Mary F. Lyon in 1961 and is known as Lyon
hypothesis. Crucial evidence for this hypothesis was provided by sexually
aneuploid individuals. Aneuploidy (meaning not the true number) refers to the
possession of an abnormal number of chromosomes. Aneuploid individuals
have the normal diploid number, plus or minus one or more chromosomes.
Females lacking one X chromosome exhibit Turner’s syndrome, designated
45, XO (45 chromosomes, with one X missing). Males with an extra X-
chromosome have Klinefelter’s syndrome designated 47 XXY. Cells from
45, XO females and 46 XY males have no Barr bodies (Fig. 7.18 a); while
those from 47, XXX females and 48 XXXY males have two (Fig. 7.18 b); 46,
XX females and 47, XXY males have one Barr body (Fig. 7.18 c) and 48,
XXXX females and 49, XXXXY males have three Barr bodies (Fig. 7.18 d).
Examination of the number of Barr bodies can be done easily to screen for
sex-chromosomes abnormalities. You have already seen in Box 7.1 how to
make a preparation of the epithelial cells from the buccal cavity for
examination. The mandatory "sex test\" that have been required for Olympic
athletes includes a count of Barr bodies. Males disguised as females can be
identified as they have no Barr bodies.
The maintenance of the germ cells and ovarian structures requires the
presence of two X-chromosomes. At this point you may wonder, whether
normal reactivation ever fails to occur. There are considerable evidences that
indicate abnormal reactivation of the heterochromatic X chromosomes. The
most common form of inherited mental retardation in humans is its example.
7.7.2 In Drosophila
Dosage compensation occurs in fruit flies, but its mechanism is different from
those of the mammals. No barr bodies are found in fruit flies. You have
already learnt that in fruit flies, the X chromosome to autosome ratio is
responsible for sex determination. Normal females have two X chromosomes
and normal males have one X chromosome. Dosage compensation in this
case is achieved by increased transcriptional activity of genes on the single X
chromosome in male cells relative to that of each of the X chromosome in
female cells The male has hyperactive X-chromosome, approaching the level
of activity of both of the females. This hyperactivity of X-chromosome can be
cytologically seen as “puffed” bands in the salivary gland chromosomes (Fig.
7.21). This is in variance to the inactive X-chromosomes in mammals which
appears condensed (sex chromation body). 203
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
SAQ 7
Indicate the expected number of Barr bodies in interphase cells of the
following individuals: Klinefelter’s syndrome; Turner’s syndrome; and
Karyotypes 47 XYY, 47 XXX, and 48 XXXX.
SAQ 8
Cat breeders are aware that kittens with the calico coat pattern are invariably
females. Why?
7.8 SUMMARY
In this unit you have learnt that:
• The dominant X-linked traits are always expressed in both the sexes.
e) both a and d
b) a third X chromosome
d) both b and c
e) both c and d
d) both a and c
Column A Column B
5. In sheep, the gene h+ for the horned condition is dominant in males and
recessive in females. If a hornless ram were mated to a horned ewe,
what is the chance that:
7. In Drosophila, the gene for bobbed bristles (recessive allele bb, bobbed
bristles; wild-type allele bb+, normal bristles) is located on the X
chromosomes and on a homologous segment of the Y chromosome.
Give the genotypes and phenotypes of the offspring from the following
crosses: a) XbbXbb × XbbYbb+, b) XbbXbb × XbbYbb, c) Xbb+Ybb, d) Xbb+Xbb ×
XbbYbb+.
8. Make a diagram for a cross between a normal woman (whose father was
defective in green colour vision) and a green colour-defective man.
Summarise the expected for sex and colour vision.
7.10 ANSWERS
Self Assessment Questions
1. Since both the husband and wife have fathers with the X-linked trait, the
husband will not carry the trait as it receives its X-chromosome from his
mother, but the wife carries the trait as she gets one X-chromosome
from her father. a) The probability of having a normal son is fifty per cent.
b) The chances of having a normal daughter is hundred per cent as a
female is not affected with X-linked recessive trait unless she receives
two genes for the trait. c) There is fifty per cent probability of having
affected son. d) There is no chance of the daughter being affected, but
there is a fifty per cent probability that they may be carrier.
2. Since the daughter is colour blind it can be assumed that both parents
carry the genes for the trait. The father’s genotype is therefore,
hemizygous and that of the mother is heterozygous for the trait. The son
must have received the normal X-chromosome from the mother and is
therefore, normal. 207
Block 2 The Physical Basis of Heredity
3.
The probability is fifty per cent for the daughters being carriers and there
is fifty per cent probability of the son being a haemophiliac.
Terminal Questions
1. i) The trait occurs more frequently in males than in females.
ii) Traits are transmitted from an affected man through his carrier
daughters to half his grandsons.
3. i) 22, XY, ii) 22, XX, iii) male, iv) holandric, v) hormones,
208
36
vi) sex-limited.
Unit 7 Sex Determination
4. i) b, ii) e, iii) f, iv) a, v) d.
5. a) 3/4, b) 1/4.
6. a) 3 hen-feathered : 1 cock-feathered
b) All hen-feathered
c) 1/2 XbbXbb+ and XbbXbb+ wild females, 1/4 Xbb+Ybb wild males, 1/4
XbbYbb bobbed males;
d) 1/4 Xbb+Xbb wild females, 1/4 XbbXbb bobbed females, 1/2 Xbb+Ybb+
and XbbYbb+ wild males.
8.
209