Unemployment and Economic Growth in Ethiopia
Unemployment and Economic Growth in Ethiopia
ABSTRACT 3
1. INTRODUCTION 5
[Link] REVIEW 10
3. METHODOLOGY 15
1
4. ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 17
4.1 Introduction 17
5.1 Conclusion 28
5.2 Recommendations 29
REFERNECES 31
2
ABSTRACT
Ethiopia's persistent unemployment rate stands as a significant hurdle to achieving
sustainable socioeconomic development. Te main purpose this study is to the analyze the
relationship between unemployment and economic growth inorder to check for the
applicability of Okun's Law in ethiopia context,. This paper employ Vector Error Correction
Model (VECM) analysis on data spanning 1992 to 2014 EC, sourced from the National Bank
of Ethiopia. This study provides a more comprehensive story than a simple cause-and-effect
relationship. While economic growth plays a crucial role, its impact on unemployment is
more contingent than traditional theories propose. The VECM analysis suggests that a 1%
increase in real GDP growth leads to a modest 0.04% decrease in the unemployment rate, all
other factors being equal (ceteris paribus). This indicates a positive but modest influence of
growth on job creation. Further exploration reveals that additional factors, such as spending
patterns and structural rigidities within the labor market, significantly influence the
dynamics between growth and unemployment. Additionally, the study finds a counterintuitive
positive correlation between inflation and unemployment, a topic that warrants further
investigation in the Ethiopian context. The findings of this study suggest that by promoting
labor-intensive industries, investing in skills development, boosting SMEs, modernizing
agriculture, and implementing active labor market policies, Ethiopia can generate large-
scale employment opportunities, bridge the skills gap, and better utilize the country's human
capital.
3
Acronyms And Abbreviations
ADF Augmented Dickey Fuller
UR Unemployment Rate
4
1. Introduction
1.1 Background of the study
The relationship between unemployment and economic growth is a complex and multifaceted
phenomenon that has been extensively studied by economists and policymakers alike.
Unemployment refers to individuals who are actively seeking employment but are unable to
find suitable job opportunities (Deribe et al. 2015). On the other hand, economic growth can be
seen as an increase in the capacity of an economy to produce goods and services, compared
from one period of time to another (Manuela Raisová, Júlia Ďurčová et al. 2014). Understanding
the interplay between these two variables is crucial for formulating effective policies that aim
to promote sustainable economic development.
Unemployment rates have fluctuated significantly over the past few decades, highlighting the
volatile nature of labour markets around the world. According to data from the International
Labour Organization (ILO), global unemployment steadily declined from 6.3% in 1992 to
5.4% in 2007 before experiencing a sharp increase during the 2008 financial crisis, reaching
6.0% in 2009. Since then, the global unemployment rate has remained relatively stable,
hovering around 5.5%. As of 2020, the world witnessed an unprecedented rise in
unemployment due to the COVID-19 pandemic. By the end of the year, the ILO reported that
global employment had declined by 8.8% compared to 2019, resulting in approximately 255
million job losses. These figures highlight the severe impact the pandemic has had on the
labour market, leading to widespread unemployment and economic instability worldwide
(ILO, 2021). These statistics indicate significant variations in regional unemployment
dynamics, Analysis of regional disparities reveals stark contrasts in unemployment rates
across different parts of the world. Western Europe has long experienced relatively low
unemployment rates, such as Germany's 4.2% or the Netherlands' 3.8% as of 2020.
Conversely, regions like Sub-Saharan Africa face higher levels of unemployment, with
countries like South Africa witnessing rates reaching a staggering 32.6% in the first quarter of
2021.
Unemployment remains to be one of the significant challenges for the economy of Ethiopia,
according to recent data from the Ethiopian Central Statistical Agency, the country's
unemployment rate has exhibited a gradual increase over the past decade. In 2010, the rate
stood at 17.5%, but by 2019, it had risen to 19.1%. However, it is essential to note that these
figures do not provide a complete picture of the situation as they only represent the formal
sector, excluding the substantial informal workforce. Urban areas witness higher
unemployment rates, primarily due to the lack of job opportunities and limited access to
formal employment. Additionally, youth unemployment remains a pressing concern, with
over 29% of the youth population currently unemployed. Several socio-economic and
structural factors contribute to the unemployment trend in Ethiopia. Firstly, a discrepancy
between the education system output and labour market demands exists. The Ethiopian
education system often fails to equip individuals with the necessary skills and knowledge to
meet the demands of the job market, leading to a surplus of unskilled laborers and a shortage
5
of skilled workers leading to a mismatch between qualifications and job requirements. The
persistent high unemployment rate in Ethiopia poses significant challenges to both
individuals and the economy at large. From an individual perspective, unemployment can
lead to diminished living standards, reduced dignity, and increased vulnerability to poverty.
On the macroeconomic level, a high unemployment rate implies a wasted labour force,
hindering the country's potential to achieve sustainable economic growth. Lower productivity,
decreased purchasing power, and reduced tax revenues exacerbate income inequality and
inflationary pressures.
Economic growth and unemployment rate have always been major drivers to explain
economic facts because of their interaction with other microeconomic and macroeconomic
factors, yet their relationship are prevalent inquiries that a great number of researchers has
embarked upon in their studies. Traditionally, there exists a commonly held assumption that a
rise in economic growth leads to a decline in unemployment rates, as expanding economic
activities create more job opportunities. Conversely, during economic downturns or
recessions, unemployment tends to rise due to decreased demand for goods and services,
leading to layoffs and downsizing by businesses aiming to cut costs. Nonetheless, the nature
and direction of the relationship between unemployment and economic growth have been
subject to various theories, empirical studies, and differing perspectives. Some economists
argue for a structural relationship where changes in one variable affect the other in a
sustained manner, while others emphasize cyclical fluctuations, suggesting that
unemployment and economic growth might move in tandem during specific phases of
economic cycles. Moreover, factors such as technological advancements, globalization,
demographic shifts, government policies, and labour market dynamics significantly influence
the correlation between unemployment and economic growth, making the relationship
intricate and context-dependent. The relationship between economic growth and
unemployment has been studied experimentally in the economic literature based on what is
known as the Okun law, which shows that there is an inversely proportional relationship
between the change in the growth rate (GDP) and the change in the unemployment rate. Okun
has succeeded to show that there is a reciprocal correlation between unemployment and
economic growth. He found that if unemployment decreased by (1%), then this would be due
to an increase in real gross domestic product (RGDP) by (3%) and vice versa, and when an
increase in the RGDP occurs, an increase in employment is achieved (Hjazeen, H., Seraj, M., &
Ozdeser, H. (2021).
Ethiopia has a predominantly agricultural economy, being the second-most populous country
in sub-Saharan Africa, with a population approaching 123 million people (UNDP,
Citation2022b) and over 63.66% of the population employed in farming (World Bank,
Citation2021a). However, the country is experiencing rapid population growth, which is
outpacing the ability to create sufficient jobs (Getahun & Fetene,2020).
The main purpose of this paper is to analyses the relationship between unemployment and
economic growth in Ethiopia and tests the validity of Okun's Law. It considers the country's
unique socio-economic landscape, policy frameworks, and challenges. The research aims to
6
provide policymakers, stakeholders, and economists in Ethiopia with actionable insights and
policy interventions to foster sustainable economic growth while addressing unemployment.
Unemployment in Ethiopia is the prominent feature of the labour market. It has undesirable
social, economic and psychological influences. The least developed countries like Ethiopia in
which physical capital is in short, the labour resource plays significant role for economic
growth. However, a significant portion of the labour force is under the unemployment
category which poses a huge burden on the current economic growth of the country.
Unemployment has prevailed in Ethiopia for many decades which is mainly caused by
political instability, operational problems in industries, volatile investment and inefficient
growing flow of new graduates to labour market. Several strategies of macroeconomy in
Ethiopia was not able to realize the anticipated target of a sustainable economic growth and
low UR. Total labour force in Ethiopia was reported at 53,746,763 in 2019 (WB: WDI,2020;
ILO, 2020). Set the UR 19.5%, the total unemployed people in Ethiopia are 10,480,619.
According to the Ethiopian Prime Minister’s report to the House of People Representative
(Ahmed, 2020), 2.4 million new hires are expected in the fiscal year 2019/2020. Oppositely,
in the same year, 2.0 million new entrants join the labour market. That means, making other
factors constant, 25 more years3 are required to substantially lower the unemployment
problems of the country. Overall, the 19.4% tall UR in Ethiopia remain high as compared to
other countries. The degree of progress in employment status achieved due to economic
growth remains unclear and controversial. Studies that have focused on empirical validity and
policy implication of Okun’s law and efforts to address the unemployment-economic growth
puzzles are hardly available in Ethiopia. (Adam Feto. Ethiopian Economics Association (EEA), 282,
(2022).
Therefore, the objectives of the study are to: assess the linkage between unemployment and
economic growth in Ethiopia and examine the existence of Okun’s law in Ethiopia in the
period 1992 to 2014 EC.
7
1.3 Objective of the study
1.3.1 General Objective
This study seeks to understand the dynamic between economic growth and unemployment in
Ethiopia with a focus on the validity of Okun's Law. The findings aim to inform policy
decisions regarding economic growth strategies that minimize unemployment in the
Ethiopian context.
To overview the trend of unemployment and economic growth in Ethiopia for the
period (1992–2014 EC)
To determine the impact of economic growth on unemployment and vice versa.
To provide insights into policy implications for managing unemployment and
fostering sustainable economic growth.
What are the trends and patterns observed in the unemployment rates and economic
growth in Ethiopia from 1992 to 2014 EC?
How does the observed economic growth in Ethiopia during the specified period
influence the unemployment rates, and conversely, how does unemployment impact
economic growth?
What policy interventions or measures could be recommended based on the
relationship identified between economic growth and unemployment in Ethiopia to
effectively manage unemployment while fostering sustainable economic growth?
9
[Link] review
2.1 Theoretical literature review
2.1.1 Definition of Concepts
Unemployment
Economic growth
Economic growth is the increase in the capacity of an economy to produce goods and
services over time. It can be measured in nominal terms, which include inflation, or more
conventionally measured by adjusting inflation in real terms (real GDP) and economic
growth typically refers to this growth of potential output. As stated by ECA (2010), Economic
growth is important for not only increasing a country’s level of income, but also for laying the
foundation of sustainable poverty reduction, improving human welfare and enhancing overall
development. Growth enables countries to increase the availability and distribution of basic
life sustaining goods and services such as food, shelter, health, and protection. It also enables
countries to generate more jobs and better education, thereby expanding the range of
economic and social choices available to their citizens (Abdulkadir Hamza 2015)
2.1.2 Theories
The okun’s law
Arthur Okun (1962) investigated the relation between unemployment and economic growth
of [Link] findings postulated the Okun’s Law that predicts that 1% increase in the growth
rate above its trend rate will lead to only 0.3% reduction in the unemployment rate. More
specifically, recently accepted versions of Okun's law states that, a 1 % decline in
unemployment, in the course of a year, is related to approximately a 2% faster growth in
real GDP over that period (Abel, 2008). Okun estimated two models of his law,
the difference and the gap model, which are considered as original ones.
Both, assumed that to produce more products and services within the
economy, more labour is required.
Later, many economists argued that the labour may be increased not only
10
through hiring new
workers, but also through increasing the number of hours worked, the
level of productivity, etc. Also, the current level of unemployment may be
determined by the unemployment rates in the past. According to these
arguments, the existing models were upgraded with additional
independent variables. Later, two more models of Okun’s Law were
designed: the dynamic and the production function model. The dynamic
model includes lags of economic growth and unemployment rate, since it
predicts that the past values of the variables, growth and
unemployment, may affect the current unemployment rate. The
production-function model is
even wider and includes variables that combine the labour, capital and
technology (Despina Tumanoska (2020)
The classical economists often define unemployment as the “excess supply” of labor over the
demand for labor that caused by adjustment in real wage. The Classical or real-wage
unemployment occurs when real wages for a job are set above the market-clearing level,
causing number of job seekers to exceed the number of vacancies. In this theory,
unemployment regarded as situation where the smoothly functioning labor market obstructed
in some way. In a smoothly functioning market, market forces would set the equilibrium
wage and quantity of labor. The Classical approach assumes that markets behave as described
by the idealized supply and demand model. The labor market characterized by perfect
competition, in which, it is assumed that, every unit of labor services is the same, and every
worker in this market will get exactly the same wage. Because such a Classical (idealized)
market for labor is free to adjust, there is ‘no involuntary’ unemployment and everyone who
wants a job at the going wage gets [Link], the only thing that can cause true
unemployment is something that interferes with the adjustments of the free market, such as a
legal minimum wage and other regulations. (Abdulkadir Hamza 2015)
11
keeping real wages constant and thus giving employers no incentive to hire more workers.
Low aggregate demand for goods and services could lead to a vicious cycle of
unemployment, low incomes, and low spending in the economy as a whole. (Abdulkadir Hamza
2015)
The negative correlation between economic growth and unemployment was first stressed by
Okun (1962). Following studies have mostly proposed evidence that is parallel to Okun’s
study. It is possible to group these studies in the literature into two. First group of studies
establishes a symmetrical tie between economic growth and unemployment and the second
group which also includes the recent studies discusses asymmetrical relationship between
unemployment and economic growth. In most of the studies that support asymmetrical
relationship between economic growth and unemployment, the main idea is that economic
growth and unemployment relationship is more intense in the economic downturn periods
compared to economic expansion periods. And he proposed that an negative relationship
existed between real output level and unemployment level in his study in which he used data
obtained from U.S. economy.
Silvapulle et al. (2004) stressed that the effect of economic growth over unemployment was
more significant during the time of economic shrinkage in his study in which he used US
economic databetween 1947 and 1999.
Lee (2000) discussed existence of a strong relationship between economic growth and
unemployment in his study which supported Okun’s law and was conducted for 16 OECD
countries.
Malley and Molana (2008) used quarterly data for G7 countries between the years of 1960
to 2001 and they stated that the relationship between economic growth and unemployment
was more significant in the case of Germany.
Noor, Nor and Judhiana (2007) examined whether there exist an Okun – type relationship
between output and unemployment in the Malaysian economy. The empirical results show
that there was an inverse relationship between output and unemployment
Emeka, Emmanuel and Michael (2016) probed the connection among unemployment rate,
private consumption expenditure and economic growth for Nigerian economy by the use of
annual data from 1980 to [Link] cointegration test outcome indicated a cointegration
12
relation among the variables and empirical findings pointed out a negative relationship.
Besides, Granger causality test results supported a causal impact of economic growth on the
unemployment rate. The issue of unemployment has become a severe challenge for all
African countries, regardless of their different socio-economic development. People often do
not have a choice with regards to their employment due to the lack of available opportunities
and are therefore underemployed, i.e. their job is not their profession or is irrelevant to their
field of study. Ethiopia is the second most populous nation in Africa after Nigeria, and the
fastest growing economy in the region. The economy experienced strong, broad-based
growth averaging 9.9% a year from 1999 to 2009 EC, compared to a regional average of
5.4%. However, it is also one of the poorest, with a per capita income of $790. Despite
reducing the extreme poverty rate from about 46% in 1995 to 23.5% in 2016, Ethiopia still
has more than 25 million people living in poverty. The relationship between economic growth
and unemployment in Ethiopia is multifaceted. While sustained economic growth is crucial
for job creation, the link between GDP expansion and employment generation in the country
is not always direct As evident, the Ethiopian economy has been growing at a remarkable rate
for the last few years. However, it is important to examine how that growth has translated
into more jobs that are of a better quality and are inclusive. The statistical figures show that
more than 70% of Ethiopians are under 30 years of age, with urban youth unemployment
standing at 22% compared to an overall unemployment rate of 17% Challenges such as the
predominance of the agricultural sector, limited diversification into the industrial and service
sectors, and vulnerability to external shocks have influenced the capacity of the economy to
absorb the growing labor force ( Betgilu Oshora1, Tiblets Nguse Maria Fekete-Farkas, Zoltan
Zeman,,2020). Unemployment and Economic growth are intertwined concepts because; the
level of unemployment in an economy may affect the rate of economic growth, and is an
indicator of the state of the economic growth of an economy. In order to sustain economic
growth, high level of unemployment must be minimized (Bean, 1998). Furthermore, this
association between economic growth and unemployment also seen in terms of the required
output of services delivered by employees needed to withstand an economy and to encourage
economic growth. When there is a high level of unemployment, the level of output also drops
due to the reduction in the number of workers contributing to the output. (Abdulkadir Hamza
2015). Hence, taking the above works of literature as a hint and baseline, this study
empirically investigates the relation between unemployment on economic growth in Ethiopia.
13
2.4 Conceptual framework
Economic growth often leads to increased demand for goods and services, which, in turn,
stimulates demand for labor. Expansion in industries such as manufacturing, services, and
technology creates job opportunities and reduces unemployment. During periods of robust
economic growth, businesses tend to hire more workers to meet rising demand, leading to a
decline in the unemployment rate. In the short term, there is an inverse relationship between
economic growth and unemployment, often depicted by the Phillips Curve. As economic
growth accelerates, unemployment tends to decrease due to increased hiring and business
expansion. Conversely, economic downturns or recessions result in reduced economic
activity, leading to layoffs, increased unemployment, and a contraction in job
[Link]-term economic growth can significantly impact the composition of
industries and the nature of employment. Technological advancements and shifts in consumer
preferences may render certain jobs obsolete while creating demand for new skills. Structural
changes in industries can lead to frictional or structural unemployment as workers need to
adapt their skills to match the evolving demands of the job market. In summary, the
independent variable i.e Economic growth in the research is expected to have postive or
negative impact based up on the reviewed literature.
14
3. Methodology
3.1 Research design
This study uses a quantitative research design, utilizing econometric techniques to analyse
time series data on economic growth and unemployment rates in Ethiopia. This paper
investigates the potential causal relationship between unemployment and economic growth,
along with examining the validity of Okun's Law. It also employs descriptive statistics to
overview the trend of unemployment and economic growth.
15
Β2 is the coefficient representing the effect of changes in total investment on unemployment
Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) Test: is used to test for stationarity in both the
dependent and independent variables (∆GDP and ∆Unemployment) to ensure they are
integrated of order one (I(1)) or stationary.
Engle-Granger or Johansen Cointegration Test: help us to determine if there exists
a long-term relationship (cointegration) between ∆GDP and ∆Unemployment.
Cointegration indicates a stable long-term relationship between the variables, which is
essential for Okun's Law
Jarque-Bera test: is an important statistical tool used to assess whether a given
sample of data follows a normal distribution
Lagrange Multiplier (LM): test is a commonly used method for detecting the
presence of autocorrelation in regression models
Lag Selection: To select appropriate lag lengths for the ARDL model this study uses
information criteria (e.g., Akaike Information Criterion - AIC, Schwarz Bayesian
Criterion - SBC).
Stability test: used to ensure that the estimated coefficients and relationships among
the variables in the VAR model are consistent and valid over time
16
4. Analysis and Interpretation
4.1 Introduction
This study uses a two-sided approach to examine the interaction between economic growth
and unemployment in the Ethiopian context. First, it uses descriptive analysis to provide a
comprehensive picture of the historical trends and relationships between these variables. This
is done by using graphs, charts, and tables to visually represent the data and identify
preliminary patterns. Second, the study examines economic analysis in depth to examine the
applicability of the Okun Law for the Ethiopian economy. Okun's Law establishes a negative
and complex relationship between a country's economic growth and the unemployment rate.
Using econometric methods, the study aims to quantify this relationship and to what extent
Okun’s law holds true for Ethiopia. This involves the development of mathematical models
and the use of appropriate economic tests to verify the validity of the hypothesized
relationship.
4.00
3.50
3.00
2.50
2.00
17
The trend of economic growth rate in Ethiopia throughout the study period reveals a pattern
of dynamic fluctuations. The initial phase witnessed a period of increasing growth, followed
by a decline to -2.1% in 1995. This negative growth suggests a period of economic
contraction. However, the trajectory subsequently reversed, with growth rebounding to 11.2%
by the year [Link] subsequent period (until 2007) is characterized by relative stability,
with growth oscillating between 11.4% and 8.7%. This period suggests a phase of moderate
economic expansion. However, a downward trend emerged after 2007, with growth dipping
to 8% in 2008. This could be indicative of a temporary economic slowdown. The following
years (2009-2011) exhibited a pattern of recovery and renewed volatility. Growth rebounded
to 10.1% in 2009, only to decline again to 7.7% in 2010. This highlights the dynamic nature
of economic performance during this timeframe. A subsequent increase to 9% in 2011
suggests a renewed period of expansion. The final years of the data (2012-2014) depict a
gradual downward trend, with growth reaching 6.1% by 2014.
18
Variable Obs Mean Std. Dev. Min Max
The above table shows us that the dependent variable unemployment rate averaged 2.74%
with minimal variation (SD = 0.53%), indicating a consistently low level of unemployment
(ranging from a minimum of 2.25% to a maximum of 3.93%). Whereas the independent
variables:
Real GDP growth exhibited moderate variability (SD = 3.51%) with an average growth rate
of 8.65%. However, the range (-2.10% to 12.60%) indicates periods of both economic
contraction and expansion.
General inflation presented a concerning picture, averaging a high of 13.45% with significant
variation (SD = 11.26%). The inflation rate even dipped into deflation (-10.60%) at times,
while reaching highs of 36.40%.
Total expenditure displayed a high degree of variability (SD = 213,014.30) with an average of
189,541.90, highlighting the substantial spread in expenditure levels across the observations
(ranging from a minimum of 15,786.40 to a maximum of 779,099.00).
19
results in terms of elasticities and helps mitigate the influence of outliers and data
fluctuations.
The results of the Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) test, with all p-values falling below the
0.05 significance level, provide robust evidence for rejecting the null hypothesis of a unit root
in each variable. This signifies the presence of non-stationarity in the level data. However, the
observed stationarity at first difference (order one integration) suggests that differencing the
data once effectively eliminates any trends or persistent effects, rendering the variables
suitable for further statistical analysis.
20
Variable Lag FPE AIC HQIC SBIC
Y t =c + A1 K−1 + A 2 Y t−2 +⋯ A p Y t− P+ e t
Where:
• c is a constant term
The short-run dynamics in a VAR model refer to the immediate responses of the variables to
changes in their own lagged values and the lagged values of other variables. By estimating
the coefficients of the VAR model, researchers can quantify the short-run impact of shocks or
changes in one variable on the other variables in the system.
This analysis of short-run dynamics is particularly useful for understanding the immediate
responses of economic and financial variables to various shocks or policy changes. It
provides insights into the underlying mechanisms and feedback effects that drive the
relationships among the variables in the short run.
21
LUNEM Coefficient Standard error p-value
The significance of a result can be determined by its p-value. If the p-value is less than 5%,
the result is significance and if it is above 5%, it is insignificant. Thus, from the above table,
it is clear that all the variables are significant except for LUNEM (-2), LINF (-1) and
LINF (-2)
22
4.3.4. Diagnostic Tests
Diagnostic tests are used to check for the validity and efficiency of the coefficients as well as
determining whether they could be used for prediction or not.
Stability Test
The stability of the VAR (Vector Autoregression) model is crucial for ensuring reliable and
meaningful analysis. Stability is an important property that needs to be examined when using
VAR models. A stable VAR model ensures that the estimated coefficients and relationships
among the variables are consistent and valid over time. Instability in the VAR model would
imply that the parameter estimates and the inferences drawn from the model are not reliable,
as the underlying relationships may be changing over the sample period.
Eigenvalue Modulus
.9930101 .99301
.5149939 + .3940469i .648453
.5149939 - .3940469i .648453
-.1502253 + .6286591i .646359
-.1502253 - .6286591i .646359
-.1294388 + .3483986i .371667
-.1294388 - .3483986i .371667
.1724418 .172442
Autocorrelation Test
23
Lagrange-multiplier test
1 21.5404 16 0.15866
2 12.8678 16 0.68240
Normality Test
The Jarque-Bera test is used in this study to check for the normality of the distribution. The
Jarque-Bera test is an important statistical tool used to assess whether a given sample of data
follows a normal distribution. This test is particularly relevant in the context of econometric
model, where the assumption of normality is often crucial for the validity of the analysis. The
Jarque-Bera test is based on the skewness and kurtosis of the data, which are measures of the
symmetry and peakedness of the distribution, respectively. Skewness measures the degree of
asymmetry of the distribution, with a value of zero indicating a perfectly symmetric
distribution. Kurtosis, on the other hand, measures the degree of "peakedness" or "flatness" of
the distribution, with a value of 3 indicating a normal distribution.
If the p-value of the Jarque-Bera test is greater than the chosen significance level (e.g., 5%), it
indicates that there is no evidence to reject the null hypothesis, and the data can be considered
to follow a normal distribution. Conversely, if the p-value is less than the significance level, it
suggests that the data does not follow a normal distribution, and the null hypothesis can be
rejected. In this study, the result shows that the error term is normally distributed within the
model, which is an important assumption for the validity of the statistical inferences drawn
from the VAR analysis.
Jarque-Bera test
24
Johansen Test
The Johansen cointegration test is a statistical tool used to determine the presence and rank of
cointegration among multiple time series variables. Cointegration is a crucial concept in
economic analysis, as it refers to a long-term relationship between non-stationary variables,
indicating that they move together in the long run despite having individual trends.
The Johansen cointegration test is particularly valuable in situations where the variables
under investigation may be cointegrated, meaning that they share a common long-term trend.
This is often the case when analysing economic variables that are expected to have a long-run
relationship.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
maximum
rank parms LL Eigenvalue Trace Statistic 5% critical value
0 20 59.58312 - 69.1328 47.21
1 27 79.762905 0.89378 28.7733* 29.68
2 32 90.868878 0.70887 6.5613 15.41
3 35 94.11934 0.30313 0.0604 3.76
4 36 94.149543 0.00335 - -
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the context of the current study, the results of the Johansen test show that there is co-
integration among the variables. Thus, there exists a long-run relationship among the
variables in the study.
25
4.3.4 VECM Estimation (Long-run dynamics)
To obtain the long-run relationship among the variables, the study employed a Vector Error
Correction Model (VECM). The VECM is an extension of the Vector Autoregressive (VAR)
model that incorporates the concept of cointegration, which is crucial for capturing the long-
run equilibrium relationships among non-stationary variables.
The VECM achieves this by incorporating an error correction term, which represents the
deviation from the long-run equilibrium. This term captures the speed at which the system
adjusts back to the long-run relationship when it is temporarily out of equilibrium. The
inclusion of this error correction term is what distinguishes the VECM from the standard
VAR model, which does not explicitly account for cointegration.
Here’s the interpretation of the long run relationship between the dependent variable and the
independent variables based on the above result;
If real GDP growth rate increases by 1%, then unemployment rate decreases by
approximately 0.04%, Ceteris Paribus.
If inflation increases by 1%, then unemployment rate decreases by approximately
0.203%, Ceteris Paribus.
If total expenditure increases by 1%, then the unemployment rate decreases by
approximately 0.09%, Ceteris Paribus. The result also shows that the coefficients of
all the variables are statistically significant at 95% confidence interval.
26
5. Conclusion and Recommendations
5.1 Conclusion
Unemployment constitutes a paramount obstacle to sustainable socio-economic development
in Ethiopia. Its detrimental effects are further exacerbated by a complex interplay of many
other interrelated factors. The objective of this study was to explore the intricate relationship
between unemployment and economic growth, while also assessing the validity of Okun's
Law in Ethiopia, with economic growth serving as the explanatory variable. Utilizing data
spanning from 1992 to 2014 EC, this study employed Vector Error-Correction Model
(VECM) analysis as the primary analytical method. This approach allowed for the capture of
both the short-term dynamics and long-term equilibrium relationships between
unemployment, economic growth, and other macroeconomic variables. Through rigorous
empirical analysis, this study sought to unravel the complexities of Ethiopia's labour market
dynamics and their nexus with broader macroeconomic conditions.
The insights gleaned from the Vector Error-Correction Model (VECM) shed light on the
dynamics of unemployment and its determinants within the Ethiopian context. Consistent
with Okun's Law which assumes an inverse relationship between changes in the
unemployment rate and changes in real GDP. Specifically, Okun postulated that a 1%
increase in unemployment would correspond to a 2% to 3% decrease in real GDP. This
suggests that during periods of economic downturns or recessions, where unemployment
rises, there tends to be a proportional decline in the overall output of goods and services in
the economy., the negative coefficient associated with real GDP (LRGDP) in the VECM
analysis suggests that sustained economic growth holds promise in mitigating unemployment
over the long term. This is because as the economy grows, businesses experience an
expansion in demand for their products and services to meet this increased demand, firms
need to hire more workers, leading to a decline in unemployment levels and generation of
additional income and this additional income generated leads to increased consumer
spending, which in turn creates more jobs in industries catering to this demand. Specifically,
the numerical findings indicate that a 1% increase in real GDP growth corresponds to a
0.04% decrease in the unemployment rate, Ceteris Paribus. Therefore, this nuanced validation
of Okun's Law in Ethiopia suggests that while economic growth does serve as an effective
lever for reducing unemployment, the labor market dynamics are more complex and the
employment-output relationship is not as straightforward as the original theory proposes.
Factors such as structural rigidities, sectoral composition, and institutional characteristics
may be influencing the strength of this link.
27
However, the findings about the relationship between inflation and unemployment differ from
Okun's theoretical postulates. While Okun's Law posits an inverse relationship between
inflation and unemployment, the empirical analysis reveals a contrasting trend within the
Ethiopian context. Specifically, the VECM numerical findings indicate that a 1% increase in
inflation corresponds to a 0.203% decrease in the unemployment rate, Ceteris Paribus. This
discrepancy can be the result of a high prevalence of informal employment, structural
rigidities in the labor market, the impact of rising prices on consumer demand and
production, or other underlying complexities of the Ethiopian labor market and
macroeconomic environment.
5.2 Recommendations
Ethiopia's remarkable economic growth has been a beacon of hope, yet it casts a long shadow
—the persistent challenge of unemployment. As the labor force expan202ds, so does the
urgency to create meaningful job opportunities. Based on the findings of this study, the
following potential remedies can be proposed to alleviate this pressing issue:
28
of the country's human capital and reducing the mismatch between labor supply and
demand.
29
REFERNECES
Abel, A. B., Bernanke, B., and Croushore, D. (2008). Macroeconomics (6th Ed.). Boston,
MA, Pearson-Addison Wesley
Abdulkadir Hamza (2015) Unemployment and economic growth: an empirical analysis for
Ethiopia (1974/75-2013/14)
Adem Feto: Unemployment and Economic Growth Puzzles in Ethiopia: Okun’s Law
Perspective
Cuaresma, J. C. (2003). Okun's law revisited. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics,
65(4), 439-451.
Fuad M, K., 2010. Economic Growth and Unemployment: An Empirical Analysis, Journal of
Social Sciences 7 (2): 228-231, 2011 ISSN 1549-3652
Hjazeen, H., Seraj, M., & Ozdeser, H. (2021). The nexus between economic growth and
unemployment in Jordan. Future Business Journal, 7(1), 42.
Lee, J. (2000). The robustness of Okun’s Law: Evidence from OECD countries. Journal of
Macroeconomics, 22(2), 331-356. [Link]
Malley, J., & Molana, H. (2008). Output, unemployment and Okun's law: Some evidence
from the G7. Economics Letters, 101(2), 113-115.
Michael, E. O., Emeka, A., & Emmanuel, E. N. (2016). The relationship between
unemployment and economic growth in Nigeria: Granger causality approach. Research
Journal of Finance and Accounting, 7(24), 153-162.
Nganwa, Peace, Deribe Assefa, and Paul Mbaka. "The nature and determinants of urban
youth unemployment in Ethiopia." Nature 5.3 (2015): 197-203.
30
Noor, Z. M., Nor, N. M., & Ghani, J. A. (2007). The relationship between output and
unemployment in Malaysia: Does Okun’s law exist. International Journal of Economics and
Management, 1(3), 337-344.
Okun, A. M. (1962). Potential GNP: Its Measurement and Significance, American Statistical
Association, Proceedings of the Business and Economics Statistics Section, 98–104
Raisová, M., & Ďurčová, J. (2014). Economic growth-supply and demand perspective.
Procedia Economics and Finance, 15, 184-191.
Silvapulle, P., Moosa, I. A., & Silvapulle, M. J. (2004). Asymmetry in Okun's law. Canadian
Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d'économique, 37(2), 353-374.
31