SiO2 Aging in Power Devices Analysis
SiO2 Aging in Power Devices Analysis
1
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
N+ Source
N+
Polysilicon
Gate
Channel
P- P-
Gate Oxide
N epi
N+ Substrate
Drain Contact
n+ Cgd
Cs p n+
p Drain-body
2
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
packaging defects (Scroder, 1990; Clemente et al., gate and drain currents are show. It should be noted that
1993; Crook, 1979). The die defects in MOSFETs are subfigures (a) through (d) in Figure 5 are correlated
generally categorized under field distortion defects and with stages 1 through 4 in Figure 6. These figures show
oxide defects. Field distortion defects are a result of the the effect of parasitic capacitance on the characaristic
electric field in the MOSFET getting distorted. This waveforms of the device.
distortion is caused when a high voltage is applied to
the device in presence of polar molecules. A polar
molecule is such that one end of the molecule is
positively charged and the other end is negatively
charged (e.g., water and atmospheric ionic
contaminants). Oxide defects are the second most
common failures associated with die defects. Defects in
the MOSFET’s layer of gate oxide can cause failures
such as short-circuiting from gate to source. These
defects are often caused by thermal damage due to
thermal cycling, which in turn leads to more trap
generation. These traps cause more conduction and
eventually the short-circuiting.
The die packaging defects fall under several
categories: die attach damage, wire bond fatigue, and
metal corrosion. Die attach defects are caused by
thermal differentials created between the die and the
headers of the MOSFET devices. The ultimate result is
creation of voids and cracks in the die attach region
leading to degradation in the on resistance and thermal
resistance of the device. Wire bond fatigue is also
thermally induced and results in the separation of the Figure 5: Capacitance interaction during switch-on
wire bond of the MOSFET device. Finally, metal
corrosion occurs due to intrusion of water particles into
the device packaging through the atmosphere.
Naturally, introduction of water in the metallic
contact area leads to corrosion and that eventually
results in device degradation in the form of on-state
resistance shift.
3. SWITCHING PROCESS
Figure 5 shows how the different parasitic capacitances
influence the switching turn-on process (Mohan, et. al).
The subfigures (a) through (d) show the equivalent
circuit for the MOSFET to estimate the characteristic
voltage and current in the device as the switching
process progresses. Figure 5 (a) and (b) show how the
power transistor begins to switch with the current
initially circulating by the freewheeling diode DF. Figure 6: Effects of parasitic capacitance as a function
During these stages, the influence of Cgd (gate-to- of time
drain) and Cd (drain-to-source) with RG, the gate
resistance, is very important. In the final stages shown Given the influences of internal parasitic elements
as (c) and (d) RDS, drain-to-source resistance, together of power semiconductors, it is then important to
with Cgd defines the process. classify the effects of aging in these parasitic elements.
Figure 6 summarizes the influences of the Figure 7 shows a schematic of how aging can be
capacitances in the switching time during on-state and represented in changes of parasitic capacitance over
how the variation in the values of the parasitic time. Figure 7 shows the model of the power MOSFET
parameters will affect the time spent in the different with the relevant parasitic elements during switch on
stages. The gate drive voltage signal is a step response process. The (a) thorugh (d) subfigures show the model
whereas the other gate to source voltage (VGS) and simplification by lumping the components together.
Increasing the power losses during switching can be
3
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
(b)
L(T ) = AF ⋅ e kT
(3)
(a)
D D
RDS ON
The acceleration factor, AF, is determined generally
RDS ON
from the Arrhenius model:
G G
E 1 1
CG AF = exp a −
(4)
S S RG k T1 T2
D.L Crook (Crook, 1979) proposed the following
expression in the case of two acceleration factors
(c) (d) (temperature and voltage):
Figure 7: Power device simplified circuit aging
E 1 1 E − E1
4. POWER DEVICE RELIABILITY
AF = exp a − ⋅ exp − 2 (5)
k T1 T2 E c
The previous section highlights some of the common where:
and widely accepted reliability issues presented with
Ec has been experimentally (Crook) been
the design and operation of MOSFET/IGBT power
devices. In this section, traditional semiconductor
shown to equal 0.062 MV/cm.
Equation 6 shows the Power Law that is used
reliability concepts are related to remaining life
commonly in determining the life expectancy of power
estimation.
devices based on the data presented in (Pearce et al.)
From a reliability engineering point of view, the
Several manufacturers use gate voltages and
failure rates caused by factors described in the previous
temperatures for aging estimation. Based on the data
section have to be addressed and taken into
(Pearce et al.) the values for the IRF4XX series are
consideration.
computed to be A=-17.2, B=0.4, C=-0.15 and the
The mean time to failure (MTTF) is usually defined
respective curves are shown in Figure 8.
by the inverse of the failure rate of devices:
MTTF =
1
(1) AF = A * 10CT * 10B*VG + a (6)
λ
where λ is the failure rate. The thermal activation energy of a failure
A failure rate (λ) could be estimated by mechanism is determined by testing at a minimum of
1 two different temperature stress levels as is shown in
λ∝ (2) Figure 8. Figure 8 shows the power MOSFET life
TDH * AF expectancy using Power Law shown in equation 6. It
can be seen that the life expectancy of MOSFET
4
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
devices changes with the varying bias voltages and are the aged devices resulting in a drop of collector-emitter
uniformly changing as the operating temperature ON voltage.
changes. In lab testing and field operations, it has been
shown that device’s failure gets accelerated when 14
Power MOSFET Life Expectancy
10
operated in higher temperature regions.
4V
12
10
8V
10
10
12V
8
10
Hours
16V
6
10
20V
4
10
24V
2
10
0
10
50 100 150 200 250 300
Temperature(Celsius)
5
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
6
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
7
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
350
300
250
Temperature (C)
200
150
100
50
0
3 5 7 9 40 44 45 47 49 56 57 58 60 65
Time (Minutes)
Figure 15: Temperature stress profile
1.25
Pre-aging
Post-aging
1.00
Capacitance
0.75
0.50
Figure 13: Migration of trap charges and capacitance
variation at year 10 with 100oC and VG =8V 0.25
-4 -2 0 2 4
Gate Voltage V
7. CONCLUSION
Analytical and numerical relationships between the
semiconductor physics-based behavior and stress
factors through capacitance shifting was presented.
This work successfully modeled the capacitance and
the subsequent changing due to device aging. The
combination of the aging stress voltages and
temperature produces shifting in the impurities of oxide
that modifies the relationship of the gate capacitance
value and the gate voltages, resulting in a good
indicator of device aging. As mentioned previously,
Figure 14: Migration of trap charges and capacitance
variation at year 30 with 100oC and VG =8V
8
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
future work will also include the trap charge generation devices”, Microelectronics Reliability, Vol. 44, pp.
phenomenon in the modeling and validation. 1-23. 2004.
Feinberg, A.A., Ersland, P., Kaper, V., and Widom, A.,
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
“On aging of key transistor device parameters,” in
The authors would like to acknowledge and appreciate Proc. Inst. Environmental Sciences &Technology,
the help extended for this work by Nishad Patil. 2000, pp. 231–236.
Feinberg, A.A., Widom, A., “On Thermodynamic
NOMENCLATURE Reliability Engineering.” IEEE TRANSACTIONS
L(T) life under thermal conditions ON RELIABILITY, VOL. 49, NO. 2, JUNE 2000.
A, B experimental constant Scroder, D.K., “Semiconductor Material and Device
C, D experimental constant Characterization”, John Wiley and Sons, New
E activation energy York, 1990.
T temperature in Kelvin Ginart, A., Brown, D., Kalgren, P.W., Roemer, M.J.,
k Boltzmann’s constant 8.6171.10-5 eV /oC “On-line Ringing Characterization as a PHM
Si02 Silicon dioxide Technique for Power Drives and Electrical
dt time step Machinery,” Autotestcon, 2007 IEEE. 7-20 Sept.
f, g generic functions 2007 pp 654 – 659.
I current Katsis, D.C., “Thermal Characterization of Die-Attach
NA total number of acceptor atoms/cm3 Degradation in the Power MOSFET” PhD thesis
q magnitude of the electron charge (1.6 x 10-19 Virginia Polytechnic Institute. 2003.
coul) Katsis, D.C. ,van Wyk, J.D., “Void-induced thermal
V Voltage impedance in power semiconductor modules: some
ΦS Potential in the silicon transient temperature effects” IEEE Transactions
Φox Potential in the Si02 on Industry Applications, Sept.-Oct. 2003,Vol.39,
AF Acceleration Factor No 5,pp.1239- 1246.
Co Capacitance Value @ VG=0 Leblebici, Y., Kang, S.M., “Hot-Carrier Reliability of
MOS VLSI Circuits”, Kluwer Academic
VG Gate Voltage
Publishers, Massachusetts, 1993.
Mohan, N., Undeland, T.M., Robbins, W.P., “Power
REFERENCES Electronics-Converters, Applications, and Design”,
John Wiley, Inc., USA, 2003.
Celaya, J. R., Patil, N., Saha, S., Wysocki, P., &
Patil, N., Celaya, J., Das, D., Goebel, K., & Pecht, M. .
Goebel, K. "Towards Accelerated Aging
Precursor Parameter Identification for Insulated
Methodologies and Health Management of Power
Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT) Prognostics.
MOSFETs (Technical Brief)". Paper presented at
Reliability, IEEE Transactions on, 58(2), 271-276.
the Annual Conference of the Prognostics and
Pearce, R., Brown, S., and Grant, D., “Measuring
Health Management Society 2009, San Diego, CA.
HEXFET characteristics,” HEXFET Power
Clemente, S., Pelly, B.R., Isidori, A., "Understanding
MOSFETs Designer Manual Application notes and
HEXFET Switching. Performance," HEXFET
reliability Data . International Rectifier 1993 Vol. I
Power MOSFETs Designer Manual Application
Application Note. 957B.
notes and reliability Data . International Rectifier
Pierret, R.F., “Semiconductor Device Fundamentals”,
1993 Vol. I Application Note 947.
Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, New York,
Clemente, S., Teasdale, K., "Understanding and Using
1996.
Power MOSFET Reliability Data," HEXFET
Saha, B., Celaya, J. R., Wysocki, P. F., & Goebel, K. F.
Power MOSFETs Designer Manual Application
(2009, 7-14 March 2009). Towards prognostics for
notes and reliability Data . International Rectifier
electronics components. Paper presented at the
1993 Vol. I Application Note 976A.
Aerospace conference, 2009 IEEE.
Crook, D.L., “Method of Determining Reliability
Sonnenfeld, G., Goebel, K., & Celaya, J. R. (2008, 8-11
screen for Time Dependant Dielectric Breakdown”
Sept. 2008). An agile accelerated aging,
Proceeding, reliability symposium, pp.1-7, 1979.
characterization and scenario simulation system for
Kerr, D. R., Logan, J.S., Burkhardt, P.J., and Pliskin,
gate controlled power transistors. Paper presented
W.A., “Stabilization of SiO2 pasivation layers with
at the AUTOTESTCON, 2008 IEEE.
P2O5,” IBM Journal of research & Development,”
Srinivasan, P., “Reliability of Solder Die Attaches for
8,376, 1964.
High Power Application,” Masters Thesis, Dept.
Miranda, E. and Sune, J. , “Electron transport through
Mech. Eng., Univ. Maryland, College Park, MD,
broken down ultra-thin SiO2 layers in MOS
2000.
9
Annual Conference of the Prognostics and Health Management Society, 2010
Wu, W., Gao, G., Dong, L., Wang, Z., Held, M., Jacob,
P., Scacco, P., “Thermal Reliability of Power Insulated
Gate Bipolar Transistor IGBT Modules,” 12thAnnual
IEEE Semiconductor Thermal Measurement and
Management Symposium, 1996.
10