Advances in Childhood UTIs Management
Advances in Childhood UTIs Management
Diagnosis of UTI
Although bacterial infection is the
most common cause of dysuria,
there are many other potential diag-
noses, which are beyond the scope
of this article. It has been docu-
mented that bacterial colony counts
of 100/mL or less can cause dysuria
in adult women, which makes initial
cultures unnecessary in those who
have typical cystitis because the
woman usually is well before cul-
ture results are known. In contrast, a
positive culture in children deter-
mines whether a radiologic evalua-
tion is necessary. Fortunately, it has
been established that 80% of infants
and children who have catheter-
proven UTIs have bacterial colony
counts of 105/mL or greater (see
Pylkkanen et al in Suggested
Reading).
FIGURE 1. Pili on Escherichia coli are seen on electron microscopy as straight The method of collecting the
white extracellular markings on a dark-stained background. urine specimen in children is very
important in distinguishing contami-
nants from low-colony count infec-
ularly if they are younger than Taken together, these two studies tions. Although urinary collection
5 years of age. The mode of inheri- suggest that early identification of bags may be convenient for urinaly-
tance is unclear, but it seems advis- VUR and long-term prophylaxis can sis and determination of specific
able to screen such families by pre- prevent development of new scars. gravity, they are not suitable for
natal ultrasonography. In a similar long-term study from culture. Instead, a catheterized speci-
Stockholm, Sweden, 30 patients men or suprapubic puncture is
were followed for a mean of needed. A clean-void specimen is
Long-term Outcome of 27 years after childhood pyelone- adequate in toilet-trained children
Childhood UTI phritis. A total of 53 patients who unless the child is to be hospitalized
had nonobstructive scarring were for intravenous therapy. In that case,
To understand the need for uncom- identified from 1,000 intravenous a catheterized specimen will prevent
fortable radiologic studies among later diagnostic confusion. Two col-
pyelograms performed in children
children at risk of renal scarring, it
between 1951 and 1967. Thirty of
is necessary to examine the natural
these patients agreed to be evaluated
history of pyelonephritis. Until this TABLE 1. Definition
decade, such information was for glomerular filtration rate (GFR)
and blood pressure. Three of the 30 of Terms
unavailable. The most convincing
data on prevention of renal scarring had end-stage renal disease, seven ● UTI: Cystitis, urethritis,
by early diagnosis and treatment had undergone renal surgery, seven pyelitis, and pyelonephritis
comes from Dr Jean Smellie, who had treated hypertension, and all had
significantly depressed GFR. Marti-
● Urethritis: Dysuria, frequency,
has published 30-year studies from or enuresis with pyuria, but
Great Ormond Street Hospital in nell et al showed good preservation
of renal function when girls who colony count of ,104/mL of
London. Intravenous pyelography urine
documented no new renal scars in had renal scars received close super-
adults 18 to 39 years of age whom vision to prevent UTIs over a ● Cystitis: Dysuria 6 frequency
she had treated as children with 15-year period. with colony count of .104/mL
antibiotic prophylaxis for UTI and Women who have VUR or renal of urine. Hematuria may be
VUR. She also reviewed the charts scars should receive prophylaxis present, but no casts, flank
of 52 children who were identified during pregnancy, a time when UTIs pain, fever, or systemic
as having severe bilateral VUR and may recur. Pre-eclampsia and hyper- toxicity are seen
renal scarring. Virtually all of these tension occur at a higher rate among ● Pyelonephritis: Febrile UTI,
children had had either untreated those who have elevated creatinine. often with flank and
febrile pyelonephritis for more than It is suggested that adolescents who abdominal pain and cystitis.
5 days or an inadequate radiologic have VUR and elevated creatinine The colony count may be
evaluation (no cystogram or no eval- levels undergo surgical correction of ,105/mL of urine
uation at all until a recurrence). VUR before pregnancy.
FIGURE 2. Algorithm for diagnosing and treating UTIs in children younger than 13 years.
lection options are available for chil- plasia or neurogenic bladders that missing 15% of UTIs. The positive
dren who have cystitis: obtain two are colonized chronically may predictive value of a positive dip-
clean-void urines before treatment require an isotopic renal scan for stick test for nitrites or leukocyte
(usually impractical) or obtain one accurate diagnosis of UTI (see sec- esterase is much lower at 34%,
specimen and delay treatment until tion on Radiology). although the nitrite test has an
results are known. In practice, many After a child has been found to excellent specificity for UTI that
clinicians treat any child who has be afebrile and without flank pain or approaches 100%.
positive findings on urinalysis after toxicity, the urinalysis is the best Infants younger than 3 years of
obtaining only one specimen. tool to determine if outpatient ther- age who have fever of unknown
Table 1 defines the terms cur- apy should be started or withheld origin are an important group to
rently used in classifying UTIs. The pending culture results. Microscopic screen by urinalysis and urine cul-
algorithm in Figure 2 initially cate- examination of unspun urine in a ture. Results of a recent survey con-
gorizes children as having clinical hemacytometer is a simple, rapid, ducted by the American Academy of
symptoms of pyelonephritis or and practical diagnostic method. Its Pediatrics (AAP) documented that
symptoms suggesting less serious use was described in children in urine cultures were obtained in only
infections. Despite many excellent 1982, and it was combined with a 50% of febrile infants in this age
studies, no diagnostic test except the Gram stain in 1993 and called an group, with 12% of such cultures
radionuclide renal scan has been “enhanced urinalysis.” The positive being positive. A study of infants
shown to distinguish cystitis conclu- predictive value of a white blood younger than 1 year of age who had
sively from pyelonephritis. The pres- cell count of at least 10 x 109/L temperatures of 38.3°C or greater
ence of fever in a child who has (.10 x 103/mcL) and any bacteria (Ä100.9°F) demonstrated an inci-
bacteruria and pyuria is as effective on Gram stain of urine is 93% for a dence of UTI of 8.8% in females
in identifying pyelonephritis as an UTI, which would allow immediate and 2.5% in males. It is prudent to
elevated erythrocyte sedimentation initiation of treatment. However, the obtain cultures for all children
rate or serum C-reactive protein sensitivity of “enhanced urinalysis” younger than 3 years of age who
concentration or leukocytosis. How- is only 84.5%, indicating that urine have fever of unknown origin, even
ever, patients who have myelodys- cultures should be obtained to avoid if the urinalysis is negative.
In conclusion, urine cultures is whether it is safe to send home develop symptomatic UTIs, there is
should be obtained in all children febrile patients who have UTI. Only no value to identifying or treating
who have dysuria, frequency, hema- one study has examined this ques- them while they are asymptomatic.
turia, or recent onset of enuresis or tion systematically, although some In fact, treatment causes emergence
who are younger than 3 years of age managed care companies are behav- of resistant strains of bacteria. It is
and have unexplained fever. Urinal- ing as if it were a settled issue. It is best not to look for asymptomatic
ysis by dipstick and the “enhanced incorrect to state that febrile chil- bacteriuria in the first place because
urinalysis” both are helpful in decid- dren who have only mild systemic it takes a strong will not to treat a
ing whether to begin antibiotics symptoms have a “UTI” and not “positive” culture!
immediately. Most importantly, a “pyelonephritis.” All febrile children
catheterized or suprapubic aspiration who have UTIs have the potential
urine specimen should be obtained for renal scarring if mismanaged Prophylaxis of UTIs
from all children before initiating and, therefore, deserve close VUR is an indication for long-term
intravenous antibiotics. follow-up by parental report and by antibiotic prophylaxis. Children
urine culture if they are sent home awaiting a radiologic evaluation
on oral therapy. Furthermore, our should be assumed to have VUR
Treatment of UTIs experience has been that a single and receive prophylaxis temporarily.
Table 2 summarizes how results of a intramuscular (or intravenous) dose Children who have recurrent UTIs
Gram stain of the urine can aid in of ceftriaxone followed by oral ther- either can receive 6 months of pro-
selecting a single antibiotic for ini- apy for 10 days will prevent later phylaxis or be instructed in the use
tial inpatient treatment of pyelone- admissions because vomiting on the of daily nitrite test strips on a first
phritis. Except in geographic areas first day may prevent absorption of morning urine. Dipsticks cost $15
that have a high level of aminogly- oral antibiotics. The algorithm (Fig. per month compared with $2 to $4
coside resistance, two drugs should 2) recommends that children who per month for low-dose prophylaxis.
not be needed. Inexpensive generic are younger than 1 year, vomiting, A third indication for prophylaxis is
drugs such as amoxicillin, or likely to be noncompliant (many a single episode of pyelonephritis in
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, or adolescents) be admitted for intrave- infants younger than 1 year of age.
nitrofurantoin are the preferred ther- nous antibiotic therapy until afebrile A neurogenic bladder that is being
apy for cystitis, although resistance for 24 hours. All children treated on managed with clean intermittent
of E coli to amoxicillin in some an outpatient basis should return at catheterization is not an indication
areas makes the other two drugs 24 hours for reassessment and to for prophylaxis because such ther-
preferable. A 10-day course is rec- obtain a second urine specimen. apy usually is not successful.
ommended for presumed cystitis Pyuria and hematuria may persist The drugs of choice for prophy-
unless the child is known to have no for several days, but motile rods laxis are shown in Table 3 and are
radiologic abnormalities. If the child should be absent, and the culture limited to those that do not select
has a normal radiologic evaluation should be sterile. At this time, a resistant fecal flora. There is longer
and is plagued by recurrent cystitis, prescription should be provided for experience with trimethoprim-
3-day therapy with trimethoprim- a prophylactic antibiotic to start sulfamethoxazole and nitrofurantoin,
sulfamethoxazole (8 mg/kg per day after 10 days, with enough drug to but a Danish study found trimetho-
divided in two doses) is an inexpen- last until VUR can be ruled out. prim alone to be equally effective in
sive option. Beta-lactams such as Renal ultrasonography and cystogra- children who had no urologic abnor-
amoxicillin and cephalosporins are phy should be performed as soon as malities. Theoretically this approach
not recommended for short-course practical (see section on Radiologic should cause fewer side effects
therapy or for the outpatient man- Studies). without the sulfa component, but
agement of febrile patients because Several prospective studies have this agent is not available as a
of high failure rates. shown that although children who suspension.
The central treatment controversy have asymptomatic bacteriuria often “Double prophylaxis” has been
recommended in one study for girls were diagnosed prenatally and cor- 5 years of age and younger receive
who experience breakthrough infec- rected in the immediate postnatal ultrasonography and cystography as
tion while receiving a single agent. period. The significant finding is soon as possible after the first UTI.
This should be the last resort, how- that up to the sixth birthday, uro- Because afebrile children younger
ever, because it would be difficult to logic problems were common in than age 5 years have an increased
ascribe an allergic reaction to either children of both genders. risk of renal scarring compared with
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole or Figure 4 demonstrates that 33% older afebrile children, we also rec-
nitrofurantoin. of febrile children 5 years of age ommend imaging of these children,
and younger had treatable abnormal- but with less insistence. The mothers
ities compared with 9.6% of afebrile of these children frequently have
Radiologic Studies children of the same age. Among had cystitis that did not require
Recommended After UTIs children age 6 years and older, with radiographic evaluation, and they
Tremendous strides have been made or without fever, 6% to 12.5% had often are opposed to imaging studies
in improving the comfort, safety, abnormalities. Based on these find- unless the pediatrician counsels
and clinical value of radiologic eval- ings, we recommend that children wisely. All boys and all children
uations of UTIs in the past decade.
An excellent, detailed review of this
subject has been published (see
Auringer in Suggested Reading).
This article will cover only those
studies most useful in children.
Parents often ask about the likeli-
hood of finding a treatable problem
with radiologic studies. In 1975, 215
children between 3 months and 13
years of age were studied in a non-
referral setting by using renal ultra-
sonography accompanied by voiding
cystography. In the first 64 children
enrolled, intravenous pyelography
also was performed, but it did not
detect any problems that were not
seen on renal ultrasonography. Sev-
eral other studies found the same
results, and intravenous pyelography
no longer is recommended for initial
evaluation in children. Figure 3
shows the age and gender distribu-
tion of children who had UTI, which
was similar to data from studies per-
formed in Sweden. The most com- FIGURE 3. Age, gender, and number of children who had abnormalities among 215
mon treatable problem was VUR cases of UTI from 1979 to 1990 (Metro Health Medical Center, Cleveland, Ohio,
because obstructive lesions usually unpublished data).
TABLE 4. Radionuclide
Scans
Renal scans for UTIs
● Glucoheptonate-Tc-99m scan
urologist. Children who have grade appeared, they proceed to surgery. Conclusion
III, IV, or V reflux (“dilating An endoscopic injection of Teflon® UTIs remain a common problem in
reflux”) also deserve a referral, particles rapidly is replacing the childhood. It has been documented
unless the primary care provider is reimplantation of ureters by an that 7.8% of girls and 1.6% of boys
experienced with this condition. Pro- abdominal route. The best news have had one or more UTIs by age
phylaxis should be continued indefi- about VUR comes from a 1998
nitely in children who have VUR, 7 years in Sweden. However, we
study in Sweden of 231 children now know to concentrate radiologic
and blood pressure and creatinine followed prospectively. Only 21
measured annually in addition to evaluations on children 5 years of
required surgery, and 75% of the age and younger who have fever or
ultrasonography or radionuclide cys- remainder were free of VUR after
tography. If breakthrough infection flank pain. We also know that
10 years of prophylaxis (see Wen- although one third of these children
occurs, most urologists repeat a
nerstrom et al in Suggested have VUR, fewer than 10% ever
renal scan or intravenous pyelogra-
Reading). will need surgery. The remainder
phy, and if new scars have
FIGURE 6. An algorithm for radiologic evaluation of a child who has a UTI. * Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (1 to 2 mg/kg
per day at bedtime). From Johnson CE. Dysuria. In: Kliegman RM, Nieder M, Super D, Fletcher J. Practical Strategies in
Pediatric Diagnosis & Therapy. Philadelphia, Penn: WB Saunders; 1996.