Understanding Indirect Categories in Procurement
Understanding Indirect Categories in Procurement
OVERVIEW
HELPING LEADING ENTERPRISES WORLDWIDE ACHIEVE EXTRAORDINARY RESULTS
STRATEGY | SOFTWARE | MANAGED SERVICES Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved.
1
AGENDA
Category that falls under all goods and services for a business that enable its activity, and those are
not directly incorporated into a product being manufactured.
Category that is indirect for one company may be direct for another. Furthermore, segmenting direct
and indirect spend can be very difficult, particularly for service companies.
Buyer Power
▪Number of buyers
▪Quality of service
▪Negotiation power
Provides a deeper insight into the Supply Market Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 9
Pricing Mechanisms
• Cost Plus
• Fixed Pricing
• Index Based
• Performance Based
• Rebate
Facility Management, Maintenance Services, Engineering Services, Industrial Supplies, Environment &
MRO & CAPEX $12.1 B Safety, Co-manufacturing, Fabrication, Manufacturing and Other Equipment, PVF, PTB, HVAC, and Other
MRO Supplies
FTL, LTL, Intermodal, Ocean Freight, Air Freight, Express Mail, Small Packages, 3PL / Warehouse, Fleet
Logistics $10.9 B Management, Others
General & Admin Temp Staffing, Office Supplies, HR & Benefits, Professional Services, Facilities & Real Estate, Fleet
$17.8 B
Services Relocation, Air Travel, Hotels, Rental Cars
Corrugated, Pallets, Stretch / Shrink Wrap, Plastic Bottles, Poly Bags, Folding Cartons, Labels, Glass Jars
Packaging $5.2 B / Caps, Others
Market Research, Media Production, Media Buying, Print & Promotion, Creative Services, FSI, Website
Marketing $6.7 B Development, Comps, Displays
IT & Telecom $10.5 B IT Hardware, Software, IT Maintenance & Support, IT Consulting, IT Outsourcing, Telecom Hardware
Telecom Data & Voice Services
Raw Material & Chemicals, Metals, Plastics, Food Ingredients, Coal, Energy, Textiles, Electronics, Sub-components,
$10.8 B
Direct Finished Goods, Others
*Partial list More than $74 billion in spend annually Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 12
•Some Indirect Categories
Supplier list:
•Allegis (US): the largest temporary
staffing agency in the US with 6.2%
market share;
• Adecco (Switzerland): makes up 3.5% of The Future:
the market share and as a result is the • The temporary labour market is predicted to experience continuing
second largest agency in the US; strong growth during 2017 as a result of increasing demand for
•Randstad Holding (Netherlands): a flexible working arrangements. According to research by Oxford
Dutch staffing company that makes up Economics and Success Factors, 83% of executives plan to increase
Procurement impact:
3.3% of the market in the US. their use of contingent staffing until 2019.
• Price increases are expected to be above the standard inflation rate, • Utilizing recruitment process
as increasing salaries in emerging markets place increasing upward outsourcing will considerably reduce
pressure on temporary labour salaries. As such, buyers expect costs for hiring temporary staff.
savings to diminish in 2017.
Demand for temporary staff will rise dramatically as attitudes to temporary work improve, and more
skilled roles are filled on a temporary basis Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 14
Indirect Categories: Temporary Staff cont.
SWITCHING COSTS
• The key drivers of switching costs are order
process complexity and the number of
employees with responsibility for ordering.
• Switching cost depend upon demand.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
• The failed merger between Staples and Office Depot, the market’s two largest suppliers, will affect the competitive nature of the
market and likely ensure prices remain low.
• Prices changes are expected to be slight between 2016 and 2017: less than 1%. Cost Drivers
The average small to mid-size company spends £19,600 a year on office supplies, or 1.6% of its total expenses
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 16
Indirect Categories: Office Supplies cont.
Globally the prices for the telecom category are expected to fall by an average of 2.6%
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 18
Indirect Categories: Mobile Telecom cont.
Globally the prices for the digital marketing category are expected to fall by an average of 0.2% Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 20
Indirect Categories: Digital Marketing cont.
SWITCHING COSTS
Switching supplier may involve using new software packages and IT platforms, which could require
additional staff training hence switching costs are HIGHER.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
•The 3PL market is predicted to grow in conjunction with the continuing global economic recovery and
increasing world trade levels; WTO economists expect world trade to grow by 5.3% in 2015
•Supplier power will rise as demand outpaces available transportation (mainly overland) capacity. This is
the result of ongoing issues regarding infrastructural limitations and a global driver shortage
• 3PL revenue will be increasingly generated in emerging markets over more mature developed markets:
Fixed pricing arrangements are the most commonly used in 3PL relationships. Globally the prices for the
3PL are expected to rise by an average of 2.1% Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 22
Indirect Categories: Third Party Logistics cont.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
• Increased warehousing wages are putting pressure on warehouse pricing. Despite this, buyers
are expecting global price decreases of 2.3%. However, in the US, significant price increases are
forecast.
• E-retailing is expected to take a larger share of global shopping and could bring an inflow of
public storage-type corporate contracts.
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 24
Indirect Categories: Warehousing Cont.
Variable Operating
● Full Unit ● Benchmark productivity of labor (packers, forklift drivers, VAS personnel,
45% security). Increased productivity can reduce total costs with same labor rates.
Handling Productivity
● Case Pick ● Combine positions where possible
● Eliminate “non value-add“ activities
Other Variable
● Shuttle Rate
10%
● Damage case
handling ● Labor is major cost component. Benchmark to align with local wage market and
Variable Costs renegotiate if significant downturn opportunity arises. Re-adjust wages every 2-
Wage Rates & Benefits
(60%) Special Handling 3 years to avoid inflated tenured wages
● Repacking
3%
● Labeling
● Expect multiple rounds of intense negotiation
● Lock in T&Cs prior to rate negotiations. Share contract boilerplate ASAP in bid to
uncover red flags.
Warehouse Supplies 2% Negotiations
● Get visibility into hidden “mgmt fees”. Separate cost item.
● Establish and contract performance metrics/SLAs
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 26
Maintenance Repair & Overhaul (MRO) – Category
Tree
MRO
• Bearing - general Hydraulics • Air Filters • Oils • Conveyor Parts • Welding / Supplies
• • Nuts
• Fans • Plastic &Rubber products
• Bearing - special • Pneumatics • Water Filters • Greases • Belts
• Bolts • Cleaning utensils
• Valves
• Airbearings • Clamps • Oil Filters • Lubricants • Screws • Tape
• Compressors
• Belts (non-conveyor) • Hoses • Media Paper • Chemicals • Adhesives / Seals
• Pins
• Heat Exchangers
• Gearboxes • Coolants • Janitorial
• Fittings • Telltales • Grommets
• Brushes
• Reducers • Lube Equip • Process Filters • Glycol
• Packaging supplies
• Couplings/Pulleys • Gages • Product filters • Spray equipment
• Rings • Valves • Process filters • Absorbents
• Gear Motors • Paint
• Tubing • Baghouse filters
• Electric Motors • Hand Tools
• Seals/Bushings
• Circuit Boards
• Valves • Safety products • Electric Pumps •Sand • Batteries
• Controllers
•Electronics • Safety equipment • Centrifugal Pumps •Gravel • Tires
• Transformers • Fittings — pipe
•Instrumentation • Fire equipment • Pneumatic Pumps •Lumber
• Lamps • Pipe — steel • Spark Plugs
• Pump Kits
• Adaptors •Process Controls • Respirators •Paints • Motor Oil
• Pipe — composite
• Wire / Conduit • Ear protection •Structural Mat. • Fork Lift repair parts
• Pipe — plastic
• Fuses • Gloves •Structural Steel • Hoses
• Pipe — nonferrous
• Circuit Breakers • First-aid supplies •Landscaping supplies
• Plumbing
• Switches
• Safety clothes
• Junction Boxes • Strainers
• Detection devices/alarms
• Relays
• Lighting Fixtures • Hard hats
Globally the prices for engineering services category is expected to increase by an average of 1.8%
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 28
Indirect Categories: MRO - Engineering Services
cont.
✓ Choose Preferred Suppliers - Minimize “maverick spend” by negotiating contracts with key suppliers in each of the top
expenditure areas. By pooling the smaller spends into a fund with fewer suppliers, you will gain increased leverage on pricing.
✓ Focus on and influence key executives - Using the data that you do have on indirect spend, prioritize areas of the
largest spends, grow expertise in those areas, and build relationships with the key executives in order to gain greater insight and be more
deeply involved in their purchase processes.
✓ Manage with Automation and Measurement - The volume of transactions and diversity of suppliers make
indirect spend an ideal area to manage through collaboration tools. Look for a solution that provides a variety of ways to connect (web,
EDI, SFTP), integrates with a variety of back office systems, allows closed loop procure-to-pay in order to minimize manual processes, and
provides metrics on spend.
✓ Set KPIs - While measuring and scoring indirect suppliers may be more challenging due to the variety of supplies and types of
vendors, suggest that there are some general KPIs that can work across a variety of vendors: contract compliance, customer satisfaction,
and cost competitiveness and continuous improvement.
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 33
Tactics to Control Indirect Spend
The tactics, used individually or collectively, can assist a company in managing and controlling
its indirect spend. Some of the tactics are:
• Zero-Based Budgeting
• Pre-Budget Savings
• Supplier Managed E-Catalogs
• Outsourcing Indirect Spend
One in four category managers will look to increase the proportion of outsourced spend
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 37
Our humble view
Thank You Clark, NJ | Toronto | Dublin | London | Frankfurt | Prague | Mumbai | Hyderabad | Shanghai | Mexico City
Costa Rica | São Paulo | Singapore | Sydney
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved.
41
Additional Examples
For Indirect Category
Procurement impact:
Supplier list: The Future: • Demand management - Buyers can reduce energy consumption,
particularly during peak demand periods. Energy management
• Yingly Solar (China): sells solar modules across Europe, Asia and • Improvements in electricity storage systems mean suppliers are becoming less consultants can be brought in to help implement energy-saving
the US; reliant on costly methods of meeting peak demand. It will also reduce the strain initiatives.
on the grid brought about by the intermittent nature of renewable electricity • Data mining - The implementation of an energy management system
• Vestas Wind Systems (Denmark): the largest maker of wind
generation. (EMS) can lead to a cost reduction of 10%-15%. An EMS monitors and
turbines.
• Relatively modest price increases are expected in electricity. Indeed, buyers in controls electricity consumption according to real-time pricing and
western Europe are anticipating prices to decline. temperature, as well as other factors.
Although companies have continued pursuing renewable energy targets, more governments may scrap their targets Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 43
Indirect Categories: Renewable Energy (Electricity)
cont.
Training will become increasingly sought-after as employers struggle to find staff with adequate skills,
knowledge and experience. Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 45
Indirect Categories: Training cont.
SWITCHING COSTS:
Although there is no benchmark amount for an agency to
charge, considering the inherent goodwill and learnings
amassed through an extended PR relationship, it is
reasonable to assume switching costs will arise (depending
on contract type).
FUTURE OUTLOOK:
PR firms will face greater demand for pricing to be based on
deliverables. Return on investment and measurable results
will be incorporated into more contracts than ever, with
buyers wanting better alignment of expectations with PR
agencies.
Shifts in social behavior will heavily dictate the ways PR is approached Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 47
Indirect Categories: PR cont.
Near-shore locations and crowdsourcing will threaten the Indian development powerhouses Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 49
Indirect Categories: Software Development cont.
SWITCHING COSTS
Switching costs are generally low
FUTURE OUTLOOK
SWITCHING COSTS
• Switching datacenter or cloud
provider can often involve an
overhaul of established operation
processes. For this reason, the cost
of change management and the
effect on business operations need
to be considered.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
• The total cost of ownership of data centres is decreasing significantly. This is due to improved methods of
data centre infrastructure management. This leads buyers to believe significant savings are potentially
achievable – in this case, in excess of 15% year on year.
• Mergers and acquisitions between suppliers will reduce the level of competition in the market, which may
arrest this trend in the medium term.
Spend on cloud computing infrastructure and platforms will grow at a CAGR of 30% until to 2018 Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 53
Indirect Categories: Data Centres cont.
SWITCHING COST
• Cost of switching between suppliers is generally
low
• Unless a contract detailing certain volumes of
travelers per year has been agreed, journeys are
generally bought on a fare-by-fare basis
FUTURE OUTLOOK
• Oil prices and ancillary fees will have an impact on airline prices. This may signify a return to relatively expensive air fees, as prices are
expected to increase. Low-cost airlines and economy premium flights will provide alternatives to existing business travel arrangements.
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 55
Indirect Categories: Air Travel cont.
SWITCHING COSTS
• Switching costs are generally high and the scale of
the costs depends on the client’s own capacities.
FUTURE OUTLOOK
• The current trend among global
leaders such as Tata, Convergys and
Teleperformance is to develop and provide a
multichannel service bundling several communication
platforms (telephony, email, web chat and others)
• The industry remains very fragmented and, despite
the annual growth of 5.8%, no one company has yet
taken a substantial share of the market (source: Sykes,
2013). The intense competition presents an SUPPLIER PRICING STRATEGY:
opportunity to drive prices down. • Building strategic and long-term relationships
•The continuous introduction of cloud-based • Bundling of services together with strategy development allows suppliers to ask for consultancy costs to be
technology in contact centers will drive down prices included in the final price
and cut both supplier and client costs • cost-per-hour should include agreed terms on billed time units and call handling time limits to avoid low
• Overall, the forecast shows a steady rise of prices productivity.
across several regions, with China having the largest • In time-based models, suppliers can include compensation for an increase in volume
increase. • Seasonal factors can be included into a pricing strategy, for example, an air travel company would pay more
in the summer months due to volume increases
Difference in salary rates remains the main profit generator for BPOs Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 57
Sourcing Trends: Future Operating Models
1. ‘SUPER-CENTRALISATION’ 2. DECENTRALISATION
• The expanding use of outsourcing will move greater proportions of • There will be greater use of ‘center-led’ or ‘co-sourcing’ models
spend outside the company; whereby buyers work with business units to agree deals;
• This will effectively ‘centralise’ spend in increasingly more influential • This leads to geographic dispersal of teams back into the regions
solution providers who take the combined demand of multiple firms and business units;
to market; • ... and the return of sourcing responsibility to BUs, with dotted
• Such models may be used more for indirect categories, those that line reports to a smaller central buying team.
are ‘business critical’ or ‘core’ directs will remain in-house.
Copyright © 2019 GEP. All rights reserved. 58
Sourcing Trends: More Supplier Collaboration
LESS MORE
• The number of suppliers will be reduced as businesses push forward with • More suppliers (in a reduced supply base) will be subject to more
supply rationalisation formalized SRM approaches and governance;
• Collaboration will be increasingly reduced as a ‘tool’ for individual suppliers, • Standardized procedures which uniformly apply to collaborative
where price negotiation fails; suppliers as a business programme;
• We will see the management of collaborative relationships increasingly • Use of technology (either internally developed, or 3rd party) will
through personal relationships between buyers and salesmen and less through support collaborative relationships.
formal channels.