So sánh GMT, ALM và TPR trong giảng dạy ngôn ngữ
So sánh GMT, ALM và TPR trong giảng dạy ngôn ngữ
→ memorize and
follow instructions
Student-teacher - Most of the - There is student- - The teacher interacts with the
and student- interaction in the to-student whole class and individual
student classroom is from the interaction in chain students; at first, the teacher speaks
Interactions teacher to the drills or when and students respond nonverbally,
students. students take then students start speaking while
- There is different roles in the teacher responds nonverbally.
little student dialogues, but this - Students perform actions together
initiation and little interaction is and learn by observing, but
student–student teacher-directed. eventually they need to
interaction. - Most of the demonstrate the commands to
interaction is remember them.
between teacher and - As students begin speaking, they
students and is give commands to each other and
initiated by the to the teacher.
teacher.
Characteristics of - Students are taught - New vocabulary - The lesson begins with modeling:
teaching/learning to translate from one and structures are the teacher gives commands and
process language into another. introduced through performs them with a few students.
- Students study dialogues with - These same students then perform
grammar deductively imitation and the commands to show
(that means rules are repetition. understanding and the observers
explained first and - Various drills are can demonstrate their
then apply them to conducted based on understanding.
examples). the dialogue - The teacher recombines
- Students learn patterns. commands to build
grammar paradigms -Students’successful students’flexibility.
such as verb responses are - After responding orally, students
conjugation. positively learn to read and write the
- Students memorize reinforced. commands.
native language - Grammar is - When ready, students give
equivalents for target induced from commands themselves, then move
language vocabulary examples, not on to skits and games.
words. taught through
explicit rules.
- Cultural
information is
contextualized in
the dialogues or
presented by the
teacher.
- Reading and
writing activities are
based on the oral
work previously
practiced.
Dealing with No principles relate to No principles relate Students’ feelings are handled by
feelings of this area to this area reducing the stress often associated
student with language learning. Learners
are allowed to speak only when
they feel ready, since forcing them
to speak too early can create
anxiety, and when they do begin
speaking, they are not expected to
be perfect. Anxiety is also lowered
by making learning enjoyable
through zany commands and
humorous skits, which show that
language learning can be fun. In
addition, teachers should avoid
both excessive modeling and
rushing students, as feelings of
success and low anxiety facilitate
learning.
Views of Literary language is The view of Just as with the acquisition of the
language and considered superior to language is native language, the oral modality
culture spoken language and influenced by is primary.
is therefore the descriptive linguists. Culture is the lifestyle of people
language that students Each language is who speak the language natively
study. - Culture is seen as having its
viewed as consisting own unique system.
of literature and the This system
fine arts includes several
levels:
phonological,
morphological, and
syntactic, and each
level has its own
distinctive patterns.
Everyday speech is
emphasized, but its
complexity is
graded so that
beginning students
are exposed only to
simple patterns.
Culture is
understood as the
everyday behavior
and lifestyle of the
speakers of the
target language.
- Writing/reading
skills are not
emphasized but in
favor of oral skills.
Mechanical - The most controlled, least - No real meaning is (+) Repetition drill:
Drills meaningful, and purest required. Repeat exactly what the
(pure accuracy) form of accuracy practice. - Students practice a teacher says.
- Students only need to minimal number of => Goals: Pronunciation
follow the linguistic language forms and Accuracy
pattern provided. repeatedly. E.g.: Teacher asks
- There is only one students to repeat the
correct response. word “restaurant” until
they can enunciate
fluently and correctly.
(+) Transformation
drill: Change the form
(tense, question,
passive,..) => Goal:
Structural accuracy
E.g.: Teacher asks a
student to change this
sentence “She cooks the
dinner.” into the passive
voice.
Meaningful - Meaningful drills are - Students must Wh_question with
Drills practice activities where understand meaning to controlled grammar:
(accuracy- students must understand respond correctly. - The teacher ask:
oriented) the meaning of the prompt, - The teacher still “ What time do you get
but their response is still controls the grammar up?”
controlled by a required form. -> Student answers: “I
grammatical structure. - There is limited get up at ______.”
freedom. => Students can choose
- The purpose is still the time (meaning) but
accuracy, not fluency. the structure is restricted.
- Usually only have one
acceptable grammatical
pattern/ multiple true
answers sometimes.
Form- - The most communicative +) Students - Teacher requires
focused type of accuracy activity, communicate meaning students to describe their
Communicative sitting between controlled (think about real personal experiences of
Practice practice and free information). travelling, using past
(semi- communication. +) Grammar is still simple tense to speak.
controlled - Students use language to controlled. + Students might speak:
accuracy) communicate real or semi- +) Students have partial “ I went to Ha Long Bay
real meaning, BUT they are freedom: They can last year.”
required to use a specific choose WHAT to say “ I took a flight to Ho Chi
target structure. but not HOW to say. Minh last week.”
+) Teacher monitors => Students can speak
form but does not out their own ideas;
control every word. however, they only speak
+) Form-focused in one grammatical
communicative practice structure: Past simple
prepares learners to use tense, as well as teacher
structures meaningfully; can’t restrict students’
communicate with thinking.
accuracy and transit to
free communicative
tasks (fluency)
Key Is the sentence formed Is the overall message clear and well-
Question correctly? organized?
(Brown, H. D. (2007). Principles of Language Learning and Teaching (5th ed.). Pearson.)
- Scholars such as Canale & Swain (1980) and Richards & Rodgers (2014) highlight sociolinguistic
competence as a central component of functional, real-world communication.
For instance, in several countries like America, England and Japan, queue culture is an important
etiquette. People cutting the line are considered very rude which causes annoyance for others. So the
teacher needs to explain and educate students to understand this culture by asking students to role-
play real situations such as waiting at a supermarket or airport. In the activity, students practice
simple dialogues like: “Excuse me, is this the end of the line?” and “Sorry, I didn’t realize—where
does the line start?” to learn polite and appropriate behaviour
2. Strategic Competence
- Strategic competence refers to use of verbal and nonverbal tactics to accomplish a communicative
goal, including compensation for breakdown.
( Canale, M., & Swain, M. (1980). Theoretical Bases of Communicative Approaches to Second
Language Teaching and Testing.)
- CLT acknowledges that language learners will inevitably encounter moments where their linguistic
resources are insufficient. Strategic competence enables them to sustain interaction, avoid
communication breakdowns, and negotiate meaning. Brown (2007) notes that this competence
fosters fluency, confidence, and communicative resilience, which are essential in learner-centered,
interaction-focused classrooms.
Conclusion:
- CLT provides authentic opportunities for learning that go beyond repetition and memorization of
grammatical patterns in isolation.
- Classroom goals followed by CLT are focused on all of the components of communicative
competence and not restrict to grammatical or linguistic competence (the knowledge of forms and their
meanings).
- Fluency and accuracy are seen as complementary principles underlying communicative techniques.
At times fluency may have to take on more importance than accuracy in order to keep learners
meaningfully engaged in language use.
A task must be meaningful and relevant so that students can see the reason for doing the task
and can see how the task relates to the possible situations in their lives outside the classroom.
Example:
Context: Students are doing a task-based discussion about their weekend
activities.
Task Description: Students work in pairs. Each student receives a different schedule card
showing their available times and preferred weekend activities (e.g., hiking, watching movies,
visiting grandparents, playing football, doing homework). They must negotiate and agree on one
shared activity they can do together this weekend. After the discussion, pairs share their final
decision with the class.
*) The outcomes: Students can gain deeper knowledge into weekend activities in the target language
(watching TV, playing sports, hanging out with friends…), discuss with friends what they are going to
do at the weekend and closely together to help each other accomplish the task.
*) Focus on form, error correction:
+ Student: Yesterday I go to my friend’s house.
+ Teacher (recast): Oh, you went to your friend’s house? That sounds fun!
→ The teacher recasts the student’s error within the flow of communication,
without stopping the task. The focus is still on meaning, but the teacher briefly
draws attention to form (past tense).
*) Classify tasks: A task must have a gap (information gap / opinion gap / reasoning gap:
Each student has different information on their schedule card → information gap.
They also have different preferences → opinion gap.
They must reason to choose one shared activity → reasoning gap.
*) Students can use strategies to ask for clarification, follow-up questions…
Students activate their existing knowledge: To complete the task, they must use what they
already know about: their own language resources about weekend routines, preferences,
grammatical structures.
Teacher’s role:
At the beginning: input provider (gives example discussion)
During task: observer - monitoring student’s performance, taking notes of language problems -
intervening when necessary.
After task: briefly highlights useful grammar/vocabulary that emerged (focus on form)
Meaning-focused: Students talk about realistic weekend activities and focus on communicating
meaning, not on producing perfect grammar.
Tasks must be meaningful and relevant: Talking about weekend activities is something students
really do in life → authentic and personally relevant.
PHÂN BIỆT TASK VÀ EXERCISE
A task An exercise
Primary focus on trying to Primary focus on using language correctly
communicate
There is a gap There is no gap
Learners use their own linguistic Text manipulating
resources
Successful performance= outcome of Successful performance= accurate use of target feature
task achieved
Example:
An exercise:
Focus on using grammar correctly
There is no gap
All language they need is present in this particular activity
The outcome is simply performing the little dialogue and then repeating it several times
A task:
Trying to communicate
There is information gap
Learners use their own linguistic language resources
There’s a communicative outcome
III. PROGRESS OF TBLT
A task-based learning lesson includes 3 phases: pre-task, task-cycle and language focus.
1. Pre -task
As a teacher, you can organise as many activities as you want to introduce topics and tasks, as long as
the activities activate students’ background knowledge and familiarize the topic.
For example, when learning about the topic “Famous destinations”, the teacher can require students to
plan a tour. As a result, students will recall their memories about activities in a tour.
2. Task-cycle
a. Task: Perform the task
Students work in pairs or groups to complete the real communicative task.
The teacher does not correct errors here; the goal is fluency and communication. The teacher
circulates, helps with meaning (not grammar), and observes.
Example Tasks for “Famous Destinations”:
Plan a 3-day tour to a famous place
Create a list of “Top 5 attractions” for foreign tourists
Decide the best destination for different types of travelers
b. Planning
Students prepare to present their results to the class.
This stage encourages accuracy and organization.
Teacher roles:
Give hints to help students self-correct
Provide phrases or structures students request or clearly need
Encourage them to prepare notes, outlines, or posters
Examples of teacher hints:
o “Check your verbs for past tense—did you use them consistently?”
o “Try adding reasons: because…, so that…”
“You can use expressions like We recommend… or Visitors should…”
c. Reporting
Groups present their task outcome to the class. This improves confidence and meaningful
communication.
Reporting options:
Oral presentation
Poster presentation
Group discussion
Class survey results
Writing a short report on the board
During reporting, the class listens, asks questions, and compares results.
The teacher gives light feedback but saves detailed corrections for the next phase.
3. Language focus
[Link]
The teacher will give some hints for students to correct mistakes by themself and then suggest
useful structures for better performance.
[Link]
With the aim to practise these mistakes and useful structures, the teacher can organise activities or
exercises.