5G Evolution: Intelligent Radio Environment
5G Evolution: Intelligent Radio Environment
evolution & 6G
Tx
Rx
: RIS
Estimation Control
Control
Optimization Achieved by RIS
2. IRE and RIS secure propagation routes that make detours around
shielding objects by optimally controlling not only
2.1 IRE the transmitter (Tx) and receiver (Rx) but the propa-
Research toward IRE has been quite active in recent gation channel*5 (H) as well.
years with the aim of adaptively and dynamically
controlling the radio environment to achieve non- 2.2 RIS
line-of-sight coverage in the millimeter-wave band RIS is essential technology for achieving IRE
[4]. In a white paper [1] issued by NTT DOCOMO described above. A RIS consists of multiple elements
toward 6G, a New Radio Network Topology was pro- that scatter electromagnetic waves. Metamaterial/
posed to increase the number of connection paths to metasurface technologies that can design and control
the network including discussions on controlling the the distribution of these scattering characteristics are
radio environment. In this regard, it is difficult to commonly used to achieve RIS. A metasurface has a
solve the problem of radio waves being blocked by thin flat shape, and depending on the base materials
shielding objects simply through the evolution of selected, it is even possible to manufacture one in the
transmitter/receiver technology, so the need is felt for shape of a flexible sheet that can be installed along
constructing a new radio network system. the side of a structure. This makes it possible to con-
Against this background, means of achieving a dra- trol the scattering characteristics of radio waves while
matic jump in radio network performance are being maintaining the shape of existing structures. Within
vigorously studied by breaking with the traditional the Tx – propagation channel – Rx sequence, this
assumption that the radio environment is uncontrol- means controlling the propagation channel. In gen-
lable and treating it instead as a controllable entity. eral, RIS can be expected to adaptively control the
This type of approach has come to be called the intel- radio environment by periodically repeating the
ligent radio environment (IRE) or smart radio envi-
ronment (SRE) to emphasize its conceptual differ- *5 Propagation channel: An individual communication path in radio
communications. Here, a communication path between a trans-
ence with the conventional radio network system. A mitting antenna and receiving antenna. The characteristics of a
conceptual diagram of IRE is shown in Fig. 1. Given communication path are expressed in terms of its transfer func-
an environment with shielding objects, IRE can tion H.
(1)
1st Fresnel zone
(2)
2nd Fresnel zone (3)
130
Direct-wave path loss for distance of 200 m
120
110
100
90
80
70
0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0
Length of one side of RIS (square-shaped) (m)
the receiving point (red line in Fig. 2). If optimized improve received power by adding phase compensa-
control is performed in this way, the received power tion consisting of only two values—0 and π (rad)—to
ends up having a positive correlation with RIS size direction-only control. As shown in Fig. 2 for the case
instead of converging to the value of the direct wave of direction-only control, path loss increases and
path. Furthermore, if RIS size should be less than the decreases repeatedly as RIS size becomes larger.
Fresnel radius, practically no difference can be Here, received power can be significantly improved
observed between conventional control of only the by shifting the wave phase by π (rad) via the even-
propagation direction (blue line in the figure) and numbered Fresnel zones, the cause of this increase-
optimized phase control, so direction-only control is decrease behavior (green line in the figure). This
sufficient in this interval. technique (hereinafter referred to as “Fresnel shift”)
When performing optimized control of a RIS from can improve received power depending on RIS size
the viewpoint of received power, the amount of phase the same as optimized control even for users posi-
change in each element of the RIS must be set to an tioned at any distance. Details of this technique are
optimal value as described above. This, however, may provided in another paper [5].
complicate the control process. To simplify this pro-
cess, we introduce a technique that can significantly
R wa
e
av
av
av
ef ve
tw
tw
tw
le
e
en
en
av
ef
en
ct
id
id
w
le
id
ed
c
c
c
In
ed
In
ct
In
ct
ed
le
ef
w
R
av
e
Fig. 3. Conceptual diagram of RIS using metasurface technology.
Make
transparent
Approx. 2 mm
Operating principle
Inter-substrate distance
dynamic control while maintaining transparency” in addition, attenuated and weak radio waves pene-
and “making it easy to enlarge the substrate.” Use of trate an indoor space without spreading out. It is
a transparent dynamic metasurface also minimizes therefore difficult to make such an indoor space into
impact on the surrounding environment and on a coverage area using outdoor base station antennas.
existing designs on installation. In response to these issues, we developed in coop-
A trial performed to assess the performance of the eration with AGC Inc. a “transparent metasurface
prototype RIS showed that it could achieve transmit- lens” that can guide millimeter waves passing
tance of approximately –1.4 dB or greater in penetra- through a glass window to a specific indoor location
tion mode and approximately –10 dB or less in reflec- (referred to below as a “focal point”). This is a film-
tion mode (calculated as reflectivity of –1 dB or like lens that can be affixed to a glass window from
greater) in 400 MHz or higher bands (Fig. 4). the indoor side [10, 11]. Focusing weak radio waves
Going forward, we plan to study further functional that pass through the entire surface of a glass window
enhancements such as functions for controlling pen- at a focal point in this way can increase power, so
etration/reflection directions with the aim of achiev- installing an area improvement tool such as a repeat-
ing a practical transparent RIS. er, reflector*12, or RIS at the focal point position
should make it possible to extend area coverage from
3.2 M aking windows into radio-wave lenses by outdoor base station antennas to the inside of a build-
transparent metasurface lens ing (Figs. 5 and 6). In a trial using this metasurface
Compared with radio waves in the frequency bands lens, we found that the received power at the focal
currently used in LTE (Long Term Evolution) and the point could be improved by 24 dB or more compared
Sub-6*11 band, radio waves in the millimeter-wave with the case of an ordinary transparent glass.
band have high straight-line propagation properties
*11 Sub-6: A specific range of frequencies. Radio signals having fre-
and attenuate easily. For this reason, radio waves quencies from 3.6 GHz to 6 GHz.
emitted from outdoor base station antennas attenuate *12 Reflector: In this article, reflectors include conventional metal re-
before arriving at the glass window of a building, and flectors and metasurface reflectors.
Indoors
×
Repeater New metasurface lens
Dynamic switching
Metasurface with distribution of Uniform control*
of focal points four types of structures
Outdoors
×
Metasurface lens prototype
Static metasurface lens Dynamic metasurface lens
*In this prototype, distance with adjoining glass
50cm substrate is controlled.
80 cm Trial results
Static metasurface lens
(1) Float glass (2) (1) + metasurface lens
50cm
80 cm
Received power at
0 dB >24 dB
focal point
*Values when using as reference the received power at focal point with only float glass
Fig. 5. Concept of making windows into radio-wave lenses by transparent metasurface lens.
Metasurface lens
Repeater, etc.
Out
doo
r ba
se s
tatio
n
We also tested a function for dynamically control- structures so that focal point positions can be
ling focal points. In this regard, the conventional switched (presently between a single focal point and
approach to controlling the penetration/reflection two focal points) even when applying the same con-
direction of radio waves was to configure a metasur- trol signal to all devices (Fig. 5). In single focal point
face with a uniform arrangement of identical devices mode, the received power at focal-point 1 was shown
and to apply different control signals to each device. to be 11 dB higher than that at focal-point 2 indicat-
In contrast, our new dynamic metasurface lens appro- ing that only focal-point 1 was functioning as a focal
priately arranges devices with four different types of point. Meanwhile, in double focal point mode,
References
Trademark notes
All company names or names of products, software, and services appearing
[1] NTT DOCOMO, “White Paper: 5G evolution & 6G,” Version 3.0,
in this article are trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective
Feb. 2021.
owners.
Yoshihisa Kishiyama
Yuto Hama Manager, 6G-IOWN Promotion Department,
Ph.D. student, Yokohama National University NTT DOCOMO, INC.
(JSPS Research Fellow). He received a B.E., M.E., and Ph.D. from Hok-
He received a B.E. and M.E. in information and kaido University in 1998, 2000, and 2010. Since
communication engineering from Yokohama joining NTT DOCOMO in 2000, he has been
National University, Kanagawa, in 2016 and involved in the research and development of 4G
2018, where he is currently pursuing a Ph.D. and 5G radio access technologies, including
degree. From 2018 to 2021, he was a researcher concept development, standardization, and trials.
at 6G Laboratories, NTT DOCOMO. Since April He is currently working on “5G evolution & 6G”
2021, he has been a research fellow of Japan and is the main author of “DOCOMO 6G White
Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS). His Paper.” He has more than 400 granted patents in
current research interests include communication the area of mobile communications. In 2012, he
theory and coded modulation for MIMO sys- received the ITU Association of Japan Award for
tems. his global contributions to LTE.