Linear Actuator Types and Comparisons
Linear Actuator Types and Comparisons
Engineering Actuator
Operation Rod Type or Rodless?
Rod Type actuators are similar in configuration to a NV Series
hydraulic or pneumatic actuator and are preferred
3 2
when you need to position an externally supported
load, move a load that pivots, retrofit a hydraulic or
pneumatic actuator, or have “reach in requirements”. 4
Rodless actuators have a bearing support system and a and each end is connected to the connector bracket (5).
carriage that runs the length of the actuator. This type The connector bracket is connected to two bearing
of actuator is preferred when you need to save space by blocks (6) that ride on the recirculating ball-bearing rail
eliminating external guides and ways, when high speed (7) that is mounted in the guide cylinder (8). The
and long stroke lengths are needed, when the shortest carriage (9) is mounted to the connector bracket and
overall work envelope is needed, or when a multi axis the seal strip (10) runs between them. The connector
Cartesian System is required. bracket lifts the seal as the carriage moves, while roller
wheels (11) in the carriage push the seal back in place.
R2, R3 and R4 rodless actuators use a leadscrew or a
R2 actuators have no bearing blocks, but instead have
transport belt to convert the motor’s power to linear
roller wheels for bearing support (as seen in the figure
thrust. Pictured below is a belt-drive actuator. As in the
below). Four track-roller bearings run on two hardened
EC and NV actuators, there is a timing belt, or gear
and ground steel shafts, pressed into the extrusion.
reduction (1) between the motor (2) and the driven
Engineering
pulley (3). The transport belt (4) runs over two pulleys
4 11 9 5 10
R2A Carriage
6 7 8
Linear Modules are very efficient, high speed systems, the Thrust Rod (2). The Thrust Block is connected to
that have repeatabilities in microns. They are similar in one or two bearing blocks (3) that ride on a wide linear
configuration to the R-series Rodless actuator family, but rail (4), which is mounted to the base extrusion (5).
operate on a different principle. A linear motor converts The Thrust Rod runs through the Thrust Block and is
electric current directly into linear force. There is no mounted to brackets on either end of the base
rotary motion to be converted. Motor coils, hall effect extrusion. The motor wiring is housed in a cable track
sensors, and the linear-encoder read head are mounted (6) that flexes with the movement of the Thrust block.
in the Thrust Block (1), while permanent magnets are in
1 2
6 5
End View
3 4
Engineering
Ballscrew Ballscrew
The majority of linear motion applications convert
motor torque to linear thrust using ballscrews due to
their ability to convert more than 90% of the motor’s
torque to thrust. As seen below the ballnut uses one or
more circuits of recirculating steel balls which roll
between the nut and ballscrew threads. Ballscrews
provide an effective solution when the application
requires:
• High efficiency - low friction
• High duty cycle (> 50%)
• Long life - low wear
Timing Belt
Belt Drive systems offer many of the benefits of actuator and is attached to the carriage to pull it back
ballscrews, yet have fewer moving parts, and do not and forth along the length of travel. The carriage is
have the critical speed limits of leadscrew-driven supported by a linear bearing system to provide load
systems. They generally provide more linear motion carrying capacity. The neoprene belt is reinforced with
from the same motor movement, resulting in higher steel tensile elements to provide strength and minimize
travel speeds with minimal component wear. In belt stretch. Timing belt systems are a good solution for
contrast, this design results in lower repeatability and applications requiring:
accuracy. Thrust capability is also smaller compared to • High speeds
screw-drive systems due to the tensile strength limitation
of the transport belt. • Low thrusts
• High efficiency
The general configuration can be seen in the figure. A
toothed belt passes around a pulley in each end of the • High duty cycle
Belt Drive
Carriage and Linear
Support Bearings
Engineering
Backlash Increases with wear Constant throughout Can increase with wear
screw life or stretching of belt
Engineering
Belt: High efficiency provides low heating and high duty cycle.
Highest - 90-95% Acme: Low efficiency sliding friction surfaces.
Ball: High efficiency smooth rolling contact.
Linear motor: Efficient - no conversion needed between rotary and linear motion.
Longest life, least mechanical wear Acme: Mechanical wear is a function of duty cycle, load and speed.
Ball: Virtually no mechanical wear when operated within rated load specifications.
Belt: High efficiency contributes to long life. Drive belts can be easily replaced to
extend system life.
Linear motor: Limited by cable flex, and bearing life.
Highest Acme: Better suited because of larger surface area.
Ball: Brunelling of steel balls limits shock load capability.
Belt: Shock loads can cause fatigue and stretching of drive belts.
Smoothest Acme: At extreme low speeds, units have a tendency to stop/start stutter (due to
friction).
Ball: Generally smoother than acme through the entire speed range.
Belt: 180° engagement of belt provides continuous smooth contact throughout the
speed range.
Highest Acme: Extreme speeds and accelerations can generate excessive heat and deform the
screw.
Belt: Each revolution of the drive pulley provides several inches of travel. Speeds up to
120 in/sec can be achieved.
Linear motor: LM to 196 in/sec. LD to 394 in/sec.
$$$$ Highest
Safe Load Acme screw units are self- Complex back-up safety Complex back-up safety
Holding locking if power fails. Fail-safe devices must be used. devices must be used.
brakes available for ball screw
models.
Cost Moderate initial cost; very low Components often cost less, Components often cost less,
operating cost. but installation and but installation and
maintenance are increased. maintenance are increased.
Hydraulic power unit cost is Most cost-effective for low
high if not pre-existing. Most power, simple point-to-point
economical above 10 HP. applications.
Engineering
V+
Trapezoidal and Triangular Profiles
V- Time
A couple of assumptions can greatly simplify the general
equations. For the Trapezoidal profile we assume
t1=t2=t3, and for the Triangular we assume t3=t4.
t1 t2 t3 t4 t5
Substituting these assumptions into equations (2) and (3)
yields the equations shown in the figure below.
For a given distance (or area), a triangular profile
requires lower acceleration than the trapezoidal profile.
(1) Total distance, dtot = vMAX t1 + t2 + t3
2 2 [ ] This results in a lower thrust requirement, and in turn, a
smaller motor. On the other hand, the triangular profile’s
peak speed is greater than the trapezoidal, so for
dtot
applications where the motor speed is a limiting factor, a
(2) Max velocity,
(
vMAX = t1 + t3
2
)+t 2 trapezoidal profile is usually a better choice.
v max
vAVE = dtot
ttot
The figure above is an example of a typical machine v avg t1 = t2 = t3 = ttot
a
cycle, and is made up of two Move Profiles; the first is Velocity 3
d tot
an example of a trapezoidal profile, while the second (in/sec)
Engineering
is a triangular profile. The horizontal axis represents vMAX = 1.5 dtot = 1.5 vAVE
time and the vertical axis represents velocity (linear or t1 t2 t3 ttot
T (time in sec)
rotary). The load accelerates for a time (t1), has a d
a = 4.5 tot 2
constant velocity or slew section (t2), and decelerates to (ttot)
a stop (t3). There it dwells for a time, accelerates in the
negative direction (t4), and decelerates back to a stop
(t5) without a slew region. The equations needed to Triangular Move Profile
calculate Peak Velocity and Acceleration for a general
trapezoidal profile are shown in the figure. A triangular Vmax
dtot
profile can be thought of as a trapezoidal profile vAVE =
ttot
where t2 = 0. a
Vavg t1 = t3 = ttot t2 = 0
2
Velocity
(in/sec) d tot
vMAX = 2dtot = 2 vAVE
t1 t3
ttot
T (time in sec)
4dtot
a= = 2vMAX
(ttot)2 ttot
Example 1 Example 3
Calculate the peak acceleration and velocity for an This is an example of a case when triangular and
object that needs to move 30 inches in 2.5 seconds. trapezoidal move profiles are not adequate
Assume a Trapezoidal Profile. approximations. Assume a maximum actuator speed is 6
inches/sec. Sketch a move profile that will complete a
Solution
10 inch move in 2 seconds. What is the minimum
allowable acceleration rate in inches/sec2?
vmax
Solution
d tot= 30 in.
v
Triangular
Trapezoidal
Actual
2.5 sec. Required
Move
vAVE = 30 in = 12 in/sec
2.5 sec
t
d
vMAX = 1.5 t tot = 18 in/sec
tot
Triangular
dtot vAVE = 10 in = 5 in/sec
a = 4.5 (t )2 = 21.6 in/sec2 2 sec
tot
vMAX = 2 × vAVE = 10 in/sec (vMAX > 6 in/sec – too fast)
Example 2
Trapezoidal
Calculate, in radians/sec, the peak acceleration and
velocity for an cylinder that needs to move 5 revolutions vMAX = 1.5 × vAVE = 7.5 in/sec (vMAX > 6 in/sec – too fast)
in 0.4 seconds. Assume a Triangular Profile. These are too fast, so we need to find t1 as follows:
Solution
Engineering
dtot = vMAX ( (t +2 t )+ t )
1 3
2
5 revs
substitute (t1 + t3) = ttot - t2
d=
vMAX
( (t 2- t ) ) + t = t2
tot 2
2 tot + t2
2
0.4 sec. solving for t2,
× 2 = ( 10 in –
2 )
ttot
t2 = (vd
MAX
tot -
2
) 6 in/sec
2 sec
×2
dtot = 5 revs x 2π rad = 31.42 rad
rev t2 = 1.33 sec
vAVE = 31.42 rad in = 78.55 rad Now assume t1 = t3, so
0.4 sec sec
t1 = (ttot - t2)/2 = 0.33 sec.
vMAX = 2 vAVE = 157.1 rad
sec
Finally, calculate acceleration
dtot
a = 4 2 = 785.5 rad2 v
T sec a = MAX = 6 in/sec = 18 in 2
t1 0.33 sec sec
thrust must be calculated for each section of the move Ma = 0 lb (since a=0)
profile. The worst case thrust and speed required
should be used to pick the appropriate actuator. All of Fapplied = 0 lb
these forces added up (Σ) must be equal to mass × Ffriction = [200 lb × cos (45)] × 0.1 = 14.14 lb
acceleration, or: Fgravity = 200 lb × sin (45) = 141.4 lb
Ftotal = 156 lb
ΣF=m×a , or, (1) Deceleration Section:
Ma = 200 lb/386 in/sec2 × -11.25 in/sec2
= -5.83 lb
Factuator - Fapplied - Ffriction - Fgravity = ma = ( Wg ) a t (2)
Fapplied = K × x = 0.5 in × 100 lb/in =50 lb
(worst case)
Factuator = ( Wg ) a + F
t applied
+ Ffriction + Fgravity (3) Ffriction = [200 lb × cos (45)] × 0.1 = 14.14 lb
Fgravity = 200 lb × sin (45) = 141.4 lb
where Wt= Wload + Wactuator (4) Ftotal = 200 lb
Ffriction = µWLcosθ, and So the worst case required thrust is 200 lb. And
the worst case velocity is 7.5 in/sec.
Fgravity = WLsinθ
Thrust Profile
= 13.03 lb Move Profile
Ftotal = 169 lb
Slew Section:
Engineering
FT RMS
Ma = 0 lb (since a=0)
Deceleration Section:
Ma = 447 lb/386 in/sec2 × -11.25 in/sec2)
tA tV tD toff
= -13.03 lb
Ftotal = 193 lb
FT RMS = (FT ACC )2ta+ (FT VEL )2tv+ (FT DEC )2td+ (FT OFF)2toff
We can see from this calculation that the addition of
t a + t v + t d + t off
this extra “acceleration weight” increases the thrust
required during acceleration, but reduces the peak
thrust required during deceleration. The EC3-B32-20-
16B-12 will work in the application.
EC3 Cylinder Actuator Linear Inertia = [A + B*(stroke, in) + D]/C Motor Inertia (in-lb-sec2)
Leadscrew Ratio A (lb-in-s2) B (lb-in-s2/in) C (lb-in-s2/lb) D (lb-in-s2)
16x16 1:1 1.1909E-03 1.1760E-05 2.6039E-05 B32 1.00 E-03
1.5:1 7.4495E-04 5.2280E-06 1.1573E-05
2:1 4.7866E-04 2.7650E-06 6.1212E-06
Fz
Carriage
Fx
Ty
• Tx
General loading condition applied at point
Fy
(lx, ly, lz) from center of the carriage.
lz
ly
lx dp or dr
Roll Axis
x
Pitch Axis
y
Rodless actuators have bearings designed to support The equations for pitch, roll, and yaw assume that the
significant loads, however actuator loading is limited, directions of the arrows in the figure are POSITIVE. If
and moment, normal, and side loads on the rodless the forces or torques in your application work in the
actuator and linear motor carriages need to be opposite direction, they are NEGATIVE and they should
evaluated. be entered as negative numbers in the formulas. The
same is true for the distances lx, ly, and lz.
Moment loads are rotational forces (or torques) which
are applied to the carriage assembly. They are defined as It is important to add the carriage to bearing distances,
Engineering
yaw, pitch, and roll and are measured in in-lb. dp (pitch) and dr (roll), in the roll and pitch moment
calculations above. These distances vary for each
To evaluate the actuator you have chosen, use the
actuator and are listed in the table below.
diagram above. The three forces (F) and the three
torques (T) are a general loading condition applied to Examples
the load a distance lx, ly, and lz from the centerpoint of To illustrate these calculations, refer to the facing page
the carriage. These forces may be due to gravity, which shows six typical rodless actuator orientations
friction, applied loads, and actuator thrust. Each of these and the equations for the calculation of moment, normal
forces may act at different points of application. For and side loads in each case.
example, gravity will act at the center of gravity of the
load, while friction and applied loads will act at the edge
of the load.
Fn = F z = W L
dp lz
Mp = Fx (lz + dp)
Fx = THRUST
ly
Fn = Fz = WL
Fx Mp = Fx (lz + dp)
WL Mr = Fz (ly)
Fz My = Fx (ly)
Fx = THRUST
lx Fz
Fn = F z = W L
dp
WL
lz Mp = Fz (lx) + Fx (lz + dp)
Fx = THRUST
Mp = Fx (lz + dp)
WL
lz Fx = THRUST
Fx dp
Engineering
lz
WL
Mp = Fx (lz + dp)
dp
My = Fx (ly)
ly Fx
Fx = THRUST
dr, dp Fy = W L
WL
Mp = Fx (lz + dp)
Mr = Fy (lz + dr)
lz
Fy Fx = THRUST
RA = RB + Fx ( Dd )
D = Fx (d) = 300 lb (10 in)
RA 150 lb
D = 20 inches
Engineering
allow duty cycles above 60%. If an Acme screw is using the RMS Thrust equation in the Thrust Calculation
required and Duty Cycle requirements exceed 60%, section. Plotting FRMS on the actuator Speed vs. Thrust
please call the factory for a custom evaluation. If power- curve indicates the allowable Duty Cycle. For ball screw
off position holding is required, consider using a brake actuators, FRMS must fall within the continuous duty
on a ballscrew or on a motor. region, while for Acme screws it must fall in the 60%
duty region. Fpeak must fall within remaining operating
envelope. The speed vs. thrust curve below is an
mm/s in/s R3H-105A example of proper servo actuator sizing.
381 15
305 12
mm/s in/s R3B23-105B
Speed
305 12
229 9
(1) (2) 254 10
152 6 • • 30% 203 8
60% 10%
Speed
76 3
152 6
VMAX
0 102 4
15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120 135 150 lbs
67 133 200 267 334 400 467 534 601 667 N 51 2
Thrust FRMS FPEAK
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 lbs
445 890 1335 1779 2224 2669 3114 N
Thrust
Degree of Degree of
Start Position Expected Position Accuracy Repeatability Comment
System 1 High High System 1 is both accurate and repeatable,
Move 1
Move 2 the end positions are tightly grouped
Move 3
Move 4 together and are close to the expected
Move 5 position
System 2 Low High System 2 is inaccurate but repeatable,
Move 1
Move 2 the end positions are tightly grouped
Move 3
Move 4
around a point but are not close to the
Move 5 expected position.
System 3 Low Low System 3 is neither accurate nor
Move 1
Move 2 repeatable, the end positions are not
Move 3
Move 4
tightly grouped and are not close to the
Move 5 expected position.
Engineering
6. Use an IDC LM or LD Linear Motor Module.
Backlash
4. Coupling
Backlash
Column Strength
All leadscrews have a maximum
column loading limit which causes
the screw to compress as load
increases. In IDC cylinders this limit Compression (column) Load
is a function of unsupported
leadscrew length. Exceeding this Column
limit will cause the leadscrew to mm/s in/s R3B23-105B Load Limit
305 12
buckle and become permanently 254 10
damaged. 203 8
Speed
152 6
203 8
Max. No-Load Accel. 360 in/s2 9.1 m/s2
152 6
Backlash 0.015 in 0.38 mm
Example
Rodless Actuators
102 4
60% 115VAC Repeatability ±0.001 in ±0.025 mm
51 2 Lead Accuracy ±0.005 in/ft ±0.13 mm
0
R3B23-155A
Speed limits for an R3B23-105B, 42 mm/s in/s
203 8
178 7
230VAC
R3B23-155A: 1.5:1 Timing Belt, 5 rev/inch Acme Screw
Min. Backdrive Load 400 lbs 1779 N
152 6
inch stroke actuator. The actuator Max. No-Load Accel. 420 in/s2 10.7 m/s2
Speed
127 5
Backlash 0.015 in 0.38 mm
102 4
115VAC Repeatability ±0.001 in ±0.025 mm
76 3
Section. Reading off the chart at the 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 lbs
222 445 667 890 1112 1335 1557 1779 2002N
Thrust
and 3.6 in/sec. The usable speed/ Max. No-Load Accel. 430 in/s2 10.9 m/s2
Speed
102 4
76 3 Backlash 0.015 in 0.38 mm
Repeatability ±0.001 in ±0.025 mm
thrust is restricted to less than these 51 2
25 1
60% 115VAC Lead Accuracy ±0.005 in/ft ±0.13 mm
0
values as seen in the modified speed 100
445
200
890
300
1335
Thrust
400
1779
500
2224
600 lbs
2669N
51 2.0
R3B23-505A
230VAC
R3B23-505A: 5:1 Helical Gears, 5 rev/inch Acme Screw
Min. Backdrive Load 400 lbs 1779 N
Max. No-Load Accel. 130 in/s2 3.3 m/s2
Speed
38 1.5
Backlash 0.015 in 0.38 mm
25 1.0 Repeatability ±0.001 in ±0.025 mm
60% 115VAC
Lead Accuracy ±0.005 in/ft ±0.13 mm
13 0.5
0
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 lbs
445 890 1335 1779 2224 2669 3114 3559 N
Thrust
n/a n/a 780 540 400 300 190 130 Column Load Limit (lbs) n/a n/a 780 540 400 300 190 130 Column Load Limit (lbs) n/a 700 390 250 175 125 95 60 40 Column Load Limit (lbs)
Engineering
Protective Boot Option
The -PB option is available for EC actuators and
increases the actuator’s resistance to liquids. The
diagram to the right shows a typical installation of an
EC with the -PB option. This option protects the
actuator to IP65. Note that some IDC motors are not
protected to this level. The -PB option is not available
with NV or R-series Rodless actuators.
Custom Environmental Options
IDC has over 20 years experience designing custom
actuators. We have designed fully encapsulated
actuators for Corrosive, Food Processing, and
Washdown environments, and have experience EC Actuator Thrust Tube Protective Boot
designing Cleanroom compatible actuators. Call IDC
for more information regarding Custom environmental
options.
PC
or Motion Drive Motor Feedback Mechanical
PLC Control Device System
Engineering
0.0005" with actuators, submicron with precision
tables). An encoder can be used if closed loop operation
is desired. This may be important when a jam or stall
condition must be detected. An encoder attached
Common Applications
directly to the load can improve the overall accuracy of
the system as well. • Short, rapid moves
• Accurate positioning systems
Advantages
• High acceleration, duty cycle
• Excellent repeatability
• No maintenance (brushless)
• High torque at rest, moderate speeds
• Mechanically stiff with no vibration at rest
• Lower cost than brushless servo
Disadvantages
• Inefficient at high speeds
• Excessive loads can stall motor
Engineering
be determined. A circuit board containing the Hall Hab
devices is aligned with a magnet on the rotor, so that the Hall
relationship shown between the Hall outputs and the Devices
motor back EMF can be established. Hbc
requiring position feedback, room must be made for 0 60 120 180 240 300 360 60
both the commutation circuit board as well as the Degrees
encoder. This generally adds both cost and complexity
to the motor package. Encoders are now available with
integrated commutation outputs equivalent to those
produced by Hall devices. The result is a more compact
system, reduced alignment time and superior switching
accuracy, due to the much lower hysteresis of the
encoder when compared to a Hall device. Adding
additional data tracks to the encoder disk provides the
commutation outputs.
ƒS ƒS
from the commanded position will cause a reduction in
Shaft Position
applied motor torque from the max torque Tm (see s
Figure 4). When the rotor is deflected from the
commanded position, a restoring torque acts on the
rotor to move it back to the commanded position Previous
Commanded
Engineering
Response
required move needs the motor torque that was lost. 0.4
1.0
This torque loss due to shaft vibration is why we look to 0.7
Engineering
conventional step motor system with a damping ratio of
0.02 rings far off to the right of the graph. Reducing a
system’s settling time increases your system’s 14.0
Commanded
throughput, allowing a user to make more parts per 12.0 Motor Response
minute.
10.0
A step motor system that lacks adequate damping not
Velocity (rps)
The superb velocity tracking and quick settling found in profile. Increasing the damping leads to better velocity tacking
the IDC microstepping drives allows a user to make very and smoother overall motion.
aggressive moves without having excessive ringing at
speed.
ta tv td
t max (time in sec)
Speed
Servo Systems
rad For servo systems, a torque safety margin of at least 20%
Total distance, dtot = 10 rev • 2π rev = 63 rad is recommended. The peak torque required by the
application must fall within the peak torque rating of the
1.5dtot 1.5•63 motor at the peak speed. You must also calculate the
Max velocity, ωmax = = 95 rad
ttot = 1 sec RMS torque based on your application’s duty cycle. The
RMS torque must fall within the continuous area of the
4.5dtot 4.5•63 rad speed torque curve at the peak speed of the application.
Acceleration, α = = = 284 sec2
(ttot)2 12
2. Mechanical Drive Mechanisms 20% Safety Margin
Peak Torque
Required
The system equations on the following page will help
Torque
Peak
you calculate the reflected inertia (J), reflected applied
loads (T), motor speed (ω), and acceleration (α), based
RMS Torque
on the move requirements that were determined in step Required
20% Safety
one. Margin Continuous
Speed
ω ω = ωL ω = ωL ω=
VL
R1
α α = αL α = αL α=
a
R1
W L + WB
WL = Lρ R2 WL = Lρ [R22 - R12] JRL = • R12
g
JT JT = JL + JMotor
JL = 1 W L • R 2
JT = JL + JMotor
JL = 1 WL [R22 + R12]
JT = JMotor + JRL + JG1 + JG2 ( )
R1 2
R2
R1 2
2 g 2 g + JG3
( )
R3
Tt
D
R
L
Js, TPL, p JL , V L , αL Ft
Engineering
1. Be sure your application's peak torque is
JS 0.0012 LD4 less than the maximum momentary torque
(for steel) JL rating of the gearhead. Be sure to multiply the
JRL =
J WL 1 2 N2 motor's torque by the gearhead efficiency and
JRL =
g 2 p JT = JRL+ JReducer + JMotor gear ratio when determining output torque
JT = JRL+ JS+ JMotor from the reducer.
2. Be sure your application's RMS torque is
Ft = FFriction + FApplied + FGravity Ft = FFriction + FApplied + FGravity less than the rated continuous torque of the
T TRL =
Ft
+ TPL TRL =(Ft • R) + Tt gearhead.
2 •p•e N•e
Units
a = acceleration rate (rad/sec2) JRL = reflected load inertia TPL = preload torque of leadscrew
α = rotary acceleration (rad/sec2) (oz-in-sec2) (oz-in)
D = diameter L = length (in) tR = running time (sec)
e = efficiency of mechanism ρ = material density (oz/in3) TR = running torque (oz-in)
Ft = total load force including p = pitch of screw (rev/in) TRL = reflected load torque due to
friction, gravity, or other R = radius (in) friction, gravity, or other
external forces (oz) tA = acceleration time (sec) external forces (oz-in)
g = gravity = 386 in/sec2 TA = acceleration torque (oz-in) VL = linear velocity of load (in/sec)
J = rotary inertia (oz-in-sec2) tD = deceleration time (sec) ω = rotary velocity (rad/sec)
JT = total inertia seen by motor TD = deceleration torque (oz-in) W = weight (oz)
(oz-in-sec2)
Industrial Devices Corporation
707-789-1000 • [Link] • 24 hour info by fax 916-431-6548 K-29
Engineering Rotary Sizing
Calculations
Rotary System Selection
EXAMPLE 1–STEPPER: Calculate the motor torque required t A= tD = t R= t/3 = 0.33 sec.
to accelerate a solid cylinder of aluminum 5" in radius and
0.40" in length from rest to 10 rev/sec in 0.3 seconds. Assume
no friction is present and there are no applied forces or gravity 2
Select mechanical drive mechanism as a leadscrew.
forces opposing the motor's rotation.
3
1 Calculate inertia, friction and load torque. A B32 motor was
Calculate maximum velocity and acceleration rates. chosen to see if it will meet the requirements of the
rev rad rad application. The friction coefficient of plastic on steel is 0.2.
= 10 sec 2 rev = 63 sec
2 oz 2
W 1 500 lb 16 lb 1
=
final - initial
=
63 - 0 rad
= 210 sec 2 JRL= gL = = 0.131 oz-in sec2
t A 0.3 2 p 386 in/sec 2 2 2 rev
in
2
Mechanical drive mechanism selected as direct drive. JS = 0.0012 LS D4 = 0.0012 24 14 = 0.0288 oz-in sec2
3 JTotal = JMotor + JRL + JS = 0.016 + 0.131 + 0.029 = 0.176 oz-in sec2
Calculate inertia (assume no friction or load torque). oz
Ft = WL µS +FApplied= 500 lbs 16 lb 0.2 + 125 lbs x 16 oz
lb
Hint: The density of aluminum can be found on page K-47.
W = ρ L s R2 = 3.14 0.40 1.57 5.0 2 = 49.3 oz + 2000 = 3600 oz
Ft 3600
1 w 2 1 49.3 TRL = + TPL = + 0 = 318 oz-in
JL = R = 5 2 = 1.6 oz-in sec2 2 e 2 2 0.9
2 g 2 386
J Total Assume motor is S42, rotor
= J Load + J Motor inertia is 0.114 oz-in-sec 2 4
= 1.6 + 0.114 = 1.71 oz-in-sec 2 Determine peak and continuous torque requirements.
4
Determine peak and continuous torque requirements. JT 0.176 567
TA= TRL + e = 318 + = 429 oz-in
0.9
JT 1.71 210
TA= TRL + e = 0+ = 359.1 oz-in JT 0.176 567
1.0 TD= TRL - = 318 - = 207 oz-in
e 0.9
[N-m] oz-in S42 If the dwell time between moves is 1.0 second, the total cycle
[8.75] 1250 time becomes 2.0 seconds.
[7.00] 1000 100%
TRMS = TA2 tA + TR2 tR + TD2 tD
Torque
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 RPS
= 233 oz-in
0 600 1200 1800 2400 3000 RPM
[N-m] oz-in B32
Plotting the required torque on the S42 speed torque curve 100%
[5.6] 800
shows sufficient torque is present with a safety margin of 80%.
Torque
IDC controls are designed to provide the optimum Edge Guide Controls
combination of cost and performance for a variety of IDC edge guide controls are a special purpose type of
applications All of our controls are designed for use with limit switch control used to maintain the position of the
IDC actuators, providing the fastest implementation time edge of a moving web of material.
in the industry.
The control uses feedback from sensors that can detect
Drives the edge of the material and move an actuator when
IDC drives provide the power to the motor and control adjustment is required. Two different correction speeds
it’s torque, velocity or position output. They are can be defined based on the amount of error.
designed to accept industry standard signals from When to use: When you want to control a web edge
motion controllers. based on input from simple on-off sensors.
Microstepping systems control the position of a step
Analog Position Controls
motor and provide resolutions up to 50,400 steps per
revolution. These drives accept a digital step and Analog position controls combine our drive electronics
direction signal and move the motor one microstep for with an analog absolute position controller. They
each pulse received. Varying the frequency of incoming control the absolute position of an actuator in direct
pulses controls velocity. proportion to an analog input signal. An IDC actuator
equipped with a linear potentiometer provides position
Brushless servo drives are available to control torque, feedback to the controller.
velocity or position of a brushless servomotor. These
drives accept digital step and direction or analog Analog position commands often come from a PLC,
command signals. industrial computer, sensor, data acquisition system, or a
manually operated joystick. Typical applications include
When to use: Use drives when your application cannot controlling flow or mixing of materials, web edge
be solved with one of IDC’s packaged motion guiding, and remote manual positioning.
controllers.
When to use: Use analog position controls when you
Limit Switch Controls need to control absolute position relative to an analog
Limit switch controls combine the functionality of a DC command signal, when you cannot home the system or
variable speed drive with a very simple position control when you need to know the position at power up.
that uses limit switches to provide position feedback.
Programmable Motion Controls
Manually adjustable (actuator or load mounted) limit IDC’s Smart Drives combining one or more of our drive
switches sense the load position and signal the control products packaged together with a powerful
to reverse direction, change speed or stop the motor. programmable positioning control.
Inputs are also provided for jog or run modes.
Engineering
A single package combines a one or two axis motion
Limit switch controls often interface with PLCs or controller, drive(s), an AC input power supply, support
industrial PCs and are our most cost effective solution for OPTO22 modules, an optional detachable front panel
for applications requiring simple position control. and RS232 communications interface.
When to use: Use limit switch controls when your They use IDC’s powerful and intuitive IDeal
positioning requirements can be met with limit switches programming language. This language has been called
and when positions, loads and speeds don’t change “simply sophisticated” by some due to its combination
frequently. of advanced capabilities in an easy to understand format.
You’ll have your system up in running in a minimum
amount of time.
When to use: Use programmable Smart Drives when
you need a flexible, powerful and easy to use motion
control system.
Axis 1
H3301B
Stop Extend
Ground
PLC Stop Retract
Axis 2
H4301
Stop Extend
Ground
Stop Retract
Engineering
• PC Analog output
• Potentiometer Joystick
• Sensor Output
• Others . . .
Command Input
Gnd
H3501 Linear
Disable
Potentiometer
STOP
Remote Program Control – PLC, Using Industrial Devices’ controls have the capability of
Binary or BCD Inputs remote program execution. A program is selected using
binary (or BCD) coded digital inputs with a PLC,
computer, or simple switches (thumbwheels or rotary).
PLC
Inputs
Program
Number 3 2 1
0 1 1 1
1 1 1 0
0 0 2 1 0 1
3 1 0 0
4 0 1 1
5 0 1 0
3 4 6 0 0 1
2 5
1 6 7 0 0 0
0 7
Engineering
Saw Control Saw
Blade
Operator
Interface
Clamp Saw
Pipe Travel
Sensor
Feed
Rodless Cylinder
H3301
Winding Control
Requirements
Load 50 lbs Analog
PLC Speed Input
Engineering
Speed 15 in/sec max Go Extend
Go Retract
Duty Cycle 100% In Motion
Extend Limit
Repeatability ±0.1 inches Retract Limit
Tach Signal
Programmability Automatic R3 Series
extend/retract Motor
sequencing
Interface Discrete I/O to
PLC Traverse
Wire Feed
From Extruder
Customer’s Objectives
A manufacturer of fence making
equipment received a special 120 VAC
Fault
request from their customer for a
machine which cuts fencing sections Estop
to length from 0 to 120 inches, with
as many as 150 product (length)
Engage Saw 240VAC
changes per day.
Motor/Encoder
Clamp
Although the company already has 120VAC
fence cutting equipment, the set up Sensor 12VDC
time to change lengths (changing
stops on a hydraulic cylinder) took Feed
more than five minutes. A five Fence
minute set up was unacceptable to
this customer. R4 Series
VAC)
2. Engage saw, to cutter (240 VAC)
3. Fault/Current limit, to yellow
light (120 VAC)
Why IDC?
The customer chose our RH Series
actuator because of its compact size
and excellent carriage moment load
capacity.
The B8961 control was chosen for
its high performance servo response,
integral operator interface, ease of
programming, and I/O capability,
which eliminated the need for a
PLC.
Application 4: Sawing
Back-stop Adjustment
Requirements
Load 400 lbs moving,
Engineering
800 lbs holding S6962
Keypad
Speed 1 in/sec
Duty Cycle 10%
Repeatability ±0.0005 inches
Programmability Synchronize two
actuators EC Series Width Adjust EC Series
Interface RS-232C
programming
Backstop
Analog Feedback
automatically adjust the height of a In Position
scrubbing deck, based on the Fault
thickness of the material passing
underneath. The rotating wire
brushes on the scrub deck were
used to smooth the surface of the
wood. EC
Series
The company received several
quotes for expensive position
following servo controls which were Ultrasonic
capable of much greater accuracy Sensor
than they needed (0.025" inches).
They also wanted the solution to
take full advantage of the PLC being Partical Board Feed
used to control the machine.
H4501 Inputs
1. 4-20 mA position input, from PLC
2. Inhibit, from PLC
H4501 Outputs
1. In position, to PLC
2. Fault/Stall to PLC
programming, Fault
3. Coarse Decrement
4. Fine Decrement
Engineering
B8961 Outputs
1. In position
2. Fault
Flow
Engineering
A measure of angular force which
by a transistor where the “open from and written to. Used as a produces rotational motion.
collector output” acts like a switch medium for temporary information
closure to ground when activated. TTL (Transistor-Transistor-Logic)
storage. Data is lost after power loss.
Refers to a family of integrated
Open Loop Repeatability circuit devices used for control.
A positioning system which does not The ability of a positioning system to Typically use voltage levels from 5-
employ feedback information. return to an exact location during 12 VDC.
Optically Coupled operation (from the same direction Velocity (Speed)
with the same load and speed). The change in position as a function
An interface circuit that transmits a
signal with no direct electrical Resistance of time.
connection except for the logic The opposition to the flow of charge Voltage
ground. through a conductor. Difference in electrical potential
Optical Isolation Resolution between two points.
An interface circuit that transmits a The smallest positioning increment Weight
signal with no direct electrical achievable. In digitally programmed Force of gravity acting on a body.
connection. systems it is the smallest specifiable Determined by multiplying the mass
positioning increment. of the object by the acceleration due
to gravity.
Inertia (Rotary)
B lb-ft-s2 or
A gm-cm2 oz-in2 gm-cm-s2 kg-cm2 lb-in2 oz-in-s2 lb-ft2 kg-cm-s2 lb-in-s2 slug-ft-s2
gm-cm2 1 5.46x10-2 1.01x10-3 10-3 3.417x10-4 1.41x10-5 2.37x10-6 1.01x10-4 8.85x10-7 7.37x10-4
oz-in2 182.9 1 .186 .182 .0625 2.59x10-3 4.34x10-4 1.86x10-4 1.61x10-4 1.34x10-5
gm-cm-s2 980.6 5.36 1 .9806 .335 1.38x10-2 2.32x10-3 10-3 8.67x10-4 7.23x10-5
kg-cm2 1000 5.46 1.019 1 .3417 1.41x10-2 2.37x10-3 1.019x10-3 8.85x10-4 7.37x10-5
oz-in-s2 7.06x104 386.08 72.0 70.615 24.13 1 .1675 7.20x10-2 6.25x10-2 5.20x10-3
lb-ft2 4.21x105 2304 429.71 421.40 144 5.967 1 .4297 .3729 3.10x10-2
Engineering
kg-cm-s2 9.8x105 5.36x103 1000 980.66 335.1 13.887 2.327 1 .8679 7.23x10-2
Angular Velocity
B deg/s rad/s rpm rps
A
deg/s 1 1.75 x 10-2 .167 2.78 x 10-3
rad/s 57.3 1 9.55 .159
rpm 6 .105 1 1.67 x 10-2
rps 360 6.28 60 1
Linear Velocity
B in/min ft/min in/sec ft/sec mm/sec m/sec
A
in/min 1 .0833 .0167 1.39 x10-3 0.42 4.2 x10-4
ft/min 12 1 .2 .0167 5.08 5.08 x10-3
in/sec 60 5 1 .083 25.4 .0254
ft/sec 720 60 12 1 304.8 .3048
cm/sec 23.62 1.97 .3937 .0328 10 0.01
m 2362.2 196.9 39.37 3.281 1000 1
Engineering
N = Newton deka da 101 10
gm = gram
— — 100 1
gm(f) = gram force oz(f) = ounce force
deci d 10-1 .1
HP = Horse Power oz(m) = ounce mass
centi c 10-2 .01
in = inch rad = radians
milli m 10-3 .001
kg = kilogram rpm = revs per minute
micro µ 10-6 .000001
kg(f) = kilogram force rps = revs per second nano n 10-9 .000000001
KW = Kilowatt s = seconds
Mass
B gm kg slug lb(m) oz(m)
A
-5 -3
gm 1 .001 6.852x10 2.205x10 .03527
-2
kg 1000 1 6.852x10 2.205 35.274
slug 14590 14.59 1 32.2 514.72
lb(m) 453.6 .45359 .0311 1 16
oz(m) 28.35 .02835 1.94x10-3 .0625 1
Force
B
A lb(f) N dyne oz(f) kg(f) gm(f)
lb(f) 1 4.4482 4.448 x 105 16 .45359 453.6
N .22481 1 100.000 3.5967 .10197 ——
-6 -5
dyne 2.248 x10 .00001 1 3.59x10 —— 980.6
Engineering
4
oz(f) .0625 .27801 2.78x10 1 .02835 28.35
kg(f) 2.205 9.80665 ——
35.274 1 1000
-3 -3
gm(f) 2.205x10 —— 1.02x10 .03527 .001 1
Note: lb(f) = 1slug x 1 ft/s2 N = 1kg x 1 m/s2 dyne = 1gm x 1 cm/s2
Power
B
A Watts KW HP(english) HP(metric) ft-lb/s in-lb/s
Watts 1 1 x 10-3 1.34 x 10-3 1.36 x 10-3 .74 8.88
KW 1000 1 1.34 1.36 738 8880
HP(english) 746 .746 1 1.01 550 6600
HP(metric) 736 .736 .986 1 543 6516
-3 -3 -3
ft-lb/s 1.35 1.36 x 10 1.82 x 10 1.84 x 10 1 12
-4 -4 -4 -2
in-lb/s .113 1.13 x 10 1.52 x 10 1.53 x 10 8.3 x 10 1
Engineering
“B” Motor Shaft Length* 0.810 1.250 1.380
ØC
“C” Pilot Diameter 1.500 2.875 2.186
“D” Pilot Length* 0.062 0.062 0.062
“E” Mounting Bolt Circle 2.625 3.875 4.950
ØF Hole (4x) D
“F” Bolt Hole Size 0.195 0.218 0.218 Equally Spaced
on a "E" Dia B.C.
B
Company Company
Phone Phone
Fax Fax
Email E-mail
Address Address
In production Year 3:
Action Required
Loads
Fn
Payload Carriage Loads My
Orientation
(Rodless only)
Weight lbs Mp Vertical
Mp in-lbs Mr
Payload Externally Supported, Horizontal
by (rails, etc.) Mr in-lbs Fs
Inclined °
My in-lbs (angle from
Hold Position:
After move Power off Side Load lbs horizontal plane)
Motion
Thrust
Thrust = ForceACCELERATED MASS + ForceFRICTION + ForceGRAVITY + ForceEXTERNAL
Engineering
lbs = lbs + lbs + lbs + lbs
Duty Cycle/Life
Environment
R2 L Gear Ratio
R R1
L Gearhead Inertia
(reflected to pinion) oz-in-sec2
Radius (R): in Weight of Cylinder oz Efficiency %
Inner Radius (R1) in Length (L) in Radius of Pinion in Radius of Driven Gear in
Outer Radius (R2) in Weight of Pinion oz Weight of Driven Gear oz
Density of Material oz /in3 Radial load on output shaft lbf
Type of Material Distance of radial load from gearhead face in
Will a gearbox be used? Yes / No / Not Sure Axial load on output shaft lbf
Orientation
Move Requirements
Horiz Vertical Incline:
Distance from Cylinder CL to Motor Face in Move Distance inches revs of motor
Move Time secs
Tangential Drive System
Required Motor Peak Speed rev/s
W F Required Accel Time secs
Required Decel Time secs
Minimum Motor Speed rev/s
Accuracy arcminutes, degrees, or inches
R
Repeatability arcminutes, degrees, or inches
Radius (R) in Duty Cycle (%) Time in Motion
Efficiency of belt or chain Total Cycle Time
Weight of load Cycle Time secs
plus belt or chain (W) lbf Maximum Continuous Time in Motion secs
Weight of Pulleys lbf Friction (F) lbf
Will a gearbox be used? Yes / No / Not Sure Cabling Requirements
Belt Tension lbf Length of Motor / Encoder Cable Required ft
Will pulleys be supported by external bearings? Yes / No Will cable be moving in application? Yes / No
Engineering
Leadscrew System
Environment
W
Operating Temperature
D
L Normal 32-140°F [0-60°C]
High Temp. °F / °C
Orientation Low Temp. °F / °C
Horiz Vertical Incline:
Contaminants (Check all that apply)
Ball Screw Acme Screw Other Solid:
Efficiency of Screw non-abrasive coarse chips
Pitch of Screw revs /in abrasive fine dust
Length of Screw (L) in Liquid:
Diameter of Screw (D) in dripping non-corrosive splashing
mist / spray corrosive high pressure
Weight of Load (W) lbf
Running Friction Coefficient (Load/Surface) Conditions
Washdown Outdoor
Breakaway Force lbf
Vacuum Cleanroom
Will a gearbox be used? Yes / No / Not Sure
Interface
Host PLC Computer
Analog I/O RS232
Digital I/O Control
Other
( ) Operator
Time Keypad/LCD Display
or Pushbuttons
Distance
Potentiometer/Joystick
Thumbwheels
Supply Voltage
110 AC 220 AC
Other
Engineering
Output Functions