Qualitative Forecasting Models Explained
Qualitative Forecasting Models Explained
possible.
It allows for making administrative decisions regarding planning and products, plants, and processes.
9. Briefly describe the Delphi method. How could someone use it?
There are three types of participants in the Delphi method: decision makers, staff, and the
interviewees. The first ones are usually a group of 5 to 10 experts who will be developing the
real forecast. The staff assists decision-makers by preparing, distributing, collecting and
summarize the series of questionnaires and the results of the surveys. The interviewees form a
a group of people, often located in different places, whose judgments are valued. This group
provides information to decision-makers before making the forecast.
10. What is the main difference between a time series model and a causal model?
A time series model predicts under the assumption that the future is a function of
past, while the associative or causal model incorporates the variables or factors that
they can influence the amount to be forecasted.
12. What effect does the value of the smoothing constant have on the weighting given to the values?
recent
When choosing the values of the smoothing constant, the goal is to obtain the forecast.
more precise based on the most recent data
14. Which forecasting technique gives more importance to recent values? How is this achieved?
The weighted average technique gives a weighting to the observations, giving more weight to the...
importance to recent data, by giving greater weight to it.
Signals are monitored, which when they have a variation outside of the
previously established limits, an automatic adjustment is made by computer
control signal.
18. What is the difference between a dependent variable and an independent variable?
Dependent variables: they are characteristics of reality that are determined or
that depend on the values assumed by other phenomena or independent variables.
One of the reasons why companies would not want to depend on seasonality is because
they find it difficult to forecast their demand.
21. What happens to our ability to forecast when we forecast periods each
more distant in the future?
In long-term forecasting, several variables that can affect are being ignored.
results, such as the temporal peaks, which are unforeseen and affect the forecast, this
helps more with creation.
Problems
12
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Demand Forecast
20
15
10
b)
i. It is anticipated that there will be 23 sales in January.
ii. Moving average
̂= +
∑ − ̅̅
= 2−
∑ ̅2
= 1.8275
= ̅ − bx̅ = 6.288
̂( ) = 30.05
c) It is recommended to use the exponential smoothing method, as it is closer to a
value that is within the sales
9. Resume the solved problem 4.1 on page 140. Use a 3-year moving average to
forecast the sales of Volkswagen Beetle in Nevada during 2008. What is the MAD?
The sales of the popular Volkswagen (VW) Beetle have grown steadily.
during the last 5 years in the establishments of Nevada (see the table below).
The sales manager forecasted in 2002 that sales for 2003 would be 410 VW.
exponential smoothing with a weighting α = .30 to develop the
forecasts from 2004 to 2008.
2004 495
2005 518
2 75.33
2006 563 487
3
1 58.67
2007 584 525
3
2008 ? 555
450 + 495 + 518 2
ó 2006 = = 487
3 3
495 + 518 + 563 1
ó 2007 = = 525
3 3
12. In problems 4.10 and 4.11, three forecasts of the enrollments were developed.
seminar on: 3-year moving average, weighted moving average, and smoothing
exponential. With MAD as a criterion, which of the three forecasting methods is better? Explain.
your answer.
1 4 5,00 1.00
2 6 4,70 1.30
3 4 5.09 1.09
15. Take up the solved problem 4.1 from page 140. Use a 3-year moving average to
forecast the sales of Volkswagen Beetle in Nevada during 2008. What is the MAD?
∑
ó : −−−− =3
18. Return to problem 4.1 and to problems 4.15 and 4.16. With MAD as the criterion.
Would you use exponential smoothing with a smoothing constant of .3 as shown in the
problem solved 4.1, a 3-year moving average, or I would use the trend to predict the
sales of Volkswagen Beetle? Explain your answer
∑| |
=
Method MAD
Exponential smoothing 74.55
Moving average 32.33
Trend 41.2
In the table, it can be observed that the moving average method has a smaller error, therefore,
moving average would be used to forecast sales.
24. The operations manager of a musical instrument distributor believes that the
demand for drums may be related to the number of television appearances of
popular rock group Green Shades during the past month. The manager has gathered the
data shown in the following table:
a) Create a graph with this data to see if a linear equation could describe the relationship
between the group's appearances on TV and the sale of drums. b) Use the regression method of
least squares to obtain a forecasting equation. c) What would be your estimate of the
Sales of drums if Green Shades had appeared 9 times on TV last month?
b.
Appearances in
Demand of
Green TV
bombs x squared
Shades xy
3 3 9 9
4 6 24 36
7 7 49 49
6 5 30 25
8 10 80 100
5 8 40 64
232 − 6(5,5)(6,5)
= =1
( )2
199− 6 5.5
= 10
The sales estimate would be 10 drums
The table presents the data on the number of transistors (in millions) manufactured in a
Japan's plant over the last 5 years:
a) Predict the number of transistors that will be manufactured next year using regression.
linear.
b) Calculate the mean squared error (MSE) when using linear regression.
c) Calculate the mean absolute percentage error (MAPE).
a) Linear regression
̂= +
∑ − ̅̅
= 2−
∑ ̅2
x̅ = 3 ; ̅ = 180;∑ = 2880∑ 2= 55
= 18
= ̅− ̅ = 126
̂ (6 )= 234
b) MSE
2
∑| |
= = 32
c) MAPE
| − |
100 ∑
= = 2.65
36. The accountants of the firm Doke and Reed believe that some executives were including
in their accounts, expense vouchers of unusually high amounts when they returned from their trips.
business. First, they took a sample of 200 vouchers issued during last year.
They then developed the following multiple regression equation to relate the cost.
expected from the trip with the number of travel days (x1) and the distance traveled (x2) in miles:
= + . + .
The calculated correlation coefficient was 0.68.
If Bill Tomlinson returns from a 300-mile trip that took him 5 days away from the city, what
Is it the expected amount that should be requested for expenses? b) Tomlinson submitted a request for
Refund of 685 dollars. What should the accountant do? c) Should other variables be included?
Which ones? Why?
a.
The accountant must review the additional expenses that Tomlinson considered because there is a
difference between what was requested and the actual value obtained in the first item
Using trend analysis, forecast the number of patients that Dr. Sweeney
It will serve in years 11 and 12. How well does the model fit the data?
= +
= 29.235 + 3.419x
( 11=) 29.235 +113.419( = 66.84
)
( 12=) 29.235 +123.419( =70.26
)
42. Des Moines Power and Light has collected the data on the demand for electric power in its
western subregion only for the last 2 years. The information is shown in the following table
To plan an expansion and agree on the energy loan with other service companies
public during peak periods, Des Moines needs to be able to forecast the
demand for each month for the next year. However, the standard forecasting models
analyzed in this chapter do not fit the data observed over the 2 years.
What are the weaknesses of standard forecasting techniques when applied to this series?
data?
Since the known models are not really suitable for this case, please make a proposal.
to approach the forecast. Although there is no perfect solution for managing data from
this type (in other words, there are no answers that are 100% correct or incorrect),
justify your model.
It is suggested to use the weighted method. With this method, what is done is
determine an average by adding the existing values in the inventory with
values of the new purchases, to then divide it by the number of units
existing in the inventory including both those initially existing and those of
the new purchase
Forecast the demand for each month of next year with the model you proposed.
45. The Dubuque East School District is trying to forecast its teacher needs.
kindergarten for the next 5 years. The district has birth data and
registrations from the last 10 years. The registrations occur 5 years after the births.
Forecast the enrollments for the next 2 years, according to the data from the last
10 years:
̂= +
∑ − ̅̅
= 2−
∑ ̅2
= −3.412
= ̅− ̅ = 111.9333
̂ (11=)74.401
̂ (12=)70.989
For the forecast of enrollments, multiple regression is used, where data was inputted.
to Excel to obtain the parameters of the equation:
̂= + 1 1+ 2 2
= 147.8945
1= -1.08116
2= −0.0149
( 11,74.401=) 134.89
( 1270.989 )= 133.8628
48. Sundar Balakrishnan, general manager of Precision Engineering Corporation (PEC), believes that
the engineering services that road construction companies hire your
the company is directly related to the business volume of road construction
that hires companies in its geographical area. It wonders if it really is this way, and if
It is, would this information help plan your operations better if you forecast the amount
of the engineering services required by construction companies in each quarter of
year? The following table presents the sales data of your services and the total amounts
of the construction contracts for roads from the last 8 quarters:
a) With this data, develop a regression equation to predict the level of demand for
the PEC services.
Trimestre Ventas servicios de PEC (en miles) Contratos firmados (en miles de dólares)
1 8 153
2 10 172
3 15 197
4 9 178
5 12 185
6 13 199
7 12 205
8 16 226
Coefficients
Interception -21.5848283
Variable X 1 -0.86852477
Variable X 2 0.19732377
=− . − . + .