Understanding Situated Learning and PBL
Understanding Situated Learning and PBL
it refers to the sociocultural context as a key element for the acquisition of skills
and skills, seeking the solution to daily challenges always with a collective vision.
Situated learning aims to encourage teamwork and cooperative work through projects.
problem-oriented that require the application of analytical methods that take into account
all kinds of relationships and connections. This necessarily implies active participation and
student's awareness.
"Discal (2005) notes that in situated learning, the construction of knowledge is conceived
as a practice in experience, so learning involves getting involved in a community
in practice. In this way, the social context becomes relevant because learning takes place in
he, and by allowing students to apply what they have learned in relevant real-life situations,
they favor the contextualization of learning, allowing it to become teaching
significatva" (Benavides, P. et. al. 2009)
Returning to Vygotsky, the situated learning approach considers that the social construction of
reality is based on cognition and practical action that takes place in everyday life;
highlights the importance of environments, of spoken expression and recognizes the importance of
informal teaching situations. (Lamas)
It is based on the idea that 'learning and doing are inseparable actions and consequently, a
the nuclear principle of this approach states that students (learners or novices) must learn
in the relevant context, privileging educational practices aimed at knowing how more than
to know what” (Lamas)
Project method.
Problem-based learning
In a strict sense, PBL does not require the inclusion of the solution to the situation or problem.
presented. At the beginning of a subject, the student does not have sufficient knowledge and
skills that allow them, effectively, to solve the problem. The objective, in these stages,
that the student is able to discover what they need to know in order to progress in the resolution of
the proposed question (diagnosis of learning needs). Throughout the process
educational, as the student progresses through the program it is expected that he/she becomes competent in
plan and carry out interventions that will ultimately allow you to solve the problem of
appropriate form (knowledge construction). And all this, working cooperatively.
The ABP facilitates, or forces, interdisciplinarity and the integration of knowledge, crossing through the
barriers arising from fragmented knowledge in disciplines and subjects.
Knowledge is developed through the recognition and acceptance of social processes and
of the evaluation of the different individual interpretations of the same phenomenon.
The ABP includes the development of critical thinking in the same teaching process.
learning is not incorporated as something additional, but rather it is a constitutive part of such a process.
It is useful to compare this proposal to traditional teaching with the aim of
visualize the substantial differences between both:
The teachers convey the information to the students. The students take responsibility for
learn and create alliances between student and teacher
The teacher assumes the role of expert or formal authority. Teachers have the role of facilitator.
tutor, guide, co-learner, mentor, or advisor.
The process of organizing all teaching techniques involves the existence of certain conditions.
for its operation. In the case of the ABP, as it is a form of work that involves a great
the number of variables, those conditions become particularly important. Next, the
they describe some desirable conditions for work in PBL:
Emphasize the development of attitudes and skills that seek the active acquisition of new ones.
knowledge and not just the memorization of existing knowledge.
Generate a suitable environment for the group (six to eight students) of participants to be able to
to work collaboratively to solve common problems analytically, in addition
promote the participation of teachers as tutors in the discussion process and in the
learning.
Open to the group the responsibility of identifying and prioritizing learning topics based on
of diagnosing their own needs.
Basically, the fundamental difference between traditional learning and PBL lies in the
linear character of the learning process that is generated in the first and the cyclical character of
second. In traditional learning, the identification of learning needs and the
The presentation of knowledge is the responsibility of the teacher (it has a beginning and an end in the activity
teacher). In the PBL, the student takes on the leading role by identifying their needs.
learning and seeking knowledge to respond to a posed problem, which in turn
generates new learning needs.
Morales and Landa (2004) establish that the development of the ABP process occurs in eight phases:
Read and analyze the problem: it is sought that students understand the statement and what is asked of them.
demand.
Conduct a brainstorming session: it assumes that students become aware of the situation they are in.
they face.
Make a list of what is not known: this step aims to make conscious what is not.
they know and what they will need to solve the problem, it is even desirable that they can formulate
questions that guide the resolution of the problem.
Make a list of what needs to be done to solve the problem: the students must
consider the actions to be taken to achieve the resolution.
Define the problem: it specifically addresses the problem they are going to solve and in which they are going to be involved.
center.
Obtain information: here it is expected that students will distribute the search tasks.
information.
Present results: in this step, it is expected that the students who have worked in groups
study and understand, while sharing the information obtained in step 7; and, for
Lastly, let them prepare that information together in order to resolve the situation.
proposed.
Other authors, such as Exley and Dennick (2007), make another classification of the phases of PBL. They
they indicate that there are seven phases that make up Problem-Based Learning:
The most notable difference between this classification and the one previously presented is that, in the
lastly, the students first define the problems presented in the exercise and afterwards they
They raise questions, hypotheses, those aspects they know, what is unknown and
They will have to investigate, etc. It is essential that students know the steps they must take.
continue to solve the problem and also that the student who takes on the role of the moderator
the organizer should guide the group in each of them.
In the traditional educational process, the teacher explains a specific topic of the subject they teach and,
subsequently offers students an activity to apply these contents. In
On the contrary, PBL is proposed as a means for students to acquire those
knowledge and apply it to solve a real or fictitious problem, without the teacher
having given a previous class or having used another method to convey that content, are the
own students, those who take on the responsibility of being active participants in the process of
learning.
Project-based learning helps students develop and work on various skills. Among them, authors such as
de Miguel (2005), Prieto (2006), Benito and Cruz (2005) highlight:
Problem solving.
Decision making.
Teamwork.
The awareness of one's own learning. They take on the responsibility of being an active part in the process.
Critical thinking.
Self-directed learning.
Lifelong learning.
The research skills since students in the learning process will have to,
start from a statement, search for and manage information to find out and understand what it is
go and achieve a suitable solution.
Project-Based Learning
The method consists of carrying out a project, usually of considerable size and in
group. That project has been previously analyzed by the professor to ensure that the
alumni have everything necessary to solve it, and in its resolution, they will develop all the
skills that are desired.
The development of the project starts with a generating question. This should not have a
simple answer based on information, but requires the exercise of critical thinking for
its resolution. The project helps to model critical thinking and provides scaffolding for
students learn to perform the cognitive tasks that characterize critical thinking.
Examples of critical thinking are: judging between alternatives, seeking the most efficient path.
to carry out a task, weigh the evidence, review the original ideas, develop a plan or summarize
the most important points of an argument.5
The main benefits reported by some authors of this model to learning include:
Students develop skills and competencies such as collaboration, problem-solving
projects, communication, decision-making, and time management (Blank, 1997; Dickinsion et al,
1998).
Integration between school learning and reality. Students retain a greater amount.
of knowledge and skills when they are engaged in stimulating projects.
Through projects, students make use of higher-order mental skills in
place to memorize data in isolated contexts, offline. Emphasis is placed on when and where
can be used in the real world (Blank, 1997; Botoms & Webb, 1998; Reyes, 1998).
Boosting self-esteem. Students take pride in achieving something that has value outside of the
classroom and making contributions to the school or community (Jobs for the Future).
To enhance individual learning strengths and their different approaches and styles towards
objectives of its implementation
Organize activities around a common goal, defined by the interests of the students and with
the commitment made by them.
Let students experience the ways of interacting that the current world demands.
Positively combine the learning of fundamental content and the development of skills
that increase autonomy in learning.
The development of the person; students acquire experience and the spirit of working in groups.
as they are in contact with the project.
Satisfying a social need, which strengthens the values and commitment of the student with the
environment.
The theory of social learning is derived from the work ofCornell Montgomery(1843-1904),
who proposed that social learning occurred through four main stages:
close contact, imitation of superiors, understanding of concepts, and
behavior of the role model.
1787: Observations directed at knowing what type of education children need.
Julian B. Rotterhe distanced himself from the theories based on thepsychosisand of theconductismradical, and
developed a theory of learning based on interaction. In Social Learning and Clinical
Psychology (1954), Rotter suggests that the outcome of behavior has an impact on the
motivation of people to engage in that specific behavior. People want to avoid
the negative consequences, and obtain the positive ones. If one expects a positive outcome from
a behavior, or thinks that there is a high possibility that it will produce a positive outcome,
then there will be more chances of executing that behavior. The behavior is reinforced with
positive consequences, leading the person to repeat it. This theory of social learning
suggests that behavior is influenced by factors or stimuli from the environment, and not solely
for the psychological ones.1
Albert Bandura (1977) expanded Rotter's idea,2like that of a previous job from
Miller and Dollard (1941)3and is related to Vygotsky's social learning theories and
Lave. Her theory encompasses aspects of cognitive and behavioral learning. Learning
Behavioral assumes that the environment of people causes them to behave in a
determined way. Cognitive learning assumes that psychological factors are
important influences on people's behaviors. Social learning suggests that
A combination of environmental (social) and psychological factors influence behavior.
social learning theory indicates three requirements for people to learn and model
his behavior: retention (remembering what one has observed), reproduction (ability to
reproduce the behavior) and motivation (a good reason) to want to adopt that behavior.
Learning strategies. Combination of methods, means, and didactic mediations.
used by instructors-tutors and learners to facilitate learning and obtaining
of the results defined in the curricular design. A strategy consists of selecting the
skills most appropriate for each situation and apply them appropriately.
Facilitating learning requires planning. To do this, attention will be focused on three
of the most important contemporary psychological currents that have tried to explain
said process in humans: they are behavioral, cognitive, and
constructivists. It is important to emphasize that no particular theory will be highlighted.
it explains better said process, but rather from the analysis of the postulates of each one
from them, the learning facilitator will determine the characteristics of the elements of
instructional process in a specified learning situation and in such a way, verify the
effectiveness of its applicability.
it is an approach that seeks to organize activities within the classroom to turn them into a
social and academic learning experience. Students work in groups to carry out the
tasks collectively.
Although in the pedagogical literature tends to be seen the relationship between collaborative learning and cooperative learning.
as synonyms, according to authors like Panitz 'The essential difference between these two processes of
learning is that in the first, the students are the ones who design their structure of interactions and
they maintain control over the different decisions that impact their learning, while
in the second, it is the teacher who designs and maintains almost completely the control in the
structure of interactions and the results that are to be obtained.
In cooperative learning, different types of learning channels are involved. One can
indicate that the channels that prevail in this learning stage are the visual, auditory, and
kinesthetic.
Index
2 References
3 See also
4 External links
Group formation: These are heterogeneous groups, ideally consisting of 4 members with diverse backgrounds.
niveles de competencia, donde se debe construir una identdad de grupo, práctca de la ayuda
mutual and the valuing of individuality for the creation of a synergy.
Individual responsibility: The result as a group will ultimately be the consequence of the
individual research of the members. This will be appreciated in the public presentation of the task.
carried out.
Equitable participation. The work that needs to be done is distributed among all members.
of the team in an equitable way (proportional to each one's capabilities).
Simultaneous interaction. In the task resolution, all students dialogue, contrast their
opinions and make consensual decisions.
In addition, according to Jordi Adell and Auxi Sales (1999), cooperative learning 'promotes democracy.'
and the solidarity in the group and the autonomy in the organization of one's own learning.
In order for the above points to be consolidated, it is necessary for the teacher to have developed the
skills related to the anticipation of actions. This is: to foresee; to be clear about the
procedure for obtaining a concrete result from both the teaching material and the
written, for the execution of the activity at any stage of the work. Giving or receiving
help does not improve learning in groups, but rather the awareness of needing it, to communicate
this need to integrate the help offered into the work itself (Guadalupe Gómez-Pezuela
Gamboa, 2007). This is how cooperative work contributes to the development of skills.
communication, teamwork, and flexibility in thinking.
Social Networks on the Internet and Collaborative Learning
By analyzing the characteristics and results of collaborative work, it is understood that the process begins
With cooperative work and as it is put into practice, thinking is stimulated.
superior, the use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) is assimilated
a collaborative level. In this way, social networks on the internet are appreciated as a
companion in the evolution of thought if they are used properly in education.
However, it is also important to emphasize that for social networks and ICTs to be able to
to be effective in the classroom, it is necessary to adequately prepare teachers, since not
it's just about introducing them to that methodology and having them work as best they can, otherwise
they need training that indicates the proper and correct way to use ICTs
in the classroom so that they can carry out the teaching process in a way that does not
not only favors their teaching process, but also collaborative learning in the
students.
To work collaboratively, it must be accepted that each student is different and one cannot expect
that always has the same implication nor contributes the same. This system embraces the
individual potentialities, making each participant's contribution to the process key.
Digital technologies can facilitate collaboration by enhancing group work and dialogue.
and learning from others and with others.
Currently, the largest collaborative resource found on the web is the use of Wikipedia.
Additionally, the creation and use of are proposed within collaborative learning models.
audioblogs and tvblogs (Podcastng) as it has been shown that students who carry out these
activities develop skills related to the mastery of audiovisual languages
they collaborate in teams and increase their capacity for self-criticism.
Raise awareness