Tagore and Gandhi: Educational Philosophies
Tagore and Gandhi: Educational Philosophies
Bce
Tagore
Rabindranath Tagore is a world-famous poet and is popularly known as "Gurudev", according to him,
to make education meaningful, the child should be in touch with the economic, intellectual,
social, aesthetic, and spiritual life of people.
According to Tagore, the main aim of education is to achieve fulfilment and completeness. Education
should aim at promoting an all-round development of children and achieving. He emphasized
that education is not intellectual development alone; it should also develop aesthetic nature and
creativity among children.
It can be noticed that the idea of Tagore is similar to the ideas of Rousseau and Dewey. He
considered that education in India would be successful only when there is proper integration of
the Eastern and Western cultures which preserved all the values of the past with the new values
of today.
He argued for a humane educational system that was in close touch with the environment and
aimed at the overall development of the personality. He spread that the learning of a child must
be filled with joy and pleasure.
encourage and foster freedom of thought, independent spirit, and free will
promote the moral and spiritual development of an individual, and liberate him from different
kinds of bondages
make the younger generation aware of their national cultural heritage and grasp its significance
for them; enable them to appreciate the cultures of other countries too and also to learn from
them
develop the individual personality as well as the social characteristics,
Child-Centered Learning:
Natural Growth: Tagore compares his educational idea to a seed that grows into a plant,
emphasizing that education should evolve naturally rather than being rigidly structured.
Personal Love: He believes that a child's relationship with the world should be one of personal
love and connection, rather than mechanical and impersonal.
Holistic Development:
Integration with Nature: Tagore's school emphasizes the importance of children being close to
nature. He criticizes traditional schools for taking children away from the natural world and
confining them to artificial environments.
Harmony with the World: Education should help children understand their place in a harmonious
world, fostering a sense of unity and connection with their surroundings.
Learning Through Experience: Tagore advocates for experiential learning, where children engage
with their environment and learn through direct experiences rather than rote memorization.
Teacher-Student Relationship: He highlights the traditional Indian system where students lived
with their teachers, learning through shared life experiences. This relationship is based on mutual
respect and spiritual growth.
Spiritual and Moral Education: Tagore emphasizes the importance of spiritual development
alongside intellectual growth. He believes that education should cultivate the soul and moral
values.
Mechanical Discipline: Traditional schools are criticized for their focus on uniformity and
discipline, which suppresses creativity and individual growth.
Intellectual Fragmentation: Tagore points out that conventional education often separates
intellectual learning from spiritual and physical development, leading to a disjointed and
incomplete understanding of life.
Self-Respect and Inner Light: Tagore sees education as a means to develop self-respect and inner
wisdom, rather than merely preparing for material success.
Global Contribution: He believes that India has a rich heritage of spiritual wisdom that should be
preserved and shared with the world as a contribution to global well-being.
Practical Difficulties: Tagore acknowledges the challenges in implementing his educational ideals,
including human nature and external circumstances.
Continuous Effort: He asserts that education is a continuous process that requires dedication and
belief in the principles of freedom and holistic growth.
Mahatma Gandhi
Gandhi’s basic education is also known as “nai talim”. It is a principle that integrates knowledge and
work. It aims to help children identify their basic identity and includes primary and secondary
education. It emphasizes values such as morality, simplicity, truth, and non-violence. His
philosophy is broad in the sense that there was a fusion of three important philosophical
doctrines - naturalism, idealism, and pragmatism, idealistic in its aim, and pragmatic in its method
and program of work. Gandhi believed in creating a universal community of free individuals
without artificial barriers based on caste, creed, color, wealth, or power, promoting the
brotherhood of humanity”. He believed in simple living and high thinking.
Gandhi's basic education was an idea of his understanding of an ideal society consisting of small,
self-reliant communities with his ideal citizen being an industrious, self-respecting, and generous
individual living in a small cooperative community.
According to Gandhiji, education means 'an all-round drawing out of the best in the child and man
body, mind and spirit'. Hence, he believed in the total development of the human personality
through education. In his view, vocational efficiency, and cultural spiritual, and character
development are the aims of education. He emphasized craft-centered education, which included
training of both the mind and the body.
education should promote cultural development, as it is more important than literary development.
Emphasized the education of 3 Hs - Hand, Head, and Heart - rather than the education of 3 Rs,
(reading, writing, and arithmetic). Spiritual development is one of the important aims of
Gandhian education.
According to him, self-realization is the ultimate goal of education and it should be achieved along
with the educational goal of preparation for life. Gandhi believed that an individual can develop
himself to the fullest extent only in society and a society cannot grow without the well-being of
its individuals.
Individual as well as social developments are mutually related or interdependent.
He imagined every school as a community center where students would be trained in social service
and provided with facilities to develop their potential. He called for universal, free, and
compulsory education within the age group of 7-14. He also allocated citizenship education for a
democratic society.
Introduction:
1. Work-Centric Education:
Description: Nai Talim emphasizes that education should revolve around productive work or
vocations that are relevant to the child's immediate environment. Examples include agriculture,
weaving, and other local crafts.
Key Points:
Learning through work helps children understand the value of labor and develop practical skills.
This approach ensures that education is directly linked to the economic and social context of the
child's community.
2. 3Hs Approach:
Description: Nai Talim focuses on the comprehensive development of the child by engaging the
Head (intellectual), Heart (emotional), and Hand (practical skills).
Key Points:
Intellectual development through critical thinking and problem-solving.
Emotional development through values, empathy, and community service.
Practical skills through hands-on activities and vocational training.
4. Moral Principles:
Description: Education should have strong moral values such as truth, love, and non-violence.
Key Points:
Moral education is integrated through stories, songs, and activities that reflect ethical living.
Children learn the importance of integrity, respect, and social responsibility.
Description: Combining education in the mother tongue with practical craft work.
Key Points:
Engages children in meaningful activities while learning.
Strengthens linguistic skills alongside vocational abilities.
2. Vocational Needs:
Description: Education should address the vocational needs specific to the child's community.
Key Points:
Tailors learning about local economic activities and opportunities.
Prepares children for productive roles within their community.
3. Integrated Learning:
Community Interaction:
Children learn local history and geography by interacting with their community.
This fosters a sense of belonging and practical knowledge of their environment.
Real-World Applications:
Science and math concepts are taught through everyday activities, like farming or cooking.
This contextual approach makes abstract concepts tangible and understandable.
Combines intellectual and manual work to promote the dignity of labor and equality.
Encourages self-sufficiency and independence among students.
2. Character Building:
3. Community Integration:
4. Environmental Awareness:
Modern Relevance:
Provides practical solutions to unemployment and social isolation by teaching marketable skills.
Prepares students for real-world challenges and self-employment opportunities.
Supports initiatives like Make in India and Digital India by emphasizing local production and self-
reliance.
Encourages the use of technology and innovation in vocational education.
Conclusion:
Nai Talim transforms education into a community-centered and holistic experience. Integrating
intellectual, emotional, and practical development, it prepares children to become responsible
and self-reliant members of society. The principles of Nai Talim, rooted in moral values and real-
world relevance, remain significant and adaptable, addressing modern educational needs and
societal challenges.
Krishnamurti
He was influenced by Maria Montessori's method of teaching.
The teacher and facilitator are the secondary partners in their development task. A child’s inner
guide is the primary partner, it is a positive force in their development.
According to Krishnamurti children must be allowed to choose their activities for themselves. They
gradually develop self-discipline and the ability to concentrate through exercising their will in the
classroom.
Krishnamurti views that when the child develops discipline and concentration by giving attention to
things of their own choice, they are ready and able to concentrate on the material given to them.
He believes that the child must group up as a two-sided human being i.e. inwardly and outwardly.
When he talks about a total human being with inward understanding, that means the capacity to
explore, to examine his inward being, his inward state, and the capacity to go beyond it but also
someone good in what he does outwardly. The two must go together.
Krishnamurti's on discipline is, not something from outside that has been imposed upon the child
and according to which he tries to conform, but it is an intrinsic value.
Education is not to fit into society and their culture, real education means that a human mind is not
only capable of being excellent in maths, geography, and history but also can never be under any
circumstances.
Educate in the real scene of that word, not to transmit from the teachers to the students. Some
information about mathematics or history or geography, but in the very instruction of these
subjects to bring about a change of mind.
Krishnamurti criticized conventional education, which makes independent thinking extremely
difficult and hinders one's understanding of oneself as a total process.
According to him, the purpose of education is not to produce ordinary scholars, technicians, and job
hunters but to integrate men and women who are mature, free of fear, and who have self-
awareness, love, and goodness. In Krishnamurti's view, another aim of education is to cultivate
the right kind of relationship, not only between individuals but also between the individual and
society. True education enables one to understand the deep significance of the human life.
Gijubhai bhadeka
Gijubhai was influenced by the theoretical base of Maria Montessori and evolved his own method,
rejecting the traditional way of educating children. According to Gijubhai: a child is a complete
person who has intellect, emotions, mind and understanding, strengths and weaknesses, likes
and dislikes'. It is very important to understand the emotions of the child and create an
atmosphere where children learn from each other through play, stories, and songs without the
fear of formal examinations and gradations. He preferred the word 'Mandir' to 'school' just to
indicate that it is a place where the child would not be beaten, or insulted. Gijubhai was emphatic
in saying that instead of imposing adult ideas on children they must be allowed to learn
something by doing/playing according to their age and interest.
John Dewey
John Dewey was the most significant American philosopher and the most influential thinker on
education of the first half of the 20" century. His concern with interaction, reflection and
experience, and interest in community and democracy, were brought together to form a highly
suggestive educational philosophy, Dewey considered education as a process through which the
needed transformation of society may be accomplished. He referred to education as a "social
need and function", as a "process of living and growth" which includes both social and individual
aspects that are mutually dependent on each other.
From the social viewpoint, education is essential to the continuous existence and transformation of
the organization of social life in all grades. From the individual perspective, it is a method to
enable individuals to play an effective role as members of a human community or society.
According to him," Education is the process of reconstruction of experience, giving it a more
socialized value through the medium of increased individual efficiency.
Education for democracy and this he considered one of the goals of education, to help people
become more effective members of a democratic society.
Education should be designed on the basis of a theory of experience whose two basic views are
continuity and interaction. Dewey describes school as a unique social institution that should
basically emphasize learning through and in relation to living on the whole, thus including and
connecting principally every aspect of human life on earth.
He said that Children come to school not as blank slates upon which teachers might write the lessons
of civilization, but with an infinite variety of experiences, which require the right direction for a
meaningful life Children come for formal education with the basic natural desires- to
communicate, to construct, to inquire and to express in better form - and these are to be
activated to promote active-growth of the child. Thus, he recommended 'learning by experience'
or 'learning by doing' rather than rote learning and rigid instruction.
My pedagogic creed
Dewey believes that the educational process has two sides one psychological and one sociological.
Child-centered education – Dewey believes education should be centered on the child's needs,
interests, and experiences. He emphasized the importance of understanding the child’s nature,
and feelings and building upon them in the learning process.
Active learning- Dewey supports learning through active participation and experience. He believed
that students learn best by engaging in hands-on activity experience. He believes the students
learn best by engaging in hands-on activities experiments and real-world problem-solving rather
than by passive reception of information.
Social interaction – according to Dewey learning is a social process that occurs through interaction
with others. He emphasized the importance of collaboration, communication, and cooperation
among students and between students and teachers.
Dewey believes the individual who is to be educated is a social individual and that society is an
organic union of individuals. If we eliminate the social factor from the child we are left only with
an abstraction, if we eliminate the individual factor from society we are left only with a passive
and lifeless mass.
What the school is
Dewey believes that the second is primarily a social institution. Education is a social process, here
the school is a form of community life in which all those agencies are concentrated that will be
most effective in bringing the child to share in the inherited resource of race and to use his own
powers for social ends.
He believes that education is a process of living and not a preparation of for future living. The school
must represent present life – life as real and vital to the child as that which he carries on in the
home, in the neighborhood, or on the playground.
School life should grow gradually out of the home life that should take up and continue the activities
with which the child is already familiar in the home.
Social necessity
He also believes in a social necessity because home is the form of social life in which the child has
been nurtured and in connection with which he has had his moral training.
School must deepen and extend his sense of the values bound up in his home life
Much of the present school/ education fails because it neglects this fundamental principle of the
school as a form of community life.
It conceive the school as a place where certain information is to be given where certain lesson are to
be learned or where certain habits are to be formed. Not following these values as a result they
do not become a part of the life experience of the child and so are not truly educated.
it is very interesting to note that Dewey's educational theory was far less child-centered and more
teacher-centered than is often supposed. He considered teachers' role very important in the
education of children. It is also noticed that as far as subject matter was concerned.
“Education is the development of all those capacities in the individual which will enable him/her to
control his environment.” Education is a social need. It is progressive in nature both for the
individual and the society. It has two aspects; psychological and social. Both are equally
important. Psychological aspect takes care of the child’s interests, capabilities, talents and
aptitude and the social aspect takes care of the social environment of the child in which he/she
takes birth and is brought up. Education is for the child and not vice versa, i.e. child is not for
education. The child is not a Tabula Rasa (clean slate) on which anything can be written. The child
is born with certain innate powers and capabilities which can be developed in the right direction.
Education develops the child in such a way that he/she is able to find values and truth in every
activity and experiment done at all levels and is able to face the future challenges with
confidence.
1. Learning by Doing: Dewey argued that students learn best when they engage in activities that
interest them and are meaningful to their lives.
2. Integration of Subjects: Instead of teaching subjects in isolation, Dewey's approach integrated
various subjects around common themes and projects.
3. Social Interaction: Dewey believed that education should prepare students for democratic
participation. Thus, social interaction and cooperative learning were fundamental.
4. Development of Critical Thinking: The school focused on helping students develop the ability to
think critically and solve problems.
The Structure of the Curriculum
The curriculum at the Laboratory School was designed to be flexible and student-centered. It had
several unique features:
1. Project-Based Learning: Students worked on projects that integrated different subjects. For
example, a project on building a model city could involve mathematics, science, history, and art.
2. Problem-Solving: Older students applied problem-solving strategies to investigate scientific
phenomena that interested them.
3. Group Work: Younger children often worked in groups to plan and discuss their activities,
fostering a sense of community and shared responsibility.
4. Choice and Autonomy: Students had significant freedom to choose their activities, which helped
them develop independence and decision-making skills.
Teaching Methods
Teachers at the Laboratory School played a crucial role in guiding students' learning. Their methods
included:
1. Redirection: If a student had behavioral problems, teachers would redirect them to other
activities that achieved the same educational goals.
2. Encouraging Exploration: Teachers encouraged students to explore their interests and provided
guidance to deepen their understanding.
3. Creating a Supportive Environment: The school aimed to be a stress-free environment where
students felt safe to express themselves and take risks in their learning.
Moral and Character Education
Dewey believed that education should also focus on developing students' character and moral
judgment. The school incorporated these aspects:
Bertrand Russell
Bertrand Arthur William Russell is a British philosopher.
Bertrand Russell, whose love for individual freedom and free inquiry is well known, argues that one
will ultimately be a better citizen. Education should aim to enlarge the mind and heart and then
acquire certain kinds of skills.
These four elements form the basis for good character formation
Vitality refers to form good health and a good mind.
Courage, which is the absence of fear, must be developed in children.
Sensitiveness is the third element of human character. We must be sensitive to our immediate
neighbors and surroundings.
Intelligence, according to Russell, is the ability to acquire knowledge. Students should be provided
an opportunity to acquire knowledge by getting involved in the thinking process.
Russell emphasized that the development of certain virtues of intelligence like creativity, open-
mindedness, and courage for intellectual probity should form the major goal of education.
Paulo Freire
Paulo Freire was known as a philosopher and theoretician of education, never separating theory
from praxis. According to Freire, conscientization “refers to the process in which men, not as
recipients, but as knowing subjects, achieve a deepening awareness both of the Socio-culture
reality. According to Freire, education is "an act of knowing and not memorizing.
According to him, education implies a dialogic exchange between teachers and students, where both
learn, question, reflect, and participate in meaning–making. By making words (literacy) relevant
to the lives of people, the process of conscientization would begin.
By analyzing Freire's pedagogy, we are able to identify his significant contribution to education:
I. Emphasis on dialogue - he upheld that education is a dialogical (conversational) rather than a
curricular form and this dialogue should not involve one person acting on another, but rather
people working with each other. A dialogue, not only requires critical thinking but also generates
critical thinking in the participants.
2. Concern with praxis - an action that is informed and linked to certain values. He upheld that
dialogue should result in deepening understanding taking informal actions and making a
difference in the world.
3. Concern with conscientization - developing consciousness that is understood to have the power
to transform reality.
4. Insistence on lived experience of participants - provide educational activity to suit the living
situation 1 experience of the people.
the aim of teaching act is not an act of depositing, in which the students are the depositories and
the teacher is the depositor
Rousseau
Concept of Negative Education
1. Natural Development:
Rousseau believed that children are born good and have an innate sense of morality. He argued
that education should allow this natural goodness to develop without being tainted by societal
norms and pressures.
Negative education aims to create an environment where children can grow and learn naturally,
without being forced into the molds set by society.
According to Rousseau, traditional education often pushes children to learn concepts and skills
before they are ready. This previous instruction can oppress their natural curiosity and
development.
Negative education delays formal instruction until the child shows a natural interest and
enthusiasm for it. For example, instead of teaching a child to read at a specific age, the child
would learn to read when they express a genuine interest.
3. Protecting Innocence:
Rousseau emphasized the importance of protecting children from the corrupting influences of
society, such as competition, envy, and deceit.
By keeping children away from these negative influences, negative education aims to preserve
their innocence and moral integrity.
Children should learn through their own experiences rather than through direct teaching. This
allows them to understand the world in a more profound and personal way.
For instance, instead of telling children about the dangers of fire, they should be allowed to
experience it in a controlled way to understand its properties and risks.
Adults should intervene as little as possible in the child’s learning process. They provide a safe
and supportive environment rather than direct instruction.
This means allowing children to make and learn from mistakes rather than stepping in to correct
every error.
Negative education places a strong emphasis on physical and emotional development. Rousseau
believed that children should be healthy and happy and that physical activity is crucial for their
overall development.
Emotional well-being is also prioritized, with a focus on nurturing the child’s natural emotions
and preventing negative feelings like fear and anxiety.
The learning environment should be as natural as possible, free from the artificial constraints of
traditional classrooms.
Outdoor activities and real-life experiences are preferred over textbook learning and rote
memorization.
2. Promoting Self-Sufficiency:
Children should be encouraged to do things for themselves and solve their own problems. This
builds confidence and independence.
Tasks like dressing themselves, preparing simple meals, and exploring nature help children
become self-reliant.
Formal education, such as reading, writing, and arithmetic, is delayed until the child shows a
natural readiness and interest.
This ensures that learning is driven by the child’s curiosity and is more meaningful to them.
1. Practical Challenges:
Critics argue that it can be challenging to implement negative education in modern societies
where formal education systems and standardized curricula dominate.
There are concerns about how children educated in this way will adapt to structured
environments later in life.
Finding the right balance between allowing freedom and providing necessary guidance can be
difficult. Too much freedom might lead to a lack of discipline, while too much guidance can
supress independence.
Critics worry that children may not acquire essential skills and knowledge needed for adulthood if
left too much to their own devices.
3. Social Integration:
Negative education might isolate children from societal norms and values, making it harder for
them to integrate and function effectively within society later on.
Some argue that exposure to societal influences, even negative ones, is necessary for developing
resilience and social skills.
Conclusion
Rousseau’s concept of negative education focuses on protecting and nurturing the natural
development of children, allowing them to grow and learn without the pressures and corrupting
influences of society. By emphasizing learning through experience, encouraging natural curiosity,
and minimizing adult intervention, negative education aims to cultivate well-rounded individuals
who are physically, emotionally, and morally sound. Despite its challenges and criticisms,
Rousseau’s ideas continue to influence modern educational philosophies, particularly those that
prioritize child-centered and experiential learning approaches.
Born Good:
Rousseau believed that children are born inherently good and pure. Unlike the prevailing views of
his time, which often saw children as needing strict discipline to overcome their bad nature,
Rousseau argued that any corruption in children comes from society, not from within themselves.
Natural Development
2. Nature's Course:
He emphasized that children should be allowed to grow and develop according to their natural
instincts and rhythms. Rousseau compared childhood to a plant that needs time to grow and
should not be rushed or forced into premature maturity.
3. Stages of Development:
Rousseau outlined specific stages of development, each with its own characteristics and needs.
He believed that education should be tailored to these stages, respecting the natural progression
of a child’s physical and mental abilities.
4. Innocence:
For Rousseau, childhood was a time of innocence and purity. He believed that children have an
innate sense of right and wrong and that this should be nurtured rather than corrupted by
external influences.
5. Preserving Innocence:
Protecting the innocence of children was the principal. Rousseau argued that exposure to adult
concerns and societal vices could damage the pure nature of a child. Hence, he advocated for
shielding children from such negative influences for as long as possible.
6. Joyful Exploration:
Childhood, according to Rousseau, should be a time of joy, play, and exploration. He saw play as a
crucial part of learning, where children naturally explore their environment and learn through
their experiences.
7. Freedom to Learn:
Rousseau championed the idea that children should have the freedom to learn at their own pace
and in their own way. This freedom allows children to follow their curiosity and interests, which
leads to more meaningful and lasting learning.
8. Child-Centered Education:
9. Learning by Doing:
He promoted experiential learning, where children learn by doing and interacting with their
environment. This hands-on approach helps children develop practical skills and a deeper
understanding of the world around them.
Critique of Society
[Link] as Liberation:
Rousseau viewed education as a means to liberate children from societal corruption, allowing
them to develop freely according to their natural inclinations.
Lasting Impact
[Link] in Education:
Rousseau’s romantic view of childhood influenced the Romantic movement, which celebrated
the natural world, emotions, and the inherent goodness of humanity. His ideas have had a lasting
impact on educational theory, inspiring approaches that emphasize the holistic development of
children.
Conclusion
Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s romantic view on childhood celebrates the natural goodness, innocence,
and unique developmental stages of children. He believed that children should be allowed to
grow and learn in a nurturing environment that respects their individuality and natural curiosity.
By protecting children from the corrupting influences of society and allowing them the freedom
to explore and learn at their own pace, Rousseau envisioned a more humane and effective
approach to education. His ideas continue to resonate in modern educational practices that
prioritize the well-being and holistic development of the child.
basic in education
Chapter 4
Knowledge is always concerned about knowing something. This something could be natural objects,
man-made things, events, processes, persons, their activities, their relationships and many
others.
Knowledge is sum of human understanding of the world, be it physical, biological, social, mental and
spiritual. In simple but generalised way, knowledge is sum of human understanding of material
and mental reality – given and constructed.
Knowledge, the noun, is used in different contexts and situations to convey different meanings to
different people. Knowledge has different aspects, kinds and levels. Knowledge, in common sense
understanding, signifies all the human meanings, beliefs about matters of facts (things, objects,
events), about relationships between facts, and about principles, laws, theories that are at work
in the nature and society.
it is the relationship of the subject with the object. Knowledge and its intensity depend on the
relationship between the knower and the known. In the school context, knowledge is the sum of
conceptions, ideas, laws, and propositions established and tested as correct reflections of the
phenomenon.
According to plato education can be defined in 3 ways
1. Knowledge is Perception or sensation;
2. Knowledge is True belief, and
3. Knowledge is True belief accompanied by a rational account of itself or ground
Plato defined knowledge as, ‘justified true belief’.
According to Plato’s definition, human knowledge, to be given the ‘status’ of knowledge, should
fulfill the condition of being a belief – true and justified.
For pragmatist Dewey (2010), knowledge denotes an ‘inference from evidence’.
three aspects associated with knowledge. These aspects are.
1. Processes involved in knowledge acquisition/generation/ construction; this eventually enters into
the domain of ways of acquisition/generation/construction of knowledge; to be precise it is ways
of knowing;
2. Forms of knowledge; since knowledge is sum of human understanding, there ought to be different
forms of understanding or types of knowledge; and
3. Purpose of knowing/knowledge. The purpose of knowing is different in different contexts.
As a process, it refers to the method of coming to know the phenomenon. Knowledge, as a product,
is resultant of knowing–the process.
Sense Perception: The Beginning of Knowing The acquisition of knowledge begins with the reception
of external stimuli by our sense organs, which is immediately converted into the form of
perception. Perception refers to having knowledge about a stimulus that affects on our sense
organs. Thus, knowledge starts with experience of the facts or matters through sense organs
Knowledge
Many believe that knowledge cannot be defined. The problem of the definition of knowledge is
ongoing and is a never-ending
1. Knowledge is Perception or sensation.
2. Knowledge is True belief, and
3. Knowledge is True belief accompanied by a rational account of itself or ground.
For pragmatist Dewey, knowledge denotes an ‘inference from evidence’.
It can also be conceived of as patterns of activity, or physical dexterity with thought, contributing to
acting in the world, and the creating and making of things
Human beings over time have evolved many bodies of knowledge, which include a collection of ways
of thinking, feeling and doing things and constructing more knowledge
three aspects associated with knowledge
1. Processes involved in knowledge acquisition/generation/ construction; this eventually enters into
the domain of ways of acquisition/generation/construction of knowledge; to be precise it is ways
of knowing;
2. Forms of knowledge; since knowledge is the sum of human understanding, there ought to be
different forms of understanding or types of knowledge; and
3. Purpose of knowing/knowledge. The purpose of knowing is different in different contexts
1. Child-Centered Education:
Description: The book argues that the starting point of education should be the child, not the
subject matter. Education should cater to the child's interests, needs, and experiences.
Key Points:
Recognize the child’s interests and natural curiosity.
Learning experiences should be relevant to the child's life.
Focus on the development of the child as a whole, including emotional and social growth.
2. Curriculum Flexibility:
Description: A rigid curriculum does not accommodate the diverse learning styles and paces of
individual students. Flexibility allows for adjustments based on each child's progress and
interests.
Key Points:
Adapt the curriculum to suit different learning needs.
Allow room for exploration and creativity.
Adjust teaching methods based on the child's responses and understanding.
3. Practical Learning:
Description: The book emphasizes the importance of learning through doing. Children learn more
effectively when they engage in activities that allow them to apply concepts in real-world
contexts.
Key Points:
Incorporate hands-on activities and experiments.
Encourage children to explore and manipulate objects.
Learning by doing helps in better retention and understanding of concepts.
4. Teacher's Role:
Description: Teachers should act as guides who facilitate learning rather than authoritarian
figures who dictate information. Their role is to support and nurture the child's natural inclination
to learn.
Key Points:
Create a supportive and encouraging learning environment.
Guide students to find answers rather than providing all solutions.
Foster a relationship of trust and respect with students.
5. Integration of Subjects:
Description: Subjects should not be taught in isolation. An integrated approach shows students
the interconnectedness of knowledge and how different disciplines relate to each other.
Key Points:
Design lessons that incorporate multiple subjects.
Use thematic units that connect different areas of learning.
Help students see the practical application of knowledge across different fields.
Description: The intrinsic motivation of children to learn is crucial. When children are interested
in what they are learning, they are more engaged and motivated to pursue knowledge.
Key Points:
Identify and build on the interests of each child.
Make learning activities engaging and fun.
Encourage curiosity and a love for learning.
7. Real-World Relevance:
Description: The curriculum should be connected to real-life situations and practical applications.
This approach makes learning more meaningful and helps students understand the relevance of
their education.
Key Points:
Use real-world examples and scenarios in teaching.
Relate lessons to everyday life experiences.
Prepare students for real-life challenges and problem-solving.
Detailed Summary:
"The Child and the Curriculum" by John Dewey discusses the importance of focusing on the child in
the educational process rather than strictly adhering to a predetermined curriculum. Dewey
argues that education should be a dynamic and flexible process that takes into account the
unique needs, interests, and experiences of each child.
He emphasizes the need for a curriculum that can adapt to the varying paces at which children learn,
advocating for practical, hands-on learning experiences that make education relevant and
engaging. Teachers play a crucial role as facilitators, guiding children through their learning
journey and helping them connect different areas of knowledge.
The book also highlights the significance of integrating subjects, fostering motivation through
interest-driven activities, and ensuring that the curriculum relates to real-life situations. This
approach not only enhances understanding but also prepares students to apply their knowledge
in practical ways.
By advocating for a child-centered and flexible curriculum, Dewey's work underscores the
importance of creating an educational system that nurtures and respects the individual learning
paths of each student, making learning a more natural, enjoyable, and effective process.
1. Introduction
No Absolute Knowledge:
There is no universal knowledge that is considered important for all times and places.
What is considered valuable knowledge changes depending on the society and its context.
Influence of Power Structures:
The knowledge chosen for school curriculums often reflects the interests of powerful groups in
society.
For instance, certain historical events may be emphasized or downplayed based on who is in
power.
Bias in Knowledge Selection:
The process of selecting what is taught in schools often favors certain social groups over others.
This means that the curriculum might not be neutral but instead promote the interests of
dominant groups.
Conclusion
Schools are seen as institutions that enforce conformity and limit creativity.
They perpetuate social inequality by favoring those who can adapt to the school system.
The formal education system teaches dependency on institutions rather than fostering
independent thinking and learning.
Illich differentiates between "learning" (which can happen anywhere and anytime) and
"schooling" (which happens in a formal setting).
He argues that learning is a natural process that does not need to be confined to schools.
People learn best through real-life experiences, not just by sitting in classrooms.
3. Hidden Curriculum:
Schools have a "hidden curriculum" that teaches students to conform, obey authority, and accept
the status quo.
This hidden curriculum is not part of the formal syllabus but is conveyed through the school
environment and practices.
4. Deinstitutionalization of Education:
5. Learning Webs:
6. Peer Learning:
Illich emphasizes the importance of peer learning where individuals learn from each other.
Peer learning is more collaborative and less hierarchical compared to traditional teacher-student
relationships.
7. Self-Directed Learning:
He advocates for self-directed learning, where individuals take control of their own education.
This involves pursuing personal interests and learning at one's own pace.
Benefits of Deschooling:
1. Empowerment:
2. Flexibility:
Learning can happen anywhere and anytime, not just within the confines of a school.
This flexibility allows people to learn in ways that suit their unique needs and circumstances.
3. Reduction of Inequality:
By removing the formal school system, deschooling aims to reduce educational inequality.
Everyone has access to learning opportunities, regardless of their social or economic background.
4. Enhanced Creativity:
Without the constraints of formal schooling, individuals can explore their creativity and
innovative thinking.
Learning becomes a more organic and enjoyable process.
Criticisms of Deschooling:
1. Feasibility:
Critics argue that completely dismantling the school system is unrealistic and impractical.
Schools provide a structured environment that is essential for many children, especially those
from disadvantaged backgrounds.
2. Quality Control:
There are concerns about maintaining the quality and consistency of education without formal
institutions.
Without schools, there might be a lack of standardized learning and qualifications.
3. Socialization:
Schools are important for socialization, teaching children how to interact with peers and function
in a community.
Deschooling might limit opportunities for social interaction.
Education
The concept of education is used in a variety of contexts and with different shades of Meaning. The
term “education” is used in the narrow and the broad sense. In the narrow Sense, ‘education’
refers to formal schooling— the process by which the society, through its different educational
institutions i.e. schools/colleges specially established for the purpose, deliberately transmits its
cultural heritage, — its accumulated knowledge, values and skills from one generation to
another. In the broad sense, education is a life-long process. All learning does not take place in
the formal school system only. A large part of human life is spent outside the school and thus the
individual learns many thing informally living in the home, the society and in the company of his
fellow beings. Thus, any act, or experience that has a positive and worthwhile effect on the mind,
character and ability of an individual during his life can be called ‘education’.
‘Education’ is also used to refer both to a process and to a product. As a product, education means
the sum total of knowledge, skills, ideals and values that are acquired through learning. As a
process, it refers to the act of developing these components in the individual.
Tagore “Education means enabling the mind to find out that ultimate truth which releases us from
the bondage of the dust....” About education,
Mahatma Gandhi says, “By education, I mean an all-round drawing out of the best in child and man
body, mind and spirit”.
four main
characteristics:
1. Education is a human enterprise
It deals with human beings who have intellect, emotions and conscience. It deals with harmonious
development of human personality.
2. Education is a life-long process It takes place from infancy to maturity. It is the sum total of
knowledge and experiences acquired during the life span of the human being. As a process,
education has three primary functions. One, it has to be ‘comprehensive’ to cover all forms of
education i.e. formal, and informal.
Two, it has to be ‘integrated’ with other social and economic developments as an input for human
resource development in the total effort for social progress. Three, it has to be ‘life long’. It
should not remain confined to school and college only; it should continue throughout life.
3. Education is human development— physical, emotional, intellectual and social —does not take
place in vacuum. It takes place in a common culture where the child learns a common value of
development and skills of adjustment with a changing social environment. A person is known to
be ‘completely developed individual’ when he is not only physically strong, emotionally stables,
intellectually alert and possesses skills and reasoning capacity but also has the ability to live
together and work together with all types of peoples in society with peace and harmony.
4. Education gives direction to the development of human personality through and educative agent
The agent may be an individual or an institution. Proper direction from an educative agent help
the child to choose the right course of studies recognising his individual differences and needs.
Colonial education
the arrival of British, the system of education experienced a major change. The western system of
schooling with English as the medium of instruction appeared on the scene. These schools, unlike
those in the past, were housed in separate buildings meant a result of the colonial rule our entire
original education system was gradually destroyed. only for imparting instruction and the teacher
was now a paid agent of the government. The main aim of education was creation of class of
citizens who would be Indian in blood and colour but English in taste, in opinions and in intellect.
Importance was on higher education of upper classes and this led to the neglect of elementary
education for the masses. With Swadeshi Movement for political freedom, demand for free and
compulsory elementary education was also voiced by national leaders. But this demand was
ignored by the rulers who advocated a policy of consolidation rather than expansion of
elementary education. Departments of Public Instruction were established for educational
administration. Schools were supervised and monitored by an Inspector of Schools. Textbooks
were also prescribed which the reference point became for the teachers. However, most of the
textual material had no relevance to learners’ life experiences. As a result of the colonial rule our
entire indigenous education system was gradually destroyed.
1) It believes Infinite Mind or God is the ultimate reality. He is the creator and all others are the
creation.
2) God or the creator or the Infinite Mind is the source of all human values. The goal of all human
activities is the realisation of the Infinite Mind in one’s own self. Human beings are born to work
out divine purpose in their lives. According to the idealists, each child has certain innate abilities.
The task of education is to help him to develop and to grow up in tune with these abilities. They
are of the view that education should help the child develop respect for the nation. The idealists
believe that true knowledge is obtained only through reasoning. Knowledge is gathered through
senses. They give as much importance to study of art and literature as to the study of science.
Both intuitive thinking and scientific thinking are equally important. Truth, beauty and goodness
are absolute and unchanging values.
Idealism offers the following aims of education:
a) to help the child to grow up in tune with his innate potentialities;
b) to help the child realise his responsibilities towards the society and nation;
c) to develop in the child scientific outlook towards life;
d) to help the child to develop the ability to test intuitions rationally and experimentally;
e) to help the child to accept permanent values that put him in harmony with the ultimate reality;
and
f) to motivate the child to explore the truthfulness of information received through senses.
4.5.2 Naturalism
During the middle ages, education became very formal. Rousseau is the founder of naturalistic
movement in education. According to naturalists there are certain innate elements present in the
child. Education should nurture these elements. The naturalists believe that by nature a child is
pure. As he grows up, he is influenced by the evil in the society and impurities come in. The
naturalists find much educative value in the nature. True education can only be given in a natural
environment away from society. They believe that good is inherent in child and in nature, the
purpose of education is only to develop the child in harmony with nature. The teacher has only a
passive role to play. The naturalists do not lay much importance on the role of the teacher as
stressed by idealists or pramatist. Rabindernath Tagore was also a naturalist, Sri Aurobindo and
Mother Teressa were naturalistst in the sense that they advocated freedom to the child. The
naturalists lay much emphasis on learning by senses. Rousseau termed this method of teaching
as ‘negative education’ which helps the child to become immune from bad influences. The child
occupies the key position. S/he should be allowed to grow up freely according to his/her own
innate nature. No curriculum should be imposed on him/her. The role of the teacher is only to
prepare suitable environment for the child to grow.
In view of these principles of naturalism, the following are the aims of education:
a) to help the child to understand the educative value of the nature and mis-educative value of the
society;
b) to help the child to grow up into a perfect individual in a natural environment without sacrificing
social aims of education;
c) to help the child to know his/her instincts and help organise them for enrichment of his/her
experiences;
d) to help the child to develop the ability to adjust to the environment;
e) to help the child get control over his or her senses and utilise them for furtherance of his/her
experiences; and .
f) to help the child to develop the ability of “self-expression”.
Pragmatism
Pragmatism is relatively a recent philosophy of education developed in America. Its propagators are
Charles Sanders Peirce, William James and John Dewey. This philosophy contrasts certain aspects
of the Idealism and naturalism. Idealism believes in permanence of values, whereas pragmatists
believe in relativity of values. While idealists lay stress on the spiritual nature of man, pragmatists
stress on the social and biological nature of man. The pragmatists hold democracy as important.
According to them educational principles and practices should be continuously reviewed and
updated in the light of recent developments.
The aims of education according to the Pragmatists are as follows:
a) to help the child to develop his/her all round personality in the social context;
b) to help the child to develop the ability to continuously reconstruct and interpret his/ her
experience;
c) to develop an awareness in the child about the relativity of values;
d) to help the child to develop a sense of democratic values in life;
e) to develop problem solving ability in the child;
f) to help the child to develop the ability to live cooperatively within a community; and
g) to help the child to develop the ability of critical intelligence and to apply it in life situation
Individualistic School of Thought
The supporters of the individualistic aims of education advocate that the main aim of education is
the all-round development of the individual in all its aspects namely, physical, intellectual,
emotional, moral and social. The aims of education should, therefore, be formulated in
accordance with this fundamental objective of life. Education of the individual should be planned
in such a way as to bring about the fullest possible development of the individual’s innate
potentialities and to help him/her attain excellence and perfection in every aspect of his/her life.
and Rousseau have emphasised that the society is the creation of the individual and not his/her
creator. The individual has evolved the society with the intention of having some important
purposes served by it. So society is merely an instrument for the fulfilment of the needs of the
individual. Beyond that it has neither any entity nor any usefulness. If there is any conflict
between the needs of the individual and those of the society, preference will always be given to
the needs of the individual. Pestalozzi, Montessori etc, have also given much importance to the
individual aims of education. No doubt each of them evolved a system of education quiet unique
to his own ideas and thoughts but each system invariably aimed to achieving the fullest
development of all the characteristics that one is born with. Balance between Individualistic and
Socialistic Aims Philosophers like Dewey, Gandhi and others assert that only in an ideal form of
democracy the interests of the individual and those of the society come to a natural
reconciliation. Education should try to make both the individual and the society flourish in an
atmosphere of freedom and goodwill and not imposition. The aims of the society must be
democratic in nature. It needs to deliver maximum good to the maximum number. If this is
achieved, the satisfaction of the individuals needs will naturally lead to progress and prosperity of
the society. A true balance between the individualistic and the socialistic aims of education lies in
reconstructing the social pattern based on democratic foundation of equality, justice and
universal brotherhood.
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF PRIMARY EDUCATION
The primary stages of education covers the age range 5-6 to 12-13 years and the classes I to VII / VIII.
1) Acquisition of tools of formal learning, namely literacy, numeracy and manual skills;
2) Acquisition of knowledge through observation, study and experimentation in the areas of social
and natural sciences;
3) Development of physical strength and team-spirit through sports and games;
4) Acquisition of skills or planning and executing socially useful productive work with a view to
making education work-based;
6) Acquisition of habits of co-operative behaviour within the family, school and community;
7) Development of aesthetic perception and creativity through participation artistic activities and
observation of nature;
9) Development of the desire to participate in productive and other processes of community life;
and to serve the community.