Analog Circuit Design on Digital CMOS
Why it is difficult, and which ideas help. Presented by HP. Schmid.
Background on Hanspeter Schmid Dissertation on video-frequency integrated filters (ETH Zrich) Analog IC Designer at Bernafon / William Demant Holding:
Analog electronics: LNAs, amplifiers, regulators, filters, standard cells, circuits for wireless communication system. System design, analog signal processing and signal integrity. Communication facilitator between Danish and Swiss Teams.
IME: research projects (sensor systems, sigma-delta, etc.), consulting, teaching. ETH Zrich: teaching analog (integrated) signal processing IEEE CAS:
Chair Analog Signal Processing Tech. Comm. Associate Editor of TCAS-I
Hobbies: going for walks, playing trombone, reading.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 2
Tutorial Philosophy
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
Philosophy I: Be a fool! multiparameter optimization
noise distortion power consumption signal delay chip area offset yield mask costs
conscious vs. subconscious
conscious mind: 45 criteria subconscious: 100? 200?
what it means to be a fool
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
Philosophy II: Be a child open for everything playful does not do what she should do a child has got time! Advice for scientists by Douglas Adams: See first, think later, then test. But always see first, or you will only see what you expect to see!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
Philosophy III: Be a climber works hard to achieve a goal is well trained normally gets to the intended goal Is the intention good? The direct path leads only to the goal! that heralds The most exciting phrase in science, the one (Andr Gide) new discoveries, is not Eureka! (I found it!), but Will That's funny ... the fool not fall down? (Isaac Asimov) if the fool also is a child. Not
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
Tutorial Contents
Image from [Link]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 7
Introduction: What is new? More metal layers Small lateral distances Thinner gates
more C less Vdd
less gain more weak inversion
Image from [Link]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 8
Multi-metal cross section Example: 6 Metal layers. Lateral dimensions are smaller than vertical dimensions!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
Transconductance in Strong and Weak Inversion
Strong Inversion
Weak Inversion
Moderate Inversion: Superposition
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
10
Maximum gain of single stage is reached in weak inversion For a given supply current: gain is proportional to supply voltage!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
11
Weak inversion = matching problems?
For a 0.25u process: Voltage offset for identical supply current Current offset for identical gate-source voltage
Therefore: Differential pairs in weak inversion Therefore: Current mirrors in strong inversion
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
from [Kinget07]
ISCAS 2009 12
Summary Thinner gates (and higher gate tunnelling currents!) more gate (overlap, ...) capacitance per area No buried channels anymore pMOS is not better anymore in terms of flicker noise! Less supply voltage Less gain same white noise at same supply current; less flicker noise Sub-threshold leakage less signal
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
13
Literature: What is new?
[Annema99] Anne-Johan Annema, "Analog Circuit Performance and Process Scaling", IEEE Trans. Circuits and SystemsII, vol. 46, no. 6, pp. 711725, June 1999. [Huang98] Qiuting Huang et. al., "The Impact of Scaling Down to Deep Submicron on CMOS RF Circuits," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 33, no. 7, pp. 10231036, July 1998 [Kinget07] Peter Kinget, "Device Mismatch: An Analog Design Perspective", ISCAS, New Orleans, pp. 12451248, May 2007. [Tsividis02] Yannis Tsividis, Mixed Analog-Digital VLSI Devices and Technology, World Scientific Publishers, 2002. [Tsividis99] Yannis Tsividis, Operation and Modelling of the MOS Transistor, ed. 2, McGraw-Hill 1999. [Dijksterhuis06] Ap Dijksterhuis et. al., "On Making the Right Choice: The DeliberationWithout-Attention Effect," Science, vol. 311, pp. 10051007, 2006. [Simons99] Daniel Simons et. al., "Gorillas in our midst: sustained inattentional blindness for dynamic events," Perception, vol. 28, pp. 10591074, 1999.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 14
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
15
Signal Integrity Ground and Power Routing Star Connections Tapered Stars Signal Grounds and Refs Improving PSR (theory) Finger capacitors and MIM-capacitors Demodulation by nonlinearity Decoupling
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
16
Why correct ground and power routing are important
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
17
On PCB: Power plane? No!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
18
On PCB: Split ground plane? Dangerous!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
19
Recommendations for PCB routing [National05] recommend
Use a single, unified ground plane use separate power planes for analog and digital let trace routing control ground currents.
Low-power low-noise circuits: require controlled power/gnd routing!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
20
The problem of the star connection on chip
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
21
Calculation example: hearing aid system
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
22
16 is not a lot!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
23
Solution: Tapered star
This means: we have full control of where the noise currents flow. But: more chip area or more supply / ground wire resistance! Paradox: most sensitive nodes are farthest away from pad.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 24
Local decoupling is sometimes needed The question is: where shall the decoupling capacitor go?
Answer: to the reference of the signal! But this may not be so easy. Many "PSR problems" are really coupling problems or problems with dirty references
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 25
How to improve PSRR and CMRR in a system? CMRR and PSRR are connected! Proof: Gauge transformation
from [Sckinger91]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 26
Solution: Additional input from quiet ground Now we have one more degree of freedom
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
27
Example: additional signal path
from [Loikkanen06]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 28
Example: additional signal path
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
29
Recommendations for chip routing Use "tapered" star connections For every differential signal node, make sure that the signal is referred to a clean signal. Input reference Problem: the references can change within a single circuit
Output reference
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 30
Multi-metal Finger-Cap MIM-Cap combination
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
31
Comparison for a six-metal 0.18um CMOS process
MIM capacitor (Metal 5 and Metal 6): Finger structure (Metal 1 Metal 4): MIM capacitor on top of Finger structure (all Metal): MOSFET gate capacitance (non-linear):
1.0 fF/m2 1.3 fF/um2 2.3 fF/um2 10.0 fF/um2
Can we use a MOSFET gate capacitor for decoupling?
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
32
Demodulation by a nonlinearity I: DC offset Normal Operation with HF-Signal on Pad (weak inversion)
Gives DC Offset! Inputs must be protected against this ...
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 33
Demodulation by a nonlinearity II: receiver Normal Operation with amplitude-modulated HF-Signal on Pad (weak inversion)
Demodulates the signal and gives more DC offset!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 34
Realistic? Yes! In all digitally driven class-D (PWM) amplifiers, the signal is amplitude-modulated on the system clock frequency. The square of this signal appears in the supply current. If this strays back into a high-gain audio system: huge distortion or even instability! Solution: decouple all inputs ... to the respective reference of the signal ... as close to the pad as possible ... with as big a capacitor as possible
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
35
Literature: Signal Integrity [Loikkanen06] Mikko Loikkanen et. al., "PSRR Improvement Technique for Amplifiers with Miller Capacitor," ISCAS 2006, Kos, Greece, pp. 13941397. [National05] National Semiconductor Analog University, Meeting Signal-Path Design Challenges, High-performance seminar series 2005, part no. 570012-001. (Can be ordered from National for free.) [Sckinger91] Eduard Sckinger et. al., "A General Relationship Between Amplifier Parameters, And Its Application to PSRR Improvement," IEEE Trans. Circuits and SystemsI, vol. 38, no. 10, pp. 11731181, Oct 1991
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
36
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
37
An amp within an amp Weak inversion Zero-Vgs amplifiers Super-Transistors
Cascode current mirrors Self-biased cascodes Regulated cascodes
Matryoshka amplifiers
Regulated cascode OTAs Nested Miller amplifiers
Image from [Link]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 38
Weak Inversion = Sub-threshold Operation
from [Tsividis99]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 39
Zero-Vgs folded-cascode opamp in 0.18m technology
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
40
Zero-Vgs folded-cascode opamp in 0.18m technology
VGS
VT=230 mV (!), L=min, ID=5uA
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 41
Maximum gain of single stage is reached in weak inversion For a given supply current: gain is proportional to supply voltage!
Less gain on (deep) submicron
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 42
Normal current mirror Output resistance
Increase this with feedback!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
43
Cascode current mirror Feedback loop: For a constant signal current, the transistor M4 tries to keep the drain voltage of M2 constant. The loop gain around M4 is
and the output resistance:
Problem: high voltage drop.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 44
Low-voltage cascode current mirror Same feedback loop!
Careful design needed such that M3 and M1 are always saturated Bias voltage necessary
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
45
Self-biased low-voltage cascode current mirror Still same feedback loop!
But: for the same current, Vgs3 < Vgs1! M1, M2 in strong inversion M3, M4 in weak inversion (makes Aloop small and M3,M4 huge) M1, M2 normal-Vt transistors M3, M4 low-Vt transistors (requires low-Vt transistors, which most submicron processes have)
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 46
Different view: build super transistors
Then: build good super transistors!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 47
The regulated cascode Increasing the loop gain ...
... gives much higher output resistance
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
48
The "original" by Sckinger simplest loop amplifier, but needs a lot of supply voltage
from [Sckinger90]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 49
Matryoshka-style regulated-cascode amplifier
several OTA Slices
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
one OTA Slice from [Treichler06]
ISCAS 2009 50
Matryoshka slice layout!
One OTA Slice Full OTA
[Treichler06]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 51
Matryoshka Miller OpAmp: Two stages
from [Huijsing01]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 52
Matryoshka Miller OpAmp: Three stages
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
53
Matryoshka Miller OpAmp: Four stages
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
54
Conclusion On modern digital technologies, we lose supply voltage gain If we need gain: we need to combine more gain stages and, if possible, use weak inversion Intuitive way to think about it: An Amp within an Amp within an Amp
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
55
Literature: New uses of old parts
[Burger96] Thomas Burger and Qiuting Huang, "A 100dB 480MHz OTA in 0.7um CMOS for sampled-data applications," Proc. CICC, pp. 101104, 1996. [Huijsing01] Johan H. Huijsing, Operational AmplifiersTheory and Design, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2001. [Sckinger90] Eduard Sckinger et. al, "A High-Swing, High-Impedance MOS Cascode Circuit," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 289298, Feb 1990. [Treichler06] Jrg Treichler et. al., "A 10-bit ENOB 50-MS/s Pipeline ADC in 130-nm CMOS at 1.2 V Supply," Proc. ESSCIRC, Montreux, Switzerland, pp. 552555, 2006. [Tsividis99] Yannis Tsividis, Operation and Modelling of the MOS Transistor, ed. 2, McGraw-Hill 1999.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
56
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
57
Switched capacitors Speed limit of SC filters SC noise filtering Switches and T-gates Voltage doublers
for clock signals for OTA tails for control voltages
Flicker Noise Autozero, CDS and Chopping
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
58
Simple SC resistor
Pole frequency of SC resistor loaded with capacitance:
from [Gregorian86]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 59
SC becomes much faster on modern processes
from [Johns97]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 60
Huge SC resistor for noise filtering
"Bucket Chain" technique Requires RC filters for antialiasing
Possible: 1s time constant! Beware of offset!!!
e.g., 80fF, 160kHz, 13 elements
1 G
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
61
Bad Layout: asymmetries of clock lines! This can give huge offset.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
62
Good Layout: as symmetrical as possible
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
63
Types of switches
from [Johns97]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 64
Voltage-level limitation
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
65
Benefitting from Narrow-Channel Effects
from [Tsividis96]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 66
Reduce switch threshold voltage by slicing
VT=610mV
0.18u Process Normal-VT Transistors VT=540mV
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 67
Clock voltage doubler "Doubling" pMOS gate voltages below VSS is also possible!
from [Basu99]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 68
What is flicker noise?
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
69
Fllicker noise comes from a process with memory!
from [Keshner82]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 70
Why is it called "flicker" noise?
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
71
On flicker noise: the Yahoo Aaaaaargh!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
72
On flicker noise: the Yahoo Aaaaaargh!
from [Schmid07]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 73
Nature of Memory in MOSFETs Mainly interface traps at the channel-to-oxide and gate-to-oxide interfaces: Spectrum caused by a single trap with time constant :
Distribution of the time constants:
Flicker noise slope is a physical property. Flicker noise magnitude is related to the absolute number of interface traps.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 74
Model of scaling-invariant memory
from [Schmid08]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 75
RMS behaviour of flicker noise
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
76
Reducing flicker noise by deleting memory I
from [Klumperink00]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 77
Sampling noise
from [Schmid08]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 78
Reducing offset and flicker noise by auto-zeroing
Autozero 1: Vos 2: Vin+Vos 21: Vin
Correlated Double Sampling 1: Vin+Vos 2: Vin+Vos 21: 2Vin
from [Enz96]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 79
Reducing offset and flicker noise by auto-zeroing
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
80
Reducing offset and flicker noise by chopping
from [Enz96]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 81
Simulated chopped noise
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
82
Chopper circuit
from [Schmid08]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 83
Matryoshka Chopper
from [Schmid08]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 84
Multipath Chopper
Chopped High Gain
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
85
Reducing offset and 1/f noise by correlated double sampling Auto-zeroing: sample offset in one phase; sample signal in other phase while compensating offset. Auto-zeroing works in sampled time. Chopping: modulate input signal to a higher frequency; modulate signal back after amplifier, and therefore modulate offset and 1/f noise to higher frequencies. Chopping works in continuous time! Correlated double sampling combines both: first sample signal, then sample inverse, then subtract. Correlated double sampling works in sampled time. CDS can be used most effectively in capacitive sensor systems where the sensor can be controlled to give normal or inverse output signals! Then sensor offset and 1/f noise is reduced too. In auto-zero and CDS, the transistor bias history must be the same for both samples!
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 86
Literature: Switched capacitors
[Basu99] S. Basu and G. Temes, "Simplified Clock Voltage Doubler," Electronics Letters, vol. 35, no. 22, pp. 19011902, Oct 1999. [Duisters98] Tonny A. F. Duisters and Eise Carel Dijkmans, "A 90-dB THD rail-to-rail input opamp using a new local charge pump in CMOS," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 33, no. 7, pp. 947955, Jul. 1998. [Enz96] Christian Enz and Gabor Temes, "Circuit Techniques for Reducing the Effects of Op-Amp Imperfections: Autozeroing, Correlated Double Sampling, and Chopper Stabilization," Proc. IEEE, vol. 84, no. 11, pp. 15841614, Nov 1996. [Gregorian86] Roubik Gregorian and Gabor Temes, Analog MOS Integrated Circuits for Signal Processing, John Wiley & Sons 1986. [Johns97] David Johns and Ken Martin, Analog Integrated Circuit Design, John Wiley & Sons 1997. [Keshner82] Marvin Keshner, "1/f Noise," Proc. IEEE, vol. 70, no. 3, pp. 212218, March 1982. [Klumperink00] Eric Klumperink et. al., "Reducing MOSFET 1/f Noise and Power Consumption by Switched Biasing," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 35, no. 7, pp. 9941001, Jul. 2000. [Schmid02] Hanspeter Schmid, "An 8.25-MHz 7th-Order Bessel Filter Built with Single-Amplifier Biquadratic MOSFET C Filters", Analog Integrated Circuits and Signal Processing, NORCHIP special issue, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 6981, January 2002. [Schmid07] Hanspeter Schmid , "Aaargh! I Just Loooove Flicker Noise," IEEE Circuits and Systems Magazine, pp. 3235, First Quarter 2007. [Schmid08] Hanspeter Schmid, "Offset, flicker noise, and ways to deal with them": Chapter in Circuits at the Nanoscale, CRC Press, 2008, edited by Krzysztof Iniewski. [Wel07] Arnoud P. van der Wel et. al., "Low-Frequency Noise Phenomena in Switched MOSFETs," IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 540550, March 2007.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
87
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
88
Feedback or no feedback The benefit of feedback Current mode and voltage mode Example: Open-Loop SigmaDelta A/D converter Case study with CSEM Zrich: Low-feedback approach applied to buffer design
Image from [Black34]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 89
Feedback (in Black's words) Advantages: constancy of amplification freedom from nonlinearity reduced delay and delay distortion, reduced noise disturbance from the power supply circuits Disadvantages: [difficult] because of the [] special control required of phase shifts Unless these relations are maintained, singing will occur
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
90
No free lunch! The famous no-free-lunch theorem states that even if we say, e.g., "A system with feedback gives us low distortion for free", it is not really for free, we just cannot possibly optimize power by trading in distortion or other parameters. A more scientific version of the no-free-lunch theorem states: A general-purpose optimization strategy is impossible, and the only way one strategy can outperform another is if it is specialized to the structure of the specific problem under consideration.
from [Ho01]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 91
High-Impedance node in AD844 current-feedback amplifier
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
92
Simple example: voltage-controlled current source
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
93
AD844: the first stage is a Current Conveyor (CCII)
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
94
Current Amplifier without high-impedance node
from [Schmid00]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 95
Real difference
from [Schmid03]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 96
Very simple, very fast voltage integrator
from [Nauta92]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 97
Impedance mismatch to decouple feedback couples again no FB
decoupled optimization is much faster optimization space becomes tidier the child finds out more in a shorter time the fool won't fall
Example
aggressive design time first time right
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
98
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
99
Case Study: Low-feedback approach applied to buffer design Hanspeter Schmid, IME/FHNW Simon Neukom and Yue-Li Schrag, CSEM Zrich
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
100
Standard SC amplifier
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 101
Why an open-loop solution?
We needed Voltage level shift from arbitrary low voltage to 1.6V Less supply current variation (lowered by 20dB) 12-bit precise settling at 4 MHz sample rate, 12-bit precise offset Our open-loop continuous-time solution gave less offset (3=3.3mV compared to SC amp's 3=11.4mV) less power (14mW compared to SC amp's 63.5mW) Disadvantages are: more harmonic distortion more noise but since this is an output driver after high-gain pre-amplifier chain, both disadvantages do not matter in our application.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 102
Operation principle: (with matched resistors) Stage 1: single-ended voltage to differential current Stage 2: current to voltage
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
103
Offset compensation with current-output Track&Hold Signal is processed in "Hold" mode
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
104
Offset compensation with current-output Track&Hold Offset is compensated in "Track" mode individually for each output path
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
105
The remaining offset comes only from the T&H OTA! All other offsets, including random offsets in the gnd references, are cancelled.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
106
Input transconductor
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
107
Output transresistance amplifier
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
108
Track&Hold amplifier
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
109
Static offset: value settled at the end of calibration cycle Dynamic offset: mean value of full-scale settled values
Static Offset
Durch Bild oder Grafik ersetzen (Grsse und Position beibehalten)
Dynamic Offset
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
110
Static and dynamic offset correlate very well digital correction possible!
Offsets of two channels do not correlate well
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
111
Supply current for full-scale steps The current peaks are much smaller than for SC amplifiers
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
112
Monte-Carlo simulation of third-order (left) and second-order (right) harmonic distortion (full scale, full speed)
Efficient Simulation of Harmonic Distortion in Discrete-Time Circuits Wednesday May 27, 2009 from 15:30 - 17:00 in Room 101B.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland ISCAS 2009 113
What causes non-idealities?
odd-order distortion
even-order distortion
gain error offset
ISCAS 2009 114
NOISE
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
115
Design time! two weeks including all simulations and layout has been used on three chips first time right; meets specs
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
116
Literature: Feedback or no feedback
[Black34] Harold S. Black, "Stabilized Feed-Back Amplifiers," Electrical Engineering, vol. 53, no. 1, pp. 114120, Jan 1934. Reprinted in Proc. IEEE, vol. 87, no. 2, pp. 379385, Feb 1999. [Ho01] Y-C. Ho, D. Pepyne, "Simple Explanation of the No Free Lunch Theorem of Optimization", Proc. 40th IEEE Conf. on Decision and Control, Orlando, pp. 44094414, Dec. 2001. [Mahattanakul98] Jirayuth Mahattanakul, "Current-Mode Versus Voltage-Mode Gm-C Biquad Filters: What the Theory Says," IEEE Trans. CASI, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 173186, Feb 1998. [Nauta92] Bram Nauta, "A CMOS Transconductance-C Filter Technique for Very High Frequencies," IEEE J. Solid-State Circ., vol. 27, no. 2., pp. 142153, Feb 1992. [Schmid00] Hanspeter Schmid, "Approximating the Universal Active Element." IEEE Trans. CASI, vol. 47, no. 11, pp. 11601169, Nov 2000. [Schmid03] Hanspeter Schmid, "Why 'Current Mode' Does Not Guarantee Good Performance," Analog Integrated Circuits and Signal Processing, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 7990, April 2003.
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
117
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
118
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
119
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
120
Thank you for coming! Hanspeter Schmid Institute of Microelectronics Steinackerstrasse 1 5210 Windisch Switzerland Tel +41 56 462 46 25 Fax +41 56 462 46 15 [Link]@[Link] Lab: [Link] Publications: [Link]
Hanspeter Schmid, Institute of Microelectronics, FHNW, Windisch, Switzerland
ISCAS 2009
121