Submitted To- Prof.
Ankur Yadav
Group Number- 10
Title- ICRA- SME ratings and credit analytics
Submitted By Roll Number
Shashank Shekhar 23BBA150
Shail Shah 23BBA149
Gagan Adwani 23BBA167
Yajat Mittal 2BBA165
Pulkit Nanhorya 23BBA166
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would like to express our sincere gratitude for the opportunity to study ICRA-SME ratings
and credit analytics for the subject of Financial Services. The knowledge and insights gained
throughout this course have been invaluable in deepening our understanding of Financial
Services and their practical applications in the business world. We are thankful for the
resources, guidance, and support that made this learning experience enriching and fulfilling.
We would also like to express our deepest gratitude to Prof. Ankur Yadav for his invaluable
guidance and support throughout the Financial Services course. His clear and insightful
teaching not only broadened our understanding of Finance strategies and concepts but also
sparked our interest in the subject. His dedication and willingness to address all our queries
greatly contributed to the overall learning experience.
The lessons learned will undoubtedly play a significant role in our academic and professional
growth.
Thank You
2
Introduction to the assigned service area
Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are businesses with a restricted size of
operations in terms of investment, income, and employees, and they constitute an important
pillar of India's economy. SMEs account for roughly 30% of India's GDP and almost half of
Indian exports. Even though SMEs are of great economic importance, they usually encounter
major barriers to accessing formal financing owing to the absence of organized financial
records, which culminates in high information asymmetry and causes lenders to be cautious
of lending them.
ICRA Limited is a top-rated credit rating agency in India that makes independent judgments
about the creditworthiness of a firm. ICRA's SME ratings are meant to provide lenders with
an unbiased view of the risk associated with lending to small and medium enterprises. In this
way, ICRA reduces information gaps and allows SMEs to raise loans at more favorable terms
and conditions.
Credit analytics is the rigorous application of financial and transaction information like
balance sheets, bank statements, GST returns, invoices, and payment history along with
statistical and machine learning algorithms to evaluate an enterprise's creditworthiness and
default risk. India has also seen the shift towards data-based lending accelerate at a fast pace,
with fintech companies and banks increasingly utilizing real-time data from digital sources
like UPI payments, bank accounts, GSTN registers, and other digital cues to appraise
borrowers in an efficient manner. Regulatory assistance in the form of RBI directions
promoting digital lending has helped such technology adoption mandating standardized
disclosures, digital agreements, and safe data handling.
In spite of all these developments, India still has a large credit gap. Official statistics reveal
that about 41.5 million businesses are enrolled under the Udyam scheme, comprising 8.01
million in manufacturing, 14.88 million in services, and 18.61 million in trading. Still, hardly
any SMEs have formal credit ratings. For example, according to SMERA, only about 4,800
companies are officially rated. Simultaneously, credit demand from SMEs is on the rise:
commercial MSME loans grew 11% year over year to ₹28.2 lakh crore as of September 2023,
and new originations increased 29% in Q2 FY2024, indicating broad-based growth, including
rural and semi-urban businesses. However, most SMEs still find it difficult to qualify against
formal credit criteria, underlining the urgent need for creative credit analytics solutions that
will enhance access and inclusion.
3
Year Total Credit to SMEs (In Lakh Crores
rupees)
2019 20.5
2020 18.0
2021 21.7
2022 25.3
2023 28.2
2024 31.5
2025 35.0
4
Problem Identification
A number of challenges limit the efficacy of SME credit rating and analytics techniques in
India:
Low Rating Penetration: Formal ratings are received by only a very small percentage of
SMEs. SMERA reports that around 4,800 SMEs are rated, which represents fewer than
0.01% of the country-wide SME pool. This implies that the majority of small enterprises have
no third-party assessment, resulting in banks having little outside data to evaluate credit
quality.
Information Asymmetry: SMEs generally don't have audited accounts yet or stable income
streams, making their credit risk unclear. Banks prefer audited reports, GST returns, and
business plans to value loans, and obtaining them raises lenders' transaction costs. This
uncertainty increases the problem of proper credit assessment, and numerous creditworthy
SMEs suffer from it.
Dependence on Collateral and Conventional Appraisal: Practically, banks prefer collateral,
i.e., land or property, to credit rating for lending decisions. SMEs with poor collateral are
compelled to pay a premium interest rate or can be denied formal credit altogether. Poor-
quality collateral or its absence compels the lenders to rely on conventional appraisal
techniques, usually ignoring the soundness of the underlying business. This dependence
lowers efficiency and perpetuates hurdles for small and medium businesses.
No Credit History: A major percentage of SMEs are "new-to-credit" borrowers with no
records in credit bureaus. For instance, 36% of trade sector loans are disbursed to first-time
borrowers. Conventional credit scoring systems are unable to assess such companies because
they lack historical data and therefore omit creditworthy SMEs solely for not having a
recorded history.
Resource and Trust Shortfalls in Ratings: Most SMEs either lack knowledge that credit
ratings are available or consider them too expensive, even with subsidization from the
government. Banks can also regard SME ratings as advisory, not authoritative, and therefore
not be used optimally in underwriting. The modal combination of limited awareness, high
expense, and weak trust leaves millions of SMEs out of sight of formal credit assessment
systems.
These inefficiencies—low uptake, lack of data availability, and process barriers—result in
despite increasing volumes of MSME loans, lending largely depends on informal checks and
5
know-your-customer relationships rather than formal analytics. This disconnect underscores
the urgent necessity for innovation in SME credit analytics.
Proposed Innovation
In order to combat these gaps, we suggest the establishment of an ICRA-led Digital SME
Credit Analytics Platform that will utilize cutting-edge technology to innovate SME ratings
and credit scoring to make them more dynamic, inclusive, and accessible.
The major features of the suggested platform are:
Real-Time Data Integration: The system would collect several data sources, such as bank
statements, GST returns, e-invoices, UPI and other payment transactions, and records of sales
through agreed access mechanisms like the Account Aggregator network. By consuming a
large number of micro-signals, such as payment gateway activity, procurement orders, and
receivable aging, the system can build a real-time and detailed risk profile for every SME.
This methodology extends traditional balance-sheet analysis to reflect real cash flows and
business cycles.
AI-Based Credit Scoring: Machine learning algorithms would translate these inputs into an
SME credit rating or score, updated in real time. As an example, invoice-level analytics might
enable real-time dynamic credit limit changes based on receivable performance. The models
would be learned from past datasets taken from RBI credit bureaus, ICRA portfolio, and
industry standards, allowing default risk to be predicted accurately. SMEs would be able to
view their existing credit scores using a web or mobile dashboard, with early warning signals
giving flagging signs of rising risk factors.
Automated Rating Issuance: Small and Medium Enterprises listed on portals such as Udyam
might seek an "ICRA SME Score" with minimal paperwork, as a large part of the required
information would be retrieved digitally. To promote widespread use, charges for micro and
extremely small businesses might be substantially subsidized, taking a cue from prevailing
NSIC subsidy models. ICRA's function would be to validate the automated score process as
per SEBI CRA standards and issue a clear, understandable rating justification per SME.
Lender Dashboard and Portfolio Analytics: The platform would provide banks and NBFCs
with access to an analytics portal showing risk metrics aggregated at the platform level. This
would comprise sector-based risk heatmaps, early delinquency patterns, and SME score
6
distribution across portfolios. These insights would lead to better lending decisions, lesser
dependence on manual valuation, enabling risk-based pricing and portfolio optimization over
time.
SME Development and Inclusion: Beyond credit evaluation, the platform would be able to
offer SMEs practical advice on enhancing creditworthiness, including quicker receivable
collection, liquidity management, and information on government credit schemes. This
advisory element would expand outreach and enhance financial literacy.
By merging ICRA's rating skills with next-generation data technologies, the platform makes
credit analytics an affordable, ongoing, and scalable solution for millions of SMEs, thereby
overtaking the traditional model of physical rating visits. It has been shown by research that
alternative credit models based on real-time data can boost loan approval rates by 25–30%
while lowering underwriting expenses, proving the effectiveness potential of this solution.
Regulatory and Risk Considerations
Implementing this platform requires careful attention to regulatory compliance and risk
management:
Regulatory Compliance: As a credit rating agency, ICRA must adhere to SEBI’s CRA
regulations, including methodology disclosure and conflict-of-interest safeguards. Any
automated score issued as a formal rating must be backed by a validated methodology and
rationale. Additionally, RBI’s digital lending guidelines require transparency, standardized
disclosures, and secure digital contracts. All usage of data shall be approved, and loan
releases will have to adhere to RBI regulations, such as direct credits to borrower accounts
without concealed fees. Data protection laws, such as the Digital Personal Data Protection
framework, shall regulate management of SME financial data.
Priority Sector Lending and Government Schemes: Banks are required to provide a
proportion of lending to micro and small businesses under Priority Sector Lending (PSL)
specifications. A digital scoring platform with transparency would help banks in evidencing
adequate credit assessment of PSL loans and support lending under government guarantee
schemes, like CGTMSE. ICRA's platform should ensure regulatory definition congruence in
credit models as well as subsidy ceilings for rating fees, where relevant.
Operational and Financial Risks: Machine learning algorithms need to be constantly validated
to avoid bias, drift, or scoring errors. Cyber security is paramount when aggregating sensitive
SME data, requiring strong encryption and IT security compliance. Financially, creating the
7
platform involves substantial initial investment, and balancing subsidized access for smaller
SMEs with revenue from large corporate ratings or lender subscriptions for sustainability is
crucial.
By following SEBI and RBI guidelines, ensuring data confidentiality, and being transparent
in the scoring process, the platform can avoid regulatory and operational risk while achieving
credibility and trust between SMEs and lenders.
Impact and Feasibility
The digital SME credit analytics platform proposed has the potential to greatly improve SME
credit flow and inclusion:
Greater Credit Availability: By giving lenders real-time, accurate information on SME
creditworthiness, more businesses, such as micro and first-time borrowers, might be able to
obtain loans. Data-driven lending has been proven to raise approval by 25–30%, enabling
banks to lend confidently to previously opaque borrowers and closing the credit supply gap.
Speedier Processing and Reduced Costs: Automation and digital integration make the loan
process more efficient. Pilots of India's Unified Lending Interface (ULI) have established that
loan disbursement can be reduced from weeks to minutes. Less paperwork and automated
approvals reduce loan origination costs, which can mean reduced interest rates for SMEs.
Increased Geographic Reach: Online platforms overcome geographical branch limitations,
and SMEs in Tier-3 and Tier-2 cities and rural regions can now get formal credit without
going to the bank. At the moment, formal credit is available to a very small percentage of
SMEs, so the growth potential is huge.
Portability and Scalability: Building on India's already established digital infrastructure, such
as GSTN, DigiLocker, and Account Aggregators, facilitates scaling across the country. A
SaaS model makes it possible for ICRA to serve thousands of SMEs at once with incremental
cloud capacity, providing financial and operational scalability. Adoption can be supplemented
through subsidies and government promotion.
Portfolio Health and Systemic Stability: With improved information for risk assessment,
loans can be priced appropriately, portfolios can be tracked efficiently, and sectoral risks can
be detected early before defaults happen. This minimizes systemic risk and makes the
financial system more robust.
8
Overall, the innovation holds a lot of promise: increased access for SMEs, quicker and more
streamlined lending procedures, broader geographic reach, and enhanced risk management.
India's information infrastructure, coupled with ICRA's knowledge base, sets this platform up
to succeed in bridging the knowledge gap and speeding up SME-driven economic
development.
Conclusion
SME credit ratings and analytics are key enablers of penetrating deeper into financial services
in India's micro-business economy. Presently, formal rating coverage is very low, leading to
unserved credit demand even as MSME loan volumes go up. With the use of new
technologies in data, real-time analytics, and AI-driven scoring, an ICRA-initiated digital
SME credit analytics platform can revolutionize lending to small and medium businesses.
Such a solution would facilitate quicker approvals, equitable pricing, and wider inclusion,
especially for first-time borrowers and businesses in Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities. Alignment with
SEBI CRA regulations, RBI digital lending guidelines, and data privacy regulations, along
with sound operational risk management, would lend credibility, security, and trust. Finally,
combining the rating skills of ICRA with cutting-edge analytics could potentially unlock the
entire economic potential of India's SME segment, drive entrepreneurship, financial
inclusion, and long-term economic growth.
9
References
ICRA Limited. (n.d.). MSME Credit Ratings by ICRA [Brochure]. ICRA Ltd.
SMERA Ratings Pvt. Ltd. (2023). Helping SMEs Grow. SMERA (SME Rating Agency)
website.
SMERA Ratings Pvt. Ltd. (2023, June 30). SME credit: challenges and SMERA solutions.
SMERA blog.
TransUnion CIBIL. (2024). MSME Pulse – February 2024.
Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises, Government of India. (2024). Annual
Report 2023–24.
Wadhawan, A., & Singh, A. (2025, June 21). Why Indian MSMEs must prioritise digital
maturity for growth. Hindustan Times.
CredAble Team. (2025, May 21). Beyond credit scores: How digital lending models are
powering SME credit in India. CredAble Business Insights.
Reserve Bank of India. (2025). Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises [FAQs]. RBI website.
10