Value Chain Analysis for Climate Resilience
Value Chain Analysis for Climate Resilience
Programme
01 02
Agriculture Value Value Chain
Chain Analysis - Mapping
Tools & Methodology
Page 1 Page 5
03 04
Analysing Financial Analysing technology,
Aspects of Value knowledge and Management
Chain Aspects of Value Chain
Page 11 Page 15
05 06
Analysing Post-Harvest, Value Climate change
Addition and Marketing Aspects & Agri value
of Value Chain chain
Page 19 Page 23
List of Figures
Figure 1: Agri-Value Chain 5
Figure 2: Key questions for decision making 6
Figure 3: Agri value chain actors 8
Figure 4: Core Processes in Cotton Value Chain 9
Figure 5: Process and Actors in Honey Value Chain 10
Figure 6: Commodity flow 11
Figure 7: Example of Price built up across supply chain 14
01 1.
1.
Session Plan
Time Slot Key Points Method
15 min Value chain, aspects and approach Lecture with Power point presentation
15 min Tools used in value chain analysis Lecture with Power point presentation
15 min Steps to follow in value chain analysis Lecture with Power point presentation
15 min Activity analysis and value analysis in a value chain Lecture with Power point presentation
15 min Evaluation and planning in a value chain Lecture with Power point presentation
The handout shall cover the details of Agriculture value chain analysis, tools & methodology as mentioned below:
Pre-
production Production Processing Marketing
Successful agricultural value chains are both productive and sustainable; it is important to conserve the environment
& natural resource base; adapt to climate change, price fluctuations & consumer needs and to improve people’s lives
and livelihoods and provide sustainable pathways to sufficient, nutritious & affordable food to meet the challenge of
our growing population.
The Value chain analysis is built on a market system (in particular a supply chain), detailing both structural and
dynamic factors that affect the contributions of each actor to the chain.
End markets, business enabling environment, supporting market, vertical and horizontal linkages are the structural
factors that affect the value chain. Dynamic factors are value chain governance, inter firm relationship and upgrading.
The concept of value chain encompasses the issues of organization and coordination; the strategies and the power
relationship (including gender concerns) of the different actors in the chain. The value chain concept helps in tracing
product flows and shows value additions at different stages, identifying key actors and their relationships in the
chain, identifying enterprises that contribute to production, services and required institutional support, identifying
bottlenecks preventing progress, provides a framework for sector-specific action, identifying strategies to help local
enterprises to compete and to improve earning opportunities, identifying relevant stakeholders for program planning.
It is an approach that analyses a production unit or process in a market chain - from input suppliers to final buyers,
and the relationships among them. It analyses the factors influencing performance, including access to and the
requirements of end market; the legal, regulatory and policy environment; coordination between firms in the industry;
and the level and quality of support services.
• Participant observation: It is a qualitative tool wherein an intensive involvement with people over an extended
period of time is done with an aim to gain a close and intimate familiarity with a given group of individuals.
• Semi structured Interview: It is a qualitative method of inquiry that combines a pre-determined set of open
questions with the opportunity for the interviewer to explore a particular theme. It is open in nature focus on
interviewee.
• Focus group discussion: It is a qualitative method of research wherein group of 8 to 10 people discuss a
particular theme. Moderator plays an important role in facilitating the discussion.
• Structured Questionnaire: It is a quantitative method of research. Here each interview is structured in a particular
manner.
• Market Mapping: In market mapping, market is being studied in terms of price trend of various commodity,
influence and relationship among market players. It is done to identify issues in functioning of market and
opportunity.
Activity Analysis
• The activities of a value chain and sub component of each activity can be analysed.
Value Analysis
• Value that changes across the chain is analysed to achieve required standard of quality and reliability. It also
analyses factors affecting the cost, and ways and means to minimize the same.
• The impact, sustainability of the value chain and the degree of coordination and synergy among the actors and
processes are assessed.
• Short and long-term solutions for guiding decision-making process for sustainable value chain development are
formulated.
Activities: Pre-production
This contains activities which are necessary for better production. In this, the factors of production like land, labour
and material are analysed.
Example: Planting the sapling or sowing the seed, irrigation, nutrient management, pest, disease management and
harvesting.
Activities: Transportation
It aims at availing certain produces at certain location through some arrangement and equipment and vehicles.
Activities: Marketing
It is a function which results in creating options for the consumer to buy a product at optimum price and of better
quality. The product moves from farm to consumer. Different interconnected activities are involved in achieving this,
such as production planning, grading, packing, transport, storage, agro and food processing, distribution, advertising
and sale.
Production Distribution
Primary Stakeholders
2.
Session Plan
Time Key Points Method
15 min Mapping core processes and players in a Lecture with Power point presentation.
value chain
15 min Mapping product, information, knowledge Lecture with Power point presentation.
flow and geographic flow of product in a
value chain
15 min Mapping services in a value chain Lecture with Power point presentation.
15 min Mapping constraints and solutions at Lecture with Power point presentation.
different processes of a value chain
The handout shall cover the details of mapping the core processes, main players involved in these processes, product,
information and knowledge mapping, geographical flow of the product, mapping the constraints and potential
solutions of the value chain as mentioned on following page;
?
Table 1: Core process mapping matrix
Commodity Core Processes Detail activity in the core process
Green gram* Post-harvest value addition Cleaning, drying, sorting, grading, splitting/crushing for dal
and primary processing* making, packaging, etc.*
* Some examples to aid clarity
Figure 8: Example of major market channels in villages from Chatrapur sub division in Ganjam district
(Odisha)
(Major market channel actors are highlighted in shaded box)
Input Provision* Biofertilisers and Biopesticides production Unit facility @25% of total financial outlay subject
to the maximum of Rs 40 lakh per unit, whichever is less for Individuals, group of farmers/
growers, proprietary, and partnership firms, Co-operatives, Fertilizer industry, Companies,
Corporations, NGOs under National Project on Organic Farming*
Cultivation* For protected cultivation in green house with fan & pad structures, the maximum permissible
cost per m2 for calculation of subsidy will vary from Rs.1420/- to Rs.1650/- out of which 70%
of the cost will be provided as subsidy. The beneficiary will contribute the balance cost as
beneficiary’s share. Maximum area per beneficiary is 2500 m2*
Collection/ Aggregation & pack house facility with credit linked back-ended subsidy @ 35% of the cost
of project in general areas and 50% of cost in case Hilly & Scheduled areas for individual
Aggregation* entrepreneurs under MIDH*
Post-harvest Establishment of mini dal mills by farmers, farmer groups or registered FPOs (@Rs. 10.00
value addition, lakhs, or 30% of the total cost, whichever is lower, as one-time support) under NFSM (Pulse)*
processing*
Export/ Import* The authorized laboratories shall issue certificate of analysis to the
exporter/processing unit as per the prescribed format within 96 hrs from drawl of sample.
The laboratory shall declare that the sampling has been done in the APEDA registered Pea nut
(ground nut) processing unit, integrated peanut processing unit, peanut shelling unit, peanut
grading unit, peanut shelling-cum-grading unit, peanuts go downs/storage*
* Some examples to aid clarity
Reference: [Link]
3.
Time Slot Key Points Method
30 min Price build up across supply chain, value chain Lecture with Power point presentation.
finance
The handout shall cover the details of financial aspects of agri value chain as mentioned below;
Cost particulars Amount (Rs) Cost particulars Amount (Rs) Cost particulars Amount (Rs)
10. Total Revenue 4500* Net profit 2000* Cost Benefit Ratio 1.8*
(Total Quantity in (300kgX15) (Total Revenue- (4500-2500) (Total Revenue/ (4500/2500)
Kg X cost per Total cost) Total cost)
Kg)
* Some examples to aid clarity
The cost benefit ratio can be calculated for each actor in a value chain to know the profit of each actor in the value
chain. For a processor, it can be calculated by dividing total cost of production of the processed product to the total
revenue earned from selling the product. Cost benefit analysis of other actors in the value chain can be done in the
same process. For a trader, this can be calculated by dividing total cost of trading (procurement cost + value addition
& packaging cost + transportation & logistic cost + marketing cost) to the total revenue earned from selling the
product.
Figure 9 depicts the price build up by different players across the supply chains and percentage of the total quantity
covered by different supply chains.
4.
Session Plan
Time Slot Key Points Method
30 min Analysis of technology use in different stages of agri Lecture with Power point
value chain presentation
30 min Capacity need assessment, analysis of Knowledge and Lecture with Power point
capacity of the value chain players presentation
The handout shall cover the details of technology mapping, knowledge and capacity mapping and capacity need
assessment of the players in agri value chain as mentioned below;
The matrix presented in Table 7 can be used to capture the information regarding use of technology by the farmer.
IFFCO
C. D. Bio fertilizer:
Micronutrient:
D. Soil test: 1. Yes 2. No D. Adoption 1. Yes √ 2. No.
of soil test
recommendations:
E. Application 1. 2. Behind 3. At root zone √ 4. Fertigation 5. Other
method: Broadcasting plough (specify)
Capacity need assessment is a process of evaluating existing gaps within farmer groups in terms of knowledge,
skills, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats, assets and other elements required for them to achieve the pre-
specified objectives. Capacity is interrelated in three levels: Individual, organizational and enabling environment.
Three steps are involved in the capacity need assessment. The first step involves identifying the existing capacity
amongst farmer groups. At this stage, existing assets, existing knowledge and skills and existing policy environment
are identified. The second step involves identification of the desired levels of capacity. This is the capacity level
necessary for the farmer groups’ objectives to be achieved. Finally, the gap between the two steps is identified which
is the difference between the desired and the existing levels of capacity. A structured and participatory approach is
required for assessing capacity needs. Capacity need assessment shall help in planning suitable capacity building
programs to strengthen knowledge, skills, processes and systems to achieve goals and meet objectives.
5.
Session Plan
The handout shall cover the details of analysis of post-harvest scenario and market in agri value chain as mentioned
below;
For analysing the current status of post-harvest scenario, the data can be captured as per the format displayed in
table 10.
For analysing the current status of market for raw and value-added products, the data can be captured as per the
format mentioned in table 11 & 12.
Selling price % of produce Time gap in Selling price % of produce Time gap in
(Rs/Kg) sold price realization (Rs/Kg) sold price realization
(days) (days)
[Link] Gate/Door 10* 30* 5*
step
[Link] Hat/ 15* 30* 1*
Mandi
[Link] sale 20* 40* 7*
Market
[Link]/Tied
sale
[Link] Town/
City Market
[Link] District
[Link] State
[Link] (specify)
(II) Availability of (i) <2 Kms (ii) 2-5 Kms √ (iii) 5-10 kms (iv) >10 Kms
mandi/market/
Krushak bazar
5. Mandi/Market 6. Other
(specify)
6.
Session Plan
20 min Value chain approach to climate resiliency Lecture with Power point
presentation.
20 min Analysis of climate change impact and responses at Lecture with Power point
pre-production and production stages in agri-value chain presentation.
20 min Analysis of climate change impact and responses at Lecture with Power point
post-harvest stages in agri- value chain presentation.
The handout shall cover value chain approach to climate resiliency and analysis of climate change impacts and
responses of the value chain players at different stages of agri value chain as mentioned below;
The analysis of climate impacts and responses along the value chain can be done through qualitative and
participatory approach to elucidate perception of value chain actors on climate impacts and responses, and to
promote climate adaptation. Climate hazards such as droughts, floods and changing rainfall patterns negatively
affect all actors of a value chain, but in different ways and to different extents. Most players are making some
effort to minimize the negative impacts of climate hazards on their activities, but not all responses are sustainable.
Furthermore, a lack of communication and trust between and among the players along the value chain particularly
hampers climate adaptation.
For analyzing the current status of adoption of climate resilient practices in the field, the information/data can be
captured as per the format mentioned in table 13.
Table 14: Assessing climate risk, impact & responses by the value chain players at pre-production &
Production stages
Stage Climate Risk Impact Coping mechanism/Responses
Pre- Dry spell Vegetative growth of saplings affected, Watering at frequent intervals*
production moisture stress condition, temporary wilting*
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm Leaf damage, sapling damage and mortality* Gap filling*
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm Damage of leaves, flowers and pods* Removal of broken twigs/
branches and damaged pods
and leaves*
Late monsoon
Draught
Cyclone
*Some examples to aid clarity
For assessing climate risk, impact & responses by the value chain players at storage, processing and marketing
stages, data/information can be captured in the format as shown in table 15.
Wet spell Pest and fungal Preventing rain water to enter storage room/
infestation* container, arranging proper ventilation, putting the
grain bags above the ground surface on racks*
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
Wet spell Raw material supply and Preventing the raw materials and grain stock from
product delivery affected, getting wet*
quality deterioration of
grain*
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood Water logging, poor Draining of excess water from market yard, stores
drainage, wastage of and counters, restoration of power supply through
products, effect on alternate arrangements, shifting of products to
power supply, effect on safer place*
transportation, product
supply and transaction*
Cyclone
*Some examples to aid clarity
1 District: 2 Block:
3 GP: 4 Village:
5 Respondent’s 6 Father/
Name: Husband’s
Name:
[Link]
[Link]
10 Education: 1. Illiterate 2. Primary /UP [Link] School/ [Link] & above [Link]/
Inter Trade
(in Ac.)
17 Hours of
irrigation per
acre:
18 No. of irrigation
per month:
Insect/ pest:
Disease:
equipment:
25 Packaging: 1. Gunny bag 2. Polythene bag 3. wooden box 4. Paper cartoon 5. Plastic 6. Bamboo
crates basket
7. Other (specify) 8. No
Wastage (%):
29 Access to credit: 1. Commercial 2. [Link] 3. Gramya Bank 4. Pvt. Bank 5. Money 6. Other
Bank lender (specify)
[Link]
32
33
34
35
1 Name
2 Address
3 District 4 State
10 In case of seasonal
business, what is his
engagement in lean/off
season
12 Place of procurement [Link] district 2. Outside district 3. Outside state 4. Other (specify)
4. supply of 5. Other 6. No
inputs
16 Place of sale [Link] district 2. Outside district 3. Outside state 4. Other (specify)
18 Transaction details During harvest 1-3 month after 4-6 month after
harvest harvest
Wastage (%)
1. Farmer Consumer
Dry spell
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
24 Opportunities
Short term
Long term
2 Name of proprietor/
Respondent
3 Address
4 District 5 State
a. Light b. Power
13 Type of product
15 Place of procurement [Link] in district 2. Outside district 3. Outside state 4. Other (specify)
4. supply of 5. Other 6. No
inputs
19 Place of sale (%) [Link] district 2. Outside district 3. Outside state 4. Outside country
20 Consumers’ preferences
Wastage (%)
Av. Volume of
production (Qtl)
23 Participation of women
in food processing
Dry spell
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late monsoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
27 Opportunities
Short term
Long term
4 Name of Dealer/
Respondent:
5 Address
6 District: 7 State
10 Commonly used
varieties:
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link] driven
Dry spell
Wet spell
Heat wave
Hail storm
Late mansoon
Draught
Flood
Cyclone
16 Opportunities
Short term
Long term
6 Name of the
Respondent
7 Designation
8 Address
9 Contact number 10 Email
Agents
15 Major buyers/ [Link] in district 2. Outside 3. Outside state 4. Outside country
customers (%) district
18 Facilities available
Short term
Long term
Mapping constraints and potential solutions improves the sustainability of value chains by providing a comprehensive overview of challenges and opportunities at various stages of production. This process identifies bottlenecks, inefficiencies, and risks, allowing stakeholders to formulate targeted strategies to enhance resilience and sustainability . It fosters better resource allocation, innovation in problem-solving, and proactive planning to address environmental and market challenges .
The primary stages of an agricultural value chain include pre-production, production, processing, transportation, and marketing. Each stage is essential in adapting to climate change as they collectively influence product quality, supply, and demand. By focusing on climate-smart practices during these stages, such as improved irrigation techniques and crop management, the overall resilience and sustainability of the value chain can be enhanced .
A lack of communication and trust between value chain players hampers climate adaptation by preventing the effective exchange of information, collaboration, and coordinated response actions. This can lead to fragmented efforts where players may not fully leverage collective strengths and resources to implement adaptive measures. Consequently, it exacerbates vulnerability to climate impacts .
Potential solutions for overcoming wastage at different stages of the agricultural value chain include improving post-harvest handling techniques, adopting better storage facilities, optimizing transportation logistics, and enhancing processing efficiency. Additionally, investing in technologies that prolong shelf life and implementing better market linkage strategies can reduce wastage significantly . Engaging stakeholders in coordinated efforts to innovate and improve resource management also plays a critical role .
Improving the effectiveness of technological interventions in agricultural value chains to address climate impacts involves aligning technology with farmer needs and capacity, enabling access to climate-smart technologies, and fostering innovation partnerships. Training and education, coupled with financial incentives for adopting new technologies, can accelerate uptake and ensure sustainability . Additionally, integrating technology with traditional knowledge can enhance resilience by offering adaptable solutions that mitigate the unique challenges posed by climate change .
Climate-resilient practices vary across different stages of the value chain, with each stage requiring targeted interventions specific to its processes. For instance, during pre-production, practices may involve selecting drought-resistant seed varieties, while in production, it may involve precision irrigation systems. In processing, practices such as using renewable energy sources and reducing waste improve efficiency and sustainability . These practices enhance the resilience of the entire value chain to climate variability and extremes .
Analytical tools used in value chain analysis for climate resilient agriculture include value mapping matrices, cost-benefit analysis matrices, and climate risk assessment techniques. These tools help in evaluating and planning value chain improvements by examining how activities, costs, and value contributions influence sustainability and decision-making processes . The use of such tools allows stakeholders to identify vulnerabilities and opportunities for upgrading the value chain to withstand climate impacts .
Stakeholders play crucial roles in adapting agricultural value chains to climate change by collaborating to address and mitigate climate impacts. They engage in activities such as strategic planning, capacity building, and implementing adaptive practices across the value chain stages, including production and marketing. This collaboration helps develop resilient systems by improving communication and trust among value chain actors, which is often a barrier to effective adaptation .
Value chain analysis supports climate resilient agricultural practices by systematically examining the activities and elements that create value at each stage of the agricultural production process. This analysis allows for the identification and integration of climate-smart practices by evaluating climate risks, impacts, and responses at different stages of the agri-value chain . By mapping core processes and assessing factors such as water, energy, and soil vulnerabilities, value chains can be upgraded to become more sustainable and climate-resilient .
Climate change impacts the pre-production and production stages of the agri-value chain by altering the availability and quality of resources such as land, labor, and materials. These stages face heightened risks like droughts, floods, and changing rainfall patterns, which can affect crop yield and quality . These climate hazards require strategic adaptation measures to ensure sustainable production .