Understanding Investment Decisions
Understanding Investment Decisions
1
INVESTMENT DECISIONS
CONTENTS
1.0 Aims and Objectives
1.1 Introduction
1.2.2 Speculation
15 Let us Sum up
1.7 Keywords
1.8 Questions for Discussion
Componentsof Investment
Evaluation of Securities
6
Security Analysis and 1.1 INTRODUCTION
Portfolio Management
Investment involves making ofa sacrifice in the present with the hope of deriving
future
[Link] has many meanings and facets. Two most important features of an
investment are current sacrifice and future benefit. We can identify a variety of activities
which display the two features of investment. For example. A
Portfolio manager buys
10,000 shares of ITCLtd for his mutual fund:
your relative may have subscribed to the
6-year Post Office Monthly IncomeScheme.A corporate firm may spend Rs. 5 crores
for expansion programmers; a middle aged man with a family decides to sped Rs. 10
lakhs to buy an apartment in a city and so on. All these constitute investment activities
because they involve current sacrifice of consumption and hope of future gain.
Perhaps,
an investment in an apartment for the purpose ofliving in it may involve, partially at least
certain,current consumption but because the family will continuc to live in the house for
a very long period of time, the act of purchasing a house or apartment may be taken as
an investment activity.
We can now give a simple yet a broad definition of investment. We can define investment
as “Postponed Consumption".
When you postpone consumption, sacrifice takes place in the present and is certain
whereas the benefits occur in future and are uncertain. Therefore, Risk and Expected
return from the investment are the two key determinants of Investment process.
Atthis point, it is necessary to distinguish between certain activities which are in the
nature of gambling and those which are genuine investments. For instance, if you buy
Rs. 1000 worth of lotteryticket you may be sacrificing current consumption in the hope
of winning a handsome return but you are not really investing. In gambling or change
games,winning involves a lot of luck and the outcome as largely very uncertain. A buyer
not win and that the
of lottery tickets knows that he will lose the noney spent if he does
act of winning is not in his hands. However, an investor, not being a speculator, does not
proceed with the assumption that he would lose his money because
the act of investment
have an
decision making isa well-thoughtout process. Genuine investors would always
the risk profile ofthe investor,
appropriate [Link] which is analyzed. In relative to
and thereafter the actual investment avenue is selected. However, in real life, it is very
motives
difficultto draw a very clear demarcating line to separate speculative or gambling
genuine investment motives and the difference is purely a matter of opinion.
firm the
In other words investment refers to a commitment of funds to one or more assets that
will be held over some future time period. Almost all individuals have wealth of some
kind, ranging from the value of their services in the workplace to tangible assets
to
Why Invest
We invest to improve our future welfare. Fundsto be invested come from assets already
1.2.1 Investment
1.2.2 Speculation
term gain.
means taking up the business risk in the hope of getting
short
Speculation
profit from the price fluctuations. This can be explained with an example. If a spouse
If she buys
Duys a stock for its dividend, she may be termed as an investor. with the
anticipation of price rise in the near future and the hope of selling it at a gain price she
would be termed as a speculator. The dividing line between speculation and investment
Is very thin because people buy stocks for dividends and capital appreciation.
Ihe time factor inyolved in the speculation and investment The investor
is different.
is
Interested in consistent good rate of return fora longer period. He is primarily concerned
WIth the direct benefits provided by the securities in the long run. The speculator is
interested getting abnormal return i.e, extremely
in
Sccurity Anasis and high rate of return than the normial
otfatio return in the short run. Speculator's investments are
Manngement made for short-term.
The speculator is more interested in the market actíon and
its price movement. The
investor constantly evaluates the worth
security whereas the speculator evaluates the
of
price movement. He is not worried about the
fundamental factors like his counterpart.
the investor.
The investor would try to match the risk and return. The speculator would like to assume
greater risk than the investors. Risk refers to the possibility of incurring lossin a financial
transaction. The negative short term fluctuations affect the speculators in a worse manner
than the investors. The risk factor involved in the investment is also limited. A fter studying
the factors related with the concerned company's
stock, the investor buys itand hence
the risk exposure is limited. The investor likes to invest in securities wherehis principal
would be safe.
Investor
Speculator
Return Likes to have moderate rate of Like to have high returns for assuming high
return associated with limited risk.
risk.
Funds Uses his own funds and avoids Uses borrowed funds to
borrowed funds. supplement his
personal resources.
1998 at Rs.50, disposed at Rs.60 in 1999 and the dividend yield is Rs.5, then the
return would be calculatedas follows:
2 Risk: Risk of holding securities is related with the probability of actual return
becoming less than the expected return. The word risk is synonymouswith the
phrase variability of return. Investments' risk is just as important as measuring its
expected rate of return because minimising risk and maximising the rate of return
The depends upon the marketing and trading facility. Ifa portion of the
liquidity
investment could be converted into cash without much loss of time, it would help
the investor meet the emergencies. Stocks are liquid only if they command good
market by providing adequate return through dividends and capital appreciation.
4 Hedge against inflation: Since there is inflation in almost all the economy, the
higher than the rate of inflation, otherwise the investor will have loss in real terms.
Growth stocks would appreciate in their values overtime and provide a protection
against inflation. The return thus earned should assure the safety of the principal
amount, regular flow of incomeand be a hedge against inflation.
5. Safety: The selected investment avenue should be under the legal and regulatory
frame work. If it is not under the legal frame work, it is difficult to represent the
grievances, if any. Approval ofthe law itselfadds a flavour of safety. Even though
approved by law, the safety of the principal differs from one mode of investment to
another. Investments done with the government assure more safety than with the
private party. From the safety point of view investments can be ranked as follows:
oftheinvestment decision
After understanding the concept of investment and the nature
you might now know as to how does an investor go about the task or business of
like to
investing? How much to invest at any moment? And when to make or unmake the
investment? These questions essentially relate to the investment process which is briefly
outlined in this section. A typical investment decision undergoes a five step procedure
which, in turn, formsthe basis of the investment process, these steps are:
.Objectives
Knowledge Company
-Future
value
allocation
that notable cases of mispricing will be corrected by the market in future which
implies that prices of undervalued shares will increase and those of overvalued
shares will decline.
3.
Portfolio Construction: This consistsof identifying the specific securities in which
to invest and determining the proportion of the investor's wealth to be invested in
each. For example, a conservative may decide to invest, say, 70 per cent
individual
able to achieve when the returns of shares and debentures which would comprise
his portfolio are not positively correlated to each other. The resultant portfolio would
be known as diversified'portfolio. Thus, portfolio constructionwould address itself
to three major problems via., selectivity, timing, and diversification. The related
questions would be which specific shares/ debentures to buy, when to buy, and
how best tocombinethen in a way that risk is reduced to a minimum for a given
level of expected return?
4
Portfolio Revision: As time passes, the investor would discover that securities
which once were very attractive have ceased to be so. Also, new securities with
promises of high returns and relatively low risk have emerged. In view of such
a way, he repeats the first three steps of the investment process. He sets new
investment policy, undertakes security analysis afresh, and re-allocates his cash
for the new portfolio. It must be observed that the transaction costs incurred in the
buy-sell activities relating to the new portfolioand also the extent of improvement
expected in the future outlook of new securities would be important considerations
in the revision of given portfolio.
constantly examine
investor would
12 Evaluation: A rational fordoing somust
5. Portfolio Performance and risk. Measures
return
Security Analysis and both for average be compared with
positions must
portfolio
his chosen
Portfolio Management risk-return acquires
the calculated
be developed. Also, step in the investment
process, thus,
This
yardsticks or norms. measurement
of
certain are quantitative
since the tasks involved
considerable significance norms.
against objective
actual risk
and return their evaluation
ATTRIBUTES/ FACTORS
1.3INVESTMENT OF INVESTMENT
INFLUENCING SELECTION definite ideas regarding
features
will need
investments, investors be consistent with the
features should
choosing specific
In
should possess. These all the incidental
should afford them
portfolios
which their
objectives and, in addition, For evaluation
general the circumstances.
are possible under
investors'
and advantages which
conveniences are relevant:
the following attributes
an investment avenue,
Returns
2 Capital Appreciation
(a) Conservation
() Aggressive Growth
(ii) Speculation
(b)
)
Form of Return
(i)
Periodic Cash Receipts
Capital Gain
Funds
3. Safety and Security of
(a) Risk
(b) Liquidity
(d) Conveyance
(e) Conceivability
stocks".
(c) Tax Benefits: To plan an investment programme without regard to one's tax status
may be costly to the investor. There are really two problems involved here, one
concerned with the amount of income paid by the investment and the other wiu
(d)Conceivabiliy:
unacceptable levels
To be
of
safe from social disorders
taxation, property
,govenment
must be concealable and leave
confiscatiol,
no record
of incomereceived been
from its use or sale. Gold and precious stones have long
esteemed for these purposes
1.3.1InvestmentAlternatives
The problem of surplus gives rise to the question ofwhere to invest. In the
past, investment
avenues were limited to real assets, schemes of the post
office and banks. At
present, a
wide varietyof investment avenues are open to the
investors to syit their needs and
nature. A knowledge about the different avenues enables the investors
to choose
investmentintelligently. The required level of return and the risk
tolerance level decide
the choice of the investor. The investment
alternatives ranges from financial securities
to traditional non-security investments. The financial securities may be
negotiable or
non-negotiable.
the post offices, banks, companies, and non-banking financial companies are of this
category. The tax-sheltered schemes such as public provident fund, national savings
certificate and national savings schemeare also non-securitisedfinancial investments.
Mutual fund is another investment alternate. It is of recent origin in India. Within a short
Span of time several financial institutions and banks have floated varieties of mutual
funds. The investors with Iimited funds can invest in the mutual funds and can have the
benefits of thestock market and money market investments as specified by the particular
fund.
The real assets always find a place in the portfolio. They are gold, silver, arts, property
and antiques. These are non-financialinvestment.
Equity
1
2 Preference shares
3 Debentures
(b)
Certificates ofdeposits
(c)
Commercial paper
(d)
Repos
14
6. Non-marketable financial assets
Security Analysis and
Portfolio Management
(a) Bank deposits
() Company Deposits
7. Real estate
Land
() Agricultural
8 Precious objects
9. Insurance policies
() Immediate Annuity
the stock market was the best and safest place for the common individual to invest.
Since 1996 the share market prices have been low. This made the retail investors
Growth shares: The stocks that have higher rate of growth than the industrial
growth rate in profitability are referred to as growth shares. For example, the
list of major gainers for 1999 is dominated by software sector stocks. The
HCL and Infosystems share prices increased sharply.
(ii) Defensive shares: Defensive stocks are relatively unaffected by the market
movements. For example, a host of pharmaceutical stocks posted returns in
excess of50 per cent in [Link] pharmaceutical industry owing to its inherent
(iv) Cyclical shares: The business cycle affects the cyclical [Link] upward
and downwardmovements of thebusinesscycle affect the business prospects
of certain companies and their stock prices. Such shares provide low to
moderate current yield. Capital gain may be highly variable. For example, the
automobile sector stocks are affected by the business cycles.
(v) Speculative shares: Shares that have lot of speculative trading in them are
referred to as speculative shares. During the bull and bear phases of the
market, this type of shares attracts the attention of the traders.
The stocks, which fall under one category in one period may switch over to another
category in another period. The classification should not be considered rigid. For
(a) Preference shares: A preference shares are no longer regarded as inferior to the
equity capital. Corporate like Siemens has placed Rs. 150 cr. worth of preference
The conversion options provided in the by preference shares also make it attractive.
The biggest advantage is the tax-exempt status of the preference share's dividend.
(b) Debentures: Corporate debentures are an option available to the investors who
are willing to sacrifice liquidity for higher return. Manufacturing companies like
Gujarat Industries Power and TISCO have issued debentures. If the detbentures
are not activelytraded in the debt segment of the capital market, the investorsmay
have to hold the instrument till maturity. If theinstruments were actively traded in
the secondary market, it would have perhaps changed hands at a considerable
premium, thereby lowering the yield on par with the present interest rate. These
reasons contribute towards high coupon rates on debentures.
(c) Bonds:Bonds are similarto the debentures but they are issued by the public sector
undertakings. The value of the bond in the market depends upon the interest rate
and the [Link] coupon rate is the nominal interest rate offered on the bonds.
Thecoupon rate is contractual involving the terms and conditions of theissuance
of the debt security. Being contractual it cannot be changed during the tenure of
the instrument. The investors are not affected by lowering of the bank rates, When
the bank rates are lowered, actually, the value of the bonds, which are carrying
have issued
IDBIandICICI discount
would appreciate. are deep
interest rates above the bank rate Some of them
ofthe investors.
arity Analysis and to suit the needs and index bond.
Management
various bonds benefit bond the
folio
benefit bond. retirement office
with
bond, education issued by the post arc in
certificates The 1VPs
IVPs and KVPs: These are saving Vikas Patra (KVP). of
(d)
Vikas Patra
(IVP)and Kisan are in the
denomination
name S000. TheKVPs return of
with the
Indira
500. 1000
and
of Rs. in 5.5 years
value doubled
the face The capital is and therefore
5000 and 10000. by hand delivery
Rs, 1000, transferable concession
IVPs are like bearer
bonds, No incometax
13.47%. cash transactions.
who prefer
to the persons
are attractive
of investment. Government
for this type
is available Central, State
issued by the or gilt edged
The securities securities
(e) Government
securities:
are known as Government it is a
agencies in the Government,
and QuasiGovernment security is a claim
capital. The
securities.
As Government guaranteedguarantees the income and the
instrument, which oftheir high
liquidity
secured financial is relatively
lower because
on these securities
rate of interest
Treasury bills
Commercial paper
Certificate ofdeposit
borrowing
an instrument of short term
Treasury bills: A treasury
bill is basically
auctions. Generally, treasury bills are of 91-days. Since the interest rates
offered on the treasury bills are very low, individuals very rarely invest in
them.
Securitics
1.3.3 Non-negotiable
Deposits
fixed rate of return. Even though
earn deposits bank
Deposits resemble fixed
they are nottnegotiable instruments. Some ofthe income
securities deposits are dcalt
subscquently.
It is the simple investment
Bank deposits: avenue open for the
(a) investors. He has
an accounttand deposit the money.
the banks offered Traditionally
to open current
nt savings account and Tixed deposit
account. Current accountdoes not
acco terestrate. The drawback of having large
amounts in savings accounts
ie that the return is just 4.5 per cent. The savings account interest rate is reoulated
Daserve Bank of India and kept low because of the high cost of servicing.
hom The savings account is more liquid and convenient to handle. The fixed
high interest rate and the money is locked up for a fixed period.
carries
account
With inereasing competition among the banks, the banks have bundlcd the nlain
account to cater to the needs of the small savers
eavingsaccount with the fixed
by Somne Banks
Exhibit 1.2: Hybrid Accounts Offered
25,000
ATM card, Anywhere
FD linked to savings
banking, Internet
Quantum
Optima
account with Auto
Banking, & overdrat
sweep Reverse-sweep. facility.
Auto Renewal
facilities.
account with
Acount Savings facility.
Induslnd2-in-1 overdraft
Bank link to FD.
Cheque book.
FD 25,000
Cluster Savings linked
book and
25,000
ATM, Cheque
Sweep-in Savings linked to FD
phone banking.
account with Reverse-Sweep
and add-on-deposit.
IS allowed in the
increase
charged. been a significant
years, there has process of financial
In recent in the
NBFC deposits: companies The amendment
(C) of the RBI.
financial
of non-banking the purview
for the NBFCs.
under
Importance
NBFC comes
The compulsory
intermediation. made registration It varies
to five years.
of RBI
Act in Jan 1997, from few months the
ranges Finance.
The maturity period the Birla
Global
from
(i) Period: For example, with maturity
to company.
from company accepts deposits
Birla group
to Aditya
companybelonging on the
been based
3-5 years.
acceptance
of deposit has of RS
limit for net owned funds
limit: The not having
(ii) Maximum The NBFCs
of the company.
credit rating deposits.
to accept
25 lakh are not entitled bank on
higher than the commercial
rate is
(ii) Internet:
NBFCs offer interest differs according to maturity period. There
rate with the
The interest
public deposit.
rate among the
companiesin accordance similar
with
in the interest the companies
a disparity
the companies. Even
deposits. Generally.í
of
and policies
credit ratings
interest rates for their the
rates to cover
provide different
credit ratings interest
credit ratings offer higher
lower by some of the
companies with rates offered
Table l.1shows the interest
risk. The following
as on July 2004.
finance companies
by Finance Companies
Rates on Deposits Offered
Table 1.1: Interest
Amount
2years 3years
1 year
Company 25,000
6.50
Bajaj Auto Finance
6.50 20, 000
6.25
6.00
Birla Home Finance |
25,000
6.79 7.04
Canbank Factors
7.50 10,000
6.50 7.00
Chola Finance |||
6.60 10,000
6.10 6.35
Dewan Housing Finance
6.75 50,000
HUDCO 6.25 6.50
Investment Decisions
deposits with banks. To improve the liquidity of
NBFCs the percentage of
liquid assets required to be maintained by them has been enhanced from 12.5
percent to 15 percent with effect from April 1999 respectively. Company
Law Board is authorised to direct the defaulting NBFCs to repay the deposits.
In spite ofthe strict rules and regulations laid down by RBI the default rate is
high in the case of NBFCs. Lately, on January 3, 2009, RBI reduces repo
rate to 5.5%,an eight-and-a-halfyear low.
Tax sheltered savings schemes are of great importance to the investors in the tax-paying
category. The tax sheltered savings schemes offer tax relief to those who participate in
their schemes according to the income tax laws. The important tax sheltered savings
schemes are:
Hindu undivided families can participate in this scheme. The maximum limit per
annum for the deposit is Rs 60,000. The interest is accumulated in the deposit. It
Individuals and HUF are eligible to open NSS account in the designated post office.
in the NSs
capital are fully taxable if withdrawn during their lifetime. Investments
scheme, with a lock in period of 4 years qualify for a rebate of 20 per cent under
lower.
fixed tenure for investment. One can also keep the account alive and earn interest
percent on the entire amount withdrawn has proved too costly to the investors.
(c) National (
SavingsCertificate 6 yrs.)-III: This scheme is offered by the post
office. These certificates come in the denominations of Rs 500, 1,000, 5,000 and
Sec
10,000. The contribution and the interest for the first 5 years are covered by
88. The interest is cumulative at the rate of 12% per annum and payable biannually
is covered by Sec 80L. No withdrawals are
permitted. There is no deduction at
maturity.
(or
person assurcd
Life Insurance money to the of
of a sum insured against
ccurity Analysis and
for payment of event
is a contract the happening
ortfolio Management insurance on date of
Life the same) amount on
the maturity or at
to receive ofan
the person entitled
the payment Among other thi
for death occurs.
provides h
Usually the contract or if unfortunate
intervals to the corporation
dates at periodic of premium periodically
specified for the payment
also provide risk.
the contracts eliminates below:
Life insurance are given
holders.
the policy oflife insurance
The major advantages full protection
againe
risk of
death of the
saved is paid.
the amount are
schemes only savings' schemes
people the salary
method of
pavment
For the salaried facility
(ii) Easy payments: is an easy
instalment
there
or yearly mode.
Further,
introduced.
quarterly,
halfyearly
through monthly, policy.
security of the
raised on the
Loans can be for amounts
(i) Liquidity: Tax is available
in Income Tax and Wealth in force.
(iv) Ta relief: Tax relief
subject to the
tax rates
Plans:
(üi) Term Assurance
Whole
to 7 years with an option to purchase a new, Limited Payment
Life Policy or an Endowment Assurance Policy at the end oftheselecieu
for return of premiums paid, on the life assured surviving the term.
(V) Bima kiran: This plains an improved version of Bima Sandesh with :
h anadded
attraction of loyalty addition, in-built accident cover and Free Term Cover
after maturity, provided the policy is then in full force.
benefit.
for either immediate or deferred pension
Plans:
These plans provide
Pension
r made till the death of the annuitant (unless
(vii)
The pension payments are
for life. Both the Deferred
of guarantced period), Annuity
has provision
the policy
are available e with the return ofthe GIVE anount
plans
and Immediate Annuity
vesting under the Jeevan Dlhara Plan and returnof Purchase
On death after
Akslhay Plan,
Price on death under the Jeevan
plan
survivor-annuity-cum-assurance
vim) Jeevan Sarita: This is a Joint-life-last
where the claim amountis payable partly in lumpsum
(for husband and wife)
on the death
annuity. Balance sum is assured
of
and partly in the form of an
the survivor.
keep in force an insurance policy on the life of the assessee or on the life of
the wife or husband or any child (whether nminor or major) of the assessee,
irespective of the status of thechild are also eligible for income tax deduction.
Premiums paid under an insurance policy effected jointly on the lives of a husband
and wife or in the case of a Hindu Undivided Family jointly on the lives of two or
more members of thefamily are eligible for the prescribed deduction under Section
88. However, such relief is not
available on premiums paid on policies singly or
jointly on the lives of
other relatives.
Mutual Funds
Investment t companies or investment trusts obtain funds from large number of investors
uirough sale of units. The funds collected from the investors are placed under
management for
professional
the benefit of the investors.
Into
open-ended schemeand
The mutual funds are broadly classified
close-ended scheme.
(a)
Oppen-endedSchemes:
The open-ended scheme offers its units on a continuous
basis andl
accepts funds from
investors
continuously. Repurchase is carried out on
a
continuing
In other
basisthus,
words,there is an
,
helping the investorsto
withdraw their money at any time.
end scheme uninterrupted
entry and exit into the funds. The open-
has a
maturity period and
Investor can
deal
they are not listed in the stock exchanges.
Idirectly with the
The
open-endedfund
mutual fundfor investment as well as redemption.
is provides liquidity
available. to theinvestors since the repurchase facility
Repurchase price is
T998 the fixed onthe basis
open-ended schemes of net asset value of the unit. In
have crossed 80
in number.
urity Analysis and (b) Closed-ended Funds: The close-ended funds have a fixed maturity period. The
rtlolio
Management first time investments are made when the close end scheme is kept open for a
limited period. Once closed,the units are listed on a stock exchange. Investors can
buy and sell their units only through stock exchanges. The demand and supoh
factorsinfluencethe prices of the [Link] investor's expectation also affects the
unit prices. The market price may not be the same as the net asset value
Sometimes mutual funds with the features of close-ended and open-ended schemes
are launched, known as interval funds. They can be listed in the stock exchange or
may be available for repurchase during specific periods at net asset value or related
prices.
Other Classification
The open-ended and close-ended schemes are classified on the basis of their objectives.
(iv) Money market schene:This type of fund invests its money on money market
instruments like treasury bills, commercial paper, etc.
(v) Tax saving schemes:This type of scheme offers tax rebates to investors. Equity
linked saving schemes and pension schemesprovide exxemption from capital gains
on specificinvestment.
on the index.
Net assets
Portfolio composition
Income composition
Unrealised appreciation
per unit
SEBIRegulations
The SEBI(Mutual Funds) Regulations,
mutual
1996 were amended in January 1998. Itprohibied
funds from investing and
in unlisted or associate
group companies of privately placed securities by
the sponsors.
A limit 25 percent
of
the net asset value of
of #
listed securities
thefund was imposed on its investment 0
the groupof
fully disclose companies of the
their portfolioin sponsors. Mutual funds are required
with minimum annual reports. Draft
disclosure Standard Offer Document make
requirements is laid down to
to enable the investors
23
informed investment decisions. SEBIdecided that all the open-ended schemes including Investment Decisions
Unit Scheme-64 of Unit Trust of India should declare their net asset value on a daily
basis.
Real Assets
Gold and Silver: For ages, gold andsilver have been considered as a form of investment.
They are considered as best hedge against inflation. This is a favourite form of investment
amongst the rural and semi- urban population. Besides, investors tend to invest in jewellery
instead of puregold. As a result, when they buy jewellery,the price realisation is usually
less than total purchase price (this is due to higher making charge of jewellery). The
price of gold has declined in the later part of the
Gold prices are suppressed nineties.
because of large supplies overtaking the demand. The government has allowed imports
of gold to certain banks and agencies and they have huge stocks of gold. The gold prices
remained depressed in the international markets too in the late nineties. The following
reasons are cited for the low price of gold in the international market:
Weak demand from Asian countries which are the largest consumers of gold
Legislative measure like the Swedish Government move to delink gold from Swiss
1.4.1 SystematicRisk
the entire Often we read in the newspaper that the
The systematic risk affects market.
the bear hug or in the bull grip. This indicates that the entire market is
stock market is in
in the economy affects the profit prospect of the industry and the stock market. The
countries has affected the
1998 recession experienced by developed and developing
the world. The South East Asian crisis has affected the stock
stock markets all over
the corporate and the investor.
market world wide. There factors are beyond the control of
the point that the systematic
They cannot be entirely avoided by the investor. It drives home
risk is unavoidable.
The variability in a security's total returns not related to overall market variability is
is attributable to
Systematic (Market)
Risk broad
Remember
factors affecting
the Difference:
unique to a security.
of fotsi
Jack Clark Francis has defined market risk as that
portion
1. Market Risk:
and bear markets
variability of return caused by the alternating forces of bull
index moves upward haltingly for a significant period time. it
When the security
of
is known as bull market. Inthe bull market, the index moves from a low level to the
declines haltingh
peak. Bear market is just a reverse to the bull market; the index
from the peak to a market low pointcalled trough for a significant period of time
During the bull and bear market more than 80 per cent of the securities' prices rise
market is known as market risk. All securities are exposed to market risk including
recessions, wars, structural changes in the economy, tax law changes, even changes
systematic risk.
2 Interest Rate Risk: Interest rate risk is the variation in the single period rates of
return caused by the fluctuations in the market interest rate. Most commonlyinterest
rate risk affects the price of bonds, debentures and stocks. The fluctuations in the
The variability in a security's return resulting from changes in the level of interest
rates is referred to as interest rate risk. Such changes generally affect securities
inversely; that is, otherthings being equal, security
prices move inversely to interest
rates. The reason for this movement is tied up with the
valuation of securities.
Interest rate risk affects bonds more directly than common stocks and is a major
risk faced by all bondholders. As interest rates change, bond prices change in the
pposite direction .
than what they originally bargained To make matters worse, there was not an
for.
extensive secondary market for these illiquid securities and many investors found
themselves unable to sell those securities at anything but “firesale prices if at all.
coupons received from a bond at a rate equal to the computed YTM on that bond.
thereby earning interest on interest over the life of the bond at the computed YTM
rate. In effect, this calculation assumes that the reinvestment rate is the yield to
maturity.
This interest-on-interest concept significantly affects the potential total dollar return.
The exact impact is a function of coupon and time to maturity, with reinvestment
becoming more important as either coupon or time to maturity, or both, rises.
Specifically:
the maturity of a
urity Analysis
and (a) Holding everything else constant, the longer bond,the
greater
tfolio
Management the reinvest:nent risk.
(b) Holding everything else constant, the higher the coupon rate, thegreater
the
of the total dollar return fromthe bond on the reinvestment
dependence of
compound return when the bond is held to maturity, with $4,040 of the total dolt.
Clearly, the reinvestment portion of the YTM concept is critical. In fact, for long.
term bonds the interest-on-interest component of the total realized yield may account
for more than three-fourths of the bond's total dollar return.
7. Bull- Bear Market Risk: This risk arises from the variability in the market returns
resulting from alternating bull and bear market forces. When security index rises
fairly consistently from a low point, called a trough, over a period of time, this
upward trend is called a bull The bull market ends when the market index
market.
reaches a peak and starts a downward trend. The period during which the market
declines to the next trough is called a bear market.
8
Management Risk: Management,all said and done, is made of people who are
mortal, fallible
and capable of making a mistake or a poor decision. Errors made
the management can harm those who invested in their firms. Forecasting errors is
difficult work and may not be the effort and, as a result, imparts a needlessy
skeptical outlook.
the past when most U.S. investors ignored international investing alternatives,
investors today must recognize and understand exchange rate risk, which
can be defined as the variability in returns on securities caused by currency
fluctuations. Exchange rate risk is sometimes called currency risk.
For example, a U.S. investor who buys a German stock denominated in marks
must ultimately convert the returns from this stock back to dollars. If the
exchange rate has moved against the investor, losses from these exchange
rate movements can partially or totally negate the original return earned.
Obviously, U.S. investorswho invest only in U.S. stocks on U.S. markets do
not face this risk, but in today's global environment where investors increasingly
consider alternatives from other countries, this factor has become important.
Currency risk affects international mutual funds, global mutual funds, closed
end single country funds, American Depository Receipts, foreign stocks, and
foreign bonds.
(b) Country Risk: Country risk, also referred to as political risk, is an important
risk for investors today. With more investors investing internationally, both
directly and indirectly, the political, and therefore economic, stability and viability
lowest country risk, and other countries can be judged on a relative basis
using the United States as a benchmark. Examples of countries that needed
careful monitoring in the 199Os because of countryrisk included the former
11. Liquidity Risk: Liquidity risk is the risk associated with the particular secondary
market in which a security trades. An investment that can be bought or sold quickly
and without significant price concession is considered liquid. The more uncertainty
about the time element and the price concession, the greater the liquidity risk. A
Treasury bill has little or no liquidity risk, whereas a small OTC stock may have
substantial liquidity risk.
It is that portion of an asset's total variability of return which results from price
discounts given or sales concessions paid in order to sell the asset without delay.
Perfectly liquid assets are highly marketable and suffer no liquidation costs. Illiquid
assets are not readily marketable and suffer no liquidation costs. Illiquid assets are
not readilymarketable -
either price discounts must be given or sales commissions
must be paid, or both the costs must be incurred by the seller, in order to find new a
investor for a illiquid asset. The more illiquid the asset is, the larger the price discounts
12. PoliticalRisk: It arises from the exploitation of a politically weak groupfor the
benefit ifa politically strong group, with the efforts of various groups to improve
their relative positions increasing the variability of return from the affected assets.
Regardless of whether the changes that cause political risk are sought by political
or by economic interests, the resulting variability of return is called political risk if
1.4.4
Minimising Risk
Exposure
Every investor wants
to guard
the nature of himself from the
theriskand risk. This
careful planning.
can be done by
protecting the The following understanding
investors fromthe paragraphs give an
differenttypes of agenda for
Market Risk risks.
Protection
(a) The investor has to
study the price
itselfeven though behaviour of the
it is not stock. Usually
in perfect history repeats
may continue to [Link] stock
do so for some that shows a
growth pattern to
more period. The growth patterm
continue for some Indian stock
more market expects the
depressing time in
conditions to information
cyclical stocks. It continue in the technology stock and
is textile related
better to avoid stock. Some
(b) The such type of stocks. stocks may be
standard deviation
and beta indicate
deviation andbeta the volatilityof
are available the stock.
National Stock forthe stocks
that are
The standard
ExchangeNews included in the
beta values, bulletin provides indices. The
the investor this
to his can gaugethe information.
risk risk Looking at the
tolerance. factor and
make wise
(c) decision
Further,the accordng
investor should
reap the be prepared
benefits of the to hold
the stock
timings ofthe rising trends for period a
leveland purchase and sale of
in the
ntarket. He
should
oftime
be caretul
o
should exit at
ahigher [Link] stock,
He
shouldpurchase nthe
it at the
Protection Against lower
Interest Rate
(a) Risk
Often suggested
in the middle
solution for
due to fall in this istohold the
heavy loss. the investment to
interestrate, Ifhe sells it
the capital maturity.
invested
woulddexperiencea
(b) The investors can also buy treasury bills and
bonds of short maturity. The portfolio
manager can invest in the treasury bills and the Investment
money can be reinvested in the Deci
(a) The general opinion is that the bonds or debentures with fixed return cannot solve
the problem. If the bond yield is 13 to 15 per cent with low risk factor, they would
provide hedge againstthe inflation.
(b) Another way to avoid the risk is to have investment in short term securities and to
avoid long term investment. The rising consumer price index may wipe
offthe real
rate of interest in the long term.
types of investments would provide a perfect hedge against inflation. It can minimise
the loss due to the fall in the purchasing power.
(a) To guard against the business risk, the investor has to analyse the strength and
weakness oftheindustryto which the companybelongs. weaknessof the industry
If
is too much of government interference in the way of rules and regulations, it is
(b) Analysing the profitability trend of the company is essential. The calculation of
standard deviation would yield the variability of the return. If there is inconsistency
in the earnings, it is better to avoid it. The investor has to choose a stock of consistent
track record.
(c) The financial risk should be minimised by analysing the capital structure of the
company. If the debt equity ratio is higher, the investor should have a sense of
caution. Along with the capital structure analysis, he should also take into account
of the interest payment. In a boom period,the investor can select a highly levered
company but not in a recession.
Volatility
Probability Distributions
need to think explicitly about a security's
returns, investors
To deal with the uncertainty
of
keep in mind that, although
of probable TRs. Inother
words, investors need to
distribution a one-point
for example, this is only
to return 10percent,
they may expect a security must deal with the
of possibilities. Given that investors
estimate of the entire range
of possible returns
can, and will, occur.
uncertain future, a number
payment will
rate of interest, the interest
In the case of a
Treasury bond paying a fixed The
barring a financial collapse of the economy.
be made with, 100 percent certainty the possibility
of occurrence is 1.0, because
no other outcome is possible. With
probability
common stocks, each possible likely
which is the norm for
of two or more outcomes,
of its occurrence assessed. The result
of
be considered and a probability
outcome must
and their probabilities together is a probability distribution
considering these outcomes and the probabilities
ofthe specification of the likely returns that may occur
consisting
somefuture
involves uncertainty, and therefore subjective
period
final analysis, investing for
(frequencies) may be relied on heavily to estimate
estimates. Although past occurrences
expected in the future.
the probabilities, the past must be modified for any changes
can be either discrete or [Link] a discrete
probability
Probability distributions
necessary to calculate its expected value. The expected value is the average of all
possible return outcomes, where each outcome is weighted by its respective probability
of occurrence. For investors, this can be described as the expected return.
We have mentioned that it's important for investors to be able to quantify and measure
risk. To calculate the total risk associated with the expected return, the variance or
standard deviation is [Link] is a measure of the spread or dispersion in the probability
distribution; that is, a measurement of the dispersion of a random variable around its
[Link] going into further details, justbe awarethat the larger this dispersion, the
larger the variance or standard deviation. Since variance, volatility and risk can in thiS
context be used synonymously, remember that the larger the standard deviation, the
the outcome.
more uncertain
always be extrapolated into the future without modifications. Ex post standard deviations
may be convenient, but they are subject erors. One important point about the estimation
to
of standard deviation is the distinction between individual securities and portfolios. Standard
deviations for well- diversified portfolios are reasonably steady across time, and therefore
whatever the sources of that variability. In summary, the standard deviation of return
measures the total risk of one security or the total risk of a portfolio of securities. The
historical standard deviation can be calculated for individual securities or portfolios of
securities using total returns for some specified period of time. This ex post value is
useful in evaluating the total risk for a particular historical period and in estimating the
total risk that is expected to prevail over some future period.
The standarddeviation, combined with the normal distribution, can provide some useful
the
information about the dispersion or variation in returns. In a normal distribution,
probability that a particular outcome will be above (or below) a specified value can be
determined. With one standard deviation on either side of the arithmetic mean of the
distribution, 68.3 percent of the outcomes will be encompassed; that is, there is a 68.3
percent probability that the actual outcome will be within one (plus or minus) standard
deviation of the arithmetic mean. The probabilities are 95 and 99 percent that the actual
Beta
Beta is a measure of the systematic risk of a security that cannot be avoided through
diversification. Beta is a relative measure ofrisk-the risk of an individual stock relative
to the market portfolio of all stocks. If the security's returns move more (less) than the
market's returns as the latter changes, the security's returns have more (less)volatility
(fluctuations in price) than those of the market. It is important to note that beta measures
Securities with different slopes have different sensitivities to the returns of the market
index. If the slope of this relationship for a particular security is a 45-degree angle, the
beta is 1.0. This means that for every one percent change in the market's return, on
average this security's returns change 1 percent. The market portfolio has a beta of 1.0.
A security with a beta of 1.5, indicatesthat, on average, security returns are 1.5 times as
Volatile as market returns, both up and down. This would be considered an aggressive
Security because when the overallmarket return rises or falls 10 percent, this security,
On average, would rise or fall 15 percent. Stocks having a beta of less than l.0 would be
considered more conservative investments than the overall market.
beta is useful for comparing the relative systematic risk ofdifferent stocks and, in practice,