Financial Engineering Overview and Insights
Financial Engineering Overview and Insights
AYYAD
ﺍﻡ ﺍ
Faculty of Sciences
Legal ﻭﺍ ﺩ ﺍﻭ
Economic and Social ﺏ ﺍ- ﺍ
Marrakech - Morocco
1
Chapter I: Definitions and Objectives
Financial engineering can be understood as a set of tools and operations.
allowing
to leaders to structure or restructure their financing, to support the
development of their firm through external growth operations or to transfer it
in satisfactory conditions;
to allow investors to take control of healthy or struggling companies while
minimizing their contributions;
Characterized by its purpose and its field, financial engineering finds its specificity
in the method she proposes, a contingent, developed, innovative, and transversal method.
2
but have a contingent nature.
Financial engineering leads to setups, to elaborate architectures that stand out.
with ready-made solutions. It stands out from more usual financial operations that
require a certain standardization, given their more repetitive nature and the deadlines
very brief often imposed.
Ingenuity characterizes the setups that have been established. Creativity, imagination, innovation
apply not only to the invented tools but also to their arrangement.
Financial engineering is not a purely financial technique. It also involves
business law, taxation law, economics, strategy, etc. The profession of engineer
the financier finds his interest and wealth in this transversal aspect of the discipline.
Engineering, which has gradually replaced the English word in common language.
engineering is generally defined as the set of intellectual activities that
allow for designing a work in a rational and functional way, ensuring
the coordination of the various disciplines that contribute to its realization.
Of ancient origin, the notion is more willingly associated with the military art from which it originates.
in civil engineering, in energy management and raw materials, or, more recently, to
telecommunications and computing, as well as jobs related to money. It has only been since
A few years since the concept of financial engineering made its entrance into the universe of
the company and its shareholders. It imposes itself today even though it is not always easy to...
clearly outline the objectives, the works, or the scope of action.
Originally, the engineer is, in any company, the specialist capable of discerning everything
the technical components of an achievement and who bears responsibility for the reliability of the
Despite its recent nature, financial engineering is not immune to these major trends:
meeting point between securities law, taxation, actuarial science, it requires
also a good knowledge of the economic sectors covered, a skill relating to
foreign or international rules and practices. It is a team, more than a man, that
contributes. This team must have the ability to adapt quickly to
changes by demonstrating creative spirit, to precede or accompany the
reflection of his mandate, to innovate alongside him or to share an acquired knowledge with him
staff. She must be able to align her response as closely as possible with the specifications
required, even if it means reconfiguring even proven solutions for each specific case, and this without
to expose their principal to abnormal risks.
Finally, it is appropriate to refine the spectrum with some reflections on the content of the approach:
4
it may - and often must - integrate a dimension of strategic advice or analysis upstream
financial, but it cannot be identified with a mission of an expert that would find its purpose in
the drafting of a report and the formulation of a recommendation whose implementation would be
decided and managed by others;
- Financial engineering provides global responses that rely on
essentially on the support of securities: a syndication of bank loans,
the financing or transfer of a real estate asset, a country risk will only retain its interest if
if they appear to significantly influence the reliability or profitability of an operation
financial encompassing the issues they raise or the opportunities they create:
- The intervention in financial engineering takes time, and ends with one or more
contracts that are rarely contracts of adhesion. The 'negotiation' part is
often at least as delicate as the part 'assembly in the preparation of an operation.'
each of the concerned parties may assert requirements or constraints
particular. Contracts, even if they often contain standard clauses, are indeed the
reflection of the diversity of situations encountered, of the relative negotiation capacity of
signatories of financial innovation.
The present work, whose purpose is to facilitate access for medium-sized retail businesses
and their leaders in the 'high balance' operations, and more specifically 'funds
"own", engages the debate from a micro-economic angle.
Within the defined scope of reflection, four study axes will be selected:
- the intimate knowledge of the company, the subject of the operation, and that of its
Economic or financial potentialities determine a suitable value whose degree of
realism exerts a predominant influence on the balance of an operation, even its feasibility.
The company's 'financial engineering' approach cannot be carried out without it being
well-known in depth, not only from a financial perspective, which corresponds to an approach
of traditional banking commitments, but based on all its potential and weaknesses.
Beyond the traditional appreciation of risk, it is indeed necessary to anticipate a rate of
growth and the induced needs for equity to assess the opportunity of any
intervention.
Even without any immediate project in this area, mastering certain techniques
legal or tax enables access to a more complete view of a financial strategy of a
CEO, to make the dialogue with him more substantial, to upgrade.
in the hierarchy of interlocutors, to finally dispel false representations or to thwart
traps. Led in a deliberate manner, the approach to financial tools, already used or
suggested, thus appears as the pivot of a strong relationship.
(2emepart: Financial toolbox.
the operational dimension connects us with the heart of the engineer's profession
financier: the reflection must indeed be validated by the development of products more or less
complexes, more or less capital-intensive, more or less risky, that could be
evoked and then implemented after negotiation. In this regard, the sum division is no longer between
equity-based products and debt-based products, or even between listed businesses and
non-listed. The division of projects depends on the changes induced at the level of positions.
of the shareholder, which determines two types of basic situations.
Is it about opening the capital without significant modification of control, in order to finance
investment or refinance the shareholder? Two solutions can be compared,
you successively choose: private equity or accessing the financial market.
6
Is it advisable, on the contrary, to take or relinquish control? One would then oppose the
7
Leverage Buy Out
Introduction
The year 2000 reached new heights in terms of corporate acquisitions, leading to its
an increase in leveraged operations such as LBO, LBI, LMBO,... In Europe we have
counted no less than 503 MBO / MBI operations for a total amount of over 37
billions of euros in 2000.
The LBO is often a solution for a family succession or a sale by a group.
from a division. The value creation often observed during an LBO cannot be explained
not by leveraging, nor by the deductibility of financial expenses, but much more by the weight
debt that strongly encourages leaders to manage the company they become responsible for.
often on this occasion shareholders, which increases their motivations.
The level of profitability of invested capital, often significant, of this type of operation
It is explained to him by the leverage effect generated by the heavy use of debt.
The Leveraged Buy Out (LBO) is the financial technique used by investors
eager to acquire a profitable company but only having financing means
limited internal considerations regarding the value of the target company to be acquired, the proportion between the two
I - Definition:
The LBO is a transaction that involves acquiring a healthy company through significant use of
indeed, a holding company is created which goes into debt to purchase a
target company whose available cash flows will be regularly reported to
level of the holding through dividends in order to allow it to pay the interest on its debt and
to reimburse her.
A LBO is carried out around an existing management (this is referred to as Leverage Management.
Buy Out, LMBO) or a new management team and is funded with equity by
specialized private equity funds. The arrangement is based on
debts with different repayment priorities (senior debt, junior debt, mezzanine debt)
and therefore increasing risks and rewards.
8
II-The steps of an LBO transaction:
Once the fund is chosen, the second step is to build the business plan, or plan of
business development. This plan is designed according to an iterative process.
Financial investors, like strategic investors, express their opinion on
the opportunity for an investment based on a business plan. It is from the documents
the constituent that every investor will be able to form an opinion and a conviction.
These documents generally include:
• A memorandum of explanation
• Financial projections
• Studies
• Appropriate presentation documents
The assumptions of the business plan are very important and will allow for the construction of the
financial and legal framework constituting the operation. The preparation stage of an operation
strategic (whatever it may be) is long, often tedious, but strategic, since it
allows you to lay the foundations of your future building (project), and therefore prepares the conditions for
sharing of the value creation that you will achieve as your ambitions grow
9
realize.
Third step: determine the debt leverage and establish the structure
Financier
The most delicate part of an LBO operation is determining the level of leverage.
the principle of the LBO consists of investing the least amount of capital possible in the acquisition price and to
maximize debt. It is necessary to find a balance between capital and debt, depending on the
valuation range, projected cash flows, and expected EBIT. Once the debts
reimbursed, the small capital acquired will be multiplied at the time of the investors' exit,
a few years later.
The financial setup includes the structuring of debt between senior debt and mezzanine.
This senior debt is the bank borrowing taken on to finance an acquisition through leverage.
It lasts for a period of three to seven years. The senior banker has guarantees on the assets.
from the buyout holding. Mezzanine is a hybrid financing between senior debt and equity.
clean. Its repayment occurs after that of the senior debt. In return, it offers
generally a higher remuneration.
The investment fund is responsible for finding banks capable of syndicating and raising
the debt. This work is not easy. Indeed, the level of remuneration for the actors who lend
the funds in the context of an LBO are extremely low, but their exposure to risk is
strong. The commission rate for banks that syndicate debts is 2 to 4% of the amount
loaned for periods of 5 to 7 years, with, in some cases, a high risk of seeing the company
not functioning. Certainly, the bank is secured on the business assets or other elements,
but her pay remains low while she takes risks in a field that she
is not a specialist. When the leading bank is chosen, the management team must make
proof of his motivation and demonstrate the strength of his business plan.
Once the debt is structured, the sellers and buyers set a final acquisition price.
This is followed by a period of several months during which the appointed auditors
the buyer reviews the thousands of pages that the seller has prepared to present
the company. The buyer's auditors can consult all of these documents in
a special room, the data room. After the seller and the buyer have agreed on a
10
approximate price level - in our case, a number of price adjustments are
intervened between August and December 2000 –, begins a period of due diligence during
which a certain number of people and businesses appointed by the buyer proceed with
to financial audits, Resuming also means creating 69 environmental, commercial,
marketing, whose objective is to verify the viability of the business against the validity of the data,
related to the activity, proposed by the seller.
Once the negotiation is completed, the deal can be signed at the time of a meeting called
closing.
11
VConvertible Bonds subscribed by shareholders can provide
additional flexibility in the assembly. They are intended to be either reimbursed by
the excess cash flow, that is to be converted.
The loans of the holding company are repaid through the dividends distributed by the
target.
They are not subject to any taxation when the holding company owns 95% or more of the capital.
of the target, and a very minimal tax if it is not the case.
The repayment of loans is generally expected over a period of 5 to 7 years, determined
so that the percentage of the distributed result does not generally exceed two thirds of the result
net of the target.
When there is surplus cash not needed for operations, it is also
possible to transfer it to the holding company through an exceptional distribution of reserves
previous.
VThe debt ratio, that is to say the ratio of bank and financial debts (acquisition and
operational) / EBIT. The ratios required by banks are generally below 4;
VThe available cash-flow ratio / total debt repayment annuities that must be
greater than 1, with a safety factor of at least 5 to 10%;
VThe EBIT / total financial expenses (operating and acquisition borrowing) ratio that the
banks wish to maintain above 3.
These ratios that banks use to evaluate a structure are then formalized.
(covenants) in loan agreements. Their compliance requires appropriate management of
the company. However, they may evolve over time or be readjusted accordingly
new events (external growth, asset disposals, ...)
In France, the secondary LBO would be the second form of divestiture in 2003, representing 19%
outputs valued at a total amount of 207.6 million euros.
12
The secondary LBO provides various advantages to the different participants in the operation.
compared to the primary LBO:
Capital and debt are less subject to risks in a secondary LBO because the company has
already demonstrated its ability to repay the acquisition debt based on proven cash flows and has
generally set up a management control and monitoring system tailored to the requirements
of shareholders and bankers.
2. Management knows how to manage the partnership with the financier(s).
The transfer process is better prepared, more structured, and better documented.
4. The risk profile is more favorable for banks that generally leverage.
senior financier.
On the other hand, the main technical constraints are relatively similar to those of
Primary LBOs.
The risk of a speculative bubble related to secondary LBOs is unlikely, primarily in
reason for a standardized market today and competitive transfer processes leading to
average to a fair valuation of assets
The financial engineering of a leveraged buyout (LBO) requires a rigorous approach. This is
intellectually very simple, the details of the implementation are complex and, there, it can be
to have for the future seller, a major risk of lost earnings.
The transfer of a company to an industrialist or a financier as part of an LBO is
always a transaction, meaning that the buyer's goal is to "pay the least amount"
possible by obtaining as many guarantees as possible." In the context of an LBO setup,
a conflict of interest. The interests only become common once the LBO is completed
when the seller is a shareholder of the acquisition holding. It should therefore not be forgotten that a
The position of a buyer is primarily a leadership position rather than that of an employee.
The spirit of entrepreneurship is the foundation of your motivation: it combines the desire to succeed in a project.
ambitious in a setting where your responsibility is total and your taste for
Taking risks is real.
The most common motivating factors can be grouped into two categories:
Example
15
16
CH II: THE BALANCE SHEET ANALYSIS
The balance sheet is the snapshot of the company's assets at a given time, generally the
closing day of the financial year. This asset can be presented using two methods.
The functional balance,
The liquidity, asset or financial balance sheet.
The balance sheet is the basic tool of financial analysis. However, it is necessary to
reprocess the elements constituting the balance sheet to allow for: An analysis
economic (the positions are classified into homogeneous groups according to their respective function.
The functional balance sheet is very close to the balance sheet presented by the P.C.G. 82. It is a presentation
Jobs Resources
Capital
Reserves
Result
Immobilisation
intangible
physical
financial
provisions for risks and
charges
Stock
Operating receivables Financial debts
Various receivables Operating debts
- Disponibilités Various debts
The functional balance sheet
Basic principles
The role of the functional balance is:
- To assess the financial structure of the company
- To assess the financial needs and the type of resources available to the company
- To determine the equilibria between the different masses
- To calculate the financial safety margin of the company
- To enable decision-making
Schematic presentation of the functional balance sheet
Equity
Function Depreciation and Function
Investment Gross Fixed Assets provisions: financing
for depreciation (resources
risks and charges durables)
Financial debts
Function
Exploitation
Current assets Function
exploitation Operating debts Exploitation
hors
Exploitation
Cash resources
Availability
Although similar to the P.C.G. 82 presentation, the functional balance sheet presentation requires
some reclassifications and adjustments. These will be used for the calculation of the fund of
net overall turnover and working capital requirement.
18
a) The reclassifications of the functional balance sheet
bondholders.
The accrued interests included in the financial debts listed in the liabilities.
of the balance sheet are reclassified as various debts. (The same applies to the
The functional balance sheet must provide a picture of the asset values by cycle. It
It is therefore appropriate to reintegrate into the balance sheet elements excluded due to their legal nature.
19
or usage.
retreatment involves listing in the assets of the balance sheet the amount of discounted bills and
receivables assigned with a counterpart in liabilities in bank loans.
20
ASSET (financing needs) LIABILITIES (financing resources)
Exploitation Exploitation
Stocks Advances and deposits received
Advances and deposits paid on Operating debts
commands Deferred products
Operating receivables operation
Expected effects not yet due Social and tax debts
Advance charges recorded exploitation
exploitation Passive conversion gap
Active conversion gap Active conversion spread
Passive conversion gap
The functional balance sheet is established from the accounting balance sheet before the distribution of the result.
21
The adjustments
The adjustments consist of:
RECLASSIFY certain items in the balance sheet according to their function.
22
Definition: Functional balances
23
Fonds de roulement net global, besoin en fonds de roulement, trésorerie
schematic.
the asset
F.R.N.G. }
Financial debt
Operating suppliers
Gross clients
Treasury
Current banking competitions
V.M.P. Liquids
Availability
•Banques
Box
24
a) Basic principles
The net working capital is the excess of sustainable resources after financing.
stable jobs.
It is therefore the permanent capital that remains in the company, to make its operations work.
exploitation.
Basic example:
The SARL du marron chaud is created with the aim of selling chestnuts, waffles.
the end of school.
Investment needs Chestnut pot 1,000 dirhams
61,800 Dirhams
The stable financing needs are 61,800 Dh but before any funding.
of the activity (operation).
25
Immovables Permanent capital
61800 Dh 66800Dh
- The larger the net working capital, the more the company will be able to
easily finance his business.
26
Specific case: Distribution companies 'supermarket type'.
27
The working capital requirement is therefore dependent on the deadlines.
of the flow or rotation of the elements that make it up.
Working capital requirement outside of operations is the difference between assets and
passives of investment cycles, financing of profit distribution
the company.
4) The treasury
The cash flow is the result of the net working capital and the funding requirements.
rollover (operational + non-operational). It is also the total of available resources under
deduction of bank loans.
The cash flow is explained by the gap between working capital and the need for funds.
Working capital. A working capital greater than the need for working capital will lead to a
positive cash flow. A working capital lower than the working capital needs
will generate a negative cash flow.
The treasury thus summarizes, in itself, all the balance sheet equilibriums and the analysis of its
The variation will be included in many flow charts.
28
5) The Ratios
From the functional balance sheet, the company can calculate:
a) Financing stable jobs
b) Financial autonomy
Own resources
Indebtedness
The financial balance favored by the approach of the 1957 accounting plan is today
less used as we pointed out in the introduction.
Ranking criteria:
29
Schematic presentation of the financial statement:
Provisions for =
risks & charges Capital
permanents
Jobs at Current assets Long-term debts
less than a year
Short-term debts Resources to
less than a year
Treasury Availability
a) Règles d'évaluation
Fixed assets are listed at their net value. If the current value is
different from the net book value resulting from the depreciation plan, a
depreciation or an exceptional recovery is practiced.
Assets are classified in order of increasing liquidity, with the least liquid assets first.
(assets) being recorded at the top of the balance sheet. All assets are evaluated
net worth.
The distinction "less than one year, more than one year" for receivables and debts is
function of the maturity of loans and borrowings and not of their origin to more than one
in less than a year. Thus a financial debt can be shared among the capitals
permanent for the part to be reimbursed in more than a year and the debts to be reimbursed at
less than a year for the repayments due in the following financial year.
The transition from the accounting balance sheet P.C.G. to the financial balance sheet mainly requires the
restructuring of receivables and debts based on the remaining maturities of more than one year and
30
less than a year.
The balance sheet represents the company's assets regardless of their origin.
(exploitation, investments...)
* The expected effects not yet due and receivables "Dailly Law" are restated in the same way.
what is in the functional balance.
The heritage design being close to the evaluation of the company:
Removal of non-values (charges to allocate, establishment expenses),
•Recording of latent tax liabilities, regulated provisions are divided into
equity and debts.
Provisions for risks and charges could be broken down.
In equity for the reserve character part.
In long-term debts for the portion intended to cover a cash expense beyond
for a year.
In short-term debts for the cash-out part within less than a year.
Dividends payable are deducted from equity and recorded as short-term liabilities.
balance being processed after distribution.
The following advanced reprocessing can be performed
Permanent stock The companies having a minimum permanent stock necessary for the
production (tool stock) or a permanent safety stock can record this part of stock
in fixed assets. The same may apply for stocks with a low turnover rate by
example, stock of spare parts ...
Note: Since the company does not own the assets acquired under a leasing agreement, there is no need to ...
retraiter.
31
Chapter III: The analysis of the CPC
The income statement is a snapshot of the activity of the’business over a given period.
This period is generally the "financial year" which covers 12 months but it can also
It is a matter of analyzing the activity for a shorter period during the fiscal year.
The analysis of the income statement is done by nature. For example, all expenses for
staff is grouped on one line, as is the’total sales of goods.
The income statement does not allow for a marginal analysis because it does not separate the
fixed costs, variable costs: what are the fixed production costs (depreciation,
permanent staff...) and the variable production costs (energy, seasonal staff,
raw materials...). This makes it difficult to analyze in terms of breakeven point.
As we have just seen, the analysis of the income statement, a global analysis of
the activity by nature will be insufficient. For a precise measure of the company's activity, it
will need to resort to analytical accounting and management control techniques.
Operating expenses
Operating products
Operating result
Financial products
32
Financial charges Financial result
Exceptional charges
The operation. It is the recurring activity of the company, the result of its industry.
Operating result allows for comparison between two companies in the same sector.
regardless of the financing method of this activity (after reprocessing of
leasing.
The financier. It is the cost of financing the activity. The cost of financing can
be a function of productive choice (strong substitution of capital for labor and investments
important for example). The financial result is also dependent on the history of
the company. An old company that has accumulated significant positive results and
so financial reserves will have a positive financial result. A recent company
will be more heavily indebted (weakness of its equity, strong increase in its
working capital needs due to the rapid increase in activity.
A very negative financial result always signifies poor balance sheet ratios.
but not necessarily of a company in poor health, the economic dynamism creating
often financial imbalances (Importance of financial debts in capital
permanents or imbalance (F.R.N.G. - B.F.R.).
The intermediate management balances are a tool for analyzing activity and
profitability of the business.
33
The calculation of GIS allows:
II Terminology
1) Commercial margin
It is also called GROSS MARGIN and only concerns trading businesses.
businesses or those with commercial activities. It measures the operating resources of
the company. It is an indicator for tracking the evolution of a commercial policy.
It is often expressed as a percentage of revenue.
Margin rate
Margin rate = x100
CA HT
The margin rate should be compared to the industry rate. The analysis of its evolution in
Time allows for judging the effectiveness of trade policy.
34
Value added
She evaluates the economic dimension of the company. She determines the wealth created and
constituted by the work of the staff and by the company itself.
It measures the economic weight of the company.
The analysis over time allows for measuring the growth or decline of the company. It
allows for the appreciation of the company's structures and their performance by comparing them to the expenses
VA
CA HT
VA
production
It represents the share of the added value that goes to the company and the capital contributors.
It indicates the resource generated by the exploitation of the company:
Regardless of the depreciation policy (allocations), and
Regardless of the funding method (financial charges)
35
EBE
stable resources
Interest charges
EBE
EBE
VA
the operating gross margin rate
EBE
CA HT
5) Operating result
It represents the result generated by the activity that conditions the existence of the company.
It measures the industrial and commercial performance of the company independently of
its financial policy. It constitutes a net economic result.
Exceptional result
36
of the company. It can reflect the company's investment policy if the disposals
investments are significant.
It indicates what remains available to the company after the payment of the profit-sharing.
of employees and payment of corporate tax, or the income of partners after tax.
It allows calculating the financial profitability of the company.
NET Result
Equity
This balance is already included in the extraordinary result. It allows for the calculation of plus or minus.
Reclassifications
The financial analysts at the balance sheet center adjust certain items of the SIG from
PCG in order to provide them with a more economical approach.
37
modified.
Operating grants are included in the added value. They are handled
as supplementary revenue.
The temporary staff billed by a supplier will be registered under "other services".
The more the company's productive choice will be the substitution of temporary staff.
the more permanent staff there is, the more the added value will decrease. It will be appropriate in most cases,
to reclassify temporary staff costs as personnel costs.
Lease rents are classified as external services, which does not allow for analysis of the
cost of the investment incorporated into production. The rents will be restated in
two parts the depreciation that would have been practiced if we had been owners of
the immobilization of one part; the financial charges paid to the leasing organization for
the difference. This will increase the added value to decrease the result
d'exploitation pour la dotation aux amortissements et le résultat financier pour les frais
financiers. The reprocessing can also be actuarial (see above for the reprocessing of
functional balance sheet)
EBIT adjustments
The temporary staff added to the added value is subtracted at the level of the surplus.
gross operating profit.
The portion of the lease rent corresponding to the depreciation allowances that
If one had been the owner of the asset, it would have been deducted at the level
of the operating result.
It is appropriate to assign the charge transfers to each concerned intermediate balance for
make the positions homogeneous.
The financial fees included in the leasing royalties are deducted at the level of
financial result.
Taxes and related payments are included in the consumption of the fiscal year.
from third parties; the added value is then modified.
Generalities
The company has financing needs, for example to finance the acquisition.
of immobilizations, etc.
To finance its needs, the company has resources from different origins:
39
loans; generated by the activity
subsidies
The self-financing capacity represents, for the company, the surplus of internal resources.
generated during the exercise, through all of its activities and that it can allocate to its
self-financing.
THE THE
CHARGES PRODUITS
DECALABLES NO ENCASABLES NO
DECAISSABLES collectible
DISCHARGEABLE CHARGES
CAF
Subtractive method
Additive method
E.B.E
Net income for the period
+ Other cashable products
+ Non-disbursable charges
Other payable charges
Non-cash products
+or- Result / disposals of assets
CONTROL
The CAF is the indicator of the financial independence of the company. It is also called
41
Cash flow.
42