Conflict Resolution in Construction Projects
Conflict Resolution in Construction Projects
IR TS DR JEFFREY YAP BH
GROUP 12
A dispute is a short-term disagreement over negotiable grounds that can lead to the disputants
coming to the same conclusion. Construction conflicts, for example, are typically caused by
two parties disagreeing on a specific circumstance. So, establishing accountability for the
contractual consequences of the situation and then negotiating a fair resolution or settlement
are examples of how to deal with it. Conflict can be helpful or destructive, and neither its
occurrence nor its outcome is entirely and rigidly controlled by a single party. Having
conflicts could be a positive outcome collecting past data for future purposes.
In Part A of this research, we will identify the causes that lead to conflict and dispute in
Malaysian construction projects by interviewing a few in-field specialists from various
organizations and backgrounds to share their workplace experiences with conflict
management in [Link] assess the common issues that lead to conflict and
disagreement in Malaysian building projects.
Part B will also address effective dispute-resolution tactics for project management in
construction.
These professionals have developed many situations to help us write the next article.
PART A: Factors of Conflict and Dispute in Construction
1. Complex hierarchy of project management
Individuals may not understand the subjects being discussed at the same level. Even if
two parties believe they are capable of completing the task, they have very different ideas
about how to do so. Conflict may resurface after an initial comment is made, as someone
discovers what was intended. This demonstrates how important it is for the entire team to be
involved in problem-solving. Before a project begins, several responsibilities are assigned to
address a wide variety of parties. While "who does what" has been addressed for years, the
relationship between roles is often overlooked. Role ambiguity causes negative friction and
may jeopardize a project's success since expectations, priorities, behaviors, and performance
levels differ. Responsibilities Certain employment is produced as a result of outcomes, others
as a result of the requirement for governance, and still others have become institutionalized as
a result of the expansion of professional institutions.
For example, in one of Mr. Eric’s shares, he claims that he was given verbal
instruction to relocate a distribution board to a different location, the actual duration for the
job to be completed will be accomplished in 1 working day, but no one wants to bear the
responsibility of issuing an enginers instruction as the responsibilities are kept being passed
around. At the end of the day, it took them 14 days for the official engineer's instruction to be
confirmed. The parties involved in the decision-making was the inhouse M&E consultant
( hired by clients representing clients), external project management team ( hired by clients
but to manage projects ) ,and the inhouse operation and maintenance team.
1.4 Bureaucracy
Complex hierarchies typically have strict rules, procedures, and protocols governing
operations. This bureaucracy can stifle innovation, creativity, and agility by making
employees feel constrained by red tape and risk aversion. It is frequently inflexible in the face
of unexpected changes and situations. Hierarchical structures are resistant to change because
they frequently prioritise stability and continuity over innovation and adaptability. Employees
and managers may be resistant to changes that threaten their existing roles, power dynamics,
or working practices.
For example, bureaucracy and the project's strict safety measures. Mr Camillus
claims to be the project manager for the Electrical Contractor on a construction project in one
of the chip manufacturing factories at Texas Instrument Kuala Lumpur. She claims that they
have the strictest safety procurements and measures based on her experiences in various
projects, particularly working in the clean room where electronic chips are manufactured; the
environment is extremely sensitive to contractor/vendor accessibility. She defines safety
objectives as short, high-level statements of the organization's safety priorities that address
the most significant safety risks. They guide the organization's activities and should thus be
consistent with the safety policy that outlines the high-level safety commitment. However,
this has resulted in the most conflicts between the client's internal emergency health and
safety department, the safety officer from the external project management consultant team,
the operation and maintenance team, and the contractors and vendors.
The contractor complained that its Overburdened Processes to carry out simple tasks.
Complex management systems may overwhelm project teams with excessive procedures and
documentation, slowing down progress and reducing efficiency. Mr Camillus claims that
inorder to transport materials, machinery and tools into the site they have to pre-register at the
Jabatan Kastam 3 days before carrying tools and materials into the client area, they have to
specifically declare each and every items that they have preregistered 3 working days before
detailly including the specification of the product , if it has chemical content , the accurate
dimension weight size and production date . tools such as battery drill, fiber cutter , velding
machines has to be inspected by the safety officer from the external project management team
and the clients safety officer daily before carrying out, they have to apply working permit
daily and must be sign off by 2 parties of safety officers or else they will strickly remove
whoever workers involve in their guard house system being permanently banned to access
Texas Instrument ever again. The safety and healthy procedues are extreamly tight ,
everything inspections must be documented as the client goal is to have a zero accident and
injuries working environment while the contactors are frustrated and conflicts are arisen as it
drags and lengthens the duration, increases the manpower to complete very simple task such
as cutting just 1 pcs of metal into half. It technically takes less than 3 minutes to cut a pcs to
material into half but to apply for the hot work permit to do so might be up to 3 hours seeking
approvals and gathering relative safety officers to sign off . as there's many different trades of
contractors at the site.
One of the Risk of Micromanagement in a complex hierarchy and procurement method,
managers at various levels may resort to micromanagement to maintain control over their
subordinates. This can undermine trust, autonomy, and empowerment among employees,
leading to frustration and disengagement. Coordinating activities and aligning efforts across
multiple layers of management can be challenging, particularly in large organizations with
diverse functions and geographically dispersed teams. This can result in coordination
breakdowns, duplication of efforts, and missed opportunities for collaboration.
2. Contractual Contract
Tenderers may not completely examine the contract due to time constraints on estimating
and pricing. The contract clarifies rights and expectations, yet participants often fail to read it
thoroughly. The same is true for numerous government activities and reports. Standardised
contracts and standards are produced to ensure project team members follow a methodical
approach throughout all stages. However, it fails to address characterisation issues in the
construction sector. Furthermore, none of it addresses the challenges caused by contradictory
role expectations. Conflicting employment expectations remain a challenge due to the fact
that they are not just based on legally binding contracts. Informal interactions also have a
major impact on role assumptions.
During the interview, the project manager Ms Sharon Chen stated that the most
challenging disagreement was due to contractual issues. The contract paperwork did not
include itemised specifications, drawings, and bills of quantities. The documents were
prepared by multiple parties. Consultants may not adhere to the specifications and generate
drawings based on their typical processes. Drawings that do not adequately describe the
material parameters will result in increased charges.
Furthermore, the descriptions created by the consultant QS were overly generic. This
will lead to contradictory goals during execution. Due to the short brief phase (about two
weeks to one month), principal contractors just use the BQ for pricing. As a result, the
contract was subject to disputes during its execution.
This is a common problem, particularly in large-scale projects like the MRT. Its criteria and
specs differ from typical projects. Consultants' designs, including architects and engineers,
did not meet specifications. For example, the designer is from another country, yet the QS is
local.
During execution, the client will require the contractors to adhere to their standards.
The contractor will start fighting and protesting. Subcontract documents must explicitly
specify any additional provisions. In this example, the prerequisites are QLASSIC. The cost,
completion time, and labour required will rise it challenged the notion that project managers'
roles are primarily influenced by contracts and cultural norms. They manage and negotiate. A
project manager's role as a mediator can positively benefit the project. Sometimes, however,
they may just serve as a channel for competing perspectives. The project team took into
account both official paperwork and informal ties, as roles are not always steady.
However, they do not investigate differences in the legal and cultural notions of task-specific
roles.
According to the literature analysis, designers may face role conflict when reviewing
subcontractors' detailed drawings to ensure compliance with design criteria. It is their
contractual responsibility. Subcontractors may seek to save money by modifying
specifications without client approval. The electrical engineer and architect must meet the
contractor's specifications. Project-specific procedures can lead to job dissatisfaction, not
simply in new roles.
Aside from that, poor coordination is one of the issues. Knowledge borders
encompassed different fields, teams, and responsibilities. Coordination mechanisms were
highly structured between design firms, design teams, contractors, and the client design
adviser. Complex building projects incorporate numerous specialised professions, such as
mechanical, electrical, and civil engineering. Inadequate work coordination leads to frequent
conflicts. This ultimately leads to disputes that are time-consuming and expensive to settle.
Each side holds the other accountable for any issues that arose . Additionally, there may be
disagreements about who is responsible for quality assurance. The principal contractor's site
agent may mistake it for the clerk of work's responsibilities, leading to confusion among both
parties. Conflict may arise if the site agent prioritises verifying quality over inspecting it.
Regular meetings (every week or every two weeks) are crucial for project teams to
avoid disagreements and provide clear instructions to members. They must follow completion
dates for each trade of labour. This will assist them attain their final goal. Another project
manager stated that information, including variation orders and verbal directions from the
superintendent officer, should only be provided to linked departments, particularly the
contract department, citing academic materials . A positive relationship between project team
members and the project manager is important. Poor organisation, planning, and
communication can lead to inappropriate sequencing and double handling, negatively
impacting job progress. It incurs additional fees for the remedial work. Commercial work,
including additions, omissions, abortives, and daywork, must be validated with agreed-upon
and fair costs. This requires a cost breakdown and management decision.
The project manager also highlights communication difficulties. During the pre-tender
stage, consultants with overlap in tasks may have questions that they are hesitant to ask.
Clients may be aware of the problem. However, they do not bring it up as they do not want to
boost costs. Delays in a project are frequently attributed to human behaviour. Clear position
definitions are crucial for aligning everyone's efforts and preventing disparities. Deductions
from the work done amount may result in insufficient payment for subcontractors. This will
result in delays and reimbursement for liquidated ascertained damages (LAD). The primary
contractor will be in difficulty unless a large firm provides cash.
Poor communication can lead to a lack of teamwork. Ms Sharon, the project manager,
stated that during the tender documentation stage, the client, QS, engineer, and other parties
do not communicate with each other. As a result, when uncertainty arises, no one asks about
it or knows who to ask. This lack of teamwork can lead to time-consuming conflicts between
project members. Mrs Sharon suggested that it's likely that the client is aware of the
uncertainty but chooses to conceal it to avoid increasing costs.
Poor communication will also cause unneeded delays. This is due to misconceptions or
delays in message flow among members, or messages being directed to the incorrect
individual. Poor communication can lead to blunders and delays, including incorrectly
implementing building methods or supplies, skipping construction processes, and hiring
unqualified labour. Misunderstandings can lead to improper execution of job tasks, resulting
in cost overruns and time delays. Delays can lead to increased project costs and conflicts
among team members. To avoid miscommunication, Mr Sharon suggests holding regular
team meetings to ensure proper execution of building materials and instructions.
Poor communication can negatively impact project team morale, motivation, and
production. Poor communication can lead to conflict, tension, and low morale among project
team members. In such an environment, project members may become disoriented and unable
to perform effectively or bring new ideas to the project. As a result, the project team may
indicate more work done but with less efficiency which may not meet the client's
requirements, leading to rework, delays, cost increases, and conflict.
PART B: Conflict Resolution in Project Management
Introduction
Furthermore, leaders play a crucial role in motivating and engaging the project team
(Bojeun,Dr.M, 2024). By fostering a positive work environment, encouraging collaboration,
and promptly addressing conflicts, leaders boost morale and productivity among
stakeholders. This, in turn, enhances teamwork and contributes to the overall success of the
project. Additionally, effective leadership is instrumental in managing risks inherent in
construction projects. Leaders proactively assess risks, develop mitigation strategies, and
implement robust safety measures to protect both workers and project outcomes. By
prioritizing safety and risk management, leaders safeguard the well-being of all involved and
minimize disruptions to the project timeline.
Moreover, leaders excel in resource allocation and optimization (Insights,G.,2024).
They allocate resources efficiently, including labor, materials, and equipment, to maximize
productivity and minimize waste. By managing budgets effectively and ensuring optimal
resource utilization, leaders contribute to the project's financial success. Additionally,
leadership is critical in fostering transparent communication channels and managing
stakeholders effectively. Clear and open communication both internally among team
members and externally with clients, subcontractors, and regulatory authorities is essential
for preventing misunderstandings and conflicts (Anon, no date). Furthermore, effective
leaders demonstrate adaptability and problem-solving skills when navigating unforeseen
challenges. Construction projects often encounter obstacles such as inclement weather, design
changes, or supply chain disruptions. Leaders remain adaptable and resourceful, guiding the
team through challenges and implementing innovative solutions to keep the project on
course.
Poor communication stands out as one of the most prevalent and impactful issues in
construction leadership (Diaz,A.A,2024). The complex and high-speed nature of building
projects frequently leads to communication failures between leaders and team members.
Breakdowns can happen for several reasons, such as the intricate nature of project activities,
the involvement of diverse stakeholders, and the high-pressure climate commonly found in
construction projects. As a result, there is a prevalence of misconceptions, contradicting
information, and imprecise instructions, leading to delays, mistakes, and the requirement for
expensive revisions. Leaders may unintentionally neglect to adequately convey project
objectives, anticipated outcomes, and time constraints, resulting in team members
experiencing uncertainty and dissatisfaction. In addition, the emergence of communication
silos, which refers to the lack of efficient information sharing among several departments or
project teams, can worsen the issue by impeding collaboration and unity within the project.
The construction sector, known for its established traditions and long-standing
processes, presents a significant challenge for construction leaders in terms of resistance to
change. Construction projects frequently require leaders to be adaptable and open-minded in
order to accommodate new technology, methods, and regulations. Nevertheless, several
leaders may demonstrate hesitancy or even open opposition to change, favoring the comfort
of established routines and techniques. The presence of resistance can impede innovation and
limit progress, hence obstructing the implementation of more efficient or cost-effective
solutions. Amidst a swiftly developing sector, it is imperative for leaders to foster a culture
that wholeheartedly welcomes change. This entails promoting experimentation, ongoing
enhancement, and the study of novel concepts and technologies. Such efforts are crucial for
driving competitiveness and ensuring long-term growth.
Leadership training and development are crucial in dealing with leadership problems
in construction projects. Organizations want to allocate resources towards implementing
extensive leadership development initiatives that are specifically designed to address the
distinct issues prevalent in their respective industries. These programs encompass a variety of
subjects such as communication skills, conflict resolution, decision-making, emotional
intelligence, and project management. Organizations may empower leaders to effectively
manage the intricacies of building projects by equipping them with the essential tools and
expertise. In addition, it is crucial to provide continuous training and professional
development opportunities to leaders to ensure they remain up-to-date with industry trends
and best practices.
Leaders must set a precedent by exemplifying the values and principles of the
organization and displaying honesty, professionalism, and a dedication to excellence. This
entails creating a model of the expected conduct from team members, which includes
qualities such as accountability, respect, and teamwork. Leaders cultivate trust and
confidence within their teams by demonstrating positive behavior, which in turn promotes a
culture of mutual respect and accountability(CCL,2023). In addition, leaders should
proactively solicit feedback from team members and stakeholders, showcasing a genuine
openness to listen and acquire knowledge from others.
Experienced leaders possess a vast amount of information and skills that can be
extremely beneficial to less experienced team members. Leaders should proactively engage in
mentoring and coaching their team members, offering guidance, assistance, and constructive
feedback to facilitate the growth of their leadership abilities. This entails the dissemination of
knowledge gained from previous encounters, delivering constructive criticism on one's
performance, and providing guidance and support when necessary. In addition, leaders should
promote peer mentorship and coaching, cultivating a culture of ongoing learning and growth
among their teams. Through the strategic allocation of resources towards mentorship and
coaching, leaders may foster the development of future construction leaders and guarantee
the sustained prosperity of their businesses.
Procore has many benefits, one of which is its centralised communication platform.
Contractors, subcontractors, architects, and owners can all work together seamlessly on a
project thanks to Procore, which acts as a single point of contact for all project-related
communications. This centralised communication facilitates information sharing, lowers the
possibility of misunderstandings, and creates a cooperative atmosphere where all team
members are working towards the same project objectives.
Procore also has strong document management features that let project teams store, arrange,
and retrieve drawings, specs, and other project materials from one central area. By
guaranteeing that all parties involved have access to the most recent information, this lowers
the possibility of errors arising from version control problems. Moreover, by offering a
transparent audit trail of document updates and approvals, Procore's document management
features foster accountability and openness.
Procore's real-time tracking of project milestones and progress is another important feature.
Procore gives project managers the tools they need to monitor project performance, spot
bottlenecks, and make data-driven choices to maintain the project on schedule and within
budget. These tools include task management, schedule tracking, and performance analytics.
In the end, this real-time visibility into project status minimises delays and cost overruns by
enabling proactive problem-solving and prompt intervention when difficulties develop.
Procore is also very good at helping project teams collaborate and coordinate. Procore
facilitates smooth cooperation among diverse disciplines and geographical locations with its
features, which include document markup, file sharing, and issue tracking. By guaranteeing
that project teams can collaborate productively regardless of their location or time zone, this
increases efficiency and production.
Additionally, project stakeholders can submit updates, access project information, and
communicate with team members while on the go thanks to Procore's mobile accessibility.
Project teams may keep informed and connected even when they are not on the job site
thanks to this adaptability and responsiveness, which speeds up decision-making and
problem-solving.
Procore provides integrated financial management solutions that simplify budget tracking,
change order administration, and invoice processing in addition to its project management
features. Procore helps project teams make wise financial decisions and keep financial
control throughout the project lifecycle by giving visibility into project expenses and
profitability.
Additionally, customers can create thorough reports on project performance, financial data,
and other important indicators using Procore's customisable reporting capabilities. These
reports give stakeholders insightful information on the status of the project and assist them in
making decisions that will maximise project success.
During the interview, [Link], the EHS Area Manager, mentioned that they have
poor communication in the company. With many layers of management, communication
channels become so confused too. so sometimes the information they shared is not tallied.
This information will cause them to suffer a bigger loss of progress at the progress site .
Sometimes, they actually have the same information. Due to the mess of management, some
of the workers are not able to know who they are going to hear from. The project
management team has a few members. Each time, the team will send a different leader to
check the progress, and every leader is a different working style. So the workers are confused
about who should be listened to. However, some of the workers do not clearly understand the
information given from the top managements and make mistakes during their work. The
mistakes are almost taking their life.
After that, the top management went through the process of communication and
realised some of the workers did not clearly understand the order given by them. So, they had
been adjusted their strategy , which is to use some plain Bahasa Melayu to explain the whole
process. The workers are also encouraged to voice out their problems when they are working
too. Moreover, the project management team promised to send the same members to check
the progress so everyone can be understanding the working style. Otherwise, the project
management teams had prepared the proper document and doing email communications to
the head of the department, not only face to face, to ensure that the related report can be used
by all the stakeholders in the construction site.
Conclusion
Construction projects are one example of a strategy that should be used to create
appropriate communication. Effective communication not only promotes worker safety and
reduces expenses but also helps to keep staff members happy. There is a separate budget set
out for the victims' insurance premiums and the project's legal costs in the event that
something goes wrong at the site as a result of inadequate communication. Additionally,
effective communication enhances the standing of project stakeholders (Oleta, 2022). After
the current project is completed, some of the participants will be called upon for another.
They will most likely be requested to work on another project as they communicate while
they are at work. This is a crucial criterion to consider when choosing a new stakeholder team
that has strong communication skills.
2. Problem will occur without appropriate training.
Construction workers' lack of training is a crucial issue that can drastically disrupt project
workflows. This shortcoming presents itself in a variety of negative ways, hurting not just the
speed of work but also its quality, safety, and adherence to rules. At its heart, a lack of proper
training results in a workforce that is unable to face the difficulties of modern construction
sites, resulting in inefficiencies and possible risks that can cause project delays and cost
overruns.
First off, employees who are not properly trained may not be aware of safety best
practices, procedures, and standards. On building sites, this raises the possibility of mishaps,
injuries, and even fatalities. Untrained personnel could, for instance, misuse equipment,
forget to put on personal protective equipment (PPE), or be unable to identify and eliminate
any risks. These safety risks not only jeopardize the well-being of the workers but also
disrupt project workflow as work may need to be halted to address accidents or implement
corrective measures (Sousa & Alves, 2018).
Furthermore, employees who lack the necessary training may find it difficult to
interact with managers, coworkers, and other project stakeholders. This may result in
miscommunications, mistakes, and disputes that impede coordinated efforts. Untrained
personnel could find it challenging to decipher instructions, analyse building plans, or
communicate crucial information to their colleagues. Communication breakdowns disrupt the
flow of work as tasks may need to be repeated or clarified, delaying project milestones, and
increasing the likelihood of rework (Alshawi et al., 2013).
Another area that is badly harmed by inadequate training is workers could take longer
to finish tasks or might operate less efficiently if they are not properly trained. This may lead
to lower output and productivity, which would cause schedule adherence to projects to be
delayed. Untrained personnel could find it difficult to handle machinery, carry out intricate
construction tasks, or solve difficulties on their own. Lower productivity levels disrupt the
workflow by extending project timelines and increasing labour costs (Zhong et al., 2018).
Lastly, workers with inadequate training may not possess the abilities and know-how
needed to complete their jobs to the appropriate levels. This may lead to subpar work, flaws,
and rework, which would raise expenses and impede the project's development. Untrained
personnel could, for example, install building components incorrectly, implement
construction plans incorrectly, or disregard quality control procedures. Addressing quality
issues requires additional time and resources, disrupting the planned workflow and
potentially impacting project deadlines (Alarcon et al., 2016). Therefore, addressing the
shortage of training among construction workers is essential for the long-term profitability
and competitiveness of construction enterprises in the market, in addition to enhancing the
results of individual projects.
First, trainings can be more flexible and save cost by conducting trainings virtually. In
certain situations, in-person instruction—or even instruction requiring a commute to the
office—is ineffective. It is costly, cumbersome, and time-consuming. Employees should be
able to access various topics on their mobile devices so they may use their phones or tablets
for training when at home or on the job site. Compared to in-person training, online training
provides videos and perhaps more interactive instruction. It can also address the issue of
language barriers by providing the same instruction in many languages. Although job-specific
and site-specific in-person training is still vital, just think of how much more an employee
might learn online. (Graham, 2021)
Besides, not only we should improve technically, but we should also improve on our
working culture between every parties. Establishing a work environment that prioritizes
ongoing enhancement and career advancement is crucial. This entails not just offering
training opportunities but also rewarding skill progress, soliciting constructive criticism, and
acknowledging staff members' accomplishments. It is important for leaders to advocate for
the significance of training and serve as role models by engaging in professional development
initiatives. By fostering an environment where learning and growth are prioritized, companies
can motivate their workforce to engage in training and apply their learning on the job
(Kouzes and Posner, 2017).
Last but not least, as a leader of the group, establishing a mechanism for tracking and
assessing results is essential to guaranteeing the efficacy of training initiatives. This entails
evaluating the skills of employees both prior to and during training, monitoring
advancements in safety logs, productivity indicators, and project results. Participant feedback
can also reveal areas for development and the applicability of the course. By regularly
analysing these outcomes, companies can refine their training programs, making them more
effective and aligned with business goals (Phillips and Phillips, 2016).
Other than that, new technologies like drones, automated machinery, and building
information modelling (BIM) are being adopted by the construction sector more and more.
Accuracy, productivity, and efficiency are increased when workers and management are
trained in these technologies and can successfully incorporate them into processes. According
to Eastman et al. (2011), maintaining competitiveness and satisfying the dynamic
requirements of construction projects necessitates continuous training in novel technologies
and techniques as the sector develops.
Next, for construction projects to comply with legal and regulatory requirements,
industry standards, and best practices, training in regulatory compliance and risk management
techniques is crucial. This covers instruction on health and safety laws, building rules,
permits, inspections, contract management, and environmental requirements. By educating
project stakeholders about their responsibilities and obligations, training helps to minimize
the risk of non-compliance, legal disputes, and financial penalties, thereby safeguarding the
project's reputation, finances, and long-term viability (Construction Industry Training Board,
2020).
Besides that, any construction project's success depends on efficient cooperation and
communication. Workflow and project results can be greatly enhanced by training that
develops these abilities. Effective communication within a team facilitates dispute resolution,
task coordination, and information exchange, all of which reduce the likelihood of
misunderstandings and delays. A more cooperative and productive work environment might
result from training that fosters a sense of respect and camaraderie among employees
(Lencioni, 2012).
Decentralizing decision-making
Another example will be a sharing session from Mr Camillus, he state that he will
usually uses a drone to fly across the construction site to manage if workers are illegally
carrying out work activities that aren’t registered in the system or working without permit.
Mr Camillus also started that drone can capture evidences. Most command disputues that
happen to Mr Camillus as a safety manager will always be with the sub contractors that fails
to wear their safety helmets , safety vest and equipment , they always argued that they are
about to wear it or they just take them off not long ago, using a drone can monitor the actual
situations with recorded footages.
Case Study
The case study of the combination of Virtual Reality (VR) and Building Information
Modeling (BIM) in building projects has the potential to change communication and
cooperation. The case study in this article highlights VR's capacity to deliver immersive
representations of BIM models, allowing stakeholders to better comprehend project specifics,
detect concerns, and make educated decisions. While VR technology has substantial benefits,
such as improved design review procedures and more stakeholder participation, its adoption
is hampered by barriers such as high initial costs and reluctance to new technologies. To fully
realize VR's potential, construction companies should engage in staff training, begin with
specific applications, partner with technology suppliers to build solutions, manage investment
costs effectively, and share success stories to drive broader adoption. Embracing VR in BIM-
enabled workflows is a strategic step toward more efficient and successful building project
management (Zaker, R., 2018).
The case study "Agile Project Management with Scrum" at a Brazilian pharmaceutical
business demonstrates the enormous benefits of implementing Agile approaches, particularly
in contexts typified by uncertainty and fast change. Implementing Scrum resulted in
significant gains in project efficiency, including a 50% cost savings and a reduced completion
time from seven to four months, demonstrating Agile's potential for improving operational
efficiency. It improved stakeholder satisfaction through iterative development and regular
value delivery, ensuring that the final product closely met stakeholder expectations. Agile
approaches promoted a collaborative and motivated project environment, improving team
relationships and fostering a culture of constant communication and development. The
research emphasizes the significance of stakeholder involvement, team training, iterative
planning, culture adaptation, and tailoring Agile principles to unique project requirements.
This case study clearly shows that Agile Project Management using Scrum is very successful
for managing projects in dynamic industries, providing flexibility, improved outcomes, and
stakeholder satisfaction (Azanha, A., 2017).
Conclusion
And open interview session carried out by Grace chia at the construction site to gather
opinions from everybody to gather mor information for this assignment
3.5 Ms Sharon Chen Chew Huay
- Managing director from Siong Heng Synergy Sdn Bhd
- Over 20 years experiences in the contractual and tendering department in
constructions
References
Bojeun, Dr.M. (2024) Why leadership skills play such a crucial role in project management,
PMWorld 360 Magazine. Available at: [Link]
skills-play-such-a-crucial-role-in-project-management/ (Accessed: 30 March 2024).
Dam, Y.V. (2023) Micro-management the silent killer of Team Morale, productivity and staff
engagement, LinkedIn. Available at: [Link]
management-silent-killer-team-morale-staff-yoke-van-dam- (Accessed: 30 March
2024).
Diaz, A.A. (2024) Bridging the gap of communication in construction, Letsbuild. Available
at: [Link]
(Accessed: 30 March 2024).
Insights, G. (2024) Difference between leadership and management: Clarifying the divide,
Gray Group International. Available at:
[Link]
(Accessed: 30 March 2024).
Big Rentz, 2023 , 10 Essential Construction Communication Skills for Your Team, [online],
Available at:<[Link] [Accessed on
30 March 2024]
Centre for Creative Leadership, 2023, How to Be a Successful Change Leader, [online],
Available at :<[Link]
leader/> [Accessed on 30 March 2024]
Brenda L.T.H., Nur I.F.B.M.N., Ng, J.L., Zakiah, A., Lee, J.C., Salihah, S., Deprizon, S.,
Ramez, A.A.A., & Ruzaimah, R., Effects of Poor Communication in the Construction
Industry in Klang Valley, Malaysia, Jurnal Kejuruteraan 34(5) 2022: pp. 837-841
Adnan, H., S. M. Shamsuddin. Onflict Prevention in Partnering Projects [J]. Procedia-Social
and Behavioral Sciences 35: 772-781, 2012
Alarcon, L. F., et al. (2016). Factors affecting the performance of construction projects in the Gaza
Strip. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 22(5), 635-647.
Alshawi, M., et al. (2013). Organisational culture and knowledge sharing in construction. Journal of
Knowledge Management, 17(2), 213-226.
Sousa, V., & Alves, A. C. (2018). Safety climate and safety practices: assessing the
mediating role of worker engagement. Safety Science, 109, 398-408.
Zhong, B., et al. (2018). The effect of team training on team performance: A controlled trial
in construction. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 144(8), 04018063.
Graham, T. (2021). Lack of Training’s Costing the Construction Industry - Here’s How to
Tackle It. [online] KPA. Available at: [Link]
construction-industry-heres-how-to-tackle-it/ [Accessed 29 Mar. 2024].
Worcman, V. (2021). How to deal with lack of training at work? [online] Bites. Available at:
[Link]
Phillips, J.J., and Phillips, P.P. (2016). Handbook of Training Evaluation and Measurement
Methods. Routledge.
Kouzes, J.M., and Posner, B.Z. (2017). The Leadership Challenge: How to Make
Extraordinary Things Happen in Organizations. Jossey-Bass.
Barber, P., Tomkins, C., & Graves, A. (1999). Decentralised site management—a case study.
International journal of project management, 17(2), 113-120.
[Link]
Zaker, R., & Coloma, E. (2018). Virtual reality-integrated workflow in BIM-enabled projects
collaboration and design review: a case study. Visualization in Engineering, 6, 1-15.
[Link]
Azanha, A., Argoud, A. R. T. T., Camargo Junior, J. B. D., & Antoniolli, P. D. (2017). Agile
project management with Scrum: A case study of a Brazilian pharmaceutical company IT
project. International journal of managing projects in business, 10(1), 121-142.
[Link]
Thomas, J., & Mengel, T. (2008). Preparing project managers to deal with complexity–
Advanced project management education. International journal of project management,
26(3), 304-315.
[Link]