Business Capstone Session Overview
Business Capstone Session Overview
Patricia Sharma
Adjunct Lecturer
1
Who am I?
Patricia Sharma
• Global consumer marketer – 20 years experience across retail/FMCG, tech/telco,
banking/wealth
• Lawyer, Bain consultant, INSEAD MBA
• Lived and worked 10 years overseas - in UK, France, USA, Netherlands, Philippines,
Indonesia, and much APAC work
• Fluent in French, Malay/Bahasa
Currently:
• Consulting - focused on marketing, strategy, sustainability
• Mentoring - to INSEAD MBAs in Entrepreneurship
• Investing - in a few start-ups with INSEAD Alumni Ventures
• Leadership - executive trainer and coach
• Volunteering - with charity Daughters of Tomorrow, Aidha
[Link]
2
Who are you?
• 2 things that define you (that most people know), for e.g.:
• I am a Psychology major
• I am on the SMU canoeing team
• Find me at the SMU gym / canteen / library
3
Plan for Today
4
Disruption of business models throughout history
5
AI is disrupting the world of business faster than ever
6
Business doesn’t need more “skilled workers”
This course:
• Caps your time at SMU by applying cross-functional academic
knowledge to ideate a solution for a real client business challenge
7
Learning Objectives for Design of Business
9
Mechanisms of MGMT330 The Design of Business
10
Integration of our BBM Majors
Marketing
Identify customer
segments and their
Finance needs, develop
distribution and pricing Strategic Management
Perform risk-return to maximize revenue Develop strategy and
analysis on the new
business model based
business solution;
on capabilities and
create value for
competition
shareholders
Operations Quantitative Finance
Management Develop quantitative
Designing business and models and statistics
production process to when applicable to
deliver goods + support business
services to optimize model ideas
value
Corporate
OBHR Communication
Diagnose org
effectiveness; develop
Business Engage in persuasive
arguments to support
Capstone
a plan to manage business plan using
change creative and effective
techniques
11
Our Approach – It’s Up to You
12
About the “Project”
Challenge Understand Strategy Design Prove Reflection Build-Out Exec Rec. Deliver
Client ‘As-is’; Rational Brainstorm, Solution Validate Iterate Financial Bus. Case; Tune; Client
Customer vs Ideate to Draft; Solution/ Change Management; Create Final
Meet the Value Iterative Solution; X-Team 15 min Business Implementation Strawman, VC-style
Client Proposition Thinking Iterate Stress-Test Prez RECESS Model Plan Exec Sum Pitch
11 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hear & Select Pain/Gain Who Draft Assumptions Emphasis on Test Stakeholder Proofed Full Solution;
Your of Client’s What Solution Constraints Client Agreement to Analyse impacts Recap Session 7
Challenge Customer How is born Business Context & Sessions 5-12
Customer Value Prop;
Sessions 2, 3, 4
Your Primary Research Continuing to Bring Client Along the Journey
Business Model Generation Text
Quiz Course Reflections
pp. 14-119 126-133 200-239 134-189
Due in week
Evaluation
14
Internet Design Other
Research Methods Reading
of Client Text TBD
& Their 83-127 NO
Industry activity ratio over course of term EXAM !
Pre-reading;
Participative Lectures
• Primary role: Your Prof is a facilitator / coach for the work YOU
undertake.
• I will not tell you how to do your research; produce ideas, or package them
• But I will advise you
• Instruction: in general, expect progressively less and less time spent on
discussions surrounding key concepts related to business design tools
Teams Working on Client Challenges
Pre-reading;
Participative Lectures
activity ratio over course of term
Teaching Assistant
Roles:
• Client liaison through whom you should initially co-ordinate with
• Manage eLearn group logistics
• Record individual attendance (med certs, etc)
• Record student participation during class discussion (quantity and
quality) and online
• Convey messages/questions to Prof if you do not wish to ask
directly
• Assist to book team consultations with Prof outside of lesson time
17
MGMT330
Six ways to
18
18
Course Assessments
19
Potential Team Challenge Deliverables
(components to present may vary, depending on your client challenge)
Mid-term Presentation Final Presentation
15min Pitch with 10 Q&A 15min Pitch, 10mins Q&A + written 2-page Executive Summary
Confirm client agreement as to: Final solution and plan can include:
• Client industry context • Value proposition for customer segment(s)
• Assessment of client’s ‘as-is’ business • Evidence for proposed solution (reframe
model (in brief) existing + additional evidence)
• Profile of client’s customer including • Some of the following:
pain/gain points (may reflect 1. Marketing plan (customer relationships
segmentations) and channels as per canvas)
• Your primary and secondary research 2. Operations plan (key activities, key
• Proposed new or improved sources of resources, key partners as per canvas)
value (ideas worth developing) 3. Strategic review (i.e., builds on key
• Preliminary trial of your BMC solution strengths of the firm, feasible in terms of
ideas (including those rejected) human resources, is difficult for
• Selected value propositions for the competitors to imitate, etc.)
customer 4. Financial viability (sensitivity of model to
defined revenue and cost drivers)
5. Stakeholder impact and management of
change overview including timeline 20
Presentation Rubrics
Details of the rules and guidelines set out by Office of Finance (OFIN)
can be found within each form. Do pay attention to claimable and non-
claimable items stated. Please ensure that students use the correct
claim forms and abide by the rules set out by OFIN.
24
Helpful Tips
[Link] 25
Embrace ambiguity!
26
How to Make an Appointment
27
BREAK
28
Plan for Today
29
Let’s Get Started!
So… What is a
Business Model
anyway?
30
Role of Business Models
QUIZ
Ex ante (Tool) TOPICS
• Understand the construct a “business”
• Innovate (from where? Affects what?)
• Iterate – quickly redesign components and linkages
• Centered around the value proposition and user
• Companies often have a technology or an idea but no value proposition yet
• Value proposition (idea and its meaning to customer) first
• Idea that is not implementable should be reworked (with all the other parts)
• Hypothesise - A business model is management’s hypothesis (plan) about who the
customers are, what the customers want, how the customers want it, as well as, the
manner the enterprise organises itself to best meet those needs; gets paid for doing so;
and makes a profit
Ex post (Descriptive)
• A business model summarises how an organisation creates value for, and captures
value from, users and customers
• Business model choices define the architecture of the business… expansion paths
develop from there
Teece, D. J. (2010). Business models, business strategy and innovation. Long range planning, 43(2), 172-194.
Osterwalder A & Pigneur Y. (2007) Business Model Generation 31
Examples of business models – Which are these?
• Ford Model T
• mass production (Model T) - “Any color as long as it's black”
• Gillette
• Bait & hook – e.g. razor and blades (also, Polaroid, Nespresso)
• Skype
• free and premium services (Freemium, also Zoom)
• Apple
• hardware mass production + software platform
32
Business Model Generation:
Introduction to the Business Model Canvas
[Link] 33
Integration of Process design WHAT WHY WHO
activities in (activity streams) outcome is the should the does the firm
process design to create and customer customer be serve?
from external deliver the value trying to loyal to you?
parties to the achieve that One or several
firm the firm specific
(through serves/solves? customer
contracts, The human, HOW is the value
segments
alliances, etc.) capital, and proposition
technology delivered:
assets to enable communication,
business model distribution,
sales
34
Think about Airbnb
• What is the value proposition?
• What is unique about this business model?
• Who are the competitors?
• What keeps others from copying this model?
• What are the organizational implications of the model?
[Link] 35
36
Activity: Business Model Canvas
40
Budget airlines
Older aircraft
41
Plan for Today
42
Understand your client’s current business model;
Are there alternative patterns that could work better?
QUIZ
TOPICS
[Link] 43
UNBUNDLED
44
Patterns: Unbundling
Does this hold true? What are the risks associated with
unbundling?
45
Unbundling the Business
Economics
Competition
Culture
46
Unbundling the Mobile Telco
- who are the players in Singapore today?
48
The Long Tail
49
The Long Tail Summary
50
MULTI-SIDED PLATFORMS
51
Patterns: Multi-sided platforms
• Multi-sided platforms bring together two or more distinct but
interdependent groups of users / customers.
• Such platforms are of value to one group of customers only if the
other groups of customers are also present.
• The platform creates value by facilitating interactions
between the different groups.
• A multi-sided platform grows in value to the extent that it
attracts more users, a phenomenon known as the network
effect. (O&P, p.77)
• Often face chicken or egg dilemma
• Can be solved by subsidizing one customer segment
• E.g. Visa, Google, eBay, game consoles, Apple (apps)
53
Multi-sided platforms: summary
54
FREE(MIUM)
55
Freemium
56
Patterns: Freemium
57
FACEBOOK FREE + MULTI-SIDED PLATFORM
58
What do you think?
61
Open Business Model
62
Open Business Model - The shifting paradigm
Closed Open
1) The really smart people in our 1) Let’s work with smart people
field work for us regardless of where they work
2) To profit from R&D, we must 2) External R&D can create great
discover, develop, and market it value. Internal R&D is needed to
claim a portion of that value
3) If we conduct the best research 3) We don’t have to originate
in the world, we can be research to benefit from it. We can
successful borrow and collaborate
4) If we create the most or the best 4) If we make the best use of internal
ideas in the industry, we will win and external ideas, we will win
5) We should control our 5) We should profit from a) our own
innovation process so that innovations and b) others using our
competitors don’t profit from our innovations and we should buy IP
ideas when it advances our interests
64
Open Business Model Example: Pharma Patent Pools
65
Open Innovation - Summary
66
Patterns Overview
UNBUNDLED LONG TAIL MULTI-SIDED FREE(MIUM) OPEN
PLATFORM
Initial Integrated BM Single VP targets Single VP targets High-value high-cost R&D is developed
context fulfilling different only most profitable single customer VP is offered to in-house and not
functions client segment paying customers sold to others, even
without when not used
complementary
sales in mind
Challenge High costs and Targeting less How to acquire new High price dissuades R&D is costly,
conflicting cultures profitable segments customers that customers productivity is
in one organization is too expensive complement falling
existing customer
base
Solution Unbundle into 1) Additional VP A VP “giving access Positive network Leverage internal
infrastructure targets new to customer base” is effects: Many VPs R&D to license and
mgmt., 2) product customers added coexist and are insource external
innovation, and 3) profitably thanks to associated with R&D when needed
customer relations platform distinct revenue
streams
Rationale Better ICT & mgmt. IT & operations Operate as inter- Premium customers External R&D can
tools make mgmt. mediary between subsidize non- boost speed to
coordination improvements various customer paying customers market while
between businesses allow low-cost segments to boost underused internal
cheaper, hence delivery of broad revenues R&D can be sold at
reducing trade-offs product scope a profit
67
Plan for Today
68
Next Week: Meet Your “Client”
• A Transition from University to the ‘Real World’
• Opportunity to work directly with a real business and their executives
• Use their time respectfully and productively – they have day jobs too
• single point of communication; present possible answers not just questions/problems
• Each executive will interact with students in their own way (we have no control of this)
69
Homework
Describe the ‘As-Is’ Business Model Canvas of your client
Relevant to Session 2 (Meet the Client) and to be discussed in Session 3
70
Team allocation
71
Next Week (Session 2)
72
Homework: Relevant to Session 2 (Meet the Client) and to be discussed in Session 3
What Are Your Insights from…
Researching Trends Impacting the Industry and Client?
There are a variety of tools and frameworks that you can use to understand the
context and situation of a business (see 101 Design Methods book)
From Kumar (2013) 101 Design Methods
76
Summary for Today
77
78