Dilmah Tea Leadership and Management Analysis
Dilmah Tea Leadership and Management Analysis
Speaker Notes:
"Welcome to my presentation on the leadership and management analysis of Dilmah
Tea Company, a prominent Sri Lankan firm facing declining growth. Today, I’ll
compare Dilmah with its competitors, HVA Tea and Watawala Tea, analyzing their
organizational situations, leadership and management practices, and organizational
cultures. We’ll also explore strategies to address Dilmah’s challenges and turn
negative outcomes into positive ones. Let’s get started."
PAGE 2: Agenda
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Here’s the agenda for today’s presentation. We’ll begin with an introduction to
Dilmah Tea Company, followed by an overview of its competitors, HVA Tea and
Watawala Tea. Next, we’ll analyze their financial and strategic situations, explore
leadership and management theories and styles, and examine their organizational
cultures. Finally, I’ll offer recommendations to improve Dilmah’s situation and
conclude with key insights."
PAGE 3: Introduction to Dilmah Tea
Company
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah Tea Company was founded in 1988 by Merrill J. Fernando and is unique as
Sri Lanka’s only fully vertically integrated tea company, controlling everything from
garden to pack. Its philosophy, 'Business is a Matter of Human Service,' underscores
its ethical focus. The company donates 15-20% of its pre-tax profits to the MJF
Foundation and Dilmah Conservation, supporting Sri Lankan communities. Since
2019, CEO Dilhan C. Fernando has led efforts in sustainability, innovation, and
community impact, emphasizing areas like Ceylon Tea, Ethical Tea, and Tea
Mixology. With 1,001 to 5,000 employees, Dilmah operates in the Food & Beverage
Services industry."
Title: Overview
Founded in 1988 by Merrill J. Fernando
Sri Lanka’s only fully vertically integrated Tea Company from garden to pack
Philosophy: Business is a Matter of Human Service
15-20% of pre-tax profits fund the MJF Foundation & Dilmah Conservation to support Sri
Lankan communities
Dilhan C. Fernando, CEO since 2019, drives sustainability, innovation, community impact &
adapts to modern trends
Key Areas: Ceylon Tea, Ethical Tea, Tea Gastronomy, School of Tea, Tea Mixology
Employees: 1,001-5,000 | Industry: Food & Beverage Services
Speaker Notes:
"This slide reiterates Dilmah’s key details. Founded in 1988 by Merrill J. Fernando,
it’s Sri Lanka’s only vertically integrated tea company. Its philosophy of human
service drives its operations, with significant profits supporting the MJF Foundation
and Dilmah Conservation. Under CEO Dilhan C. Fernando since 2019, Dilmah
focuses on sustainability and innovation in areas like tea gastronomy and mixology,
employing between 1,001 and 5,000 people in the Food & Beverage Services sector."
PAGE 5: Financial Situation of Dilmah
Tea Company
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah is experiencing a severe financial downturn. Revenue has declined by 17%,
profit before tax by 77%, and net profit by 85%. Earnings per share have dropped
dramatically from Rs. 242.77 to Rs. 36.76, an 84.9% decrease. The table illustrates
these changes, comparing previous and current years. This financial decline signals
the urgency for strategic interventions, which we’ll explore later."
Speaker Notes:
"Now, let’s look at Dilmah’s first competitor, HVA Tea. Founded in 1990 as HAVA
Lanka Exports, it became fully Sri Lankan-owned in 1993 and a BOI-approved export
company in 1996. Today, it’s one of Sri Lanka’s leading tea exporters, owning the
HELADIV brand, which draws from the Sinhala term for Sri Lanka, 'Land of the
Lion.' HVA Tea focuses on exporting high-quality Ceylon tea, establishing a strong
global presence."
Title: Overview
Founded in 1990 as HAVA Lanka Exports, fully Sri Lankan-owned since 1993
BOI-approved export company since 1996
One of Sri Lanka’s top tea exporters
Owns the HELADIV brand
Employees: 501-1,000 | Industry: Food & Beverage Exports
Key Focus: High-quality Ceylon tea exports
Speaker Notes:
"This slide provides an overview of HVA Tea. Since its founding in 1990 and full Sri
Lankan ownership in 1993, it’s been a BOI-approved exporter since 1996. As a top
tea exporter with 501 to 1,000 employees, HVA Tea operates under the HELADIV
brand, focusing on high-quality Ceylon tea exports. Its export-driven strategy has
solidified its position in the global market, contrasting with Dilmah’s challenges."
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea has performed well financially. Revenue grew by 10% last year, with a net
profit margin rising from 10% to 12%. Export volume increased by 8%, from 3.5
million to 3.78 million kilograms. Despite challenges like rising raw material costs
and global competition, HVA Tea’s growth, as shown in the table, contrasts sharply
with Dilmah’s decline, highlighting effective strategies we’ll explore later."
Speaker Notes:
"Our second competitor, Watawala Tea, is a dominant player in Sri Lanka’s tea
market. Owned by Sunshine Holdings PLC, renamed Sunshine Consumer Lanka Ltd
in 2021, it holds a 35-37% share of the branded tea market. Watawala has earned
multiple SLIM Nielsen People’s Awards as the top hot beverage brand. With 501 to
1,000 employees, it operates in the Food & Beverage Manufacturing industry, posing
a strong challenge to Dilmah."
Title: Overview
Parent Company: Fully owned by Sunshine Holdings PLC (renamed Sunshine Consumer Lanka
Ltd in 2021)
Market Position: Leader with ~35-37% share of Sri Lanka’s branded tea market
Awards: Multiple SLIM Nielsen People’s Awards as top hot beverage brand
Industry: Food & Beverage Manufacturing
Employees: 501-1,000
Speaker Notes:
"This slide outlines Watawala Tea’s key details. Fully owned by Sunshine Holdings
PLC, rebranded in 2021, Watawala leads with a 35-37% market share in Sri Lanka’s
branded tea sector. Its repeated SLIM Nielsen People’s Awards affirm its status as a
top hot beverage brand. Employing 501 to 1,000 people, Watawala thrives in Food &
Beverage Manufacturing, offering lessons for Dilmah in market dominance and
branding."
PAGE 11: Financial Situation of
Watawala Tea
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Watawala Tea shows robust financial health, with a 15% revenue increase and a net
profit margin rising from 13% to 15%. Its market share remains stable at 35-37%.
Despite challenges like rising production costs and inflation, as shown in the table,
Watawala’s performance outpaces Dilmah’s, reflecting strong management and
market strategies we’ll analyze further."
o Revenue: -17%
o Profit Before Tax: -77%
o Net Profit: -85%
o EPS: Rs. 242.77 to Rs. 36.76 (-84.9%)
Strategic Issues:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s current problems are twofold: financial and strategic. Financially, revenue
is down 17%, profit before tax 77%, net profit 85%, and EPS has fallen 84.9% from
Rs. 242.77 to Rs. 36.76. Strategically, declining export volumes, reduced demand,
competition from cheaper alternatives, immature brand repositioning, and supply
chain disruptions are crippling the company. These issues demand immediate
attention."
Speaker Notes:
"This slide details why Dilmah’s export volume fell from 4.5 million to 1 million
kilograms. Decreased demand in key markets, competition from cheaper alternatives,
and immature brand repositioning are key drivers. Global supply chain disruptions,
costly sustainability efforts, inflation, industry structural issues, low government
support, and rising costs for energy, packaging, materials, and wages are squeezing
margins, explaining Dilmah’s struggles."
Speaker Notes:
"This table compares Dilmah with HVA Tea and Watawala Tea. Dilmah’s revenue
dropped 17%, while HVA Tea grew 10% and Watawala 15%. Net profit for Dilmah
fell 85%, compared to HVA’s 12% and Watawala’s 15% margins. Export volume for
Dilmah declined 78% to 1 million kilograms, while HVA’s rose 8% to 3.78 million,
and Watawala’s stayed stable. Dilmah’s market share is shrinking, unlike its
competitors. Challenges include supply chain and sustainability costs for Dilmah,
versus raw material costs and inflation for HVA and Watawala."
PAGE 16: Leadership Theories &
Application
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Let’s explore leadership theories at Dilmah. Trait Theory highlights Dilhan C.
Fernando’s inherent vision for sustainability. Behavioral Theory reflects Merrill J.
Fernando’s ethical actions that shaped Dilmah’s ethos. Contingency Theory shows
adaptation to global trends like tea gastronomy, while Transformational Theory is
seen in driving innovation through tea mixology. These theories frame Dilmah’s
leadership approach and its effectiveness."
o Vision
o Influence
o Motivation
o Goal Achievement
Speaker Notes:
"Leadership is defined as the ability to influence a group toward achieving a vision or
goals. At Dilmah, this involves a vision of sustainability, influencing teams,
motivating through ethical values, and aiming for goals like innovation. This
definition helps us assess how leadership drives Dilmah’s performance compared to
its competitors."
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea’s leadership aligns with Behavioral Theory through its export-driven
actions, Transactional Theory by meeting export targets with structured processes,
and Situational Theory by adapting to global market demands. These approaches have
fueled HVA’s export growth and financial success, offering a contrast to Dilmah’s
leadership challenges."
Speaker Notes:
"Watawala Tea employs Transformational Theory to drive market leadership via
innovation, Charismatic Theory by leveraging its award-winning reputation, and
Contingency Theory to adapt to its parent company’s FMCG expansion. These
leadership strategies have sustained Watawala’s dominance, providing lessons for
Dilmah to enhance its own approach."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s struggles stem from high sustainability costs, supply chain disruptions, and
immature brand repositioning. HVA Tea thrives due to export efficiency and market
adaptability, while Watawala succeeds with a strong reputation and innovation. These
factors explain the differing impacts on each company’s performance."
Speaker Notes:
"To turn negatives into positives, Dilmah can reframe sustainability as a competitive
edge, appealing to eco-conscious consumers. Digital marketing can mature brand
repositioning, while diversifying into tea-based beverages can boost demand.
Strengthening supply chain resilience and lobbying for government support can
address structural issues, paving the way for recovery."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah applies Scientific Management through its efficient vertical integration,
Systems Theory in managing its supply chain, Contingency Theory to adapt to market
shifts, and Human Relations Theory via employee welfare programs like the MJF
Foundation. These theories shape Dilmah’s management practices and their
outcomes."
o Planning
o Organizing
o Directing
o Controlling
Speaker Notes:
"Management is the process of planning, organizing, directing, and controlling
resources to achieve goals. At Dilmah, planning sets sustainability targets, organizing
structures the supply chain, directing leads teams, and controlling monitors finances.
This framework helps us evaluate management’s role in Dilmah’s performance."
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea uses Scientific Management for streamlined export processes, Systems
Theory for integrated supply chain management, and Bureaucratic Theory for a
structured approach to export targets. These practices enhance efficiency and support
HVA’s growth, contrasting with Dilmah’s management struggles."
Negative Impacts:
o Contingency Theory: Slow adaptation to rapid market changes
o Systems Theory: Complexity in managing global supply chains
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s management theories yield positives like production efficiency from
Scientific Management and better morale from Human Relations Theory. However,
negatives include slow adaptation to market changes under Contingency Theory and
supply chain complexity from Systems Theory, impacting overall effectiveness."
Negative Impacts:
Speaker Notes:
"Positive impacts arise from efficiency meeting industry needs and employee welfare
boosting loyalty. Negative impacts stem from resistance to change in traditional
management and over-reliance on complex systems, hindering Dilmah’s ability to
adapt and manage globally."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah can adopt agile management to enhance adaptability, simplify supply chains
with technology, train managers in change management, and balance efficiency with
flexibility. These steps can turn management weaknesses into strengths, improving
overall performance."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s leadership includes Transformational style, with Dilhan C. Fernando
inspiring innovation, and Democratic style, involving teams in sustainability.
Management styles are Coaching, focusing on development, and Authoritative,
controlling production. These styles shape Dilmah’s operations but need refinement
for better results."
Speaker Notes:
"A leadership style is the behavior pattern a leader uses to influence others. Dilmah
uses Democratic and Transformational styles, while Autocratic and Laissez-faire are
less evident. This framework helps us assess how leadership styles impact Dilmah’s
situation."
PAGE 30: Leadership Styles in HVA Tea
& Watawala Tea
Slide Content:
Watawala Tea:
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea uses Transactional leadership for export targets and Situational leadership
for market adaptability. Watawala employs Charismatic leadership, leveraging its
reputation, and Transformational leadership for innovation. These styles drive their
success, offering models for Dilmah to consider."
o Authoritative: Control-based
o Coaching: Development-focused
o Delegative: Hands-off
Speaker Notes:
"A management style is a manager’s preferred method for overseeing work. Dilmah
uses Authoritative and Coaching styles, while Delegative could add flexibility. This
lens helps us evaluate management’s role in Dilmah’s performance."
Watawala Tea:
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea’s Authoritative and Bureaucratic styles ensure export efficiency, while
Watawala’s Coaching and Visionary styles support development and expansion.
These approaches contrast with Dilmah’s, suggesting areas for improvement in
management flexibility and vision."
o Shared Values
o Norms
o Beliefs
o Communication
o Leadership Tone
Speaker Notes:
"Organizational culture comprises values, beliefs, and behaviors shaping work. At
Dilmah, shared values like human service, ethical norms, sustainability beliefs, open
communication, and a leadership tone of innovation define its culture, influencing
performance."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s culture blends Person, focusing on development, and Task, emphasizing
projects like tea mixology. Power and Role types are less prominent. Culture
enhances engagement, drives innovation, and affects finances, critical for Dilmah’s
recovery."
Watawala Tea:
Speaker Notes:
"HVA Tea’s Role and Task cultures prioritize export structure and targets, while
Watawala’s Person and Innovation cultures focus on development and market
leadership. These cultural strengths support their success, offering insights for
Dilmah."
Negative Impacts:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s ethical culture boosts its reputation, and its employee focus aids retention.
However, resistance to change stifles innovation, and sustainability raises costs,
negatively impacting finances. Balancing these is key."
Negative Impacts:
Speaker Notes:
"Positive cultural impacts come from ethical alignment and leadership’s welfare
commitment. Negative impacts arise from a traditional mindset resisting change and
costly sustainability efforts, explaining Dilmah’s mixed outcomes."
Negative Effects:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah faced criticism for aggressive marketing. By highlighting product benefits
and adopting a nuanced approach, it improved brand perception and sensitivity. The
takeaway is to adapt strategies to cultural contexts, a lesson applicable to other
challenges."
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah needs to foster innovation, balance sustainability with cost efficiency,
promote agile decision-making, enhance collaboration, and align with global trends.
These changes can create a dynamic culture to boost performance."
PAGE 41: Final Evaluation &
Suggestions
Slide Content:
o Dilmah: Strong ethical culture but hindered by financial decline and resistance to
change
o HVA Tea: Efficient export-driven culture, adaptable to global markets
o Watawala Tea: Innovative culture, strong market leadership
Suggestions:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah’s ethical culture is a strength, but financial decline and resistance to change
are hurdles. HVA Tea excels in export efficiency and adaptability, while Watawala
leads with innovation. Suggestions include agile practices, simplified supply chains,
digital marketing, and cost-efficient sustainability to improve Dilmah’s standing."
Speaker Notes:
"To enhance leadership, Dilmah should adopt Transformational style for innovation,
Democratic style for team involvement, Situational skills for adaptability, Charismatic
style for reputation, and train leaders in change management. These steps can
revitalize leadership effectiveness."
PAGE 43: How Can Management Bring
Short-Term and Long-Term
Improvements?
Slide Content:
Long-Term Improvements:
Speaker Notes:
"Management can achieve short-term gains by streamlining supply chains, cutting
costs, and using digital tools. Long-term, investing in employees, cost-effective
sustainability, and market expansion into tea beverages can ensure sustained growth."
Title: Dilmah Can Learn from HVA Tea & Watawala Tea
From HVA Tea:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah can learn export efficiency and adaptability from HVA Tea, and innovation
and reputation-building from Watawala Tea. These lessons can help Dilmah regain its
competitive edge."
PAGE 45: What Must Dilmah Change?
Slide Content:
Speaker Notes:
"Dilmah must adopt agile and transformational leadership, simplify management
systems, foster an innovative culture, diversify products, strengthen supply chains,
and lobby for government support. These changes are essential for recovery."
Title: Conclusion
Dilmah faces significant financial and strategic challenges
Competitors HVA Tea and Watawala Tea demonstrate strengths in export efficiency and
innovation
Leadership and management improvements can help Dilmah recover
Cultural changes are needed to foster innovation and adaptability
Strategic interventions can convert negative outcomes into positive ones
Speaker Notes:
"In conclusion, Dilmah faces serious financial and strategic challenges. HVA Tea and
Watawala Tea excel in efficiency and innovation. Improving leadership, management,
and culture, alongside strategic interventions, can help Dilmah recover and thrive."
Speaker Notes:
"Thank you for listening. I hope this presentation offered valuable insights into
Dilmah’s challenges and solutions. I’m ready to answer your questions."
PAGE 48: Template Editing Instructions
and Feedback
Slide Content:
o Use a consistent font (e.g., Calibri, 24pt for headings, 18pt for body)
o Include visuals (e.g., charts, images of tea products) to enhance engagement
o Ensure slide transitions are smooth and professional
Feedback:
Speaker Notes:
"For the final presentation, use a consistent font like Calibri, 24pt for headings and
18pt for body text. Add visuals like charts and tea product images, and ensure smooth
transitions. Feedback suggests more visuals for financial and comparison slides, less
text on strategic analysis, and a summary slide before the conclusion for clarity."
PAGE 2: Agenda
PAGE 44: Dilmah Can Learn from HVA Tea & Watawala Tea