FIRST AFFIRMATIVE SPEAKER
INTRODUCTION
Good Afternoon Mr/Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen. The topic of our debate is
“That This House Regrets the Rise of VTubing”
We define the topic as a practice of creating virtual personas or simply said as a used of
animation avatar to stream and entertain audiences online. VTubing or Virtual YouTubing
has witnessed an unprecedented rise in popularity, captivating millions of viewers worldwide
and the rise of it came with the negative consequences. We the affirmative team believe that
this statement is true.
TEAM SPLIT
Today as first speaker I will be talking to you about Vtubing blurs the line between reality
and virtual personas and the rise of Vtubing sustains unrealistic beauty standards and body
image issues.
Our second speaker will be talking about VTubing is detrimental to the job market and
Vtubing can have a negative impact on content creators themselves.
Our third speaker will rebut and sum up our team case.
ARGUMENTS
I am going to discuss the first point. My first point is about Vtubing blurs the line between
reality and virtual personas. This is because this anonymity destroys authenticity and genuine
human connection that traditional YouTubers provide. It is essential to recognize the impact
of this shift on our society, where real-life interactions are already being overshadowed by
the virtual world. VTubing perpetuates the idea that it's acceptable to hide behind a mask,
inhibiting true self-expression and fostering a lack of accountability.
Now to my second point is about Vtubing sustain unrealistic beauty standards and body
image issues. Many virtual avatars represent idealized versions of appearance, creating
unattainable beauty expectations. This can harm the self-esteem of individuals, particularly
young viewers who may strive for an unattainable physical ideal.
ENDING
So Mr/Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen, in conclusion, Vtubing is just like a ‘wolf
in sheep’s clothing’. We may think it is good for us, but it is actually harmful. With that,
thank you.
SECOND AFFIRMATIVE SPEAKER
INTRODUCTION
Good Afternoon Mr/Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen. The topic of our debate is
“That This House Regrets the Rise of VTubing”
We define the topic as a practice of creating virtual personas or simply said as a used of
animation avatar to stream and entertain audiences online. VTubing or Virtual YouTubing
has witnessed an unprecedented rise in popularity, captivating millions of viewers worldwide
and the rise of it came with the negative consequences. We the affirmative team believe that
this statement is true.
REBUTTAL
The first speaker from the negative team has tried to tell you
This is wrong because …
S/he has also said that …
This is wrong because …
RECAP
Our first speaker has already explained about Vtubing blurs the line between reality and
virtual personas and the rise of Vtubing perpetuates unrealistic beauty standards and body
image issues.
ARGUMENTS
Today I will be talking to you about my points. My first point is VTubing is detrimental to
the job market. This is because as more individuals turn to VTubing, they divert their
attention and talent away from real-world jobs and contribute to an already saturated online
content industry. This can lead to economic instability and increased competition among
creators, making it even harder for talented individuals to earn a living. We must question
whether the popularity of VTubing is worth the potential economic and societal repercussions
it brings.
Now to my second point, Vtubing can have a negative impact on content creators themselves.
The reasons for this is by hiding behind virtual avatars, they can avoid accountability for their
actions and statements. This anonymity can enable toxic behaviour and harassment.
Moreover, it undermines the authenticity of content creation, as creators are disconnected
from their true identities. When content creators adopt virtual avatars, they create a separation
between their real selves and their online personas. While this can provide a sense of
anonymity, it can also lead to a disconnection from their true identity. This disconnection can
result in difficulty in maintaining a genuine and authentic presence online, potentially leading
to feelings of isolation or a loss of self.
ENDING
So Mr/ Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen, in conclusion VTubing has unleashed a
'Digital jobocalypse,' where traditional content creation jobs are replaced by virtual avatars”
and "The rise of VTubing has transformed content creators into 'Virtual content clones,'
diluting the uniqueness and originality of online entertainment. Thank you.
THIRD AFFIRMATIVE SPEAKER
INTRODUCTION
1. Good Afternoon Mr/Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen. The topic of our debate is
“That This House Regrets the Rise of VTubing”
We define the topic as a practice of creating virtual personas or simply said as a used of
animation avatar to stream and entertain audiences online. VTubing or Virtual YouTubing
has witnessed an unprecedented rise in popularity, captivating millions of viewers worldwide
and the rise of it came with the negative consequences. We the affirmative team believe that
this statement is true.
REBUTTAL
4. The first negative speaker has tried to tell you…
5. This is wrong because…
6. The second negative speaker has tried to tell you…
7. This is wrong because…
SUMMARY
8. Our first speaker spoke to you about Vtubing blurs the line between reality and virtual
personas. I do agree with her/his point because the blurring of reality occurs as the audience
becomes accustomed to engaging with the virtual avatar rather than the actual person behind
it. The viewers' perception of the content creator is shaped primarily by the characteristics,
appearance, and behaviours of the avatar, rather than the genuine traits of the individual
operating it. This can lead to a disconnection between the person's true self and the persona
they project online.
9. S/he also spoke about Vtubing perpetuates unrealistic beauty standards and body image
issues. This point is legit because these avatars are meticulously designed to embody a
particular aesthetic, which can include flawless skin, perfect proportions, vibrant hair colours,
and exaggerated features such as large eyes or exaggerated expressions. As viewers engage
with these virtual avatars, they may internalize these idealized images as the standard of
beauty. This can lead to individuals, particularly young viewers, developing unrealistic
expectations about their own appearance and body image.
10. Our second speaker told you that VTubing is detrimental to the job market. I do agree
with this point because the focus on VTubing as a career choice may lead to a devaluation of
other skills and professions. As more people shift their attention and aspirations towards
becoming VTubers, there is a potential decline in individuals pursuing careers in other
industries. This can lead to a lack of diversity and expertise in various fields, causing a
negative impact on the overall job market.
11. S/he also said that Vtubing can have a negative impact on content creators themselves.
This point cannot be denied because by hiding behind virtual avatars, creators can detach
themselves from their real identities, leading to a potential erosion of responsibility for their
actions and statements. This anonymity can enable toxic behaviour and harassment, as
individuals may feel emboldened to engage in harmful actions without facing the same
consequences they would in real-life interactions.
ENDING
So Mr/Madam Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen, in conclusion, the rise of VTubing blurs
reality, perpetuates unrealistic beauty standards, detrimentally affects the job market, and has
a negative impact on content creators. Considering these factors, it is clear that regretting the
rise of VTubing is justified. Society must be mindful of the consequences and promote a
responsible approach to online content creation. Thank you.