I'll now begin generating **Unit 1** of your comprehensive exam-ready notes.

Based on my
analysis, your existing notes contain excellent coverage of insurable interest principles, utmost
good faith, indemnity, subrogation, contribution, risk elements, and related topics. However, the
syllabus requires additional content on:

1. **Nature and definition of insurance** (needs more foundational material)

2. **History of Insurance business in India** (completely absent)
3. **Regulation of Insurance business** (minimal coverage)
4. **IRDA—Function and powers** (partial coverage in notes)
5. **Premium** (absent)
6. **Proximate cause** (absent)

I will now present Unit 1 with all existing content preserved verbatim, supplemented with new
material for gaps.

***

# **UNIT 1: NATURE AND DEFINITION OF INSURANCE, IRDA, AND GENERAL

PRINCIPLES**

## **1.1 NATURE AND DEFINITION OF INSURANCE**

### **Definition of Insurance**

An insurance contract is a legal agreement under which one party (the insurer) accepts
significant insurance risk from another party (the policyholder) by agreeing to compensate the
policyholder if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the
policyholder. Insurance is fundamentally a contract whereby the insurer undertakes to indemnify
the assured, in the manner and to the extent agreed upon, against losses incidental to the
insured risk.[1][2]

**Statutory Definition:** Under **Section 2(7) of the Insurance Act, 1938**, "insurance business"
is defined as any business connected with:
- Life insurance business
- General insurance business
- Reinsurance business

An insurance contract must satisfy all essentials of a valid contract under the **Indian Contract
Act, 1872**, including offer and acceptance, lawful consideration (premium), capacity to
contract, free consent, and lawful object.[3][4]

### **Nature and Characteristics of Insurance Contracts**

**1. Contractual Nature:** Insurance is always a written contract between the insurer and the
insured. The policyholder makes an offer through a proposal form, and the insurer accepts by
issuing a policy document.[2][1]

**2. Consideration:** Like all contracts, insurance requires lawful consideration. The
consideration is the **premium** that the insured agrees to pay to the insurer in exchange for
the promise of indemnity or payment upon occurrence of the insured event.[1][2]

**3. Co-operative Device:** Insurance operates on the principle "all for one and one for all." It is
a system wherein a large number of persons exposed to similar risks are covered, and the risk
is spread over the larger insurable public. The losses of one are borne by the collective society.
[2][1]

**4. Risk Transfer Mechanism:** Insurance is a mechanism for risk distribution and sharing. The
insured transfers the financial consequences of risk to the insurer, who pools similar risks
across many insureds and uses actuarial principles to distribute losses.[5][1]

**5. Conditional Contract:** Insurance contracts are subject to conditions and privileges
provided in the policy. The conditions—whether precedent or subsequent—must be fulfilled to
complete the contract and trigger the insurer's liability.[1]

**6. Aleatory Contract:** Insurance is an aleatory contract where no mutual exchange of equal
monetary value occurs. Payment depends on the happening of a contingent event, which is a
matter of chance. If death or loss occurs after payment of only a few premiums, the full sum
assured is still payable.[1]

**7. Contract of Adhesion:** The terms of an insurance contract are not arrived at by mutual
negotiation. The contract is prepared entirely by the insurer, and the insured must either accept
or reject the policy as offered.[1]

**8. Standard Form Contract:** Insurance policies are standardized documents that must
contain all essentials of a general contract as provided by the Indian Contract Act, 1872.[1]

### **Types of Insurance Business**

Insurance business in India is classified into three broad categories under the Insurance Act,
1938:

**1. Life Insurance:** Provides coverage for human life, promising payment of a sum assured
upon death or maturity of the policy.[3][1]

**2. General (Non-Life) Insurance:** Covers risks such as fire, marine, motor vehicles, health,
property damage, and liability.[3]
**3. Reinsurance:** Insurance purchased by insurance companies to limit their exposure by
transferring part of the risk to another insurer.[6]

***

## **1.2 HISTORY OF INSURANCE BUSINESS IN INDIA**

### **Early Development (Pre-Independence)**

The insurance industry in India has a long history spanning over 150 years. The earliest
evidence of insurance business dates back to the establishment of the **Oriental Life Insurance
Company** in Calcutta in 1818, which was the first life insurance company in India. The industry
grew gradually during British rule with both Indian and foreign insurance companies operating in
the market.[7][8][9]

By the early 20th century, numerous private insurance companies—both Indian and foreign—
were conducting business in India. However, the sector suffered from issues including
undercapitalization, insolvencies, and lack of consumer protection. Between 1950-1954 alone,
43 life insurance offices exited the business due to valuation deficits and inability to meet claims
on matured policies.[7]

### **Regulation Before Nationalisation**

To address the problems in the insurance sector, the government enacted the **Insurance Act,
1938** to consolidate and amend the law relating to insurance business. The Act established
regulatory requirements for capital, solvency margins, investment norms, and registration of
insurers.[10][11]

In 1950, an Amendment Act was passed that necessitated reorganization and imposed controls
on expenses, leading to further exits from the market.[7]

### **Nationalisation of Life Insurance (1956)**

Following independence, concerns grew about the misuse of policyholders' funds and the
inefficiency of private insurance companies. In 1956, parliamentarian **Feroze Gandhi** raised
the matter of insurance fraud by owners of private insurance agencies in Parliament. In the
ensuing investigations, major business figures were prosecuted for insurance-related offenses.
[12]

On **January 19, 1956**, life insurance business in India was completely nationalised through
the enactment of the **Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956 (Act No. 31 of 1956)**. The Act
provided for:[13][14][12]

- **Nationalisation** of all life insurance business by transferring it to a corporation

- Establishment of the **Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC)** on **September 1, 1956**
- Regulation and control of life insurance business by the Corporation
- Transfer of all existing life insurance businesses to LIC[14][15]

**Statutory Provision:** **Section 1 of the Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956** states: "An Act
to provide for the nationalisation of life insurance business in India by transferring all such
business to a Corporation established for the purpose and to provide for the regulation and
control of the business of the Corporation".[14]

The stated objectives of nationalisation included:

1. Mobilisation of people's savings for economic development
2. Prevention of misuse of policyholders' funds
3. Preventing concentration of wealth
4. Ensuring better service to policyholders
5. Spreading insurance coverage to rural and social sectors[7]

### **Nationalisation of General Insurance (1972)**

Following the nationalisation of life insurance, the general insurance sector continued with
private players until 1972. Prior to 1973, there were **107 companies**, including foreign
companies, offering general insurance in India.[8]

The **General Insurance Business (Emergency Provisions) Act, 1971** first provided for taking
over the management of general insurance companies. This was followed by comprehensive
nationalisation.[16]

On **January 1, 1973**, the entire general insurance business in India was nationalised through
the **General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Act, 1972 (Act No. 57 of 1972)**.[9][17][18]
[16]

**Statutory Provision:** The Long Title of the Act states: "An Act to provide for the acquisition
and transfer of shares of Indian insurance companies and undertakings of other existing
insurers in order to serve better the needs of the economy by securing the development of
general insurance business in the best interests of the community and to ensure that the
operation of the economic system does not result in the concentration of wealth to the common
detriment".[18][19]

Under this Act:

- The **General Insurance Corporation (GIC)** was established in November 1972 to
superintend, control, and carry on general insurance business[17][8]
- All 107 private general insurance companies were amalgamated and grouped into **four
subsidiary companies** of GIC:
1. National Insurance Company Ltd.
2. New India Assurance Company Ltd.
 3. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
4. United India Insurance Company Ltd.[8][17]
- GIC undertook mainly reinsurance and aviation insurance, while the four subsidiaries handled
fire, marine, motor, and miscellaneous insurance[8]

### **Liberalisation and Opening of the Sector (1990s-2000s)**

The insurance sector remained under complete government control from 1956/1973 until the
economic liberalization of the 1990s. During this period, state-owned companies functioned with
bureaucratic inefficiency, but consumers had no alternatives.[7]

In **2000**, the government ended GIC's supervisory role over its four subsidiaries through
administrative instruction. The **General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Amendment Act,
2002** further provided that:[17]
- GIC ceased to be a holding company
- Ownership of the four companies and GIC was vested with the Government of India
- The Central Government must maintain **at least 51% shareholding** in general insurance
companies[16][17]

The **Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority Act, 1999** was enacted to allow
private sector participation while maintaining regulatory oversight. This ushered in the modern
era of insurance regulation in India.[20]

***

## **1.3 REGULATION OF INSURANCE BUSINESS—IRDA**

### **Establishment and Incorporation of IRDA**

The **Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI)**, commonly known as
IRDA, is the supreme statutory authority that regulates the insurance business in India.[21][22]

**Statutory Provision—Section 3 of the IRDA Act, 1999:** "The Central Government may by
notification appoint and establish for the purpose of this Act an Authority to be called the
'Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority'".[20][1]

Once established, the IRDAI is incorporated as a **statutory body corporate** with the following
features:[1]

1. **Perpetual Succession:** The Authority exists continuously and does not cease with
changes in its membership
2. **Common Seal:** It has an official seal to authenticate documents and contracts
3. **Acquire, Hold, and Dispose of Property:** It can own both movable and immovable property
4. **Enter into Contracts:** It can legally contract in its own name
5. **Sue or Be Sued:** It operates as a juristic person and can initiate or defend legal
proceedings[1]

### **Objectives of the IRDA Act, 1999**

The Act has four primary objectives:[6][1]

**Objective I:** To protect the interest of and secure fair treatment to policyholders

**Objective II:** To bring about speedy and orderly growth of the insurance industry

**Objective III:** To ensure speedy settlement of genuine claims and prevent insurance frauds
and other malpractices

**Objective IV:** To promote fairness, transparency, and orderly conduct in financial markets
dealing with insurance

### **Composition of IRDA (Section 4)**

The Authority consists of a **maximum of ten members**, all appointed by the Central
Government:[6][1]

1. **A Chairperson:** Chief executive and head of the Authority

2. **Not More Than Five Whole-Time Members:** Responsible for day-to-day executive and
regulatory functions
3. **Not More Than Four Part-Time Members:** Provide guidance and expertise[1]

**Qualification Requirement:** The Central Government appoints individuals who have shown
knowledge or experience in:
- Life Insurance
- General Insurance (fire, marine, accident)
- Finance
- Other relevant professional disciplines[1]

This composition ensures the IRDAI possesses necessary expertise and dedicated leadership
to regulate the insurance sector effectively.[1]

### **Tenure of Office (Section 5)**

**1. Term of Office:**

- Chairperson and Whole-Time Members: **Five years**
- Part-Time Members: **Not exceeding five years**[1]

**2. Age Limit:**

- Chairperson: **65 years**
- Whole-Time Members: **62 years**[1]

**3. Resignation:** A member may resign by giving notice to the Central Government, typically
**not less than three months**, or until a successor is appointed.[1]

**4. Removal:** Under Section 6, members may be removed by the Central Government if they:
[1]

### **Removal from Office (Section 6)**

Members may be removed if they:[1]

1. Are adjudged as an **insolvent** (legally bankrupt)

2. Become **physically or mentally incapable** of carrying out duties
3. Are **convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude** (fraud, deceit)
4. Have acquired a **conflict of interest** affecting their regulatory function
5. Have **abused their position** rendering continuance detrimental to public interest[1]

### **Administrative Provisions**

**Salary and Allowances (Section 7):** Prescribed by the Central Government.[1]

**Bar on Future Employment (Section 8):** The Chairperson and whole-time members shall not,
for a period of **two years** from ceasing to hold office, accept:
1. Any employment under Central or State Government
2. Any appointment in any company in the insurance sector
(except with prior approval of Central Government)[1]

**Administrative Powers of Chairperson (Section 9):** The Chairperson has powers of general
superintendence and direction in respect of all administrative matters of the Authority.[1]

**Meetings of Authority (Section 10):**

- The Authority shall meet at such times and places as determined by regulation
- If the Chairperson is unable to attend, meetings proceed as per regulations
- All questions are decided by **majority of votes**[1]

***

## **1.4 DUTIES, POWERS AND FUNCTIONS OF IRDA (SECTION 14)**

**Section 14 of the IRDA Act, 1999** lays down comprehensive duties, powers, and functions of
the Authority.[23][21][6][1]
### **Primary Duty**

**Section 14(1):** The Authority has the duty to **regulate, promote and ensure orderly growth**
of the insurance business and re-insurance business, subject to provisions of the Act and any
other law.[23][6]

### **Specific Powers and Functions**

**A. Registration of Insurers:** Issue to applicants a certificate of registration; renew, modify,

withdraw, suspend, or cancel such registration.[21][6][1]

**B. Protection of Policyholders' Interests:** Protect interests of policyholders in matters

concerning:
- Assignment of policy
- Nomination by policyholders
- Insurable interest
- Settlement of insurance claims
- Surrender value of policy
- Other terms and conditions of insurance contracts[21][6][1]

**C. Regulation of Intermediaries:** Specify requisite qualifications, code of conduct, and

practical training for agents, intermediaries, and insurance intermediaries.[6][21][1]

**D. Regulation of Surveyors and Loss Assessors:** Specify code of conduct for surveyors and
loss assessors.[6][1]

**E. Promoting Efficiency:** Promote efficiency in the conduct of insurance business.[21][6][1]

**F. Regulation of Professional Organizations:** Promote and regulate professional

organizations connected with insurance and reinsurance business.[21][6][1]

**G. Levy of Fees and Charges:** Levy fees and other charges for carrying out purposes of the
Act.[6][1]

**H. Information and Investigation Powers:** Call for information from, undertake inspection of,
conduct enquiries and investigations including **audit** of insurers, intermediaries, and other
organizations connected with insurance business.[21][6][1]

**I. Control of Rates and Terms (General Insurance):** Control and regulation of rates,
advantages, terms, and conditions offered by insurers in respect of general insurance business
not controlled by the Tariff Advisory Committee under **Section 64U of the Insurance Act,
1938**.[23][6][1]
**J. Accounting Standards:** Specify form and manner in which books of account shall be
maintained and statements of accounts rendered by insurers and intermediaries.[6][21][1]

**K. Regulation of Investments:** Regulate investment of funds by insurance companies.[21][6]

[1]

**L. Solvency Margin:** Regulate maintenance of margin of solvency.[6][1]

**M. Adjudication of Disputes:** Adjudicate disputes between insurers and intermediaries or

insurance intermediaries.[21][6][1]

**N. Supervision of Tariff Advisory Committee:** Supervise the functioning of the Tariff Advisory
Committee.[23][6][1]

**O. Financing Professional Organizations:** Specify the percentage of premium income of the
insurer to finance schemes for promoting or regulating professional organizations.[6][1]

**P. Rural and Social Sector Obligations:** Specify the percentage of life insurance business
and general insurance business to be undertaken by insurers in the **rural or social sector**.
[21][6][1]

**Q. Capital Structure Compliance:** Ensure compliance of requirements as to capital structure

of companies and solvency margin, insurance business in rural and social sectors, submission
of returns/reports, approval and preparation of schemes of amalgamation and transfer of
insurance business.[6]

**R. Control Over Management:** Exercise control over management of insurers.[21][6]

**S. Search and Seizure:** Powers of search and seizure for protection of policyholders'
interests.[6]

**T. Frame Regulations:** Frame regulations to carry out purposes of the Insurance Act, 1938.
[23][6]

**Illustration:** When the IRDAI specifies that life insurers must allocate at least 20% of their
policies issued in a year to the rural sector, it exercises its power under Section 14(P) to
promote social welfare objectives while ensuring orderly growth of the industry.[21]

***

## **1.5 GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF INSURANCE LAW**

### **1.5.1 Principle of Insurable Interest**

**Insurable interest** is a foundational principle of insurance that states a policyholder must
have a legitimate financial or emotional stake in the subject of the insurance (a person or
property). This means the policyholder would suffer a genuine **loss** if the insured event
occurs, preventing the policy from becoming a speculative wager or a tool for profit or fraud.[1]

-According to **Patterson** insurable interest is a relation between the insured and the event
insured against so that occurrence of the event would result in substantial loss or injury of some
kind to the insured.[1]

-**Rodda** interpreted it as an interest of such nature that the occurrence of the event insured
against would cause financial loss to the insured.[1]

**Characteristics of Insurable Interest**[1]

1. There must be some subject-matter to insure, namely, the life of a person, property like
house, vehicle etc.

2. The insured must have some legally recognized relationship with the subject matter of the
insurance

3. The insured must be benefited by the safety of the subject-matter and suffers loss if the
subject-matter is lost, damaged or destroyed

4. The subject-matter should be definite and it should be capable of being valued in terms of
money

**Insurable Interest in Life Insurance**

For life insurance, insurable interest must exist at the time the policy is taken out (not
necessarily at the time of death) and is based on either a close blood/family relationship or a
financial relationship where the policy owner would suffer a financial hardship upon the
insured's death.[1]

**One's Own Life:** Everyone is presumed to have an **unlimited insurable interest** in their
own life. This allows an individual to purchase a policy on themselves and name anyone as the
beneficiary, though the insurer may still require the beneficiary to have an interest in the
insured.[1]

**Husband and Wife:** Spouses are automatically considered to have an insurable interest in
each other, based on both the **emotional bond** and the **mutual financial dependency**. The
loss of a partner would undoubtedly cause financial hardship to the survivor.[1]

**Parents and Children:** Parents have an insurable interest in the lives of their **minor
children** (to cover unexpected costs like funeral expenses), and conversely, **adult children**
typically have an insurable interest in their parents (to cover final expenses or loss of financial
support). The interest is primarily financial but often includes a strong emotional component.[1]

**Creditor and Debtor:** A **creditor** (the lender) has an insurable interest in the life of their
**debtor** (the borrower), but only **up to the amount of the outstanding debt**. This policy
ensures the creditor can recover the loan balance if the debtor dies before repayment is
complete.[1]

**Insurable Interest in Property Insurance**

For property insurance (like fire, auto, or home), insurable interest must exist both at the **time
the policy is purchased** and at the **time the loss occurs** (Principle of Indemnity). The
interest is almost always measured by the **financial loss** suffered.[1]

**Agent:** An agent may have an insurable interest in their **own goods** that are mixed with
the principal's goods, or if they are responsible for the goods under a contract.[1]

**Bailee:** A bailee is someone who holds property belonging to others (a bailor), such as a
**dry cleaner**, a **storage facility**, or a **repair shop**. The bailee has an insurable interest to
the extent of their **legal liability** to the owner for damage or loss, or to protect their own
service/repair charges.[1]

**Vendor and Vendee (Seller and Buyer):**

The **vendor** retains an insurable interest in the property **until the sale is fully completed**
(e.g., until the deed is transferred and money is paid). The **vendee** (buyer) obtains an
insurable interest **as soon as they sign a binding purchase agreement**, even if they haven't
taken possession yet, because they are obligated to complete the purchase or suffer a loss of
their down payment.[1]

**Mortgagor and Mortgagee:**

The **mortgagor** (homeowner/borrower) has an insurable interest because they are the
**owner** and would lose their equity if the property is destroyed.

The **mortgagee** (lender/bank) has an insurable interest **up to the amount of the outstanding
loan balance**. They require the homeowner to carry insurance to protect their investment.[1]

**Landlord and Tenant (Lessor and Lessee):**

The **landlord** (lessor) has an insurable interest in the **entire property structure** because
they own it.
The **tenant** (lessee) has an insurable interest in their **personal property** (contents) and
potentially in any **improvements** they made to the structure, or in the continued **use** of the
premises.[1]

***

### **1.5.2 Principle of Utmost Good Faith (*Uberrimae Fidei*)**

- The person getting insured must willingly disclose and surrender to the insurer his complete
true information regarding the subject matter of insurance.[1]

- If the assured fails to make such disclosure, the insurer may avoid the contract.[1]

- The reason being that important facts having or bearing on the contract are known only to the
insured.[1]

- E.g. how many times he claimed under fire or burglary policy, how many times he has fallen ill
etc.[1]

- If he conceals anything which he knows to be material it is fraud.[1]

**Following need not be disclosed:**[1]

i. Any circumstances which diminishes the risk

ii. Any circumstances which is known or presumed to be known to the insurer

iii. Any circumstances as to which information is waived by the insurer

iv. Any circumstances which is superfluous to disclose by reason of any express or implied
warranty

- Alteration in disclosed facts has to be done before acceptance.[1]

A **material fact in insurance** is any critical information that would reasonably influence an
insurer's decision to accept a risk, set the policy's terms, or calculate the premium. Non-
disclosure or misrepresentation of these facts can void the policy.[1]

**Material Facts in Life Insurance**

The material facts for Life Insurance will directly affect the insured person's mortality risk:[1]

**Age** is material because it is the primary factor used to calculate the applicant's life
expectancy and determine the basic premium rate.[1]
**Disease/Health** is crucial; any condition that shortens life or requires ongoing medical
attention is an important risk factor that must be disclosed.[1]

**Habits** such as smoking, excessive alcohol use, or drug use increase health risks
significantly, which leads to a higher premium to cover the increased hazard.[1]

**Family History** is relevant for assessing potential hereditary risks, such as a family history of
genetic diseases or a pattern of short lifespans.[1]

**Place of Residence** matters if the location presents a heightened environmental risk, such as
areas with high pollution or a high incidence of a particular disease.[1]

An individual's **Profession** is also material, as hazardous occupations (like construction or

mining) increase the risk of accidental death or injury, impacting the premium.[1]

**Statutory Provision—Section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938:** "Policy not to be called in

question on ground of mis-statement after two years". This provision protects policyholders from
policy repudiation after two years from the date of commencement of the policy, except in cases
of fraud.[10]

***

### **1.5.3 Principle of Indemnity**

- All insurance policies, except life policies and personal accident policies, are contracts of
indemnity.[1]

- This principle may be defined as "under the indemnity contract the insurer undertakes to
indemnify the insured against the loss suffered by the insured peril".[1]

- Literally, indemnity means "make good the loss".[1]

- The object of insurance is to place the insured as far as possible in the same financial position
in which he was before the happening of the insured peril.[1]

- The insured is not allowed to make any profit out of the happening of the event because the
object is only to indemnify him and profit making would be against the principle.[1]

**Illustration:** If a building valued at ₹10 lakhs is insured for ₹15 lakhs and suffers damage
worth ₹5 lakhs, the insurer will only pay ₹5 lakhs (actual loss), not the full sum insured of ₹15
lakhs. This ensures the insured is indemnified but does not profit.

***
### **1.5.4 Principle of Subrogation**

- Subrogation is the substitution of one person in place of another in relation to a claim, its
rights, remedies or securities.[1]

- Having satisfied the claim of the assured, the insurer stands in the place, and is subrogated to
all the rights of the insured.[1]

- In other words the subroggee steps into the shoes of the person whose rights are subrogated
to him.[1]

- "Subrogation is the transfer of rights and remedies of the insured to the insurer who has
indemnified the insured in respect of the loss".[1]

**Illustration:** If an insured's car is damaged due to the negligence of a third party, and the
insurer pays the claim of ₹2 lakhs to the insured, the insurer acquires the right to sue the
negligent third party to recover the ₹2 lakhs paid. This prevents the insured from collecting twice
—once from the insurer and once from the negligent party.

***

### **1.5.5 Principle of Contribution**

- Principle of Contribution is a corollary of the principle of indemnity.[1]

- According to this principle, the insured can claim the compensation only to the extent of actual
loss either from all insurers or from any one insurer.[1]

- If one insurer pays full compensation then that insurer can claim proportionate claim from the
other insurers.[1]

**Essential conditions of Contribution:**[1]

i. All the insurance must relate to the same subject-matter

ii. The policies concerned must all cover the same interest of the same insured

iii. The policies concerned must all cover the same peril which caused the loss

The principle of indemnity, subrogation, and contribution are not applicable in life insurance
because the value of a life of a person cannot be valued.[1]
**Illustration:** If a property worth ₹20 lakhs is insured with Insurer A for ₹15 lakhs and with
Insurer B for ₹10 lakhs, and a loss of ₹20 lakhs occurs, the insured can claim the full ₹20 lakhs.
If Insurer A pays the entire ₹20 lakhs, Insurer A can recover a proportionate amount ( ₹10
lakhs/₹25 lakhs × ₹20 lakhs = ₹8 lakhs) from Insurer B under the principle of contribution.

***

### **1.5.6 Principle of Loss Minimization**

- Insured must always try his level best to minimize the loss of his insured property.[1]

- The insured must take all possible measures and necessary steps to control and reduce the
losses in such a scenario.[1]

- The insured must not neglect and behave irresponsibly during such events just because the
property is insured.[1]

- Hence it is a responsibility of the insured to protect his insured property and avoid further
losses.[1]

**Illustration:** If a fire breaks out in an insured factory, the owner must immediately call the fire
brigade and attempt to extinguish the fire using available fire extinguishers. The owner cannot
simply watch the property burn, relying on insurance compensation. Failure to take reasonable
steps to minimize loss may result in reduction of the claim amount.

***

## **1.6 THE RISK UNDER INSURANCE CONTRACT**

### **Introduction**

Man is continuously exposed to risk. Life may stop suddenly with a massive heart attack. The
crop may be lost by nature. The house may unexpectedly catch fire.[1]

Understandably we wish to protect ourselves against such contingencies.[1]

A contract of insurance is a contract under which the insurer undertakes to protect the insured
from a specified loss if it occurs.[1]

The insured is afraid of loss which is called the risk of loss and the insurer undertakes to
indemnify him from the apprehended loss if it occurs for a consideration called the premium.[1]

The insurer calculates the premium according to the probability, nature and extent of risk from
which the insured desires to be protected.[1]
The insured must describe the risk which he wants.[1]

### **Elements of Risk**

Risk depends upon various elements of the event insured against in its happening sooner or
later.[1]

These circumstances must be described by the insured and the insurer generally calculates the
premium with reference to these elements.[1]

### **Risk in Life Insurance**

The factors are the fundamental elements of risk an insurer assesses to determine the potential
longevity of an applicant and, consequently, the cost of the life insurance policy.[1]

**Habits or Mode of Living:** This element concerns the applicant's routine lifestyle choices that
affect their health. Insurers are specifically concerned with habits such as smoking or any form
of tobacco use, excessive alcohol consumption, and drug use. These habits are material
because they significantly increase the statistical probability of developing serious illnesses (like
lung cancer, heart disease, or liver failure), leading to higher premiums.[1]

**Age:** Age is the most crucial demographic factor in life insurance risk. Underwriters use
actuarial science and mortality tables to determine the baseline risk of death at any given age.
As a person ages, their expected remaining lifespan decreases, and the risk to the insurer
increases, which is directly reflected in a higher premium.[1]

**Occupation:** This factor assesses the risks inherent in the applicant's job. Hazardous
occupations—such as those involving high altitudes (like pilots), deep water (like commercial
divers), dangerous machinery (like miners), or toxic materials—increase the risk of accidental
death or severe injury. Insurers categorize jobs into different risk classes to determine whether a
standard, higher-rated, or denied policy is appropriate.[1]

**Environment:** Environment relates to the physical surroundings that may impact the
applicant's health or safety. This includes living or working in areas with high levels of air or
water pollution, regions prone to natural disasters (like floods or earthquakes), or countries
experiencing political instability or war. These external factors can contribute to health issues or
increase the risk of accidental death.[1]

**Heredity:** Heredity involves examining the family medical history to identify genetic
predispositions to serious illness. Underwriters look for patterns of early-onset disease or death
among immediate family members (parents, siblings). A family history of conditions like heart
disease, certain cancers, or diabetes that manifested before a specific age (e.g., age 60) can
elevate the applicant's overall risk rating.[1]
**Previous Illness:** This refers to the applicant's complete personal medical history. Insurers
thoroughly review past and current health conditions, including major surgeries, chronic
diseases, or treatments for severe conditions like cancer or a heart attack. The risk assessment
depends on the nature of the illness, the success of treatment, and the time elapsed since
recovery, as this data helps predict the likelihood of recurrence or the development of related
complications.[1]

### **Elements of Risk in Property Insurance**

The factors are the critical **elements of risk** assessed by underwriters to determine the
probability and severity of a potential loss for a property, which dictates the insurance premium
and policy terms.[1]

**Nature of Property:** This element focuses on the inherent qualities of the asset being
insured, distinguishing between its classification and its basic composition. **Movable
property**, such as inventory or machinery, is vulnerable to risks like theft and transit damage.
**Non-movable property**, like buildings, is primarily exposed to site-specific perils. The
classification of property as **perishable** (e.g., food, pharmaceuticals) introduces a high risk of
loss due to spoilage, temperature failure, or time itself, often requiring specific policy
endorsements. Crucially, the **construction materials** of a building are evaluated; a structure
built with fire-resistant materials (steel, masonry) is a significantly lower fire risk than one made
of wood, and is priced accordingly.[1]

**Area and Situation or Locality:** These two elements pertain to the external environmental
and geographical hazards surrounding the property. **Area** refers to the broader, macro-level
geographic risks. Underwriters assess if the property is located in a **flood zone, earthquake-
prone region, or a high-risk wildfire area**, as these conditions increase the likelihood of a
catastrophic loss. The **Situation or Locality** considers the immediate vicinity. This includes
the proximity of the property to **emergency services** (such as a fire station or fire hydrant),
which can mitigate loss severity and lower premiums. Conversely, being situated next to an
**external exposure** like a chemical plant or a flammable storage facility significantly raises the
risk profile. Local **crime rates** are also analyzed here, as they directly impact the risk of theft
and vandalism.[1]

**Use and Habits of the Assured:** This factor evaluates the activity taking place on the
property, known as **occupancy**, and the insured's management of that property. The **use**
of a building determines the kind of internal hazards present; for instance, a residential dwelling
is safer than a commercial manufacturing plant with heat, machinery, and production waste. The
**habits of the assured** refer to the owner's commitment to loss control and **maintenance**.
A property with deferred maintenance, obsolete electrical systems, or improperly stored
combustibles is considered a much higher risk due to the increased probability of internal failure
or fire.[1]
**Inherent Defect:** An **inherent defect** is a fault or characteristic within the property itself
that causes it to damage or destroy itself without the action of any external peril. This risk is
typically **uninsurable** and **excluded** from standard property policies because the loss is
considered inevitable, not accidental. Examples include items that spontaneously combust due
to internal chemical instability or materials that naturally decay, rust, or spoil over time. While
the loss itself is usually excluded, underwriters must still be aware of the potential for such
defects to cause a wider loss (e.g., a spontaneous combustion causing a building fire).[1]

### **Elements of Risk in Marine Insurance**

Marine insurance risk assessment is a specialized evaluation focusing on two main categories
of risk: the inherent characteristics of the property and the environmental/political perils it faces
during transit.[1]

**1. Voyage and Nature (Subject Matter):** This element establishes the basic risk profile by
defining the **duration of the exposure** and the **vulnerability of the item being** insured. The
**Voyage** dictates the operational period of the policy, which can be for a single, specific
journey (a **Voyage Policy**) or for a fixed period (a **Time Policy**). The longer or more
complex the commitment, the higher the risk exposure. The **Nature** of the subject matter
refers to its inherent physical properties. For **cargo**, underwriters assess if the goods are
fragile, perishable, or hazardous, as these qualities increase the chance of loss even without a
major external event. For the **vessel (hull)**, the primary concern is its **seaworthiness**,
which includes the ship's age, construction materials, and overall maintenance condition. An
older or poorly maintained ship carries a much higher risk of mechanical failure or structural
damage, irrespective of external conditions.[1]

**2. Route of Voyage and 3. The Winds and Storm in the Locality (Perils of the Sea):** These
factors are fundamentally linked, as they define the **geographical and environmental hazards**
that constitute the classic **Perils of the Sea**. The **Route of Voyage** is the contracted path
the vessel must follow; any deviation from this route, unless justified by safety, can void the
insurance policy. Underwriters assess this route for permanent dangers, such as areas with
high traffic congestion (increasing collision risk), narrow channels, or historically challenging
navigational areas. This evaluation is immediately cross-referenced with **The Winds and
Storm in the Locality**. This is the key natural hazard, where underwriters analyze seasonal
data to determine the probability of encountering major perils like **hurricanes, typhoons, or
severe winter storms**. Sailing a route through a known high-risk weather area during peak
storm season drastically increases the premium due to the greater likelihood of damage,
capsizing, or cargo loss overboard. Modern risk management actively uses **weather routing**
to mitigate this exposure.[1]

**4. Pirates, Danger of War, Capture (Extraneous Perils):** These elements represent the
**political and deliberate human perils**, which are generally referred to as **War and Strikes
Risks**. These risks are universally considered **excluded** from standard marine insurance
policies due to their catastrophic and systemic nature. Coverage for them must be purchased
separately, often under a specialized **War Risks Insurance policy**. **Piracy** involves the
violent seizure of a ship or cargo for ransom or theft, with insurers focusing on the vessel's
journey through known **piracy hot-spots** like the Gulf of Aden. The **Danger of War and
Capture** refers to the risks of a vessel or cargo being damaged, seized, or detained due to
international conflict, political instability, or the actions of a hostile government. These are
volatile, non-accidental events requiring specialized underwriting and significant premium
loading.[1]

***

## **1.7 COMMENCEMENT, DURATION AND TERMINATION OF RISK**

### **Introduction**

Man is continuously exposed to risk. Life may stop suddenly with a massive heart attack. The
crop may be lost by nature. The house may unexpectedly catch fire.[1]

Understandably we wish to protect ourselves against such contingencies.[1]

A contract of insurance is a contract under which the insurer undertakes to protect the insured
from a specified loss if it occurs.[1]

The insured is afraid of loss which is called the risk of loss and the insurer undertakes to
indemnify him from the apprehended loss if it occurs for a consideration called the premium.[1]

The insurer calculates the premium according to the probability, nature and extent of risk.[1]

The insured must describe the risk which he wants.[1]

### **Commencement of Risk**

Risk commences when a legally binding contract comes into existence.[1]

The issue of the policy by the company itself shows that the risk has commenced; payment of
premium is not that material.[1]

Usually the company issues a risk note, known as a **cover note**, after receiving the proposal
form from the assured.[1]

In life policies, there is a limitation that the risk will not attach till the first premium is paid.[1]

Mere payment of premium to the agent doesn't amount to a concluded contract, unless a cover
note or an insurance policy is issued by the company.[1]
### **Alteration of Risk**

The insurer accepts the proposal of insurance on the assumption that there has been no
material change in the risk between the date of proposal and the date of its acceptance.[1]

Any material change in the risk between these dates exempts the insurer from liability.[1]

The insured may under the policy have the right to alter the risk but he has to give due notice to
the company.[1]

The insurer usually demands higher premium if the assured wants to alter the risk.[1]

### **Duration of Risk**

A contract of insurance is incomplete till the duration of the policy is specified.[1]

If the period is not mentioned in so many words, the duration of the policy may be inferred from
general usage.[1]

For instance, the period of insurance in general insurance i.e. Fire, burglary, accident insurance
is one year.[1]

The period of insurance may also be inferred from the previous contracts of insurance between
the parties.[1]

If the policy is expressed to be in force till a specified date, the risk continues till the end of that
day.[1]

Similarly if the policy is to be renewed on a particular date, it cannot be said that the policy
would not be in force for the whole of that day.[1]

### **Termination of Risk**

A contract of insurance is incomplete till the duration of the policy is specified.[1]

If the period is not mentioned in so many words, the duration of the policy may be inferred from
general usage.[1]

***

## **1.8 THE PREMIUM**

### **Definition and Nature**

**Premium** is the consideration paid by the insured to the insurer in exchange for the insurer's
promise to indemnify or pay upon occurrence of the insured event. It is the price of insurance
coverage.[2][1]

Premium is an essential element of every insurance contract. Without payment or agreement to

pay premium, no valid insurance contract can come into existence. Under the **Indian Contract
Act, 1872**, consideration is a mandatory requirement for a valid contract.

### **Determination of Premium**

The insurer calculates the premium according to:

1. The **probability** of occurrence of the insured event
2. The **nature** of the risk
3. The **extent** of the risk from which the insured desires protection[1]

Premium calculation is based on **actuarial principles** and **mortality tables** (in life
insurance) or **loss experience** and statistical data (in general insurance).

### **Premium in Different Types of Insurance**

**Life Insurance:** Premium rates are determined primarily by:

- Age of the insured
- Health status and medical history
- Occupation and lifestyle habits
- Type of policy (term, whole life, endowment)
- Sum assured
- Policy term[1]

**General Insurance (Fire, Marine, Motor):** Premium depends on:

- Nature and value of property
- Location and exposure to risk
- Previous loss experience
- Type of coverage required
- Deductibles and policy limits[1]

### **Payment of Premium**

**Mode of Payment:** Premium may be paid:

- As a single premium (one-time payment)
- As regular periodic premiums (monthly, quarterly, half-yearly, annually)
- As limited payment premiums (paid for a specified number of years)[1]

**Consequence of Non-Payment:** If premium is not paid:

- In life insurance, the policy may lapse after the grace period (usually 30 days)
- In general insurance, the policy terminates, and no coverage exists from the due date of
unpaid premium
- The insurer is discharged from liability if premium is not paid when due

**Statutory Provision—Section 64VB of the Insurance Act, 1938:** This section deals with
rebates and discounts on premiums, ensuring that only authorized reductions are permitted.[10]

### **Return of Premium**

Premium may be returned in certain circumstances:

- If the risk never commenced
- If the policy is cancelled before the risk attaches
- If there is a breach of warranty by the insured that voids the policy *ab initio*
- In case of double insurance, proportionate premium may be recovered
- Where premium is paid under mistake of fact

**Illustration:** If an insured pays an annual premium of ₹12,000 for a fire insurance policy on
January 1st, but the property is sold on March 31st and the policy is cancelled, the insured may
be entitled to a return of proportionate premium (₹9,000 for the remaining 9 months), subject to
policy terms and cancellation charges.

***

## **1.9 PROXIMATE CAUSE**

### **Definition and Importance**

The doctrine of **proximate cause** (*causa proxima*) is a fundamental principle in insurance

law that determines whether a loss is covered under an insurance policy. The Latin maxim
*"causa proxima non remota spectatur"* means "the immediate, not the remote, cause is to be
considered".[1]

**Proximate cause** is the active, efficient cause that sets in motion a train of events which
brings about a result, without the intervention of any force started and working actively from a
new and independent source.

### **Determining Proximate Cause**

To determine the proximate cause:

1. Identify all causes that contributed to the loss
2. Determine which cause was the **dominant** or **effective** cause
3. Check if the dominant cause is an **insured peril** (covered) or an **excluded peril** (not
covered)
4. If the proximate cause is an insured peril, the claim is payable
5. If the proximate cause is an excluded peril, the claim is not payable

### **Illustrations of Proximate Cause**

**Illustration 1 (Fire Insurance):** A building is insured against fire. During a riot, miscreants set
fire to the building. The building burns down.

**Analysis:** Two causes exist—riot and fire. The riot led to the fire, but the **proximate cause**
is fire (the direct cause of loss). If the policy covers fire but excludes riot, the claim is **payable**
because fire is the proximate cause, even though riot was the remote cause.

**Illustration 2 (Marine Insurance):** A ship insured against perils of the sea is carrying a cargo
of coal. The ship springs a leak due to ordinary wear and tear (not an insured peril). Water
enters and damages the cargo.

**Analysis:** The proximate cause of the loss is the leak caused by **wear and tear** (an
excluded peril), not perils of the sea. The claim is **not payable** even though water damage
occurred, because the efficient cause was an excluded risk.[1]

**Illustration 3 (Sequential Causes):** A property insured against fire suffers an earthquake

(excluded peril), which damages the building's electrical wiring. Three days later, the damaged
wiring causes a short circuit, resulting in a fire that destroys the property.

**Analysis:** This involves a **chain of causation**. The earthquake was the initial cause, but
there was an **intervening independent cause** (electrical short circuit) that directly caused the
fire. If the fire resulted from the **new and independent** electrical fault (not inevitably from the
earthquake damage), then **fire** may be considered the proximate cause, and the claim could
be payable. However, if the fire was the **inevitable consequence** of earthquake damage, the
earthquake remains the proximate cause, and the claim would be denied.

### **Concurrent Causes**

When two or more causes operate simultaneously and both contribute to the loss, the following
rules apply:

**Rule 1:** If one cause is **insured** and the other is **not excluded**, the loss is covered.

**Rule 2:** If one cause is **insured** and the other is **excluded**, the loss is generally **not
covered** (the exclusion operates to defeat the claim).

**Rule 3:** If both causes are **insured perils**, the loss is covered.
**Illustration of Concurrent Causes:** A house insured against fire is hit by an earthquake. The
earthquake cracks the gas pipeline, and simultaneously an electrical short circuit occurs. Both
the gas leak and the electrical fault cause an explosion and fire that destroys the house.

**Analysis:** If earthquake is excluded but fire is covered, and both operated concurrently, most
courts would hold the loss **not covered** because one of the operating causes (earthquake) is
excluded.

### **Application in Different Insurance Types**

**Fire Insurance:** The principle of proximate cause is crucial in fire insurance to determine
whether the fire was caused by an insured or excluded peril.[1]

**Marine Insurance:** Proximate cause determines whether loss was due to perils of the sea
(covered) or inherent vice, delay, or war (typically excluded).[1]

**Motor Insurance:** Helps determine if an accident was caused by an insured peril (accidental
collision) or excluded cause (driving under influence, if excluded).

**Case Law Principle:** Though specific Indian case names are not provided in the source
materials, the doctrine of proximate cause has been consistently applied by Indian courts
following principles established in English insurance law, which India inherited through common
law tradition.

***

**Unit 1 Complete. Confirm to proceed to Unit 2.**

Sources
[1] [Link] [Link]
[Link]/web/direct-files/attachments/86860808/9a415d19-381f-400a-a0f2-
0e678ab921c6/[Link]
[2] [Link]
[Link]
[3] Guaranteed Insurance Contracts: Definition, Features & Procedures
[Link]
[4] [PDF] ESSENTIALS OF INSURANCE CONTRACT - NIOS
[Link]
[5] [PDF] concept, nature and scope of insurance
[Link]
[6] [PDF] Duties, Powers and Functions of IRDA Section 14 of IRDA Act, 1999 ...
[Link]
[7] [PDF] Nationalisation of Insurance in India - Centre For Civil Society
[Link]
[8] [PDF] HISTORY OF INSURANCE LEGISLATION IN INDIA - Manupatra
[Link]
%[Link]
[9] LIC History - Decades of Trust, Excellence, and Financial Security [Link]
[10] [PDF] THE INSURANCE ACT, 1938 | India Code
[Link]
[11] [PDF] THE INSURANCE ACT, 19381 - Department Of Financial Services
[Link]
[12] Life Insurance Corporation - Wikipedia
[Link]
[13] Insurance in India - Wikipedia [Link]
[14] [PDF] THE LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION ACT, 1956 - India Code
[Link]
[15] [PDF] Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956 - High Court of Tripura [Link]
%20Governmental%20Acts/LIC%20Act,%[Link]
[16] GENERAL INSURANCE BUSINESS (NATIONALISATION) ACT, 1972
[Link]
notes/
[17] Changes in General Insurance Business Bill: RSTV – Big Picture [Link]
prep/changes-in-general-insurance-business-bill-rstv-big-picture/
[18] General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Act, 1972 - India Code
[Link]
[19] [PDF] THE GENERAL INSURANCE BUSINESS (NATIONALISATION) ACT ...
[Link]
[20] [PDF] The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority Act, 1999
[Link]
[21] Overview and Analysis of the Role of IRDA in India - iPleaders [Link]
of-irda/
[22] What is IRDA? Objectives, Features, Powers & Functions - Adda247
[Link]
[23] Section 14 of IRDA Act, 1999 Lays Down The Duties, Powers and ...
[Link]
[24] IRDAI: Powers and Functions - ClearIAS [Link]
[25] What is IRDAI? Meaning & Functions of IRDA - Kotak Life Insurance
[Link]
[26] Insurance contract : all you need to know - iPleaders [Link]
contract-all-you-need-to-know/
[27] What is IRDAI? Functions of IRDA - Tata AIA [Link]
insurance/[Link]
[28] Nationalisation of Insurance Business | PDF - Scribd
[Link]
[29] History Of Insurance - SATHEE - IIT Kanpur
[Link]
[30] Nature of The Contract of Insurance | PDF - Scribd
[Link]
[31] [PDF] THE INDIAN CONTRACT ACT, 1872 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
[Link]
[32] Standard Form of Insurance Contracts and Consumer Rights- India
[Link]
[33] Guide to Understanding Insurance Law in India [Link]
law-in-india/
[34] [PDF] Section 38, 39, 41 & 45 of Insurance Act
[Link]
[35] History in Brief - GIC [Link]
[36] [PDF] INSURANCE LAWS OF INDIA - [Link] [Link]
%[Link]

# **UNIT 2: MARINE INSURANCE**

## **2.1 SCOPE AND NATURE OF MARINE INSURANCE**

### **Definition of Marine Insurance**

A contract of marine insurance is a contract whereby the insurer undertakes to indemnify the
assured in the manner and the extent thereby agreed, against marine losses, that is to say, the
losses incidental to marine adventure.[1][2][3]

In *Lloyd v. Fleming*, Blackburn J defined a policy of marine insurance as a contract of

indemnity against all losses occurring to the subject matter of the policy from certain perils
during the adventure.[1]

**Statutory Definition—Section 3 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963:** "A contract of marine
insurance is a contract whereby the insurer undertakes to indemnify the assured, in manner and
to the extent thereby agreed, against marine losses, that is to say, the losses incident to marine
adventure".[4][5][3]

### **Nature of Marine Insurance Contract**

Marine insurance is fundamentally a **contract of indemnity**. This means its primary function is
to restore the insured to the financial position they held immediately before the loss occurred,
ensuring the insured cannot profit from the loss. The payment will always be restricted to the
amount of the actual loss or the sum insured, whichever amount is smaller.[1]

The policy is also a **contract of utmost good faith (*Uberrimae Fidei*)**. This imposes a strict
duty on the insured to voluntarily disclose every material fact that would influence the insurer's
decision to accept the risk or calculate the premium.[2][3][1]
Furthermore, a valid **insurable interest** must exist in the property not just when the policy is
taken out, but critically, at the time the loss occurs. The insured must possess a legitimate
financial stake such that they would suffer a detriment if the property were damaged.[3][1]

Finally, the **Doctrine of Contribution** applies when a property is covered by several policies
from different insurers. In such cases, the insured cannot collect the full loss amount from every
insurer; instead, each insurer is entitled to contribute a proportionate share of the loss payment,
reinforcing the principle that the insured is only indemnified once.[2][1]

### **Subject Matter of Marine Insurance**

**Statutory Provision—Section 2(c) of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963:** "Insurable property"
means any ship, goods or other movables which are exposed to maritime perils.[5][4]

Marine insurance can cover:

**1. Ship (Hull Insurance):** The vessel itself, including its machinery, equipment, and fittings.[3]
[1]

**2. Cargo:** Goods being transported by sea.[3][1]

**3. Freight:** The consideration paid for the transportation of cargo. Section 2(b) defines
"freight" as including the profit derivable by a ship-owner from the employment of his ship to
carry his own goods or other movables, as well as freight payable by a third party, but does not
include passage money.[4][5][1]

**4. Liability:** Third-party liabilities arising from maritime operations.[3]

### **Maritime Perils Covered**

Marine insurance protects against losses incidental to **marine adventure**, which includes
exposure to maritime perils such as:[2][1]

- Perils of the sea (storms, shipwreck, collision, stranding)

- Fire
- War perils (with specific coverage)
- Pirates and rovers
- Thieves
- Capture and seizure
- Jettisons (deliberate throwing overboard of cargo)
- Barratry (fraudulent conduct by ship's master or crew)

***
## **2.2 TYPES OF MARINE INSURANCE POLICIES**

**Section 4 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963** specifies different types of marine insurance
policies. Policies can be voyage-based, time-based, or mixed, depending on duration and
scope.[4][3]

### **1. Time Policy**

Where ship is insured for a particular time from a particular date to a particular date, the policy is
called a time policy.[1][3]

The period should not exceed one year though it may contain one or several voyages. A time
policy which is made for any time exceeding 12 months is invalid.[1]

A time policy is defined as a policy in which the contract is to insure the subject matter for a
definite period of time.[1]

Generally, in a time policy there is a **continuation clause** that if the ship at the expiration of
the policy is still at sea or in distress or in a port, she shall be held to be covered by the same
policy at pro rata monthly premium until she reaches safely to her port of destination, provided
prompt notice to that effect is given to the insurer.[1]

### **2. Voyage Policy**

Where the contract is to insure the subject matter at and from one place to another or others,
the policy is called a voyage policy.[3][1]

A contract for both voyage and time may be included in the same policy and such policies are in
mercantile usage called **mixed policies**.[1]

**Example:** A ship may be insured under the same policy from Bombay to Goa for six months
or from Bombay to Visakhapatnam and 90 days after arrival.[1]

In voyage policy the risk commences at the port of departure and ends at the port of destination.
[1]

The voyage insured must be accurately described in a voyage policy, i.e., the local limit of the
risk must be specified.[1]

### **3. Cargo Insurance**

Cargo means the goods carried on a ship. Thus the term suggests, cargo insurance is taken in
respect of the cargo carried by the ship from one place to another.[1]
The cargo insurance policy may be a time policy or voyage policy. When the policy is for a
definite period it is known as time policy. If it is for a particular voyage it is known as voyage
policy and there is no time limit.[1]

### **4. Freight Insurance**

The freight is the rent or amount paid for the transportation of cargo. Generally the ship owner
and the person receiving the freight is one person.[1]

The freight could be paid in advance or at the port of destination. Under the marine law the
freight could be paid only if the cargo reaches safely at the destination port.[1]

Therefore, if the freight has been paid in advance, it poses no difficulty, but the problem
sometimes arises when the freight is payable at the destination port and the cargo may get lost
during the voyage and could not reach destination. In that event the freight is lost. In order to
overcome such contingency, the freight insurance is taken.[1]

However, if the freight has been paid in advance it cannot be recovered in case the cargo is lost
during the voyage.[1]

### **5. Hull Insurance**

Literally hull means body or frame of the ship or vessel and its machinery. This type of
insurance covers ship and its equipments.[1]

The hull policies may also cover the risk while the vessel is under construction.[1]

### **6. Fleet Policy**

This policy covers a number of vessels under a single policy.[1]

The advantage in this type of policy is that if each vessel is insured separately, the amount of
premium may be much more. If some vessels are in such condition that those cannot be insured
because of their condition, those are also covered in a fleet policy.[1]

### **7. Named Policy**

Name of ship and value of ship mentioned by name.[1]

### **8. Valued Policy**

A valued policy is one which specifies the agreed value of the subject matter.[1]
The advantage is that in case of total loss, the insured receives the agreed value without having
to prove the actual value at the time of loss.[1]

***

## **2.3 INSURABLE INTEREST IN MARINE INSURANCE**

### **Definition and Importance**

**Section 7 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963** provides that a person must have a legal or
financial interest in the subject matter (e.g., ship, cargo, freight) to purchase insurance. This
ensures that compensation is only paid for actual financial losses, discouraging speculative or
fraudulent claims.[3]

Insurable interest is the financial stake the insured party has in the subject matter. It's the legal
right to insure, established because the insured will suffer a quantifiable financial loss if the
subject matter is damaged or lost.[1]

### **A. In Case of Ship**

The **Ship Owner** has an interest up to the full value of the vessel.[1]

A **Charterer** also has an interest based on their contractual liabilities or loss of use.[1]

### **B. In Case of Cargo**

The **Cargo Owner** can insure the goods for their full price.[1]

If the owner has paid the freight in advance, the insurable interest covers the full value of the
goods plus the amount of the prepaid freight.[1]

### **C. In Case of Freight**

The party due to receive the carriage payment—typically the carrier or receiver of the freight—
can insure this amount to cover the income they will lose if the voyage fails and the freight is not
earned.[1]

***

## **2.4 DISCLOSURE AND REPRESENTATION**

### **Principle of Utmost Good Faith (*Uberrimae Fidei*)**

**Section 19 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963** embodies the **Doctrine of Utmost Good Faith
(*Uberrimae Fidei*)**. This is the principle requiring both parties to the contract to act with
absolute honesty and to voluntarily disclose all material facts.[6][3][1]

A fact is considered material if it would influence a prudent insurer's decision to accept the risk
or determine the premium.[2][1]

Because ships and cargo proposed for insurance may be thousands of miles away, the insurer
must rely entirely on the information provided by the insured. Failure by the insured to uphold
utmost good faith, whether through concealment or misrepresentation, entitles the insurer to
void the contract.[7][2][1]

### **Material Facts in Marine Insurance**

Material facts that must be disclosed include:

**1. Seaworthiness of the Vessel:** The condition, age, maintenance history, and structural
integrity of the ship.[7][1]

**2. Nature of Cargo:** Whether goods are hazardous, perishable, or fragile.[1]

**3. Route of Voyage:** The intended path, including any high-risk areas.[1]

**4. Previous Losses:** Any prior claims or losses suffered by the vessel or cargo.[1]

**5. True Ownership:** Accurate identification of the vessel's owner and any liens or
encumbrances.[8][7]

**6. Manning and Crew:** Adequacy and experience of officers and crew.[1]

**7. Any Defects or Damage:** Pre-existing damage, ongoing repairs, or known defects.[8][7]

### **Consequences of Non-Disclosure or Misrepresentation**

If the assured fails to make such disclosure, the insurer may avoid the contract.[7][1]

If he conceals anything which he knows to be material, it is fraud.[1]

**Case Law Illustration—*Hind Offshore Pvt. Ltd. vs IFFCO-Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd.*
(2023):** The Supreme Court of India observed that in case of failure to disclose essential
material facts regarding worthiness of ship, the insurance company is discharged from liability.
In this case, the appellant purchased a marine hull insurance policy but failed to disclose
material facts about the vessel's condition and class warranty status. The Court upheld the
insurer's repudiation of the policy due to breach of the principle of utmost good faith under
Section 19 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963.[6][7]

**Case Reference—*Rajaram NS Bandekar v Oriental Insurance* (2009):** The Bombay High

Court held that suppressing the fact that the vessel was undergoing a major overhaul and that it
was not seaworthy was enough to void coverage. The court stated: "Where there has been a
suppression of fact, acceptance of the policy by an officer of the insurance company would not
be binding on it".[8]

### **Facts Not Required to be Disclosed**

The following need not be disclosed:[1]

**i.** Any circumstances which diminish the risk

**ii.** Any circumstances which are known or presumed to be known to the insurer

**iii.** Any circumstances as to which information is waived by the insurer

**iv.** Any circumstances which are superfluous to disclose by reason of any express or implied
warranty

Alteration in disclosed facts has to be done before acceptance.[1]

***

## **2.5 WARRANTIES IN MARINE INSURANCE**

### **Definition of Warranty**

A warranty is that by which the assured undertakes that some particular thing shall or shall not
be done, or that some condition shall be fulfilled, or whereby he affirms or negatives the
existence of a particular state of facts.[1]

Warranties are statements according to which insured person promises to do or not to do

particular thing or to fulfill or not to fulfill a certain condition.[1]

Warranties are **the most fundamental conditions** of a marine insurance contract. Breach of
warranty discharges the insurer from all liability from the date of breach, regardless of whether
the breach caused or contributed to the loss.[1]

### **Types of Warranties**

Warranties are of two types:

### **A. Express Warranties**

Express warranties are those warranties which are expressly included or incorporated in the
policy by reference.[1]

**Examples:**
- A warranty that the vessel will carry a specified crew size
- A warranty regarding the vessel's classification with a recognized classification society (Class
Warranty)
- A warranty that certain safety equipment will be maintained

**Illustration—Class Warranty:** A vessel is insured with a warranty that it must maintain its
classification with Lloyd's Register. If the vessel loses its classification due to failure to undergo
required surveys, the warranty is breached, and the insurer is discharged from liability even if
the loss is unrelated to the classification lapse.[7]

### **B. Implied Warranties**

These are not included in the policy at all but are tacitly understood by the parties to the contract
and are as fully binding as express warranties.[1]

Implied warranties are:

### **1. Warranty of Seaworthiness of Ship**

The warranty implies that a ship should be seaworthy at the commencement of the voyage, or if
the voyage is carried out in stages, at the commencement of each stage. This warranty applies
only to **voyage policies**, though such policies may be of ship, cargo, freight or any other
interest.[1]

**Definition of Seaworthiness:** A ship is seaworthy when the ship is suitably constructed,

properly equipped, officered, sufficiently fueled and documented, and capable of withstanding
the ordinary strain and stress of the voyage.[1]

The standard to judge the seaworthiness is not fixed; there may be different standards for
different oceans, for different cargo, for different destinations and so on.[1]

Seaworthiness does not depend merely on the condition of the ship but includes the suitability
and adequacy of its equipment, adequacy and experience of the officers and crew.[1]

**Seaworthiness also includes cargo-worthiness.** It means the ship must be reasonably fit and
suitable to carry the kind of cargo insured.[1]
**Note:** There is no warranty that the cargo should be seaworthy.[1]

**Illustration:** A vessel is insured under a voyage policy to carry timber from Chennai to
Singapore. If the vessel's hatches are not properly secured to prevent water ingress during
heavy seas, the vessel is not seaworthy for that particular voyage. If loss occurs due to water
damage to the timber, the insurer may avoid liability on the ground of breach of the implied
warranty of seaworthiness.

### **2. Warranty of Legality of Venture**

This warranty implies that the adventure insured shall be lawful and that, so far as the assured
can control the matter, it shall be carried out in a lawful manner of the country.[1]

Marine policies cannot be applied to protect illegal voyages or adventures. The examples of
illegal ventures may be trading with an enemy, smuggling, breach of blockade and similar
ventures prohibited by law.[1]

Illegality must not be confused with illegal conduct of third parties, e.g., theft, pirates.[1]

**Illustration:** If a vessel is insured to carry contraband goods in violation of customs laws, the
adventure is illegal. Even if the vessel suffers a legitimate marine peril like a storm and sinks,
the insurer can avoid the policy because the fundamental warranty of legality is breached.

### **3. Other Implied Warranties**

There are other warranties which must be complied with in marine insurance:

### **A. No Change in Voyage**

When the destination of voyage is changed intentionally after the beginning of the risk, it is
called change in voyage.[1]

Any voluntary change in the destination after the risk has attached discharges the insurer from
liability from the time of the change.[1]

**Illustration:** A ship is insured for a voyage from Mumbai to Dubai. After departure, the ship
owner decides to divert to Oman instead. This constitutes a change in voyage, and the insurer
is discharged from liability from the moment the decision to change was made.

### **B. No Delay in Voyage**

This warranty applies only to voyage policies. There should not be delay in starting of voyage
and no laziness or delay during the course of journey.[1]
This is an implied condition that the venture must start within the reasonable time. Moreover, the
insured venture must be dispatched within the reasonable time.[1]

**Illustration:** A cargo policy covers goods to be shipped from Kolkata to London. If the ship
remains in port for an unreasonable period without any justifiable cause, the delay breaches the
warranty, and coverage may be voided.

### **C. Non-Deviation**

The liability of the insurer ends in deviation of journey. Deviation means removal from the
common route or given path.[1]

When ship deviates from the fixed passage without any legal reason, the insurer quits his
responsibility. This would be immaterial that the ship returned to her original route before loss.
[1]

**Exceptions—Deviation or Delay is Excused When:**

**1.** Deviation or delay is authorized according to a particular warranty of the policy

**2.** When the delay or deviation was beyond the reasonable approach of the master or crew

**3.** The deviation or delay is excused for the safety of ship or insured matter, or human lives

**4.** Deviation or delay was due to barratry (fraudulent conduct by master or crew)[1]

**Illustration:** A vessel insured for a voyage from Singapore to Karachi deviates to Colombo
without any justifiable reason. If the vessel suffers a loss after deviation, the insurer is not liable.
However, if the deviation was necessary to save the ship from a storm or to rescue persons in
distress at sea, the deviation is excused, and coverage continues.

***

## **2.6 PERILS OF THE SEA**

### **Definition**

Chalmer observes that it is unsafe to attempt a complete definition of the expression "peril of the
sea." Broadly speaking, a peril of the sea may be defined to cover everything that happens to
the ship in course of a voyage by the immediate act of God without the intervention of human
agency.[1]
It refers only to accidents or casualties not attributable to the free will and desire of a human
being. Even in the act of God, it does not include the natural and ordinary action of the winds
and waves.[1]

**Sections 55 to 58 of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963** lay down conditions which cover loss by
perils of the sea.[9]

The burden of proving a loss by perils of the sea lies on the insured. The reason for placing the
burden of proof on the ship owner in such a case is that they are likely to have all the relevant
information.[1]

### **Examples of Perils of the Sea**

### **1. Foundering at Sea (Sinking)**

If the ship is missing and after a reasonable time no news has been received, the loss may be
presumed to be by the perils of the sea.[10][1]

For marine insurance, if a vessel is declared missing with no communication for an extended
period, it is also deemed an actual total loss.[10]

### **2. Shipwreck (Destruction of Ship)**

It is loss caused by the perils of the sea when it happens by the ship striking against the rock or
driven to the shore by the violence of winds.[1]

The shipwreck may occur in various ways, e.g., the ship may be so shattered that it becomes a
mere collection of planks or it is unable to navigate except at a great cost.[1]

### **3. Stranding**

It happens when a ship by an accident gets out of the ordinary course of her voyage and gets
stuck up in shallow regions of sand and receives injury.[1]

**Illustration:** A vessel navigating through shallow coastal waters runs aground on a sandbank
due to unexpected tidal changes. The vessel suffers damage to its hull. This is a peril of the sea
covered under the policy.

### **4. Collision**

Collision is regarded as a peril of the sea and it may arise by the ship striking against another
ship or any other subject matter.[1]
**Illustration:** Two cargo vessels collide in dense fog in the Arabian Sea, causing damage to
both hulls and loss of cargo. The collision, being an accidental maritime peril, is covered.

### **5. Loss by Fire**

If fire is caused on board the ship and if the goods or ship is damaged, the insurance company
will be liable.[1]

But it will not include the loss caused by the inherent vice of the subject matter insured. It covers
also a fire voluntarily caused in order to avoid capture by an enemy.[1]

### **6. Loss by Capture, Seizure**

The term capture will include not only taking by an enemy but by revenue and statutory
authorities.[1]

**Note:** Capture and seizure by war or piracy are typically excluded from standard marine
policies and require separate **War Risks Insurance**.[1]

***

## **2.7 EXCLUDED LOSSES (NOT PERILS OF THE SEA)**

### **1. Wear and Tear**

The term is used to denote the natural decay and deterioration which invariably happens to a
ship or any portion due to the action of the winds and waves.[1]

In case of ship it means decay of the body of the ship and its accessories, e.g., splitting or break
of a sail, breakage of rope or cable; and in case of cargo of perishable nature like fruits,
vegetables, weakness and defects.[1]

### **2. Springing a Leak**

If a ship develops a leak, it is not a peril of the sea unless it is due to an accident.[1]

**Illustration:** If a vessel develops a leak due to ordinary wear and tear of aging pipes, the
resulting damage is not covered. However, if the leak is caused by the vessel striking a
submerged object, it is a peril of the sea.

### **3. Breakage of Goods**

If the goods are broken or damaged during the voyage due to movement of the ship, it is not a
peril of the sea. But if it is due to violent action of the waves and consequent labouring of the
ship, it is a peril of the sea.[1]

### **4. Inherent Vice**

The insurer will not be liable for any loss caused due to the defect in the goods, etc. If the fruits
become rotten or wine becomes bad due to inherent decomposition.[1]

**Illustration:** A shipment of bananas deteriorates and rots during a normal voyage due to their
natural perishable nature, not due to any external maritime peril. This loss is not covered as it
arises from inherent vice.

### **5. Death of Animals Due to Natural Causes**

Death of livestock being transported due to natural causes (disease, old age) is not a peril of the
sea.[1]

### **6. Loss by Rats and Vermin**

If loss is caused by rats, etc., it will not be deemed to be peril of the sea.[1]

**Case Illustration—*Hamilton v. Pandorf*:** Where rats made a hole in a pipe and sea water
entered damaging the cargo of rice and there was no negligence on the part of the carrier, it
was held that the insurer was not liable.[1]

### **7. Loss by Delay**

Loss of market or consequential loss due to delay in voyage is not covered unless specifically
insured.[1]

***

## **2.8 IMPLIED TERMS IN MARINE POLICY**

Marine insurance policies contain several **implied terms** that govern the rights and
obligations of both parties, even if not expressly written in the policy document:

### **1. Implied Warranty of Seaworthiness**

As discussed in Section 2.5, this warranty requires the vessel to be reasonably fit to encounter
the ordinary perils of the voyage at the commencement of the risk.[1]

### **2. Implied Warranty of Legality**

The adventure must be lawful and carried out in a lawful manner.[1]

### **3. Implied Condition of No Deviation**

The vessel must proceed on the contracted voyage without unjustified deviation.[1]

### **4. Implied Condition of No Delay**

The voyage must commence and proceed without unreasonable delay.[1]

### **5. Duty of Assured to Sue and Labor**

Though not always expressly stated, the assured has an implied duty to take reasonable
measures to avert or minimize loss covered by the policy. This is known as the **sue and labor
clause**.[1]

The insurer is liable for reasonable expenses incurred by the assured in taking measures to
prevent or minimize loss, even if ultimately unsuccessful. These expenses are payable in
addition to the total loss.[1]

**Illustration:** When a vessel starts taking water after striking a submerged object, the ship
owner arranges for emergency pumping equipment and towing services to bring the vessel to
the nearest port. The reasonable costs of these salvage efforts are recoverable from the insurer
under the sue and labor obligation.

***

## **2.9 PARTIAL LOSS AND TOTAL LOSS**

Marine insurance losses are classified into two broad categories: **Total Loss** and **Partial
Loss**.

### **TOTAL LOSS**

Total loss may be either **Actual Total Loss** or **Constructive Total Loss**.

### **A. Actual Total Loss**

**Actual Total Loss** occurs when the subject matter insured is completely destroyed or so
damaged that it ceases to be a thing of the kind insured, or when the insured is irretrievably
deprived of it.[11][12][10]
An actual total loss is based on **irretrievable loss or destruction** of the insured property. The
damage that occurred to the insured cargo is beyond repair, leaving it unseaworthy or sunken.
[12][10]

**Statutory Reference—Marine Insurance Act, 1963:** The Act recognizes actual total loss
when:
- The ship is lost or sunk, and the owner has no means of recovery
- Cargo is damaged beyond its original form and cannot be sold or reused
- The ship is not heard of for a prolonged period and is officially declared "missing"[10]

**Examples of Actual Total Loss:**

**1. Ship Sinks Completely:** A cargo vessel encounters a severe storm in the Bay of Bengal
and sinks completely with all cargo. The vessel cannot be recovered. This is an actual total loss.
[10][1]

**2. Cargo Destroyed by Fire:** A shipment of cotton bales is completely destroyed by fire on
board the vessel. Nothing remains of the insured cargo. This is an actual total loss.[1]

**3. Vessel Missing:** A ship departs from Kochi and is never heard from again. After a
reasonable period (typically several months), it is presumed lost at sea—an actual total loss.[10]
[1]

**Claim Settlement:** In case of an actual total loss, the insured can claim the full claim
settlement, and the insurer is liable to pay it. The ownership of wreckage or remaining cargo
passes to the insurer.[12]

### **B. Constructive Total Loss**

**Constructive Total Loss (CTL)** occurs when the subject matter insured is reasonably
abandoned because its actual total loss appears unavoidable, or because it could not be
preserved from actual total loss without an expenditure which would exceed its value when the
expenditure had been incurred.[13][11][12]

A constructive total loss in marine cargo insurance means that **the cost of repair of a damaged
item is more than the current value of the item**.[11][12]

Constructive total loss applies when:

- The cost to salvage or repair the insured object exceeds its value after the loss
- It is physically impossible or commercially unreasonable to recover or repair the property[14]
[11]

Insurance companies often consider the loss equal to **50% or 60% of the stated value** of the
item to ascertain constructive total loss.[11]
**Situations Justifying Constructive Total Loss:**

**1. Cost of Repairs Exceeds Value:** A vessel suffers collision damage. The cost of repairing
the damage is ₹80 lakhs, but the vessel's market value after repair would be only ₹60 lakhs.
The vessel may be declared a constructive total loss.[12][11]

**2. Cost of Recovery Exceeds Value:** A cargo ship runs aground on a remote reef. The cost
of salvage operations to refloat the vessel and tow it to port exceeds the vessel's insured value.
The owner can claim constructive total loss.[13][11]

**3. Cargo Inaccessible:** A cargo of electronic goods is trapped in the hold of a partially
submerged vessel. The cost of recovering the cargo exceeds the value of the goods. This is a
constructive total loss of cargo.[11]

**Notice of Abandonment:** In case of a constructive total loss, the policyholder must inform the
insurance company and surrender its interest in the subject matter to the insurance company.
This formal notice is called **Notice of Abandonment**.[12][11]

The insurer may accept or reject the abandonment. If accepted, the insurer takes over all rights
and responsibilities regarding the abandoned property.[13][12]

**Claim Settlement:** In case of constructive total loss, the insurer pays the insured value to the
policyholder. The insured may retain the ownership of remaining cargo, or it may pass to the
insurer depending on whether abandonment is accepted.[12]

### **Difference Between Actual Total Loss and Constructive Total Loss**

| Feature | Actual Total Loss | Constructive Total Loss |

|---------|-------------------|-------------------------|
| **Nature of Loss** | Complete and irrecoverable | Partial but economically irrecoverable |
| **Claim Payable** | Full insured amount | Usually full, after notice of abandonment |
| **Ownership After Claim** | Ownership passes to insurer | Insured may retain ownership
unless abandonment accepted |
| **Basis of Determination** | Physical loss or total destruction | Based on cost-benefit analysis
of recovery |
| **Common In** | Marine, property, motor insurance | Mainly marine, sometimes motor |

[12][10]

**Illustration:** A vessel valued at ₹1 crore is insured for that amount. During a voyage, it
suffers storm damage. Survey reveals repair costs of ₹75 lakhs. The post-repair value would be
₹80 lakhs. The owner serves notice of abandonment claiming constructive total loss. The
insurer may accept and pay ₹1 crore (taking ownership of the damaged vessel), or reject the
abandonment and pay for partial loss repairs.

***

## **2.10 PARTIAL LOSS**

When the loss is neither actual total loss nor constructive total loss, it is a **partial loss**.

Partial losses are of two types:

### **A. Particular Average Loss**

**Particular Average** is a partial loss caused by a peril insured against and which is not a
general average loss.[1]

It is a loss borne solely by the owner of the damaged property. The loss is not shared with other
parties with an interest in the voyage.[1]

**Example:** During a voyage, rough seas damage a portion of the cargo belonging to
Merchant A. The cargo of Merchant B in the same ship is unaffected. Merchant A bears the loss
alone. This is a particular average loss.[1]

### **B. General Average Loss**

**General Average Loss** is a loss caused by or directly consequential upon a general average
act. It includes a general average expenditure and general average sacrifice.[1]

**General Average** arises when extraordinary sacrifices or expenditures are voluntarily and
reasonably made or incurred for the common safety of the ship and cargo to preserve them
from a common peril.[12][1]

The loss or expense is shared proportionately by all parties with a financial interest in the
voyage (ship owner, cargo owners, freight owner) based on the saved values.[1]

**Example:** During a storm, the ship's master orders that part of the cargo be thrown
overboard (jettisoned) to prevent the ship from sinking. This deliberate sacrifice saves the ship
and remaining cargo. The loss of the jettisoned cargo is a **general average loss** and is
shared proportionately by the ship owner and all cargo owners whose goods were saved.[12][1]

**Statutory Reference:** Section 66 and related provisions of the Marine Insurance Act, 1963
govern general average contributions.

***
## **2.11 MEASURE OF INDEMNITY**

The measure of indemnity determines how much the insurer must pay to compensate the
insured for a loss.

### **In Case of Total Loss**

**1. Valued Policy:** If the policy is a valued policy (one that specifies an agreed value), the
insured recovers the **full agreed value** in case of total loss, without having to prove the actual
value at the time of loss.[1]

**2. Unvalued Policy:** If the policy is unvalued (open policy), the insured recovers the
**insurable value** of the subject matter at the time of loss.[1]

### **In Case of Partial Loss**

**1. Total Loss of Part:** If only a part of the goods is totally lost, the measure of indemnity is the
insurable value of that part, proportionally calculated.[1]

**2. Damage to Ship:** The measure of indemnity is the reasonable cost of repairs, subject to
the sum insured. If the ship is insured on a valued basis, the repairs cannot exceed the agreed
value.[1]

**3. Damage to Goods:** The measure is the proportion which the depreciated value bears to
the sound value of the goods.[1]

**Illustration—Damaged Goods:** Goods valued at ₹10 lakhs when sound suffer water damage.
Their damaged value is ₹6 lakhs (a depreciation of 40%). If insured for ₹8 lakhs, the indemnity
is 40% of ₹8 lakhs = ₹3.2 lakhs.

### **General Average Contributions**

When general average loss is incurred, the insurer is liable for the assured's proportionate
contribution to the general average, in addition to any particular average loss.[1]

**Illustration:** A ship and cargo valued collectively at ₹50 crores suffer a general average act
(jettison of cargo worth ₹5 crores to save the ship). The ship is valued at ₹20 crores and cargo
of Owner X at ₹10 crores. Owner X's proportionate contribution to general average is (₹10
crores / ₹50 crores) × ₹5 crores = ₹1 crore. If Owner X's cargo is insured, the insurer pays this
₹1 crore contribution.

### **Sue and Labor Charges**

The insurer is liable for reasonable expenses incurred by the assured in taking measures to
avert or minimize loss, known as **sue and labor charges**. These are payable in addition to
any other claim under the policy.[1]

**Illustration:** A vessel starts taking water after striking a submerged rock. The owner incurs
₹10 lakhs in emergency towing and pumping to save the vessel. Even if the vessel is saved and
no total loss claim arises, the insurer must reimburse the ₹10 lakhs as sue and labor expenses.

***

**Unit 2 Complete. Confirm to proceed to Unit 3.**

Sources
[1] [Link] [Link]
[Link]/web/direct-files/attachments/86860808/9a415d19-381f-400a-a0f2-
0e678ab921c6/[Link]
[2] The Marine Insurance Act, 1963: Provisions & Implications - TATA AIG
[Link]
[3] Marine Insurance Act, 1906 - Blog - BimaKavach [Link]
insurance-act-1906-india-overview/
[4] [PDF] THE MARINE INSURANCE ACT, 1963 - India Code
[Link]
[5] Marine Insurance Act, 1963 - Indian Employees [Link]
rules/details/marine-insurance-act-1963
[6] [PDF] reportable - Supreme Court of India
[Link]
[Link]
[7] SUPREME COURT UPHOLDS INSURANCE COMPANY'S ...
[Link]
policy-due-to-non-disclosure-of-material-fact/
[8] [PDF] Insured Duties from Utmost Good Faith to Fair Presentation
[Link]
[9] MARINE INSURANCE LAW IN INDIA - S.S. Rana & Co. [Link]
admirality-law/marine-insurance-law-india/
[10] Actual Total Loss In Insurance Explained - PlanCover
[Link]
[11] What is Constructive Total Loss in Marine Cargo Insurance?
[Link]
[12] What is the Difference Between Actual Total Loss and Constructive ...
[Link]
loss-and-constructive-total-loss
[13] What is Constructive Total Loss in Marine Insurance? - James Hallam
[Link]
[14] Kinds of Losses in Marine Insurance - LawBhoomi [Link]
in-marine-insurance/
[15] Marine Insurance Act, 1963 - India Code
[Link]
[16] What is the Marine Insurance Act of 1963? - Insuropedia - SecureNow
[Link]
[17] The Marine Insurance Act, 1963 Bare Act - Full Sections List & Free ...
[Link]
[18] Case Summaries – MARINE INSURANCE (Maritime Law ... - PacLII
[Link]
[19] Marine Insurance Act, 1963 | Bare Acts | Law Library - AdvocateKhoj
[Link]
Title=Marine+Insurance+Act%2C+1963
[20] Supreme Court's Enunciation of Insurance Law in India
[Link]
[21] [PDF] Development Of Laws Relating To Marine Insurance In India
[Link]
[Link]

# **UNIT 3: LIFE INSURANCE**

## **3.1 FORMATION OF LIFE INSURANCE CONTRACT**

### **Definition and Meaning**

"If a child, a spouse, a life partner, or a parent depends on you and your income, you need life
insurance".[1]

The whole idea of insurance has developed on the fact that human life is full of uncertainties
and the life of a person itself is very uncertain.[1]

The scheme of life insurance provides an assurance that if such an event happens, the person
or his dependents would get financial assistance to bear the loss.[1]

In simple words, life insurance means an agreement in which one party agrees to pay a given
sum of money upon the happening of a particular event contingent upon duration of human life
in exchange of the payment of a consideration.[1]

**Key Terminology:**

- The person who guarantees the payment is called **Insurer**

- The amount given is called **Policy Amount**
- The person on whose life the payment is guaranteed is called **Insured or Assured**
- The particular event on which the payment is guaranteed to be given may be **Death or Life**
- The consideration is called the **Premium**
- The document evidencing the contract is called **Policy**[1]

### **Formal Definition**

"Life insurance is a contract in which one party agrees to pay a given sum of money upon the
happening of a particular event contingent duration of human life in consideration of immediate
payment of a smaller sum or other equivalent periodical payments by the other".[1]

"A life insurance policy promises that the insurer will pay to the policy holder a certain sum of
money if the person insured dies or any other specified contingency happens".[1]

### **Formation Process**

The formation of a life insurance contract involves the following essential steps:

**1. Proposal:** The proposer (intending insured) submits a proposal form containing complete
information about age, health, occupation, habits, family history, and other material facts.[1]

**2. Acceptance:** The insurer evaluates the proposal, assesses the risk, and decides whether
to accept, reject, or accept with modified terms. Medical examination may be required
depending on the sum assured and age.[1]

**3. Consideration:** The first premium must be paid. In life policies, there is a limitation that the
risk will not attach till the first premium is paid.[1]

**4. Issuance of Policy:** Upon acceptance and payment of premium, the insurer issues the
policy document, which is the written evidence of the contract.[1]

**5. Communication:** The issue of the policy by the company itself shows that the risk has
commenced. The policy must be communicated to and received by the assured.[1]

***

## **3.2 NATURE OF LIFE INSURANCE CONTRACT**

Life insurance contracts possess unique characteristics that distinguish them from other
insurance contracts:

### **i) Unilateral Contract**

Only one party to the contract makes legally enforceable promise.[1]

The insurer can repudiate the contract of payment of full policy, but he cannot compel the
insured to pay the subsequent premiums.[1]

On the other hand, if the insured continues to pay the premium, the insurer has to accept them
and continue the contract.[1]

### **ii) Conditional Contract**

Life insurance is subject to the conditions and privilege provided on the back of the policy.[1]

The conditions whether precedent or subsequent of the legal rights must be fulfilled in order to
complete the contract.[1]

### **iii) Aleatory Contract**

In such a kind of contract, no mutual exchange of equal monetary value is done.[1]

It is the happening of the contingency on which the payment is made.[1]

The happening is a matter of chance which may occur or not.[1]

If death occurs only after payment of a few premiums, full policy amount is paid.[1]

### **iv) Contract of Adhesion**

In such a contract, the terms of the contract are not arrived at by mutual negotiations.[1]

Similarly, in a life insurance contract, the contract is decided upon by the insurer only.[1]

The party on the other side has to choose between the two options, i.e. either to accept or reject
the policy.[1]

### **v) Contract of Certain Amount**

Life insurance contract does not provide an indemnity.[1]

It is in the nature of a contingency contract by providing for the payment of the agreed amount
on the happening of the event.[1]

### **vi) Standard Form of Contract**

In the life insurance, all the essentials of a general contract as provided by the Indian Contract
Act, 1872, for a valid contract are present.[1]
***

## **3.3 TYPES OF LIFE INSURANCE POLICIES**

### **I) Term Policy**

It provides a risk cover only for a prescribed period.[1]

Usually these policies are short-term plans and the term ranges from one year onwards.[1]

If the policyholder survives till the end of this period, the risk cover lapses and no insurance
benefit payment is made to him.[1]

The amount of premium to be paid for these policies is lower than all other life insurance
policies.[1]

It has no surrender value.[1]

This plan is most suitable for those who are initially unable to pay high premium.[1]

### **II) Whole Life Policy**

This policy runs for the whole life of the assured.[1]

The sum assured becomes payable to the legal heir only after the death of the assured.[1]

The whole life policy can be of three types:

**a) Ordinary whole life policy:** In this case premium is payable periodically throughout the life
of the assured.[1]

**b) Limited payment whole life policy:** In this case premium is payable for a specified period
(Say 20 Years or 25 Years) Only.[1]

**c) Single Premium whole life policy:** In this type of policy the entire premium is payable in
one single payment.[1]

### **III) Endowment Life Policy**

In this policy the insurer agrees to pay the assured or his nominees a specified sum of money
on his death or on the maturity of the policy which ever is earlier.[1]

The premium for endowment policy is comparatively higher than that of the whole life policy.[1]
The premium is payable till the maturity of the policy or until the death of the assured which ever
is earlier.[1]

It provides protection to the family against the untimely death of the assured.[1]

### **IV) Joint Life Policy**

This policy is taken on the lives of two or more persons simultaneously.[1]

Under this policy the sum assured becomes payable on the death of any one of those who have
taken the joint life policy.[1]

The sum assured will be paid to the survivor(s).[1]

For example, a joint life policy may be taken on the lives of husband and wife, sum assured will
be payable to the survivor on the death of the spouse.[1]

### **V) With Profit and Without Profit Policy**

Under with profit policy the assured is paid, in addition to the sum assured, a share in the profits
of the insurer in the form of bonus.[1]

Without profit policy is a policy under which the assured does not get any share in the profits
earned by the insurer and gets only the sum assured on the maturity of the policy.[1]

### **VI) Double Accident Benefit Policy**

This policy provides that if the insured person dies of any accident, his beneficiaries will get
double the amount of the sum assured.[1]

### **VII) Annuity Policy**

Under this policy, the sum assured is payable not in one lump sum payment but in monthly,
quarterly and half-yearly or yearly installments after assured attains a certain age.[1]

This policy is useful to those who want to have a regular income after the expiry of a certain
period e.g. after retirement.[1]

Annuity is paid so long as the assured survives.[1]

### **VIII) Policies for Women**

**a) Jeevan Sathi Policy:** Jeevan Sathi is also known a Life Partner plan where the husband
and wife.[1]

On maturity, provided both are alive, full sum assured with bonus is paid.[1]

On the death of one of the assured during the period of the policy, basic sum assured is paid to
the surviving partner, who is not required to pay any further premium.[1]

### **IX) Group Insurance**

Group life insurance is a plan of insurance under which the lives of many persons are covered
under one life insurance policy.[1]

Usually in group insurance the employer secures a group insurance for the benefit of his
employees.[1]

Insurer provides coverage for many people under single contract.[1]

**Characteristics of Group Insurance:**

1. **Homogeneous by Nature of Occupation:** The members of the group should ideally share a
similar level of risk, typically defined by their employment. This prevents high-risk individuals
from unfairly driving up the cost for the entire group.[1]

2. **Insurance Must Be Incidental:** The group must be formed and exist for a purpose entirely
separate from obtaining insurance. This rule prevents individuals from gathering solely to obtain
coverage and ensures the group is naturally formed, helping to avoid adverse selection (where
only people who know they are ill seek coverage).[1]

3. **Single Central Administrative Machinery:** The group must have one entity—like the
employer's HR department—to act as the policyholder. This central body handles premium
payment, record-keeping, and general administration on behalf of all the insured members,
simplifying the process for the insurer.[1]

4. **Entry and Exit of Members Every Year:** Group membership is dynamic. There must be a
constant, natural turnover of members (new employees joining and existing employees leaving),
which helps the insurer maintain a balanced and healthy risk pool over time.[1]

**Different Types of Groups:**

1. **Employer and Employees Group:** The most common type, where an employer provides
coverage as a benefit to all or a class of their employees.[1]
2. **Creditor and Debtor Group:** A lender insures the lives of its debtors. The insurance payout
covers the outstanding loan balance if the debtor dies, protecting the lender's interest.[1]

3. **Professional Group:** Members of recognized professional bodies, such as Doctors,

Lawyers, or chartered accountants, may secure group coverage through their associations.[1]

4. **Other Groups:** This category includes diverse bodies like cooperative societies or the
members of residential societies, provided they meet the statutory requirements for group
formation.[1]

### **X) Policies for Children**

Marriage endowment and educational annuity plans.[1]

***

## **3.4 INSURABLE INTEREST IN LIFE INSURANCE**

### **Definition and Requirement**

According to **Patterson** insurable interest is a relation between the insured and the event
insured against so that occurrence of the event would result in substantial loss or injury of some
kind to the insured.[1]

The insured must be benefited by the safety of the subject-matter and suffers loss if the subject-
matter is lost, damaged or destroyed.[1]

'Interest' means 'if the event happens, the party will gain advantage, if it is frustrated, he will
suffer a loss'.[1]

For life insurance, insurable interest must exist **at the time the policy is taken out** (not
necessarily at the time of death) and is based on either a close blood/family relationship or a
financial relationship where the policy owner would suffer a financial hardship upon the
insured's death.[1]

### **Persons Having Insurable Interest**

In life policies, the following persons have been recognized as having insurable interest and
they may conveniently be considered under two main headings:[1]

### **A) Blood Relationship**

### **(i) On One's Own Life**

Everyone is presumed to have an **unlimited insurable interest** in their own life. This allows an
individual to purchase a policy on themselves and name anyone as the beneficiary, though the
insurer may still require the beneficiary to have an interest in the insured.[1]

### **(ii) Husband or Wife**

Spouses are automatically considered to have an insurable interest in each other, based on
both the **emotional bond** and the **mutual financial dependency**. The loss of a partner
would undoubtedly cause financial hardship to the survivor.[1]

This is an exception to the general rule that insurable interest means pecuniary interest or an
interest which is capable of being expressed in terms of money.[1]

Policy taken during marriage, it continues after dissolution also.[1]

Policy on the life of fiancee, on the life of divorced wife.[1]

### **(iii) Parents and Children**

Parents have an insurable interest in the lives of their **minor children** (to cover unexpected
costs like funeral expenses), and conversely, **adult children** typically have an insurable
interest in their parents (to cover final expenses or loss of financial support). The interest is
primarily financial but often includes a strong emotional component.[1]

### **B) Contractual Relationship**

A wide variety of relations may acquire insurable interest by reason of contractual relationship.
Some of them are noted hereunder:[1]

### **(i) Debtor and Creditor**

A **creditor** (the lender) has an insurable interest in the life of their **debtor** (the borrower),
but only **up to the amount of the outstanding debt**. This policy ensures the creditor can
recover the loan balance if the debtor dies before repayment is complete.[1]

### **(ii) Partner and Co-partner**

Business partners have insurable interest in each other's lives as the death of one partner may
cause financial loss to the surviving partners due to dissolution or disruption of business.[1]

### **(iii) Principal and Agent**

A principal may have insurable interest in the life of an agent if the agent possesses special
skills or knowledge crucial to the principal's business.[1]
### **(iv) Trustee and Co-trustee**

Trustees may have insurable interest in each other's lives as the death of a co-trustee may
affect the administration of the trust.[1]

***

## **3.5 PROPOSAL AND POLICY**

### **Proposal Form**

The **proposal form** is the foundation document for a life insurance contract. It is a detailed
questionnaire that the proposer must complete with full disclosure of all material facts.[1]

The proposal form typically includes questions about:

**1. Age of the Proponent:** Age is an important material fact in the life insurance as the rate of
premium depends on the age of the insured.[1]

**2. Family History:** The risk in life policies depends on longevity of the assured and heredity
throws sufficient light and plays an important role in the determination of the probable longevity
of a person.[1]

Therefore medical officers usually put a number of questions about the birth and death of
brother, sister, parent and near relations, the disease from which they suffer then or suffered in
the past.[1]

Insanity of the near relatives is one of the things to be revealed.[1]

**3. Personal Health:** The present state of health is material because no prudent insurer would
underwrite the life of a person afflicted with a fatal disease or who is one on a death bed.[1]

**4. Geographical Position:** The place where the applicant lives an important, as climate and
environment have an appreciable effect on the health.[1]

Unhealthy surrounding have a tendency to shorten the life.[1]

Further particular place may be subject to earthquake volcanoes and floods.[1]

Therefore applicant must give his residential address.[1]

**5. Occupation:** If it is dangerous occupation like soldier, sailor, airman or a workmen in an

ammunition factory the insurer charge a higher rate of premium.[1]
**6. Habits in Life:** The habits of life past and present which tend to shorten the life must be
disclosed e.g. the use of opium, tobacco or alcohol.[1]

### **Material Facts That Must Be Disclosed**

Insurance companies fix the premium on the basis of the average rates of mortality.[1]

Every facts which shorten the life of the insured is material.[1]

Information relating to age, health and disease, habits, family history, nature of business or
profession.[1]

The material facts for Life Insurance will directly affect the insured person's mortality risk:

**Age** is material because it is the primary factor used to calculate the applicant's life
expectancy and determine the basic premium rate.[1]

**Disease/Health** is crucial; any condition that shortens the life or requires ongoing medical
attention is an important risk factor that must be disclosed.[1]

**Habits** such as smoking, excessive alcohol use, or drug use increase health risks
significantly, which leads to a higher premium to cover the increased hazard.[1]

**Family History** is relevant for assessing potential hereditary risks, such as a family history of
genetic diseases or a pattern of short lifespans.[1]

**Place of Residence** matters if the location presents a heightened environmental risk, such as
areas with high pollution or a high incidence of a particular disease.[1]

An individual's **Profession** is also material, as hazardous occupations (like construction or

mining) increase the risk of accidental death or injury, impacting the premium.[1]

### **The Policy Document**

The **policy** is the formal written document evidencing the contract of life insurance. It
contains:

- Policy number and date of commencement

- Name and details of the policyholder
- Sum assured
- Premium amount and payment frequency
- Policy term and maturity date
- Nomination details (if any)
- Terms and conditions
- Exclusions and limitations
- Bonus provisions (if applicable)[1]

***

## **3.6 NON-DISCLOSURE AND MISREPRESENTATION**

### **Principle of Utmost Good Faith**

The person getting insured must willingly disclose and surrender to the insurer his complete true
information regarding the subject matter of insurance.[1]

If the assured fails to make such disclosure, the insurer may avoid the contract.[1]

The reason being that important facts having or bearing on the contract are known only to the
insured.[1]

E.g. how many time he claimed under fire or burglary policy, how many time he fallen ill etc.[1]

If he conceal anything which he knows to be material it is fraud.[1]

### **Statutory Protection—Section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938**

**Section 45** provides special protection to policyholders and prevents insurers from
repudiating policies on grounds of misstatement after a certain period.[2][3][4]

**Key Provisions of Section 45:**

**1. Three-Year Incontestability Period:** No policy of life insurance shall be called in question
by an insurer on the ground that a statement made in the proposal or in any report of a medical
officer, or referee, or friend of the insured, or in any other document leading to the issue of the
policy, was inaccurate or false, **after the expiry of three years** from the date on which the
policy was effected, i.e., from the date of commencement of risk.[3][4][2]

**2. Exception for Fraud:** On the ground of **fraud**, a policy of life insurance may be called in
question within **3 years** from:
- The date of issuance of policy, or
- The date of commencement of risk, or
- The date of revival of policy, or
- The date of rider to the policy,
whichever is later.[4][2]

**3. Burden of Proof on Insurer:** The insurer must prove that:

- The statement was inaccurate or false
- Such statement was on a **material matter** or that the statement suppressed facts which was
material to disclose
- The statement was **fraudulently made** by the insured
- The insured knew at the time of making the statement that it was false to his knowledge of
facts which it was material to disclose had been suppressed.[5][2]

**4. Materiality Test:** For the purposes of this sub-section, the misstatement of or suppression
of fact shall not be considered material unless it has a **direct bearing on the risk undertaken by
the insurer**. The onus is on the insurer to show that had the insurer been aware of the said
fact, **no life insurance policy would have been issued** to the insured.[6][2][5]

**5. Communication Requirement:** If the insurer intends to repudiate a policy on grounds of

misstatement or suppression, they must communicate the grounds for repudiation to the
policyholder in writing within a reasonable time.[2]

**6. Proof of Age Exception:** Nothing in this section shall prevent the insurer from calling for
proof of age at any time if he is entitled to do so, and no policy shall be deemed to be called in
question merely because the terms of the policy are adjusted on subsequent proof that the age
of the life insured was incorrectly stated in the proposal.[3][2]

**Illustration:** Mr. A takes a life insurance policy on January 1, 2020. In his proposal form, he
does not disclose that he had been treated for hypertension two years earlier. Mr. A dies on July
1, 2024 (4 years and 6 months after policy commencement). The insurer discovers the non-
disclosure during claim investigation. Under Section 45, the insurer **cannot repudiate** the
claim because more than three years have elapsed since policy commencement, and fraud has
not been established.

**Case Analysis:** The Supreme Court has consistently held that Section 45 places a heavy
burden on insurers to prove fraud. Mere inaccuracy or omission is insufficient after three years;
the insurer must demonstrate that the non-disclosure was deliberate, material, and made with
fraudulent intent.[7][2]

***

## **3.7 ASSIGNMENT OF LIFE INSURANCE POLICY**

### **Introduction and Statutory Provision**

The provision regarding assignment and transfer are given in **Section 38 of the Insurance Act
1938**.[8][9][10][1]

An assignment is the complete transfer of the rights, title and the interest in the policy.[1]
Briefly stated, an assignment is an instrument through which the beneficial interest rights and
title under the policy are transferred.[1]

So far life policies are concerned, the assignment could be made either by endorsement on the
policy itself or through a separate instrument which should be signed either by the assigner or
his duly authorized agent and attested by at least one witness.[10][8][1]

### **Procedure for Assignment (Section 38)**

**1. Method of Assignment:** This policy may be transferred/assigned, wholly or in part, with or
without consideration. An assignment may be effected in a policy by an endorsement upon the
policy itself or by a separate instrument under notice to the insurer.[9][8][10]

**2. Content Requirements:** The instrument of assignment should indicate:

- The fact of transfer or assignment
- The reasons for the assignment or transfer
- Antecedents of the assignee
- Terms on which assignment is made.[8][10]

**3. Attestation:** The assignment must be signed by the transferor or assignor or duly
authorized agent and attested by at least one witness.[10][8][1]

**4. Notice to Insurer:** The transfer of assignment shall not be operative as against an insurer
until a notice in writing of the transfer or assignment and either the said endorsement or
instrument itself or copy thereof certified to be correct by both transferor and transferee or their
duly authorized agents have been delivered to the insurer.[8][10]

**5. Fee:** Fee to be paid for assignment or transfer can be specified by the Authority through
Regulations.[10][8]

**6. Acknowledgment:** On receipt of notice with fee, the insurer should grant a written
acknowledgement of receipt of notice.[8][10]

**7. Insurer's Right to Refuse:** An insurer may accept the transfer or assignment, or decline to
act upon any endorsement made where it has sufficient reason to believe that such transfer or
assignment is **not bona fide** or is not in the interest of the policyholder or in public interest or
is for the purpose of trading of insurance policy.[11]

### **Features of Assignment**

Section 38 of the Insurance Act speaks that an assignment can be effected either by an
endorsement on the policy itself or through a separate instrument.[1]
A notice in writing must be given to the insurance company by the assigner along with the policy
document.[1]

The insurer must register the assignment in the book, and give written acknowledgement of the
receipt of such notice.[1]

The effect of the assignment should be the transfer of all rights and liability under the policy to
the assignee subject to condition.[1]

### **Necessary Conditions for Assigner & Assignee**

1. An assignment can be made by a person competent to contract and the assignee should not
have any legal disqualification.[1]

2. It must be in writing under the signature of the assignor and it should be attested at least by
one witness.[1]

3. Further the assignment should also not be in contravention of any law.[1]

### **Effect of Assignment**

1. The assignment once made cannot be cancelled despite the fact that no notice had been
given to the insurance company.[1]

2. If such an assignment is required to be cancelled, there should be a valid re-assignment.[1]

3. If the assignment is made on the policy itself, there is no need of any court fee.[1]

4. But if it has been done through a separate instrument it must be dully stamped.[1]

### **Types of Assignment**

### **A. Absolute Assignment**

1. An assignment may be absolute or conditional.[1]

2. Where all rights, title and interest in the policy are transferred to assignee without any
reservation it is known as absolute assignment.[1]

3. Generally it is made for a valuable consideration.[1]

4. Once such assignment made, it is irrevocable and assignor loses all rights in the policy.[1]

5. It becomes the property of assignee that, in his turn, may assign it to any other person.[1]
**Illustration:** Mr. X takes a loan of ₹10 lakhs from a bank and assigns his life insurance policy
with a sum assured of ₹15 lakhs to the bank as collateral. This is an absolute assignment for
valuable consideration. If Mr. X dies while the loan is outstanding, the bank receives the policy
proceeds and adjusts the outstanding debt, returning any surplus to the legal heirs.

### **B. Conditional Assignment**

Where the interest in the policy is transferred to the assignee only on assignor death, it is known
as conditional assignment.[1]

Such type of assignment is effected generally due to natural love and affection.[1]

**Illustration:** Mr. Y assigns his life insurance policy to his daughter with the condition that she
will receive the benefits only upon his death. During his lifetime, Mr. Y retains all rights in the
policy.

### **Relationship Between Assignment and Nomination**

**Section 38(4):** A transfer or assignment of a policy made in accordance with section 38 shall
**automatically cancel a nomination**. However, there is an exception: assignment of a policy to
the insurer for the purpose of a loan on the policy shall not cancel a nomination.[12][11]

***

## **3.8 NOMINATION**

### **Statutory Provision—Section 39 of the Insurance Act, 1938**

**Section 39** establishes the provisions for nomination by a policyholder in life insurance
policies.[13][14][12]

### **Key Provisions of Section 39**

**1. Right to Nominate:** The policyholder of a life insurance on his own life may nominate a
person or persons to whom money secured by the policy shall be paid in the event of his death.
[14][12][13]

**2. Minor Nominee:** Where the nominee is a minor, the policyholder may appoint any person
to receive the money secured by the policy in the event of policyholder's death during the
minority of the nominee. The manner of appointment to be laid down by the insurer.[13][14][1]

**3. Time of Nomination:** Nomination can be made at any time before the maturity of the
policy.[14][13]
**4. Mode of Nomination:** Nomination may be incorporated in the text of the policy itself or may
be endorsed on the policy communicated to the insurer and can be registered by the insurer in
the records relating to the policy.[13][14]

**5. Cancellation or Change:** Nomination can be cancelled or changed at any time before
policy matures, by an endorsement or a further endorsement or a will as the case may be.[14]
[13][1]

**6. Notice Requirement:** A notice in writing of change or cancellation of nomination must be

delivered to the insurer for the insurer to be liable to such nominee. Otherwise, insurer will not
be liable if a bonafide payment is made to the person named in the text of the policy or in the
registered records of the insurer.[13][14]

**7. Acknowledgment and Fee:** Insurers must provide written acknowledgment of registering a
nomination, cancellation, or change, and may charge a nominal fee not exceeding one rupee for
registering such changes.[12][13]

**8. Effect of Assignment:** Any transfer or assignment of a policy under Section 38

automatically cancels a nomination, with a specific exception for assignments to the insurer for
loan purposes.[12][13]

**9. Payment of Policy Proceeds:**

- If the policy matures during the lifetime of the insured person or if all nominees die before the
policy matures, the policy amount becomes payable to the policy-holder, their heirs, legal
representatives, or the holder of a succession certificate.[12][13]

- If one or more nominees survive the insured person, the policy amount becomes payable to
such surviving nominee(s).[12][13]

### **Legal Status of Nominee**

**Important Legal Principle:** The Supreme Court has held that **a nominee under Section 39 is
merely a receiver of the policy money** and is expected to distribute it among legal heirs
according to succession laws.[12]

The nomination does not confer beneficial ownership; the nominee holds the money in trust for
the legal heirs unless there is clear evidence (such as a Will) that the policyholder intended to
make a gift to the nominee.[12]

**Case Reference—Supreme Court Ruling (2024):** The Supreme Court emphasized that the
Insurance Act cannot override succession laws. The nominee is not the absolute owner but a
trustee for legal heirs.[12]
### **Nomination vs. Assignment**

| Feature | Nomination | Assignment |

|---------|------------|------------|
| **Nature** | Designates who receives money upon death | Transfers ownership of policy |
| **Effect** | Nominee is a trustee for legal heirs | Assignee becomes absolute owner (if
absolute) |
| **Revocability** | Can be changed anytime before maturity | Absolute assignment is
irrevocable |
| **Rights During Life** | Nominee has no rights during insured's life | Assignee may have
immediate rights |
| **Cancellation** | Automatically cancelled by assignment | Assignment cancels nomination |

[11][13][12][1]

### **Exclusion—Married Women's Property Act**

Section 39 does not apply to policies covered under **Section 6 of the Married Women's
Property Act, 1874**, except when nominations expressly state they are made under Section
39.[13][12]

**Illustration:** Mr. Z has a life insurance policy with a sum assured of ₹20 lakhs. He nominates
his mother as the nominee. Mr. Z dies, leaving behind his wife, two children, and his mother.
The mother, as nominee, receives the ₹20 lakhs from the insurer. However, legally, she holds
this money in trust for Mr. Z's legal heirs (wife and children) according to succession law, unless
Mr. Z explicitly made a Will stating the money is a gift to his mother.

***

## **3.9 CLAIMS OF POLICY**

### **Introduction**

"If a child, a spouse, a life partner, or a parent depends on you and your income, you need life
insurance".[1]

The whole idea of insurance has developed on the fact that human life is full of uncertainties
and the life of a person itself is very uncertain.[1]

The scheme of life insurance provides an assurance that if such an event happens, the person
or his dependents would get financial assistance to bear the loss.[1]

### **Settlement of Claim**

The easy and timely settlement of a valid claim is an important function of an insurance
company.[1]

The measure to judge insurance company's efficiency is as to how quick the claim settlement is.
[1]

The speed, kindness and fairness with which an insurer handles claims show the maturity of the
company and may lead to great satisfaction of the client.[1]

It is the liability of the insurance company to honour valid and legal claims.[1]

At the same the company must identify the fraudulent and invalid claims.[1]

A claim may arise:[1]

**i) On death of Policyholder before the maturity date**

**ii) On maturity**, i.e. after expiry of the endowment period specified in the policy contract when
the policy money becomes payable

***

## **3.10 DEATH CLAIMS**

### **I. Intimation of Death**

The death of the life assured has to be intimated in writing to the insurer.[1]

It can be done by the Assignee or nominee under the policy or from a person representing such
Assignee or Nominee or when there is no nomination or assignment by a relative of the life
assured, the employer, the agent or the development officer.[1]

Where policy is assigned to a creditor or a bank for valuable consideration, intimation of death
may be received from such assignee.[1]

The intimation of the death of the life assured by the claimant should contain the following
particulars:[1]

1. his or her relationship with the deceased

2. the name of the policyholder
3. the number/s of the policy/policies
4. the date of death
5. the cause of death and
6. sum assured etc.[1]

### **II. Proof of Death and Other Documents**

In case of claim by death, after the receiving the intimation of death the insurance company
ensures that the insurance policy has been in force for the sum assured on the date of death
and the intimation has been received from assignee, nominee or other claimant.[1]

The following documents are required:[1]

**(i) Certificate of death**

**(ii) Proof of age of the life assured** (if not already given)

**(iii) Deeds of assignment / reassignments**

**(iv) Policy document**

**(v) Form of discharge**

**If the claim has accrued within three years from the beginning of the policy**, the following
additional requirements may be called for:[1]

**(i) Statement from the hospital** if the deceased had been admitted to the hospital

**(ii) Certificate of medical attendant** of the deceased giving details of his/her last illness

**(iii) Certificate of cremation or burial** to be given by a person of known character and

responsibility present at the cremation or burial of the body of the deceased

**(iv) Certificate by employer** if the deceased was an employee

**(v) In case of an air crash** the certificate from the airline authorities would be necessary
certifying that the assured was a passenger on the plane

**(vi) In case of ship accident** a certified extract from the logbook of the ship is required

**(vii) If the life assured had a death due to accident, suicide or unknown cause** the police
inquest report, panchanama, post mortem report, etc would be required[1]

### **Additional Benefits Apart from Regular Claims**

**Double Accident Benefit:** Normally for claiming this benefit documents like FIR, Post-mortem
Report are required.[1]
**Disability Benefit Claims:** Waiver of all premiums to be paid in future till the expiry of the
policy of the life assured if a person is totally and permanently disabled and cannot earn any
wage/compensation/profit as a result of the accident.[1]

***

## **3.11 MATURITY CLAIMS**

If the life insured survives to the full term, then basic sum assured is payable.[1]

This payment by the insurer to the insured on the date of maturity is called maturity payment.[1]

The amount payable at the time of the maturity includes a sum assured and bonus/incentives.[1]

The insurer sends in advance the intimation to the insured with a blank discharge form for filling
various details in it.[1]

It is to be returned to the office along with:

**i. Original Policy document**

**ii. Age proof if age is not already submitted**

**iii. Assignment /reassignment, if any**[1]

### **Procedure of the Maturity Claims**

After receipt of completed and stamped discharge form from the person entitled to the policy
money along with policy documents, claim amount will be paid by account payee cheque.[1]

If the life assured is reported to have died after the date of maturity but before the receipt is
discharged, the claim is to be treated as the maturity claim and paid to the legal heirs.[1]

In this case death certificate and evidence of title is required.[1]

Where the assured is known to be mentally deranged, a certificate from the court of law under
the Indian Lunacy Act appointing a person to act as guardian to manage the properties of the
lunatic should be called.[1]

***

**Unit 3 Complete. Confirm to proceed to Unit 4.**

Sources
[1] [Link] [Link]
[Link]/web/direct-files/attachments/86860808/9a415d19-381f-400a-a0f2-
0e678ab921c6/[Link]
[2] ANALYSIS OF PROVISIONS OF SECTION 45 OF THE INSURANCE ...
[Link]
1938/
[3] Section 45: Policy Not To Be Called In Question On Ground Of Mis ...
[Link]
45-0346224d98da168c
[4] Important information to know - Section 45
[Link]
important-to-know/
[5] Fraudulent Suppression of Material Facts in Life Insurance Policies ...
[Link]
insurance-policies-under-section-45-of-the-insurance-act,-1938/view
[6] 45 - India Code: Section Details [Link]
actid=AC_CEN_2_33_00044_193804_1523351752525&orderno=87
[7] Supreme Court's Enunciation of Insurance Law in India
[Link]
[8] [PDF] Section 38, 39, 41 & 45 of Insurance Act
[Link]
[9] Section 38 - ABSLI - Birla Sun Life [Link]
service/manage-your-policy/section-38/
[10] [PDF] Section 38 - Assignment and Transfer of Insurance Policies
[Link]
Insurance%20Laws%20(Amendment)%20Act,%202015%[Link]
[11] [PDF] INSURANCE ACT, 1938 – AMENDMENTS Section 38 - SBI Securities
[Link]
%[Link]
[12] Insurance Act Can't Override Succession Law - Drishti Judiciary
[Link]
[13] Section 39 - Nomination by policyholder - ABSLI
[Link]
[14] Section 39: Nomination By Policy Holder | The Insurance Act, 1938
[Link]
and-nominations-section-39-2876ed68d3548101
[15] Section 38: Assignment And Transfer Of Insurance Policies
[Link]
and-nominations-section-38-f59804fbdf090545
[16] The Insurance Act, 1938 | [Link] and transfer of insurance ...
[Link]
[17] [PDF] THE INSURANCE ACT, 1938 | India Code
[Link]
[18] [PDF] Section 38 in The Insurance Act, 1938 38. Assignment and transfer ...
[Link]
[19] Act Year - India Code: Section Details [Link]
actid=AC_CEN_2_33_00044_193804_1523351752525&orderno=74
[20] [PDF] section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938 - S3waas
[Link]
2022/08/[Link]
[21] The Insurance Act, 1938 | [Link] by policy-holder [Link]
175/[Link]
[22] [PDF] Kotak Life - Section 38, 39, 45 of insurance act 1938
[Link]
[Link]

# **UNIT 4: FIRE INSURANCE, PROPERTY INSURANCE, AND LIABILITY INSURANCE**

## **4.1 FIRE INSURANCE—DEFINITION AND NATURE**

### **Definition**

A fire insurance is a contract under which the insurer in return for a consideration (premium)
agrees to indemnify the insured for the financial loss which the latter may suffer due to
destruction of or damage to property or goods, caused by fire, during a specified period.[1][2][3]

Fire insurance is a specialized form of property insurance designed to protect against financial
losses resulting from fire damage to buildings, machinery, stocks, and other movable or
immovable property.[2][4]

### **Characteristics of Fire Insurance**

**1. Contract of Indemnity:** Fire insurance is fundamentally a contract of indemnity. This

means its primary function is to restore the insured to the financial position they held
immediately before the fire occurred, ensuring the insured cannot profit from the loss. The
payment will always be restricted to the amount of the actual loss or the sum insured, whichever
amount is smaller.[5][1]

**2. Contract of Utmost Good Faith (*Uberrimae Fidei*):** The policy is also a contract of utmost
good faith. This imposes a strict duty on the insured to voluntarily disclose every material fact
that would influence the insurer's decision to accept the risk or calculate the premium. If the fire
is proven to have been deliberate arson, nothing can be recovered, as a fraudulent act violates
this core principle and breaks the chain of causation by the insured peril.[1][5]
**3. Insurable Interest Requirement:** A valid insurable interest must exist in the property not
just when the policy is taken out, but critically, at the time the loss occurs. The insured must
possess a legitimate financial stake such that they would suffer a detriment if the property were
damaged by fire.[1]

**4. Doctrine of Contribution:** The Doctrine of Contribution applies when a property is covered
by several policies from different insurers. In such cases, the insured cannot collect the full loss
amount from every insurer; instead, each insurer is entitled to contribute a proportionate share
of the loss payment, reinforcing the principle that the insured is only indemnified once.[1]

***

## **4.2 STANDARD FIRE POLICY**

### **Introduction to Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy (SFSP)**

The **Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy** is the primary fire insurance product in India,
structured under the **All India Fire Tariff** which has eight sections:[2]

- **Section I:** General Rules and regulations

- **Section II:** Standard Fire and Special Peril Policy
- **Section III:** Dwelling, Offices, Shops etc.
- **Section IV:** Industrial/Manufacturing Risks
- **Section V:** Utilities outside industrial Risks
- **Section VI:** Storage Risks (Godowns etc.)
- **Section VII:** Tank farms/Gas Holders outside industrial Risks
- **Section VIII:** Add-on Covers[2]

The SFSP covers all properties on land (excluding cost of land), moveable or immovable, at
various locations against named perils.[3][4]

### **Perils Covered Under Standard Fire Policy**

The Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy covers **12 specified perils**:[6][3][2]

**1. Fire:** Loss or damage caused by actual fire with ignition accompanied by heat and/or
flame and some kind of chemical reaction (generally oxidation with atmospheric oxygen). Loss
by smoke, sparks consequent on ignition is covered.[3][2]

**2. Lightning:** Damage caused by lightning strike, whether or not it results in a fire.[6][3]

**3. Explosion/Implosion:** Loss or damage from explosion or implosion other than that caused
by nuclear reaction.[3][6]
**4. Aircraft Damage:** Damage caused by aircraft or articles dropped from them.[6][3]

**5. Riot, Strike, and Malicious Damage (RSMD):** Damage arising from riots, strikes, and
malicious acts.[3][6]

**6. Storm, Cyclone, Typhoon, Tempest, Hurricane, Tornado, Flood, and Inundation:** Damage
from natural calamities involving water and wind.[6][3]

**7. Impact Damage:** Damage caused by impact from road vehicles, rail vehicles, or animals.
[3][6]

**8. Subsidence and Landslide:** Including rockslide, but excluding subsidence due to workings
of underground coal, metalliferous and other mines.[6][3]

**9. Bursting and/or Overflowing of Water Tanks, Apparatus, and Pipes:** Water damage from
internal sources.[3][6]

**10. Missile Testing Operations:** Damage from missile testing activities.[6][3]

**11. Leakage from Automatic Sprinkler Installations:** Accidental water discharge from fire
protection systems.[3][6]

**12. Bush Fire:** Damage from fires originating outside the insured premises from vegetation
or bush.[6][3]

### **Losses Covered Under Fire Policy**

The following types of losses are covered under fire insurance policies when fire is the
proximate cause:[7][5][2][1]

**1. Goods Spoiled or Property Damaged by Water Used to Extinguish the Fire:** This is
covered because the damage from water or other extinguishing agents (like foam or chemicals)
is considered a necessary and unavoidable consequence of fighting the fire. The proximate
cause of this damage is the fire itself, which necessitated the use of water.[5][1]

**2. Pulling Down of Adjacent Premises by the Fire Brigade to Prevent Progress of Flame:**
This is covered under the principle of salvage or necessary sacrifice. The actions of the fire
brigade, though damaging, were taken solely to save the insured property from greater loss.
The financial loss incurred from demolishing a part of the insured premises or adjacent property
is considered proximately caused by the fire.[7][1]

**3. Breakage of Goods in Process of Removal from the Building Where Fire is Raging:**
Damage to insured goods that occurs during their removal from the burning premises to a place
of safety is covered (e.g., damage caused by throwing furniture out of a window). This is
considered damage proximately caused by the fire, as the removal was a reasonable act to
mitigate the ultimate loss, even if the goods were damaged in the process.[1]

**4. Wages Paid to Persons Employed for Extinguishing Fire:** Reasonable expenses, such as
the wages paid to temporary labor employed specifically to assist in extinguishing the fire or
saving the property, are covered. These are viewed as necessary sue and labor charges
incurred by the insured to minimize the loss, which benefits the insurer.[1]

**Illustration:** In *Stanley v. Western Insurance Co.*, it was held that "Any loss resulting from
the fire and resulting from the necessary and bonafide efforts to put out the fire whether by the
spoiling of goods by water or throwing the articles out the window or pulling down a house for
the purpose of preventing the spreading of the flames are within the policy of fire insurance".[7]

***

## **4.3 PROXIMATE CAUSE IN FIRE INSURANCE**

### **Definition and Importance**

The doctrine of **proximate cause** (*causa proxima*) is fundamental in determining whether a

fire insurance claim is payable. The Latin maxim *"causa proxima non remota spectatur"*
means "the immediate, not the remote, cause is to be considered".[8][5][7]

**Proximate cause** is the active, efficient cause that sets in motion a train of events which
brings about a result, without the intervention of any force started and working actively from a
new and independent source.[5]

### **Application in Fire Insurance**

**Case Law—*New India Assurance Company Limited v. Zuari Industries Limited*:** The
Supreme Court held that for a cause to be considered a proximate cause, there should not be
any break in the chain of causation between the initial event and the event immediate to the loss
of property. The requirement under Indian law to establish a proximate cause is the clear chain
of causation where there is no external involvement that interferes with or affects the chain of
causation. A damage that is by way of fire caused by lightning, explosion, or implosion may be
considered a proximate cause of damage. The essential test is that these factors must
ultimately lead to a fire, and the fire must be the proximate cause of damage.[9][8][5]

### **Illustrations of Proximate Cause in Fire Insurance**

**Illustration 1—Fire as Proximate Cause:** A textile company takes an insurance policy

covering fire damage. A fire breaks out in the insured premises, and while the fire is being
controlled, water used for extinguishing causes further damage to the textile stock. When the
company claims for fire damages stating fire as the proximate cause of the entire loss, the
insurance company cannot deny the claim for water damage arguing that the immediate cause
was water and not fire, because water damage was a direct and inevitable consequence of
efforts to control the fire. The insurer cannot escape liability by separating the causes into fire
and water damages and would be held liable to pay for the entire loss.[5]

**Illustration 2—Short Circuit Leading to Fire:** If a ship malfunction causes a fire that damages
cargo, then the fire is the proximate cause. If a flood causes electrical short-circuits that cause a
fire, the flood is the proximate cause.[10][5]

**Supreme Court Ruling:** The Supreme Court has ruled that the cause of a fire in a fire
insurance claim is irrelevant as long as the insured party is not held responsible for starting the
fire. The focus is on whether fire occurred and whether it is the proximate cause of the loss, not
on the specific origin of the fire.[11]

***

## **4.4 EXCLUSIONS FROM FIRE INSURANCE**

### **Losses Not Covered by Standard Fire Insurance**

The following losses are typically excluded from a basic fire policy and require specific
endorsements, separate policies, or are considered uninsurable:[2][1][3]

**1. Loss to Property by Its Own Defect (Inherent Vice):** Loss caused by a defect inherent to
the property itself, such as a bomb exploding due to internal chemical instability or spontaneous
combustion of certain goods, is not covered. This upholds the principle that insurance covers
accidental loss caused by an external peril, not an inevitable internal deterioration or defect.[2]
[1]

**2. Loss Due to Fire Caused by Earthquake, Act of Foreign Enemy, Riots:** Fires caused by
these events are classified as Excluded Perils. Catastrophic events like earthquake (natural
disaster) or war, riot, strike, and malicious damage (geopolitical/human perils) can cause
widespread, simultaneous losses that insurers cannot cover under a standard policy. Coverage
for these must be added via a separate, often compulsory, endorsement (e.g., an Earthquake
Endorsement or a Riot, Strike, and Malicious Damage Endorsement).[1][3]

**3. Loss Caused by Subterranean (Underground) Fire:** Fire caused by events originating
deep beneath the surface, such as volcanic activity or spontaneous combustion of underground
mineral deposits, is often excluded. These are treated similarly to earthquake-related fires as
large, non-standard geophysical events.[1]

**4. Loss Caused by Burning of Property by Order of Any Public Authority:** If a governmental
or public authority (like the fire brigade or police) orders the destruction of property (e.g., to
prevent the spread of a disease, create a firebreak, or enforce demolition orders), the resulting
loss is not covered. The proximate cause of the loss is the deliberate legal act, not the
accidental peril of fire.[1]

**5. Loss by Theft During or After the Occurrence of Fire:** Standard fire policies cover damage
to the property, not losses due to theft. If property is stolen while the premises are unsecured
during the fire or during the removal of salvaged goods, this is considered a separate risk and is
excluded. Coverage for theft must be secured under a separate Burglary and Theft policy.[2][1]

**6. War, Invasion, Civil Commotion:** Loss, destruction, or damage directly or indirectly caused
by war, invasion, acts of foreign enemy, hostilities (whether war be declared or not), civil war,
rebellion, revolution, insurrection, military or usurped power, or civil commotion assuming the
proportions of or amounting to a popular rising.[7][3]

**7. Nuclear Risks:** Loss, destruction, or damage directly or indirectly caused by ionizing
radiations or contamination by radioactivity from any nuclear fuel or from any nuclear waste
from the combustion of nuclear fuel, or the radioactive toxic, explosive, or other hazardous
properties of any explosive nuclear assembly or nuclear component thereof.[3]

**8. Pollution or Contamination:** Loss, destruction, or damage caused to the insured property
by pollution or contamination, excluding:
- (a) Pollution or contamination which itself results from a peril insured against
- (b) Any peril insured against which itself results from pollution or contamination[2][3]

**9. Specified Valuables:** Loss, destruction, or damage to bullion or unset precious stones, any
curios or works of art for an amount exceeding ₹10,000, goods held in trust or on commission,
manuscripts, plans, drawings, securities, obligations or documents of any kind, stamps, coins,
or paper money, cheques, books of accounts or other business books, computer systems
records, explosives unless otherwise expressly stated in the policy.[3]

**10. Change of Temperature in Cold Storage:** Loss, destruction, or damage to the stocks in
cold storage premises caused by change of temperature.[3]

**11. Excess/Deductible:**
- The first 5% of each claim (Minimum ₹10,000) in losses arising out of "Act of God perils"
- ₹10,000 in other losses[2]

***

## **4.5 CONDITIONS FOR VALID FIRE CLAIM**

A claim for loss by fire must satisfy the following conditions:[2][1]

**1. Loss Must Be Caused by Actual Fire:** There must be actual ignition accompanied with
heat and/or flame and some kind of chemical reaction (generally oxidation with atmospheric
oxygen), not just by high temperature.[1][2]

**2. The Proximate Cause of Loss Should Be Fire:** The fire must be the dominant and effective
cause of the loss, not a remote cause.[5][1]

**3. The Loss Must Relate to Subject Matter of Policy:** Only property specified in the policy
schedule is covered.[1]

**4. The Fire Must Be Accidental, Not Intentional:** Deliberate arson by the insured voids
coverage. If proven to have been intentional, nothing can be recovered, as a fraudulent act
violates the principle of utmost good faith.[11][1]

***

## **4.6 TYPES OF FIRE POLICIES**

### **1. Comprehensive Policy**

Also known as "all in one policy," it covers risks like fire, theft, burglary, third-party risks, etc. It
may also cover loss of profits during the period the business remains closed due to fire.[1]

### **2. Valued Policy**

A valued policy is a departure from the contract of indemnity. Under it, the insured can recover a
fixed amount agreed to at the time the policy is taken. In the event of loss, only the fixed amount
is payable, irrespective of the actual amount of loss.[1]

### **3. Floating Policy**

A floating policy covers loss by fire caused to property belonging to the same person but located
at different places under a single sum and for one premium. Such a policy might cover goods
lying in two warehouses at two different locations. This policy is always subject to average
clause.[1]

### **4. Replacement or Reinstatement Policy**

A replacement policy is one in which the insurer inserts a reinstatement clause, whereby he
undertakes to pay the cost of replacement of the property damaged or destroyed by fire. Thus,
he may reinstate or replace the property instead of paying cash.[12][1]

***
## **4.7 SUBROGATION IN FIRE INSURANCE**

### **Principle**

Subrogation is the substitution of one person in place of another in relation to a claim, its rights,
remedies, or securities.[1]

Having satisfied the claim of the assured, the insurer stands in the place and is subrogated to all
the rights of the insured.[1]

In other words, the subrogee steps into the shoes of the person whose rights are subrogated to
him.[1]

### **Application in Fire Insurance**

If property insured under a fire policy is damaged by fire caused by the negligence of a third
party, and the insurer indemnifies the insured, the insurer acquires the right to sue that third
party to recover the amount paid.

**Illustration:** A factory insured under a fire policy suffers a fire due to the negligence of a
neighboring factory that allowed combustible materials to ignite and spread. The insurer pays
the claim of ₹50 lakhs to the insured factory owner. Under the principle of subrogation, the
insurer can now sue the negligent neighbor to recover the ₹50 lakhs. This prevents the insured
from receiving double compensation—once from the insurer and once from the negligent party.

***

## **4.8 DOUBLE INSURANCE, CONTRIBUTION, AND AVERAGE**

### **Double Insurance**

Double insurance is a form of insurance wherein the individual/company insures a particular

property with more than one insurer or with multiple policies from the same insurer.[1]

In double insurance, the insured can claim from all the insurers, but the actual amount of loss
incurred will be shared by all the insurers in the proportion of the sum insured.[1]

### **Principle of Contribution**

Principle of Contribution is a corollary of the principle of indemnity.[1]

According to this principle, the insured can claim the compensation only to the extent of actual
loss either from all insurers or from any one insurer.[1]
If one insurer pays full compensation, then that insurer can claim proportionate contribution from
the other insurers.[1]

**Essential Conditions of Contribution:**

- i. All the insurance must relate to the same subject-matter
- ii. The policies concerned must all cover the same interest of the same insured
- iii. The policies concerned must all cover the same peril which caused the loss[1]

**Illustration:** A warehouse valued at ₹1 crore is insured with Insurer A for ₹60 lakhs and with
Insurer B for ₹40 lakhs (total insurance = ₹1 crore). A fire causes a loss of ₹50 lakhs. The
insured can claim the full ₹50 lakhs from either insurer. If Insurer A pays the entire ₹50 lakhs,
Insurer A can recover a proportionate contribution from Insurer B: (₹40 lakhs / ₹1 crore) × ₹50
lakhs = ₹20 lakhs.

### **Average Clause**

The **average clause** applies when property is under-insured (sum insured is less than actual
value). Under this clause, the insured is treated as their own insurer for the difference, and the
claim is reduced proportionately.

**Formula:** Claim payable = (Sum Insured / Actual Value) × Actual Loss

**Illustration:** A building valued at ₹20 lakhs is insured for only ₹10 lakhs (under-insured). A
fire causes damage of ₹8 lakhs. Under the average clause:

Claim payable = (₹10 lakhs / ₹20 lakhs) × ₹8 lakhs = ₹4 lakhs

The insured receives only ₹4 lakhs instead of ₹8 lakhs because they are deemed to be their
own insurer for 50% of the value.

***

## **4.9 PROPERTY INSURANCE AND LIABILITY INSURANCE**

### **A. Property Insurance**

**Property insurance** covers physical assets (buildings, machinery, stock, furniture) against
loss or damage from specified perils including fire, theft, natural calamities, and accidental
damage.[4][1]

**Types of Property Insurance:**

**1. Fire Insurance:** Covers damage to property caused by fire and special perils as discussed
above.[4][1]
**2. Burglary and Theft Insurance:** Covers loss of property due to theft following forcible entry
or exit.[1]

**3. All Risk Property Insurance:** Comprehensive coverage for property against all risks except
those specifically excluded.[1]

**Risk Insured:** Property insurance covers risks such as:

- Fire and lightning
- Explosion and implosion
- Natural calamities (flood, earthquake, storm)
- Impact damage
- Burglary and theft
- Riots and strikes
- Water damage[6][2][1]

### **B. Liability Insurance**

**Liability insurance** protects the insured against legal liability to third parties for death, bodily
injury, illness, or property damage caused by the insured's negligence or by activities for which
the insured is legally responsible.[13][14]

Unlike property insurance (which is first-party insurance covering the insured's own property),
liability insurance is **third-party insurance** covering the insured's legal obligation to others.
[14]

***

## **4.10 CONTRACTORS' RISK INSURANCE (CONTRACTORS' ALL RISKS INSURANCE)**

### **Nature and Scope**

Contractors' Risk Insurance, also known as **Contractors' All Risks (CAR) Insurance**, provides
coverage for construction and erection projects against unforeseen physical loss or damage
during the period of construction.[1]

**Coverage:** The policy covers:

**1. Material Damage Section:**

- Loss or damage to works under construction
- Loss or damage to construction plant, equipment, and machinery at the site
- Loss or damage to construction materials
- Loss or damage due to natural calamities, fire, theft, collapse, subsidence
**2. Third-Party Liability Section:**
- Legal liability for death or bodily injury to third parties
- Legal liability for damage to third-party property arising out of construction operations

**Insured Parties:** The policy typically covers:

- The Principal (project owner)
- The Main Contractor
- Sub-contractors
- Consulting engineers
- Any other party having an insurable interest in the project

**Illustration:** A construction company undertakes to build a bridge. A CAR policy is taken

covering the bridge under construction. During construction, heavy rains cause a partially
completed pier to collapse, and a crane at the site is damaged. Additionally, falling debris
injures a passerby. The CAR policy will cover: (1) the cost of rebuilding the collapsed pier, (2)
repair/replacement of the damaged crane, and (3) the legal liability for injury to the passerby.

***

## **4.11 EMPLOYER'S LIABILITY INSURANCE**

### **Nature and Scope**

**Employer's Liability Insurance** covers the legal liability of employers for compensation
payable to employees who suffer death, bodily injury, or disease arising out of and in the course
of their employment.[1]

This insurance is distinct from statutory insurance under the **Employees' State Insurance Act,
1948** (ESI) or **Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923**. It provides coverage for employees
not covered under these Acts or for amounts exceeding statutory compensation.[1]

**Coverage:** The policy covers:

- Death of an employee due to work-related accidents
- Bodily injury or disease caused during employment
- Legal costs and expenses in defending claims
- Compensation payable under common law or statutory provisions

**Who Needs This Insurance:** Employers in industries not covered under ESI, or those
employing workers for whom statutory insurance limits are insufficient.[1]

**Illustration:** A small manufacturing unit employs 8 workers. One worker suffers severe burns
due to a machinery malfunction. The Workmen's Compensation Act provides a maximum
compensation of ₹2 lakhs, but the actual medical expenses and loss of earning capacity
amount to ₹10 lakhs. The employer's liability insurance covers the additional ₹8 lakhs and legal
defense costs if the worker files a civil suit.

***

## **4.12 GOODS IN TRANSIT INSURANCE (CARGO INSURANCE—INLAND)**

### **Nature and Scope**

**Goods in Transit Insurance** (also called **Inland Transit Insurance** or **Cargo Insurance**)
covers loss or damage to goods while being transported by road, rail, or inland waterways within
the country.[1]

**Coverage:** The policy covers:

- Loss or damage due to fire, explosion, collision, overturning, or derailment of the conveyance
- Loss or damage due to theft, burglary, or pilferage during transit
- Loss or damage due to natural calamities like flood, landslide, earthquake
- Loss or damage during loading and unloading operations
- General Average and Salvage charges (in water transit)

**Exclusions:** Typically excluded are:

- Loss due to ordinary wear and tear, inherent vice, or inadequate packing
- Loss due to delay
- Consequential losses
- War and nuclear risks (unless specifically covered)

**Illustration:** A consignment of electronic goods valued at ₹50 lakhs is transported from Delhi
to Bangalore by road. En route, the truck meets with an accident, and goods worth ₹20 lakhs
are damaged. The Goods in Transit Insurance policy will indemnify the consignor/consignee for
the ₹20 lakhs loss, subject to policy terms.

***

## **4.13 PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE**

### **Introduction—Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991**

The **Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991** is a landmark legislation enacted to provide liability
insurance for the purpose of immediate assistance to those affected by accidents while handling
hazardous substances.[15][16][17][13]

**Statutory Provision:** The Act was enacted to provide for public liability insurance for giving
immediate relief to the persons affected by accident occurring while handling any hazardous
substance and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.[15]
### **Key Definitions Under the Act**

**Section 2 of the Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991** provides the following definitions:[18]
[13]

**1. Accident:** A sudden or unexpected incident related to a hazardous substance that causes
continuous or temporary exposure or injury to a person but does not result in an accident that is
solely caused by war or radioactivity.[13]

**2. To Deal with Hazardous Substances:** To manage the production, handling, packaging,
storage, transportation, use, collection, destruction, conversion, offering for sale, transfer, or
removal of hazardous substances.[13]

**3. Owner:** The person who controls and handles hazardous substances at the time of the
accident:
- Partners, in the case of a company
- Any member, in case of an association[13]

**4. Hazardous Substance:** Any substance or preparation defined as hazardous under the
Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.[15][13]

**5. Relief Fund:** The Environmental Relief Fund established under Section 7A.[18][13]

### **Obligations of Owner (Section 3)**

**Section 3** mandates that before handling hazardous substances, the owner must have
insurance policies regulating an insurance contract in which they are insured.[16][13]

**Key Requirements:**
- Each owner must obtain an insurance policy before entering into handling hazardous
substances
- The insurance policy must be extended from time to time before the expiration date so that the
insurance policy continues to apply throughout the period in which this processing continues[13]

**Minimum Insurance Amount:** Any insurance policy taken out or renewed by the owner shall
be for an amount not less than the paid-up capital of the undertaking that handles any
hazardous substance, and the amount should not be less than ₹50 crores or as prescribed.[13]

### **No-Fault Liability**

The Act establishes a **no-fault liability regime**, meaning that the owner is liable to pay relief
even in the absence of proof of negligence. The victim need not prove fault or negligence on the
part of the owner.[17][13]
### **Relief Payable**

Under **Section 3(2)**, the owner shall be liable to pay relief to persons affected by an accident
as per the scheme provided in the Schedule to the Act:[15][13]

**Relief for Death:** Amount prescribed based on nature of accident

**Relief for Permanent Total Disability:** Amount prescribed
**Relief for Permanent Partial Disability:** Amount prescribed proportionate to disability
**Relief for Temporary Disability:** Amount prescribed for treatment period

### **Environmental Relief Fund (Section 7A)**

An **Environmental Relief Fund** shall be established by the Central Government for making
relief payments in cases where:
- The owner is unable to pay the relief amount
- The accident involves a substance not covered by insurance[18][15]

### **Application and Adjudication**

**Collector's Role:** Claims for relief are filed before the **District Collector**, who acts as the
adjudicating authority under the Act.[18][13]

**Time Limit:** Application for relief must be made within **5 years** from the date of accident.
[13]

**Powers of Collector:** The Collector has powers similar to a civil court for:
- Summoning and examining witnesses
- Requiring production of documents
- Issuing commissions for examination of witnesses
- Passing interim orders[18]

### **Illustration**

A chemical manufacturing plant in Bhopal handles toxic gases classified as hazardous

substances. As per the Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991, the owner must obtain public liability
insurance of at least ₹50 crores before commencing operations. An accidental gas leak occurs,
affecting 500 residents in the vicinity. The affected persons can file claims before the District
Collector for immediate relief for death, injury, or disability without having to prove negligence.
The insurance company must provide immediate compensation as per the Schedule, and any
shortfall is covered by the Environmental Relief Fund.
**Case Context:** The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991 was enacted in response to the
**Bhopal Gas Tragedy (1984)**, which highlighted the need for immediate relief mechanisms for
victims of industrial accidents involving hazardous substances.[17]

***

**Unit 4 Complete. Confirm to proceed to Unit 5.**

Sources
[1] [Link] [Link]
[Link]/web/direct-files/attachments/86860808/9a415d19-381f-400a-a0f2-
0e678ab921c6/[Link]
[2] [PDF] 2.0 fire insurance - NICOA [Link]
[3] [PDF] Fire Policy Wording - SBI General Insurance
[Link]
[4] Standard Fire And Special Perils Policy | Fire Insurance [Link]
insurance-policy-for-home
[5] Proximate Cause: Principle of Insurance Law - Vintage Legal
[Link]
[6] 12 Perils Covered in Standard Fire Insurance Explained - SecureNow
[Link]
[7] Causa proxima on fire insurance - ORIGIN26 LAW LABS [Link]
proxima-on-fire-insurance/
[8] Proximate Cause Doctrine Under Fire | PDF | Insurance - Scribd
[Link]
[9] [PDF] IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Civil Appeal No. 4436 of 2004 ...
[Link]
[10] fire+insurance+policy+statute | Indian Case Law - CaseMine
[Link]
[11] Supreme Court Ruling: Fire Insurance Valid Even if Insured Not at ...
[Link]
ruling-fire-insurance-valid-even-if-insured-not-at-fault-for-fire-outbreak-3
[12] [PDF] STANDARD FIRE AND SPECIAL PERILS POLICY
[Link]
[Link]
[13] Overview of Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991 - iPleaders
[Link]
[14] Liability Insurance - Public Liability - Industrial - New India Assurance
[Link]
[15] [PDF] THE PUBLIC LIABILITY INSURANCE ACT, 1991 - India Code
[Link]
[16] Public Liability (Act) Insurance Policy Online [Link]
insurance/liabilities-insurance/[Link]
[17] Why Public Liability Insurance Act 1991 matters for Indian businesses
[Link]
1991-matters-for-indian-businesses
[18] [PDF] The Public Liability Insurance Rules 1991
[Link]
[Link]
[19] "proximate+cause"+insurance | Indian Case Law - CaseMine
[Link]
[20] [PDF] nonreportable - Supreme Court of India
[Link]
[Link]
[21] [PDF] STANDARD FIRE & SPECIAL PERILS POLICY - UJVN Limited
[Link]

# **UNIT 5: MOTOR INSURANCE, ACCIDENT INSURANCE, AND SOCIAL SECURITY

INSURANCE**

## **5.1 MOTOR INSURANCE—SCOPE AND NATURE**

### **Definition**

Motor insurance is a contract of insurance that provides financial protection against physical
damage and/or bodily injury resulting from traffic accidents and against liability that could arise
from incidents involving a motor vehicle.[1][2]

Motor insurance is mandatory under Indian law, ensuring that vehicle owners have financial
protection and that victims of accidents receive compensation.[3][2][4][1]

### **Types of Motor Insurance**

Motor insurance is broadly classified into two categories:

### **1. Third-Party Liability Insurance (Compulsory)**

**Third-party insurance** or liability coverage is a statutory requirement under the Motor

Vehicles Act, 1988.[3]

As the name suggests, the beneficiary of the policy is not the two parties involved in the
contract. The vehicle owner and the insurance company are not the beneficiaries of this
contract. The insured is not provided with any benefit. Rather, it helps in covering the legal
liability owed by the insured to the third party on account of the disability/death caused to the
party by the insured's vehicle.[3]
This insurance cover is mandatory, and non-life insurance companies are obligated to provide it.
[3]

**Coverage:** Third-party liability insurance covers:

- Death or bodily injury to any third party (person other than the insured)
- Damage to third-party property caused by the insured vehicle
- Legal liability arising from accidents caused by the insured vehicle[1][3]

**Personal Accident Cover:** In addition to third-party liability, a compulsory personal accident

cover of ₹**15 lakhs** for the owner-driver is mandated.[1]

### **2. Comprehensive Insurance (Own Damage + Third-Party)**

It is advisable to buy the **comprehensive insurance policy** because it covers the insured, the
vehicle, and third parties in a single policy.[2][1]

This type of insurance covers all the risks covered in the Motor Vehicles Act plus loss or
damage caused to the vehicle itself.[1]

**Coverage under Comprehensive Motor Insurance:**

**A. Personal Accident Cover:** Coverage of ₹15 lakhs for the individual owner-driver of the
vehicle while traveling, mounting, or dismounting from the car. Optional personal accident
covers for co-passengers are also available.[1]

**B. Third-Party Legal Liability:** Protection against legal liability due to accidental damages
resulting in the permanent injury or death of a person, and damage caused to surrounding
property.[1]

Subject to the limits of liability as laid down in the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, as amended from
time to time, the insurance company will indemnify the insured in the event of an accident
caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle.[1]

**C. Own Damage Cover:** Coverage for loss or damage to the insured vehicle from:
- Accidental collision, overturning
- Fire, explosion, self-ignition, lightning
- Burglary, theft, housebreaking
- Riot, strike, malicious damage
- Earthquake, flood, typhoon, hurricane, storm, tempest, inundation, cyclone, hailstorm, frost
- Acts of terrorism
- Transit by road, rail, inland waterway, lift, elevator, or air[1]

***
## **5.2 COMPULSORY INSURANCE OF MOTOR VEHICLES**

### **Statutory Provisions—Motor Vehicles Act, 1988**

**Section 146 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988** mandates that no person shall use or permit
any other person to use a motor vehicle in a public place unless there is in force an insurance
policy providing coverage against third-party risks.[5][4][2][3][1]

**Key Requirements Under Section 146:**

**1. Necessity for Insurance Against Third-Party Risk:** No person shall use, or cause or allow
any other person to use, a motor vehicle in a public place unless there is in force in relation to
the use of the vehicle by that person or that other person a policy of insurance complying with
the requirements of Chapter XI of the Act.[5][3][1]

**2. Mandatory Coverage:** The driver of the vehicle must always carry at least:
- **Bodily injury liability** coverage
- Coverage for **liability of property damage**[3]

**Case Law—*Govindan v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.:*** The court held that **no clause in
an insurance policy can override the third-party insurance policy**. This has been specifically
mentioned as the insurance sector for motors has two types of insurance, namely first-party and
third-party insurance.[3]

### **Section 147: Requirements of Policies and Limits of Liability**

**Section 147(1)** specifies that an insurer authorized to transact motor insurance business
must provide coverage for any damage to a third party's vehicle or person caused by the
insured.[3]

These policies are required to cover any accident in accordance with the value of the liability
incurred. A certificate is to be granted in the prescribed format containing prescribed particulars
and must be handed over to the insured.[3]

**Limits of Liability (as per Section 147):**

**A. Death or Bodily Injury:** The policy must cover liability for death or bodily injury to any
person without any financial limit.[5][1]

**B. Property Damage:** The policy must cover damage to property of third parties up to a limit
of ₹**7.5 lakhs** (as prescribed and subject to amendments).[5]

### **Section 149: Duty of Insurers to Satisfy Judgments and Awards**

**Section 149** places a statutory duty on insurance companies to satisfy judgments and
awards passed by courts or tribunals against insured persons in respect of third-party risks,
subject to policy terms.[6]

### **Section 157: Transfer of Certificate of Insurance**

**Section 157** provides that the certificate of insurance can be transferred to the new owner of
the vehicle if and when the vehicle is transferred to a new owner.[3]

In order to make the required changes with the authority in question, the transferee is required
to apply within **14 days** to make the necessary changes.[3]

**Case Law—*Karnataka SRTC v. New India Assurance Company Ltd.:*** The vehicle in
question was only given on hire in accordance with an agreement and was not transferred
completely. It was held by the court that the insurer would be held liable even in case of an
agreement of lease or hire. In the case of agreements for hire, liability cannot be excluded
merely on the basis that there is a case of extended contractual liability. Thus, even if the
transfer of the vehicle takes place without providing notice to the insurer, the liability of the
insurer will not cease.[3]

***

## **5.3 MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL (MACT)**

### **Statutory Provision—Section 165 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988**

**Section 165** empowers the **State Government** to constitute **Claims Tribunals** to

adjudicate upon claims for compensation arising out of motor vehicle accidents resulting in
death or bodily injury to persons or damages to any property of third parties.[7][8][9][10]

### **Constitution and Composition**

**Section 165(1):** A State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute
one or more Motor Accidents Claims Tribunals for such areas as may be specified in the
notification.[9][10]

**Section 165(2):** A Claims Tribunal shall consist of such number of members as the State
Government may think fit to appoint, and where it consists of two or more members, one of
them shall be appointed as the Chairman thereof.[10]

Typically, the Tribunal consists of a judicial officer with the rank of a **District Judge or Sessions
Judge**.[8][9]
**Section 165(3):** Subject to any rules that may be made in this behalf, the Claims Tribunal
may, for the purpose of adjudicating upon any claim for compensation, choose one or more
persons possessing special knowledge of any matter relevant to the inquiry to assist it in holding
the inquiry.[9]

### **Jurisdiction of Claims Tribunal (Section 166)**

**Section 166** specifies that a Claims Tribunal has jurisdiction to adjudicate claims for
compensation in respect of accidents involving death or bodily injury to persons or damage to
property arising out of the use of motor vehicles.[9]

A victim of an accident arising out of the use of motor vehicles may file their claim application to
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal within whose local limits of jurisdiction:
- The claimant resides, or
- The claimant carries on business, or
- The accident occurred.[8][9]

### **Application for Compensation (Section 166)**

Any person claiming compensation may make an application to the Claims Tribunal within
whose jurisdiction:
- The accident occurred, or
- The claimant resides or carries on business, or
- The defendant resides.[8][9]

### **Procedure of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal**

The procedure for filing and processing a claim before MACT involves the following steps:

### **Step 1: Seek Legal Advice**

The MACT claim process may look simpler, but it could be complex if expert advice is not
obtained. At the initial stage, the claimant must seek legal advice or consultation. Legal experts
will guide through the whole procedure and help to get claim compensation in less time;
otherwise, cases might take years to resolve.[8]

### **Step 2: Filing the Claim/Petition**

The claimant must submit a written **claim petition** to the tribunal, detailing:
- The nature of the claim
- The circumstances of the accident
- Details of injuries or death
- Particulars of the claimant and the deceased/injured
- Amount of compensation claimed
- Details of the vehicle, driver, owner, and insurance company involved.[7][9][8]

**Documents Required with Claim Petition:**

1. Copy of the **FIR** registered in connection with the accident, if any

2. Copy of the **MLC (Medico-Legal Case)/Post Mortem Report/Death Report** as the case
may be
3. Documents of the identity of the claimants and of the deceased in a death case
4. **Original bills** of expenses incurred on treatment along with treatment records
5. Documents of the educational qualifications of the deceased, if any
6. **Disability Certificate**, if already obtained, in an injury case
7. Proof of income of the deceased/injured
8. Documents about the age of the victim
9. The cover note of the **third-party insurance policy**, if any
10. An affidavit detailing the relationship of the claimants with the deceased
11. Any other document as required by MACT.[9][8]

**Court Fee:** A nominal court fee is required to file the petition. The amount varies depending
on the state and the claim amount. Ensure that the fee is paid at the time of filing.[7]

### **Step 3: Issuance of Notice (Service of Notice)**

After filing the petition, the tribunal issues a **notice** to the respondents, typically:
- The vehicle owner
- The driver
- The insurance company.[7][8]

The respondents must submit their response within a set period. The notice contains all details
and claims that the claimant mentioned in the petition. The date of hearing is also mentioned in
this notice, giving the insurer time to represent their view and evidence.[8]

### **Step 4: Submission of Written Statement by Respondents**

The respondents submit a **written statement**, either admitting or contesting the claims made
by the petitioner. This may include defenses such as:
- Lack of negligence
- Contributory negligence by the victim
- Disputes over the compensation amount
- Policy exclusions or breach of policy conditions.[7]

### **Step 5: Presentation of Evidence and Examination**

**Submission of Evidence:** Both sides present their evidence, including:

- Documents
- Witness statements
- Expert opinions
- Medical reports
- Detailed Accident Report (DAR) prepared by police.[7][8]

In the event of an accident, the police staff would have already inquired about the place. The
police have to make a **DAR (Detailed Accident Record)**, which contains every micro detail
that can be helpful to understand the incident and fault. Apart from this DAR, other evidence
such as medical reports, eyewitnesses, and many more pieces of evidence can also be
presented in MACT.[8]

**Cross-Examination:** Witnesses and the claimant may be cross-examined by the opposing

party to test the credibility of their testimony.[7]

### **Step 6: Final Hearing**

Once all evidence has been presented, the tribunal schedules a **final hearing** where both
parties make their closing arguments. This is the stage where the tribunal assesses the case in
its entirety.[7]

### **Step 7: Pronouncement of Judgment/Award**

The tribunal delivers its **judgment (award)**, which includes:

**A. Determining Liability:** The tribunal decides who is liable for the accident and to what
extent.[7]

**B. Quantum of Compensation:** The tribunal determines the amount of compensation

payable, based on:
- Loss of earning capacity (in case of death or permanent disability)
- Medical expenses
- Pain and suffering
- Loss of consortium and love and affection
- Funeral expenses (in death cases)
- Future medical expenses (in injury cases).[9][8][7]

**C. Allocation of Compensation:** The compensation is awarded to the claimants in

appropriate shares.[7]

**D. Interest:** The tribunal typically awards interest on the compensation amount from the date
of filing the claim until payment.[9]
**E. Direction to Pay:** The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunals shall, as a matter of rule, direct
the insurance companies or transport corporations or such other entities held liable to deposit
the compensation amount within a specified period.[11]

### **Section 169: Procedure and Powers of Claims Tribunals**

**Section 169** provides that a Claims Tribunal shall follow such procedure as may be
prescribed by the State Government for disposal of applications.[9]

The Tribunal has powers similar to a **civil court** under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
including powers to:
- Summon and examine witnesses
- Require production of documents
- Issue commissions for examination of witnesses
- Pass interim orders.[8][9]

### **Appeal**

An appeal against an award of the Claims Tribunal lies to the **High Court** within **90 days**
from the date of the award, under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.[9]

***

## **5.4 PERSONAL ACCIDENT INSURANCE**

### **Definition and Scope**

**Personal Accident Insurance** provides financial protection against death or disability

resulting from accidental bodily injury.[12]

Unlike life insurance, personal accident insurance is not a contract of certain amount but
provides compensation based on the nature and extent of injury.[12]

### **Coverage**

Personal accident policies typically cover:

**1. Accidental Death:** Payment of full sum assured to nominee/legal heirs in case of death
due to accident.[12]

**2. Permanent Total Disability (PTD):** Payment of full sum assured if the insured suffers total
and permanent disability preventing them from any gainful employment.[12]
**3. Permanent Partial Disability (PPD):** Payment of a percentage of sum assured based on
the schedule of benefits (e.g., loss of one limb, one eye, etc.).[12]

**4. Temporary Total Disability (TTD):** Weekly payments for the period during which the
insured is temporarily and totally disabled from working.[12]

**5. Medical Expenses:** Reimbursement of medical, surgical, and hospitalization expenses

incurred due to accident, subject to limits.[12]

### **Exclusions**

Typically, personal accident insurance does not cover:

- Death or injury due to suicide or intentional self-injury
- Injury while under the influence of alcohol or drugs
- Injury arising from participation in hazardous sports or activities (unless specifically covered)
- Injury due to war, nuclear risks
- Pre-existing ailments or diseases (unless directly caused by accident)[12]

***

## **5.5 SOCIAL SECURITY INSURANCE**

### **Introduction**

**Social security insurance** refers to government-mandated insurance schemes designed to

provide financial protection to workers and their families against loss of income due to sickness,
maternity, employment injury, unemployment, old age, and death.[13][14][15]

Social security is a fundamental right aimed at ensuring dignified living conditions for all citizens,
particularly workers and economically vulnerable sections.[15][13]

### **Types of Social Security Insurance in India**

India has several social security schemes, including:

1. **Employees' State Insurance (ESI)** for sickness, maternity, disability, and medical care
2. **Employees' Provident Fund (EPF)** for old age and retirement benefits
3. **Workmen's Compensation** for employment injury
4. **Unemployment Allowance** under ESI
5. **Insurance for Seamen** under various maritime laws[14][13][15]

***

## **5.6 EMPLOYEES' STATE INSURANCE (ESI) SCHEME**

### **Introduction and Statutory Basis**

The **Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948** is India's pioneering social security legislation
providing health and financial benefits to workers.[16][17][13][14][15]

The Employees' State Insurance Act of 1948 is legislation enacted in India to provide social
security and health insurance benefits to employees and their dependents. It mandates
employers to contribute to a fund managed by the **Employees' State Insurance Corporation
(ESIC)**, which administers the scheme.[13][15]

The Act aims to protect employees against financial burdens arising from sickness, maternity,
disability, or death due to employment-related injuries. It covers various benefits, including
medical care, maternity benefits, rehabilitation, and funeral expenses.[14][13]

### **Applicability and Coverage**

The ESI Scheme extends medical coverage and essential benefits to workers and employees in
various sectors such as:
- Factories
- Businesses
- Hotels
- Transportation
- Cinemas
- Newspapers
- Educational or medical institutions
- Shops

The scheme applies to establishments employing **10 or more persons**.[15][13][14]

**Wage Limit:** Employees earning up to **₹21,000 per month** are eligible for this social
security program under the ESI Act.[13][14][15]

### **Benefits Under ESI Act (Section 46)**

**Section 46** of the ESI Act envisages the following six social security benefits:[18][14]

### **1. Medical Benefit**

These benefits are guaranteed to the employee as soon as they are hired, with the benefits
extending to their **family members** as well.[18][14]

This benefit covers the payment of all **treatment expenses** in lieu of medical issues faced by
the employee.[14]
**Coverage:** Medical care for self and family from ESI Hospitals/Dispensaries, including:
- Outpatient treatment
- Inpatient hospitalization
- Specialist consultations
- Medicines and diagnostic tests
- Maternity care.[19][18][14]

### **2. Sickness Benefit**

The employees covered by the ESI Act can avail **periodical payments** in case of sickness as
per **Section 46(1)(a)**, as long as the medical condition is verified by the appointed medical
practitioner.[15][18][14]

**Quantum:** The compensation is approximately **70% of their wages**, with the upper limit
for availing compensation being **91 days in a year**.[14][15]

**Eligibility:** In a period of 6 months of employment, the employee must have been working for
a minimum of **78 days**, else the benefit cannot be claimed.[15][14]

### **3. Maternity Benefit**

As per **Section 46(1)(b)** of the ESI Act, an insured woman can claim periodical payments in
case of occurrence of any of the following situations:
- **Confinement** (labor leading to birth or birth after 26 weeks)
- **Miscarriage**
- **Sickness arising out of pregnancy**
- **Premature birth of child**.[18][14][15]

**Duration:** The benefit is payable for **three months**, with an extension of **one month** if
required.[14]

**Eligibility:** The minimum work duration must be **70 days** in the year preceding the year of
pregnancy.[14]

### **4. Disablement Benefit**

**Disablement benefit** is provided in case of employment-related injury or occupational

disease resulting in temporary or permanent disablement.[18][15][14]

**Types:**

**A. Temporary Disablement Benefit:** Periodic payment at **90% of wages** during the period
of temporary disablement.[18][14]
**B. Permanent Disablement Benefit:** Monthly payment for life in case of permanent total
disablement. For permanent partial disablement, the benefit is proportionate to loss of earning
capacity.[15][18][14]

### **5. Dependents' Benefit**

In case of death of an insured person due to employment injury or occupational disease,

**monthly payment** is made to the dependents (spouse, children, parents).[15][18][14]

The benefit is typically **90% of the wages** of the deceased employee, distributed among
dependents as per the prescribed schedule.[18]

### **6. Other Benefits**

**A. Funeral Expenses:** A lump sum amount (currently ₹15,000) is paid to cover funeral
expenses of the deceased insured person.[13][15]

**B. Unemployment Allowance:** Equal to **50% of wage** for a maximum period of up to **two
years**, payable to insured persons who have been involuntarily unemployed.[19][15][18]

**C. Rehabilitation Allowance:** Provided to permanently disabled insured persons to help them
undergo vocational rehabilitation.[15][18]

**D. Benefits to Retired Insured Persons:** Medical benefits continue for retired insured persons
and their spouses who have contributed for a specified period.[18]

**E. Vocational Rehabilitation:** Training and placement assistance for disabled insured
persons.[18]

### **Contributions**

The ESI scheme is financed through contributions from employers and employees:

**Employee Contribution:** **0.75%** of wages (rounded)

**Employer Contribution:** **3.25%** of wages paid (rounded)

The contributions are deposited with the ESIC, which maintains the fund and provides benefits.
[14][15]

### **Administration**
The ESI scheme is administered by the **Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC)**, a
statutory body constituted under the ESI Act.[13][14][15]

The ESIC manages:

- Collection of contributions
- Provision of medical care through ESI hospitals and dispensaries
- Payment of cash benefits
- Adjudication of disputes
- Overall administration of the scheme.[14][15]

***

## **5.7 OTHER SOCIAL SECURITY SCHEMES**

### **Workmen's Compensation**

The **Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923** (now replaced by the **Employees' Compensation
Act, 1923**) provides for payment of compensation to workmen or their dependents in case of
injury, disability, or death arising out of and in the course of employment.[12]

**Coverage:** The Act applies to workers employed in hazardous industries and provides for
compensation without requiring proof of employer negligence (no-fault liability).[12]

### **Provident Fund**

The **Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952** provides for old
age, retirement, and family pension benefits to employees in organized sectors.[14]

Employees and employers contribute a percentage of wages to the provident fund, which is paid
to the employee upon retirement or to dependents in case of death.[14]

### **Insurance for Seamen**

Seamen (seafarers employed on ships) are covered under special insurance provisions that
provide:
- Medical benefits during service and after retirement
- Disability and death benefits for employment-related injury or death at sea
- Repatriation benefits
- Social security benefits as per international maritime conventions[12]

India is a signatory to various **International Labour Organization (ILO)** conventions that

mandate social security protection for seafarers.[12]

***
## **5.8 UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE**

### **Scope and Provisions**

**Unemployment insurance** provides financial support to workers who become involuntarily

unemployed.[19][15]

In India, unemployment allowance is provided under the **ESI Act** (as discussed in Section
5.6).[19][15][18]

**Eligibility:** Insured persons who have contributed for a minimum period and have become
involuntarily unemployed are entitled to unemployment allowance.[19]

**Quantum:** The allowance is equal to **50% of average daily wages** for a maximum period
of **up to two years**, subject to conditions.[19][15]

**Purpose:** The unemployment allowance is intended to provide temporary financial support

during the period of job search and to maintain the subsistence of the worker and their family.
[19][15]

***

**Unit 5 Complete.**

***

## **CONCLUSION**

You now have **complete, exam-ready notes** for all five units of the **UL-27 Insurance Law
syllabus**. The notes incorporate:

✅ **All syllabus topics** covered comprehensively

✅ **Existing student notes** preserved verbatim
✅ **Case law** and **statutory provisions** with exact section numbers added
✅ **Practical illustrations** to explain complex principles
✅ **Structured** in strict syllabus order

These enhanced notes are ready for your exam preparation. Review each unit, focusing on:
- Case names and principles
- Statutory sections (especially Sections 38, 39, 45 of Insurance Act; Sections 146, 165, 166 of
Motor Vehicles Act; Section 46 of ESI Act)
- Practical applications and illustrations
- Definitions and key concepts
**Best wishes for your UL-27 examination!**

Sources
[1] Motor Insurance - General Insurance Council
[Link]
[2] Indian Motor Vehicle Act, 1988: Features, Rules & Penalties
[Link]
[Link]
[3] Motor vehicle insurance : rights of third party against insurers [Link]
vehicle-insurance-rights-of-third-party-against-insurers/
[4] Plying motor vehicles without valid motor third party insurance ... - PIB
[Link]
[5] [PDF] THE MOTOR VEHICLES ACT, 1988 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
[Link]
[6] MVA : Insurance Of Motor Vehicles Against Third Party Risks
[Link]
[7] A Complete Guide to Navigating the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal ...
[Link]
tribunal-(mcop)-process
[8] MACT Claim Process | Claim Justice With Hassle-Free Process [Link]
[Link]
[9] [PDF] Motor Accident Claims Tribunals [MACT Courts]
[Link]
[10] Motor Accidents Claims Tribunals - India Code: Section Details
[Link]
actid=AC_CEN_30_42_00009_198859_1517807326286&sectionId=28440&sectionno=165&ord
erno=182
[11] [PDF] Circular No. 01/2024 - Kerala Judicial Academy
[Link]
[12] [Link] [Link]
[Link]/web/direct-files/attachments/86860808/9a415d19-381f-400a-a0f2-
0e678ab921c6/[Link]
[13] Employee's State Insurance (ESI) - Definition and Benefits
[Link]
[14] Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948: details you must know
[Link]
[15] Key Benefits & Provisions: The Employees State Insurance Act [Link]
employees-state-insurance-act/
[16] [PDF] EMPLOYEES' STATE INSURANCE ACT, 1948
[Link]
[17] Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 | ESIC Social Security Scheme [Link]
acts
[18] ESIC Benefits | Employees' State Insurance Corporation [Link]
benefits
[19] Employees' State Insurance Scheme - Social welfare - Vikaspedia
[Link]
%E2%80%99-state-insurance-scheme?lgn=en
[20] Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 - iPleaders [Link]
[21] Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Mumbai | India [Link]